by the fact that compared to other gen 3 girl group main vocalist, she in another level! :) Wendy really standout and have great skill of controlling her vocal.
I've always thought Yeri gets overshadowed by her unnis and hasn't really found her spot. But I felt her low tone is what distinguishes her in this performance
I dunno how many times i watched this and am more impressed by her vocals at 01.30... boom, she went with that smooth vocals with low register like what? The recording didn't do justice compared to this.
It's Brandon lol I’m glad I’m a small seulmin shipper because they interacted. They did a dance together with other idols at 2016 SBS Gayo Daejun . I can just imagine them and the other idols being friendly while practicing.
Yeri seems to have a pretty good one too which shocked me. Like when her and Seulgi sang together Yeri was doing the super low notes which is mind boggling to me.
Annalee Higley Yeah Yeri was the one who most surprised me . She is super talented and I feel like S.M. is eating her talent not having more songs like this
Those who had said RV can't sing should watch this. Edit: for those who said "there's no one who said that (rv can't sing)", my comment referred to their debut days (I've corrected my words). They got a bunch of hate back then, vocals was just one of it. Nowadays of course they're famous with their amazing vocals & harmonization. I'm sorry for the misunderstanding I've made.
I personally am not a big fan of catchy kinda songs that red velvet commonly produces but this songs just gets to me. It is probably one of my favorites songs from a girl group and im not afraid to admit it. I love their voices and how they harmonize. i hope to see more songs like these in the future! go Red velvet!!
Probably my fave performance of OOTN, the girls did so well and that Sax tho! Adds a bluesy jazz element to song which is mainly rnb/ballad ( I think) Seulgi shone the most for me here, her voice 💗💗
I'm reveluv since their debut. And even in 2018 i consider The Velvet one of their best albums. I'm not usualy to buying many albums but The Velvet is one of my favorites and i bought it with great pride. All the songs are incredible and i love all, in fact. And One of These Nights is one of my favorite songs from the entire Red Velvet discography, not just the performance but also the depth of this song. It always makes me excited to the point of crying just listening. This song gives me several meanings. And when i watch this performance, the compassion of each member, each detail, everything becomes a thousand times stronger, it's incredible how red velvet never failed to give me pride. It's all so intense. Since their debut i've always believed that they were much more than what Sm showed, and they really are. They only tend to get better and i never tire of being impressed. I'm so proud to be Reveluv. Thanks Red Velvet for debuting.
MylYah 11 me too😭 i am so also reveluv since the debute and still The Velvet is my favorite, omg i was sure that from the very first teasers it’s era gonna be my fav... all songs from the album gives me so many feelings that i cannot describe, my favorite one is ‘First Time’
There's a story that's common to China Korea and Japan. In Japan it's called Tanabata. It talks of a cowherd and a weaver girl who fell in love but were separated by her father. The story is kinda long but basically they were allowed to meet once a year. In astronomy around the 7th of July, 2 stars will seem to come into close proximity but are separated by the Milky Way. Hence the story. I can't remember all of it but it's quite a romantic but sad story.
@jimin dreams of jams yeah it will be dangerous since that tragedy had many issue about politics and if rv told that mv represent sewol maybe politician will be mad at sm
This performance really highlight Seulgi's talent: voice smooth like butter, she literally puts her heart in it, graceful dance move. She's just perfect!
That kind of performance should be in the books for reference for future performers. Beautiful harmonies, strong visuals, awesome musicians, beautiful song. This is a masterpiece
i didnt stan them at first.....i was just a fan of them but after i watched several of their mr removed and some videos im now stanning this grp. Their vocals are totally awesome!!!! they totally slayed
![Red Velvet - Goodbye | 레드벨벳 - 안녕 [Immortal Songs 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rxh8l62zT1M/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet - Goodbye | 레드벨벳 - 안녕 [Immortal Songs 2]](/img/tr.png)
![Red Velvet - One of These Nights | 레드벨벳 - 7월 7일 [Music Bank / 2016.06.24]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V1OH73hnCxg/mqdefault.jpg)
and why is exactly no one's talking about Joy's voice?? she sounds like pure honey.. so smooth and so distinct!!
JBs Tooth Gap it’s okay... we know how smooth and clear her voice is... i’m so grateful to her bec her voice cured my insomnia 💚
@@JoyismyQ hhahaha hello unnie hahahhahah
some body hello who’s this please 😅🤣
@@JoyismyQ hahahaha
wait you can hear honey- you need a doctor
jk I luv Joy
Damn, the music arrangement tho...
yasss
smth sm should learn
@@ms.ripley3236 wait what isnt this SM
Sm should learn from this 😊
esp. the be natural era it would've been extra better if it was rearranged😉
@@ms.ripley3236 oh oh u mean for the future songs of SM. Sorry for the misunderstanding
Irene💖
Seulgi💛
Wendy💙
Joy💚
Yeri💜
Glad that someone else actually knows yeri's color. Some people confuse it with pink or red which is more of Irene's
+Corey Sullivan That's because Yeri loves pink and Irene loves purple. Which is funny
I can't tell them apart...
