I really liked this idea. Sometimes we don't always take the original into account because Pentatonix tends to blow us away. Hope comparisons become a regular feature. Nice suggestion, Jane!!
Shai does an a Capella version of the song that Pentatonix got the ooh-da-da-do-da-do and some of the blends... Pentatonix was great of course but comparing the acapella versions might be even better
I really enjoyed the comparison to the videos. I believe the Shari was a more of a sensuality during the 90s. The Baywatch reference had me snickering as I'm 55 and all I remember was Pamela Anderson. In the Pentatonix version Just throwing quick snippets if Kirsten just giving a look pulled the sensuality into play. Well done and a great idea.👍👍👍
Music like this is so beautiful and when other people sing it it’s soooo beautiful I’m listening to other people sing this song rn and it’s melting my heart 💙
I love the idea for this video. I'd like to see more comparison videos. As always, I tend to like Pentatonix's version a lot better. They always tend to raise the bar in my opinion.
One thing to note is that Shai has 2 versions of this song. The original (which is Acapella) and the remix which is the one you compared to. Pentatonix and Jason D incorporated both in this cover. The first half they did the Acapella version of Shai's song and the 2nd half where Scott comes in they were covering the remix version. Quite frankly i LOVE all 3 versions. Have always loved Shai and love PTX!
Isn't it ridiculous what Pentatonix can do with a cover? I always love their covers compared to the originals. I can't think of an exception, and this collab was off the charts. And I love that PTX doesn't need to be the center of attention in a collaboration. They let Jason Derulo shine (and Scott). Love the idea of comparing an original to a PTX cover!!
What I find interesting is that when ptx does a colab they let the guest shine, but they also bring out the best in the guest. You might say ptx sets up the guest for success.
I love the comparison format! We Pentaholics do generally feel that the PTX version rises above the original in most cases, so it would be interesting to get the opinion of someone well versed in the realm of music to put that conviction to the test. I suspect the acid test might be "Bohemian Rhapsody", as even Pentatonix long avoided covering it because... well, hell... it's Queen! And they didn't want to do an unworthy cover. Whether it was better or not (and I'm sure there will be vocal advocates on both sides of that argument...), I'd definitely contend that it was, at the very least, worthy, and that Freddie would have approved.
Jerod, this was a great idea -- comparing an original with a PTX cover. I LOVED the blues feel of Shai's version, but -- I may be slightly biased (LOL), PTX's version just rocks the planet!! The vocals and harmonies are much more prominent and clear. Both were good, but my heart is set on PTX. . . PS. Jason DeRullo just rocks it!!
Weird thing about Shai's version of this is the music. They were originally an acapella group, this song had no music until it was re-released. I liked it better without to be honest. The "vibe" was 100% 90's..lol.. over sexed with heavy bass feels like it's been a million years but I was in high school bk then. I like the PTX version better! ❤ your reactions!😍😍
I do like this format, Jerod. I typically prefer what PTX does over the original artist predominantly because I don't listen to a lot of pop/r&b type music simply because it's a lot of looping and autotuning. Once PTX's version is burned in my brain, it's hard to accept any other version. When Papaoutai came out, I decided to seek out the original first and then watched the PTX version. Now I do that for ever cover song I encounter. It deepens my appreciation for what PTX does, how gifted they are at deconstruction, reconstruction and elevation of the original without losing the original intent. I agree whole heartedly that Jason's voice was more powerful than Shai's and the collab pushed this one over the top! Thank you again for your reaction.
I didn’t. I stated that I don’t listen to a lot of pop/r&b. Here’s a grammar lesson on the use of forward slash between words: “To Indicate Or” Often, when a slash is used in a formal or informal text, it is meant to indicate the word or. Grammarly › blog › slash Slash: Grammar Rules About How to Use a Slash
I remember this song first time round (Yes I'm THAT old 😱) it was HUGE (I'm in Ireland and only huge hits made a dent over seas and this was really popular due to mtv branching out over here on our national broadcaster on a sunday) I LOVED this song back then and PTX version is AMAZING. Shai was of their time obviously and they did a version with the start that PTX use here (The do dada do do do) but PTX just killed it, and Jason's voice is spectacular
I would have recommended "Valentine" but you already did it. The original is... not sure what to call it. Unique, maybe. I would never have listened to it if not for the PTX cover. Just like with this one, I like both versions and I typically like the PTX better on their covers.
YEP, No question which group was the best. I used to do these comparisons more than I do now but it is almost always PTX that comes out on top. And, with just five voices and no instruments. They are the masters at what they do. Incredible talent and they all have an attitude of giving 110% for everything they do.
Never heard of ptx,they were great,however I disagree that ptx won..what was missing and integral was Shai's sensuality...this song was never about power and in your face...
I never watched Shai's video but now that I've seen it I can definitely say that I prefer PTX's version! Btw are you going to react to their cover of Praying (that's on their new album) soon? :) It's gonna blow your mind!
