Alert Alert | Chat GPT used for Question Papers | ICAI Testing Pattern | CA Final | CA Inter

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 117

  • @caramharsha
    @caramharsha  18 днів тому +16

    You can check MTPs and Suggested Answers of ICAI for AI-generated content using tools like (quillbot.com/). But at many resources used by ICAI are being humanized with tools. So difficult to detect.
    Please note that, Already AI Generated content is being humanized If any content is flagged and the same can refined with tools that make the text sound more natural and human-like. In some cases, parts of MTPs and RTPs may already pass these checks and were humanised so that we cannot detect AI involvement.

  • @amitdayma1345
    @amitdayma1345 15 днів тому +31

    Yes he is saying true .......even paper setter is not able to solve such mcq and they are expecting from students...
    ...

  • @catopper6880
    @catopper6880 18 днів тому +189

    Wow. Now I understand why electronic gadgets are strictly banned in CA exam 😂😂😂

  • @intersmartians841
    @intersmartians841 18 днів тому +61

    yes i felt that same doubt last time also...you have rightly identified sir...super inisight...

  • @sagarchandwani3013
    @sagarchandwani3013 18 днів тому +106

    No wonder why they always give incorrect information in mcq... Because paper setters believes AI has more Knowledge than them

  • @chrupa8513
    @chrupa8513 18 днів тому +35

    Sir has identified it earlier itself as he already told in regular class .. Now he is sharing with all of us..🖤with his insights and teaching style which entirely changed how people feel about Audit subject
    Thankyou so much sir

    • @Visible-e9m
      @Visible-e9m 11 днів тому

      Yeah he told n showed demo's by using Gemini AI

  • @srutheravindran2010
    @srutheravindran2010 18 днів тому +23

    But be careful while using Chat Gpt for studying. When we give the illustration and ask it to explain the answer, it identifies mistakes in ICAI materials. But it does not know what portions we have now under the new scheme. But it is beneficial for studying concept-wise and explanation-wise.

    • @Lovelylilacccc678
      @Lovelylilacccc678 12 днів тому +1

      Yes you are right it is not updated

    • @Lovelylilacccc678
      @Lovelylilacccc678 12 днів тому +1

      Or not having complete knowledge we have to put whole paragraph 🥲 and this was time consuming

  • @noddy....7403
    @noddy....7403 18 днів тому +15

    So this is the reason that there were so many errors in questions in almost all the subjects

  • @menorahbenjamin4731
    @menorahbenjamin4731 18 днів тому +31

    No wonder why is that 100 pages lengthy 😂

  • @_A_Student_
    @_A_Student_ 18 днів тому +37

    using AI Detectors by Grammarly or Copyleaks to check if the MCQs are generated by AI would have been a better test, GPTs (Generative Pretained Transformers) use a specific pattern to predict words and frame sentences and these tools can tell how much of some text is AI generated.

    • @chinmay511
      @chinmay511 15 днів тому +1

      @_A_Student_ is it real? AI generated texts can be recognised? How?

    • @avi_official
      @avi_official 13 днів тому +1

      Bro did you tried this if yes then what was the result

  • @Chartered_Edu
    @Chartered_Edu 18 днів тому +38

    Ram Sir just take a glimpse of strategic management MCQs from RTPs of MAY'24. I was literally shocked when I used tool called "ai detector ". 😂😂 100% ai framed.

    • @Fixit7590
      @Fixit7590 18 днів тому +2

      Really bro🤔

    • @Chartered_Edu
      @Chartered_Edu 18 днів тому

      @Fixit7590 check kro bhaii

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +8

      Perfect. I'll come with proof

    • @Chartered_Edu
      @Chartered_Edu 18 днів тому

      @@caramharsha it starts "swasthya". Use ai detector from Google sir. 😁💀

    • @noddy....7403
      @noddy....7403 18 днів тому

      Ruko mai bhi check karta hu ..agar 100% plagiarized hoga toh pakka Chatgpt use hua hai

  • @poojabashetty
    @poojabashetty 16 днів тому +6

    I remember sir...u were telling in our CA Final class that ICAI may use ChatGPT for framing questions...and u were 💯 correct 😅 ur brilliant guess turned out to be true 😁👏🏻

  • @2stoicsm
    @2stoicsm 18 днів тому +13

    Dont wake up the people sir . The question papers have been easy in inter past 2 attempts . Especially audit MCQ
    Let them pass🤫🤫

