@@smbledsoe21 yeh but the what made the show good to watch was the cast sorry to say but without Nathan haley Lucas this won't even work , it will fall flat literally on the pilot episode.
You can't have a good story without Lucas, Nathan, and Haley. They'll chop the story and make it look like Lucas is a jerk like Dan. Hilary's character raising a kid alone? Yeah, right.
Recently I went back and binge watched OTH. I completely forgot about Jake! I always rooted for Peyton and Lucas. But I’m totally a Jake and Peyton, they were a great couple with an unfinished storyline. So I’m really hoping for a Jake and Peyton reunion ❤🤞
I have no idea how you could do OTH without both Scott Brothers, BUT I do know this will center around some teenagers of Tree Hill also, so this could be the kids going through some of the same things and having the original OTH stars show them how to get through it
They can totally make a plausible plot Lucas dies from heart failure, Brooke is divorced and they can bring peyton back to tree hill to mourn lucas and reconnect with brooke
I hate to say this, but if the original cast doesn’t come back (Bethany, James, and Chad) then it’s not gonna be One Tree Hill. They ended the show the best way possible. To bring it back means having to change their endings and breaking the fans hearts if they kill off characters or divorced characters.
I know Sophia is the busiest, seeing she’s a lead on another show but if she can comeback then the others would too. Chad doesn’t have much going on these days and past interviews he never said no. A lot of these people don’t have any major jobs happening besides Sophia
@@thatgirl9532 what show is she a lead on? That woman isn't filming anything and is beyond jobless. Bethany has other projects, James has his own independent show, and Chad isn't returning if Sophia is the executive producer spear heading this whole thing.
I'm sorry but if no Lucas and Haley then there's no point. And Nathan was no better lol he was with Peyton Haley and Brooke. And slept with Haley's sister. And tried to hide the fact that he let the nanny come onto him from Haley.
If Lucas isn’t in it, or Nathan and Haley, I’m not watching! The show was about the Scott brothers - you cannot do the show without them! I don’t want a show about Brooke & Peyton. I hated Peyton. The show was never about them. I’m at peace with how their characters ended up, leave it alone!
If Lucas, Nathan, and Haley aren't on the show, then Hilary and Sophie might as well just star in a new show together where they're single moms raising their kids. There's no point in calling this One Tree Hill. Cause there's no OTH without at least 2 or 3 people listed. An OTH show characters like Jake and Rachel and Julian is barely OTH. They were side characters for a reason. Huge PASS if it's only Peyton and Brooke. Peyton wasn't even a good friend to Brooke. And they better not TOUCH NALEY
Everyone has their own interpretations as to what this show meant to them. But for me there were 4 things that defined OTH: 1) Nathan and Lucas finding their way to each other and their eventual bond in spite of Dan. 2) Naley. They were the long-standing core relationship of the show which helped to set OTH apart from all the other teen drama's EVER because of their consistency. Those 2 were solid. 3) Keith's awful death and the aftermath. Does anyone not remember the frenzy and the CW website crashing after Dan shot Keith?! And of course 4) basketball. The heart of OTH to me were the first 6 seasons. After Lucas left and even afterwards when even Nathan was featured less it felt like the show was scrambling to find its way. The one thing that made the latter seasons after 6 tolerable was the fantastic additions of Clay and Quinn (and again both had ties to Naley). The Scott/James/Roe/Lee family to me was the original foundation of the show. Without them this new reboot just feels weird. They were the center of the show -- all the other characters branched off of them (that included Peyton and Brooke). And as BFF as Sophia and Hilarie claim Peyton and Brooke were -- Lucas and Haley's friendship was superior. They were family before she ever married Nathan and they remained that way through it all. It was also so refreshing to see a guy and girl just be friends and stay that way throughout the shows entirety. And I'm sorry but I just can't picture a show where Lucas wouldn't be living near his kid if he and Peyton are separated or atleast not even checking in on her?! Not after what Dan put him through! And Sullivan's Crossing isn't even an excuse. Morgan Kohan is reprising her role as leading lady on When Hope Calls for season 2. Both SC and WHC are on two different networks. I will still watch this weird reboot -- but only in the way you would slow down when you pass by a car accident. It's clear Sophia's history with both Chad and James is why they weren't invited back - which is such a bizarre statement in and of itself. How are the 2 core actors of which the show was based on not at the helm of this? And a book cannot be the only reason Hilarie is icing out Joy. Maybe the fact that Joy is thriving at Hallmark has something to do with it. Maybe we can get 2 versions of the reboot. Sophia&Hilarie's. And Chad/James/Joy's. But of course the latter's would have to be set in Tree Hill. Sophia and Hilarie's can take place in LA. They can call it Brah's Over Bro's. But quite frankly since they both want to act together again so bad they should just create an entirely new show about 2 single mothers since the vision they seem to be painting for this revival feels like a gaslit version of OTH thrusted on the viewers.
I think if Chad doesn’t return or Julian I could see Lucas being dead bc they did originally have some arc planned for season 7 for Lucas’s heart before Hilarie left a similar storyline where Dan basically takes over Keith’s role helping Peyton and Sawyer through this era and that’s the reason Paul who plays Dan extended his contract for another season he wanted to see Dans redemption arc come full circle. I could see Julian and Brooke being divorced maybe Julian’s in LA a lot doing movies leaving Brooke divorced. I could see Peyton and Jake having another chance if Brian returns and I’d be game for that.
