Have We Found the Lost Battlefield of Brunanburh?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 кві 2023
  • The Battle of Brunanburh was one of the bloodiest and biggest battles of early medieval history. The battle features in the new Netflix movie 'The Last Kingdom: Seven Kings Must Die', but what really happened? Fought 1100 years ago, Athelstan - the king of the English - opposed a coalition of Irish, Scots and Vikings led by Olaf Guthfrithson, King of Dublin, Constantine II, King of Scotland, and Owain, King of Strathclyde and attained a decisive victory. The enemy shield wall was penetrated. Their troops ran back to their ships for safety. Thousands died.
    Apart from this we know little else. No physical evidence exists of where the battle was even fought. But recently, a stunning discovery has been made that might provide the answer to the key question - where was the Battle of Brunanbruh fought?
    Dan Snow heads to a field in Wirral where a group of archaeologists have found a huge amount of battlefield detritus from around the 10th Century. Has the search to find the lost battlefield of Brunanburh finally ended?
    Discover the past on History Hit with ad-free exclusive podcasts and documentaries released weekly presented by world renowned historians Dan Snow, Suzannah Lipscomb, Lucy Worsley, Mary Beard and more. Watch, listen and read history wherever you are, whenever you want it. Available on all devices: Apple TV, Amazon Firestick, Android TV, Samsung Smart TV, Roku, Xbox, Chromecast, Xfinity, and iOs & Android.
    Sign up to History Hit now and get 14 days free: access.historyhit.com/checkout
    We're offering a special discount to History Hit for our subscribers, get 50% off your first 3 months with code UA-cam: www.access.historyhit.com/
    #historyhit #brunanburh #lastkingdom

КОМЕНТАРІ • 472

  • @TihetrisWeathersby
    @TihetrisWeathersby Рік тому +93

    One of the things love about these shows is they keep us interested in the real history behind them

    • @abulrex_h4771
      @abulrex_h4771 10 місяців тому +1

      most people hate learning history from shows and games but they are stupid asl i swear games and tv shows are like a time machine it’s basically witch craft how lucky are we to have a tiny glimpse of probably how it was living in history

  • @Dannyboyefc
    @Dannyboyefc Рік тому +41

    I’m glad the series brought to light the battle and used the Wirral as the potential location.

  • @richardmann145
    @richardmann145 Рік тому +21

    Can't believe this isn't all over the news & Universities & Government aren't going crazy over this find.
    It's the start of Nation States in the British Isles.
    So glad there's people out & about bringing our history alive.
    God bless em

    • @Mmjk_12
      @Mmjk_12 Рік тому +3

      There is to a degree, the guy that appears at 11:00 is my uncle and it's quite a big project, multiple universities are involved and many of the artifacts collected from the field are sent to America to be analysed.

  • @mushroom-mac617
    @mushroom-mac617 Рік тому +8

    I grew up just around the corner from this site I know exactly were you are. I live about a 1500 yards away we moved there in the 70’s onto a housing estate being built, I remember as a child we had to dig our own drainage a few neighbours helped each other I remember my neighbour (who’s now dead unfortunately ) dug up a spear head and also found a small axe head they sat in his garage for years. The axe head and spear tip were found close to brimstage road.

  • @NailahRoberts
    @NailahRoberts Рік тому +38

    Bromborough is my neck of the woods and I was brought up being told that there was a Viking battle in Bromborough.

    • @dannybennett3697
      @dannybennett3697 Рік тому +1

      Stephen Harding book called ingimunds saga Norwegian wirral

    • @jimwhelan4485
      @jimwhelan4485 Рік тому +2

      I’m from the Wirral too, there is lots of Viking history here and I have no problem with Brunanburgh having been Bromborough. they came over here from Ireland.

    • @charlesbarnett2724
      @charlesbarnett2724 Рік тому +1

      Only half an hour from me too Nailah. I've strong family connections with Wirral and a sprinkling of Scandinavian DNA apparently (although mostly a Welsh English split)😂
      It makes me wonder what happened in the camp 😄

    • @Wessex90
      @Wessex90 Рік тому +1

      I live nearby too. It’s by accident that I moved to this area not knowing that this is Brunanburh (despite reading the poem). A friend told me in passing.

  • @MseeBMe
    @MseeBMe Рік тому +35

    This is astounding; a huge tip of the hat to the Wirral Archaeology group!

  • @bobfunkhouse8437
    @bobfunkhouse8437 Рік тому +66

    I have lived in Bromborough and all my life and the is a old court house in the village and the urban legend is that the archers sharpened their arrows on the wall before the battle. Also local history says it was fought on Bebington common which is gone today but ran between Bromborough and Bebington which is mostly built on now.
    Having spent a few years reading about this battle and knowing the local geography, if the battle did happen here i think the best and closest landing spot for boats would of been the modern new ferry shore. That would put them within a two to four miles (there about) of the possible battle sites. With it saying the Vikings were drove back there ships.
    Will also add that Wirral also has a big natural rock in Thurstaston Common nature reserve that is called Thor's rock, which apparently comes from Vikings of the time.

    • @FlashyVic
      @FlashyVic Рік тому +6

      The name Thurstaston sounds like it might derive from Thor too.

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому +2

      Best wishes from deepest Prenton....

    • @juliemercer1458
      @juliemercer1458 Рік тому +3

      I'm by Leasowe Rd.....peeps back then would have seen the ships sailing down the river......maybe.

