That might be your secret but that doesn't make it true

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @rafaelaveralugo7626
    @rafaelaveralugo7626 23 години тому +3103

    This is one of the reasons Glinda isnmt evil.
    She might be vain at times, but she still cares for Elphaba. She's not evil, she's just been raised under the idea of perfectionism

    • @TruuColorZ
      @TruuColorZ 18 годин тому +85

      She evil af 🤣 in every wizard of oz version the green witch dies, not to mention Glinda is the reason for her dying. Glinda made Dorthy come to oz have her the shoes yet didn’t tell her she could’ve went home the whole time. She made Dorothy do all that shit and could’ve died.

    • @achmadputra2
      @achmadputra2 16 годин тому +24

      @@TruuColorZ she’s not actually evil, she just full of herself, and act like a little brat but she’s not a bad guy or evil person.

    • @thesirensystem
      @thesirensystem 16 годин тому +25

      @@TruuColorZ that doesn't happen in the original book though. In the book Dorothy only meets Glinda at the very end, and Glinda apologises she didn't get to meet her sooner because she could have helped her avoid that whole journey. They just changed it for the film

    • @thesirensystem
      @thesirensystem 16 годин тому +6

      @@TruuColorZ that doesn't happen in the original book though. In the book Dorothy only meets Glinda at the very end, and Glinda apologises she didn't get to meet her sooner because she could have helped her avoid that whole journey. They just changed it for the film

    • @lol-ot4pn
      @lol-ot4pn 14 годин тому +6

      @@TruuColorZThe green witch is evil in every other version except for this one i believe.

  • @joemcguire9988
    @joemcguire9988 День тому +2680

    So because your dad was vain and prejudiced, he made your mother partake in dangerous medicine that had unintended repercussions for her and the baby and then rather than explore his own faults and decisions that led to this situation, he blames his young daughter who did nothing but be born with a non-conventional skin color? Sounds like a real winner, that dad.

    • @NadiaAzzahra-m2r
      @NadiaAzzahra-m2r 22 години тому +69

      Yup! Sounds like “playing victim” and “gaslighting” 😂

    • @kingcastlequeenbeckett
      @kingcastlequeenbeckett 21 годину тому

      Yep her dad sucks 😂

    • @Punk3rGirl
      @Punk3rGirl 19 годин тому +30

      well said. i wish they had given glinda the good sense to say it was the dad's fault and not the milkflowers

    • @jellybean7993
      @jellybean7993 18 годин тому +2

      Great summary 😂

    • @Sagittariusfactors
      @Sagittariusfactors 16 годин тому +2

      That dad is the wizard of oz

  • @thesongbird6101
    @thesongbird6101 День тому +961

    No it was not Elphaba's fault. It was the parents. The mother cheated and drank this green liquid which made Elphaba green. Then the father made the mother drink those dang milkflowers because they didn't want their other daughter to be green. Worst yet, they didn't want to bother raising her so the bear raised Elphaba all on their own. Awful parents..

    • @sweettea735
      @sweettea735 14 годин тому

      That’s the point of Glinda’s line. She tends to be a little shallow and bimbo-ish sometimes. She sees the actions more than the person a lot of the time.

    • @alanjyu
      @alanjyu 11 годин тому +20

      The father is squarely to blame. He killed his wife. He made his daughter physically challenged.

    • @Procc75
      @Procc75 11 годин тому

      The "cheating" is changed from the play and the books, to make the story a little more palettable. In the play, elphaba's mother *does* go out with a mysterious stranger while her husband is away because hes a stickler and she wants to have fun. But the stranger slips her the green elixir and r*pes her.

    • @SylviaEze-f2q
      @SylviaEze-f2q 6 годин тому

      @@alanjyuI disagree. The mom should not have cheated in the first place. Both are to blame. Mom and dad. There are better ways to handle all these things. If you do not feel satisfied with your partner in bed, there are other ways to satisfy yourself. Plus it is not fun to give birth to a kid and force that Kid to suffer. Trust me, that kid if they had the opportunity would beg that you should not be their parents. As much as they act tough, it hurts. I blame mom and dad

    • @4rtsyval
      @4rtsyval 3 години тому

      elphaba's mother was raped. she didn't cheat.

