The WORST NHL Trades Of The Past Decade
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- NHL Trades can be incredibly exciting at times, but have you ever looked back on some deals and wondered what were they thinking! Well that's what I'll be doing today. Let's look back at some of the worst trades from the past decade and breakdown why these deals would never happen again if they were proposed today. Subscribe to Jimmy Hockey for more NHL News and Breakdowns and NHL 2024 Highlights
TikTok:
www.tiktok.com...
Instagram:
/ jimmyhockeyy
#nhl #hockey #stanleycupplayoffs #icehockey #hockeyhighlights #montrealcanadiens #hockeyvideos #goldenknights #edmontonoilers #nhlplayoffs #nhlhockey #connorbedard #chicagoblackhawks #vancouvercanucks
![[UA] Eternal Fire проти NAVI | EPL Season 20 Malta](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/chvlsDygrZM/mqdefault.jpg)
Which NHL Trade of the past decade is the worst, drop them for a part two
The Winnipeg LA Dubois Trade was a fleece. I will also say the Ullmark trade as well.
@@jimmyhockey Taylor Hall to Jersey
you don't even put the Sens trading Karlsson for Norris and picks which one led to Stutzle?
@@swen1208Yeah!! Agree 👍
@swen1208 that's my pick
That buch pronunciation is crazy lol
Bro has never watched hockey in his life. Or he is mentally challenged
He lost a bit of credibility to me when I heard that lol
And the Erat😂
American is not the only english there is
Interesting how Tkachuk in the thumbnail just won the Stanley Cup along with the Panthers. I do feel happy 99% of Flames fans had our backs, you guys are amazing.
@@mcrmonkey0 you're very welcome, as for mistake from our perspective thats the treliving special (have fun toronto hiring him), but tbh he wasnt going to win with us, we have a dumpster fire clown management/ownership on par with the sabres, glad he could find success in florida
@@mcrmonkey0it’s because Chucky didn’t want to resign with Calgary, he made that clear to them, so instead of letting him walk for nothing, they opted to take the best offer available and ig that was the panthers.
@@mcrmonkey0 Calgary was forced into a trade with Florida and I'm happy with Weegar and Hub will be fine.
as a flames fan, i've always hated tkatchuk
@@mcrmonkey0bro you clearly didn’t do any research.
i thought you were gonna be one of those new, legit hockey chanel’s i subscribed to, until you said, “byuke-no-vick” wtf bro lmao
Haha! That did hurt me in my soul when I heard that, but otherwise a well done video.
Add Martian Uh-Rat to the brutal mispronunciation.
For those unaware, it’s E-Rat not that butchering
@@dylanjohnson505Erat I used to play games in franchise mode and score like 40 goals with him on Washington cause I felt so bad for him hahaha
@@Statsy10I was about to say the same exact thing lol
He kept saying it too 😅😊
The fact the Winnipeg highway robbery Dubois trade isn’t on there is crazy
Yes the trade was bad, but everyone’s acting like LA gave up two first round picks to get him. The contract extension was worse than the trade itself. Also, the Jets and Kings both got blown out in the first round and face a future of mediocrity, so where exactly is the “win” for the Jets here?
@@oceanthresher6184 I think the “win” for the jets comes when you look at the fact that Dubois was traded for 4 assets 2 of which are solid roster players for the jets. And even if the trade was a one for one vilardi for Dubois I think Winnipeg STILL wins the trade. Dubois had 40 points in 82 games last season and vilardi had 36 in 47 games played. And when you look at the big picture it gets really ugly the kings traded Rasmus kupari Alex iafallo gabe vilardi and a second round pick for Darcy kuemper who is past his prime and has maybe 2 years left in the tank.
@@oceanthresher6184jets places 4th overall lol and vilardi played on the top line. Just coz we lose one year in the first doesnt mean it was a bad trade. You seem to not understand how trades work
Vancouver fan here. Kinda surprised that the list spared Jim Benning's embarrassing catalogue of bad trades.