    • @Bobario1
      @Bobario1 Рік тому +4

      @@FlashyVic I believe it means Thors Stone.

    • @wendylorimer5663
      @wendylorimer5663 Рік тому +3

      @@Bobario1 Settlement (ton) at Thor's stone 👍

  • @Alun49
    @Alun49 Рік тому +88

    Utterly fascinating. I watched The Last Kingdom finale a couple of days ago. To see artefacts from the actual battle fields is fascinating.

    • @gujjewman96
      @gujjewman96 Рік тому +2

      You should also watch the new movie.

    • @Gang-zy7lq
      @Gang-zy7lq Рік тому +4

      ​@@gujjewman96 I think he means the film

    • @howwwwwyyyyy
      @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому

      The books are much better,as usual.

    • @Gang-zy7lq
      @Gang-zy7lq Рік тому

      @@howwwwwyyyyy I not no about tha movie decent every one to ther own

    • @mondom6332
      @mondom6332 Рік тому +2

      Destiny is all !!

  • @observationsfromthebunker9639
    @observationsfromthebunker9639 Рік тому +17

    I was very interested and excited when this video appeared in my feed. Brunanburh is the one of the most important battles in the history of the English-speaking peoples that the average person has never heard about. The amount of the artifacts found by the Wirral group in the probable location is very encouraging!

  • @alancoe1002
    @alancoe1002 Рік тому +27

    Super-viking Egil Skallagrimsson was a friend of Æthelstan's and present at this battle. An account of it is in Egil's Saga. Thanks for the history spade-work and dedication.

    • @andrewhart6377
      @andrewhart6377 Рік тому +2

      A Mercenary. Many Normans signed up on the other side as well (typical)

    • @murrayscott9546
      @murrayscott9546 Рік тому +1

      I've read Egils Saga and love it for it's description of greed, deception, plotting and all the things I've seen of what takes over and xestroies families . Do you know where the gold is buried ?

  • @mattmurdoch5575
    @mattmurdoch5575 Рік тому +63

    Actually, as someone mentioned below, I think it would be great to have Stuart from time to you coming to survey the land. His eye at interpreting the landscape is extraordinary and he is capable of interpreting detail in the landscape that others seem to miss. His contribution to something so important Would be a valuable thing to have.

    • @davidsullivan7743
      @davidsullivan7743 Рік тому +17

      You can see Stewart Ainsworth in the background working on site

  • @harbourdogNL
    @harbourdogNL Рік тому +20

    Fascinating indeed. And she sure knows her stuff- not a pause, not an um or an ah. Refreshing to hear knowledgeable delivery without pause.

  • @mikepelosi9877
    @mikepelosi9877 Рік тому +8

    I've been a fan of history since I've been a young lad (one of the few subjects that kept my attention and GPA up in school) but, for some reason, the Last Kingdom has drawn me into English/European/Nordic history more than any other historical drama. And I say this with all due respect: it's a shame the show didn't get a bigger budget and more marketing. History Hit, as always, has done a fantastic job tying in the real underlying history and bridging the gap between entertainment and reality. By centering major historical events on biggest players involved, History Hit brings the drama and makes the details necessary to understand how the real stories played out that shaped the world.

  • @FreeFallingAir
    @FreeFallingAir Рік тому +18

    I'm absolutely fascinated by this time in English history. Thanks history Hit

  • @barle5566
    @barle5566 Рік тому +19

    In this year, King Æthelstan, lord of earls,
    ring-giver of warriors, and his brother as well,
    Eadmund ætheling achieved everlasting glory
    in battle, with the edges of swords
    near Brunanburh. They cleaved the massed shields,
    hewed the battle-wood, the relics of hammers,
    of the heir of Eadweard, as it suited
    their heritage, so that they often in battle
    defended their lands, treasures, and homesteads
    against every one of the hateful- (1-10a)

  • @David-oi7im
    @David-oi7im Рік тому +8

    ... the war vestiges found on that field had me mesmerized,, I mean a thousand years ago, how much more history do you need to certify this ground as truly historic!!!

  • @Cara-39
    @Cara-39 Рік тому +62

    So many people consider 1066 to be the beginning of British history but this battle is essentially the starting point. Also, the only 2 English rulers given the epithet "the Great", Alfred and Cnut, reigned before the Norman Conquest

    • @adventussaxonum448
      @adventussaxonum448 Рік тому +10

      Cnut wasn't English.
      "Rulers of England", maybe?

    • @Althom1990
      @Althom1990 Рік тому

      So William the Norman was English?

    • @shawnbenson7696
      @shawnbenson7696 Рік тому

      ​@@adventussaxonum448 Cnut used as his base and where he raised the money to create his kingdom.

    • @ianbaker8225
      @ianbaker8225 Рік тому +11

      @@adventussaxonum448 sorry to nit-pick but Alfred wasn't a ruler of England but King of Wessex.

    • @chrisar2252
      @chrisar2252 Рік тому +8

      I think referring to Cnut as "the Great" in England is a new thing, he didn't do anything to merit that. But you are right, Alfred, Edward the Elder, Aethelfead (ruler of Mercia and who raised and educated Aethelstan), Athelstan, as well and Edmund 1 and Edgar the peaceful, were seriously important early rulers.