Someone pls help me😢
Rainbow Snappers She's pink
Laura S.
Wendy 0:13
Seulgi 0:38
Joy 0:50
Yeri 1:32
Irene 2:58
How come Wendy sounds so much better here than on the recorded audio?
Jonathan Adriel
I swear it's a conspiracy as to not outshine the others too much 😂😂😂
That’s what makes her the main vocalist 💗
by the fact that compared to other gen 3 girl group main vocalist, she in another level! :) Wendy really standout and have great skill of controlling her vocal.
Jonathan Adriel Live is always better. I dont really like my recorded voice.
@@Haruko_Le true
How has nobody spoken about Yeri and Seulgi's beautiful dance
I know right!! 😍🤩
I've always thought Yeri gets overshadowed by her unnis and hasn't really found her spot. But I felt her low tone is what distinguishes her in this performance
bro I swear I almost see you everywhere-
main dancer kim yerim YUPPPPPP
I dunno how many times i watched this and am more impressed by her vocals at 01.30... boom, she went with that smooth vocals with low register like what? The recording didn't do justice compared to this.
Wendy pulled the mic away and the voice faded. She pull it back and the voice sound raised again. This is real singing, 0% playback *.* ❤
Sunarwati Sunarwati please don’t ship idols who probably have never interacted
It's Brandon lol I’m glad I’m a small seulmin shipper because they interacted. They did a dance together with other idols at 2016 SBS Gayo Daejun . I can just imagine them and the other idols being friendly while practicing.
Jennie Kim seulgi didn’t go to a majority of the dance practices because of her busy schedule
Jennie Kim I doubt she spent time socializing with the idols there
Jennie Kim BTS and rv ships are so gross like I swear y’all lose it to them even glancing at each other
OH COME ON IRENE WITH THE LOWER HARMONY. Her lower register is breathtaking.
Yeri seems to have a pretty good one too which shocked me. Like when her and Seulgi sang together Yeri was doing the super low notes which is mind boggling to me.
True it's actually shocking since all of them sopranos with good lower registers, which is actually not common
Annalee Higley Yeah Yeri was the one who most surprised me . She is super talented and I feel like S.M. is eating her talent not having more songs like this
Yes!
@@annapandalee4915 that part comes when I read your comment LOL😂
Those who had said RV can't sing should watch this.
Edit: for those who said "there's no one who said that (rv can't sing)", my comment referred to their debut days (I've corrected my words). They got a bunch of hate back then, vocals was just one of it. Nowadays of course they're famous with their amazing vocals & harmonization. I'm sorry for the misunderstanding I've made.
Shoffi Hanifa lol no one would dare so
No one says that. Whoever said might be deaf xD
Lol I just told some hater to listen to this before saying that
Yeah...like watch their MR REMOVED....DAEBAK!!!
PEOPLE THINK RV CANT SING!?WUT
They're girl crush for reasons. All of SM's girl groups such a magnet for female fans. More loyal and dedicated than male fans..
Pradita Ananda Hanafiah totally agree!
Pradita Ananda Hanafiah How sexist....
Sexist.
sexist or nah its true.
Pradita Ananda i was with you until the male fans part lmao.
Wow their visual are no joke, All sm artist are full of talents and visual
I am yg fan but I love some of sm artist too such as snsd, fx, red velvet
우리 다시 만나... 🎗️
I personally am not a big fan of catchy kinda songs that red velvet commonly produces but this songs just gets to me. It is probably one of my favorites songs from a girl group and im not afraid to admit it. I love their voices and how they harmonize. i hope to see more songs like these in the future! go Red velvet!!
this is their velvet side. smooth and beautiful
G-nie May ikr, and it’s a tribute song to Sewol...
It's almost 2019 and I'm still wishing that they produce this kind of song again. I also like the Wish Tree which they performed during Christmas 😍
That's why I love velvet song and B-side tracks
Nah red songs are soooo much better
OOTN is a 6-10 at best
I stan the right group. Btw i think so far this is the best era for Seulgi and Joy's hair. Simple but chic! So modern..
I agree with you 😍😍
Wendy is my bias, but I think Seulgi's voice fits this song so freaking perfect
Sha w indeed
Yes, I agree. syagauaaja I love all of them so much, omg.
Sha wol Seulgi is my bias YAS
👌👌👌
Wendy is mi bias to.