  • @amberthomas4839
    @amberthomas4839 10 годин тому +156

    I relate to this
    I’m biracial and my parents divorced when I was an infant ( mostly because of my moms racist relatives)
    When I was older and she was supposed to marry my sisters dad I could tell he didn’t want to marry her because of me. I carried that around for decades. He finally admitted that is why he didn’t marry her and my mom and sister told me not to blame myself, but it messed up my sister’s relationship with her dad her entire life. Kids carry burdens and sins that shouldn’t be theirs to carry

    • @sihamel5721
      @sihamel5721 5 годин тому +4

      I’m so sorry you had to experience that. None of that was your fault and I hope you were able to move on from that ❤

    • @Boo0o258
      @Boo0o258 5 годин тому +3

      I think he used you as a bs excuse. He had no issues having sex with your mom and a child with her, but marrying is too far? It's not like marrying her would have been different from dating. He just didn't want to commit that it. I know r4cist are dumb but this is on another level.

    • @Boo0o258
      @Boo0o258 4 години тому +3

      To me, it seems like her dad just didn't want to be committed to your mom and sister. Your sister is right. He is a pos, and it has nothing to do with you. Men will blame everyone for not taking responsibility but themselves.

    • @toricollins6516
      @toricollins6516 3 години тому +1

      ::hugs::
      It’s your MOTHER’s fault, for no clearly understanding the impact of race, & choosing a man (after your dad) who was equally as racist. You did nothing wrong. I wish you peace & tranquility, Sis.❤

    • @mirandav7477
      @mirandav7477 3 години тому

      Please don't make this about yourself racism doesn't exist in America anymore really so stop

  • @namzhilmia
    @namzhilmia День тому +702

    Itd not like even milkflowers fault bat the fathers i think

    • @jennyjones-tw5hp
      @jennyjones-tw5hp День тому

      Welcome to narcissistic abuse. If you’ve been raised in a bubble to believe it’s your fault, you believe it too.

    • @s_shaleh
      @s_shaleh 12 годин тому +9

      Both the parents were at fault. Her mom cheated on her father which started all this mess in the first place.

  • @Swathi-k4o
    @Swathi-k4o 10 годин тому +24

    Elphaba great acting 👍👏

    • @Lovetwou
      @Lovetwou 50 хвилин тому

      I can't stand them both

  • @alanjyu
    @alanjyu 12 годин тому +26

    In this case it was her father's fault. The father killed her mother and made her sister come out physically challenged.

  • @mairagadia8905
    @mairagadia8905 День тому +163

    Oh that hurts

  • @mariafox9226
    @mariafox9226 22 години тому +93

    Your father may have been mad that your mom cheated but you were just a baby who happened to be born green, neither of which is your fault.

  • @jrjkaay4225
    @jrjkaay4225 11 годин тому +7

    I think I'll end up watching the movie in shorts

  • @drunkpekka4284
    @drunkpekka4284 23 години тому +83

    Spoiler:
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    Elphaba is green because her mother was cheating and drank green elixir. The one she was cheating with is the Wizard of Oz. Elphaba is the Wizard's daughter.

    • @luizmarinho6138
      @luizmarinho6138 13 годин тому +1

      And what is the elixir for?

    • @YOYO-dv8gv
      @YOYO-dv8gv 13 годин тому +4

      ​@@luizmarinho6138 maybe it's to make sure she didnt get pregnant from cheating? Idk lol

    • @ashleyelisabeth4
      @ashleyelisabeth4 6 годин тому

      I was about to ask this because I saw the play years ago so I don't remember certain details except for that spoiler. Thanks for helping me remember the full story! Also, wasn't it the Wizard trying to use the elixir to give himself powers? I forgot lol

    • @MillyThe_Rat
      @MillyThe_Rat Годину тому

      This spoiler has NOTHING to do with the scene, what's the reason of your comment?

  • @schizophrenicbaby111
    @schizophrenicbaby111 4 години тому

    Acting on point ❤❤

  • @Sam-c7j3o
    @Sam-c7j3o Годину тому

    What is this movie?