  • @rosariocatlin4845
    @rosariocatlin4845 Рік тому +83

    I don’t know if you have found the lost battlefield but DESTINY IS ALL

    • @saltyfruits3961
      @saltyfruits3961 Рік тому +2

      DESTINY IS AAAALLLLLLL

    • @wywk
      @wywk Рік тому +6

      Arseling!

    • @gb3007
      @gb3007 Рік тому +3

      @rosariocatlin4845 Weird bid ful araed = Fated is inexorable (unstoppable)
      The term weird when applied to a person used to mean touched by fate.

    • @IrishInsomniac76
      @IrishInsomniac76 Рік тому

      wyrd bið ful aræd

    • @StixDarKlor
      @StixDarKlor Рік тому

      @@gb3007 It’s spelling in this context is Wyrd, which is what Bernard Cornwell uses but really glad to see someone use the term properly….I really can’t stand Destiny is all!

  • @Jin-Ro
    @Jin-Ro Рік тому +46

    You can see how Brunanburh would evolve into Bromborough. Wirral has known historical links to the Norse. It's about half a mile from the Mersey river. Chester was an English stronghold. A field full of military artifacts for the relevant period. It's an exceptionally strong candidate.

    • @dannybennett3697
      @dannybennett3697 Рік тому +4

      Ingimunds saga Norwegian Wirral by Stephen Harding great read

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому +1

      bennett hear,hear...😊

    • @alancoe1002
      @alancoe1002 5 місяців тому +1

      Bron was an ancient God of these parts

  • @Jenissuperhero
    @Jenissuperhero Рік тому +15

    It looks like Time Team has a new location! I’d love to see them do a dig here.

    • @davidsullivan7743
      @davidsullivan7743 Рік тому +7

      If you look in the background of some of the shots, you'll notice Stewart Ainsworth working on site.

  • @knockshinnoch1950
    @knockshinnoch1950 Рік тому +20

    Fascinating. I had never heard of this battle despite its importance in the history of how England and Great Britain were formed.

    • @EvoraGT430
      @EvoraGT430 Рік тому

      The Normans tried to erase all history prior to 1066.

    • @Cara-39
      @Cara-39 Рік тому

      So many people assume that British history began in 1066 but this battle is essentially the starting point. Also, the only 2 English rulers given the epithet "the Great", Alfred and Cnut, reigned before the Norman Conquest

  • @natalieeis9284
    @natalieeis9284 Рік тому +8

    "Call me Uhtred, or, from time to time, you may wish to call me Arseling" 😁

  • @frankhoeppel2314
    @frankhoeppel2314 8 місяців тому +2

    Thank you for asking multiple pertinent questions and allowing the subject matter expert time to answer thoroughly. Saddened by how rare this is, but thankful I’ve found it here.

  • @admiralbenbow5083
    @admiralbenbow5083 Рік тому +11

    There are lots of ideas as to where this was fought. All I can say is that in the name I hear, a fortification (burh, old English), and I hear a well (Brunnen in German, Brunn in Swedish).

  • @julianheath2718
    @julianheath2718 Рік тому +14

    Worth mentioning that close to this site, is a ridge (now Storeton Woods), and running down either side of this, are two lanes with interesting names, perhaps pointing to conflict: 'Red Hill Road' and 'Rest Hill Road'.

    • @thedrumdoctor
      @thedrumdoctor Рік тому +1

      Or it could be reference to the ancient Roman sandstone quarry which Storeton woods now occupies.

    • @julianheath2718
      @julianheath2718 Рік тому +2

      @@thedrumdoctor Yes, that could be a possibility - I forgot about that!

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому

      @@julianheath2718 Tom Sleman a local author has written extensively about the hauntings around the battle site...

    • @julianheath2718
      @julianheath2718 Рік тому +1

      @@eamonnclabby7067 Thanks - will check out. I like Tom Sleman's books.

  • @williamanderson5437
    @williamanderson5437 Рік тому +6

    It was Norwegian Vikings from Dublin, but note a 'breakaway' Norwegian 'group' had seperated from Dublin in 902ad and settled on Wirral, which still has a large Norwegian DNA (up to 50% in 2022, see Prof Stephen Harding). Bernard Cornwell in his 13th Last Kingdom novel confirms Wirral Archaeology's work. Red Hill Road on Storeton Woods was said to have 'run red with blood after the battle' in 937 - folk lore, as personally known.

    • @SEnnever
      @SEnnever Рік тому +1

      Viking DNA: The Wirral and West Lancashire Project Paperback - Illustrated, 19 Feb. 2015, also written by Prof. Turi E King from the Richard III project at Leicester Uni. This was her first project and had some very conclusive results.

  • @marc8631
    @marc8631 Рік тому +3

    After watching Vikings and of course The Last Kingdom my interests in UK is so grown a lot. Amazing the history of England wow. Hope to visit the country once. 🙏

  • @kevdimo6459
    @kevdimo6459 Рік тому +2

    Thanks again for another great video, I’ll be watching for the follow up.

  • @ImolaS3
    @ImolaS3 Рік тому +4

    I only found this site around xmas 2022 and love it! So much interesting material and so well presented - loved the end of year quiz too :)

  • @cymro6537
    @cymro6537 Рік тому +13

    I just hope that this field is guarded to stop any unscrupulous treasure hunters.