  • @keepsmiling1603
    @keepsmiling1603 18 днів тому +8

    Thank you for this sir. 🙏

  • @Rafey124
    @Rafey124 18 днів тому +13

    Thank u sir for wake-up call

  • @maheshtambe7056
    @maheshtambe7056 14 днів тому +3

    Wow it's really helpful for your concepts 😅😅
    Thanks a lot

  • @shradhashelar6195
    @shradhashelar6195 18 днів тому +6

    Thank you so much sir😊

  • @Ramadan23-w9w
    @Ramadan23-w9w 14 днів тому +2

    OMG your subscriber reached 73k . Its really great achievement . I’m a CA who was watching your youtube audit video when subscriber around 5k

  • @manjunathmt2816
    @manjunathmt2816 17 днів тому +19

    How sir you break the thought 😮
    Modern problem requires modern solutions 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @CA_Divya1111
    @CA_Divya1111 12 днів тому +2

    So finally we get to know how to practice FR
    Icai ❌
    AI ✔️

  • @CAFinalRevision9
    @CAFinalRevision9 15 днів тому +3

    That's why the papers are so difficult now😮already the syllabus was so vast, now its unlimited 😂😂😂

  • @dollyojha5040
    @dollyojha5040 18 днів тому +6

    Late usa cpa we are gttng like that only n every student and each time it's different untill india don't copy evn it's surprising for teachers and students but it's time to get modern n evolve with techniques

  • @prashantkolage6091
    @prashantkolage6091 18 днів тому +14

    Thanks, sir... Can you make a short video on how to become conceptually clear in any subject? OR add this point in the May 25 strategy video.

  • @NehaYadav-i1h
    @NehaYadav-i1h 13 днів тому +3

    This is helpful for Cs executive too 😮 thanks sir❤❤

  • @subhashbarse3379
    @subhashbarse3379 18 днів тому +8

    OMG , that's why the papers becomes so lengthy ...😢

  • @som0325
    @som0325 15 днів тому +2

    Thanks for the info sir😊🙏🏻
    Love your South Indian accent😍

  • @vivekjain9944
    @vivekjain9944 18 днів тому +4

    It's a very very useful as well as meaningful video❤

  • @ps-gh3hu
    @ps-gh3hu 18 днів тому +9

    I tested ICAI Q&A on chatgpt 4.0 & gemini 2.0. almost 6 to 12 marks Answers are itsef wrong 😢
    Looks like ICAI drafted Q from GPT but gave their own answers, or they they trained their LLM agent on incorrect deta set 😢 millions of careers destroyed in coming days 😞

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +1

      They design using AI and humanise it. Also some subject expert will modify to suit requirement of exam.

  • @dineshvadivelan4245
    @dineshvadivelan4245 18 днів тому +22

    I was shocked when the fr mcq generated by Ai is looks similar in exam paper😢
    I dono what is going to happen in future.

  • @BuJyo
    @BuJyo 18 днів тому +4

    superb insight

  • @anirudhgupta2814
    @anirudhgupta2814 18 днів тому +3

    Yes sir if we check the mcq of tax papers the questions are so vague...i was laughing the whole time about how senseless those questions looked😂

  • @shravanyadav6266
    @shravanyadav6266 13 днів тому +1

    Recently i used an chatgpt for my sol 1 st semester practical exam
    And i got an 15/80 marks😢

  • @sonisrivastava7223
    @sonisrivastava7223 16 днів тому +1

    I love your sound acent sir

  • @santoshnandagiri5393
    @santoshnandagiri5393 17 днів тому +1

    Super sir
    Very much valuable information and insights Shared.

  • @lokendarsinghshekhawat8403
    @lokendarsinghshekhawat8403 16 днів тому +1

    Namaskar sir please share this type of information vedio before 1 month exam and very nice information provided by you thanks lot from jaipur

  • @Lovelylilacccc678
    @Lovelylilacccc678 12 днів тому +1

    I think Chat gpt is best for practicing question..

  • @MeaAnjali786
    @MeaAnjali786 12 днів тому +2

    Financial Reporting ❌ Financial Restructuring ✅😂

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  12 днів тому

      The topic is taken from financial reporting subject

  • @बोध_मात्र
    @बोध_मात्र 16 днів тому

    I have used chat gpt for making mcq for my exam preparation in audit

  • @psppp08
    @psppp08 18 днів тому +4

    Sir make a video about last day must do questions from each chapters from all subjects sir...
    I have seen ism already twice, but In many places I forgot to mark which question is imp but I can't sit nd see all questions again as time won't permit, many of my friends also did the same mistake, but we want to rectify it sir...
    Kindly make it sir within exams

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +1

      Will make it ASAP. Stay tuned.

