📌 Quick update: Apologies for my voice in this video - I was fighting a cold during filming! But I couldn't wait to share these theories with you all. Huge thanks for your support and understanding! 🙏
Fatima says the childs' parents sacrificed them, but Victor said that the BIW told Christopher that their loved ones and people they trusted did , and I think this is the correct version. If it was just the parents, we'd only have 12 monsters because 7 kids were sacrificed and two parents didn't participate. Besides, we have some young monsters who were probably their brothers in charge, the old lady who probably was some child's grandmother, might be some relatives too, etc. We have many more monsters than 12.
It's poetic you know. One Smiley dies. Another is born. Boyd kills Smiley and says 'My blood is in your blood now MF' Fatima gives birth and Smiley will be calling Boyd GRANDPA lol
Yooo I never even caught that parallel! 🤯 Wild how it comes full circle - Boyd takes out one Smiley while his grandbaby is literally part Smiley. That "my blood is in your blood" line hits SO different now 💀
My thought’s exactly.. Mr. Smiley about to be outside colony house apologizing to mom and dad for breaking curfew😂. Elgin gave blood too and lost an eye, Top Tier prenatal care.
For anyone who hate Jim here's what happened to him 1. Thomas die 2. Tabita wanna divorce 3. Last trip 4. Car crash 5. Son leg is staked 7. Found himself in contradict reality with his logic 8. Told that monster are real and stone have power 9. First experience monster 10. Julie wanna separate 11. Wife still bitchin 12. Son playing around with mentally crippled old man and having gun 13. Almost got Ethan slit by Sarah 14. Get hope by static radio 15. Big radio fail 16. MIY threatened him 17. Wife fall to the tunnel 18. Trying to save her only house to be collapse 19. Witnesses monster kill 2 person in close proximity 20. Getting injured and now need to be latched on tian chien 21. Get second idea only to put dona in danger 22. His wife always talking nonsense according to him 23. His wife also doesn't want to be calmed down 23. Julie get cicada-ed and almost died 24. Tabitha hell bent on becoming savior 25. His wife is unknown only to ethan get started pessimistic 26. Trying to searching his wife in the wood only for Ethan and Julie edging him to the brim 27. Taunted by dead son 28. Wife back and almost killed again 29. His wife is being blamed by from folks 30. Trying to calm down Tabitha, she saying he should be honest 31. Honest then wife get mad 32. His daughter mingling with old dude randal smoking zaza 33. Wife prefer listening to jade 34. Found out his daughter get seizure 35. Making up with his family 36. Finding out his wife and jade were destined 37 get killed by MIY On top of that Jim didn't get supernatural vision, trying to maintain his logic and rationale, having 2 idea that cost life, his wife is stone headed, his daughter is rebel bitch, his son can't sit still and slowly becoming emo, he is not sitting around but helping townfolks, he's not bad parent, he already trusted townfolks He is not insufferable, he just being realistic character
I completely agree jim is not a bad person or a bad parent.But tabitha ,julie and ethan are not bitch either ,maybe u hate his family like many others but others but no they are not bad either.
I agree jim is not a bad person or parent,but julie,tabitha and ethan are not so bad as u think,i understand u hate his family like many others but they are not bad
Jim went through a very realistic arc indeed, driven by logical thinking and trying to find a rational reason for everything happening. Amazing character that I will definitely miss!
One thing I noticed is the boy in white's refusal to explain things to victor. The last time he told christopher what was going on, the entire town was slaughtered. I believe there are rules and literally "knowledge has a price."
Miranda also told Victor not to hide anywhere Christopher knew about. I think he told where everyone was hiding for an advantage but like with Sarah and Elgin the entity lied. 🤔
I’m here for the chaos 😂 we didn’t get all the answers, and won’t till Season 5 as they’ve planned I’m sure. But I like the answers we got with the finale, so some big shake ups, new big questions would be fun. Just as long as they splice in some small answers hah
The best way to start season 4 would be it opening to the original sacrifice the town people made of the children to Tabitha and Jades hosts at that time singing to the kids to that transitioning to present day and then dealing with everything….Also an overlooked part in my opinion was when Martin or the boy in white said “in order to change/fix everything you have to go back to the beginning”….when Jim has his flashback of him and the family driving, he literally says “remember how easy things were in the beginning”…maybe coincidence but I think there’s a correlation. Has to be
I have a feeling there will be a full flashback episode next season that builds up to the sacrifice. And then maybe they will start showing what other sacrifices town people made to end up there.
The man in yellow only came to intervene because they are getting too far with figuring things out. Before he indirectly intervened with stuff like the radio, but now that tabitha and jade know their past and are learning more he has to directly involve himself to stop them from getting too close to truly figuring things out. He didn’t need to intervene when they had no idea about their pasts, didn’t understand the bottle tree, the root symbols, how the monsters were created, etc. because the people didn’t pose a threat yet to him.
That's why he killed Lisa's father he has the capability to put things together to aid in the solution, whereas Jade and Tabitha have been failing every cycle. I also think that Julie's powers do not come from her being tortured but are a special gift passed to her because she is the daughter of the Tabitha reincarnated. in the same way her son seems to have a gift of perception with regards to how things fit together. The Entity wanted Tabitha's son killed and tried to break Julie's mind with torture. so if you put the two children and their father together with Tabitha answers would have been more quickly discovered in the future. the man in yellow took a bishop off the boardThat's why he killed Lisa's father he has the capability to put things together to aid in the solution, whereas Jade and Tabitha have been failing every cycle. I also think that Julie's powers do not come from her being tortured but are a special gift passed to her because she is the daughter of the Tabitha reincarnated. in the same way her son seems to have a gift of perception with regards to how things fit together. The Entity wanted Tabitha's son killed and tried to break Julie's mind with torture. so if you put the two children and their father together with Tabitha answers would have been more quickly discovered in the future. the man in yellow took a bishop off the board.
A random theory I just came up with: Maybe the boy in white doesn’t reveal too much information because the man in yellow said that information comes at a cost and would come after the boy in white.
That's what I'm thinking too. It's possible the boy in white is similar to Julie and he's going around in time, trying to change things in indirect ways.
When he shared information with Christopher it led to the Massacre which is why he's more circumspect with the information this time round and says they must find out the knowledge themselves.
Then that would make the boy in white, a supernatural being, a coward. How is giving helpful information detrimental? This isn't like learning a skill where you have to build knowledge incrementally to understand the theory. This is life and death for hundreds of people. Maybe thousands if this pocket dimension is allowed to exist longer. There has to be a compelling reason to not say anything otherwise the premise of the show comes off as a convoluted mess. Like Lost 😂
@wayofthekodiak3118 a loy of it has to do with how humans operate we aren't good at dealing with things that completely contradict our entire understanding of the world so if the BIW trued to get ol' Christopher to understand things that are so completely foreign to a 60 yr old dude in the 70's it makes sense that Christopher likely had a complete psychotic break
@@wintertrooper7918 No it doesn't. I can explain to a child what danger is, how to avoid it, and what to do if it's encountered. The writers are just trying to stretch things. For instance, the boy in white for SURE knows how to kill the monsters but doesn't offer even a hint.
Tabitha isn't Miranda, but whoever came before, Dating back to the original incarnations that disagreed with the towns sacrificing of their kids. Same with Jade, he's not Christopher. They're all still their own incarnations, but a looped incarnation of the OG's that defied the man in yellow's offer (or whoever controls the man in yellow if that's the case) The reason the boy in white sent tabitha to mirandas house was to help her remember her previous incarnation which would eventually lead her and jade to remember their OG incarnations/memories. They only NOW remember what happened on the night the town's curse was created. So, yes. She WAS miranda and jade WAS christopher. But they remembered wayyyyy more than just Miranda's and Christopher's memories. The angkooey kids dont want them to remember being miranda and christopher... those incarnations failed. They wanted them to do what non has done yet, and thats REMEMBER WHO THEY ORIGINALLY WERE AND WHAT THE TOWN DID. The answers to leave lie in the beginning, not of the show... but of fromville itself. This was all very clearly explained in the show. Also, about the bottle tree. All that is, is a way that past incarnations have tried to help future incarnations remember absolutely everything. I.e. they only remembered the full scope of things once they played the song (and jade subconsciously remembered the songs importance while solving the bottle tree. Which is funny cuz thats the nursery song they used to sing to their OG kid) therfore i can only take away that that was the whole purpose of the numbers in the bottles. Man in yellow is now angry and killed jim for assisting in solving the numbers because the incarnations arent suppose to remember. Jim made the man in yellows job way harder than it had to be and now the town actually has a chance to fight back against him because of jim, tabitha, and jade. They remember!! Now they just need julie to storywalk to the beginning and give them clues on how to stop the town curse and free the kids
@@jonfreeman9682 not a possibility, it's simply so. That's stated, if not insinuated in the most recent episode. Thats one of the first things I say in my comment up top ☝️... We don't really know when the curse started or how many cycles it's been since. But it's definitely been a lot of cycles.
Man in yellow being one of the monsters being out in broad daylight leads me to think that all the monsters will be out in daylight however they'll only be in the forest and not the town, BUT if you remember Victor saying to Ethan in the diner (I forget the exact measurement) "The trees have moved 3 inches" or something, also leads me to believe that they will maybe some day have the trees by the town and monsters will be able to walk around the town during the day then also. I probably explained that INSANELY poorly but I do like the theory of it.
The yellow king is likely the priest who oversaw the sacrifice and the kimono lady the priestess but he took her share of immortal powers so he retains his human form even in daylight and can puppeteer the other monsters while kimono lady stays a spirit as skeletor 💀
🤯 oh, I kept thinking well at least they just come out at night, but you may be right. I feel like the town keeps changing the rules once the trapped figure something out.
Don't think the music brought the yellow king but only the kids. The yellow king is the puppet master who controls the monsters and enjoys the show in the background. They did the same thing in lost with the yellow king except he wasn't yellow. The same guy wrote the story for lost and this show so is recycling old ideas.
If there were 7 sacrificed children, and the Tabitha/Jade child was one of those, that leaves 6 kids. With 2 parents. Meaning that there are only 12 monsters? I thought there was more than that. I also want to see how much the Boy in White continues to age up in Season 4. I'm guessing he might age up to actually become the Man in Yellow.
@@RaneishaMorris I mean the souls of Tabitha/Jade. We don't know their original names so really can't come up with a better name for them. And there were indeed a total of 7 kids on the slabs being sacrificed, not 6. They also said in the show that the monsters were given immortality for sacrificing their children.