When broadcasted in France, "One Tree Hill" was titled "Les Frères Scott", which means "The Scott Brothers". So bringing back OTH without "les frères Scott" would be weirder than weird...
I 1000% agree that we have already watched their stories and said goodbye to these characters! I would’ve preferred a more 90210 reboot style, we could’ve gotten completely new characters and guest stars from our favorites
You can’t have OTH without Nathan and Haley. IMO Hillary doesn’t like you to have different opinions than her. Sophia at least tries to listen. James won’t do the show if Joy doesn’t
He has a movie with Lindsay Lohan and Jamie Lee Curtis coming out as well but if Sophia is very busy as well… and if Brooke can come back then Lucas can come back too!
that was the most long winded roundabout way of saying BJL is apparently right wing and not LGBTQ friendly, and Sophia and Hilary are as woke left as they come and therefore they clash. BJL being anti gay obvi clashes with Sophia. People think BJL book cover copied Hilaries (if BJL even had a say in the cover, often authors dont). Also, I think Hillaries sub-tweet RE book was petty and passive aggressive. sub-tweeting post teenage years is a bit off....
These girls spent 12 minutes beating around the bush. Just call it what it is, Bethany and the rest of the cast dont want to be a part of another leftist woke reboot. And lets be clear, with Sofia and Hilarie running the show, thats exactly what its going to be.
Sophia and Hillarie will make this spin off as a propaganda of their silly activism instead of good stories. Hillarie could be as annoying as Payton. No Scotts/Haley will make this useless. A reboot with showing more about the group in 80s (before they became parents, Dan, Keith, Karen) would be better.
Don’t call it one tree hill if the main characters don’t come back, if Brooke and Peyton wanna do a show together fine but don’t call it one tree hill, I absolutely love that show it won’t be the same without the rest of the main cast
I would call it a spinoff. Not reboot. And is totally doable. If well written. Of course Brooke and Peyton will be there, and im expecting Julian. Because they cannot break up all the couples, and I imagine Chad won’t be there. James already said a few years ago that he was done with that and wanted to move on, for ao sure he won’t be in. And Bethany Joy won’t be there too, because of hilaries and her fallout. So I think it works. Because no one wanted Haley without Nathan. Greys did a wonderful with private practice. So I would imagine if this takes place in other city than Tree Hill, but that doesn’t seem the case. And for me it will make hard to explain why some characters won’t be there
This reebot doesn't interest me, and it makes me sad as a long time OTH fan. The brothers the show was surrounded around isn't gonna be there, and none of the staple couples the fans loved are seemingly there either. Sure, it could end up being a show for some to enjoy on it's own, but it won't be OTH to me so I'm not really planning on watching.
OTH is also one of my all time favorite shows and I don’t think they should do a reboot. I’m not super on board with any reboot of a good original tv show or movie, but especially One Tree Hill. It’s too special, too good just the way it is. A reboot won’t ever feel the same, and in order to continue to tell compelling stories, they will have to adjust storylines and details that made OTH what it was. I can understand them wanting to come back together, but a reboot is a terrible idea. Also, I am so team Leyton lol
What’s the point of doing a reboot of OTH if the original cast isn’t going to be part of it? How does that honor the fans? To me, it’s a dishonor lol OTH, while it was about more than just the Scott brothers, was still very much a show because of the Scott brothers. CMM, James, and Bethany need to be part of it if it’s going to be a real reboot. Otherwise, Sophia, Hilarie, Daneel, and Bevin should just create an entire new show altogether with no relation to OTH. Fans of those actors would probably watch regardless.
I’ll never watch that reboot with no Lucas it’s stupid especially if they give Peyton another love interest after working that hard to get Peyton and Lucas together it’ll ruin the original show
Honestly I'd rather they just do a new story with completely new characters just set in OTH with the same vibe. And the og cast can make occasional cameos.
Lucius has a heart condition kill switch written into his character so that’s his future in this, I watch for Haley and Nathan so without them, and James has said he won’t do it without Beth and mess up their ending, I’m not interested. No 15 - 20 year later reboot is that good, just make a new show please
I hate this painting of Joy as the bad guy. Without evidence of a fake insta with anti LGBTGIA+ posts it’s a really unfair and damaging rumour to spread. Clearly their presence and support for eachother on social media is not as abundant as it was when they first started, or pre the podcast. But don’t plant the roots of turning commentary around Joh into an Allison Mack smallville situation
I can understand why chad doesn't wanna do it. He's filming Sullivan's Crossing probably 4-5 months out of the year in Canada. When would he have time to film OTH Sequel and still have family time and dad time and etc. I love Hilarie to death (never been a fan of sophia really) but those 2 think they can do a sequel to honor the fans and etc. and can't get James or Chad or Joy to do the show? They are out of their fucking minds.....nobody will watch it (more fans will be pissed off than anything else). They should have gotten everyone on board with doing it before anything ever got leaked out.
Sullivan's Crossing main character played by Morgan Kohan will be returning to When Hope Calls for season 2. She is leading lady on both shows. Sullivan's Crossing has no more than 13 episodes a season. Its mid season. Sadly its clear Chad wasn't invited back.
I love hilarie and Sophia but the show does not need to come back. It had 9 seasons (which most teen shows don’t get) and everyone wrapped up nicely. We don’t need that.
