I have never clicked on anything so fast in my life. Trent Reznor is my favorite composer and you have perfectly captured the feeling of this song in your performance.
Breeze still carries the sound Maybe I'll disappear Tracks will fade in the snow You won't find me here Ice is starting to form Ending what had begun I am locked in my head With what I've done I know you tried to rescue me Didn't let anyone get in Left with a trace of all that was And all that could have been Please, take this And run far away, far away from me I am tainted The two of us were never meant to be All these pieces and promises and left behinds If only I could see In my nothing You meant everything, everything to me Gone Fading Everything And All that Could have been Could have been Please, take this And run far away, far as you can see I am tainted And happiness and peace of mind Were never meant for me All these pieces and promises and left behinds If only I could see In my nothing You meant everything, everything to me
yes, we're all thankful for this beautiful exercise in uselessness: apparently the fact that this is an instrumental version puzzled you. however, since this is not karaoke, next time you feel like sharing choose silence instead. would be greatly appreciated.
@@frenschDensch if anyone wanted the lyric Google would have been the go to site. Instrumental means without words. Dont pollute the experience with your needs, kid
@@pedropereiraneto any help comes to late for you. Just let it be. You see the likes his comment got? And the amount of people who did like your angry and unnecessary harsh view on posting lyrics to an instrumental Version of a Song? There are none, maybe because of your way to communicate your opinion, now you even attack me. Just wow.
@@frenschDensch your remarks are as useless and unwelcome as the lyric you pushed. While commenting is possible, you should really think before you share and make sure it is necessary. In this case, it is not. And the likes are for the artist, not for the tool pasting his lyric.
There was a time where I couldn’t hear it, got an accident, almost lost my leg and got bedridden 1 year, and broke a 12 year relation. But now it’s one of the most enjoyable songs
Vika!! You are a true gift to this world. For over a decade, I have been blown away by your immense talent and ability to capture the emotion and essence of songs performed by 3+ piece performance groups. At times, I’ve sworn I could hear the lyrics being sung as you’ve played… That’s how true your transpositions are to the original. It blows my mind. I’ve seen your other videos for this particular song, but I am in total awe with this one. Yes, this is a beautiful and unimaginable unicorn of a piano, but I think the real magic is in you… it seems more impromptu, less rehearsed and edited, and the result is a performance version that’s raw and surrendering. Are you even reading sheet music, or just allowing your hands take over? Either way, you produce beauty and make it look effortless. I have been watching your tours, and only hope one day I may have the opportunity to see you in Canada.
@@vkgoeswildofficial you’re most welcome! Your level of talent should be recognized and congratulated - I can’t fathom how many (possibly thousands of) practice hours have been devoted to this! Im grateful to have discovered your videos. 💗
This is incredible, you are one of the most emotive players I've heard and it comes across so well in the beautiful music. Thank you for all you've performed so far. (Plus that piano sounds gorgeous).
I'm learning piano and a big fan of this song. Thank you very much. Edit: I've been listening to this video on loop for most of the evening and went through some of your other videos. It amazes me how strong and deeply emotional you play and how fast your music helped me process some inner emotions of my own. Thank you you are amazing. I am a new fan
Back in 2011 I began a really important relationship in my life, it was also when I listened to this song for the first time. I had this eerie feeling that it was a song from my future, and that it was tied to that newly formed relationship. In 2017 I realized I would never be able to speak to that loved one ever again, and the song playing right then and there was "And All That Could Have Been". The cycle was sealed. All these pieces and promises and left-behinds
I know this song..I know every single note every beat and you just brought me to tears. That has never happened before without lyrics, you are so talented! So beautifully executed, thank you for sharing!
My God, this serie of french recordings is just amazing ! I wasn't expected this song at all, and in fact I thought that it was a new NIN's song when I saw the notification. But this song and the interpretation are so beautiful that I think it is more enjoyable than a new release. As an huge Reznor's fan, I have just two things to say : "wow !" and "thank you !"
With NIN finally performing the song live, i wanted to revisit your performance only to find that you made another version! I love your work. You're incredible.
This is one of my favorite NIN songs, and I still get chills when I hear it, but you just put a whole new level of emotion into this. and i dont have the words to thank you. It's beautiful. I'm crying.
This so beautiful. I've always had a deep connection with anything that Reznor writes. This piece overflows with emotions that it's hard to put into words.