ULLMARK JUST GOT TRADED TO THE SENS
Yeah idk what Boston is cooking 😬
Nothing much 😂
@@Mr_Mister15893 he might dive in sens
The Flyers trading away Bobrovsky is laughable. What they got in return for Columbus was two second round picks which ended up being Anthony Stolarz, and Taylor Leier. And a fourth round pick which they used to reaquire Simon Gagne lol. Meanwhile Bobrovsky is a two time Vezina trophy winner, and a Stanley cup champion probably a hall of famer as well.
And Stolarz ends up becoming bobrovsky’s backup for a year and gets his name on the cup too
I'm sad as a lightning fan to miss out on JT Miller he's been great in Vancouver since his trade thare
Chicago...Hands down, it's a two-part disaster. Trading for Seth Jones, then signing Jones to a massive no-move contract. The only problem with the Panarin trade was they got nothing in return, Panarin was never going to be part of the team's future plans. The Jones nightmare will last for years and only get worse.
for some reason i thought the Jets kings Dubois trade was going to be here lol
You think kings won that??
@planetcaravan2925 No, they got ripped off, that's why it's a bad trade
As Panthers fan - Tkachuk trade was great! :)
The hawks were cap strapped. On top of that to a lot of these guys were rushed out. Nobody wanted to pay for some contracts
Mark stone was about to become a free agent and had told the senators management that he did not want to come back to ottawa.
They needed to get a better haul for Stone. That's the issue.
Blackhawks won 3 Cups since 2010. Pretty tough to maintain that. In the end, they got Bedard and are kind of starting over. I think with Kane, Toews, Hossa and Keith pretty much gone or in decline, the overall concept of rebuilding makes sense after losing 4 of the best players to ever play the game.
See I don’t know about the JT Miller trade because I’m sure the lightning at least at the time wanted 91 to retire in Tampa
I feel like it is important to look at logistics aswell like if the player forced his way out or character issues
raise the floor on the salary cap by $25M and the ceiling by $40M and trades like these will stop. As it is, teams have a choice to stay under the cap: trade the guy and get something for him, or lose him and get nothing to show for it, because teams cant afford to pay everyone what they want and stay under the Cap.
You look like Walter Whites son.
Thanks for the content.
Oilers getting Ekholm for Barrie was a total steal. It completely transformed their defense and made them into a true Cup contender and gave them one of the best pairings in the league with him and Bouchard. Barrie, meanwhile, was constantly scratched from the Preds lineup.
Patrick Roy demanded a trade tho
The tkachuk trade gives me life as an oilers fan
The debrincat trade is not the worst trade really cause at the time hawks had to commit on the rebuild and needed a 1st round pick if anything ottawa lost this trade sort of cause he had a meh season that time and debrincat did not stay in ottawa after 1 yr. So the hawks got korchinski out of that trade as well as Paul ludwinski, who may look like a quality steal MAYBE, from the draft and a 3rd rounder for this upcoming draft. So getting draft capital was worth the risk. The panarin one til this day for me HURTZ REAL BAD.....F*!? YOU BOWBUM
Sergachev for Drouin
Stu Barnes and Jason Wooley for Chris Wells was a trainwreck
Half these players didnt want to be on their current team. Also, Barkov makes average players elite.
Miller trade wasnt worst trades of decades, Lighting won two Cup row after trade and was in Stanley Cup finals three time. It was cap tump trade. Winning Cup is only thing whats matters. Trade winners should look like that. After Miller trade Tampa won 2 cup, how many cup Miller won? None. You can argue Tampa could have won those Cups with Miller too, but we cant know it, but what we can know, they did win two without him.
What about when Montreal gave Sergachev to Tampa for Drouin??
Zibanejad trade happened cuz owner was cheap. Zibanejad was on his bridge deal and was due for a big pay raise in the future. Meanwhile Brassard's contract had front loaded bonuses that the rangers already paid so the salary the senators owed him was around 3million a year with 5million cap hit. Its meaningless meddling that made me gave up as a Senators fan. They had a lot of very good homegrown talent, that were thoroughly developed and paid their dues in the AHL and were basically loyal to the team and franchise but just gave up on them for practically nothing.