Yeah, I'm not sure how this would work tbh without everyone, especially given how popular Naley was throughout the show's run. I'd miss James much more than Chad but think we need at least one Scott brother, even as a cameo. I think the only reason I would watch is if I got the Jeyton endgame we all deserved lol.
Honestly Hilary could kill off Lucas and wind up with that other guy who had the baby. Nathan may not be able to come back either because he often directs one show and is currently on another on Hulu
WTF is this?! Sophia and Austin Nichols were just together at an OTH event, taking photos and being playful calling him her "TV husband". There's no issue there. Just because their podcast is called "Drama queens" doesn't mean you have to feed into stories. And the who doesn't know how to pronounce "Daneel"?! And she says OTH is her all time favorite show? Laughable.
Not without Peyton and Luke ❤❤❤ wannaa prove ? OTH for lots if not almost all ended by season 6 , should have refered to where they went and should have at least brought them for the finale
I never thought we would get a reboot or movie s i'm seated and excited for whatever is created. And story wise my mind and heart is open. The joy book drama was not a turn i expected because i loved the bond between the three of them.
@@wildcatblue13still having her twins though. I don’t care for the guy that Brooke married. I believe that she didn’t end up with Lucas because of Sophia & Chad’s marriage ending in real life.
If Sophia Bush and Hilarie Burton are hell bent in making the One Tree Hill reboot a "feminist reclamation" of the series, then it won't work. One Tree Hill at its core was so much more. Everyday life, struggles, character growth, forgiveness, parenting, etc. There is a reason why Brooke was one of the best characters in One Tree Hill because of her progression from Season 1 where she was a self-centered high school kid to being one of the most selfless and responsible human beings in the show. It was not perfect but the development was relatable. I think Sophia and Hilarie are so hell bent to take the show away from Mark Schwahn (and he is a scumbag), but they are kind of missing what made One Tree Hill great. And there is no point in bringing the show back if the are not bringing the "Core 5" characters back. And also remember characters like Dan and Keith are dead. Karen and Deb are probably not coming back. Will we see Quinn and Clay? What about Mouth and Millie as Lisa Goldstein who played Millie has quit acting. Jackson Brundage who played Jamie Scott has quit acting as well. So I dont know how this work.
I thought it was odd that Lisa Goldstein was not mentioned in this re-boot now that makes sense Iwould have loved Brooke to revive Clothes over Bros after 20 years for Millie to be the vice president or something.
Bitching about making OTH "feminist" while lauding Brooke's character development. And not seeing the irony 😅 People are really just using buzzwords nowadays
@9crimes87 there is no irony. Brooke's character development was actually relatable. But if they are going to reboot the series in a way that some of the reports are suggesting, then it wont be good and will be pointless. I don't think One Tree Hill fan wants to see Peyton and Brooke being moms and other characters relegated to second fiddle
yea sadly I think I'm gonna pass...OTH without Lucas, Nathan or Hayley just won't be the same....you really can't...Peyton/Lucas got their HEA finally and this new show is gonna mess with that!!!! HUGE PASS
Oh man i would be soooo excited for jake to come back and be with Peyton. I do think they need alot more of the original cast to come back to make this a success. I'm gonna watch regardless but no luke with peyton or Julian with brooke?! 😭
To be honest, I´m excited for it, but also scared. Excited if all the core characters come back, scared because they are going to ruin my beloved show, I wish they would leave alone, they all had a very happy ending. Besides, reboots do not work seriously, look what they did with Veronica Mars and Gilmore Girls, especially with VM, I wish they wouldnt have done the series, because, they broke my heart.
20 years into the future he’d be at least 25, seeing as he was at least like 5 or older when the show ended Maybe 10 years into the future rather than 20 would of been a better option
I really don’t believe either Bethany, Sophia and Hilary have had a falling out, they have been best friends for probably a decade. When Beth suffered what she went through both the girls tried to help her as best she could. It’s just hard to imagine these three hating one another…
I'm surprised it was said that fans don't like Peyton and Lucas together now. I wonder if its newer fans or some fans changing their minds. It's been many years since I've watched the show but almost everybody was a Leyton together fan back then, unlike me lol. I never loved them together past the 1st season i believe (its been a while i don't remember well). It was just too much and like you all said Lucas was all over the place, they were all over the place. To be honest I always liked him with Brooke best but then suddenly that went to sht too. I actually think I like Peyton and jake so I guess I wouldn't be so opposed to that coming back but its been so long I don't remember peyton and jake's story well. I been wanting to do a rewatch actually sometime soon. It's been long enough that I can do a rewatch having forgotten a lot about it. Hearing about a One Tree Hill spin off, like the host said there is initial excitement but then also worry about how they'll change the character's history and endings. Even though I was not a Leyton fan I think I'd be sad if they killed off Lucas as he was a beloved character. And honestly killing him off is the most sound choice i feel between that and divorce because a divorce would make no sense for their characters. And I REFUSE for them to make him a dead beat dad that is never around 😭. Somehow that would be the worst. Also if haley is not in it then nathan can't be either. At least not as a permanent character, I could see him having a short visit though because of one of his kids or something. But one thing that is an ABSOLUTE NO NO is splitting Naley up. Naley was like the main ship of the show if not top 2 main ships in the show. They hard carried till the end and you just don't mess with that. Brooke and Julian.. well I was never that invested in them tbh so I wouldnt be heart broken by a divorce. However Julian just wouldn't be an absentee parent at all either in my opinion i dont know. If they went forward with this they'd have to think up a really strong excuse for his absence. Im on the fence, kinda excited, kinda worried. Also if they make it a continuation then I don't think its a reboot but a sequel spinoff. As a big fan that loved nathan and haley's characters its kinda sad not having them around. But also I want to say if they make this I hope they make the incorporation of music a big part of the show, and im not talking about the characters doing music, but back then the music on the episodes of OTH hit so hard. It was the way music was used to deliver scenes that helped have a greater impact on the viewer. The music on the show was elite and talking about it with others i recommended the show to agreed on this. The way music choices were done on scenes made OTH that much more special.