  • @katecorinnetabora4757
    @katecorinnetabora4757 2 години тому

    cuteeee! happy holidays, guys! ❤

  • @kaylajackson9490
    @kaylajackson9490 20 годин тому +27

    That man hated her since she was born but I’m glad she didn’t know the full thing ❤

  • @rwdswght4057
    @rwdswght4057 2 години тому

    This parallels closely how daughters often experience their fathers: abusive, accusatory, lacking empathy, projecting blame

  • @mountainfolks
    @mountainfolks Годину тому

    Green make-up and a wig really does improve her looks.

  • @WillieGraham-x5c
    @WillieGraham-x5c 7 годин тому

    Magical

  • @Hannah.the.huge.swiftie
    @Hannah.the.huge.swiftie 2 години тому

    the only reason elphaba is green is bc of the green drink thing that you see her mum drink at the start(idk if am wrong i haven’t watched it in a few weeks)

  • @samanthab1923
    @samanthab1923 День тому +77

    What’s wrong with Nessa?

  • @Thepokedek
    @Thepokedek День тому +149

    She's NOT responsible for her father's actions.

  • @jayteah1349
    @jayteah1349 День тому +100

    It’s 1000% better when nessa doesn’t have Arms and is an accepted love child instead of just a patsy put in a wheelchair

  • @shaylov6763
    @shaylov6763 19 годин тому +5

    So it's the dad's ignorance

  • @Kitsunekohime
    @Kitsunekohime 14 годин тому +1

    It wasn‘t the milkflowers fault, nur her fathers!

  • @meameam
    @meameam 9 годин тому

    Why is she always smirking 😏

  • @britt3795
    @britt3795 20 годин тому +3

    Why did i think elphaba was the witch who died at the beginning of oz?

    • @ApexPreadator89
      @ApexPreadator89 20 годин тому +1

      Watch the Wizard of Oz and watch Wicked again 😉

  • @DintlePitso
    @DintlePitso 17 годин тому +1

    It's not the child's fault 😭

  • @jonathanatalig2592
    @jonathanatalig2592 17 годин тому +2

    Is it me or does her green skin look cgi?

    • @lol-ot4pn
      @lol-ot4pn 14 годин тому +5

      just you

    • @luizmarinho6138
      @luizmarinho6138 13 годин тому +3

      It does look that way in this scene, like it's just green lighting on her. In other scenes, it seems more like makeup.

  • @paktype
    @paktype 7 годин тому

    Elphie isn’t green, she’s clearly an ordinarily gorgeous black woman.

  • @hisokaaa6785
    @hisokaaa6785 4 години тому

    the mom cheated on the dad though with the wizard of oz right? i think that's what i remember it said in the book

  • @Zombiemommie2000
    @Zombiemommie2000 15 годин тому +1

    And really her and her sister look so different from eachother because her mom was a cheater lol

  • @FatimaJamal-b7b
    @FatimaJamal-b7b 9 годин тому

    Elpaba glinda

  • @keshastewart8408
    @keshastewart8408 18 годин тому +4

    This movie seems to be hiding racism in pure site

    • @tamipierce5916
      @tamipierce5916 16 годин тому

      With how woke america has been since Biden's been in office it doesn't surprise me.....!!

    • @lol-ot4pn
      @lol-ot4pn 14 годин тому +4

      Youre late to the party cause it was about racism from 20 years ago.😂
      The movie is essentially beat for beat with the musical.

    • @belzerahan5732
      @belzerahan5732 14 годин тому +2

      @tamipierce5916 y'all just be catching on and pretend this sort of messaging just come up this decade when its a prominent aspect of the book and the musical 😭
      Just yapping and not thinking

  • @visser_madi
    @visser_madi 15 годин тому +1

    Why does elphaba do that with her mouth 💀

  • @zcvxs
    @zcvxs 10 годин тому

    They're starving, can they please have food ?

  • @ikediobirita1543
    @ikediobirita1543 17 годин тому +2

    hmmm

  • @CaiThomas-l1f
    @CaiThomas-l1f 3 години тому

    It’s not even the flowers fault it’s her Fathers he’s such a Douce I hated him more than any other character in the film.