I am going to approach this in a different way... I think one of the worst trades for all parties involved was the Panthers and Flyers trade in the 2021-2022 season. Stick with me here... This trade was supposed to put the Panthers over the top. Sending Owen Tippet and some sweeteners to the Flyers for Claude Giroux. Giroux while productive down the stretch, was basically a non-factor in playoffs for the Panthers. Now here is where the trade gets crazy for me. The following year, Giroux declines to sign with the Panthers missing out on an epic Stanley Cup run. imagine if Giroux would have stayed with the Panthers. Tippet on 25 is a 50+ PT scorer who I believe on the right team could do even more. Giroux ends up in Ottawa on a bad time. In end, FL got nothing for this trade and lost a good young talent. The Flyers missed the playoffs. Giroux being the biggest loser if the deal didn't get to lift the cup.
The Alex Debrincat trade wasn’t a bad on on the hawks end idk wtf you’re talking about
Dorion had a 8x8 ready for Stone but Melnyk said youre not doing that were rebuilding trade him. Its been reported
Wasnt stone traded because of drama with karlsson?
Its tough being a capitals fan😔
Wayne Gretzky from Oilers to LA
I remember thinking flames fleeced the panthers🤡
The zibanejad trade looked bad the day they made it ans even worse now
If the flames didn’t trade tkwchuk wasn’t he gonna walk as a UFA?
If the lightning had kept miller, they probably wouldn’t have had those cups
I’ve never heard buchnevich pronounced like that😂😂 it’s Booch-neh-vitch
Hall for Larsson
Tyler Seguin trade
Tkachuk trade isn’t the worst.
jake guentzel for a 3rd😭
BYOOKNOVICH???? BLAIZ??????
You pronounced it Bouk-ne-vitch, you’re supposed to pronounce it Bouts-nev-itch
Debrincat one wasn’t bad
😃: Byuknavich
I would say that although it wasnt a devastating trade but when the blues traded tage thompson and a 1st round pick to buffalo for O'Reilly. Now O'Reilly was a pretty decent player leading the blues to a cup, but i think if we just devloped thompson more he couldve been a franchise staple.
Mitch marner got traded to the Utah hockey club
Cap
Gee what inspired this video
Booshnayvich
Toews most overrated hockey player I’ve seen tbh. Dude was average asf his entire career and idek how that did got the C. dude got carried by Kane, sharp, Keith, etc.
3 cups? Clearly never watched him play
@@Luke-ou6wh buddy I’ve watch every year since 2007 so I think I know what I’m saying. He’s literally been average his entire career. Got carried by players his whole career just like how fluery got carried by top tier teams his entire career
Does this guy even watch hockey lol? These pronunciations are brutal
Hi
👋
Sergachev for Drouin is up there for sure
Montreal fleeced Vegas by trading Max Pacioretty for Nick Suzuki, Tomas Tatar, and a 2nd round pick in 2019. Suzuki is now our captain and Tatar, during his time with Montreal put up better numbers than Pacioretty ever did with Vegas.
Habs also got fleeced with that mcdonagh gomez trade
@@lennyshow5146 then got fleeced again when they sent Sergachev to Tampa for Drouin
As a Knights fan, the Pacioretty deal is easily the worst. Basically we traded a future all star and more assets for an injury prone drama queen. Good for the habs, but that still stings a bit
And this all traces back to the Craig Rivet trade..!
@@lennyshow5146remembering hurts a lot
Another one-
FLA receive:
Alex Auld
Todd “7-game” Bertuzzi
VAN:
Roberto FUCKING Luongo
Worst trade I’ve ever heard in my life
Preach. Worst fucking trade i've ever seen. I wanted criminal charges filed when that happened.