sad bc like i love naley, but if they didn’t come back like id be ok. but like if peyton and lucas can’t be together ill kill myself. bc what do you mean i waited 4 seasons and 9 episodes, just to have them for 12(ish) episodes AND THEN THEY BROKE UP! only for me to get them for a season. then they leave the show altogether?!? i’m dead bye
I don't think they know their audience at all which is why this is going to fail horribly. OTH was popularized by hormonal girls who wanted to see the Scott brothers, I highly doubt in their middle aged lives they wanna see the Golden Girls of Tree Hill reminding them of their own mortality. It's like bringing back the OC without Seth Cohen we all know why the show was popular and it wasn't because of Peyton and Brooke. Just read the comment section it's majority women saying no Scott brothers no OTH. 😂😂😂
Your not wrong both Hilary and sophia have bias though sophia dated both brothers /married one of them in real life at separate times and Hilary never had any attraction to either so they don't get the hype around them or even understand what the show was actually about they are just projecting their opinions into the sequel brooke and peyton wasn't even friends by the series finale so I love to see how they expect this to work without the scott brothers and their romances for people to root for
The show's been off the air for 12 years. Which seems like a long time but, in the grand scheme of things, isn't really. I mean, the og show is still vividly remembered. Which means that the comparisons between og OTH and the reboot will be inevitable. And when you compare a beloved show with its cheap knockoff, the comparison is very rarely favorable to the new product... That's a fact. All of this to say that no reboot is needed. Plus everybody knows that reboots NEVER work so why even bother?
Without the 2 brothers or haley you are left with the worst characters. Sinse it's Christmas, when I hear this it reminds me of looking at the Charlie brown Christmas tree. You feel sorry for the tree but dream of your nostalgic Christmas tree. It's depressing.
Nathan was my favorite until the Mana mana scene. That was pure embarrassment. That show got so cheesy. There is no recovering from that. The show peaked at season 3. It was all downhill from there.
We need killer scripts and storylines and 20 years into the future is crazy, Jamie would almost be 30 😂, 10 years into the future would be better and without the Scott brothers wouldn’t work!!
OTH with no Scotts isn’t OTH lol
i don't think it will survive. especially since the story was originally rooted with the scotts family about the two brothers.
Agreed. OTH without Lucas and Nathan is like Martin without Martin and Gina. It doesn't work.
It’s a SPIN OFF not a reboot. Original cast does not to be entirely included.
@@smbledsoe21 yeh but the what made the show good to watch was the cast sorry to say but without Nathan haley Lucas this won't even work , it will fall flat literally on the pilot episode.
No Naley, no viewers
You can't have a good story without Lucas, Nathan, and Haley. They'll chop the story and make it look like Lucas is a jerk like Dan. Hilary's character raising a kid alone? Yeah, right.
I think Lucas should be dead. Unexpected but due to his HCM
They better not! If anything they need to make it where he's died either from his heart condition or some tragic accident.
One Tree Hill w/o Nathan and Lucas isn't One Tree Hill. It's a just show about two women raising their kids.
OTH purest totally agree with what yall said if you cant bring it back with the original cast dont bring it back at all IMO
No Nathan, No Lucas, No Haley? Yeah its about to be trash, im 100% sure of that🤣
Recently I went back and binge watched OTH. I completely forgot about Jake! I always rooted for Peyton and Lucas. But I’m totally a Jake and Peyton, they were a great couple with an unfinished storyline. So I’m really hoping for a Jake and Peyton reunion ❤🤞
Calling it now Lucas is dead “ because of his HCM”
daaamn I didn't think about that.
I have no idea how you could do OTH without both Scott Brothers, BUT I do know this will center around some teenagers of Tree Hill also, so this could be the kids going through some of the same things and having the original OTH stars show them how to get through it
Let’s not forget who has a child on the show… Haley and Nathan. Maybe their child Jamie could be the main character of that show!!
They can totally make a plausible plot Lucas dies from heart failure, Brooke is divorced and they can bring peyton back to tree hill to mourn lucas and reconnect with brooke
Lucas was outta pocket but I liked him with Peyton🤣🤣🤣
No Haley and no Nathan? NO, THANKS.
I hate to say this, but if the original cast doesn’t come back (Bethany, James, and Chad) then it’s not gonna be One Tree Hill. They ended the show the best way possible. To bring it back means having to change their endings and breaking the fans hearts if they kill off characters or divorced characters.
Exactly my thoughts!!
I know Sophia is the busiest, seeing she’s a lead on another show but if she can comeback then the others would too.
Chad doesn’t have much going on these days and past interviews he never said no. A lot of these people don’t have any major jobs happening besides Sophia
@@thatgirl9532 what show is she a lead on? That woman isn't filming anything and is beyond jobless. Bethany has other projects, James has his own independent show, and Chad isn't returning if Sophia is the executive producer spear heading this whole thing.