Julie has the opportunity to travel where her family showed up in fromville and get them to walk past the tree, or even when the bus showed up and have that group move the tree off the road. Everyone turns back when they reach the tree, there's either an exit that way or that's where the children are trapped.
I dont think Julie has the 'three eyed raven's power, she cannot go into the past wherever she likes, it happens automatically. She cannot choose which event she can go back to...
I’m wondering if the Man in Yellow will start appearing to the residents more often now. What’s funniest is that we, as viewers, know about him, but currently none of the residents have any idea he exists. Either they’ll find out because he reveals himself to them, or Julie will be the first one to learn about him in the future.
I think Ethan is a reincarnation of Victor hear me out. So after S3 E10, I decided to start watching season 1 again, when Ethan wakes up after they fix his leg Ethan talks about the tears in the water, and talks about seeing all the drawings on the wall, the scene then goes to Victor drawing the accident. Ethan has always been close with Victor, Ethan also can see the boy in white, I'm pretty convinced about this now, after what we saw in S3 E10.
Ethan can't be reincarnation of Victor as Victor is still alive ..in.hindu mythology reincarnation works as when one soul leaves a body then it is reborn in another means one has to die to reincarnate
I was thinking this too because of when the voices told Sarah to kill Ethan. Wondering if that’s the reason everything is changing because she didn’t do it and now two of the same souls/characters/reincarnations are there at once.
Why did the man in Yellow on painting have a scar on his cheek same as Randall? Martin knowing julie finally makes sense due to time travel, also if u look at Jades arm in episode 1 hes got Tabithas bracelet on
The boy in white said they have to learn themselves. I am starting to think the boy in white and the man in yellow are two players using people in town as chess piece. Like a game, there are rules put in place they have to follow. Julie can't change the past but maybe she can influence some change.
@@belgradewanderer That's exactly what I was thinking. Like the MiB, he interferes directly, uses other pieces like the monsters... The boy, like Jacob let people make their own decision.
Makes me wonder if the boy in white is similar to Julie and he's traveling through time. Would explain why he seemed frustrated when he told Victor they'd have to learn on their own.
@@macster1613 I think it's because she didn't change anything but was part of that event. She was supposed to throw the rope. If she comes back to that moment again, she wouldn't be able to stop herself from doing it.
People been whining like babies about "slow pace" when it was a masterful buildup, elegantly developing characters and laying out the themes elegantly leading to this final episode. And I knew it all along. Do you people now realize this show is not meant to be treated merely as a puzzle and "owing" you some major reveals like regularly every episode? So stupid
Welcome to the real world where people want answers instead of being around the bush. Imagine if a person like you and that person was unclear about their motives, would you stick around and waste all your phone minutes? No, you would stop talking to that person but when it comes to a television show people will wait 5 years to find out the truth.
But it wasn't elegantly or masterfully developed. It was sloppy. When you compare it to a show that WAS elegantly developed, it's easy to see. Something like Breaking Bad is a perfect example. FROM is fun to watch, but calling it "masterful" is a stretch. The first season of True Crimes is Masterful. The first EPISODE of FROM can be called that.
Had a puff and thought, season 4 will begin with Jim not dead, it will show his death in a more conventional means, not making it indoors before sundown. The paradox is Julie returning to that time and triggering the man in the yellow suit.
@@jonfreeman9682Julie, Randall, and That blonde chick all can manipulate time in different ways. Right now we know Julie can walk into the past. Who knows what the others can do.
Great episode, but them tying big old Elgin up with some string had me crying laughing. I mean, big boy could have just raised his arms up, and it would have snapped the string. 😭
I’m going to go through withdrawal not seeing my friends in Fromville until 2026, but I’m glad it got picked up for another season. I’m sad what happened to Elgin. He seemed like such a sweet soul. Now the questions. I thought the ending was a little abrupt. I understand you need to have some loose threads, but there were too many. The issue with Lost which the director or producer is tied to brought in too many story lines which is too much for an audience. Tighten things up a bit (my non-professional opinion) 😊. If the monsters became immortal because they sacrificed their children, there is a teenage boy. Did he have a child? Maybe not an important question? You introduce the spiders and Bam no more word about them. Maybe there should have been a little more about their importance. I liked Boyd a lot. Now no more. He kind of disgusted me in the last episode. Such a sad character drop. I have high hopes for Kenny to take over. Also, they left poor Randall struggling with the bug sounds. It would have been nice to end this season with some other character development as to what is his next chapter. But again, I’m not a writer and overall From is a brilliant storyline concept with great actors.
Boy in White, Man in Yellow and Kimino lady were once a family. Kimino lady drowned the boy in white and sent the man in yellow in a fit a rage that made him kill kimino lady. Opening credits even has the kimino lady and man in yellow with the dog drawn. Now they are like you said, playing chess with each other
@@-Sceneshorts- I'm not sure but yeah maybe. Just looking back on earlier seasons it's hard to really know what the writers are trying to tell us a clue or just a red hearing. Think Elijin and his lake scare. Besides maybe one or two scenes we really haven't even seen the lake nor come close to what it has to do with Eligin even though I'd imagine he would be more afraid of sarah of all things. Or Tabitha and Miranda being different ethnitancy but yet still are the same person.
Yes it's possible. They're definitely all connected in some way. Yellow king and kimono lady seem to be higher up in management and could be the priest and priestess who conducted the sacrifice. The boy in white could be one of the sacrifice kids who fought back.
Elgin should have think twice before helping Kimono lady. The same lady tried to kill him by drowning him in bathtub. How’s she is good and helping them to get out from Fromville.
I don't think she was trying to kill him; she pushed him in the water to wake him up, the music box was playing after all. She probably told him, "I saved you because you're the only one who can help me" and he fell for it.
if tabitha fell from the light tower, it’s hard to imagine that she didn’t die in fromville. Does this mean that people who die in fromville are transported back to the real world? Or is that a special case because of the boy in white? I’m curious if her body is laying below the tower
she didn't die as that's some sort of portal....but it only work under the right conditions, same with the faraway bottle tree....you can go into, but if the right conditions are not met, you won't end up at the lighthouse.
One thing ive just realized, how did Victor survive for all those years without the talismans? I mean the guy went about 30-40 years just hiding in different places every night? Brutal.
I think Eloise is still alive. That’s the greatest twist they are hiding. I feel Jim is not dead yet makers shows us future. Julie try to change past so that bring different impact on future.
Jim is not dead. In fact nobody dies as it's a time loop and it can all be changed. Julie is the key to time travel and she can stop the sacrifice ritual so it never happened. And stop everything.
Ethan is the narrator Tabitha and jade are the main characters victor is the survivor The man in yellow is one of the final bosses Boyd is the heart and soul if he dies the series dies Julie and Sara are players in this mission called survival And I think it would be cool if Acosta was Boyd wife reincarnated and what if Julie went back in time and saved father caffrey what won’t make sense if these entities just have to power to pop up anywhere because if so these people are as good as dead the doors don’t even have protection and the glass look like plastic lol I see upgrades coming and some really cool storylines
Are the lyrics of the opening song talking about Julie when it says "The future is ours to see, what"ll be will be" And its referring to how she can travel through time.
They seem to be on an average 14 months between each season, It is possible they get it out around Halloween next year. I got a feeling they are going to Film it in Spring, b/c it was end of winter in the show, stuff was coming back and if they set filming early spring then a fall release is def possible unless they plan on having it full summer again then they would have to wait till June ish. But we also have to consider when you hear 2026 it seems much further down the road but 2025 is like 6 weeks away. So even if they stay on that 14 month timeframe between seasons then early 2026 is just over a year.
I don’t think the man in yellow is the main bad he’s probably the rook or bishop of some sorts with all the chess references I would hate if he’s the only villain
Or he could be the architect. I think he's one of the main players in the sacrifice ritual with the kids but somehow he survived without turning full monster mode.
@@jonfreeman9682 lol Why wouldn't he be the one who offered them immortality and cursed them in fromville ? Even better. Maybe they were offered immortality for sacrificing their kids and turned into monsters. And to protect the world from them, the man in yellow (some sort of wizard) cursed them into fromville.
I’m curious about Acosta. She said in an interview that they were keeping her first name a secret because it was somehow important to the storyline. We know it now, but as far as I know it means nothing so far… Absolutely on board with the theory that Julie is from another time. I don’t trust that Jim is dead, or will stay dead… but I think if she is messing with time somehow things are about to get even more crazy. lol. Also I know we aren’t supposed to be rooting for the bad guys, but I’m so excited Smiley is back lol
It could be she's the reincarnation of Boyd's wifey who died. Don't worry Jim is not dead and next season Julie will master time travel and will go back to bring everyone back from the deal by stopping the sacrifice ritual in the first place to break the cycle. Anyone dies is reincarnated.
@@nikkidevereaux6306 they did call her by her name in the episode. A few times at the start. Easy to miss though. Dani. Im assuming spoilers from the episode are ok here since that’s what the video is. I didn’t know there was an interview out there with that revealed! I’m glad I missed that. I had the smiley thing ruined (my fault though)
for fans of DarK, this finale is like the ending of season 2. What we get after this could possibly be the most convoluted explanation, that ends up making sense, or we go full lost and have an unsatisfying end, with parables of heaven and hell
I think the hole is where Tabitha started to unlock her past self, that’s why he was warned to stop her and now when she fully remembers, he pays the price for his failure. I think not everyone that comes to the town is in this cycle, Jim for instance wouldn’t have been wiped out if he was important
Twin peaks scared the sht out of me. Honestly from isn't scary. Not the same level. You can't beat David Lynch atmospheric filming technique. And the sound work etc. Twin peaks has some ''comedy'' in it but it adds even more to the bizarre etc. From is just intriguing. Honestly I never really cared about what happened realy in twin peaks cause I was so absorbed. Here it's a other kind of addiction. I just want to know what happened. Even if the show isn't that good in a lot of points. If it's supposed to be scary, they do a terrible job at it ^^> you never have realy an atmospheric work on that part. Except from Sarah in the first season who was adding a lot of bizarre. And victor ofc !!! The rest of the people seemed pretty normal. That part is interesting too. How Jade reacted. And Boyd. The contrast of Boyd trying to stay grounded and the crazy stuff happening. But scary ? Mmmmm. Realy once or twice. Twin peaks freaking froze me when I watched it lol
go check victor mom paintings , look at the shirt in boy in white and the man in yellow , exacly the same he is the admin, past and future , fighting, thats why the town is stuck in limbo theres another wild theory about a huge spider , we can see multiple clues , and all the spiderweb in the woods etc , but check the paintings
People only act out of character when threatened. I believe when tab and jade remembered the man in yellow felt cornered. Which is why he killed Jim to balance the scales. Now Tab will have to deal with her husband's death along with the children
Maybe, now Tabitha and Jade are the OG couple and to advance that storyline Jim was supposedly killed as a hindrance. It kind of also is similar to the twin flame theory where the souls reincarnate to complete a shared purpose which in this case is to save the kids. The reincarnation and time travel trope is interesting as it could delve upon other characters, which also share the same connection to the town and might also possess otherworldly powers which could be crucial in defeating the monsters who have now almost 'undefeated skills'.
