Le Sserafim's Coachella Is God-Tier Trash And A Complete Embarrrasment

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 кві 2024
  • I can't believe that the bar is really this low. Y'all need to stop lying they suck. Previously known as Alanary Section.
    FAIR USE
    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
    Intro Song: Jim Yosef - Risk It All (ft. Rory Hope) [Official Lyric Video]
    Written by: Rory Hope, Helen Milena Lietzenmayer, Jim Yosef
    Violin: Jinty McTavish
    Visuals: arsacre.com
    Artwork: Shupeipa
    Link: • Jim Yosef - Risk It Al...
    Outro Song: cycle by Rexlambo / / rexlambo
    Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0
    Free Download / Stream: tinyurl.com/2p8yvw7b
    Music promoted by Audio Library tinyurl.com/84r9zmas

КОМЕНТАРІ • 114

  • @Rosiary
    @Rosiary  Місяць тому +32

    There is no hate in this video. I needed to get this off of my chest. If you have any questions please feel free to ask. Thanks.

    • @aliciaavendano2194
      @aliciaavendano2194 Місяць тому +6

      I would always criticize their lack of vocal abilities, but there is hate in this video

    • @flipchuu
      @flipchuu Місяць тому +1

      im just curious cause when she says 'coachella are u ready to shake some ass', didnt the ha sisters give her that line to say at coachella, or no?

    • @ch3rryboo_
      @ch3rryboo_ Місяць тому

      Yup that was originally their idea ​@@flipchuu

    • @norabeckwith9154
      @norabeckwith9154 Місяць тому +3

      With ur hating on them wtf wrong with you their getting hate already your not making it any better bro get a life

    • @Rosiary
      @Rosiary  Місяць тому +1

      Hi Nora, I missed you too.

  • @amiboacid7183
    @amiboacid7183 Місяць тому +54

    I was in TEARS when Yunjin screamed "Coachella, shake some f a*s" 💀

    • @Starlight06
      @Starlight06 Місяць тому +12

      It was so unserious fr😭

    • @indigo_neo
      @indigo_neo Місяць тому +3

      that was sooo funny

    • @KamenRider808
      @KamenRider808 Місяць тому +1

      Thank Evelyn Ha for that one. It was awesome

    • @afsaratasnia9150
      @afsaratasnia9150 10 днів тому

      She tried to copy Jennie

    • @Starlight06
      @Starlight06 10 днів тому +3

      @@afsaratasnia9150No she didn’t lmao, it was a K-UA-camr who recommended her to say that to the crowd and she actually did it. And even if she did say the same thing as Jennie, does Jennie own the phrase “let me hear you f*cking scream” or something? 😂 Be for real, it has nothing to do with Jennie, not everything is about Jennie. She’s just hyping up the crowd, like literally every single artist💀. Please get a life.

  • @Divetiny
    @Divetiny Місяць тому +82

    What really gets me is when people say "they were terrible" then others call it bullying but how come yall didn't bat an eyelid when y'all said the camera man for ATEEZ should be fired? K-pop stans say staff like stylists and cameramen should be fired all the time but when people say an idol was terrible then it's bullying. Saying that "oh don't be mean cuz idols are humans" like aren't the staff humans too? What do you think they are?
    Aliens? The double standards are crazy...

    • @yutaloml989
      @yutaloml989 Місяць тому

      Wait what happened with Ateez's cameraman ?

    • @Divetiny
      @Divetiny Місяць тому +4

      @@yutaloml989 The camera work for day one was horrid so people said it was really bad and that he should be fired

    • @Hobiemyhubby
      @Hobiemyhubby Місяць тому +7

      The most valid criticism a fan could give to idols is about their performance. There's no "force hate" when everything said about their poor vocals is true. I love Lsf because of their songs so it's unfortunate that they are getting hate but I won't be defending shit cause what people are saying about them are again true, not in just coachella but on their other stages as well their vocals is unforgivably bad. Hybe is so stupid for sending them to Coachella they could send ANYONE from their company and there's not gonna be an issue as big as this. Fear nots and LSF themselves gaslight every body when that people are just bullies, which is just not right 3 out of 5 members can't sing and everyone could see and hear it except for them. I'm hoping they would be put on break for a while and train their vocals and comeback with a bang

    • @Divetiny
      @Divetiny Місяць тому +5

      @@Hobiemyhubby THATS WHAT IM SAYING! From how long your comment was I was thinking u were a defender😅. I also agree like Lsf should be put on break for 6-12 months so they can train their live and overall vocals. Hopefully they can come back as better singers and I don't want to see anyone say that they "proved haters wrong" because no they didn't. They just finally worked to being better.