@@thatgirl9532 He has Sullivans Crossing he is on.
@@thatgirl9532Chad has two projects, Sullivan’s crossing and the freaky Friday reboot whereas Sophia and Hilary don’t have anything.
I'm sorry but if no Lucas and Haley then there's no point. And Nathan was no better lol he was with Peyton Haley and Brooke. And slept with Haley's sister. And tried to hide the fact that he let the nanny come onto him from Haley.
OMG EXACTLY! No Heyley? No LUCAS F***ING SCOTT?? I'm not watching.
If Lucas isn’t in it, or Nathan and Haley, I’m not watching! The show was about the Scott brothers - you cannot do the show without them!
I don’t want a show about Brooke & Peyton. I hated Peyton. The show was never about them. I’m at peace with how their characters ended up, leave it alone!
Why can’t they make their own show, instead of unraveling these characters happy endings🙄
If Lucas, Nathan, and Haley aren't on the show, then Hilary and Sophie might as well just star in a new show together where they're single moms raising their kids. There's no point in calling this One Tree Hill. Cause there's no OTH without at least 2 or 3 people listed. An OTH show characters like Jake and Rachel and Julian is barely OTH. They were side characters for a reason. Huge PASS if it's only Peyton and Brooke. Peyton wasn't even a good friend to Brooke. And they better not TOUCH NALEY
There shouldn't be an OTH reboot. If you don't have Scott's brother in it. You're better off having a Smallville next generation.
I agree and Hailey aka Bethany and Nathan. To me they were the stars
Please don’t reboot Smallville 😭
@@lukescribner9100 I agree
Everyone has their own interpretations as to what this show meant to them. But for me there were 4 things that defined OTH: 1) Nathan and Lucas finding their way to each other and their eventual bond in spite of Dan. 2) Naley. They were the long-standing core relationship of the show which helped to set OTH apart from all the other teen drama's EVER because of their consistency. Those 2 were solid. 3) Keith's awful death and the aftermath. Does anyone not remember the frenzy and the CW website crashing after Dan shot Keith?! And of course 4) basketball. The heart of OTH to me were the first 6 seasons. After Lucas left and even afterwards when even Nathan was featured less it felt like the show was scrambling to find its way. The one thing that made the latter seasons after 6 tolerable was the fantastic additions of Clay and Quinn (and again both had ties to Naley). The Scott/James/Roe/Lee family to me was the original foundation of the show. Without them this new reboot just feels weird. They were the center of the show -- all the other characters branched off of them (that included Peyton and Brooke). And as BFF as Sophia and Hilarie claim Peyton and Brooke were -- Lucas and Haley's friendship was superior. They were family before she ever married Nathan and they remained that way through it all. It was also so refreshing to see a guy and girl just be friends and stay that way throughout the shows entirety. And I'm sorry but I just can't picture a show where Lucas wouldn't be living near his kid if he and Peyton are separated or atleast not even checking in on her?! Not after what Dan put him through! And Sullivan's Crossing isn't even an excuse. Morgan Kohan is reprising her role as leading lady on When Hope Calls for season 2. Both SC and WHC are on two different networks. I will still watch this weird reboot -- but only in the way you would slow down when you pass by a car accident. It's clear Sophia's history with both Chad and James is why they weren't invited back - which is such a bizarre statement in and of itself. How are the 2 core actors of which the show was based on not at the helm of this? And a book cannot be the only reason Hilarie is icing out Joy. Maybe the fact that Joy is thriving at Hallmark has something to do with it. Maybe we can get 2 versions of the reboot. Sophia&Hilarie's. And Chad/James/Joy's. But of course the latter's would have to be set in Tree Hill. Sophia and Hilarie's can take place in LA. They can call it Brah's Over Bro's. But quite frankly since they both want to act together again so bad they should just create an entirely new show about 2 single mothers since the vision they seem to be painting for this revival feels like a gaslit version of OTH thrusted on the viewers.
No Naley is crazy
oth without chad would so suck. s7-9 was so bad. chad is the central character and basically the narrator. Also leyton is the main couple.
I think if Chad doesn’t return or Julian I could see Lucas being dead bc they did originally have some arc planned for season 7 for Lucas’s heart before Hilarie left a similar storyline where Dan basically takes over Keith’s role helping Peyton and Sawyer through this era and that’s the reason Paul who plays Dan extended his contract for another season he wanted to see Dans redemption arc come full circle. I could see Julian and Brooke being divorced maybe Julian’s in LA a lot doing movies leaving Brooke divorced. I could see Peyton and Jake having another chance if Brian returns and I’d be game for that.
When broadcasted in France, "One Tree Hill" was titled "Les Frères Scott", which means "The Scott Brothers". So bringing back OTH without "les frères Scott" would be weirder than weird...
I 1000% agree that we have already watched their stories and said goodbye to these characters! I would’ve preferred a more 90210 reboot style, we could’ve gotten completely new characters and guest stars from our favorites
They should bring back 90210 with the same cast… I know those actors never wanted to end the show the way it did
You can’t have OTH without Nathan and Haley. IMO Hillary doesn’t like you to have different opinions than her. Sophia at least tries to listen. James won’t do the show if Joy doesn’t
Honestly I don't think Lucas was allowed back because of contract issues since he currently has his other tv show with a different network
He has a movie with Lindsay Lohan and Jamie Lee Curtis coming out as well but if Sophia is very busy as well… and if Brooke can come back then Lucas can come back too!
that was the most long winded roundabout way of saying BJL is apparently right wing and not LGBTQ friendly, and Sophia and Hilary are as woke left as they come and therefore they clash. BJL being anti gay obvi clashes with Sophia. People think BJL book cover copied Hilaries (if BJL even had a say in the cover, often authors dont). Also, I think Hillaries sub-tweet RE book was petty and passive aggressive. sub-tweeting post teenage years is a bit off....