    • @johnlanddigging1987
      @johnlanddigging1987 Рік тому +1

      They would need a J.C.B to dig down to that level. You wouldn't hear a peep on a normal detector. I've been all over the wirral and been moaned at by the likes of you but it will never stop me. I look for gold and silver not rusty swords and crap spears.

    • @pipins3616
      @pipins3616 День тому

      That’s the British museum, the place where things disappear

  • @DaveSCameron
    @DaveSCameron Рік тому +20

    Battle of Connahs Quay is the only battle I recall with Tranmere Rovers vs Wrexham. ⚽🇬🇧📚

    • @NEEJER
      @NEEJER Рік тому +1

      Will be resumed next season 😮

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому

      @@NEEJER Prenton park awaits...😊

  • @Aswaguespack
    @Aswaguespack Рік тому +6

    Good stuff. Glad to see the reveal of the location of an historic event.

  • @jannerkev
    @jannerkev Рік тому +6

    Brilliant. This Makes sense of the battle shown on the TV film. Now we know it was close to the Wirral.

  • @blxtothis
    @blxtothis Рік тому +6

    They should have asked Bernard Cornwell where it happened!😊

  • @mohammedsaysrashid3587
    @mohammedsaysrashid3587 Рік тому +9

    It was a wonderful historical coverage about that remarkable battle that shaped Britain 🇬🇧

  • @Lastbus511
    @Lastbus511 Рік тому +5

    Coming from the Wirral, I've always heard roumers since I was a kid this battle might have been fought near by. There's a lot of Viking heritage on the Wirral. I was once told that the Vikings were originally allowed to settle on the Wirral and the Merseyside coast by the Saxons in return they would secure the mouth of the River Dee and Mersey to stop other Viking groups from sailing up the River Dee to raid the likes of Chester and other places. Chester was quite an important city for the Saxons. Modern DNA testing appears to fit in with this theory many people on the Wirral and Merseyside appear to have direct Viking heritage.

  • @stephennelmes4557
    @stephennelmes4557 Рік тому +7

    I'm from Yorkshire, spent most of my working life at sea ( RN/RFA), and was in the Wirral area last night on a delivery drop discussing this very battle with a colleague. I have always found this battle😅 fascinating and have a passion for history. Claire 16:24 is absolutely gorgeous. Brains and beauty, a winning combination.

  • @Nebulasecura
    @Nebulasecura Рік тому +11

    Destiny is all! And rest in peace Utred!

    • @ML-bw4yt
      @ML-bw4yt Рік тому

      Uhtred didn’t even live at the time of this battle lol

    • @Nebulasecura
      @Nebulasecura Рік тому

      @@ML-bw4yt I know.

  • @soulfate2
    @soulfate2 Рік тому +1

    Very good very interesting.. love the passion of archeologists and others ..they do wonders in their work so important

  • @ToniCherub
    @ToniCherub Рік тому +2

    My family’s surname go back prior to 1066 & I found myself moving to a place where our ancestors have lived & didn’t even know about it until I went to the church with our name there on a slab it’s fascinating how far we all do go back !

  • @julianheath2718
    @julianheath2718 Рік тому +3

    Absolutely fascinating!

  • @BenSHammonds
    @BenSHammonds Місяць тому

    very good program, fascinating subject, these early battles

  • @Go-Dawgs
    @Go-Dawgs Рік тому

    This is Exciting & What An Excellent Job those metal Detectorist have done!!
    Thank You so much for Sharing with us.

  • @darklingeraeld-ridge7946
    @darklingeraeld-ridge7946 Рік тому +6

    Fifty years and more afterwards, it was still widely referred to simply as ‘The Battle’. Egil Skallagrimsson’s saga says he fought there, with Aethelstan, and his brother was killed in the battle, for which he received two chests of silver from the king. It massively impacted the identity of these islands. There should be every necessary commitment of resources to investigate this potentially crucial British historical site, properly.

    • @andrewhart6377
      @andrewhart6377 Рік тому +1

      Not Battle, but 'Great Battle' as it was. The Irish accounts put their death Toll down as being near 35,000. Considering the Populations of the British Isles in those times, Per Capita, this would rival any Battle of WW1 in Terms of Combatants and Losses for a Set-Piece conflict, possibly even dwarfing them.

  • @AnthonyEvelyn
    @AnthonyEvelyn Рік тому +6

    I really hope this is the battle site, been reading about this epic battle for decades. The use of Lidar and other imaging technologies will aid in confirming if this is the area of the great battle.

  • @daejavue69
    @daejavue69 Рік тому +1

    As a massive fan of Bernard's Cornwell last kingdom & his Sharp series has shone a light in an exciting way of our British History & the Birth of England as a nation .
    He follows the early battles led by King Alfred the Great , Aethelstan being his grandson & the king at the time of the Battle of Brunanburh , cementing the kingdom in to one Engaland .
    Following this story of where the great battle took place has been a history jigsaw , still to completed & my money is on the great work the Wirrel Archialogical have been dong over the years & thank you BC for igniting my interest in our history .

  • @mccblarney
    @mccblarney 11 місяців тому +1

    Anything found near to the coast that may or may not relate to the battle , could only make its case to be a base camp for the warrior fleet. The Saxon Chronicle describes the battle taking place a days fast ride on horseback from the landing area. They need to look further afield than the Mersey area. If they can pinpoint the site, I for one, will be so happy. It has been an all consuming passion of mine for the last 45 years.