You are a phenomenal piano musician. I wish I could do this kind of thing. Trent Reznor is definitely one of the most talented composers out there and you have captured the soul of what this music is meant to drive in it's delivery. Bravo. I am sure that Trent would love your execution of this if he ever got the chance to see this. Keep up your incredible work. I love your translations and they bring a new light and complexity to the soul of songs that are masterful or have the potential to be more when they become piano language. It is truly fascinating.
I can feel this through my whole body. What if.. Trent and Vika collaborated? Take my soul to other places. Love all of this.. every note, Trent’s voice in the shadows.. every rocking move that Vika does. Art in its finest 🥰 please make babies!! 🥲😁😘😭😊
Tell me do you ever get shaky when you come down from a climax to a very calm breakdown like “we’re in this together” or the end of this song because it is the most beautiful discomfort I have ever felt playing the piano or listing to you. Simply blown away by your talent and work. Thank you and I hope you consider playing for Colorado or any of the states.
This is just ridiculously amazing. I can proudly say this is the first time a piano arrangement has brought me to tears. The only thing I can compare it to is Johnny Cash's rendition of Hurt. Quite possibly better in it's own way, yet still a tribute to one of the greatest composers of our time.
$250,000.00 Piano, Bosendorfer is my personal favorite, I hope one day my piano skill will be good enough to be worthy of playing on such an instrument. Maybe at that time I might be able to afford one...
As others have said, this is stunning. Would you please cover La Mer? There only seem to be a couple of it on here, and it translates pretty well I think.
Are you OK? I just saw your channel name mentioned on Reddit in regards to Ukraine, and I of course recognized the username from your lovely cover of my favorite NIN song. Hope all is well for you and your loved ones.
Excellent! I take it this was multitracked? I'm trying to learn the first 2 bars for the first verse for a cover. not worked it out yet. then I see you playing the vocal parts aswell over it on the 3rd bar but I dont need that. this is so good!
I have never clicked on anything so fast in my life. Trent Reznor is my favorite composer and you have perfectly captured the feeling of this song in your performance.
and 2nd place is Maynard James Keenan, and the new third is Vika :D
They are both 1st
Well said sir!! Well said
An underrated gem. Probably in my top 5 favorite NIN songs.
Breeze still carries the sound
Maybe I'll disappear
Tracks will fade in the snow
You won't find me here
Ice is starting to form
Ending what had begun
I am locked in my head
With what I've done
I know you tried to rescue me
Didn't let anyone get in
Left with a trace of all that was
And all that could have been
Please, take this
And run far away, far away from me
I am tainted
The two of us were never meant to be
All these pieces and promises and left behinds
If only I could see
In my nothing
You meant everything, everything to me
Gone
Fading
Everything
And
All that
Could have been
Could have been
Please, take this
And run far away, far as you can see
I am tainted
And happiness and peace of mind
Were never meant for me
All these pieces and promises and left behinds
If only I could see
In my nothing
You meant everything, everything to me
yes, we're all thankful for this beautiful exercise in uselessness: apparently the fact that this is an instrumental version puzzled you. however, since this is not karaoke, next time you feel like sharing choose silence instead. would be greatly appreciated.
@@pedropereiraneto you talk for yourself. How dare you? Next time YOU choose to share, keep silent.
@@frenschDensch if anyone wanted the lyric Google would have been the go to site. Instrumental means without words. Dont pollute the experience with your needs, kid
@@pedropereiraneto any help comes to late for you. Just let it be. You see the likes his comment got? And the amount of people who did like your angry and unnecessary harsh view on posting lyrics to an instrumental Version of a Song? There are none, maybe because of your way to communicate your opinion, now you even attack me. Just wow.
@@frenschDensch your remarks are as useless and unwelcome as the lyric you pushed. While commenting is possible, you should really think before you share and make sure it is necessary. In this case, it is not. And the likes are for the artist, not for the tool pasting his lyric.
Trent would be proud :)
This song really spoke to me once, and hearing it today freaks me out. I think i suffered from depression for quite a while.
