wonderful voices these two. Thank you, it's so great that you put them on youtube giving we folk in far flung places the opportunity to enjoy this beautiful music. Blessings
I think it was the Baal Shem Tov who said that when a popular song is used for a prayer the song has been sanctified. Could there be a more glorious example of that than Cantor Brook's take on Shallow? It's like a good song finally became the miracle it was meant to be all along. Thank you so much, Cantors Brook and Schwartz!
This is lovely. Our congregation adopted this in recent services and it was beautiful and well received. My only complaint? It gets stuck in my head all week 😂. If that is the worst of my problems, I am very blessed.
Azi, can you share the score to this and the adon Olam you did a few weeks ago? Our Congregation would love for or\ur Rabbi Mark Solomon to sing these.
EL MISMO CREADO EN ELLA SEA DE ELLA EL CIELO..COMO EL MISMO DE MADRE A TODA LA TIERRA...LA OBRA..DE AQUELLOS EN ELLAS..UN DUO..MADRE E HIJO.. AaaaaaaaaMe'e'e'e'e'eE'e'e'e'e'N AAAAAAAAAME'E'E'E'E'EE'E'E'E'E'N AaaaaaaaaaMe'e'e'e'e'e'eE'e'e'e'N
Peace will come upon us Peace will come upon us Peace will come upon us and on everyone. Salaam ('peace' in Arabic) On us and on everyone Salaam, Salaam
@@DavidPNeff this is not the correct translation. You posted a translation of an Israeli popular song by Mosh Ben Ari. And they on the other hand sang a combination of it with a song by Yigal Bashan that is based on different prayers. The translation for the second song is: He who makes peace in His high places May He bring peace upon us And upon all Israel And say Amen. May He bring peace, may He bring peace Peace upon us and on all of Israel May He bring peace, may He bring peace Peace upon us and on all of Israel. What they sing is something that based on both of them
It sounds like they mixed two songs together - 2. Ose Shalom ('make' Peace) (www.hebrewsongs.com/?song=osehshalom ) and 1. "Od yavo' shalom aleinu" peace will come onto us www.hebrewsongs.com/song-salaam.htm )... I put the links to the song translations/transliterations in parenthesis.. so the song goes something like this: 1 .Od yavo' shalom Peace will come Od yavo' shalom aleinu Peace will come onto us Od yavo' shalom Peace will come Od yavo' shalom aleinu Peace will come onto us Shalom aleinu Peace on Us V'al kol Yisrael and all Israel (Israel refers to the children of Israel) V'imru: (And we say) V'imru: amen. (and we say: Amen) 2 Oseh shalom bimromav ((he who) makes peace from above) Hu ya'aseh shalom aleinu he will make peace onto us V'al kol Yisrael (and on all of Israel) V'imru: amen. (and we say: Amen)
@@SeanMilford wow, really? I didn't know they did this kind of thing anywhere but reform. When I was a child, conservative congregations were very strict. How nice ☺
@@barbarahumphreys4887 I think times have changed. TheReform is more reformed and the Conservative synagogues are more Reformed... read that as further away from Observing Jewish Laws.As much as I enjoyed this music, there is no way I can get comfortable with going to Synagogue on a Shabbos and people are playing instruments or setting prayer to secular/movie music. Just my opinion.
While, yes, this presentation does seem a lot like that of a church, it isn't that of a church. The simple prayers are from Jewish canon and are to the one and only God, who always was and always will be invisible and indivisible. Jesus seems to have been one of many Jewish teachers of his day. Raised in a kosher home. Born an observant Jew. Died an observant Jew.
Always so beautiful voice of great Mr. Schwartz ( the lady herself is sadly out of tune at many times) but truly this is not appropriate. Not the place, not the time. For a concert yes. For a time of prayer and humility, nope.
A prayer for peace is never out of place. If adapting a popular song this way, makes more people think about peace and draws any of them closer to God, then why isn't that a good thing? I'm a Catholic, but I enjoyed this very much.
macmancapecod Agreed. You miss the point if you think this out of place. The fault lies in that perspective, not in the beautiful musical performance of Peace and Love
לפי התפיסה האורתודוקסית כן, מצד שני כשמבינים שהתנך נכתב ע"י בני האדם , (בוודאות של %💯 ...ואין שיפוט אלוהי, אז פחות משנה לי.. ישבתי עם דתיים הכי חכמים בישראל והם לא הצליחו להוכיח לי שהתורה נכתבה עי אלוהים. יצא לי לגרום לאדם כמעט להוריד כיפה מרוב שנגנב ממה שהראיתי לו, הוא פשוט עדיין מפחד מהמשפחה שלו אז משאיר אותה.