How you gonna have an OTH show with no Scotts??? LOL
These girls spent 12 minutes beating around the bush. Just call it what it is, Bethany and the rest of the cast dont want to be a part of another leftist woke reboot. And lets be clear, with Sofia and Hilarie running the show, thats exactly what its going to be.
Sophia and Hillarie will make this spin off as a propaganda of their silly activism instead of good stories. Hillarie could be as annoying as Payton. No Scotts/Haley will make this useless. A reboot with showing more about the group in 80s (before they became parents, Dan, Keith, Karen) would be better.
It would be one thing if they didn’t have Chad but without Bethany and James just NO!
Don’t call it one tree hill if the main characters don’t come back, if Brooke and Peyton wanna do a show together fine but don’t call it one tree hill, I absolutely love that show it won’t be the same without the rest of the main cast
I would call it a spinoff. Not reboot. And is totally doable. If well written. Of course Brooke and Peyton will be there, and im expecting Julian. Because they cannot break up all the couples, and I imagine Chad won’t be there. James already said a few years ago that he was done with that and wanted to move on, for ao sure he won’t be in. And Bethany Joy won’t be there too, because of hilaries and her fallout. So I think it works. Because no one wanted Haley without Nathan.
Greys did a wonderful with private practice. So I would imagine if this takes place in other city than Tree Hill, but that doesn’t seem the case. And for me it will make hard to explain why some characters won’t be there
Naley and Brooke carried the show. We dont need Lucas.
This reebot doesn't interest me, and it makes me sad as a long time OTH fan. The brothers the show was surrounded around isn't gonna be there, and none of the staple couples the fans loved are seemingly there either. Sure, it could end up being a show for some to enjoy on it's own, but it won't be OTH to me so I'm not really planning on watching.
OTH is also one of my all time favorite shows and I don’t think they should do a reboot. I’m not super on board with any reboot of a good original tv show or movie, but especially One Tree Hill. It’s too special, too good just the way it is. A reboot won’t ever feel the same, and in order to continue to tell compelling stories, they will have to adjust storylines and details that made OTH what it was. I can understand them wanting to come back together, but a reboot is a terrible idea.
Also, I am so team Leyton lol
What’s the point of doing a reboot of OTH if the original cast isn’t going to be part of it? How does that honor the fans? To me, it’s a dishonor lol
OTH, while it was about more than just the Scott brothers, was still very much a show because of the Scott brothers. CMM, James, and Bethany need to be part of it if it’s going to be a real reboot.
Otherwise, Sophia, Hilarie, Daneel, and Bevin should just create an entire new show altogether with no relation to OTH. Fans of those actors would probably watch regardless.
OTH without the Scott brothers is not OTH. Without the original 5 it WON'T work.
Nope will last one season without the full cast .
Sophia and Hilarie should’ve just created their own show. Let OTH rest in peace.
I’ll never watch that reboot with no Lucas it’s stupid especially if they give Peyton another love interest after working that hard to get Peyton and Lucas together it’ll ruin the original show
I just read where James is prob not gonna do it either.....
Especially not if Joy doesn’t
I love Brooke and Payton but Haley and Nathan made the show!
Honestly I'd rather they just do a new story with completely new characters just set in OTH with the same vibe. And the og cast can make occasional cameos.
No way Nathan and Hayley have to be in it. Let Peyton stay where she moved to. Maybe Hilarie can direct.
I feel like it would ruin the show for me if the guys are not in it, and Haley and Nathan who were my favorite. They had wrapped it up so perfectly.
Lucius has a heart condition kill switch written into his character so that’s his future in this, I watch for Haley and Nathan so without them, and James has said he won’t do it without Beth and mess up their ending, I’m not interested. No 15 - 20 year later reboot is that good, just make a new show please
I hate this painting of Joy as the bad guy. Without evidence of a fake insta with anti LGBTGIA+ posts it’s a really unfair and damaging rumour to spread. Clearly their presence and support for eachother on social media is not as abundant as it was when they first started, or pre the podcast.
But don’t plant the roots of turning commentary around Joh into an Allison Mack smallville situation
I can understand why chad doesn't wanna do it. He's filming Sullivan's Crossing probably 4-5 months out of the year in Canada. When would he have time to film OTH Sequel and still have family time and dad time and etc. I love Hilarie to death (never been a fan of sophia really) but those 2 think they can do a sequel to honor the fans and etc. and can't get James or Chad or Joy to do the show? They are out of their fucking minds.....nobody will watch it (more fans will be pissed off than anything else). They should have gotten everyone on board with doing it before anything ever got leaked out.
Sullivan's Crossing main character played by Morgan Kohan will be returning to When Hope Calls for season 2. She is leading lady on both shows. Sullivan's Crossing has no more than 13 episodes a season. Its mid season. Sadly its clear Chad wasn't invited back.
@@wickedlyunique It's clear that you have no clue.
@@pulses33 oh wow. I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to offend you.
