I hope they will bring back Paul Qui despite that will incur a lot of social cost. However, without one of the contestant that the judges consider as the best. Then any other winners who ended up winning an all winners season. Would win with an asterisk. And I wouldn't want that. Whether it is Brooke Williamson, or Hung, or Michael V, or Krishten Kish, or Stephanie Izard. I want them to win an all winners season without anyone can question or doubt it. And that they are indeed the best of the winners including besting Paul Qui if it comes down to that.
Brooke is an overrated chef. Brooke acts like she was robbed during her season. Kirsten beat her fair and square and Tom couldn’t pull a fast one because the judging was so structured. I believe that second season Brooke was on in South Carolina was set up to give her the title. Shirley, Sheldon, and Selver are better chefs and cooks than Brooke. Whenever Brooke ventures outside of her fine dining realm she is a disaster. For example her nasty so-called fried chicken during her first season. Shirley or Sheldon should have won over her. They are way more talented.
I don't recall Brooke saying she was robbed, she was disappointed in not winning against Kristen. She even said in the lead up to that finale that she wanted to win against Kristen to prove she didn't win all those challenges just because Kristen wasn't there. She actually seems pretty humble about her loss, and now is close friends with Kristen
Selver? You mean Silva? Brooke was not the strongest in season 14 (it was Sheldon) but she was definitely better than both Shirley and Silva. Hence why she won 8 challenges. Top chef is about the food and she did the best when it counts and it is one of the most succesful winners until now
@@bluesky23_ At this time, she is 10-1 in the Tournament of Champions head to head matches. Blind tests. This obliterates all the idiotic claims that she is overrated. You don't have to like her, but those claims are so ridiculous.
Who are you to say that Shirley, Sheldon, and Sylva are better chiefs? Who won top chief season 14? Brooke did. As you said with Kristen, Brooke when fair and square during season 14. Seriously though, it makes me laugh knowing that someone like you could ever say that other chiefs are better when she took the title of top chief. Who the f are you??
I have watched her from the beginning of her journey and even on other shows. She's really great and deserves to win!
Brook is one of the best chef's in the country. She has come a long way
Has some great restaurants.
Love Brooke!
Are you guys doing All Winners Season soon??? 🥰😭
I hope they will bring back Paul Qui despite that will incur a lot of social cost. However, without one of the contestant that the judges consider as the best. Then any other winners who ended up winning an all winners season. Would win with an asterisk. And I wouldn't want that. Whether it is Brooke Williamson, or Hung, or Michael V, or Krishten Kish, or Stephanie Izard. I want them to win an all winners season without anyone can question or doubt it. And that they are indeed the best of the winners including besting Paul Qui if it comes down to that.
as long as Kristen isn't there, she can win lol
How did she make that Panna Cotta in so little time? I never understood that. Doesn't it need at least 4 hours to set?
She is the best.
Brooke is an overrated chef. Brooke acts like she was robbed during her season. Kirsten beat her fair and square and Tom couldn’t pull a fast one because the judging was so structured. I believe that second season Brooke was on in South Carolina was set up to give her the title. Shirley, Sheldon, and Selver are better chefs and cooks than Brooke. Whenever Brooke ventures outside of her fine dining realm she is a disaster. For example her nasty so-called fried chicken during her first season. Shirley or Sheldon should have won over her. They are way more talented.
I don't recall Brooke saying she was robbed, she was disappointed in not winning against Kristen. She even said in the lead up to that finale that she wanted to win against Kristen to prove she didn't win all those challenges just because Kristen wasn't there. She actually seems pretty humble about her loss, and now is close friends with Kristen
But she won the 1st ever Tournament of Champions beating Michael Voltaggio, Jed Tila and Amanda Freitag, all under BLIND TASTING. So???
Selver? You mean Silva? Brooke was not the strongest in season 14 (it was Sheldon) but she was definitely better than both Shirley and Silva. Hence why she won 8 challenges. Top chef is about the food and she did the best when it counts and it is one of the most succesful winners until now
@@bluesky23_ At this time, she is 10-1 in the Tournament of Champions head to head matches. Blind tests. This obliterates all the idiotic claims that she is overrated. You don't have to like her, but those claims are so ridiculous.
Who are you to say that Shirley, Sheldon, and Sylva are better chiefs? Who won top chief season 14? Brooke did. As you said with Kristen, Brooke when fair and square during season 14. Seriously though, it makes me laugh knowing that someone like you could ever say that other chiefs are better when she took the title of top chief. Who the f are you??