It just stiked me that the lighthouse could be a way to travel between fromville and real world just like the lighthouse is "LOST" which jacob used to keep watch on all the candidates
@beyondpremiere Hello there, i have a theory and would like to know your opinion! I think the boy in white is the son of tabitha from the first time, since she always had a couple, victor and heloise, ethan and julie! So my idea is that the girl was sacrifice and died, and the boy survived! Thats why only ethan and victor can see him plus tabitha! Plus the other part is that the Daughters can time travel, so heloise is not dead just in the future ( or in the past) while julie is discovering now this ability! Thats why Heloise is so good at hide and seek! I still didnt decided if the boy in white is time traveling thats why he is changing appearance! Or if he is just an identity but for sure i still think he is the son of jade and tabitha! I have more ideas but for now i will leave with this, thank you for your content and insights!
But Sarah also saw the boy in white in the forest. Sarah is not at all related to Tabitha, so this point negates your theory that the BIY is son of Tabitha.
I love the show and it’s really disappointing me that at first it told a really beautiful compelling story now it just feels like they’re basing the story off of all these theories people are making up. I hope season four is not more of This theory base plot that they’re moving!
Or it could be fans got it right. Those theories mean showrunners gave us enough clues to piece together a theory. Most of us guessed it already at the beginning of this season the monsters were the townsfolk who got their wish for immorality but paid the price with their humanity so turned into monsters. The poor children sacrificed in the ritual became spirits of the forest. Smiley is reborn as he's immortal and can't die even though the worms killed him. So next season we will see Julie develop her time travel powers and she can go back and break the cycle and this place and sacrifice never happened.
@@jonfreeman9682julie can’t stop the sacrifice from ever happening, you remember her brother said a story can never be changed when it has been already told?
people, I think that Mariel is related to Martin, season 2 she gave Christie a stone with an anchor, the anchor is associated with the marines, and the name Mariel itself is similar to the marine that is Martin.
@@BEYONDPREMIERE thank you, we know nothing about her except that she is Christie's fiancee, I started watching the second season again and noticed that.
The only way to stop all of this is to go back in time and prevent the townspeople from doing what they did. That will be the endgame. Julie will be able to save Jim as well.
I think we are overthinking about Eloise, I think she is dead already. Fatima says that the people of the town sacrificed their own children as it said they could live forever.. so who is it ? Some entity or the same voices that manipulated Elgin and Sarah. I think it's the same entity who has many other sub entries working for him including the Kimono lady and the man in yellow. Their job is to ensure that the curse remains intact in the town. Kimono lady appeared because she has the job to deliver the baby(smiley) while the man in yellow popped up when the melody is played and jade and Tabitha remembered who they were, so I guess all of these entities are trying to prevent the town and the people to remain under the curse.
I have a HUGE TWIST TO ADD WHAT IF THEY EVENTUALLY FIND A WAY TO TRAPP THE MONSTERS FORCING THE MAN IN YELLOW TO FKIP THE TOWN UPSIDE DOWN ! Let’s spice it up and connect random people to other visions maybe of other missions because let’s be honest everyone won’t be free if you free the children , what if he confuses them by giving them false hope another big influx of people with great knowledge of zombie’s basically nerds and they design a vehicle and weapons that actually subdue and puts the zombies in a short term paralysis only to decide to move the tree to find more clues and finds a tow. With an actual hotel and post office and gas station with tons of supplies only to find out while they discovered this new place things went haywire back home and survivors are forced to move to the new town
Is anyone else confused as to why there are several Season 1 monsters that haven't shown back up? Was it just a thing the actors weren't available and so just ignore it? Or maybe those monsters are off doing something else outside the town? Would like for someone to ask the creators this as it bugs me.
I think since Julie came back to save Jim and knew exactly whats was going to happen, it means it already happened in the past but still Julie came back to save Jim of the current. I think this cycle will keep on repeating itself and finally Julie would be able to convince Jim to run to the town....
I believe the first 3/4episodes will be all Julie time traveling through the past timelines starting with the 1506 and than episode 3 or 4 will end with her going to the event of season 3 finale and than pick up from there
Ok this is a long one, so we know there’s change going on with the town and the Boy in White (BiW). Now let’s look at the Man in Yellow (MiY). In the painting that Miranda made we see the Man in Yellow. We know that Miranda made these paintings based on the memories/influence of her past lives or people chosen before her. So the painting of the Man in Yellow may be from when he first introduced himself to the settlers. When we look at the painting he doesn’t look as ragged and old as he does now. Now I’m guessing that him and the BiW are similar beings in the town, meaning they may follow similar rules as well. Not only has the town been changing, but Victor has said that the BiW has clearly changed for the first time since he’s been there. What if this change has also affected the MiY. What if these changes are a visual representation of the paradigm shift that’s going on in the town. As the town folk are discovering more about what’s going on the MiY is aging and possibly getting weaker, which is why he shows himself and kills Jim. This would also explain why the BiW is starting to get older and may be growing in power. Now let’s talk about Martin, Julie, Randall and Marielle. I believe the MiY or who he’s working with is the person who has Martin locked up in the Tower. That’s because Martin giving Boyd his blood is the reason one of the monsters died. Not only did this lead to the death of one of the monsters, this also leads to the cicadas and Julie becoming a “Story Walker.” It makes sense that the entity doesn’t want these two abilities to get out, because they can lead to everything being undone. Now I know the next thing to wonder is were the cicadas killing people? Either they were, because only certain people have the ability to be a host for them similar to Martin while others die from it. On the other hand I believe it may have been the music box, look at it like a failsafe. It may have been truly killing everyone in there sleep, while at the same time it was imprisoning Julie, Randall, and Marielle, because they were chosen by the cicadas, to ensure that they wouldn’t be able to use these abilities that they’ve gained from the cicadas. I’m gonna try to tie this to the nursery rhyme. “They come for three,” the cicadas can only choose three people at a time. Let’s combine the “No one is free, unless you stop the melody,”everyone in town is in danger of dying while sleep and those three are forced in the dungeon. Then breaking the music box stops people from dying and frees them by stopping the song from playing, which further shows the strength of music in the town. “They touch,” this is Julie, a person who is caring and can touch the hearts of others. “They break,” this Randall, he’s been breaking the rules since he stepped in town. “They steal,” this is Marielle, because she stole the morphine. I also want to add that it’s strange that the MiY goes after Jim and not Tabitha, Jade or Future Julie, with those three being significantly more important than Jim. I don’t know if he knows about the reincarnation/spirit transfer that’s going on or he just doesn’t know who’s been chosen. This also explains why Tabitha and Jade showed up on the same day and why two cars coming on the same day is significant. I’m just gonna end this right here or I’ll keep going on. Someone look into the two car theory, because Miranda and Chris may have gotten there on the same day. I don’t think that’s something we’ve been told yet tho.
Another doubt: Tabitha tells Jim that she and Jade were here before in the form of Miranda and Christopher. She also tells Jim that Jade (Christopher) and she had a daughter, so does that mean Miranda had an affair with Christopher? What puzzles me is if it is so, when did it happen bcoz she already had her 2 kids in Victor and Eloise, when did she had Christopher's baby???
One rule of purgatory is the design can change at any time look for the scenery to change more often in the future there’s a good chance they find way more supplies and a more secure place where everyone can stay and why not it makes it easier for the monsters to trap them
My perspektive is that the soul of the man in yellow would live in them, or that it had already happened in the past and that he was alive now, but it was actually the man in yellow, or that he became Martin after that.
There's this theory going on I think it's much aligns with show The man is yellow is mabuse The spider is witch They both play cards game. On Sun eclipse everything get reset like everyone in town dies and we will get new people or new cycle. Tarot card used by witch also resembles where Tabitha saws Jim hanging in tower. Boyd and Sarah experice the spider as the spider is witch.
That's why he killed Lisa's father he has the capability to put things together to aid in the solution, whereas Jade and Tabitha have been failing every cycle. I also think that Julie's powers do not come from her being tortured but are a special gift passed to her because she is the daughter of the Tabitha reincarnated. in the same way her son seems to have a gift of perception with regards to how things fit together. The Entity wanted Tabitha's son killed and tried to break Julie's mind with torture. so if you put the two children and their father together with Tabitha answers would have been more quickly discovered in the future. the man in yellow took a bishop off the board
Did anyone else notice in 1 of the last episodes there was a scene with Ethan and his dad in the cafe that felt out of place because Ethan went to the toilet for unreasonably long time and unlike any othet scenes it wasnt contributing to the pllot in any way. When I saw it I was convinced there was someone in the toilet that he d meet. But nothing was revealed. So maybe next season we see him meet Julie from the future telling him smth he should know 🤔
Miranda and Eloise were killed leaving Victor on his own as a child. Now, Tabitha is left to protect Julie and Ethan. Will they also be slaughtered leaving Ethan as the eventual "Victor"?
When Ethan kills Victor and reveals who he is and there is no escape, thats going to be the real shocker of this show. They've had Ethan and Boyd in yellow the entire series of the show since season 1. Boyd is being "groomed" "broken", and with his horrible decision making he's losing pieces of his humanity thus slowly creating a new origin story as the man in yellow for a short time before the parkinsons takes over. And Ethan is all knowing, slowly telling the pawns where they should go and who they are in "the story". Whats his quest? Who's "story" is he telling? His own. Ethan seemed so confident that wasn't his brother on the radio in episode 10 and just walked away. In Season 2 Ethan gives Victor a drawing he made of himself that initially Victor refuses being he only draws things to remember the past and the dead. Yet They make a deal and Victor takes the drawing and in the drawing Ethan's wearing a bright YELLOW shirt.
Also I wonder if he never told Julie she was a story walker what would of happened to Jim, the boy in white said they have to figure it out on their own, and yet as soon as he told Julie, next time we see her she's jumped right into her father's death, from no other then the MAN IN YELLOW making his grand entrance.
this seems very unlikely regarding anthing to do with Ethan but one thing i think you are right is the suspicious way Ethan tells his father that it was not Thomas on the radio.