  • @laurabinfa8940
    @laurabinfa8940 Місяць тому +123

    Exactly, don't get me wrong, If BabyMonster came to Coachella, just forget it, they will serve and slay they show and also netizens should apologize to Aespa and Black pink for saying they can't sing live

  • @Sheepy16able
    @Sheepy16able Місяць тому +48

    Well, i agree with the most but i don`t think it`s copying Jennie when Yunjin asked the audience if they are ready. Thats a normal thing many artists do during concerts.

  • @krishnabhojne
    @krishnabhojne Місяць тому +42

    But you know. Some stans are defending their performance like," Their performance wasnt perfect but theyre humans afterall." Seriously it was a clown like excuse these fans make💀

    • @haleyhutchinson8302
      @haleyhutchinson8302 Місяць тому +10

      Or saying that there choreographies are hard. They were just getting criticism for them encore stage for Easy and they were just standing there. Itzy and NMIXX have harder choreographies and still sound good. I watch their dance practices with live vocals all the time. Itzy aren’t outstanding vocals but they still sound good at that’s what matter. An idol does not need to know how to sing like Wendy, Taeyeon or Baekhyun . They just need to be able to care some kind of tune but the majority of Le sserafim can’t do that.

    • @krishnabhojne
      @krishnabhojne Місяць тому +9

      @@haleyhutchinson8302 Yup exactly. I saw Itzy singing live and tho they were super tired, they're still sounding good, trying their level best with their complex choreos. Kudos to them. The talent of these girls will go to waste with this joke company if they don't get them a vocal coach

    • @lonleypotato7035
      @lonleypotato7035 Місяць тому +5

      frrr, like imagine a doctor f*cks up a surgery and tell u “we’re all humans and make mistakes”

    • @afsaratasnia9150
      @afsaratasnia9150 10 днів тому

      ​@@lonleypotato7035hey that's what sultry film said in her recent video about illit

  • @wonderfuljackson8941
    @wonderfuljackson8941 Місяць тому +35

    2:28 ateez actually was at Coachella this year and they did kill it 🔥

  • @shikinami-san
    @shikinami-san Місяць тому +31

    Not me sitting here patiently waiting for the Rosiary tea xD

  • @hearteuz2252
    @hearteuz2252 Місяць тому +31

    I was really so embarrassed, this whole thing is to be embarrassed about... and I'm not blink but just as they criticize them they should do the same with LS, I don't understand why there are so many who defend LS, there are no excuses, what they are doing is mediocre...
    Hybe has proven to be a joke, they are the most superficial thing there is, there is no demonstration of talent, they are not ashamed to send them like this to one of the most important music festivals, you can tell that they are not interested or concerned about their artists, they only want money, too bad for the girls

  • @soomi
    @soomi Місяць тому +33

    You missed the opportunity to add 'mess mess mess mess mess mess' at the title at the end 🤭 /lh

    • @Rosiary
      @Rosiary  Місяць тому +8

      You' re right. Such a missed opportunity 😭.

  • @bishopman2308
    @bishopman2308 Місяць тому +24

    I will admit that I was looking forward to LleSerfims show, because of seeing their fans talk so much crap in youtube comments. I was completely disappointed by their subpar vocals. They can dance good, but this is a kpop group, not a dance group. Also after reading the feed during the concert, I'm pretty sure that LleSerefims fans are tone deaf.

  • @ITSLEMOON
    @ITSLEMOON Місяць тому +18

    In the words of Kim jisoo: not bad but not good

  • @babyimmamons7er
    @babyimmamons7er Місяць тому +20

    Jimin can sing that’s all I’m gonna say. He may need to improve but he can sing.

  • @AmiAki
    @AmiAki Місяць тому +10

    Yunjin - I was expecting her to struggle this much on stage and she is basically their main vocalist
    Chaewon - did the best
    Eunchae. - competing with Sakura to have the worst vocal
    Sakura - can’t sing period but somehow at Coachella she sounded decent for once
    Kazuha - barely trying and was quiet at times
    The way I agree with everything you just said about them . This is l how I felt when i watched their week 1 live

  • @belaytriks
    @belaytriks Місяць тому +16

    I knew this a disaster when the best theird paid publicity was talking about was their super expensive LV outfits, the members expectations of the show, how hot they look swearing, what they did outside of stage and the debut of their new song and no one even mentioned their performance.
    At this point, I can see they are here for the money and the fame, never because the music and that is why they are fearless because they know they lack skills but are fine with it because they are whilling to support the critic as long as they keep winning millions selling their youth and beauty instead of their skills as "singers" because they are not singers, they are dancers and models.
    I point their fans for the future IAs music that would be given to us instead of having real musicians in stages.

