JDS-BJP in Karnataka, inheritance tax debate, issues with PMLA | Hafta 482 FULL EPISODE
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 кві 2024
- #loksabhaelection2024 #inheritancetax #congress #sampitroda
Tune in wherever you get your podcasts: pod.link/582585399/episode/dc...
This week, Newslaundry’s Abhinandan Sekhri, Jayashree Arunachalam and Shardool Katyayan are joined by The News Minute’s Pooja Prasanna and lawyer Vakasha Sachdev.
On the Karnataka polls, Pooja says the JDS and BJP are “better allies” than the Congress and JDS since “their target base does not overlap. Both parties bring something new and fresh to the table”. She adds that the “myth of the Vokkaligas being secular is nonsense”.
The panel discusses the inheritance tax debate, with Vakasha saying the tax has a solid rationale behind it “from a social justice perspective”. Jayashree says the matter escalated into a controversy because people are “conflating a lot of things, like what Modi said about the Congress taking away people’s money”. Shardool adds, “Most of the people arguing about this tax won’t have to pay it because it applies to the creamy layer of society.”
Vakasha then explains why the PMLA is problematic. On the state of the Indian judiciary, he says over the years, “we’ve had our justice system constantly become a voice for the establishment”, adding that there is a lack of critique of the courts. Abhinandan says people are possibly “afraid of critiquing the court because of contempt of court...so courts have completely gone out of scrutiny”.
This and a whole lot more. Tune in!
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscript...
Power NL and TNM's coverage of the 2024 general elections: www.newslaundry.com/2024-elec...
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61...
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
Tune in wherever you get your podcasts: pod.link/582585399/episode/dc30ece57cfe0a709ab004763396c554
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=hafta
Power NL and TNM's coverage of the 2024 general elections: www.newslaundry.com/2024-electionfund?ref=nl-social
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61PEo0QeacOqU9vr2k
Abhinandan's views r spot on regarding privileges n being 'self-made' He is right regarding Jyotiraditya
In countries like the UK or US, the state taxes it and pays for healthcare and social security etc. Here after inheritance tax, do you think the Indian government will provide free healthcare and quality education to all ?
Whch inheritance tax? Hvnt u realised dat d pm lies by nw?
@@diamond_dew What are you babbling about buddy we are not deaf and blind we have all seen video of Sam Pitroda talking about it. Lets not pretend that Sam Pitroda is literally the fucking mentor of Rahul Gandhi the prince of Congress whose photo is on the congress manifesto while he occupies no office in that organisation
@@sukantpanigrahi76did you just come here to spread misinformation in this comment section? What you said has been literally discussed in the video. At least watch the video before commenting like a moron. India is declining because of people like you.
Yes!! But only to chuslims lol 😂
Such lovely Halfta folks! It's always a delight to hear Shardool and Jayashree's takes on matters. I hope more people learn about NL's awesome work and subscribe.
Thank god for no Anand.
I am sitting here in purnea.. and listening to it... Pappu pass ho gaya yaha pe...
CONGRESS ZAMEEN LELEGI YAAD RAKHNA
@@Change9819 zameen kis cheez ki jab kisano ko daam na mile
A deeper concern I think is the question of what is the conviction that the person or more importantly their parent who earned the assets and wealth have about this tax being put to good use. What is the India they have encountered in the pursuit of that wealth? This btw is a general problem I have with taxation not anywhere else as much as in India. If I do not see the country in any way shape or form taking that money putting it into the future of my children and my society am I not safer securing the future of my family?
Also here’s a solution .. third generation gets taxed the fuck out of their inheritance
Is abhi the only fit guy in news laundry ...😂😂😂
Guys, time to research about things before putting your expert opinion
Cpi manifesto does not talk about nuclear energy
The CPI(M) in its manifesto has said there will be "complete elimination of nuclear weapons and other weapons of mass destruction." 🤦♂️😂🤷♂️
Watching this today, a bit late. Interesting to talk about JDS. Now that I have advantage of hindsight
Inheritance tax is a great idea provided it actually covers everyone rather than providing another loophole to super rich to skip on them, which we know would happen. Does INC for example plans to introduce estate tax for farmers ? Because we know that plenty of politicians already hide their wealth in farming, which is tax-exempt.
Time stamps??
Insightful talk
I am impressed by how much Satish Shah knows about the current events
Hahahahahhaha😂
One more thing. When people say inheritance is unearned, it pains me to not that I am eligible for that law, BUT I work 5-6 days a week 12hr shift. If by any miracle I’m able to save enough time to leave 5-10 million worth of property for my child, that is unearned.
I know there are exceptions. But just a good for thought.
I do thank Waheguru that I am able to work, but that doesn’t marginalize my hard work.