*I want to live the world of this series for a long time, please continue this series with many more seasons. It's a request. I'm so addicted to this show.* *"From" is my All-time favourite Web series.* 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌 *It's all seasons are worth watching 1000%* 👌👌👌👌👌👌 *I finished all seasons in one sitting.* *I haven't seen a show this good in ages.* 👌 *The name of the show should have been "Mysterious Town/Village". The reason why this show is not famous is because its title name "FROM" is not unique.*
You know Julie is gonna be able to change the story. Most likely she will save Jim amongst others. There’s no reason for all that set up otherwise. Also, if they get out they’ve changed the time paradox anyway.
I think the man in the chamber is victors father , wether in a past life or now but what if as they found ways to subdue the towns people they get more violent and it causes a great panic but what would spice this up is if maybe some bad guys got stuck in purgatory which this is wether they are alive or not this is purgatory
I have a theory too. - The monsters don't attack people who belong to the city. Only others. For example, people who have visions, hear voices or cicadas are not killed. I know that the monsters didn't kill Handall and Boyd when they could so they could break Boyd... so he would feel guilty. However, even when Boyd kills Smile, no one attacks him. I don't remember anyone with this connection to the city being killed by them, only 'normal' people. Or people who shouldn't be there and arrived by chance.
Most of what this guy says i've seen on reddit, did you get this from reddit or did you make the theories yourself. Not saying these theories are bad, i just want the creator of the theory have credit
Imagine trying to fight a mysterious monstrous looking man with a fciin stick instead of running at full sprint until your legs give out😂 Jim deserved to die.
I disliked how they didnt conclude that part of the season. I was really hoping they would expand on what they are going through before the end of the season.
There were 3 in the dungeon Julie, Mariel and Randall. So Julie is the story Walker then I believe the other 2 will have abilities and we will see their powers
Just clear my doubt: It seems that in the last scene of this series when Jim dies, Julie is not the present Julie bcoz her hairstyle is different, she sees her father and she knows that her father is going to get killed any time now, she pleads Jim to go to town but he does not listen to her and as a result, Jim dies... Does it mean that this cycle will keep on repeating itself and finally we will see Julie able to convince Jim to run to town and not get killed??
I posted this on Yesterdays video today. Do you think the man in yellow could be who was talking to jim on the radio when he said, "You better stop your wife from digging that hole."
That explains why victor was only warm woth Tabitha and jade adult wose because Tabitha gave him feelings of his mom and jade gave him feelings of Christopher which we now victor liked before he went "crazy" the only other person Victor even dlightly tolerates is ethan because ethan is his sister energy i think
Season 4 of From 10 Episodes Overview Episode 1: "Echoes of the Bell" Summary: A new character arrives in the town by boat, carrying a mysterious map and old photos. Tabitha struggles with the trauma of Jim’s death but begins experiencing visions of him. The children start having strange dreams filled with symbols hinting at “The Keepers,” powerful entities never seen before. The episode ends with the town hearing a mysterious bell tolling, signaling the arrival of a new danger. Episode 2: "Gate of Shadows" Summary: Boyd leads a group to find the source of the bell, while the newcomer reveals it signifies the opening of a deep underground gateway tied to "The Keepers." While exploring, the group discovers a network of tunnels under the church, filled with ancient markings. Tabitha sees disturbing visions of Jim, suggesting his death may have been linked to the opening of the gate. Meanwhile, a child who sketched strange symbols begins acting possessed, as though following unseen instructions. Episode 3: "Dreams of the Keepers" Summary: The nocturnal creatures begin behaving strangely, approaching the town without attacking. The children have shared dreams hinting that the Keepers control these creatures. The newcomer reveals the town is part of a larger experiment to "feed" the Keepers with human despair. Tabitha finds old, hidden letters from Jim that deepen the mystery of his connection to the Keepers. Episode 4: "The Sentinel Tree" Summary: Tabitha leads a group into the forest after seeing visions of a massive tree displaying faces of the dead, including Jim’s. They find a hidden entrance near the tree leading to deeper tunnels. Inside, they hear whispers warning them to turn back. The newcomer cautions against proceeding, but Tabitha presses on, desperate to understand Jim's role in the town's horrors. Episode 5: "Light in the Dark" Summary: Boyd and his team delve deeper into the tunnels, finding a ritual chamber etched with symbols linked to summoning "The Keepers." Back in the town, children fall into a trance-like state, speaking in an ancient language. One of them draws an image of the man in the yellow suit, hinting at his pivotal role in the unfolding events. A giant shadow is seen moving through the forest, terrifying the townsfolk. Episode 6: "The Man in the Yellow Suit" Summary: Tabitha begins having visions of the man in the yellow suit and learns he can travel freely between the town and the outside world. The newcomer reveals he encountered the same man before being trapped in the town and believes he is responsible for selecting victims for the town. Tabitha resolves to confront him to uncover the truth behind Jim’s death. Meanwhile, Boyd discovers that destroying the tunnels could bring catastrophic consequences. Episode 7: "The Chosen and the Lost" Summary: The truth about the town emerges: the Keepers feed on human suffering to maintain their existence. Tabitha learns Jim’s death was part of a balance designed to prevent the Keepers from fully manifesting. Boyd clashes with the newcomer, who insists that destroying the tunnels would release something far worse. Tabitha begins piecing together that the man in the yellow suit manipulated Jim’s fate. Episode 8: "Truth of the Keepers" Summary: Tabitha receives a cryptic dream leading her to a box hidden beneath the town. Inside, she finds items belonging to Jim, including a note in his handwriting that reads: "Tabitha, don’t let them open the gate." Meanwhile, the Keepers begin to materialize near the edges of the town, causing widespread panic among the residents. Episode 9: "Battle for Survival" Summary: The nocturnal creatures align with the Keepers to launch an all-out assault on the town, forcing the survivors to take refuge in the tunnels. The newcomer reveals that a specific ritual could seal the gateway and stop the Keepers, but it requires a sacrifice. Tabitha volunteers, driven by her visions of Jim, but she discovers the ritual may also release something far worse if performed incorrectly. Episode 10: "The Last Keeper" Summary: Tabitha prepares to sacrifice herself to complete the ritual, but she realizes at the last moment that the man in the yellow suit has been manipulating her to unleash the Keepers fully. Boyd leads a desperate counterattack against the creatures, using items discovered in the tunnels. The ritual is completed, sealing the gate and banishing the Keepers, but at a heavy cost: Tabitha sacrifices herself and disappears into the Sentinel Tree. In the final scene, the fog returns to the town, and the voice of the man in the yellow suit echoes: “The cycle begins anew.”
Thanks for leaking the plot summary. So it's still lots of fillers but we know that Julie is the key with her time travel powers she will go back and stop the ritual. The yellow king is the priest that conducted the sacrifice ritual.
I think the little girl that we thought was little tabitha is actually their daughter that was sacrificed and i think the BIW is the MIY ...🤍💛 white clothes yellow over time...or they are brothers?
📌 Quick update: Apologies for my voice in this video - I was fighting a cold during filming! But I couldn't wait to share these theories with you all. Huge thanks for your support and understanding! 🙏
Get well soon 🫰🏻
Thank you for fighting through your cold! I hope you feel better soon 😊
Fatima says the childs' parents sacrificed them, but Victor said that the BIW told Christopher that their loved ones and people they trusted did , and I think this is the correct version. If it was just the parents, we'd only have 12 monsters because 7 kids were sacrificed and two parents didn't participate. Besides, we have some young monsters who were probably their brothers in charge, the old lady who probably was some child's grandmother, might be some relatives too, etc. We have many more monsters than 12.
It's poetic you know. One Smiley dies. Another is born. Boyd kills Smiley and says 'My blood is in your blood now MF' Fatima gives birth and Smiley will be calling Boyd GRANDPA lol
Yooo I never even caught that parallel! 🤯 Wild how it comes full circle - Boyd takes out one Smiley while his grandbaby is literally part Smiley. That "my blood is in your blood" line hits SO different now 💀
@BEYONDPREMIERE Lol i hope in season 4 they will mention Smiley being the grandson of Boyd 🤣
My thought’s exactly.. Mr. Smiley about to be outside colony house apologizing to mom and dad for breaking curfew😂. Elgin gave blood too and lost an eye, Top Tier prenatal care.
@@jpatters1984😂😂
Yeah but Fatima was only a surrogate. It's not her baby, so Boyd it not the G'Pa.
For anyone who hate Jim here's what happened to him
1. Thomas die
2. Tabita wanna divorce
3. Last trip
4. Car crash
5. Son leg is staked
7. Found himself in contradict reality with his logic
8. Told that monster are real and stone have power
9. First experience monster
10. Julie wanna separate
11. Wife still bitchin
12. Son playing around with mentally crippled old man and having gun
13. Almost got Ethan slit by Sarah
14. Get hope by static radio
15. Big radio fail
16. MIY threatened him
17. Wife fall to the tunnel
18. Trying to save her only house to be collapse
19. Witnesses monster kill 2 person in close proximity
20. Getting injured and now need to be latched on tian chien
21. Get second idea only to put dona in danger
22. His wife always talking nonsense according to him
23. His wife also doesn't want to be calmed down
23. Julie get cicada-ed and almost died
24. Tabitha hell bent on becoming savior
25. His wife is unknown only to ethan get started pessimistic
26. Trying to searching his wife in the wood only for Ethan and Julie edging him to the brim
27. Taunted by dead son
28. Wife back and almost killed again
29. His wife is being blamed by from folks
30. Trying to calm down Tabitha, she saying he should be honest
31. Honest then wife get mad
32. His daughter mingling with old dude randal smoking zaza
33. Wife prefer listening to jade
34. Found out his daughter get seizure
35. Making up with his family
36. Finding out his wife and jade were destined
37 get killed by MIY
On top of that Jim didn't get supernatural vision, trying to maintain his logic and rationale, having 2 idea that cost life, his wife is stone headed, his daughter is rebel bitch, his son can't sit still and slowly becoming emo, he is not sitting around but helping townfolks, he's not bad parent, he already trusted townfolks
He is not insufferable, he just being realistic character
I completely agree jim is not a bad person or a bad parent.But tabitha ,julie and ethan are not bitch either ,maybe u hate his family like many others but others but no they are not bad either.
I enjoyed your comment, very well written, superb.
How could anyone hate Jim. He really was one of my favourites.
I agree jim is not a bad person or parent,but julie,tabitha and ethan are not so bad as u think,i understand u hate his family like many others but they are not bad
Jim went through a very realistic arc indeed, driven by logical thinking and trying to find a rational reason for everything happening. Amazing character that I will definitely miss!