  • @ayexplained3548
    @ayexplained3548 Місяць тому +27

    After watching ateez's performance I thought they might give a decent performance but only one or two members were carrying the performance.

  • @aesglow
    @aesglow Місяць тому +10

    saying yunjin copied jennie is CRAZYY when literally hj evelyn suggested her to say that LMFAOOOOOO

    • @aesglow
      @aesglow Місяць тому +2

      and ur saying “i feel bad for the audience” yet everyone who was there is saying they enjoyed it but obviously u know what ur talking abt sister

    • @jesuschristsonofgod9709
      @jesuschristsonofgod9709 7 днів тому +1

      ​@@aesglowthey sounded terrible

    • @aesglow
      @aesglow 7 днів тому

      @@jesuschristsonofgod9709 ok idgaf like what does that have to do with me

  • @Sanatizer_
    @Sanatizer_ 19 днів тому +3

    Chaewons back must hurt from carrying the group

  • @loucantcant06
    @loucantcant06 Місяць тому +13

    Everyone owe an apology to aespa fr

  • @thursdayscat
    @thursdayscat Місяць тому +5

    We've seen kpop groups like txt, ateez, bp etc crushing major festival stages and performed well, even much longer than lsfm's set with intense choreo. If they could do it, then lsfm could've done it too, but unfortunately they're not prepared enough

  • @shwetha1244
    @shwetha1244 Місяць тому +23

    Everything else is valid, but the fact u said Yunjin copied that line from Jennie is actually not it. It was recomended by Ha sisters in their vlog and def not cringey of her to say that.

    • @Divetiny
      @Divetiny Місяць тому +2

      True. Everything else is ok

    • @kenieherox2625
      @kenieherox2625 23 дні тому

      it just the way she said it: the shakiness of her voice made it cringy

  • @lauarascott
    @lauarascott Місяць тому +3

    Hybe wants to be known as a company with famous groups so badly that they have forgotten to train talent and if they have any they are overused.
    Look at TXT is so overworked every second they on-tour brand deals and so on I don't think they have been doing vocal training in a bit and some sounded a bit off in their live singing. And in my opinion, they are the best from hype with all five can sing.
    I'm not even going to talk about the amazing singing as their fans say, my problem is this harder dance Choreography their stan keep talking about I just don't see it. It may look good in the MV but their performance just can't be seen.

  • @Aerishu_
    @Aerishu_ Місяць тому +3

    Your videos are so entertaining oh my god

  • @Hanni._.Bubblegum.
    @Hanni._.Bubblegum. Місяць тому +15

    Chaewon is the only one who can save the group vocal wise and the only GG that has good vocal talent under HYBE is NewJeans and Fromis_9 and this is coming from a fearnot.

    • @nazafrin8762
      @nazafrin8762 Місяць тому +2

      Newjeans also have the same problem as lsfm. They can't also sing, only Hanni and Hyein can sing.
      The only girl group who is good in vocals is Fromis 9

    • @alrightloves
      @alrightloves Місяць тому +3

      ​@@nazafrin8762 Almost all members of NewJeans are lead vocalist material.
      Hanni, Danielle & Hyein are great but Minji & Haerin also have a beautiful lower register that they can develop.
      At least NewJeans doesn't have a massive ego that is getting in their way.
      They will definitely improve 🙌🏻

    • @Hanni._.Bubblegum.
      @Hanni._.Bubblegum. Місяць тому

      @@alrightloves Yes. NewJeans are still rookies but they I’m still rooting for them.

  • @Karthagast
    @Karthagast Місяць тому +2

    I'm fine with being brutally honest about Le Sserafim. I mean my intention here is not to defend them or, even less, to defend HYBE Corp. But let's be brutally honest about Coachella as well. Shall we?
    What is Coachella at this point?? Coachella is a trash show for Western "music" industry (American mainly), trashy celebrities, pathetic influencers worthing no more than their brainless followers, and commercial brands trying to make some money out of the human garbage gathering flooded in drugs who, obviously, will enjoy whatever noise, pretending to be music, is offered to them.
    Therefore, considering the whole Coachella context, Le Sserafim brought what was due to a public so high on drugs that they couldn't tell the difference between a fart and a flute.

  • @ketakikhobragade7168
    @ketakikhobragade7168 Місяць тому +16

    Can't believe standard for performance is blackpink like kpop is really going downhill if the most lackluster group is considered the best. Imagine how bad you have to be to get outperformed by blackpink. Kpop is truly a joke

    • @Mitchelle-hb7wk
      @Mitchelle-hb7wk Місяць тому +5

      I will have to disagree about the bp being lackluster,it's not I agree they have bad performance,but they are really good performance

    • @AA-ed6ek
      @AA-ed6ek Місяць тому

      So true.