@@AlphaImpact מבחינתי זה לא משו שאתה אמור להיות גאה בוא בכלל.. דבר שני זה ממש לא קשור למי כתב את התורה בכלל אני מציבה פה עובדה שככה לא אמור להראות בית כנסת .. ושזה פשוט נוראי שגויים יראו את זה ויחשבו שככה ניראה העם היהודי .. שזה ממש לא אמור להיות ככה ..
Shaina G that’s such a helpful comment! I’m reminded of my grandmother’s advice: “if you don’t have anything nice to say, then don’t say anything at all.”
When it’s safe (post Covid) to fly to NYC, I’ll come to Park Synagogue to hear you. Inspirational!
Beautiful voices together!! Shalom.
wonderful voices these two. Thank you, it's so great that you put them on youtube giving we folk in far flung places the opportunity to enjoy this beautiful music. Blessings
I love it !!! Shabbat Shalom , it make me feel that I can touch the heaven
I think it was the Baal Shem Tov who said that when a popular song is used for a prayer the song has been sanctified. Could there be a more glorious example of that than Cantor Brook's take on Shallow?
It's like a good song finally became the miracle it was meant to be all along. Thank you so much, Cantors Brook and Schwartz!
Wunderbar❤❤❤❤❤
This is lovely. Our congregation adopted this in recent services and it was beautiful and well received. My only complaint? It gets stuck in my head all week 😂. If that is the worst of my problems, I am very blessed.
Beautiful voice, love hearing you from Oregon.
Shalom, thanks for the beautiful song. May Hashem make his presence enlighten you and grant you grace.
Shalom!!!! Many thanks! Very beautiful song. From Rio de Janeiro - Brasil❤❤❤
This is absolutely beautiful!
Love the intersection of sacred and popular. ❤️
Your music is so inspiring. Keep up with the wonderful work.
Shalom aleichem! What a beautiful arrangement!! Thank you.
Shalom Azi, thanks for the beautiful song
Thank you Cantor Schwartz & Park Avenue Synagogue for the beautiful music ... Keep up the great work!
Without bothering to google it, is this a Reform Shul? They are wearing tallis and yamukahs (many Reformed synagogues I attended did not).
WOW, I don’t normally like “new” versions of our sacred music, but this is pretty great!
Steven S conservative
Im shaking under her annointed voice...
Wow! This is beautiful.
Wow, this is beautiful! My daughter and her family just joined this temple. I can’t wait to hear both of you in person!!
So so so so beautiful ...we loge you in England Avi
Love..
I love this so much
I never get tired of this arrangement
Wow! Amazing!
Mesmerizing
Vraiment très beau ❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤Michèle from France
Sehr schön! Danke!
I’d like to see Cantor Swartz some day in person
wonderfull...
Shalom!
❤ Blesses my Soul 🎉
WOWWWWW!!!
SHALOM ALEIJEM.AMÉN
Azi, can you share the score to this and the adon Olam you did a few weeks ago? Our Congregation would love for or\ur Rabbi Mark Solomon to sing these.
Wonderful
The probem here is the lady Spoils a brilliant Azi.
On your own please Azi or with Naftali
Amen
❤😂🎉🌐👍👍👍 sa
EL MISMO CREADO EN ELLA SEA DE ELLA EL CIELO..COMO EL MISMO DE MADRE A TODA LA TIERRA...LA OBRA..DE AQUELLOS EN ELLAS..UN DUO..MADRE E HIJO..
AaaaaaaaaMe'e'e'e'e'eE'e'e'e'e'N
AAAAAAAAAME'E'E'E'E'EE'E'E'E'E'N
AaaaaaaaaaMe'e'e'e'e'e'eE'e'e'e'N
Am Yisrael Chai 🕎
Can someone post a translation of the lyrics, please? Toda raba.
Peace will come upon us
Peace will come upon us
Peace will come upon us
and on everyone.
Salaam ('peace' in Arabic)
On us and on everyone
Salaam, Salaam
@@DavidPNeff this is not the correct translation. You posted a translation of an Israeli popular song by Mosh Ben Ari. And they on the other hand sang a combination of it with a song by Yigal Bashan that is based on different prayers. The translation for the second song is:
He who makes peace in His high places
May He bring peace upon us
And upon all Israel
And say Amen.
May He bring peace, may He bring peace
Peace upon us and on all of Israel
May He bring peace, may He bring peace
Peace upon us and on all of Israel.