One thing I noticed is the boy in white's refusal to explain things to victor. The last time he told christopher what was going on, the entire town was slaughtered. I believe there are rules and literally "knowledge has a price."
Miranda also told Victor not to hide anywhere Christopher knew about. I think he told where everyone was hiding for an advantage but like with Sarah and Elgin the entity lied. 🤔
I just know season 4 episode one is going to be so chaotic.
The massacre will be repeated .
I’m here for the chaos 😂 we didn’t get all the answers, and won’t till Season 5 as they’ve planned I’m sure. But I like the answers we got with the finale, so some big shake ups, new big questions would be fun. Just as long as they splice in some small answers hah
@@Manananggal-oe8gs how do u know?
@@himamandalia_15 think its just a theory
@@himamandalia_15 well smiley is back, and the man in yellow is set free(if i got that right), that's some good groundwork for a tragedy lol
The best way to start season 4 would be it opening to the original sacrifice the town people made of the children to Tabitha and Jades hosts at that time singing to the kids to that transitioning to present day and then dealing with everything….Also an overlooked part in my opinion was when Martin or the boy in white said “in order to change/fix everything you have to go back to the beginning”….when Jim has his flashback of him and the family driving, he literally says “remember how easy things were in the beginning”…maybe coincidence but I think there’s a correlation. Has to be
I honestly think that they should make a whole spin-off series about that called Welcome To From
There's a lot that they can unpack about the story of before and lead that into the story of "now"
I have a feeling there will be a full flashback episode next season that builds up to the sacrifice. And then maybe they will start showing what other sacrifices town people made to end up there.
i dont think this is how the shows writers like to tell stories. They wont give you everything at onceand from the start? oh boy😂
The man in yellow only came to intervene because they are getting too far with figuring things out. Before he indirectly intervened with stuff like the radio, but now that tabitha and jade know their past and are learning more he has to directly involve himself to stop them from getting too close to truly figuring things out. He didn’t need to intervene when they had no idea about their pasts, didn’t understand the bottle tree, the root symbols, how the monsters were created, etc. because the people didn’t pose a threat yet to him.
That's why he killed Lisa's father he has the capability to put things together to aid in the solution, whereas Jade and Tabitha have been failing every cycle.
I also think that Julie's powers do not come from her being tortured but are a special gift passed to her because she is the daughter of the Tabitha reincarnated.
in the same way her son seems to have a gift of perception with regards to how things fit together.
The Entity wanted Tabitha's son killed and tried to break Julie's mind with torture.
so if you put the two children and their father together with Tabitha answers would have been more quickly discovered in the future.
the man in yellow took a bishop off the boardThat's why he killed Lisa's father he has the capability to put things together to aid in the solution, whereas Jade and Tabitha have been failing every cycle.
I also think that Julie's powers do not come from her being tortured but are a special gift passed to her because she is the daughter of the Tabitha reincarnated.
in the same way her son seems to have a gift of perception with regards to how things fit together.
The Entity wanted Tabitha's son killed and tried to break Julie's mind with torture.
so if you put the two children and their father together with Tabitha answers would have been more quickly discovered in the future.
the man in yellow took a bishop off the board.
@@The-Mstr-PookWho the hell is Lisa?😂😂😂
@@wayofthekodiak3118the side chick 😂😂
But why does he kill jim and not tabitha/jade?? Jim is clearly less of a threat he isn't a reincarnated person, i don't understand
A random theory I just came up with: Maybe the boy in white doesn’t reveal too much information because the man in yellow said that information comes at a cost and would come after the boy in white.
That's what I'm thinking too. It's possible the boy in white is similar to Julie and he's going around in time, trying to change things in indirect ways.
When he shared information with Christopher it led to the Massacre which is why he's more circumspect with the information this time round and says they must find out the knowledge themselves.
Then that would make the boy in white, a supernatural being, a coward. How is giving helpful information detrimental? This isn't like learning a skill where you have to build knowledge incrementally to understand the theory. This is life and death for hundreds of people. Maybe thousands if this pocket dimension is allowed to exist longer. There has to be a compelling reason to not say anything otherwise the premise of the show comes off as a convoluted mess. Like Lost 😂
@wayofthekodiak3118 a loy of it has to do with how humans operate we aren't good at dealing with things that completely contradict our entire understanding of the world so if the BIW trued to get ol' Christopher to understand things that are so completely foreign to a 60 yr old dude in the 70's it makes sense that Christopher likely had a complete psychotic break
@@wintertrooper7918 No it doesn't. I can explain to a child what danger is, how to avoid it, and what to do if it's encountered. The writers are just trying to stretch things. For instance, the boy in white for SURE knows how to kill the monsters but doesn't offer even a hint.
You know I think about what happened with Abby when Boyd found those talismans when it comes to the “knowledge comes with a cost” statement
Tabitha isn't Miranda, but whoever came before, Dating back to the original incarnations that disagreed with the towns sacrificing of their kids. Same with Jade, he's not Christopher. They're all still their own incarnations, but a looped incarnation of the OG's that defied the man in yellow's offer (or whoever controls the man in yellow if that's the case)
The reason the boy in white sent tabitha to mirandas house was to help her remember her previous incarnation which would eventually lead her and jade to remember their OG incarnations/memories. They only NOW remember what happened on the night the town's curse was created. So, yes. She WAS miranda and jade WAS christopher. But they remembered wayyyyy more than just Miranda's and Christopher's memories.
The angkooey kids dont want them to remember being miranda and christopher... those incarnations failed. They wanted them to do what non has done yet, and thats REMEMBER WHO THEY ORIGINALLY WERE AND WHAT THE TOWN DID. The answers to leave lie in the beginning, not of the show... but of fromville itself. This was all very clearly explained in the show.
Also, about the bottle tree. All that is, is a way that past incarnations have tried to help future incarnations remember absolutely everything. I.e. they only remembered the full scope of things once they played the song (and jade subconsciously remembered the songs importance while solving the bottle tree. Which is funny cuz thats the nursery song they used to sing to their OG kid) therfore i can only take away that that was the whole purpose of the numbers in the bottles. Man in yellow is now angry and killed jim for assisting in solving the numbers because the incarnations arent suppose to remember. Jim made the man in yellows job way harder than it had to be and now the town actually has a chance to fight back against him because of jim, tabitha, and jade. They remember!! Now they just need julie to storywalk to the beginning and give them clues on how to stop the town curse and free the kids
I agree,i believe they have been reincarnated multiple times.
It's possible they've been recycled many times. Not sure how the reincarnation works but guessing their spirit jumps from one life to another.
@@jonfreeman9682 not a possibility, it's simply so. That's stated, if not insinuated in the most recent episode. Thats one of the first things I say in my comment up top ☝️... We don't really know when the curse started or how many cycles it's been since. But it's definitely been a lot of cycles.
Yes! All of your answers seem right on track!
Perfect
if you watch an episode of from from every 2 weeks from now it would last you until 2026 😅
hahaha let the game begin
i would rather jump off the bridge than rewatcj the show lol
its not a good rewatch
@commisionerq1374 Whats funny is I probably wouldn't mind rewatching to maybe catch something I missed the first time
@@commisionerq1374 I love the show
@@aithjawcraig9876I have rewatched it a few times and found it is one of the more rewatchable shows.
Man in yellow being one of the monsters being out in broad daylight leads me to think that all the monsters will be out in daylight however they'll only be in the forest and not the town, BUT if you remember Victor saying to Ethan in the diner (I forget the exact measurement) "The trees have moved 3 inches" or something, also leads me to believe that they will maybe some day have the trees by the town and monsters will be able to walk around the town during the day then also.
I probably explained that INSANELY poorly but I do like the theory of it.
The yellow king is likely the priest who oversaw the sacrifice and the kimono lady the priestess but he took her share of immortal powers so he retains his human form even in daylight and can puppeteer the other monsters while kimono lady stays a spirit as skeletor 💀
@@jonfreeman9682oh nice I like that actually
Kids mind
Scary thought...
🤯 oh, I kept thinking well at least they just come out at night, but you may be right.
I feel like the town keeps changing the rules once the trapped figure something out.
I thought when Jim told Jade about music in that place that Jade playing that music bought the man in Yellow
I think the man in yellow only came out to interfere because they now know a lot of things.
Don't think the music brought the yellow king but only the kids. The yellow king is the puppet master who controls the monsters and enjoys the show in the background. They did the same thing in lost with the yellow king except he wasn't yellow. The same guy wrote the story for lost and this show so is recycling old ideas.
The man in yellow appeared only to kill Jim because he was responsible for Jade and Tabatha figuring out about the melody
@@jonfreeman9682"Recycling old ideas" 👍🏽
If there were 7 sacrificed children, and the Tabitha/Jade child was one of those, that leaves 6 kids. With 2 parents. Meaning that there are only 12 monsters? I thought there was more than that.
I also want to see how much the Boy in White continues to age up in Season 4. I'm guessing he might age up to actually become the Man in Yellow.
They sacrificed 6 children period. It’s wasn’t their direct kids… maybe a few.
@@RaneishaMorris I mean the souls of Tabitha/Jade. We don't know their original names so really can't come up with a better name for them. And there were indeed a total of 7 kids on the slabs being sacrificed, not 6. They also said in the show that the monsters were given immortality for sacrificing their children.
there more monster atleast according to creatures page in from fandom wiki
Julie has the opportunity to travel where her family showed up in fromville and get them to walk past the tree, or even when the bus showed up and have that group move the tree off the road.
Everyone turns back when they reach the tree, there's either an exit that way or that's where the children are trapped.
I dont think Julie has the 'three eyed raven's power, she cannot go into the past wherever she likes, it happens automatically. She cannot choose which event she can go back to...
I’m wondering if the Man in Yellow will start appearing to the residents more often now. What’s funniest is that we, as viewers, know about him, but currently none of the residents have any idea he exists. Either they’ll find out because he reveals himself to them, or Julie will be the first one to learn about him in the future.
I think Ethan is a reincarnation of Victor hear me out. So after S3 E10, I decided to start watching season 1 again, when Ethan wakes up after they fix his leg Ethan talks about the tears in the water, and talks about seeing all the drawings on the wall, the scene then goes to Victor drawing the accident. Ethan has always been close with Victor, Ethan also can see the boy in white, I'm pretty convinced about this now, after what we saw in S3 E10.
Ethan can't be reincarnation of Victor as Victor is still alive ..in.hindu mythology reincarnation works as when one soul leaves a body then it is reborn in another means one has to die to reincarnate
I agree with you. The only reason Victor is alive is because he got stuck in Tabitha and Jade timeline.