There was a time where I couldn’t hear it, got an accident, almost lost my leg and got bedridden 1 year, and broke a 12 year relation. But now it’s one of the most enjoyable songs
Vika!! You are a true gift to this world. For over a decade, I have been blown away by your immense talent and ability to capture the emotion and essence of songs performed by 3+ piece performance groups. At times, I’ve sworn I could hear the lyrics being sung as you’ve played… That’s how true your transpositions are to the original. It blows my mind. I’ve seen your other videos for this particular song, but I am in total awe with this one. Yes, this is a beautiful and unimaginable unicorn of a piano, but I think the real magic is in you… it seems more impromptu, less rehearsed and edited, and the result is a performance version that’s raw and surrendering. Are you even reading sheet music, or just allowing your hands take over? Either way, you produce beauty and make it look effortless. I have been watching your tours, and only hope one day I may have the opportunity to see you in Canada.
Thank you very much.
@@vkgoeswildofficial you’re most welcome! Your level of talent should be recognized and congratulated - I can’t fathom how many (possibly thousands of) practice hours have been devoted to this! Im grateful to have discovered your videos. 💗
That rug really ties the room together
Fuckin A
Donny, please.
That's just like, your opinion, man
They pee'd on your fuckin' rug...
The carpet pissers pee’d on your fucking rug
This is incredible, you are one of the most emotive players I've heard and it comes across so well in the beautiful music. Thank you for all you've performed so far. (Plus that piano sounds gorgeous).
I can't stress enough how much i love this song and how terrific you've always performed it.
I completely forgot i already commented on this two years ago.
Thank you for such a beautiful cover. It's one of the greatest NIN songs.
This completely broke me. I can't describe how sad yet incredibly beautiful this is.
Just wanted to say that this song is what got me into Nine Inch Nails! Love all your music man!
I'm learning piano and a big fan of this song. Thank you very much.
Edit: I've been listening to this video on loop for most of the evening and went through some of your other videos. It amazes me how strong and deeply emotional you play and how fast your music helped me process some inner emotions of my own. Thank you you are amazing. I am a new fan
Back in 2011 I began a really important relationship in my life, it was also when I listened to this song for the first time. I had this eerie feeling that it was a song from my future, and that it was tied to that newly formed relationship.
In 2017 I realized I would never be able to speak to that loved one ever again, and the song playing right then and there was "And All That Could Have Been". The cycle was sealed.
All these pieces and promises and left-behinds
That Grand piano captures those super low notes so well. This song wouldn't sound nearly as good with an upright.
I know this song..I know every single note every beat and you just brought me to tears. That has never happened before without lyrics, you are so talented! So beautifully executed, thank you for sharing!
Thank you !
My God, this serie of french recordings is just amazing ! I wasn't expected this song at all, and in fact I thought that it was a new NIN's song when I saw the notification. But this song and the interpretation are so beautiful that I think it is more enjoyable than a new release. As an huge Reznor's fan, I have just two things to say : "wow !" and "thank you !"
Absolutely incredible! You really captured the pure emotion of this beautiful song. Bravo!
Beautiful and played on a Bosendorfer no less. Always wanted to play on one of those. Wish I could be there in person to hear.
I was here during this recording session and it was unforgettable.
MAYBE THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST SONGS IN HISTORY AND YOU MADE A BEAUTIFUL GREAT TRIBUTE.
Thankyou so much this is my favourite NIN song by far and a beautiful cover!
The sound of the piano is so beautiful, it fits perfect with the song .
a heart-breakingly beautiful cover... made my cry and think of all that could have been, just like the original does, every time... every single time.
Amazing! One of the lesser known NIN masterpieces, and you played it beautifully ❤
With NIN finally performing the song live, i wanted to revisit your performance only to find that you made another version! I love your work. You're incredible.
My hearts melting thank you for this.
This is one of my favorite NIN songs, and I still get chills when I hear it, but you just put a whole new level of emotion into this. and i dont have the words to thank you. It's beautiful. I'm crying.
So beautiful. So well captured the feeling of the song.
what so beautiful, amazing performance! Thank you!
Amazing version ,truly loved it.
You cover all my favorite songs. Been watching you for years and will watch many more. Thank you so much you are an inspiration!
Another amazing interpretation/composition/performance of an amazing composer/musician perfectly illustrating the power of music.
Thank you very much
incredible arrangement, wow.
This so beautiful. I've always had a deep connection with anything that Reznor writes. This piece overflows with emotions that it's hard to put into words.
So powerful. Brings up lots of emotions.
it's amazing, I have never heard more beautiful interpretation of this song!
Good God.... Those bass notes are haunting. Forgot how much I loved this album.
