Yes, aespa slay! But are we going to ignore the aenergy of Mys in the showcase? Their fanchant makes the performance more Savage! Mys are on another level.
what I love about Giselle is her duality. Everytime she gives me so much sexy and badass vibes but on the other side she seems so simple, so cute and nice. Like I don't know, Ningning is my bias but something unique has always attracted me to Giselle.
OMG NINGNING'S VOICE KILLED IT!!!! Happy with Giselle's and Karina's rap parts, too, they sound stronger than in their past live performances! And Karina's moves during the dance break!
WHY am i crying? this means so much and i’m so proud of our girls. they’ve grown so much and have been through so much. they are so talented and deserve the world
kpop stans when other kpop groups use loud backtrack : OMGEEEEE THEY SLAY LIVE! kpop stans when aespa uses loud backtrack : lipsync again. y'all just hate aespa
I mean it is clear that they are singing live here but it is also pretty clear sm dosnt let them sing live that much too ehich is sad even in encore they had loud backtrack even though they can sing but atleast they are allowed to sing live in america i m loving that
@@yrbigfanyea sm won't let them sing live in sk buuut- for encore mbc music core always used loud backtracking for almost all groups, but it was never an issue, ITS ONLY ISSUE WHEN IT COMES TO AESPA 🥲 while the other one is fully live with minimal backing track.
not quite sure if this is live or pre-recorded but definitely not the studio version. ningning's approach in her high notes are a bit different and winter sounded strained on the latter half of her last high note. cmiw because the only performance i'm sure they did 100% live in the showcase is black mamba, life's too short and lucid dream.
They use backtrack to cover some difficult part and highnote but they still singing live because the mic is always on. i'm happy that Aespa improve so much after Coachella, go AESPAA 💙⭐🌙🦋
yess it’s live!! they sang all songs live, you can hear clearer during aenergy since karina was more hype & even yelled louder into the mic during her part “beolleo aespa!”
pre-recorded again??? really sm?? when will sm let them sing actual LIVE ffs, even tho they sounded a bit unstable live like their coachella showcase one i feel like it's much more better than letting them sing live pre-recorded over and over again no hate tho but i really wish they could give it a rest on singing live pre-recorded
IF SM KEEP DOING THIS I SWEAR- i mean what's the use of training them for years just to not letting them sing ACTUAL LIVE listen what I'm saying is actual live not LIVE PRE-RECORDED, JUST BY SINGING ACTUAL LIVE ON COACHELLA FOR ONCE AND FEW TIMES AT ENCORE DOESN'T MEAN YALL CAN FOOL US TO NOT HEAR THE DIFFERENCE IF YALL SINGING LIVE OR NOT, SM ISTG DONT BE INSECURE W THEM SINGING UNSTABLE ON LIVE BCS THAT'S THEIR JOB TO SING BC THEY'RE A SINGER
I think it’s because they dont want their throat to have a problem & you should watch their aenergy, bm, life too short & lucid dream performance, they sing live there
Guys u need to Calm down ilove them and i hear all the performances Im talking about Savage iknow they singing live in other songs and proud of them But why Savage hope i can listen to the song live everytime 😔
Jajajajaja sonó también en vivo que piensan que es play Back pobr**ecitos están más sorprendidos que ard**idos de ver a la chicas haciéndolo bien como siempre...
![[Knowing Bros] Who's the Prettiest in aespa?💕✨](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dXOF4FExQAM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] 240629 에스파 지젤 Dopamine 2024 aespa LIVE TOUR－SYNK：PARALLEL LINE 1st day 개인무대 #aespa #giselle](/img/n.gif)
you can hear them singing live. they have such strong and beautiful voices. I wish these little ones achieve the best, I love it!
Yes, aespa slay! But are we going to ignore the aenergy of Mys in the showcase? Their fanchant makes the performance more Savage! Mys are on another level.
I’m literally crying 😭 I’m so proud of them 🫡🫡
😭😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️
They slay!!!😭 I love AESPA
i’m literally sobbing i’m so proud!!!
Their live vocals omg are the best 😭😭😭
i’m so happy when the crowd sings along
what I love about Giselle is her duality. Everytime she gives me so much sexy and badass vibes but on the other side she seems so simple, so cute and nice. Like I don't know, Ningning is my bias but something unique has always attracted me to Giselle.
OMG NINGNING'S VOICE KILLED IT!!!! Happy with Giselle's and Karina's rap parts, too, they sound stronger than in their past live performances! And Karina's moves during the dance break!
Aespa and Mys and Audience are ONE, this is now THE SAVAGE ERA OF AESPA, shine more brightly and thank you for your wonderful voices👏😍😍😍😍
WHY am i crying? this means so much and i’m so proud of our girls. they’ve grown so much and have been through so much. they are so talented and deserve the world
ningning is so hot!!!!!!!!!!!! Her voice just like moonlight!!
Mys "cheers to aespa and us and to the haters who's mouth are shut now 😂😌"
Savage Queens on stage. Yassss
Their live vocals are insane!!!!
I will never get tired of saying this, GISELLE YOU ARE SLAYINNNN QUEEN🌙✨💯
I’m so happy for happy for them they deserve so much love ❤️
kpop stans when other kpop groups use loud backtrack : OMGEEEEE THEY SLAY LIVE!
kpop stans when aespa uses loud backtrack : lipsync again.
y'all just hate aespa
Live vocals were easily audible from the front rows, especially black mamba. See the fancans closer to the stage.
@@balagopalvm1760 ik ;; i meant it for people who are saying they lipsync here ;; which is not true...;; the mics were on 🥲 but they all go blind.