  • @souravkumarray8155
    @souravkumarray8155 16 днів тому +3

    Jobs nai mil rahe hai aur chat gpt based question paper , IBS ke naam par mazaq bana ke rakha hai , jo pass ho gaye unko job ke liye tension aur jo nai huye unhe attempts ka tension

    • @annubhai3143
      @annubhai3143 15 днів тому

      ky kre m found m hu

    • @CAMahfoozNazir
      @CAMahfoozNazir 11 днів тому

      ​@@annubhai3143 always keep a secret backup plan incase of badluck

  • @sahilmore7342
    @sahilmore7342 15 днів тому +2

    But didn't the prompts will form a part of database and when some one access or search such prompts they will not exactly the same but similar cases/questions??

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  15 днів тому +1

      That why they don’t purely depend on AI. It will be humanised with our intelligence and can be made tough

  • @Bharathv12
    @Bharathv12 18 днів тому +1

    This is huge sir dont know if it happens in real QP, but ICAI is promoting AI these days for sure with ICAI GPT & AI videos in channel. This does mean that we have to be conceptual strong. We cant prepare for all mcqs since it is no more a "rumoured pool of MCQs questions" thats probably y MCQs QP are released from CA inter sept 24. Its unlimited question potential with AI & Subject matter expert thats the msg sir want to pass.
    I dont feel it is wrong move if it is the case - the questions should be reframed correctly by subject expert. it will increase the standard of questions if used right way. Maybe they can also develop great case studies here by giving the format from other global level professional exams as an additional prompt.
    But yeah time consumption should be kept in mind too lengthy papers coming out. I noticed it in CA Inter sept 24 glad I finished off both grps 😅😅😅. Anyway new challenges coming in CA final and articleship.
    Thank you soo much for making this video sir 🤩🤩

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому

      Soo matured reply. Yes. We have to be extreme commandable in conceptual learning. We can easily answer any sort

  • @srinusatyanarayana1302
    @srinusatyanarayana1302 15 днів тому +2

    If they really used AI for setting the paper... It is a kind of very shameful act ...

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  15 днів тому

      Nothing shameful..today obvious everyone uses AI. They use it and apply mind for user and make it complicated. Only AI cannot ask tough questions.

    • @srinusatyanarayana1302
      @srinusatyanarayana1302 13 днів тому

      ​@@caramharshaBut sir, what is the use of having so called resource persons in the board,
      Can't they even set the question papers on their own.
      I have a huge respect on you sir, but sorry for contradicting with you in this matter.

  • @arindam21jana
    @arindam21jana 13 днів тому

    Oh my God 😂......unbelievable....

  • @Lovelylilacccc678
    @Lovelylilacccc678 12 днів тому

    case scenario in paper is in similar pattern they give 🙄 wow great....

  • @kkkk-ry5ys
    @kkkk-ry5ys 18 днів тому

    Thankyou sir

  • @Shiva-f2e3l
    @Shiva-f2e3l 18 днів тому +2

    What about those questions in which option is incorrect?

  • @abhishekagarwal4559
    @abhishekagarwal4559 13 днів тому +1

    sir but the answers were too much different in comparing with both ICAI and chat gpt especially in practical paper

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  13 днів тому

      Yes. That’s why AI is not an absolutely substitute but can be used to make ourselves more abled.

  • @BuJyo
    @BuJyo 18 днів тому +14

    and thats why they allowed us to take question papers this time, ICAI be like ab questions ka resources unlimited hogaya hai

    • @Bharathv12
      @Bharathv12 18 днів тому

      @StarxOp412 Yes mcq QP can taken from sept 24 attempt

    • @CA_Divya1111
      @CA_Divya1111 12 днів тому

      I was thinking same

  • @DilliSanketh-t6s
    @DilliSanketh-t6s 18 днів тому +6

    But In reality a Case scenario consists atleast 2 to 3 chapters and each MCQ is restricted to a single passage in such lengthy case study ..If concept is clear for us then you can complete easily

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +4

      Yes. If we give input with multiple concepts then it will design interlinked case study itself. It all depends on input

  • @candycrazy2588
    @candycrazy2588 18 днів тому +4

    Sir pls upload law marathon part 2

  • @beright56
    @beright56 9 днів тому

    Hi sir i am ca student cleared ca foundation in 2022 i gave ca intermediate 4 attempt still did not clear ca inter 😢many other youtubers are uploading vedios that even after clearing Ca final 50% CA's are unemployed 😢i am in confusion about exam and future kindly make vedio on this sir please please please 😖🥲🥹😭