    • @Daniel_Neil
      @Daniel_Neil Місяць тому

      👍👍👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👌👌

    • @rubyrubacus9787
      @rubyrubacus9787 28 днів тому

      Bcuz Blackpink is an actual K-pop group. Not just a dance group filled with cute tone deaf girls

  • @aliciaavendano2194
    @aliciaavendano2194 Місяць тому +5

    03:03 now hold on a minute, Kazuha at the beginnig was really doing it good (not that much vocally) so i don't know where that comment comes from... at the end, yeah, she sounded as awful as always, but at the beginning she was really trying

  • @Mitchelle-hb7wk
    @Mitchelle-hb7wk Місяць тому +1

    New voice over this is lovely

  • @michaeladove7269
    @michaeladove7269 Місяць тому +7

    💯💯💯💯💯💯

  • @archelynwolf
    @archelynwolf Місяць тому +11

    I agree their vocals were not good as a whole. However, Sakura actually made a huge improvement (she did get very few lines though). Additionally, bringing up Jimin's encore is something I've seen a lot from people on ktube but it really is only a tiny snapshot of hours upon hours of good live singing Jimin has on record (even recently), and professional singers have given reasons as to why he sometimes sounds unstable, and it isn't his lack of skill or talent; usually it's because of his unique voice making it hard for him to sing in vapor and because his in ears weren't working. Additionally, blaming HYBE is pretty inaccurate imo because have you seen TXT's encores for Deja Vu? Also, Newjeans' vocal coach has a public profile online meaning Hybe definitely sends at least some of their artists to train vocally. Just a reminder that Hybe is a collection of pretty independent labels, not a singular company. (I have a lot of respect for your videos I'm just frustrated with this narrative)

    • @belaytriks
      @belaytriks Місяць тому +2

      Jimin himself admited to returning to vocal lessons from ground zero in Suchita with Taemin. He admited he was worried about being abble to sing live in the stage. He knows he struggle and as ARMY recognicing it does not make us less ARMY.
      Yes, they have a lot of labels, like teams to manage their groups but at least all the girls groups they have debuted are following a pattern. Those women were modeled in what they tought would be standard for the next "BlackPink" in the words of the same Bang PD.
      They free Source Music (SoMu) to manage them and gave their trainees to Ador for that creep CEO to materialize all her twisted concepts with them and because they managed to make it at the level they wanted now we have their new group as a carbon copy for non fans, they can not return this particular group to that trend because after being sell as sexy women it will be hard to make their fans to go for a more "innocent" image.
      You said they are independent but is funny that JYP and SM has debuted more variety of concepts than them in terms of groups being single labels. As a casual listener I find no difference in the music style of Txt and Enhypen, it seems they can change their music and it will be OK. I can not said the same between aespa, Red Velvet and SNSD or Itzy, Twice and NMIXX but you know wich agency can that apply: YG with 2ne1, BlackPink and now Baby Monster, because BP was the pretty version of 2ne1 by their own creator words and we all know BM is the continuarion of BP.
      This group follows BP last legacy with a twist of BTS: amazing and complex stories for fans to talk about, huge stages, amazing dancing skills and from BP is the fashion target, the influencer focus , a sexy image, the supperficial "empowered women" concept that saids a women is powerfull because they can be "unapologetic sexy" no matter the age, they are rich and thereforth cab de rude to all because that is being "badass"... That is what they were selling... Here in the west we have seen how well that is aging with Marvel, Wish and Star Wars franchise. With BP worked because the time and because the girls are really proyected than. Time has changed and now people is starting to get tired of that really outdated version of empowered and went to the oposite, a more pure concept, a more traditional mindset and NJ came and gave that with a dose of "Pretty Baby" sugar coated with fan gaslight and we knows how well that sells specially with a lot od millions to possition pretty faces.
      Then we have the trend of playback, they are all abusing but againg, you have the Big 3 listening the public and delivering, that is why it is the Big 3 and Hybe. The Big 3 debuted talented artists with huge vocal skills so their fans could see that K-Pop could be taken musical serious and was not only for teens but what does Hybe gave us: looks, dance and amazing production skills while JYP gave us NMIXX, SM debuted aespa that had this same stage as one of their first real live experience and still manage to deliver and now YG debuted BM even after the whole fiasco that was how unreliable was being half of BP to deliver during their tour and are after a redebut wetting huge praises with their talent. What does Hybe delivered: excuses, gaslighting and unapologetic peep talks that could not be taking serious because does not reflect a serious intention of improvement. Gfriend as rookies could sing their songs and dance the most complex songs for a girl group to that date, BTS has cried and apologized to ARMY for small mistakes and make their own reflections and critiques of world stages unanimous aclamed by the public, IVE went from all playback to try and more or less nail their encores, aespa rarelly sing but when they do there is no excuses for them to deliver even at the brink of a change of company.
      So yes, there seems to be a narrative here but it is because we see, we think and we make our own conclusions but it is not some farfetched conspiration theory, BP was the top girl group and most girl groups started to copy them, now NJ is taking their place and I am sure a bunch of groups are gong to start copying them. And abou the claims of lack of training, we have ears, we take notice, the Big 3 took notice, Source is what it is because there was a gir group full of talented artist called Gfriend that rise them from oblivion, Hybe exist because 7 passionate artist poured their all in their music and BTS is what it is. SM notice that and created NCT and took carefull steps until aespa, JYP noticed and spend time and money with NMIXX, YG noticed and took their time with BM even if at the end they rushed their debut, all they took notice that people wanted vocals, personality and dance and they delivered. Hybe watched BP and decided fans wanted influencers, personality, looks and show and that is what they delivered. The Big 3 were about looks, yes, but music at the end, Hybe has shown they are to sell whatever it sells ans music is not their bussiness and never were, Big Hit is another thing separated from Hybe but Big Hit can do as it pleases because Big Hit is the owner of Hybe. BTS can do as they pleased because they are the sift and gentle face of Hybe, take BTS from Hybe and you will see how their nice work place go down fast.
      Hybe is the only one of the big agencies that has lacked to gave us vocalist, why? Because they do not sell musicians, they sell dance crews with amazing lips syncs habilities.