1 teee hill with no hailey,Nathancand lucas is not 1 tree hill
I love hilarie and Sophia but the show does not need to come back. It had 9 seasons (which most teen shows don’t get) and everyone wrapped up nicely. We don’t need that.
Can it survive without 90% of the former cast?
Nope.
It makes no sense that their husbands won’t be there. That was a big part of the show. Will brook still have twins? The new show will be confusing.
Literally what i said. 0 Point to even make the show if Lucas isnt there, Nathan isnt there, Haley isnt there & etc
Yeah, I'm not sure how this would work tbh without everyone, especially given how popular Naley was throughout the show's run. I'd miss James much more than Chad but think we need at least one Scott brother, even as a cameo. I think the only reason I would watch is if I got the Jeyton endgame we all deserved lol.
Honestly Hilary could kill off Lucas and wind up with that other guy who had the baby. Nathan may not be able to come back either because he often directs one show and is currently on another on Hulu
WTF is this?! Sophia and Austin Nichols were just together at an OTH event, taking photos and being playful calling him her "TV husband". There's no issue there. Just because their podcast is called "Drama queens" doesn't mean you have to feed into stories.
And the who doesn't know how to pronounce "Daneel"?! And she says OTH is her all time favorite show? Laughable.
Peyton and Lucas not together in the future doesn’t surprise me at all. Peyton could meet Jake again. He was much better than Lucas
Austin has a good relationship with Sophia. Not friends, but friendly.
They posted a group photo together not that long ago so I’m sure they are friends again
I don’t want him back,sorry I don’t care for his character on One Tree Hill.
So half a tree hill?
Not without Peyton and Luke ❤❤❤ wannaa prove ? OTH for lots if not almost all ended by season 6 , should have refered to where they went and should have at least brought them for the finale
I never thought we would get a reboot or movie s i'm seated and excited for whatever is created. And story wise my mind and heart is open. The joy book drama was not a turn i expected because i loved the bond between the three of them.
Nope. Always wanted Lucas and Brooke to figure it out when I was growing up on this show.
Then she wouldn’t have her twins .. so pass on that
@@wildcatblue13still having her twins though. I don’t care for the guy that Brooke married. I believe that she didn’t end up with Lucas because of Sophia & Chad’s marriage ending in real life.
Brooke and Lucas had better chemistry than Peyton and Lucas.
Agreed. They had that opposites attraxr vibe from the beginning. 🙂
I never wanted Lucas to get a happy ending. He was terrible. Peyton and Jake always.
Not without the full main cast.
If Sophia Bush and Hilarie Burton are hell bent in making the One Tree Hill reboot a "feminist reclamation" of the series, then it won't work. One Tree Hill at its core was so much more. Everyday life, struggles, character growth, forgiveness, parenting, etc. There is a reason why Brooke was one of the best characters in One Tree Hill because of her progression from Season 1 where she was a self-centered high school kid to being one of the most selfless and responsible human beings in the show. It was not perfect but the development was relatable. I think Sophia and Hilarie are so hell bent to take the show away from Mark Schwahn (and he is a scumbag), but they are kind of missing what made One Tree Hill great.
And there is no point in bringing the show back if the are not bringing the "Core 5" characters back. And also remember characters like Dan and Keith are dead. Karen and Deb are probably not coming back. Will we see Quinn and Clay? What about Mouth and Millie as Lisa Goldstein who played Millie has quit acting. Jackson Brundage who played Jamie Scott has quit acting as well. So I dont know how this work.
I thought it was odd that Lisa Goldstein was not mentioned in this re-boot now that makes sense Iwould have loved Brooke to revive Clothes over Bros after 20 years for Millie to be the vice president or something.
Bitching about making OTH "feminist" while lauding Brooke's character development. And not seeing the irony 😅 People are really just using buzzwords nowadays
@9crimes87 there is no irony. Brooke's character development was actually relatable. But if they are going to reboot the series in a way that some of the reports are suggesting, then it wont be good and will be pointless. I don't think One Tree Hill fan wants to see Peyton and Brooke being moms and other characters relegated to second fiddle
@@9crimes87 no its about making sure that the reboot goes along with the spirit of the original and not just become a Sophia and Hilarie show
yea sadly I think I'm gonna pass...OTH without Lucas, Nathan or Hayley just won't be the same....you really can't...Peyton/Lucas got their HEA finally and this new show is gonna mess with that!!!! HUGE PASS
Oh man i would be soooo excited for jake to come back and be with Peyton. I do think they need alot more of the original cast to come back to make this a success. I'm gonna watch regardless but no luke with peyton or Julian with brooke?! 😭
To be honest, I´m excited for it, but also scared. Excited if all the core characters come back, scared because they are going to ruin my beloved show, I wish they would leave alone, they all had a very happy ending. Besides, reboots do not work seriously, look what they did with Veronica Mars and Gilmore Girls, especially with VM, I wish they wouldnt have done the series, because, they broke my heart.
Yes same with Melrose Place and Beverly Hills 90210 the reboots just make it worse people need to leave the Good old shows and not reboot them
But they literally just put up a drama queens podcast ep together yesterday?
They’re pre-recorded I believe
Guys Jamie would be 17 not 30 😂
20 years into the future he’d be at least 25, seeing as he was at least like 5 or older when the show ended
Maybe 10 years into the future rather than 20 would of been a better option
Jamie was at least 16 when the show ended with the flashforward
None of them would be teens,unless they would have more kids!