NL App not on play store ????????
its there
Your app is missing from the playstore😢😢
Should the money news laundry is getting from China be taxed?
Dune fans should know that sandworms thrive on spice mélange .
Sorry, I need to disagree. The panels views on inheritance tax are atrocious. If someone has worked hard and saved to pass it on, the state has no right to have a part of the pie!
Also, I am no congress supporter, but how can you so non challantly call a senior politician “bored” of his job?
You guys do a decent fact check and I appreciate that. But do tone down the attitude
Exactly. And how many times will the same property be taxed.
At some point in this discussion, I feel like a bunch of people in the name of journalism discussing the matters who they don't give a damn.
@newslaundry What do you think Congress means by 'personal laws' under religious section of the Manifesto if not things like Sharia law? A sincere question.
“Haha… thats our strategy” lol 😂 its working for sure
Deep intellectual discussions but the lady is not at the same level as her co-panelists..Minisha would have been a better choice!
abhi ki gaali lagti hee nahi ki gaali hai.. i love your roughg talks abhi
👍🏾
Is it that chandrachoor is a lone warrior despite being the head of it all or is it that he’s very wisely deciding to have this two pronged approach to justice so that he and the court somehow has some appearance of fidelity with law just enough to maintain the power of the court just enough that they still have an bargaining power over the government? In that we don’t care what you do as long s how you do you and how little you portray as our power having being lost. Because when that becomes obvious our circle won’t respect us
Sir, it's not Worm Emperor 😭😭😭😭😭...... it's God Emperor 😣😣😣😣😣
IHT will be the biggest con, I see in UK, you can give meaningful amount to your kids while no IHT for royal lol
And there are always loopholes for rich ppl
Inheritance tax will help countries economy..
ho skta hai english padhne me dikkat ho, translate kardena chahiye manifesto ko...
It’s available in Hindi as well.
What these Commies and Chamchas won't say is even in US , inheritance tax is just levied in 6 states , not whole USA 😂
@@pp47-04 usmein bhi toh wahi bakwas likha jo inhone English mein likha
@@catfish9391 Kounsa tumko bakhwas lagta hai?
@@biswarupbhatacharjee6537 private sector mein reservation lagana reservation ke cap ko 50% bhardha dena phir 50% women reservation adha se zaida toh reserved hi hogya hm general category male logo ka kya hoga🥲🥲??
Save constitution
From Congress ? They changed the constitution most till now .
So when you all acuse the government of dictatorship, but it's wrong if Yogi says they are enacting Sharia Law, both the statements are hyperboles, what is your justification?
These are Commies...don't take them seriously. I watch them rant just for fun😂😂
@@souravbanerjee5796 I am glad a Bengali man like yourself is looking down at Commies, it gives me hope that Bengal isnt all lost cause. But it pisses me off man, these people are hyping idiots like Dhruv Tatti, and those idiots are gaining traction and misleading people.
@@johnyepthomi892 then there's no such thing as dictatorship, you should look at how you can talk freely over the internet and not face and repercussions instead of believing whatever hate is being spewed by your commie leaders.
@@souravbanerjee5796 aren't you a bengali
@@catfish9391 yes , so ??
I am definitely not a BJP supporter but I lean center right on fiscal issues. I have been voting for BRS, even though I don't particularly like them, because I have no option with BJP or congress. If congress becomes more conservative fiscally i will have a party to identify with, up until then people like me only have options at the state level.
😂 u r so lazy dat u dnt evn put d slightest effort to understand eco or d society arnd u... Elitist anti poor
save ladakh
save manipur
save democracy
save constitution
save INDIA❤
Save India by voting BJP❤❤❤❤
War rukwa di Papa
Thanks
Rahul Gandhi, also a child of privilege, is making the point repeatedly, about upper castes and classes capturing most of the institutions of power and wealth. It would make more sense to mention this rather than reacting to Modi’s election speeches.
Hi Team, I couldn't resist to register my complaint. I watched/heard 5 times the part where Vakasha was talking about the inheritance tax, I don't know who is "pikati" - The english was just like Jayashree, why I like those episodes where these highly educated people do not speak too much, I do not understand the English they speak, I can understand US accent and the UK as well, but Indian's vocabulary is so vast and the way SOBO and South Delhi and South Chennai guys speaks they just mess this big time, so casual but and fast and without opening the mouth .. I got headache and I super angry - because he was talking very important and interesting ... but fu#k it.
Dude do you even know what GINI coefficient means? 😂
Dune SPOILERS.!
Wealth and inheritance tax is must in India given massive income and living style inequality, this society has Party like SP where out of 62 candidates 2 are of family, same goes with NCP, BJP, CONGRESS, JDS. They are earning as MLA, MP, MINISTER by every means they are getting money and common person is just surviving somehow, likewise is case of businessmen, by political Nexus there families of businesses earning billions not by merit all these misusing power, it's just ILLITERACY RIGID FOOLISHNESS, IGNORANCE that will oppose Wealth and inheritance tax in India.