@@saurabhcinemuze He is the reincarnation. But for some reason Victor didn't die or got stuck in the next generation/timeline.
@ doesnt make any sense
I was thinking this too because of when the voices told Sarah to kill Ethan. Wondering if that’s the reason everything is changing because she didn’t do it and now two of the same souls/characters/reincarnations are there at once.
Why did the man in Yellow on painting have a scar on his cheek same as Randall? Martin knowing julie finally makes sense due to time travel, also if u look at Jades arm in episode 1 hes got Tabithas bracelet on
The boy in white said they have to learn themselves. I am starting to think the boy in white and the man in yellow are two players using people in town as chess piece. Like a game, there are rules put in place they have to follow.
Julie can't change the past but maybe she can influence some change.
True, reminds me of Jacob and MiB from Lost.
@@belgradewanderer That's exactly what I was thinking. Like the MiB, he interferes directly, uses other pieces like the monsters... The boy, like Jacob let people make their own decision.
If Julie cant change the past, how come she threw the rope in the well that saved Boyd?
Makes me wonder if the boy in white is similar to Julie and he's traveling through time. Would explain why he seemed frustrated when he told Victor they'd have to learn on their own.
@@macster1613 I think it's because she didn't change anything but was part of that event. She was supposed to throw the rope. If she comes back to that moment again, she wouldn't be able to stop herself from doing it.
People been whining like babies about "slow pace" when it was a masterful buildup, elegantly developing characters and laying out the themes elegantly leading to this final episode. And I knew it all along. Do you people now realize this show is not meant to be treated merely as a puzzle and "owing" you some major reveals like regularly every episode? So stupid
Thank you! Totally agree!!
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Facts... Tell them
Welcome to the real world where people want answers instead of being around the bush. Imagine if a person like you and that person was unclear about their motives, would you stick around and waste all your phone minutes? No, you would stop talking to that person but when it comes to a television show people will wait 5 years to find out the truth.
But it wasn't elegantly or masterfully developed. It was sloppy. When you compare it to a show that WAS elegantly developed, it's easy to see. Something like Breaking Bad is a perfect example. FROM is fun to watch, but calling it "masterful" is a stretch. The first season of True Crimes is Masterful. The first EPISODE of FROM can be called that.
Had a puff and thought, season 4 will begin with Jim not dead, it will show his death in a more conventional means, not making it indoors before sundown. The paradox is Julie returning to that time and triggering the man in the yellow suit.
Too much puff...
Jim is not dead. Neither is Chen or Nikki or Tom or it priest. But Julie is the key to unlocking time travel.
@@jonfreeman9682Julie, Randall, and That blonde chick all can manipulate time in different ways. Right now we know Julie can walk into the past. Who knows what the others can do.
Great episode, but them tying big old Elgin up with some string had me crying laughing. I mean, big boy could have just raised his arms up, and it would have snapped the string. 😭
I’m going to go through withdrawal not seeing my friends in Fromville until 2026, but I’m glad it got picked up for another season. I’m sad what happened to Elgin. He seemed like such a sweet soul. Now the questions. I thought the ending was a little abrupt. I understand you need to have some loose threads, but there were too many. The issue with Lost which the director or producer is tied to brought in too many story lines which is too much for an audience. Tighten things up a bit (my non-professional opinion) 😊. If the monsters became immortal because they sacrificed their children, there is a teenage boy. Did he have a child? Maybe not an important question? You introduce the spiders and Bam no more word about them. Maybe there should have been a little more about their importance. I liked Boyd a lot. Now no more. He kind of disgusted me in the last episode. Such a sad character drop. I have high hopes for Kenny to take over. Also, they left poor Randall struggling with the bug sounds. It would have been nice to end this season with some other character development as to what is his next chapter. But again, I’m not a writer and overall From is a brilliant storyline concept with great actors.
I need to see a flashback of the original towns people
Boy in White, Man in Yellow and Kimino lady were once a family. Kimino lady drowned the boy in white and sent the man in yellow in a fit a rage that made him kill kimino lady. Opening credits even has the kimino lady and man in yellow with the dog drawn. Now they are like you said, playing chess with each other
Wouldnt the boy in white be half asian unless he was adopted ig
@@-Sceneshorts- I'm not sure but yeah maybe. Just looking back on earlier seasons it's hard to really know what the writers are trying to tell us a clue or just a red hearing. Think Elijin and his lake scare. Besides maybe one or two scenes we really haven't even seen the lake nor come close to what it has to do with Eligin even though I'd imagine he would be more afraid of sarah of all things. Or Tabitha and Miranda being different ethnitancy but yet still are the same person.
Yes it's possible. They're definitely all connected in some way. Yellow king and kimono lady seem to be higher up in management and could be the priest and priestess who conducted the sacrifice. The boy in white could be one of the sacrifice kids who fought back.
Elgin should have think twice before helping Kimono lady. The same lady tried to kill him by drowning him in bathtub. How’s she is good and helping them to get out from Fromville.
I don't think she was trying to kill him; she pushed him in the water to wake him up, the music box was playing after all. She probably told him, "I saved you because you're the only one who can help me" and he fell for it.
if tabitha fell from the light tower, it’s hard to imagine that she didn’t die in fromville. Does this mean that people who die in fromville are transported back to the real world? Or is that a special case because of the boy in white? I’m curious if her body is laying below the tower
she didn't die as that's some sort of portal....but it only work under the right conditions, same with the faraway bottle tree....you can go into, but if the right conditions are not met, you won't end up at the lighthouse.
So that means if Father Khatri die he should be transported back to the real world?
One thing ive just realized, how did Victor survive for all those years without the talismans? I mean the guy went about 30-40 years just hiding in different places every night? Brutal.
I think Eloise is still alive. That’s the greatest twist they are hiding. I feel Jim is not dead yet makers shows us future. Julie try to change past so that bring different impact on future.
100% agree with the Julie theory. I said the same thing as soon as I watched. I hate that we have to wait til 2026 lol
@ True 🤧
@@jeaninekivimaki5593they said it's not 2026 but 4th quarter of 2025
Jim is not dead. In fact nobody dies as it's a time loop and it can all be changed. Julie is the key to time travel and she can stop the sacrifice ritual so it never happened. And stop everything.
Ethan is the narrator
Tabitha and jade are the main characters victor is the survivor
The man in yellow is one of the final bosses
Boyd is the heart and soul if he dies the series dies
Julie and Sara are players in this mission called survival
And I think it would be cool if Acosta was Boyd wife reincarnated and what if Julie went back in time and saved father caffrey what won’t make sense if these entities just have to power to pop up anywhere because if so these people are as good as dead the doors don’t even have protection and the glass look like plastic lol I see upgrades coming and some really cool storylines
I have a theory that the town needs to start working on their cardio. Those monster can RUN!
I do feel like the solution might be in the trees. Remember that boy in white told not to cut down trees. That could be the solution.
Are the lyrics of the opening song talking about Julie when it says
"The future is ours to see, what"ll be will be"
And its referring to how she can travel through time.
@@seanakima50515e the song has multiple meanings may revisit it 🙌
In the beginning when the teenage monster boy asked Julie if if she remembers him, I bet you that’s from a time jump
monsters didnt killed boyd becoz he is smileys grandfather😂😂😂
😂
They seem to be on an average 14 months between each season, It is possible they get it out around Halloween next year. I got a feeling they are going to Film it in Spring, b/c it was end of winter in the show, stuff was coming back and if they set filming early spring then a fall release is def possible unless they plan on having it full summer again then they would have to wait till June ish. But we also have to consider when you hear 2026 it seems much further down the road but 2025 is like 6 weeks away. So even if they stay on that 14 month timeframe between seasons then early 2026 is just over a year.
@@incredible5587 still so long way 😭
I don’t think the man in yellow is the main bad he’s probably the rook or bishop of some sorts with all the chess references I would hate if he’s the only villain
Or he could be the architect. I think he's one of the main players in the sacrifice ritual with the kids but somehow he survived without turning full monster mode.
@@jonfreeman9682 lol
Why wouldn't he be the one who offered them immortality and cursed them in fromville ?
Even better. Maybe they were offered immortality for sacrificing their kids and turned into monsters. And to protect the world from them, the man in yellow (some sort of wizard) cursed them into fromville.
I’m curious about Acosta. She said in an interview that they were keeping her first name a secret because it was somehow important to the storyline. We know it now, but as far as I know it means nothing so far…
Absolutely on board with the theory that Julie is from another time. I don’t trust that Jim is dead, or will stay dead… but I think if she is messing with time somehow things are about to get even more crazy. lol.
Also I know we aren’t supposed to be rooting for the bad guys, but I’m so excited Smiley is back lol
It could be she's the reincarnation of Boyd's wifey who died. Don't worry Jim is not dead and next season Julie will master time travel and will go back to bring everyone back from the deal by stopping the sacrifice ritual in the first place to break the cycle. Anyone dies is reincarnated.
Heavy Spoilers did an interview with the actor who plays Kenny and he revealed her name.. I forgot what it was but it didn’t seem significant
@@nikkidevereaux6306Dani
I’m actually very annoyed that smiley is back. I hated that character and and I really hate that he has come back.
@@nikkidevereaux6306 they did call her by her name in the episode. A few times at the start. Easy to miss though. Dani.
Im assuming spoilers from the episode are ok here since that’s what the video is.
I didn’t know there was an interview out there with that revealed! I’m glad I missed that. I had the smiley thing ruined (my fault though)
for fans of DarK, this finale is like the ending of season 2. What we get after this could possibly be the most convoluted explanation, that ends up making sense, or we go full lost and have an unsatisfying end, with parables of heaven and hell
I think the hole is where Tabitha started to unlock her past self, that’s why he was warned to stop her and now when she fully remembers, he pays the price for his failure. I think not everyone that comes to the town is in this cycle, Jim for instance wouldn’t have been wiped out if he was important
They answered enough questions to keep me interested. Can't wait for season 4 😃
The man in yellow gave me Bob vibes from twin peaks for some reason
Twin peaks scared the sht out of me. Honestly from isn't scary. Not the same level. You can't beat David Lynch atmospheric filming technique. And the sound work etc.
Twin peaks has some ''comedy'' in it but it adds even more to the bizarre etc.
From is just intriguing. Honestly I never really cared about what happened realy in twin peaks cause I was so absorbed.
