Can Mini LED Beat OLED? - 2024 TCL 75” QM851G Review

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 129

  • @thedisplayguy
    @thedisplayguy  4 місяці тому +9

    Update: After further testing I actually was able to get the QM8 to follow HDR EOTF well at the cost of max brightness. This also improves the HDR color accuracy.
    Thank you to Ruipro for sponsoring this video!
    Buy the Ruipro HDMI 2.1 Certified Fiber Optic Cable (6FT): amzn.to/3wvHB7j
    Buy the Ruipro HDMI 2.1 Certified Fiber Optic Cable (25FT): amzn.to/432NDGS
    Buy Ruipro Cables: ruipro.store/collections/all
    Best Monitor Settings Here (Guides & Discord): patreon.com/TheDisplayGuy
    Thank you to TCL for providing the TV for this review!
    Buy 2024 QM8 Amazon Affiliate Link: amzn.to/46ANcas
    Buy 2024 QM8 Best Buy Affiliate Link: howl.me/cmN359KqAuV

    • @RedLeo-pf9yo
      @RedLeo-pf9yo 4 місяці тому

      Man called these awesome TVs used to cost their upper leg. Now they’re practically giving them away.

    • @GenX_in_the_wild
      @GenX_in_the_wild 3 місяці тому +1

      Max brightness is overrated.. Accuracy ftw..

    • @BangSkeeet
      @BangSkeeet 2 місяці тому

      So what is the new peak HDR brightness, and what does the HDR color accuracy look like now? These were the main 2 things holding me back from purchasing this 75" TV

    • @zadarblack
      @zadarblack 28 днів тому

      They fixed the EOTF issues with latest firmware so no more need to sacrifice max brightness :)

    • @BangSkeeet
      @BangSkeeet 28 днів тому

      @@zadarblack Sounds great, has anyone re-tested this new firmware with an improved EOTF chart?

  • @ShuhDonk
    @ShuhDonk 4 місяці тому +17

    Just got the qm8 98" the other day, got it from bb for 4k when they had it on sale, well worth it imo, the tv looks amazing and for that price it is a no brainer.

    • @sammy10001
      @sammy10001 4 місяці тому +1

      Solid purchase man. 77 qd oled doesn't stand a chance against the 98.

    • @chebrubin
      @chebrubin 4 місяці тому +1

      Everyday you wake up to the brightest most impressive 98" in the world. Is a good day. Put on the first 10 minutes of Bad Boys: Ride or Die in Dolby Vision. Be prepared to be blown away.

    • @micdoses1
      @micdoses1 4 місяці тому

      All I have to say is
      🙌

    • @shanew7361
      @shanew7361 3 місяці тому +2

      How's the motion handling and blooming? I'm debating on getting this in 75 and 98 inches. Have only owned LG OLED's, and the burn in over time from static images sucks 😂 I'm done with OLED's. The Sony Bravia B9 is too damn expensive 😂. Any issues over 25hz like judder or screen tearing etc.

  • @budthecyborg4575
    @budthecyborg4575 4 місяці тому +3

    I am very happy to see this review since RTINGS only reviewed the 65" version, so now we have actual hands-on verification of the zone count at 75".

    • @ZeitGeist_TV
      @ZeitGeist_TV 4 місяці тому +4

      That's what I was waiting on as well since the 75 inch is what I'll be buying with a 5 yr warranty from Best Buy this Black Friday.

    • @harshrajjadhav940
      @harshrajjadhav940 Місяць тому

      do you really need a warranty for a lcd?​@@ZeitGeist_TV

    • @AstroDeathZombie
      @AstroDeathZombie 16 днів тому +1

      Without having to watch the whole video and find it, could you tell me what he got for the zone count? I bought one last saturday and am curious since I haven't found it anywhere listed :EDIT: Found for anyone else who wants to know- He counted 4032- ALLEGEDLY :P

  • @budthecyborg4575
    @budthecyborg4575 4 місяці тому +6

    I would love to see a head to head comparison of the TCL QM8 and the Hisense U8N.