Excellent!
And it was my life that was built upon this Melody.
Thank you so much for this. I have tears running down my cheeks
You are a phenomenal piano musician. I wish I could do this kind of thing. Trent Reznor is definitely one of the most talented composers out there and you have captured the soul of what this music is meant to drive in it's delivery. Bravo. I am sure that Trent would love your execution of this if he ever got the chance to see this.
Keep up your incredible work. I love your translations and they bring a new light and complexity to the soul of songs that are masterful or have the potential to be more when they become piano language. It is truly fascinating.
Mother of god this is good. One of Trent’s best - played superbly by a wonderful piano player! Bravo!
I can feel this through my whole body. What if.. Trent and Vika collaborated? Take my soul to other places. Love all of this.. every note, Trent’s voice in the shadows.. every rocking move that Vika does. Art in its finest 🥰 please make babies!! 🥲😁😘😭😊
One of my Favorite terribly sad songs. You did it very well VR. thumbs up for sure watch till the end most certainly.
No words. This is amazing
Incredible.
I can't believe what I'm hearing. You have so much soul
This gave me goosebumps! 🖤
this is so good
OMG THANK YOU VIKA! This is my favorite song from Nine Inch Nails and finally can hear a piano cover. :D
Спасибо огромное за это видео.Каждый раз меня пробирает до самых костей.
Stunning performance, you are incredibly talented.
I'm speechless... wow!
I just saw him here in Portland tonight. It was to finally see with next to Atticus Ross as well. The did a great rendition of “La Mer”.
Lovely!
Absolutely incredible!
you made that piano very happy,,, it was made for that song,,,, sooo deep and rich wow
your music heals my soul. Thank you! :*
I've been listening to tour poop for a while now. I love it
Very Good. A great pianist.
Love it! really captures the song
Beautiful.
Tell me do you ever get shaky when you come down from a climax to a very calm breakdown like “we’re in this together” or the end of this song because it is the most beautiful discomfort I have ever felt playing the piano or listing to you. Simply blown away by your talent and work. Thank you and I hope you consider playing for Colorado or any of the states.
Beyond astonishing!
This is just ridiculously amazing. I can proudly say this is the first time a piano arrangement has brought me to tears. The only thing I can compare it to is Johnny Cash's rendition of Hurt. Quite possibly better in it's own way, yet still a tribute to one of the greatest composers of our time.
Love this
Amazing! If you could play Silhouette by Opeth with this setup it would be awesome.
I think I’ve watched this over 100 times now. You are amazing! And so is Trent Reznor :-)
Well this turned lit.
Oh my!
He played this song live recently
Just wow
Soon as I saw the notification, the song already started playing in my head before I even clicked
Yup! Vocals and all! One of my all time favorites
i've fucken fallen in love with you you're so inspiring thanks for sharing your work ❣️😱
You're all I need to hear
Mam!! You are beyond the human ear. Love you!!!!
excellent
WOW!!!!
LIKE LIKE LIKE LIKE LIKE!!!! AWESOME!
This is awesome
$250,000.00 Piano, Bosendorfer is my personal favorite, I hope one day my piano skill will be good enough to be worthy of playing on such an instrument. Maybe at that time I might be able to afford one...
very NICE.
Это прекрасно!!!
I love you because you do this.
I love this song so much... Could u make a new video playing it? ❤
Шикарно!
Vika, you recorded so many pieces at this piano that you can do a cd..... Can you? :-)
I really don’t care but you made a grown man cry I 🖤 you
As others have said, this is stunning. Would you please cover La Mer? There only seem to be a couple of it on here, and it translates pretty well I think.
Thank you.
I love this song, I actually used to listen to a reversed version (lyrics n everything) but I can't find it anymore (it was here on YT)
Bravo! 💘 😊
Oooh a grand 🎹, sweet
thank you.
Yes.
👌
Eeeeeeending what had begun
Are you OK? I just saw your channel name mentioned on Reddit in regards to Ukraine, and I of course recognized the username from your lovely cover of my favorite NIN song. Hope all is well for you and your loved ones.
Excellent! I take it this was multitracked? I'm trying to learn the first 2 bars for the first verse for a cover. not worked it out yet. then I see you playing the vocal parts aswell over it on the 3rd bar but I dont need that. this is so good!
Hey, you're right! All of that *could* be played on Bösendorfer Imperial! ;P