    • @archelynwolf
      @archelynwolf Місяць тому

      @@belaytriks I'll just respond to every point you made here and try to be as concise as possible.
      Your first point was about Jimin. I rewatched the Suchwita episode to be sure of the context in which he talked about his vocal lessons. Now, to summarize, you basically said that Jimin recognizes that he has to improve and that he is starting from scratch because HYBE didn't give him enough resources beforehand. However, from what I watched, Jimin was just doing what every artist should do: strengthening his fundamentals. Now, that does not mean he's had no vocal lessons before recently, it just means he wants to improve. As a musician myself, I have to balk at the assumption that this means his fundamentals are bad by any means. He's taking lessons for the simple reason of wanting to improve, no more, no less.
      Your second point was not extremely clear to me as to what it meant, because you talk about HYBE girlgroups having a "sexy" concept. Of course, this is false even based on your own statements, as you bring up NJ having an opposite concept. Le Sserafim is the only girl group from HYBE that can be said to use any sort of girl crush concept similar to BP, and yet, they are still different as their concept is more about rebellion against societal expectations. Yes, both NJ and Le Sserafim have had mature songs, but I will get into this in my next section.
      Your third point is that there is not a lot of variety in stylistic choice of groups under HYBE, in response to my statement that HYBE are pretty independent as labels. There are a few issues with this statement. The first is the nature of having a divisional structure like HYBE does. When you have a top-down management style such as the Big 3, it's much easier to make sure there is no overlap in concept. However, when you have the more bottom-up approach pioneered by HYBE, it is much more likely that there will be similarities, because the top-level management isn't controlling the individual labels to reduce overlap. The second issue with your statement is that even within each label, many of the labels have the value pioneered by Bighit of allowing the artists to grow into their own style. Allowing artists to write their own music means they will not automatically be extremely different from concepts other people have, because their music will resonate with the life path they're on. This leads to more nuance in concept that the casual listener may not pick up on, but that's okay because it's at a deeper level that makes it different. This point leads me to discussing NJ and Le Sserafim's mature songs. Because top-level management doesn't have that much control over SoMu and Ador, these labels' marketing decisions are almost solely theirs. Later, when you mention NJ's impact on the kpop scene, you completely prove the point that HYBE is not unoriginal.
      Your fourth point is basically that HYBE does not produce singers, they produce good-looking dancers who know how to lipsync. In this section, you talk about how Bighit does what they want to do because they own HYBE. I can say that out of every group I've seen from HYBE, the only one that fits this label is Le Sserafim. As I mentioned in my first comment, NJ has public vocal coaches, so we know HYBE gives them training. If you listened to any group other than Le Sserafim without bias, you would find that they are quite stable, have decent vocal agility, and portray emotion in their voices very well. Your point that the Big 3 saw that the public wanted vocals so they debuted vocal-heavy groups again shows that the Big 3 has much more control over the specific types of groups they debut over HYBE. You even name BTS as a group that gives 100% and works hard to sing live. BTS is part of HYBE as well. The idea that Bighit is the only independent label because they own HYBE is incorrect because if Bighit was the only independent label, every label would fall under the same philosophy as Bighit, which it doesn't. If your point was that HYBE but not Bighit promotes payola and monetary gain, my response is that if that were true, Pledis would have changed and become similar to what SoMu are doing. This is not happening, so as a result, the narrative that HYBE is a bad vocal company is false.