I really don’t believe either Bethany, Sophia and Hilary have had a falling out, they have been best friends for probably a decade. When Beth suffered what she went through both the girls tried to help her as best she could. It’s just hard to imagine these three hating one another…
make julian and lukas hookup hahahaha
A lot of people always wanted Brooke and Lucas. But we knew it was not going to happen because Sophia and Chad’s divorce
I'm surprised it was said that fans don't like Peyton and Lucas together now. I wonder if its newer fans or some fans changing their minds. It's been many years since I've watched the show but almost everybody was a Leyton together fan back then, unlike me lol. I never loved them together past the 1st season i believe (its been a while i don't remember well). It was just too much and like you all said Lucas was all over the place, they were all over the place. To be honest I always liked him with Brooke best but then suddenly that went to sht too. I actually think I like Peyton and jake so I guess I wouldn't be so opposed to that coming back but its been so long I don't remember peyton and jake's story well. I been wanting to do a rewatch actually sometime soon. It's been long enough that I can do a rewatch having forgotten a lot about it.
Hearing about a One Tree Hill spin off, like the host said there is initial excitement but then also worry about how they'll change the character's history and endings. Even though I was not a Leyton fan I think I'd be sad if they killed off Lucas as he was a beloved character. And honestly killing him off is the most sound choice i feel between that and divorce because a divorce would make no sense for their characters. And I REFUSE for them to make him a dead beat dad that is never around 😭. Somehow that would be the worst.
Also if haley is not in it then nathan can't be either. At least not as a permanent character, I could see him having a short visit though because of one of his kids or something. But one thing that is an ABSOLUTE NO NO is splitting Naley up. Naley was like the main ship of the show if not top 2 main ships in the show. They hard carried till the end and you just don't mess with that.
Brooke and Julian.. well I was never that invested in them tbh so I wouldnt be heart broken by a divorce. However Julian just wouldn't be an absentee parent at all either in my opinion i dont know. If they went forward with this they'd have to think up a really strong excuse for his absence.
Im on the fence, kinda excited, kinda worried. Also if they make it a continuation then I don't think its a reboot but a sequel spinoff. As a big fan that loved nathan and haley's characters its kinda sad not having them around. But also I want to say if they make this I hope they make the incorporation of music a big part of the show, and im not talking about the characters doing music, but back then the music on the episodes of OTH hit so hard. It was the way music was used to deliver scenes that helped have a greater impact on the viewer. The music on the show was elite and talking about it with others i recommended the show to agreed on this. The way music choices were done on scenes made OTH that much more special.
sad bc like i love naley, but if they didn’t come back like id be ok. but like if peyton and lucas can’t be together ill kill myself. bc what do you mean i waited 4 seasons and 9 episodes, just to have them for 12(ish) episodes AND THEN THEY BROKE UP! only for me to get them for a season. then they leave the show altogether?!? i’m dead bye
They tried with Beverly hills it didn't work lol
I don't think they know their audience at all which is why this is going to fail horribly. OTH was popularized by hormonal girls who wanted to see the Scott brothers, I highly doubt in their middle aged lives they wanna see the Golden Girls of Tree Hill reminding them of their own mortality. It's like bringing back the OC without Seth Cohen we all know why the show was popular and it wasn't because of Peyton and Brooke. Just read the comment section it's majority women saying no Scott brothers no OTH. 😂😂😂
Your not wrong both Hilary and sophia have bias though sophia dated both brothers /married one of them in real life at separate times and Hilary never had any attraction to either so they don't get the hype around them or even understand what the show was actually about they are just projecting their opinions into the sequel brooke and peyton wasn't even friends by the series finale so I love to see how they expect this to work without the scott brothers and their romances for people to root for
The show's been off the air for 12 years. Which seems like a long time but, in the grand scheme of things, isn't really. I mean, the og show is still vividly remembered. Which means that the comparisons between og OTH and the reboot will be inevitable. And when you compare a beloved show with its cheap knockoff, the comparison is very rarely favorable to the new product... That's a fact. All of this to say that no reboot is needed. Plus everybody knows that reboots NEVER work so why even bother?
Love one tree hill
Only Brooke fans hated Leyton. The highest ratings of the show was lucas and peyton and show tanked after that
I liked him with both,but I wish that Brooke would’ve ended up with someone else,I don’t care for Julian!
What about Clayton and haleys sister?I liked them
Without the 2 brothers or haley you are left with the worst characters. Sinse it's Christmas, when I hear this it reminds me of looking at the Charlie brown Christmas tree. You feel sorry for the tree but dream of your nostalgic Christmas tree. It's depressing.
Love Chad and think the only way it would work is if Peyton moves home after Lucas dies from his HCM
Do not do this!!
Hilarie burton is desperate for fame
No
Nathan was my favorite until the Mana mana scene. That was pure embarrassment. That show got so cheesy. There is no recovering from that. The show peaked at season 3. It was all downhill from there.
We need killer scripts and storylines and 20 years into the future is crazy, Jamie would almost be 30 😂, 10 years into the future would be better and without the Scott brothers wouldn’t work!!
They are liberal they’ll make it garbage. Oh without the Scott’s is stupid 🤣🤣
We need Mouth, Jamie Scott jeez it ended with him. Alex, Mia, Chris Keller! SAM and Jack together. Omg
Psycho Derek lol
Podcasting needs to be done better than this….Horrible segment
I love the idea of a reboot without Lucas...never could stand him.
I disliked Peyton and Jake.