Im so offended, hurt in my feelers almost 20 years on- I think im going to sue bertuzzi
GM accidentally clicked accept like it was Franchise Mode 🤣
This is a terrible take …. what were the Flames supposed to do? Gaudreau left for nothing, they got a decent defenseman, and a decent winger…. it wasn’t the trade that was bad especially considering the position the Flames were in… it was the signing huberdeau to a contract paying him for his career year instead of paying him a reasonable salary… if his salary was actually on par with his skills instead of for an outlier season then all is fine.
Calling the trade terrible is just a lazy ridiculous statement
But if you can tell me what they were supposed to do instead….
Well you could’ve actually gone somewhere while you had him and maybe then he wouldn’t have wanted the first flight out of there. The “he wanted out” crowd is always the biggest sore losers.
While more than 10 years ago.... ottawa trading Alexei Yashin to the NYI for Bill Muckalt, Zdeno Chara, and and 2nd overall pick ( Jason Spezza)
Tampa and Nashville with Jeannot
Matt duchene to the sens has to be one of the worst all time imo.
Canuck fan here, and I'm shocked the Oliver Ekman Larsson trade didn't make the list. OEL was so bad for the Nucks that he was bought out, and his buyout is gonna cripple the Canucks for years to come. The 9th overall that was traded to the Coyotes turned into Guenther, who's looking like a star in the making.
That trade made no sense (from canucks perspective). Being swedish myself I always though OEL was underrated during his prime and somewhat held back by playing in a fairly bad team, so I always looked upon that contract he signed with Coyotes as a sort of "reward" contract (loyalty/long-time service) and that he was sort of destined to finish his career in Arizona. Then for some reason Canucks take over this lengthy, expensive contract for a player past his prime, just to off-load another bad contract (that was close to expire). Why didn't they just buy out Eriksson's contract instead? That would have been so much cheaper and less staining on the salary cap. Mind boggling...
@@erikhogberg6635 Benning trying desperately to save his job, which he lost the next year anyways
Erat/Forsberg trade basically got the GM in Washington (George McPhee) fired. Long story short- his replacement pieced together a better lineup and they won the Cup in '18. That pretty much got everyone in DC over this trade, but it was a major annoyance up until then. Not sure Forsberg ever would have gotten the ice time in DC to develop into what he became in Nashville. And after all that McPhee goes to Vegas and loses to the Caps in '18, but wins it in '23.
For years that trade was a big wound … still bleeds sometimes tho 🫣
agreed on all that I still think Mcphee was the best executive of the bunch . I understand why he got fired but he set the capitals up for the success that they had .
This trade still haunts me even though the Caps won in '18
Difficult one with Panarin.. of course he is a top 3 winger in the league but when they traded Panarin, they already had 3 cups within 5 years and looking at it right now, having Nazar, Korchinsky, Bedard and likely getting Demidov or another top talent this year, they set themselves up for another good run in couple of years. Keeping Panarin would help them stay on the top for couple years longer but inevitably they need to go through a rebuild. This way they got a generational talent in Bedard
It was not a hockey decision - Panarin was going to be UFA and made it known that he wanted to play in NY. Chicago wanted to get something rather than nothing .
@@pjpredhomme7699 Don’t think that’s right when it comes to Chicago. Panarin didn’t go to Rangers, he went to Blue Jackets for 2 seasons or so before he was traded to Rangers
What about Taylor Hall to the Devils for Adam Larsson
Def turned larsson into quite a haul as that trade tree keeps going
Hall needed to leave to start a 🔥under him, a little more than Larson would’ve been nice though.
Calgary flames trading away Sam Bennett for basically nothing is a very bad trade for calgary
The reason why they traded Patrick Roy was because his coach left him in net for 9 straight goals and when they finally pulled him he told his coach that he never wanted to play for Montreal again, and then the next day Montreal traded him to Colorado.
I think most people know that. It was still a bad trade.