    • @blossom6693
      @blossom6693 Місяць тому

      ​@@belaytriks mam bp was debuted as preetier version of 2ne1 and female BTS in America, their so called legacy is riding on BTS coattail, youtube ads , paid award show after losing vote , basically Robbing independent artist, bad bunny was most stream artist in 1022 in every platform but he was not given time artist of the years but bp, so called putting them as a standard is bs when they were getting 20k qrt by actual local for their lip syncing and why they are making goal for hybe group
      Also about sm vocal,thank God they are flop and has done multiple hate campaign against BTS and kpop dtan had joined them in past and need to hide them now by ass licking sm stan 24/7 bcz your sm idol was lip syncing,has literal organisation saying that they use pre recorded vocal for encore , that's your standard, ask them why they are not invited to NPR TINY DESK,a respectable show where critics choose who will perform

    • @ketakikhobragade7168
      @ketakikhobragade7168 Місяць тому +1

      I stan jimin, but I am tired to defending him. He was good singer in past but hybe has regressed his vocals. Even jhope sings better than jimin.

    • @archelynwolf
      @archelynwolf Місяць тому

      @@ketakikhobragade7168 Please search up Jimin singing live. There's hours and hours of examples of him singing well, and pro singers who have talked about his (recent!) singing. Obviously I'm not saying he's perfect, but people point to a few clips that go viral and generalize his singing as "bad" or "regressed."

  • @wandeesthoughts
    @wandeesthoughts Місяць тому +8

    They weren't that bad most people are doing too much & using the lesserafim hate train to promote their faves

    • @henrixsontombrady2467
      @henrixsontombrady2467 Місяць тому +1

      Who? To blackpink fame? 😅😅😅

    • @nubelinda
      @nubelinda Місяць тому +7

      Oh no.. they were REALLY bad, that’s why everyone is criticizing them because it was that bad

    • @VickyJang-ov5kn
      @VickyJang-ov5kn 29 днів тому +5

      Naur they were that bad 😰

    • @rubyrubacus9787
      @rubyrubacus9787 28 днів тому +2

      To promote whom? BP? Ateez? Aespa? Bcuz it sucked so bad it would bring shame to other girls too. 💀

  • @Hobiemyhubby
    @Hobiemyhubby Місяць тому +1

    I've been hearing the argument that atleast the paying audience and the fans enjoyed it. But that doesn't change the fact that 3 out of 5 members can't sing and that's not okay, atleast acknowledge that fact people that is majority of the group that can not sing and this is the first time i saw this in a none nugu group and that is not right. People are so frustrating when people are just stating the obvious and they get mad of the truth???

  • @vivitrumanto
    @vivitrumanto 24 дні тому +1

    You were so harsh, but I can see how frustrated you are. Like these fans are so delusional though, they aren't helping the girls to improve at all as artists. Yeah, their live raw vocals are bad, they need professional vocal training and good breathing techniques. I hope they can see how important it is to improve. Even they already debuted, doesn't mean they can stop doing any vocal training and just focus solely on dancing and doing performances.

  • @hbicfae7116
    @hbicfae7116 Місяць тому +1

    Everybody coming for HYBE forgetting that it's not actually HYBE managing the group, they're the parent company. Drag source music instead and leave HYBES name out your mouths

    • @indigo_neo
      @indigo_neo Місяць тому +1

      right, but hybe does need to be dragged lol.

    • @taijini6312
      @taijini6312 28 днів тому +4

      Did I just see a Hybe Stan 😮

    • @hbicfae7116
      @hbicfae7116 27 днів тому

      @@taijini6312 idk how you got hybe Stan from that, but okay

  • @dsibrbidll7752
    @dsibrbidll7752 Місяць тому +4

    As a person who was on the Born Pink tour, I can say that I had an amazing time. My bias is Jennie so I was paying mostly attention to her and she was truly the best and most catchy performer to me. Those clips that I saw from her being lazy are 4-5 and are seconds so the hate is really too much and as someone who saw her live I can totally defend the group from those statements.

  • @kenieherox2625
    @kenieherox2625 23 дні тому

    guys, she is harsh, but valid. i mean le sserafim can’t sing much except chaewon (yunjin, i’m disappointed in you). it’s not bullying because author doesn’t spread misinformation, it’s just stating facts without sugarcoating and yes, it’s rather hard to swallow for someone.