    • @heyolorenns
      @heyolorenns 3 місяці тому +1

      Qm8 molly whops U8N and yes they have similar specs but U8n doesn't utilize it. Qm8 rivals the Samsung S95D with quantum tv’s settings. (yes everyone hates him but his settings and calibrations are god tier).

    • @beammeupscottsp7952
      @beammeupscottsp7952 3 місяці тому

      @@heyolorennswhat’s wrong with the u8n, I heard it’s really good except for the 55 inch.

    • @bucclao209
      @bucclao209 7 днів тому

      @@beammeupscottsp7952 I also bought the 98” U8n and I returned for the tcl 98” S5 even though it wasn’t mini led it still looked better to me & the processor on the u8 can’t compete with the tcl so I think the go with tcl vs hisense

  • @suedepup
    @suedepup 3 місяці тому +3

    You mention slight audio delay. Is that with the on-board audio or external soundbars via eARC? This is something I really need to know.

  • @tadejpeckaj1151
    @tadejpeckaj1151 16 днів тому

    I just ordered this TV today :)

  • @tgeorgom
    @tgeorgom 4 місяці тому +6

    The issue I have with those monitors is the limited warranty. You are getting a high price monitor and won't even get any replacement any true free repair (shipping costs, extra possible defects might be found, etc), for a piece of equipment most of us will want to have for at least a decade.

  • @nBasterd
    @nBasterd 4 місяці тому

    Goooood job. Excellent review. Well explained & easily understandable graphs.

  • @joshbreaux5475
    @joshbreaux5475 7 днів тому

    This is on sale at best buy right now for $899, casual gamer...everyday tv watcher. Not a calibration snob cuz i dont understand all of that crap so will be using it out of the box.

  • @Keivz
    @Keivz 4 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for mentioning vrr flicker. I have a u8k and it’s an excellent tv minus the vrr flicker which makes it nearly useless for gaming. Black smearing is also an issue and because of it I think va panels will never come close to oled in gaming.

  • @larryhoffman7471
    @larryhoffman7471 4 місяці тому +1

    How does the comparable Hisense 75” compare? U8L I believe.

  • @bucclao209
    @bucclao209 8 днів тому

    The qm7 is mini led has simi gloss, but I’m torn on getting the qm8 mini led I like the glossy screen look cuz the pictures pop more. Should wait for the qm8 on next year Black Friday??? I know it’s a long time but it’s worth the wait if price drops close to $2000 I’m talking about the 98” qm8 & 98”qm7 ..

    • @ithrowcardsalex9992
      @ithrowcardsalex9992 8 днів тому

      Get the QM8. One of the best TV’s I’ve ever seen and quite the upgrade from the QM7.

    • @bucclao209
      @bucclao209 7 днів тому

      @ yeah I ordered the 98” qm7 delivery next week, but might wait a year next Black Friday !!! Thx for your input it’s a long wait but hope it’s worth it!! Gonna cancel my qm7

  • @jakethebeast3166
    @jakethebeast3166 4 місяці тому +9

    searing my eyeballs with 5000 nits

  • @jesus-fg2bd
    @jesus-fg2bd 19 днів тому

    Displayguy Where do you have the calibration settings?

  • @Trai1b1aze
    @Trai1b1aze 4 місяці тому +1

    Have you received the new pg32ucdp for review? If it wasn't for the partial matte coating it looks like it might finally be true endgame gaming monitor (for single player and fps games) and higher hdr brightness than normal for WOLED.

  • @cjcaton19
    @cjcaton19 4 місяці тому +4

    I love my last years 85" QM8

  • @bungalowtomcat1
    @bungalowtomcat1 3 місяці тому

    HI Is there BAD MACROB-LOCKING 1 Horrible 10 PERFECT ???

  • @noidsuper
    @noidsuper 4 місяці тому +1

    I'd love a mini led TV, but holy shit they are almost all too big for a desk setup or too expensive. I feel like we should have mini leds competing at the 42" size competing with the LG C series but we kind of just don't.