Seulgi's eyes, voice, dance and visual kills me everytime.
fan of Joy here from philippines 😁
same
Yasss
Lenie Castro same!!
Please continue to support Red Velvet reveluuuuvs~♡
I T S O K A Y 👍🏻
They all sang so well!!! Red Velvet is such a great group ^_^ really, the most well-rounded female rookies right now
Minah infires me and all of them can be visuals.
Ananda Hanafiah Well that's what I meant! Because they have great vocals, great visuals, great dancing and great music. They are the whole package!
They aren't rookies they already had 2 mini albums and a full album released.
@@gwenconcretemage1 ok and? Rookie means under 1 year old
Joy-aah im falling all over again 💘😍
Probably my fave performance of OOTN, the girls did so well and that Sax tho! Adds a bluesy jazz element to song which is mainly rnb/ballad ( I think)
Seulgi shone the most for me here, her voice 💗💗
Joanne Denney I agree
The sax solidified how classy this piece is, along with the lyrics and arrangement
wendy and seulgi slays this 😍😍😍😍
Seulgi is so good that she can be the main vocalist of almost all the girl groups, but wendy is just god level, she's the taeyeon of 3rd generation
Sim 🛐
Anyone else catch Yeri almost spinning after she sings "It's alright, even if its just a dream"??? lol so cute
Congratulations to Red Velvet and KBS, this live performance... it's so perfect.
slayed the live performance
girl, they can sing! 80s feel to it with that saxophone
이런 분위기 노래 부른 걸그룹을 최근 보지 못한 것 같은데 너무 좋네
joyyyyyy such a queen in this world T_______________T
nqq i hate you
Roirobin Lose so if it is because she likes joy then that’s a pretty sad reason.
joy is beatiful
I'm reveluv since their debut. And even in 2018 i consider The Velvet one of their best albums. I'm not usualy to buying many albums but The Velvet is one of my favorites and i bought it with great pride. All the songs are incredible and i love all, in fact. And One of These Nights is one of my favorite songs from the entire Red Velvet discography, not just the performance but also the depth of this song. It always makes me excited to the point of crying just listening. This song gives me several meanings. And when i watch this performance, the compassion of each member, each detail, everything becomes a thousand times stronger, it's incredible how red velvet never failed to give me pride. It's all so intense.
Since their debut i've always believed that they were much more than what Sm showed, and they really are. They only tend to get better and i never tire of being impressed. I'm so proud to be Reveluv.
Thanks Red Velvet for debuting.
Good for you i cant even buy just one album from them.
MylYah 11 me too😭 i am so also reveluv since the debute and still The Velvet is my favorite, omg i was sure that from the very first teasers it’s era gonna be my fav... all songs from the album gives me so many feelings that i cannot describe, my favorite one is ‘First Time’
SEULGISUS I LOVE YOU SO MUCH. SARANGHAEYO KANG SEULGOD!!!! RED VELVET I LOVE YOU TOO 💕💕
I've been a musician for over 50 Years ... this is one of the most talented groups I've ever seen ... and that's a long long time .
They sing it perfectly 😍👌🏾
Its about tragedy of sewol right? 😔🎗️
yes
Red Velvet said it's not. But I still believe it is. The MV shows it all.
@@extraacc7671 it's not? But the whole MV was represent sewol tragedy:((
There's a story that's common to China Korea and Japan. In Japan it's called Tanabata.
It talks of a cowherd and a weaver girl who fell in love but were separated by her father. The story is kinda long but basically they were allowed to meet once a year.
In astronomy around the 7th of July, 2 stars will seem to come into close proximity but are separated by the Milky Way. Hence the story.
I can't remember all of it but it's quite a romantic but sad story.
@jimin dreams of jams yeah it will be dangerous since that tragedy had many issue about politics and if rv told that mv represent sewol maybe politician will be mad at sm
joy ♡♡♡
RV deserve another one ballad , a real soft velvety ballad like this!!
AS EXPECTED OUR TALENTED GIRLS 💕
is no ome talking about the the rap line? joy’s voice honestly fits this so well!
That 80s sax at 3:05 tho!!! Jumped out of nowhere!!!
JoJo A oh I never knew that lol!
Ikr?? Loved that ❤
If only the Velvet concept took off, rather than Red. I fell in love with this side of RV.
Velvet did take off, they both did. Bad Boy, Peekaboo, Psycho are some of their most known songs
I really like the saxophone that was added at 3:00 and a bit at the end too!
Kang Seulgi ❤
So much talent in all of them wow, Seulgi and Wendy sounded amazing
joy slayed it :)
Joy😙
8 years and it always has me in tears 🎗️
Joy 😍
i think this is their best stage for this song tho
like they slayed this so much
jimin park truth!!