  • @belaytriks
    @belaytriks Місяць тому +4

    Oh! Sakura has apologized already, as I suspected she is not anouncing them retreating to improve their vocal skills so I would still call them a model dance crew.
    They did fine because people praised them and they were better that yesterday, enjoyed themselves and did their best and they only compare with themselves... A nice peep talk... That said they do not care what the people said about them, that they know they have delivered a crap presentation and they are fine with it, they will do what they want and what they do without even caring of the resoult as long as fans still gave them money. People can talk all they want because they did their very best and that is enough. 🙄
    Really... The most self indulgent excuse of the world... At least Jimin had the decency to admit he had to return to vocal lessons since ground zero after his encore... But I think they knew they only have 5 years to go after their disbandment and going to enjoy their millions into oblivion without a care of the damage they are doing to the whole industry with their attitude. This is why the world is like it is right now. 🙄

    • @blossom6693
      @blossom6693 Місяць тому +2

      When did jimin said that he needs to take lessons? The absolute audacity to create narrative and then impose on him ,you have 10 years of his career and only 1 clip that too was good if we ignore those 3 second off key singing where his ear piece is not even working,and crows is too loud, he is the one who went viral for his NPR TINY DESK LIVE SINGING WHERE ACTUAL MUSICIAN PERFORM LIVE AND GET INVITED BCZ OF THEIR PERFORMANCE NOT BY KPOP STAN

    • @belaytriks
      @belaytriks Місяць тому

      ​@@blossom6693Suchita, the episode of Taemin, he admited to have started to take vocal lessons from the beggining and that it was being hard... 🙄
      Please comprehension reading here.
      First, ARMY do not scream to other people if they disagree with you, that is rude, do not tarnish ARMY name with such attitude, it is not proper of us.
      Second. He said in one of his own BTS episode or BangTang Bomb in wich Jungkook visited him while he was rehersing his alone stages that he was worried if he can sound the same live.
      Yes, he is unrediable in some songs, as ARMY I know it and he has many time admit his own shortcommings and take responsability of them, something I was highlithing here. That does not mean he had never had amazing stages nor that he does not know how to sing, he can sing but because he has been unrediable he is willing to start to train again instead of being self condecented with himself, he knows he failed in his encore and instead of giving excuses to us, ARMY, he went to take vocal classes again. He showed us once more why we love them, because he took responsability of his own career and his own improvement in order to become a better soloist and singer.
      Sakura and her group had consisted bad encores for a couple of comebacks and one shamefull international stage and they are claming to be proud of themselves and calling haters to people that had pointed the truth: the prestige of that stage was way above their skills as their encores had pointed.
      Jimin had one bad encore during a world wide succesfull promotion and he went to take classes. Tell me why, as ARMY, should I feel ashame of thaf action of him?

    • @blossom6693
      @blossom6693 Місяць тому

      @@belaytriks let me make it pretty clear,I watch the suchwita episode, never did he mention about that fucking encore , jimin is good enough to know that he is the one performing at NPR TINY DESK,
      AND LISTEN KID STOP WITH THAT "AS A ARMY" bs bcz that's not gonna make your point relevant to me , I am not 15 years old , 2 nd of all HE IS WONDERFUL VOCALIST, I WATCH THE ENCORE TOO ,you know from official channel not from stan twt , he was sounding good,there was barely 19 second of error and he was still holding note but back track and his voice was not matching bcz it was a technical issues, audience was loud and his ear piece was not working, that' happen to everybody, every artist will face the same issue,
      Also stop with the bs lie " he is taking vocal lessons bcz of that " when he was talking abou learning,ore which is foreign things for typical kpop stan who will like sm sound, YG sound with heavy lip syncing and loud back track with 2 writing and producting credit whole career, stop throwing word in his mouth, and give me the link where he said that he is worried that if he can sound the same or not? Stop making things out of our flat ass ,
      And check note , every professional artist who actually sing LIVE think about that, that's not mean that he can't sing , that man has performed multiple live show all over the world which was reviewed by actual music critic you know,not social reject kpop stan

    • @rubyrubacus9787
      @rubyrubacus9787 28 днів тому

      ​@@blossom6693girl I was agreeing with you until You brought yg. Saying they used heavy autotune especially when BM just debuted is a new level of delulu. 🤡

    • @blossom6693
      @blossom6693 28 днів тому

      @@rubyrubacus9787 bfr they have a sound and bm is literally new , they have a long way to go

  • @kf5338
    @kf5338 Місяць тому +2

    I imagine the Coachella booking was made far in advance? So maybe they didn't want to take a financial hit by pulling out of Coachella. It was maybe booked during a time when they weren't being criticised, as the criticism of their poor vocals wasn't as bad before the recent comeback

    • @Rosiary
      @Rosiary  Місяць тому +9

      Actually they were getting criticized for their vocals since the beginning. It has gotten a lot stronger now because of the lack of improvement.