What they sing is something that based on both of them
It sounds like they mixed two songs together - 2. Ose Shalom ('make' Peace) (www.hebrewsongs.com/?song=osehshalom ) and 1. "Od yavo' shalom aleinu" peace will come onto us www.hebrewsongs.com/song-salaam.htm )... I put the links to the song translations/transliterations in parenthesis.. so the song goes something like this:
1 .Od yavo' shalom Peace will come
Od yavo' shalom aleinu Peace will come onto us
Od yavo' shalom Peace will come
Od yavo' shalom aleinu Peace will come onto us
Shalom aleinu Peace on Us
V'al kol Yisrael and all Israel (Israel refers to the children of Israel)
V'imru: (And we say)
V'imru: amen. (and we say: Amen)
2 Oseh shalom bimromav ((he who) makes peace from above)
Hu ya'aseh shalom aleinu he will make peace onto us
V'al kol Yisrael (and on all of Israel)
V'imru: amen. (and we say: Amen)
Tov meod!!
Its the kol Isha and shomer nagia for me
My call to return
Isn’t this from A Star Is Born? Lady Gaga?
ברוך ה'
Much better than lady gaga. I mean hers was good, but Hebrew is is like the tongue of angels
Poderiam disponibilizar a letra da canção?
This is Reform Judaism?
@@SeanMilford wow, really? I didn't know they did this kind of thing anywhere but reform. When I was a child, conservative congregations were very strict. How nice ☺
@@barbarahumphreys4887 I think times have changed. TheReform is more reformed and the Conservative synagogues are more Reformed... read that as further away from Observing Jewish Laws.As much as I enjoyed this music, there is no way I can get comfortable with going to Synagogue on a Shabbos and people are playing instruments or setting prayer to secular/movie music. Just my opinion.
Conservative Judaism.
Reform they'd be singing in English eating cheeseburgers while driving to a Christmas party on Shabbat.... This is Conservative.
ScreamToASigh I just died 😂😂
Yeshua is blessed!
While, yes, this presentation does seem a lot like that of a church, it isn't that of a church. The simple prayers are from Jewish canon and are to the one and only God, who always was and always will be invisible and indivisible. Jesus seems to have been one of many Jewish teachers of his day. Raised in a kosher home. Born an observant Jew. Died an observant Jew.
Melody Lady gaga ???? 🤦🏼♀️
Always so beautiful voice of great Mr. Schwartz ( the lady herself is sadly out of tune at many times) but truly this is not appropriate. Not the place, not the time. For a concert yes. For a time of prayer and humility, nope.
You may be right in a way, but the Hebrew lyric was meant to adapt to any tune. So really, it could work either way.
3337 Facebook shares say it's worthwhile.
Please
A prayer for peace is never out of place. If adapting a popular song this way, makes more people think about peace and draws any of them closer to God, then why isn't that a good thing? I'm a Catholic, but I enjoyed this very much.
macmancapecod Agreed. You miss the point if you think this out of place. The fault lies in that perspective, not in the beautiful musical performance of Peace and Love
Black Korean comedian
זה בית כנסת? בושה!
בתור חילוני תל אביבי שמכיר לעומק את חוקי התורה, אין הלכה נגד שירת נשים, אלה זה סוגיה שרבנים לקחו אותה, ועל הדרך לקחו בעלות על אלוהים.
@@AlphaImpact אני לא מדברת על שירת הנשים אני בעצמי שרה מול גברים זה הבעיה שהבית כנסת עצמו ניראה ומתנהל כמו כנסיה של גויים וזה חילול ה לכל דבר
לפי התפיסה האורתודוקסית כן, מצד שני כשמבינים שהתנך נכתב ע"י בני האדם , (בוודאות של %💯 ...ואין שיפוט אלוהי, אז פחות משנה לי.. ישבתי עם דתיים הכי חכמים בישראל והם לא הצליחו להוכיח לי שהתורה נכתבה עי אלוהים. יצא לי לגרום לאדם כמעט להוריד כיפה מרוב שנגנב ממה שהראיתי לו, הוא פשוט עדיין מפחד מהמשפחה שלו אז משאיר אותה.
@@AlphaImpact מבחינתי זה לא משו שאתה אמור להיות גאה בוא בכלל.. דבר שני זה ממש לא קשור למי כתב את התורה בכלל אני מציבה פה עובדה שככה לא אמור להראות בית כנסת .. ושזה פשוט נוראי שגויים יראו את זה ויחשבו שככה ניראה העם היהודי .. שזה ממש לא אמור להיות ככה ..
@@AlphaImpact ומזה תפיסה האורתודוקסית??!! יש דרך אחת ויחידה .. המטרה היא לעשות ולנסות את כל מצוות ה' לא לשנות אותם כדי שלך יהיה נוח.
Reform and conservatives ppl caused the shoah....reshaim
Lol reform is so stuffed up. And not jewish
Shaina G that’s such a helpful comment! I’m reminded of my grandmother’s advice: “if you don’t have anything nice to say, then don’t say anything at all.”
Angela Hoffberg thanks Angela. Your response is equally obnoxious and just about as uninformative as the original useless comment.