  • @eamonnclabby7067
    @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому +5

    Excellent, best wishes from deepest Prenton on the wirral peninsula,bounded by the mersey and the Dee and the Irish sea...geography and rhyme ❤❤😊😊😊

  • @jonathandnicholson
    @jonathandnicholson Рік тому +4

    Very interesting. I shall post this to some people I know who live in the Wirral.

  • @benjaminrush4443
    @benjaminrush4443 Рік тому

    Great Stuff! Thanks.

  • @glynluff2595
    @glynluff2595 2 місяці тому +1

    From the comments made it would seem possible that the Mercians gathered in Chester because the Roman Walls of Deva would still have stood to some degree thus giving a certain area of protection.

  • @tipofthespear7182
    @tipofthespear7182 Рік тому +4

    Yes . Just watched the 7 Kings must die story 2 days ago which was the sequel to the Last Kingdom and now to see the real battlefield is quite something

    • @howwwwwyyyyy
      @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому

      The books are much better,you can even listen to them on youtube

  • @murrayscott9546
    @murrayscott9546 Рік тому

    The more that I learn about the history of us all - here, there and everywhere - the more I feel that we are all under the same Sun, in all our wisdom, ignorance, anger and beauty. Thanks, crew for your dedicated work.

  • @rwcowell
    @rwcowell Рік тому +1

    I am very Excited that the Brunaburh battlefield has been finally located. There are so many Viking Age battlefields that we still haven't definitively located. Even the Hastings battlefield has never been fully established as to where the actual battle was fought. There is so many artifacts and information that could tell us more about how the battles were actually fought, the real number of participants, the type of gear and weaponries that was utilized. I hope we can soon find Edington's battlefield. IAC this is Amazing news!

  • @nevamind68t23
    @nevamind68t23 Рік тому +2

    Fascinating, thank you 👍🏾

    • @HistoryHit
      @HistoryHit  Рік тому +1

      You're welcome! Glad you enjoyed

  • @glenchapman3899
    @glenchapman3899 Рік тому +12

    Going to admit I have never heard of this battle. But given the amount of skin all the leading players had in this makes Hastings look almost like a side show

    • @helpmaboabb
      @helpmaboabb Рік тому +1

      Likewise the Battle of Deorham in 577, which I'd never heard of but was just as important further down - South Wales and Cornwall & Devon

  • @willgibbons1733
    @willgibbons1733 Рік тому +9

    We love you Aethelstan 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

    • @kernowboy137
      @kernowboy137 Рік тому

      Speak for yourself 😢

    • @willgibbons1733
      @willgibbons1733 Рік тому

      @@kernowboy137 yeh, obviously. Who do you speak for?

    • @kernowboy137
      @kernowboy137 Рік тому +1

      @@willgibbons1733 I suggest reading some history with a particular focus on “that filthy race” expelled from Exeter to the other bank of the River Tamar.

    • @adventussaxonum448
      @adventussaxonum448 Рік тому +1

      ​@@kernowboy137
      That was necessary, so that Devonshire folk could eat their scones properly. 😄

    • @willgibbons1733
      @willgibbons1733 Рік тому +2

      @@kernowboy137 you are english now though, aren't you?

  • @barbarossarotbart
    @barbarossarotbart Рік тому

    Do you know what I like on all of your documentaries? The fact that you include uncut interviews with scientists. Most modern documentaries cut those interviews in a way that makes them look if they support the theory of the presenter, even if this is not the case. I've got the feeling that it is more important today that a documentary correlate with the current Zeitgeist and not with historical facts. (The best example for this is Netflix' Cleopatra documentary, but sadly it is not the only one.)

  • @markstallman1670
    @markstallman1670 Рік тому

    Keep up the great work on this important battle, and remember there is an amber pommeled sword somewhere out in that turf!

  • @fingazblank
    @fingazblank Рік тому +3

    I have never heard of this battle, I love history but I'm just a casual and just like nearly probably maybe a good percentage only found out by the TV show the last kingdom. Thank you, now all we need is utrids sword

  • @rogueriderhood1862
    @rogueriderhood1862 Рік тому +7

    I remember, many years ago, watching Michael Wood's series 'In Search of the Dark Ages', the programme on Athelstan, and Dr/Professor(?) Wood suggested the site of the battle was at Tinsley, near Sheffield.

    • @jonathantitterton9455
      @jonathantitterton9455 Рік тому +1

      That wouldn’t make sense because that’s in the middle of Saxon territory and too far inland for the Hiberno-Norse contingent. Also the Etymology doesn’t make sense meanwhile BROMBROUGH on the Wirral makes sense.

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому

      ​@@jonathantitterton9455 Bernard Cornwell would agree with you 😅😅😅

    • @jonathantitterton9455
      @jonathantitterton9455 Рік тому +2

      @@eamonnclabby7067 which is good to know since he’s known to do extensive research into the period before writing his novels. Plus it’s just basic common sense

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому +3

      ​@@jonathantitterton9455 he actually came here on the wirral, was presented with a dagger retrieved from the battle site by Wirral archeologists...😊

  • @sammyholman2566
    @sammyholman2566 Рік тому +8

    There is an old map of the wirral showing the supposed location of the battle Wargrave, I'm sure they must know about it

    • @glenchapman3899
      @glenchapman3899 Рік тому +5

      Maps can be notorious though. The battle of Bosworth field was a well defined mapped battle site, till it was not

  • @doncook2054
    @doncook2054 Рік тому

    Absolutely stunning! The concentrations of "metal" are key.