  • @ToTheMaxGaming85
    @ToTheMaxGaming85 10 годин тому

    At least she admits her faults that's the first step of forgiveness

  • @LuluLala-oo1my
    @LuluLala-oo1my 22 години тому +7

    Glinda: I have a secret well there was this woman and her husband came onto ME but it wasn’t my fault you see he came ONTO me 😂😂😂😂

  • @joemcguire9988
    @joemcguire9988 День тому +22

    It’s certainly not elphaba’s fault but it’s kind of a stretch to blame the milkflowers, they didn’t ask to be eaten. Maybe blame the idiot whose vanity, shame. and arrogance caused him to push his wife to eat high volumes of dangerous herbs because he couldn’t reconcile the fact that his child had an unconventional skin color.

    • @tamipierce5916
      @tamipierce5916 16 годин тому +1

      Or the mother for having an affair where he thought his first daughter was born green....!! See how they've both to blame.....?!!

    • @lol-ot4pn
      @lol-ot4pn 14 годин тому +1

      Its both the parents’ fault.

  • @Lovetwou
    @Lovetwou 51 хвилина тому

    I HATE THIS MOVIE WITH A PASSION
    IT SHOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN NADE. THESE TWO CHARACTERS ARE A FAIL. ITS A JOKE

  • @Ozzymandius1
    @Ozzymandius1 День тому +46

    The words, face, and tone of voice don’t match the emotions they should be conveying.

    • @LucíanPDJ
      @LucíanPDJ День тому +49

      Right, spoke the winner of five Oscars, 10 Tony's and 15 more awards 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @erystitch5299
      @erystitch5299 День тому +9

      @@LucíanPDJPLEASE TELL THEM!!!! 👏 👏 👏

    • @SoraJack
      @SoraJack День тому +26

      Local man doesn't understand emotions but pretends to be an expert on em anyways.

    • @zoeb3573
      @zoeb3573 День тому +6

      ​@@LucíanPDJI disagree with what they said too but implying they can't judge acting if they aren't a professional actor is very dumb. I'm not an actor but I know awful acting when I see it. I'm not a chef but I know when food I'm served tastes like crap. I'm not an architect but if a building falls down I'm gonna have some concern. No one needs an Oscar to have an opinion on acting.

    • @Bratzismylife
      @Bratzismylife День тому +3

      I felt sadness when I heard her story, she did sound sad…

  • @LO-dm6uf
    @LO-dm6uf 4 години тому

    The acting is so terrible omg

  • @jhadebredenkamp97
    @jhadebredenkamp97 18 годин тому

    Ariana fr can't act LMAO

  • @concernedhomeownervictim5397
    @concernedhomeownervictim5397 11 годин тому

    STUPID even this story Hollywood would be able to ring in racial differences. We are all shades of brown. Just make a cute movie for the family. Or spectacular musical.

    • @missycat7598
      @missycat7598 7 годин тому

      Wicked is based on The Wizard Of Oz, but is not meant to be kid friendly. It was originally a series of novels written by Gregory Maguire in the 90s, before it was turned into a broadway musical in the 2000s. The movie follows the same storyline as the previous iterations from the past, none of which have been very kid friendly, I'm afraid.

  • @alexdeleon1463
    @alexdeleon1463 День тому +21

    Damn, Ariana Grande can't act.

    • @syneathiabell1350
      @syneathiabell1350 День тому +20

      That's not true!!....she nailed her part..

    • @aliveidz
      @aliveidz День тому

      worry about that ugly stop motion animation you uploaded to your channel that shows no talent at all and a boring ass life that can tell why you mad over a talented and successful person

    • @Roselyse
      @Roselyse День тому +13

      Bro I don’t like the actress as a person either, but if you think she can’t act, then you just can’t see or hear.

    • @Lakishia
      @Lakishia 22 години тому +7

      hater, get a life she was amazing

  • @mattanderson3617
    @mattanderson3617 День тому +2

    I know the Wizard of Oz story is public domain and people can play with the narrative however they want, but god damn this looks bad. Bad and stupid.