Caps fan chiming in here. The Forsberg trade isnt just one of the worst trades in the past decade. Its arguable one of the top 3-5 worst trades of all time. The real question is, do we win a cup with Forsberg? My thinking is if we have him signed, we dont go out an acquire Oshie who helped win the cup due to cap restraints. But would we have won in 2015 or 2016 when we were heavy favorites with him on the roster or even not at all? Who knows
The Tkachuk trade was honestly fair value for the Flames. The issue isn’t with the trade itself, but with how Calgary immediately signed Huberdeau to a massive extension despite totally not needing to, and trying to keep being competitive, despite having a woefully insufficient roster.
I was shocked they didn't let him play for the season before signing him...the Panthers had switched to that new offensive system and huberdeau had barkov feeding him pucks, so of course he scored...if they had bothered to look at his past record he'd never came anywhere close to 100 plus points. The great thing about Weeger leaving is I didn't have to hear my husband scream, Oh Weeger anymore...plus I still have bad memories from game 3 against Tampa when Weeger decided at 3 seconds left in the game and the score tied, he could just skate off the ice leaving Bob totally unprotected and the lightning scored...that game was followed by the potential strip club incident and a game 4 not only did we get swept but also shut out...yeah the Tkachuk deal was a steal
Yeah lol I honestly don’t understand why the trade is always talked about as a disaster when it was 100% the contract. Obviously Huberdeau isn’t the player anyone thought at the time of the trade but even in hindsight they still got a middle 6 winger, a top pairing defenseman and a first round pick, still a loss on the trade but definitely not one of the worst of the last decade.
I still remember everyone saying that the Flames fleeced the Panthers after it happened. I don’t think anyone saw Huberdeu falling off a cliff this hard
As a Canucks fan I thought we way overpaid to get Miller at the time, but that trade has turned into one of the best in franchise history.
Worked out for the lightning to. 1st round pick was used to trade for Blake Coleman who helped them win back to back cups. Win win for both teams
I feel like this video is missing some context.
The flames deal wasnt bad. It still wouldn't be bad if management didnt mismange everything.
They got a 1st rounder witb it and just sent it to montreal with monahan for future considerations to sign kadri and then signed hubby to a massive deal. If they managed it better it wouldnt be "one of the worst in nhl history"
Excellent video.
I loved the thumbnail choice too 😂
If you want an old trade that was terrible it was Leafs Russ Courtnall to the Habs for John Kordic.
A large part of the Panarin trade was his lack of performance in playoffs on top of the large contract coming up, hence why they wanted Saad back… he went missing in the playoffs for the Blue Jackets/Rangers too
As a maple leafs fan, I was so annoyed when they traded Alexander Steen for Stempniak and Coliacovo.
Tikchuk was an interesting one. He wasn’t resigning and at the time hunerdeau had a career year and you get a first round pick. Looked like panthers got robbed until huberdeau was ass
The Eric Karllson trade for the sharks. We lost 2 1st round picks, 1 being the 5th overall. And we had to let Pavelski walk because we paid Karlsson to score points and not play defense
The Tkachuk Huberdeau trade was an incredible trade. The Flames got 2 (theoretically) solid players and a prospect for Tkachuk straight up. The signings are what became a disaster. The trade itself was great. Don’t get it mixed up.
They should of moved Huberdeau for picks and player. I think management continues to interfere.
Flames went from a good team to a shite team. Don't get it mixed up. It was great on paper and not on the ice.
You forgot the leafs trading Tuka rask for roycroft, who’s roycroft? Exactly 😂
Jeannot trade
Can you do the worst draft picks
Dallas Stars Find Jake Oettinger - Anaheim played 11 games while beating Calgary and Edmonton in the first two rounds and Eaves played in seven, which meant the Stars would pick 29th in the first round in the Ducks' slot. GM Jim Nill then swapped slots with the No. 26 Chicago Blackhawks, sending the pick to the Windy City and selecting, wait for it...Jake Oettinger
This is evident that you don't know anything about the Flames. There was no way the Flames could of won with Tkachuk and Gaudreau. Tkachuk was invisible in the playoffs for Calgary. Johnnny too. Tkachuk wasn't a key player for Florida in their Stanley cup run. He is grossly overated. Yes Huberdeau has been terrible but Weeger has been amazing. This trade wasn't one for one. So to say we lost this trade is absurd. We also recieved a first and a prospect. Well done considering Tkachuk had us over a barrel. Tkachuk is one of the most overated players in the NHL , He is super Lazy.