Here it's a other kind of addiction. I just want to know what happened. Even if the show isn't that good in a lot of points. If it's supposed to be scary, they do a terrible job at it ^^> you never have realy an atmospheric work on that part. Except from Sarah in the first season who was adding a lot of bizarre. And victor ofc !!! The rest of the people seemed pretty normal. That part is interesting too. How Jade reacted. And Boyd. The contrast of Boyd trying to stay grounded and the crazy stuff happening. But scary ? Mmmmm. Realy once or twice. Twin peaks freaking froze me when I watched it lol
go check victor mom paintings , look at the shirt in boy in white and the man in yellow , exacly the same
he is the admin, past and future , fighting, thats why the town is stuck in limbo
theres another wild theory about a huge spider , we can see multiple clues , and all the spiderweb in the woods etc , but check the paintings
@@RicardoRangel-v3l may do one final video in the hidden clues, thanks for the suggestion
Maybe he's the younger version of the man in yellow and he just took that form to look less suspicious or less evil has a child
People only act out of character when threatened. I believe when tab and jade remembered the man in yellow felt cornered. Which is why he killed Jim to balance the scales. Now Tab will have to deal with her husband's death along with the children
Maybe, now Tabitha and Jade are the OG couple and to advance that storyline Jim was supposedly killed as a hindrance. It kind of also is similar to the twin flame theory where the souls reincarnate to complete a shared purpose which in this case is to save the kids. The reincarnation and time travel trope is interesting as it could delve upon other characters, which also share the same connection to the town and might also possess otherworldly powers which could be crucial in defeating the monsters who have now almost 'undefeated skills'.
It just stiked me that the lighthouse could be a way to travel between fromville and real world just like the lighthouse is "LOST" which jacob used to keep watch on all the candidates
@beyondpremiere Hello there, i have a theory and would like to know your opinion! I think the boy in white is the son of tabitha from the first time, since she always had a couple, victor and heloise, ethan and julie! So my idea is that the girl was sacrifice and died, and the boy survived! Thats why only ethan and victor can see him plus tabitha! Plus the other part is that the Daughters can time travel, so heloise is not dead just in the future ( or in the past) while julie is discovering now this ability! Thats why Heloise is so good at hide and seek! I still didnt decided if the boy in white is time traveling thats why he is changing appearance! Or if he is just an identity but for sure i still think he is the son of jade and tabitha! I have more ideas but for now i will leave with this, thank you for your content and insights!
That’s something I hadn’t thought about, but it does make sense.
Sarah also saw the BIW.
But Sarah also saw the boy in white in the forest. Sarah is not at all related to Tabitha, so this point negates your theory that the BIY is son of Tabitha.
Wondering would playing the music where the children are laying on the stones not the bottle tree
either nothing or something bad would happen as like what they said before, if the music is at the tree, it should be played there.
Let's hope that season 4's gonna answer our questions instead of giving a bunch of new ones.... One of the best series ever.❤
I love the show and it’s really disappointing me that at first it told a really beautiful compelling story now it just feels like they’re basing the story off of all these theories people are making up. I hope season four is not more of This theory base plot that they’re moving!
Or it could be fans got it right. Those theories mean showrunners gave us enough clues to piece together a theory. Most of us guessed it already at the beginning of this season the monsters were the townsfolk who got their wish for immorality but paid the price with their humanity so turned into monsters. The poor children sacrificed in the ritual became spirits of the forest. Smiley is reborn as he's immortal and can't die even though the worms killed him. So next season we will see Julie develop her time travel powers and she can go back and break the cycle and this place and sacrifice never happened.
@@jonfreeman9682julie can’t stop the sacrifice from ever happening, you remember her brother said a story can never be changed when it has been already told?
people, I think that Mariel is related to Martin, season 2 she gave Christie a stone with an anchor, the anchor is associated with the marines, and the name Mariel itself is similar to the marine that is Martin.
@@natalist8391 waaao that’s an incredible observation. Let see what happens two years for the next season haha
@@BEYONDPREMIERE thank you, we know nothing about her except that she is Christie's fiancee, I started watching the second season again and noticed that.
The only way to stop all of this is to go back in time and prevent the townspeople from doing what they did. That will be the endgame. Julie will be able to save Jim as well.
I think we are overthinking about Eloise, I think she is dead already. Fatima says that the people of the town sacrificed their own children as it said they could live forever.. so who is it ? Some entity or the same voices that manipulated Elgin and Sarah. I think it's the same entity who has many other sub entries working for him including the Kimono lady and the man in yellow. Their job is to ensure that the curse remains intact in the town. Kimono lady appeared because she has the job to deliver the baby(smiley) while the man in yellow popped up when the melody is played and jade and Tabitha remembered who they were, so I guess all of these entities are trying to prevent the town and the people to remain under the curse.
I agree. I think people are overthinking the Eloise storyline
I have a HUGE TWIST TO ADD WHAT IF THEY EVENTUALLY FIND A WAY TO TRAPP THE MONSTERS FORCING THE MAN IN YELLOW TO FKIP THE TOWN UPSIDE DOWN ! Let’s spice it up and connect random people to other visions maybe of other missions because let’s be honest everyone won’t be free if you free the children , what if he confuses them by giving them false hope another big influx of people with great knowledge of zombie’s basically nerds and they design a vehicle and weapons that actually subdue and puts the zombies in a short term paralysis only to decide to move the tree to find more clues and finds a tow. With an actual hotel and post office and gas station with tons of supplies only to find out while they discovered this new place things went haywire back home and survivors are forced to move to the new town
Is anyone else confused as to why there are several Season 1 monsters that haven't shown back up? Was it just a thing the actors weren't available and so just ignore it? Or maybe those monsters are off doing something else outside the town? Would like for someone to ask the creators this as it bugs me.
So that was Julie from the future trying to warn Jim….look at her hair.
I think since Julie came back to save Jim and knew exactly whats was going to happen, it means it already happened in the past but still Julie came back to save Jim of the current. I think this cycle will keep on repeating itself and finally Julie would be able to convince Jim to run to the town....
I believe the first 3/4episodes will be all Julie time traveling through the past timelines starting with the 1506 and than episode 3 or 4 will end with her going to the event of season 3 finale and than pick up from there
Ok this is a long one, so we know there’s change going on with the town and the Boy in White (BiW). Now let’s look at the Man in Yellow (MiY). In the painting that Miranda made we see the Man in Yellow. We know that Miranda made these paintings based on the memories/influence of her past lives or people chosen before her. So the painting of the Man in Yellow may be from when he first introduced himself to the settlers. When we look at the painting he doesn’t look as ragged and old as he does now. Now I’m guessing that him and the BiW are similar beings in the town, meaning they may follow similar rules as well. Not only has the town been changing, but Victor has said that the BiW has clearly changed for the first time since he’s been there. What if this change has also affected the MiY. What if these changes are a visual representation of the paradigm shift that’s going on in the town. As the town folk are discovering more about what’s going on the MiY is aging and possibly getting weaker, which is why he shows himself and kills Jim. This would also explain why the BiW is starting to get older and may be growing in power. Now let’s talk about Martin, Julie, Randall and Marielle. I believe the MiY or who he’s working with is the person who has Martin locked up in the Tower. That’s because Martin giving Boyd his blood is the reason one of the monsters died. Not only did this lead to the death of one of the monsters, this also leads to the cicadas and Julie becoming a “Story Walker.” It makes sense that the entity doesn’t want these two abilities to get out, because they can lead to everything being undone. Now I know the next thing to wonder is were the cicadas killing people? Either they were, because only certain people have the ability to be a host for them similar to Martin while others die from it. On the other hand I believe it may have been the music box, look at it like a failsafe. It may have been truly killing everyone in there sleep, while at the same time it was imprisoning Julie, Randall, and Marielle, because they were chosen by the cicadas, to ensure that they wouldn’t be able to use these abilities that they’ve gained from the cicadas. I’m gonna try to tie this to the nursery rhyme. “They come for three,” the cicadas can only choose three people at a time. Let’s combine the “No one is free, unless you stop the melody,”everyone in town is in danger of dying while sleep and those three are forced in the dungeon. Then breaking the music box stops people from dying and frees them by stopping the song from playing, which further shows the strength of music in the town. “They touch,” this is Julie, a person who is caring and can touch the hearts of others. “They break,” this Randall, he’s been breaking the rules since he stepped in town. “They steal,” this is Marielle, because she stole the morphine. I also want to add that it’s strange that the MiY goes after Jim and not Tabitha, Jade or Future Julie, with those three being significantly more important than Jim. I don’t know if he knows about the reincarnation/spirit transfer that’s going on or he just doesn’t know who’s been chosen. This also explains why Tabitha and Jade showed up on the same day and why two cars coming on the same day is significant. I’m just gonna end this right here or I’ll keep going on. Someone look into the two car theory, because Miranda and Chris may have gotten there on the same day. I don’t think that’s something we’ve been told yet tho.
Another doubt: Tabitha tells Jim that she and Jade were here before in the form of Miranda and Christopher. She also tells Jim that Jade (Christopher) and she had a daughter, so does that mean Miranda had an affair with Christopher? What puzzles me is if it is so, when did it happen bcoz she already had her 2 kids in Victor and Eloise, when did she had Christopher's baby???
No no, she meant herself and jade were a couple in the beginning when the sacrifice stuff happened and then they keep coming back again and again.
One rule of purgatory is the design can change at any time look for the scenery to change more often in the future there’s a good chance they find way more supplies and a more secure place where everyone can stay and why not it makes it easier for the monsters to trap them
I like how children = shildren, but then she's alive = cheese alive
2026 is a long wait but the bigger evil that the chained up guy mentioned to Boyd we still don’t know who they are
It might be sooner. At the rate they drag the story with 80% fillers it shouldn't be too hard to shoot the next season.
All hail the king in yellow
We got the how everything happened. But now we need to know why. What’s The Man In Yellow’s main motivation.
My perspektive is that the soul of the man in yellow would live in them, or that it had already happened in the past and that he was alive now, but it was actually the man in yellow, or that he became Martin after that.
Would live in Jim*
There's this theory going on I think it's much aligns with show
The man is yellow is mabuse
The spider is witch
They both play cards game.
On Sun eclipse everything get reset like everyone in town dies and we will get new people or new cycle.
Tarot card used by witch also resembles where Tabitha saws Jim hanging in tower.
Boyd and Sarah experice the spider as the spider is witch.
We need Ed ,Lorraine and Sherlock holmes to solve this!!😅😂
Did anyone notice Acosta name is Danielle and Kenny called her Dani!
That's why he killed Lisa's father he has the capability to put things together to aid in the solution, whereas Jade and Tabitha have been failing every cycle.
I also think that Julie's powers do not come from her being tortured but are a special gift passed to her because she is the daughter of the Tabitha reincarnated.
in the same way her son seems to have a gift of perception with regards to how things fit together.