    • @budthecyborg4575
      @budthecyborg4575 4 місяці тому +1

      It is a real shame they won't even make this display in 55".
      What's more it's a common trend among Mini-LED TVs to make the 55" version really crappy with often half the dimming zones you'd find at 65" or 75". Which is super annoying when I'd gladly pay the same price for the same specs just at a smaller size.

    • @noidsuper
      @noidsuper 4 місяці тому +1

      @@budthecyborg4575 Yeah. It’s like the mid size miniledTVs get disproportionately shafted. It ends up being a sort of awkward middle ground where it they don’t have the dimming zones, or the response times to compete with OLED. I can sacrifice the response times for exceptional HDR performance, but you only really get that on the bigger screens.

    • @tomaspla4252
      @tomaspla4252 4 місяці тому +1

      I game on a 43' qn90b, it has around 400 zones, but the HDR is great, the main drawback is that its 400nits on 2% windows, but then it is 800/1000 for 10% up until 50% at 800 and 100% at 600.
      Since it has that low brightness on smaller highlights, it doesn't produce very noticeable blooming.
      I think it can compete with Oled in some aspects, it looks better on bright scenes and worse on dark ones.
      I have been eyeing oleds for a time but the brightness specs in bigger windows currently don't cut it for me. Also, of course pixel response time is superior on oled as well, but having temporal ghosting and blur in games kind of kills the advantages of the lower response times.
      Edit: got it used at 400bucks, so pretty good deal.

    • @budthecyborg4575
      @budthecyborg4575 4 місяці тому

      @@tomaspla4252 After buying an 1,100nits PC monitor and comparing with my OLED it's surprising how much brighter the 800nits OLED appears in many scenes.
      Even though RTINGS records the same 2% window brightness between the LG C1 and INNOCN27M2V monitor, the LG C1 obviously produces specular highlights much better than the 1,152 zone IPS type LCD monitor.
      LCD FALD is great if you need to pump out a lot of light but I almost always prefer the OLED.

  • @erzascralet48
    @erzascralet48 4 місяці тому +2

    Would love to see your comparison of this to the Hisense U8N. My local Best Buy has only the QM751G on display, NO QM851G, which is so dumb. The Hisense U8N on display however looks incredible with great blacks, glossy screen and I think no rainbow effect on the reflections.

  • @marklloyd4153
    @marklloyd4153 22 дні тому

    I want to really like this tv . The Chinese have had a lot of problems in the past is that over ? How reliable are they compared to the Korean Japanese makers ? Doesn’t offer the Sony processing ability . It has thousands of dimming zones . For $1500 to $2K for 75 to 85 inch tvs I think I’ll give it a shot . I have satellite , Netflix & Amazon for movies news and weather .

  • @deus_nsf
    @deus_nsf 4 місяці тому

    7:03 What about 1080p240Hz though? You said it supported it.

    • @thedisplayguy
      @thedisplayguy  4 місяці тому +2

      It’s not good.

    • @deus_nsf
      @deus_nsf 4 місяці тому

      ​@@thedisplayguyoh... Sadge. Thanks for answering

    • @Vegatablez
      @Vegatablez 4 місяці тому

      @@thedisplayguy unfortunate... but i still would have liked to see the ufo test😁

  • @TheMasterMakarov
    @TheMasterMakarov 4 місяці тому

    honestly the only thing where 1000 zone mini led lack behind is Stars in Space
    so how can it handle that now that there is 5x the zone count

  • @sammy10001
    @sammy10001 4 місяці тому +2

    Is baldurs gate even a hdr 5000 game?
    You'd need a game like God of war with sliders upto 10k

    • @deus_nsf
      @deus_nsf 4 місяці тому +1

      Or SpecialK HDR.

  • @OlderRockRocks
    @OlderRockRocks 4 місяці тому

    Whats's the european model umber or are they the same??

  • @Eusebiugh
    @Eusebiugh 4 місяці тому

    Where is tcl 27r83u review?

  • @jonathanchaney6140
    @jonathanchaney6140 4 місяці тому +4

    Is it better than the hisense u8n

    • @thedisplayguy
      @thedisplayguy  4 місяці тому +14

      I will be reviewing that next.