Gosh Seulgi gives me chills. I'm definitely sticking to her as my bias in RV. 😉
is she still your bias? She is mine. I'm a new reveluv :)
they finally fixed the audio!❤
what do you mean?
+Wendy Sage When Kbsworld tv uploaded the full episode, the sound was wack, you can barely hear anything.
Seulgi's voice gives me goosebumps. 😳😳😖😍
seulgi's voice
seriously! I cry! I heard this while imagining what happened 6 years ago :(
So beautiful :) Seulgi and Yeri!!!!
WENDY😍😍😍💞💞💞
The emotions that Wendy expresses when singing this song always gets to me. She sounds amazing here.
joy has a great voice, just if they gave her more lines ...
Joy's voice even just URI DASHI MANNA but its enough for make me goosebumps
SEULGI IS PERFECTION Y'ALL
SEULGI'S VOICE IS THE MOST PERFECT THING IN THE WORLD
This performance really highlight Seulgi's talent: voice smooth like butter, she literally puts her heart in it, graceful dance move. She's just perfect!
Wendy hitting dem high notes with her eyes open. MY QUEEN
I LOVE SEULGI'S VOICE. THEY ALL DID A GOOD JOB, THEY'RE AMAZIIING
Most talented kpop group of all time. You can't change my mind.
I made this comment before I found Gfriend so I ended up convincing myself otherwise. They're matched, in my opinion.
@@Daisy-Moo Mamamoo too
Pepper i would say Red Velvet, Gfriend and Mamamoo
@@Daisy-Moo Wh red velvet are waaau better than gfriend
That kind of performance should be in the books for reference for future performers. Beautiful harmonies, strong visuals, awesome musicians, beautiful song. This is a masterpiece
Joy is mine ❤️❤️❤️
yah how bout we share?
Sungjae will beat you up, you want that?
Oh nevermind, that's more like a blessing lmao
crush says hi
that "let's meet again" part is just too awesome.
Joy has the sweetest of the sweetest voice and she must be appreciated for it and my girls stayed it as the usual
wow seulgi voice
바유사붙라 she’s so stable!
son seungwannn wendyy wendy......
I cried at the end, this was honestly one of the most beautiful performances by a female group I have ever seen.
Idk joy voice is so different and sweet i just love her voice😍
Wendy is so beautiful in every way. I don't understand why she gets hate. Jealousy is the only explanation I can think of
Seulgi's high note slays.
OMG!! That saxo arrangement makes everything 😍😍😍😍😍 reminded me Whitney`s songs, so delicate, classy and romantic.
Saving all my love for you
wendy’s voice is sounds a mix of regret and sadness-she delivered the message of the song so well :( i wish rv can sing this again!
i didnt stan them at first.....i was just a fan of them but after i watched several of their mr removed and some videos im now stanning this grp. Their vocals are totally awesome!!!! they totally slayed
cant believe that this gold is only at 500k+ views even after *3 FREAKING YEARS* sleep on your bed not on this *masterpiece* smh
3:02 no words can describe how perfect this part goes. The vocal and the saxophone just astonishingly beautiful
Just imagine, (if they will have their own concert in the future) One Of These Nights with that jazzy background ( sax and drums)... omg perfection❤️
Taking this time to appreciate Joy’s vocals. Her voice is smooth af, like a glazed donut
Hear that, Kpop fans?
This is what live vocals sound like.
Exactly
This is pure art!
joy makes emotional :(
damn the look in joys eyes when she sings
This gave me chills. Especially Seulgi. 💖
I'm literally crying. 😭😍
I love you RV!
Here because of the long hiatus of the girls. We miss talent, we miss visuals, we miss Red Velvet.
their live vocals are always incredible, but they're on another level here
I love how casually Wendy hits those high notes.
Wendy hit every note effortlessly! I love her voice so much!
I never knew how much I needed that saxophone in the background!!!
Ikr
This song is so moving and that piano and drum entrance leading into the chorus is groovy as hell
This is so underrated. But I love this
This live version is better than the recording! Damn, the musical arrangement along with their voices is beautiful.
Beautiful omg. I love how Wendy suited her voice to the jazzy feel
One thing I love about one of these nights is the lack of background music. It makes their voice shine even better.
oh my joy😍😍😍😍 hope to see you in person my little girl..
Some said the song is flop but actually RV showing to those who said them flop to challenge their favourite if their favourite CAN ACTUAL SING.
R.I.P. Sewol Ferry Tragedy Victims 😥
JOYYY OMG IM CRYINGGG I LOVE U SOMUCH JOYYYY
IRENE 's very BEAUTIFUL
Wendy sings happily in any of their up beat songs. But wgen it comes to ballad she poured her whole heart and soul to the song
They could've performed this without dancing, but Red Velvet is Red Velvet. And Red Velvet equals queens.