  • @richardchapman842
    @richardchapman842 Рік тому

    absolutely brilliant

  • @vipertwenty249
    @vipertwenty249 Рік тому +5

    Looks like Regia Anglorum reenactors there. Nice to see some better authenticity for once. Use them more.
    When we're talking about lost battlefield sites - it would be nice to find the site of the battle of Hastings. The only thing we know for certain is that it wasn't on the English Heritage site in the town of Battle.

    • @jonathantitterton9455
      @jonathantitterton9455 Рік тому

      I don’t think it’s Regia, looking at the kit and shield designs I think it’s Free Warbands of England.

    • @vipertwenty249
      @vipertwenty249 Рік тому

      @@jonathantitterton9455 Never heard of 'em. As other reenactment groups go they don't look too bad.

    • @jonathantitterton9455
      @jonathantitterton9455 Рік тому +1

      @@vipertwenty249 they’re….questionable when it comes to kit, if you look at them there’s a lot of Rus style armour and equipment which would’ve not been seen on an English battlefield.

    • @vipertwenty249
      @vipertwenty249 Рік тому

      @@jonathantitterton9455 True.

  • @bertiescunsbutch9323
    @bertiescunsbutch9323 Рік тому

    This is a fantastic discovery.

  • @davidhynes9683
    @davidhynes9683 Рік тому +2

    It was known the battle was in Bromborough. for a long time. Very surprising it has taken such a long time to arrive at this examination of the fields. Bromborough very flat. There is an ancient poem about the battle, between Northerners and Southerners who controls Britain, the poem describes the River Mersey and its distinctive brown colour.

  • @WargamingHistory
    @WargamingHistory Рік тому

    Will be following this location with interest

  • @robertlubel734
    @robertlubel734 Рік тому

    Most interesting. Would be really awesome to find the battlefield between King Arthur and Modred which is documented but strictly lore.

  • @catherinegadbois1532
    @catherinegadbois1532 Рік тому

    Love this old history!

  • @stevekeenan4212
    @stevekeenan4212 Рік тому +5

    I grew up in Bromborough and went to St Barnabas primary school, our teacher at the time said there had been a big battle around the Bromborough area. I was about 9 years old at the time so around 1966. He was correct by the looks of it. Good old Mr Maddox 🙂

  • @666johnco
    @666johnco Рік тому +9

    I would love to see Dan Snow have a conversation with Michael 'the battle was fought in the east of England' Wood about this. Isn't there a theory from the people who hold that opinion that a military camp does not a battle make. This would be for the presentation of a balanced opinion as other historian's state that as the camps time of existence cannot be dated it could have been from troops of .Edward the Elder or Æthelflæd conducting operations to secure the northern frontier of Mercia.

    • @666johnco
      @666johnco Рік тому +3

      A lecture by Michael Wood as to why he thinks the battle took place in Yorkshire. BTW as a Cheshireman I have no personal objection to it being on the Wirral. I just point out there are other opinions ua-cam.com/video/-C_DjWU2HnA/v-deo.html

    • @wedgeantillies66
      @wedgeantillies66 Рік тому +1

      He, Michael Wood, did an article in BBC history magazinr a few years back, putting forward five different sites as to the battle's location including wirral as one of the five. If memory served he still plumps for site on borders of ancient Mercia/Northumberland border in south Yorkshire, given available evidence, from chronicles and archelogy.
      As for him, wirral camp is not a smoking gun, given it has only been dated to 10th century and therefore can easaily date from other eras of conflict during that century.

    • @666johnco
      @666johnco Рік тому

      @@wedgeantillies66 Yes the example his opinions is a lecture from two years ago where he is still firmly situation the battle in south Yorkshire. This camp being at the literal border bet ween Mercia and Northumbria you have possibilities such as The cam pains by Æthelflæd and Edward the Elder to secure that border by building Burhs along the river. It could relate to Athelstan's earlier campaigns or indeed to the site of the battle of Brunanburh. Further on it could relate to some defensive preparedness from the war fought with Northumbria in 948 after they un-united by inviting Erik Bloodaxe to become their king.

    • @wedgeantillies66
      @wedgeantillies66 Рік тому

      @@666johnco Yes, indeed he is still firmly adamant in that belief and with good reason. As fortified camp found in the wirral could date from any period of major conflict between Saxons and Vikings during reign of Edward the elder right through to those of his sons, including those of his sister too.
      Plus find dismissal of oh vikings couldn't have landed a fleet in the humber as chronicles state to be rather biases, given Athelstan had done exactly the same in reverse before Brunanburh during his invasion of Scotland by land and sea, after only a couple of decades of having major shipbuilding prowess. So vikings, the sea power without equal of the age, could done such a feat easily..

    • @wedgeantillies66
      @wedgeantillies66 Рік тому

      @@666johnco Thanks very much for the link as Wood made a very persuasive argument as to why he comes down as to the battle's location in Yorkshire. Although suspect this is a historical argument that like the actual fate of the princess in the tower will run and run for many centuries until a smoking gun is found.
      Yeah, think that would make for a great video, something he has form for as he did a great video with Saul David on start of Zulu war and opening battles for this channel, so not beyond the realms of possibility.