    • @jonathanchaney6140
      @jonathanchaney6140 4 місяці тому

      ​@@thedisplayguy thank you

    • @budthecyborg4575
      @budthecyborg4575 4 місяці тому +4

      @@thedisplayguy TV Showdown of the year.
      What I really want to see in the U8N vs QM8 comparison is the perceived brightness of a starfield pattern: ua-cam.com/video/PMJiHJoE0L8/v-deo.html
      If you're getting the 75" U8N it becomes particularly interesting when according to RTINGS the 75" U8N has an ADS Pro panel (IPS type) vs. the 65" with VA, and in this case I would personally recommend the 65" U8N over the 75" U8N because I consider native contrast just as important as dimming zones, and reportedly the 65" U8N has the highest native contrast of any LCD ever tested.

    • @gangs0846
      @gangs0846 4 місяці тому

      @@budthecyborg4575so ads (pro) is a worse than va?

  • @MakeSh00t
    @MakeSh00t 4 місяці тому

    lets go mini led input lag 18msec when HDR ADAPTIVE sync is on ! And ghosting :D

  • @burd7455
    @burd7455 3 місяці тому

    My issue with these tvs is the quality control.

  • @perceptivity_
    @perceptivity_ 4 місяці тому

    we need those zones x 10.

  • @stephensheldon-mx4uv
    @stephensheldon-mx4uv 15 днів тому

    At this price why would u pick it this over a lg g3 oled

  • @davidnikon8501
    @davidnikon8501 3 місяці тому +1

    My 83 inch oled has 8,294,400 dimming zone's let that sink in.

  • @BangSkeeet
    @BangSkeeet 2 місяці тому

    Great channel brother. I have 2 things I would like to see improved for future reviews.
    You included the Intra-Frame Contrast test in the U8N, but excluded it here
    I would also like to know is the 5200 nits in 10% is reachable in 600nit, 1000nit or 4000 nit graded content
    I would standardize all testing in each section for every TV and keep videos updated with any significant changes in addition to pinned comment (updated charts & measurements greatly appreciated)

  • @euphorichaggis8486
    @euphorichaggis8486 4 місяці тому

    It doesn't matter how bright a TV can get if the source material is only graded in 1000 nits. Most movies these days are only graded at that, same with games, so the extra 4000 nits on this TV is wasted (for now anyway) until future movies are graded in 4000 nits such as on Sony's new 4000-nit mastering monitor, then you will get huge benefit from TV's like this TCL but that will be later down the track.

    • @thedisplayguy
      @thedisplayguy  4 місяці тому +4

      This isn’t necessarily true.
      If a Mini LED TV does 1000nits full screen vs an OLED which does let’s say 150-250nits than the Mini LED can produce more accurate and brighter high APL scenes.

  • @agiverreviga4592
    @agiverreviga4592 4 місяці тому +1

    Yikes, that miniLED vignetting/shadowing is always visible

  • @黄紫真
    @黄紫真 3 місяці тому

    Hello, I'm Shenzhen Ruiling Optoelectronic Company, specializing in aluminum film group display screen, including common cathode energy saving, current sharing backup, low voltage switching and other technologies.

  • @ozgurkuzu2202
    @ozgurkuzu2202 4 місяці тому +1

    How come mini led more expensive then qd oleds i dont understand.oled image is the best.only downside brightness sdr.

  • @JoeyGageyt
    @JoeyGageyt 4 місяці тому

    The dark level motion is trash, I returned mine. I’d rather have IPS glow than dark level smearing at this point. Still, nothing comes close to my LG C3 so far that I’ve tested.

    • @shanew7361
      @shanew7361 3 місяці тому +1

      Enjoy your complimentary burn in.

  • @Eusebiugh
    @Eusebiugh 3 місяці тому

    Tcl 27r83u

  • @Games_and_Tech
    @Games_and_Tech 4 місяці тому +2

    Good luck getting any warranty from TCL or Hisense 😂

    • @ZeitGeist_TV
      @ZeitGeist_TV 4 місяці тому +3

      That's why you get the extended warranty from the store or a home electronics warranty from Ausurion.