  • @adityas2537
    @adityas2537 18 днів тому +3

    Sir , Please give an update regarding marathons for ca inter may25 attempt..eagerly waiting

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому

      Feb mid onwards will upload all subjects

    • @adityas2537
      @adityas2537 18 днів тому

      @SHRESHTAForCAandCMA thankyou sir for the response 🙏

  • @FireSparkle-mt7ce
    @FireSparkle-mt7ce 18 днів тому +4

    Even another sir told same icai is now using AI

  • @jaaneshvimal
    @jaaneshvimal 18 днів тому +4

    Sir can you upload a preparation strategy for CA Final for May 2026 ?

    • @jaaneshvimal
      @jaaneshvimal 18 днів тому

      @@Dhana93 my attempt is May 26 bro

    • @Dhana93
      @Dhana93 18 днів тому

      @@jaaneshvimal ok

  • @pradnya31ca
    @pradnya31ca 7 днів тому

    What is the purpose of this video?
    Should we use chat gpt for mcq practice?

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  7 днів тому

      No need. Be conceptually strong. I told the same in video..if u watched fully u would have got it

  • @hafsaaa4089
    @hafsaaa4089 18 днів тому +5

    Sir will you upload video for foundation?

  • @DAZN_INDIA
    @DAZN_INDIA 8 днів тому

    Source?

  • @sagarchandwani3013
    @sagarchandwani3013 18 днів тому +4

    Icai even gives mcq question in which you have to chose the wrong option

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +2

      That's the new pattern you need to be aware of.

    • @Chartered_Edu
      @Chartered_Edu 18 днів тому

      @@sagarchandwani3013 broo I really didn't understand what u said..pls rephrase this.

    • @muralipasumarthi7881
      @muralipasumarthi7881 17 днів тому

      What he said is , icai make you choose wrong answer (prepare question like that)

  • @worldfighter4779
    @worldfighter4779 18 днів тому +2

    Is it because of hair style or something Idk why looking like weak , take care of you sir..❤

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +2

      I’m becoming fit. That’s why. Yea. Hair cut recently.

  • @jiteshdewani8981
    @jiteshdewani8981 17 днів тому

    Sir, how to see the correct option

  • @Dhana93
    @Dhana93 18 днів тому

    How to score 40 marks with minimum efforts because i am very poor at theory

  • @BhagyammaBadhagoni
    @BhagyammaBadhagoni 18 днів тому +1

    Sir iam ca inter student
    Iam going to attempt in jan
    Sir can you pls tell
    The repeated sections in tds tcs icai will ask because I want to leave sir due to huge content

  • @premmonani5653
    @premmonani5653 15 днів тому +1

    bro stop giving them ideas 🤦‍♂

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  15 днів тому

      To best of my knowledge they are following this since a year ago. Nothing new.

  • @chandrakumari5407
    @chandrakumari5407 8 днів тому

    It mostly given wrong answer...

  • @gokularaman1826
    @gokularaman1826 18 днів тому +2

    Question prepared by chatgpt are easy sir 🤩

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +5

      Can be complicated easily with human intervention

  • @kunalpanwar3098
    @kunalpanwar3098 12 днів тому

    Toh achaa h na

  • @s_reddy
    @s_reddy 18 днів тому +7

    CA exams board is so creative.
    😌They make ups stunts in exams :
    If we pass finally we get pennys of salary .
    Which ACA, US CPA easily gets ... without performing useless stunts.

  • @aunzaidi6394
    @aunzaidi6394 18 днів тому +6

    Nothing new
    Obviously chat gpt can make mcqs
    But it doesn't prove that icai is using it!
    And even if they use it that does not change anything.

    • @caramharsha
      @caramharsha  18 днів тому +5

      That's why told they using AI tools..that's what reflected in Question Papers especially MCQs. CA GPT also ICAI providing and using for material works.

    • @aunzaidi6394
      @aunzaidi6394 18 днів тому +1

      @SHRESHTAForCAandCMA may be sir
      But i agree with the last part that we should work on concepts rather than practicing mcqs👍

  • @Biswajit2019-n3y
    @Biswajit2019-n3y 18 днів тому

    Yeah true

  • @ashrafanjum3601
    @ashrafanjum3601 17 днів тому

    Thank you so much sir