The Entity wanted Tabitha's son killed and tried to break Julie's mind with torture.
so if you put the two children and their father together with Tabitha answers would have been more quickly discovered in the future.
the man in yellow took a bishop off the board
Season 3 Finale remember me the Season 3 Finale of LOST. When it was revealled Jack and Kate left the Island in the Future
If there was a movie spinoff for ‘smiley’, it would be a box office success! The guy is scary!!!!
Did anyone else notice in 1 of the last episodes there was a scene with Ethan and his dad in the cafe that felt out of place because Ethan went to the toilet for unreasonably long time and unlike any othet scenes it wasnt contributing to the pllot in any way. When I saw it I was convinced there was someone in the toilet that he d meet. But nothing was revealed. So maybe next season we see him meet Julie from the future telling him smth he should know 🤔
I think they should do an ark where the towns people start taunting and chastising the monsters forcing the town to change up and get more gruesome
Boyd unknowingly made a pact with the DIABLO
Randall is the man in yellow a million percent
Why?
@@susandelgado6926 Scar on the man in Yellows face in the painting.
Miranda and Eloise were killed leaving Victor on his own as a child. Now, Tabitha is left to protect Julie and Ethan. Will they also be slaughtered leaving Ethan as the eventual "Victor"?
that's an interesting observation mmm I don't think so Ethan is loved. but who knows in this show haha
When Ethan kills Victor and reveals who he is and there is no escape, thats going to be the real shocker of this show. They've had Ethan and Boyd in yellow the entire series of the show since season 1. Boyd is being "groomed" "broken", and with his horrible decision making he's losing pieces of his humanity thus slowly creating a new origin story as the man in yellow for a short time before the parkinsons takes over. And Ethan is all knowing, slowly telling the pawns where they should go and who they are in "the story". Whats his quest? Who's "story" is he telling? His own. Ethan seemed so confident that wasn't his brother on the radio in episode 10 and just walked away. In Season 2 Ethan gives Victor a drawing he made of himself that initially Victor refuses being he only draws things to remember the past and the dead. Yet They make a deal and Victor takes the drawing and in the drawing Ethan's wearing a bright YELLOW shirt.
Also I wonder if he never told Julie she was a story walker what would of happened to Jim, the boy in white said they have to figure it out on their own, and yet as soon as he told Julie, next time we see her she's jumped right into her father's death, from no other then the MAN IN YELLOW making his grand entrance.
this seems very unlikely regarding anthing to do with Ethan but one thing i think you are right is the suspicious way Ethan tells his father that it was not Thomas on the radio.
*I want to live the world of this series for a long time, please continue this series with many more seasons. It's a request. I'm so addicted to this show.*
*"From" is my All-time favourite Web series.* 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
*It's all seasons are worth watching 1000%* 👌👌👌👌👌👌
*I finished all seasons in one sitting.*
*I haven't seen a show this good in ages.* 👌
*The name of the show should have been "Mysterious Town/Village". The reason why this show is not famous is because its title name "FROM" is not unique.*
You know Julie is gonna be able to change the story. Most likely she will save Jim amongst others. There’s no reason for all that set up otherwise. Also, if they get out they’ve changed the time paradox anyway.
I think Julie will go back in time and save Eloise? (tell her to go through a faraway tree maybe?)
I think the man in the chamber is victors father , wether in a past life or now but what if as they found ways to subdue the towns people they get more violent and it causes a great panic but what would spice this up is if maybe some bad guys got stuck in purgatory which this is wether they are alive or not this is purgatory
I have a theory too.
- The monsters don't attack people who belong to the city. Only others. For example, people who have visions, hear voices or cicadas are not killed. I know that the monsters didn't kill Handall and Boyd when they could so they could break Boyd... so he would feel guilty. However, even when Boyd kills Smile, no one attacks him. I don't remember anyone with this connection to the city being killed by them, only 'normal' people. Or people who shouldn't be there and arrived by chance.
Smiley killed Miranda
Most of what this guy says i've seen on reddit, did you get this from reddit or did you make the theories yourself. Not saying these theories are bad, i just want the creator of the theory have credit
Imagine trying to fight a mysterious monstrous looking man with a fciin stick instead of running at full sprint until your legs give out😂
Jim deserved to die.
I need to know whats going on with randall, Christie and marelle
I disliked how they didnt conclude that part of the season. I was really hoping they would expand on what they are going through before the end of the season.
They're souls are still maybe bind in the chamber .
Julie not Christie but yeah
They have their mind infected by cicadas and can't get it out. They'll both survive though.
There were 3 in the dungeon Julie, Mariel and Randall. So Julie is the story Walker then I believe the other 2 will have abilities and we will see their powers
Just clear my doubt: It seems that in the last scene of this series when Jim dies, Julie is not the present Julie bcoz her hairstyle is different, she sees her father and she knows that her father is going to get killed any time now, she pleads Jim to go to town but he does not listen to her and as a result, Jim dies... Does it mean that this cycle will keep on repeating itself and finally we will see Julie able to convince Jim to run to town and not get killed??
I posted this on Yesterdays video today.
Do you think the man in yellow could be who was talking to jim on the radio when he said, "You better stop your wife from digging that hole."
Yup
if yall like from, I recommend dark on netflix!
You got a point about Victor he said he could never find Her during Hide and seek.
That explains why victor was only warm woth Tabitha and jade adult wose because Tabitha gave him feelings of his mom and jade gave him feelings of Christopher which we now victor liked before he went "crazy" the only other person Victor even dlightly tolerates is ethan because ethan is his sister energy i think
Anghokooey means Remember, who the hell thought about it??
Knowledge comes at a cost. Yeah, 6,7 years (5 seasons) of more and more questions and an occasional answer.
Season 4 of From
10 Episodes Overview
Episode 1: "Echoes of the Bell"
Summary: A new character arrives in the town by boat, carrying a mysterious map and old photos. Tabitha struggles with the trauma of Jim’s death but begins experiencing visions of him. The children start having strange dreams filled with symbols hinting at “The Keepers,” powerful entities never seen before. The episode ends with the town hearing a mysterious bell tolling, signaling the arrival of a new danger.
Episode 2: "Gate of Shadows"
Summary: Boyd leads a group to find the source of the bell, while the newcomer reveals it signifies the opening of a deep underground gateway tied to "The Keepers." While exploring, the group discovers a network of tunnels under the church, filled with ancient markings. Tabitha sees disturbing visions of Jim, suggesting his death may have been linked to the opening of the gate. Meanwhile, a child who sketched strange symbols begins acting possessed, as though following unseen instructions.
Episode 3: "Dreams of the Keepers"
Summary: The nocturnal creatures begin behaving strangely, approaching the town without attacking. The children have shared dreams hinting that the Keepers control these creatures. The newcomer reveals the town is part of a larger experiment to "feed" the Keepers with human despair. Tabitha finds old, hidden letters from Jim that deepen the mystery of his connection to the Keepers.
Episode 4: "The Sentinel Tree"
Summary: Tabitha leads a group into the forest after seeing visions of a massive tree displaying faces of the dead, including Jim’s. They find a hidden entrance near the tree leading to deeper tunnels. Inside, they hear whispers warning them to turn back. The newcomer cautions against proceeding, but Tabitha presses on, desperate to understand Jim's role in the town's horrors.
Episode 5: "Light in the Dark"
Summary: Boyd and his team delve deeper into the tunnels, finding a ritual chamber etched with symbols linked to summoning "The Keepers." Back in the town, children fall into a trance-like state, speaking in an ancient language. One of them draws an image of the man in the yellow suit, hinting at his pivotal role in the unfolding events. A giant shadow is seen moving through the forest, terrifying the townsfolk.
Episode 6: "The Man in the Yellow Suit"
Summary: Tabitha begins having visions of the man in the yellow suit and learns he can travel freely between the town and the outside world. The newcomer reveals he encountered the same man before being trapped in the town and believes he is responsible for selecting victims for the town. Tabitha resolves to confront him to uncover the truth behind Jim’s death. Meanwhile, Boyd discovers that destroying the tunnels could bring catastrophic consequences.
Episode 7: "The Chosen and the Lost"
Summary: The truth about the town emerges: the Keepers feed on human suffering to maintain their existence. Tabitha learns Jim’s death was part of a balance designed to prevent the Keepers from fully manifesting. Boyd clashes with the newcomer, who insists that destroying the tunnels would release something far worse. Tabitha begins piecing together that the man in the yellow suit manipulated Jim’s fate.
Episode 8: "Truth of the Keepers"
Summary: Tabitha receives a cryptic dream leading her to a box hidden beneath the town. Inside, she finds items belonging to Jim, including a note in his handwriting that reads: "Tabitha, don’t let them open the gate." Meanwhile, the Keepers begin to materialize near the edges of the town, causing widespread panic among the residents.
Episode 9: "Battle for Survival"
Summary: The nocturnal creatures align with the Keepers to launch an all-out assault on the town, forcing the survivors to take refuge in the tunnels. The newcomer reveals that a specific ritual could seal the gateway and stop the Keepers, but it requires a sacrifice. Tabitha volunteers, driven by her visions of Jim, but she discovers the ritual may also release something far worse if performed incorrectly.
Episode 10: "The Last Keeper"
Summary: Tabitha prepares to sacrifice herself to complete the ritual, but she realizes at the last moment that the man in the yellow suit has been manipulating her to unleash the Keepers fully. Boyd leads a desperate counterattack against the creatures, using items discovered in the tunnels. The ritual is completed, sealing the gate and banishing the Keepers, but at a heavy cost: Tabitha sacrifices herself and disappears into the Sentinel Tree.
In the final scene, the fog returns to the town, and the voice of the man in the yellow suit echoes: “The cycle begins anew.”
@BEYONDPREMIERE any theories on this? Plz make another content on this before man in yellow slit my throat for exposing “leak”💀
damn bro you cracked the code
makers want to know you location
Unrealistic. Add more filler
Thanks for leaking the plot summary. So it's still lots of fillers but we know that Julie is the key with her time travel powers she will go back and stop the ritual. The yellow king is the priest that conducted the sacrifice ritual.
This seems AI generated.
I think the little girl that we thought was little tabitha is actually their daughter that was sacrificed and i think the BIW is the MIY ...🤍💛 white clothes yellow over time...or they are brothers?
When will season four will come , can anyone tell me?
2026
I think Jim's daughter's hair is small and the look different did someone notice it
Everyone did.😊
Man in yellow was young in the drawings but he looks so old in reality ???
2026 because they now know they have us hooked