See, when Rajasthan, MP, Chattisgarh assembly elections were held all predictions were in favour of opposition parties, including opinion polls.
But finally unbelievable happened all doubts were on EVMs and still that strong conviction exist. That's why prominent people went to supreme court against EVM.
When first phase election was going on EVM case was under SC and there was an impression that SC is going to order counting of 100% VVPAT slip. This fear, coupled with the low voting percentage in first phase has shaken the confidence of Modi, as a result he went out of control and started uttering hate speeches.
But you see the change in Modi from yesterday after the supreme court (comedy) order in EVM case. There is visible relief on the face of Modi and Amit Shah. That means something transpired at higher level just before the supreme court order. Now Modi seems to be little calm. Means, the circumstantial evidence indicate that there is heightened possibility of EVM / VVPAT manipulation.
So don't think that Modi and Shah will go down without fighting. They have the support of all traitors in Police forces, Civil service and judiciary. They have huge black money power to purchase anybody and power to offer any cream positions in Govt. They have no respect in human rights and democratic principles. So anything can happen wrong with election process and EVM and they can manipulate final result. Surat is a small example.
Bhai log itni bade ecomic hai mai kya batao
I support 100% inheritance tax for the top 1% . Inheritance of wealth by super rich does not make any sense by any logic. Neither by economic rationality argument nor by moral or philosophical argument.
In india you come under top 10% , cause 90% are def poorer than u, as they don't know English, so why would they say on 1% , If they say top 10% quickly comes to you
Commie labourer don't talk too much 🤡🤡
Wrong, because by that logic of top 1% comes waqf act, and also inheritance laws won't apply to minority because their personal laws
I am not a bjp fan but inheritance tax redistribution, after so many years of socialism which end in 1991 liberalisation congress is moving so far left moving toward communism. They want me to vote bjp despite i hate them
There is no inheritance tax pm z lying... Dont b lazy read d manifesto instead f depending on random strangers on d net
that's a lame excuses. did congress manifesto say anything on Inheritance tax. no. then why vote for corrupt and weak BJP govt ?
@@diamond_dew wealth redistribution, inheritance tax, then excluding minorities giving their personal law excuse.. Everything makes sense.
Recently they gave reservation to minority in OBC. In past they removed SC ST reservation from AMU and Jamia Milia.
Message is clear, their votebank is their first love. Congress is actually khangress, worse party.
@@kshitijmawal5098 aa gaya bhakt bakwaas pelne... Tumhare paas wealth hai jo redistribute hoga? 80 cr ppl get free ration. Dimaag hota yo shayad istamaal karte.. Duffer
R@NDTV is happy to pretend as Journalist- R@ndish Kumar jindabaad- kaun jaat ho?
Pathetic logic
Actually there's no rationale for inheritance tax. Please understand that taxation is taking money from you and giving it to Adani or Ambani.
Replace BJP with Congress and you replace crony A with crony B.
Taxation is the cause of inequality, not the cure.
Can't agree. Scandinavian countries have tge highest level of taxation and inequality is lower there.
@@Pravasi-tm1tx Scandinavia has a functioning judiciary that actively prevents corruption and cronyism unlike India.
What you're advocating is to give 50% of your wealth to known thieves to either uplift others or take care of you when old.
Good luck with that
@@Pravasi-tm1tx Scandinavian countries have a functioning judiciary that punishes corruption and cronyism. India does not.
So if you wanna make Adani fatter, go ahead
Lage raho beta...this channel is excellent to pursue people vote for Modi ji... MODI 3.0💪
Only leftists agenda on this Congress bhakts channel. 😮
Clearly u dnt listen to dm else u wid knw de whine about inc fr no rsn all d time...
Gandhi Media 💊💊💊 got nice money from Gandhi's Family😂😂😂
Good to know that Gandhi Family is doing well enough to be able to buy off news channels.
I cannot believe you talk about Estate Tax and Inheritance tax and you know ‘Jack shit’ about it. The use of ‘Modality’ is a shroud for ignorance! It’s very clear, do your research. Its seems that the American Estate tax threshold is $13million, in Germany it’s an inheritance tax that varies between 7%-30%.
It’s really pleasing to hear this echo chamber. I am assured that my hypothesis - that hearing any ‘news channel’ give zero credible information - holds true … as yet. At least some of the other channels get Left-Right participants.
What sneering pretentiousness 😂! Typical left liberal , Khan Market types 😂! Interesting 🎉!!
Shekhar Gupta is up in arms because his neoliberal feelings are hurt and many more like him are too. Who cares 😂 33:07
Moye Moye in advance.. 😅😅