I mean it is clear that they are singing live here but it is also pretty clear sm dosnt let them sing live that much too ehich is sad even in encore they had loud backtrack even though they can sing but atleast they are allowed to sing live in america i m loving that
@@yrbigfanyea sm won't let them sing live in sk buuut- for encore mbc music core always used loud backtracking for almost all groups, but it was never an issue, ITS ONLY ISSUE WHEN IT COMES TO AESPA 🥲 while the other one is fully live with minimal backing track.
@@sleepy5670 ya its true trolls will make a fuss about anything and everything
Aespa did great but lets credit the fans with that crazy fanchant.
The crowd! Finally! MYs 😭😭❤️
omg thank you so much!
HATERS WHERE ARE YOUUUU🧐 AESPA KEEP ROCKING 🔥🔥🔥🔥👑
im so proud of my girls! slayyyyy
omg, they live !!!!! this is like audio, I just say it's better audio 😭😭
Haters and people who called them a cheater.... crying in the corner😂
Do you need tissues mys will provide you 🥺😂
00:06 savagee!!!😭
다들 너무 이쁘다
와 진짜 미국 마이들 부러워 한국도 팬미팅 할거지만 그래도 일단 부러움 분위기 최고다 떼창 재밌어 보임
우리 해외 팬들이 에스파를 좋아하고 한국에서 콘서트가 항상 열리는데 해외에서는 스파가 덜 활발히 해서 부럽다. 난 당신이 이해 바랍니다
Thankyou so much for this fancam 💜💜💜💜
Y'all know it's live when Winter & Ning2 halts their dancing to belt their hearts out😌✨.
even ning’s high note at 0:58 sounded different, their live vocals are top tier!
축하해요, 에스파....^^
0:05 girl feeling it🤣
Queens 👑❤🔥😍
GISELLE STANS RISE UP!!! SHE SLAYED AT 1:27
2:54 this part💕
My girlssss💚
Aaaa Thank you so much 😚
Winter:"Oh my Gosh don't you know..."☺️☺️
MY:"SaVaGe!!!?"👹👹👹
not quite sure if this is live or pre-recorded but definitely not the studio version. ningning's approach in her high notes are a bit different and winter sounded strained on the latter half of her last high note. cmiw because the only performance i'm sure they did 100% live in the showcase is black mamba, life's too short and lucid dream.
sounds like a mix of live with a prerecorded track to me
Oh my god winterrrr
This is insane
I LOVE aespa but i don’t think this one’s live, black mamba and next level, yes, but not savage… still I’m proud of them!! ✨
I think Savage is the hardest vocally out of all them (producers' faults) so they lipped this one.
They use backtrack to cover some difficult part and highnote but they still singing live because the mic is always on. i'm happy that Aespa improve so much after Coachella, go AESPAA 💙⭐🌙🦋
Thanks ❤
everybody look at me 😏
"lipsync accusations" came in 3...2....1....
This is soundcheck what do you expect also their performance is soon
@@blacklemonaesthetic im not the one who accusing them lipsync 😁
they sing live too btw.
💯
sorry, but were they singing live? It sounded so perfect
you can watch aenergy, bm, life too short & lucid dream performance to hear the live vocals more clearly
Yassss proud of themm 😭👏👏
yes it's live
yess it’s live!! they sang all songs live, you can hear clearer during aenergy since karina was more hype & even yelled louder into the mic during her part “beolleo aespa!”
slaaaaaaaaayyyyyyy ❤❤❤❤❤❤
This is soundcheck right???
Yes
❤
All the haters out there just see these thry r singing live....
Mic off.
pre-recorded again??? really sm?? when will sm let them sing actual LIVE ffs, even tho they sounded a bit unstable live like their coachella showcase one i feel like it's much more better than letting them sing live pre-recorded over and over again no hate tho but i really wish they could give it a rest on singing live pre-recorded
IF SM KEEP DOING THIS I SWEAR- i mean what's the use of training them for years just to not letting them sing ACTUAL LIVE listen what I'm saying is actual live not LIVE PRE-RECORDED, JUST BY SINGING ACTUAL LIVE ON COACHELLA FOR ONCE AND FEW TIMES AT ENCORE DOESN'T MEAN YALL CAN FOOL US TO NOT HEAR THE DIFFERENCE IF YALL SINGING LIVE OR NOT, SM ISTG DONT BE INSECURE W THEM SINGING UNSTABLE ON LIVE BCS THAT'S THEIR JOB TO SING BC THEY'RE A SINGER
I think it’s because they dont want their throat to have a problem & you should watch their aenergy, bm, life too short & lucid dream performance, they sing live there
This is live
this is live !!
Actually their mic are always on
Guys u need to Calm down ilove them and i hear all the performances
Im talking about Savage iknow they singing live in other songs and proud of them
But why Savage hope i can listen to the song live everytime 😔
while holding and adjusting their mics to project their non-existent live vocals… 💀
Black Mamba they were actually singing
They sing live aenergy, black mamba, lucid dream
i dont think they are lipsynching. if u watch their black mamba fancam its obvious their singing live.
its live. it'a a showcase bro they cant lipsync. they are just sooo good live that you cant tell. just SM things they eat cds
PUNCH
Lipsync
Shhh
bro what its fucking live yall are obsessed 💀
Jajajajaja sonó también en vivo que piensan que es play Back pobr**ecitos están más sorprendidos que ard**idos de ver a la chicas haciéndolo bien como siempre...
You are so obsessed with them lol
Yes they are singing LIVE :)