  • @SLICK8116
    @SLICK8116 3 місяці тому +1

    Tcl qc and customer service absolutely sucks

  • @imlegend8108
    @imlegend8108 4 місяці тому

    Yes in theory it could. But definitely not from TCL

  • @LorentGuimaraes
    @LorentGuimaraes 4 місяці тому +17

    1400 dollars??!! Just get an OLED at that point, I will save up just a bit more to get per pixel dimming

    • @catalyst9568
      @catalyst9568 4 місяці тому +35

      Are there 75" oled at 1400$ ??

    • @FemboyStorm26
      @FemboyStorm26 4 місяці тому

      @@catalyst9568only 65 inch s90c

    • @MrReaperder2
      @MrReaperder2 4 місяці тому +32

      75" inch OLED for 1400 bucks that beats this tv is non existent. The Quality and size you get for this price is unbeatable right now with the QM851G

    • @LorentGuimaraes
      @LorentGuimaraes 4 місяці тому

      @@catalyst9568 Right now you can get a 77" LG B3 OLED for 1,796

    • @jimtepedino9295
      @jimtepedino9295 4 місяці тому +5

      $1400 is cheap ma boy

  • @UhhhhhnooOOo00oO
    @UhhhhhnooOOo00oO 3 місяці тому +1

    No. End of video. I have top Mini-LEDs, Mid Budget Mini-LEDs, Top OLEDs/QD-OLEDs and Mid Budget OLEDs. The answer is NO. Stop with ABL BS. The only thing Mini-LEDs have at certain levels is Brightness. OLEDs have gone closer to the brightness level in 2024. Stop with any burn in BS as well. Price is the only reason one would buy a Mini-LEDs LCD TV. We are not talking about Micro-LED. The goal is to get near the Sony HX310 reference monitor with it's image quality and 1000nits on a 100% window. (Not a 10% window)

  • @michaelwyckoff7593
    @michaelwyckoff7593 4 місяці тому +2

    OLED will always outshine Miniled because of infinite contrast and deep black levels.😊

    • @gangs0846
      @gangs0846 4 місяці тому +7

      But wont get as bright and burn in issue ...

    • @shanew7361
      @shanew7361 3 місяці тому +1

      Enjoy your complimentary burn in.

  • @BIGBASSSAMA_4
    @BIGBASSSAMA_4 4 місяці тому

    It doesn't have usable brightening leaving it's 5k nits peak brightness pointless for example when a low light scene is displaying with the sun in the corner getting brighter it'll brighten the entire screen VS just on only the sun ☀

    • @itisabird
      @itisabird 4 місяці тому +4

      It has 4032 dimming zones, it will behave really similar in contrast to OLED, and in your example you'd see that sun far brighter than in the OLED, while you'd have dark parts still dark.

    • @BIGBASSSAMA_4
      @BIGBASSSAMA_4 4 місяці тому

      @@itisabird you can't prove it doesn't do what I said VS just only brightening the entire backlight

    • @alejandrourbinaalva3740
      @alejandrourbinaalva3740 4 місяці тому +2

      ​@@BIGBASSSAMA_4If you don't like the TV, then just don't buy it. It's that simple.

    • @BIGBASSSAMA_4
      @BIGBASSSAMA_4 4 місяці тому

      @@alejandrourbinaalva3740 I'm calling it out for what it is don't have to sugar coat anything it's not Disneyland 😂

    • @budthecyborg4575
      @budthecyborg4575 4 місяці тому +2

      @@BIGBASSSAMA_4 RTINGS recorded 161,000:1 contrast with local dimming, of course the FALD is doing its job.

  • @MagexMonitor
    @MagexMonitor 4 місяці тому

    Good job. Excellent review. Well explained,I’d love to discuss a potential collaboration with you. I’ll be sending you an email soon with more details, so please keep an eye out for it. Looking forward to the possibility of working together!