  • @leanneknowles2290
    @leanneknowles2290 Рік тому

    I love my history... i would love to go see some old castles... i love vikings and early english history.... nice to see some scenes from the last kingdom film.... i enjoyed this episode....

  • @the_rover1
    @the_rover1 Рік тому +7

    Sounds like a splendid site for a new time team episode, doesn't it?

  • @kev3d
    @kev3d Рік тому

    Very exciting!

  • @ste2442
    @ste2442 Рік тому +5

    The Wirral truly is a special place (from a scouser ).

  • @karmad3269
    @karmad3269 Рік тому

    High middle age struggles for increasing or creating new kingdoms are so interesting as far very few is known by sources and traditions. Same everywhere in old Europe and England...here in Italy too😊

  • @AnnaAnna-uc2ff
    @AnnaAnna-uc2ff Рік тому +1

    Thank you.

  • @markhand4530
    @markhand4530 Рік тому +4

    geographically the location makes a lot of sense. I am not an historian but clare from liverpool university mentioned that vikings were already established in that area from earlier times after having to withdraw from Ireland. I am sure i read something about this they was given permission by a king of wessex or mercia. They obviously would have been sympathetic to the vikings from dublin and fought with them.

    • @howwwwwyyyyy
      @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому +1

      It's on the edge of what was called the Danelaw,England was split along a road called Watling street,that ran from the Wirral to London,it's the A something now

  • @katherinecollins4685
    @katherinecollins4685 Рік тому

    Really interesting

  • @pharaohmedjaylawofmedjay2680

    Pretty Cool Stuff So Many Nationality All in Same place

  • @davidhynes9683
    @davidhynes9683 Рік тому +2

    Surely the ancient mention of the River Mersey was enough to tell that it was Bromborough.?

    • @user-xd5pr4qd4z
      @user-xd5pr4qd4z Місяць тому

      Yeah but common sense and academics always have to butt heads, as the academics are always more interested in putting forward their own ingenious opinions rather than what seems utterly obvious. I'm in preston where the largest viking hoard was ever found and I suspect it was probably deposited whilst on the run from this battle. It looked like enough to pay an army with and they never managed to come back for is, so something tells me they buried it in a hurry then shortly after got killed or captured. So imo it has to be in the northwest. The idea that they would sail from Ireland all the way around the treacherous waters around the island is madness. Of course they'd have gone A to B as fast and direct as possible and it provides the perfect meeting place for their allied forces. I've never considered the alternative idea it was fought somewhere in the east to lack any evidence other than something someone scribbled down 300 years later. It just has to be on the wirral, and then I'd guess in the aftermath when it was every man for himself it spread further. And those trying to get back north or to Scotland (alba) would obviously have to cross the Ribble at some point, and the hoard was found very close to the old roman Fort, so that was obviously a very ancient route north/south.

  • @MrSunlander
    @MrSunlander Рік тому +2

    History Hits is All!

  • @fred869
    @fred869 2 місяці тому +1

    The telling of this great story would be helped by the use of maps.

  • @sigliumantiqua.1002
    @sigliumantiqua.1002 Рік тому

    Great to see that the research being done by detectorists is being appreciated by historians. The Battle of Hastings site has been called into doubt and it seems that little research has been done (since the Time Team dig) by English Heritage who have more or less shrugged off the lack of evidence. The mystery of the site of the Battle of Watling Street (61 CE) is still unsolved. There should be vast amounts of lost weaponry where supposedly 80,000 Britons fell. I think we need more responsible detectorists to help solve both these mysteries.

  • @Richard-fv7rq
    @Richard-fv7rq Рік тому +1

    Awesome.

  • @CajunRed
    @CajunRed Рік тому

    Is this a series? If so, is the series on DVD? Very interested American, that has Norwegian/Scandanavian as well as Scots/English/Irish/English ancestry. I'm just trying to fill in the gaps as much as I can. The artificats are awesome as well. I'm also, the person that if my wallet were thicker; I'd be buying antiques every chance I could! Great job, everyone!

  • @horuslupercal9936
    @horuslupercal9936 Рік тому +1

    Very exciting news for Dark Age Britain enthusiasts.

    • @justonecornetto80
      @justonecornetto80 Рік тому

      Indeed. I really hope this is Brunanburh because it will undoubtedly yield a huge trove of artifacts that could change our understanding of Saxon England.

  • @lenjames
    @lenjames Рік тому +7

    Has there ever been discoveries of human bones that might be of the warriors of these great battles?

    • @rhysnichols8608
      @rhysnichols8608 Рік тому +4

      Thing is most bodies, if not all, were likely removed after the battle to be buried or maybe cremated in a proper mass funeral

    • @sirrathersplendid4825
      @sirrathersplendid4825 Рік тому

      @@rhysnichols8608 - Would they be cremated? I don’t know. The Viking tradition at least was to leave the bodies exposed so ravens could feast on them.
      Most battlefields have a few burial pits where bodies were thrown in haste.

    • @damedusa5107
      @damedusa5107 Рік тому

      Depends on the soil, most ones would be long gone

  • @thisoldnurse1521
    @thisoldnurse1521 Рік тому +2

    Canadian here 🇨🇦 Love learning about history, now I do have a suggestion, would it be possible for you to put up some maps as many watching cannot figure the location. It is fine if you live in Great Britain but for the red, we don’t know where the Mercy River is or the other river. Please we would like points of reference.