You’re placing a high premium on being able to evaluate these trades after the fact.
Several of the trades you mentioned, at the time, we’re either well received (CAL/FLA) or well understood, due to context (Panarin).
The mark Stone trade in particular, I remember several TSN analysts, saying this might end up being called the Fabian Brannström trade.
There’s a difference between say the watch trade, which was bad when it happened, and bad, after the fact. And a trade, where you use the benefit of foresight to judge it.
Bad trades aren't always a reflection of bad management. Circumstances often dictate bad trades. General managers often knowingly make trades in which they give up more than they obtain. Sometimes it's cap related while other times a player is not so good for the rest of the team in the dressing room or the team has an abundance of one type of player and a pressing need for another. Maybe they're in rebuild mode. The list goes on. Matthew Tkachuk is what Florida needed when they were building up - he was one of the final missing pieces. Not so sure that Calgary was or would be stronger have been with Tkachuk and Johnny Gaudreau bu a Cup contender????? The Flames will recover soon while the Panthers dismantle and Columbus goes nowhere. At least Florida and Matthew Tkachuk got their Stanley Cup.
Excellent analysis. I love the way the commentary is balanced and includes the salary cap realities, but digs into the truth of just how one sided some of these trades are. Tkachuk for Huberdeau is the worst trade of the last ten years. I get that Calgary was under the gun, but... as a Leafs fan? Brad Treliving did not seem to be the GM to sign. Hoping I'm wrong. Not sure that I am.
Winnipeg Jets Trade Teemu Selanne to Anaheim Mighty
Calgary Trades Brett Hull to the St. Louis Blues
Calgary Trades Doug Gilmour to the Toronto Maple Leafs
Edmonton trading Mark Messier to the NY Rangers
The Sabres parting ways with Reinhart & Eichel who both went on to WIN CUPS makes the Sabres look foolish. The Sabres are NOT even in the playoffs & are always on the cusp but never take that next step.....
Easily one of the worse trades in recent NYR history that being a trend in this video,
Ryan McDonagh, JT Miller sent to Tampa and I don’t even remember what they were given when typing this out. I think Brett Howden, and some picks but that one hurts
One trade I would’ve included was the Devils trading for Taylor Hall for Adam Larsen, I get he wasn’t with New Jersey for very long, but he won an MVP
If I remember right Canucks fans didn't really like that Benning gave that 1st. It had lot of critics. Tampa traded that pick for Coleman and they won the cup twice.So I'd say it worked out for both
Love these Monday morning QB videos..it's so difficult to say years later..they shouldnt have made this trade....how about a real video and tell me the trades that just happened will not pan out..then after a few years go by look to see how right you were..show some balls
With the Panarin trade, the Blackhawks had a bunch of players with NMCs thus making a trade of those other players harder to make. Either way, Columbus won that trade easily.
Ryan Callahan had to be one of the worst trades rangers made. Maybe not in the past decade but Ryan callanhan could’ve given us what we needed to win the cup. Marty St. Louis did nothing for the rangers. Poor decision
If you do another video like this you can add the Drouin for Sergachev trade. One player got his team two cups playing top minutes, while the other was overpaid and never lived up to his super high expectations
Seth Jones to the hawks (plus extension) a team who were clearly in need of a rebuild gave up multiple first round picks for a slightly above average defenceman
Seth Jones to the hawks (plus extension) a team who were clearly in need of a rebuild gave up multiple first round picks for a slightly above average defenceman
So Calgary should of kept tkachuk and let him walk in FA? Makes no sense. Still was a great trade for a player who was not going to sign and limited places to trade too. Weegar is an absolute stud