    • @Welchs-Fruit-Snacks
      @Welchs-Fruit-Snacks Місяць тому +8

      @@Rosiary And because their fandom refuses to leave people alone. They love to drag idols (especially GGs and IVE) for their dance, stage presence and vocals.

    • @belaytriks
      @belaytriks Місяць тому +5

      ​@@Welchs-Fruit-SnacksIVE are not a lot better but the girls are improving little by little, they manage to sound alike their songs at least, I was actually impressed with their "I am" encore because they actually kind of singed it. I just hope one day they rise vocally to their potential even if it slow.

    • @ketakikhobragade7168
      @ketakikhobragade7168 Місяць тому +5

      ​@@belaytriks liz is better than all le sserafim members.

  • @ningpop_
    @ningpop_ Місяць тому +1

    Blackpink and aespa deserve an apology

  • @KamenRider808
    @KamenRider808 Місяць тому

    Its a music festival especially with the location of the festival. Screaming is excitement and pumping up the crowd. The energy is there!

    • @rubyrubacus9787
      @rubyrubacus9787 28 днів тому +3

      But Vocals are not there.

    • @KamenRider808
      @KamenRider808 28 днів тому

      @@rubyrubacus9787 They still did the performance either way

  • @seastar-qw2qg
    @seastar-qw2qg Місяць тому

    Remember sulli. Lets criticise not insult or bully. We cant lose another pls

    • @Rosiary
      @Rosiary  Місяць тому +3

      No one is bullying anyone here.

    • @seastar-qw2qg
      @seastar-qw2qg Місяць тому

      @@Rosiary yeah the title of your video is very anti bullying. GOD TIER TRASH. 😂🤥. yeah right because we use the word god tier trash when criticising someone. Maybe bullying wasnt ur intention but ur video title makes it seem like le sserafim gave the worst concert in the history of humanity. ure going to increase the levels of negativity and encourage people to hate on le sserafim more and continue bullying. Im sure there are other ways u could have phrased ur title that wont make the video sound like the world is ending because of a bad concert. Someone literally commented sakura should be raped and killed because of her singing on twitter. Dont give me that antibullying BS. U clearly made the video title to attract attention

    • @seastar-qw2qg
      @seastar-qw2qg Місяць тому

      @@Rosiary yes because the title of ur video is so antibullying. god tier trash? Girl their concert wasnt as bad as ure making it sound. U make it sound as if it is the worst concert in humanity history. Pple said sakura should be raped and killed on twitter because of her vocals. Like it or not ure just adding fuel to the fire. Later if all the hate causes them to commit suicide, y'all will be running with ur tragic story videos. Smh

    • @taijini6312
      @taijini6312 28 днів тому

      There’s no bullying here thou , the creator is just spitting facts

    • @seastar-qw2qg
      @seastar-qw2qg 27 днів тому

      @@Rosiary u all r jokers. That video title is enough bullying and hate on its own.god tier trash? Ure making it sound like their coachella performance was the worst concert in the history of humanity. That title is inviting more hate to them. Maybe hate wasnt ur intention but it definitely is. Pple online are saying they should be killed and raped bcuz of their vocals. Yes their vocals were not good and completely awful at some points but that doesn't qualify it being called god tier trash. If someone called ur work god tier trash, u would like it right. Dont even give me its not bullying

  • @TheGravygun
    @TheGravygun 22 дні тому

    You little kids got short changed on your music you have no idea what you missed back in the '80s and '90s. Digdeep

  • @Hdjdnddjdhzksks
    @Hdjdnddjdhzksks Місяць тому

    of course its a blackpink fan, shameless to shame these girls when blackpink barely sang as headliners in coachella.

    • @Rosiary
      @Rosiary  Місяць тому +1

      I'm not even a blink😑

    • @rubyrubacus9787
      @rubyrubacus9787 28 днів тому +1

      A delulu fearnot who loves to drag BP. BP really set the standards huh?

    • @joesama3282
      @joesama3282 6 днів тому

      @@rubyrubacus9787 They will drag anything, even those who don't really care... They tend to target smaller fandoms like Gfriend fandom only because it is easy to bully and having the power to rub their "chart and sales" obsession in everyone faces just to shiny knight defending Lesserafiim to the bone. If this company stan or sublabel stan under an big company which all they do is bragging about charting and album sales, numbers, then I don't see them having the standard on music and performance wise as priority. Seeing numbers so high for them is a illusion to hide their insecure IRL aspects, school, job, etc...

  • @trentonpower1823
    @trentonpower1823 Місяць тому

    Why are BP and YG kids so obsessed w lsf bruh y'all trash 😂