    • @howwwwwyyyyy
      @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому +3

      The Mersey is the river that Liverpool is on,the wirral is on the other side between The Mersey and the Dee.

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому

      Try The King in the North by Max Adam's,vividly described the British Isles of 400 to 700 AD

  • @leobulero3485
    @leobulero3485 Рік тому +5

    after seeing that pommel, somebody in this battle must have been ended rightly with it

    • @24934637
      @24934637 Рік тому

      Would be a shame if they hadn't, after all, it is the primary purpose of a pommel! LOL.

  • @damo5701
    @damo5701 Рік тому +4

    I thought it took Olaf Guthfrithson many days (weeks?) to get back to Dublin, indicating he was not fleeing from the Wirral which would only be a day or two journey.

    • @jonathantitterton9455
      @jonathantitterton9455 Рік тому +2

      It depended on the direction of the wind because they relied on sails. If the wind wasn’t blowing constantly westward they would’ve had to sail whichever the wind was blowing and it would take longer to get back to Dublin.

    • @Bobario1
      @Bobario1 Рік тому

      I remember reading somewhere they stopped on the isle of man for a while to recover.

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому +1

      @@jonathantitterton9455 indeed, the tides from Morecambe bay down to the Menai straits are very treacherous...

  • @letiekllib
    @letiekllib Рік тому

    "The prerequisite of all intelligent tinkering, is that you maintain all the pieces." A. Leopold.

  • @morriganmhor5078
    @morriganmhor5078 Рік тому +4

    Northumbria was in no way Pictish territory, so I do not know what tharchaeologistist speaks about. Yes, Highlander tried to invade southlands much more often than the English went north - because, before oil was discovered, why should they? Scots were for the whole Middle Ages and Renaissance something like a fifth column serving French interests for free.

    • @morriganmhor5078
      @morriganmhor5078 Рік тому +1

      And also, the Anglo-Saxon kingdom of Northumbria was just not the same as the Scandinavian Kingdom of York which became the thing only after conquering the local dynasty. What is not said here also is that the kings of Northumbria founded Edinburgh and other towns/castles that Scots fought for many hundreds of years after.

    • @eamonnclabby7067
      @eamonnclabby7067 Рік тому

      Try the King in the North by Max Adam's,vividly described the British Isles of 400 to 700...including Nechtansmere...

    • @howwwwwyyyyy
      @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому

      The auld alliance came much later,the French had their hands full with Viking raids themselves

    • @morriganmhor5078
      @morriganmhor5078 Рік тому

      @@howwwwwyyyyy i should Havel written high Middle.

    • @morriganmhor5078
      @morriganmhor5078 Рік тому

      @@howwwwwyyyyy 937 was more than 25 years after Rollo and his band obtained future Normandy from Charles the Simple. But at that time, the raids were already ending, as Scandinavia began to Christianize. But you´re right that de iure the Auld Alliance began only at 1295, though the Scots or at least their marchers never lost any opportunity in raiding England, were there any disturbances there.

  • @markashton6853
    @markashton6853 7 місяців тому

    I heard that Æthelstan's objective was to get a massive geological tow rope to drag the Wirral near to the Isle of Man and turn it into a leper colony. The technology wasn't available at the time though so he just had a big battle instead.

  • @thelostlegendsoflewesandhamsey

    Battle of Ringmere - Ringmer Nr Lewes
    Batte of Ashdown - Ashdown Forest near Kings Standing, Withyham
    Battle of Heathfield - Heathfield Nr Mayfield
    All lost battle sites, fairly obviously in East Sussex.

  • @anthonytaylor6972
    @anthonytaylor6972 Рік тому +1

    Makes sense that it was in bromborough shouldn't even be still debated.Irish-norse fleet crossing the Irish sea which wouldn't of took them long atall and the Celts and other Norse fleets coming down the west coast past Blackpool down to the north and west parts of the Wirral to group together at places like west Kirby,thursaston,hoylake,thingwall etc.As the lady in the video said the Wessex and Mercian army would of come up through Chester and marched north through the peninsula to battle.After getting a good ass kicking the tired,defeated Norse/Celt army got chased back up to the northern shores of the Wirral where they fled

  • @lvg1865
    @lvg1865 Рік тому +2

    Has it even been explained anywhere how or what it would mean to fight a whole day? Would troops break up for a cup of tea? Or where they simple more men then us to the could keep it up all day? Moves are moves I know, but they are all right at it. Or where battles more organised, and every hour an additional men where send in for example?

  • @RAFASOP
    @RAFASOP Рік тому +2

    Wirral should have a sign saying 'Wirral Birthplace of England'

  • @CerdicTheGreat
    @CerdicTheGreat 11 місяців тому

    The Anglo-Saxon chronicles tells of the English nobility criticising Athelstan for delay and watching the hords ravage England. If Bromborough was the staging (or meeting) place for the coalition, why did they stay there and wait for Athelstan (in his own sweet time) to get to Chester, refresh, and then engage in battle? Perhaps the "hords" had been ravashing and were using Bromborough as their main base. Athelstan made his way to Chester to destroy said camp and the elements of the coalition returned to engage while Athelstan's troops were getting refreshed.