This wasn’t a fair comparison. Shai does an A Capella version of their song which is the version Pentatonix came with. I love both groups but I’m an 80’s baby so Shai won me over back when I first heard this as it was magical during its time. Pentatonix added a bit more, but Shai hit it in the element that it was in.
You need an addendum with Shai's acapella version of this song. Actually, that would have been the better original comparrison. Now that you've heard the PTX version, Shai's is a step down though still one of my favorites in the day. I had a cassette single copy. Still have it, in fact. ☺
I avoided the acapella one because while pentatonix is only acapella, they are filling in beats and bass. Shai's acapella version is good, but the comparison was different because it lacked the low end and beat.
Im sorry but Shai is still better the tone of the music fits better Pentatonix sound like a pop version if i didnt read who sings the other version i would of guess back street boys or Nsync.
I like Pentatonix but I don't really like this version of the song it's so soulless compared to the original. This song is about losing somebody you thought was the love of your life a swearing off love ever again unless you can find that one special love. It's sad and mournful not peppy and aria's to show of your vocal skills. It's passion not playtime.
Never heard of the second group other than Jason Derulo tbh and while listening I was disappointed with the cover that the second group did because I feel like they did way too much. When I hear this song I expect something romantic and soft and smooth the second group can sing but I was not a fan of the cover. The second group was too loud and just ruined the whole vibe for me. Sometimes we need to leave classics alone because knowing how to sing does not mean you would sound good in just any song. Sorry not sorry
Ok, how can you compare the two. One came out with the original song in 1992, Plantonix basically copied everything Shai did. The original song will always be the best version because it let Plantonix copy each note and just add their touch to it. If Plantonix was the original singers than you can say they were best but all they did was speed up the beat and make it more of a dancing song. Shai version was a r&b slow jam. Plantonix did not add anything to it but a beat box. They copied every note Shai did
How can I compare them? Because one group sang it and then another one sang it. I want to see how each group interpreted the song and how they delivered the vocals. One group did it without any beat, Pentatonix* did it with a beat. That’s the point of the comparison. Not to say one is better or worse but to hear the two side by side.
@@JerodM but that's not true. The original song by Shai was done without a beat. That's why Plantonix did a remix. Shai performed it acapela without any beat boxing or anything. They sung it with no music at all. No disrespect to you but that's why Plantonix or Jason didn't change a note because it was already done before almost 20 years ago. I give them respect because they didn't messed up the remix and they sped up the tempo. Shai has always been known for singing acapela. Just like boys to men. Trust Plantonix is following in those people steps. They are a good group but they are nothing we haven't seen before in r&b
Shai has that version and the acapella version, both are great but I remember growing up listening to the acapella one on the radio! Damn I miss the 90s lol
This is me with music and PTX. Original Song: "Ooooh, I really like that!! Great song!" PTX version: "Holy ***!!!! WOW, that's........it's.........dude, they're INCREDIBLE!!!" Yeah. Every single time.
Awesome! I'm so glad you liked my idea. Thanks for fulfilling my request so soon. The first time I watched this video, I didn't like the Shai version very much. I'm listening again right now, and this time I do. It's not fair to compare a recording and video from--what, 1992, was it?--with a recent one, but I do really prefer the clarity and "cleanness" (is that a word?) of the PTX/JD version, as opposed to the soft, kind of fuzzy texture of Shai's version. The solidity of Avi's bass provides an anchor. Little nitpick--Jason's highest notes sound a bit shrill to me. He's right on pitch, though, and really amazing. All the rest of the time his voice is beautiful. I wouldn't mind another collab. I wonder why, whenever PTX does a collab with another soloist, the PTX soloist is always Scott. (Since I wrote "always," somebody is sure to tell me about an exception.) Finally--I really love the effect of the stripes of colored lights. The green on Kevin's face is breathtaking. Jerod, PLEASE do more comparative videos when the opportunity arises!
Based on Jason Derulo's most popular songs you wouldn't really think he was as talented as he really is because those are some ridiculous silly songs they are catchy but still didn't show his talent like this one did and also when he was on sytycd that showed how talented he is in dance. This was definitely better than the original it was just so full and awesome. mitch even said that Jason could sing higher than him I thought that was funny. Also it was Kevin that saw Jason at one of the awards shows and just walked up to him and said hey we're pentatonix and we should do something together and then this happened! :)
Please keep doing this comparisons! I love the idea and was already excited when you explained it, but now I've seen it and it was amazing! And as a viewer not just your comparison is very interesting, but I was also comparing them while watching and when you talked about, I could see if you also noticed different things and stuff like that, so it was a really interesting and nice video!
I don’t think I’ve heard a PTX cover yet that I don’t prefer to the original. They nail it every time. I would like to see you check out their cover of Ride. It’s not on their official channel, it’s on Nova FM.
I loved the comparison! This video/song has never been my favorite... I still enjoyed it, it just wasn't my favorite. Doing the side by side like this made me appreciate it on a totally different level. Thank you! 🙂
Ptx always adds so many flavors to a song: in this one, Avi’s beautiful bass, Scott’s lead with his runs, Mitch even had a little run section that was SO cool and unexpected, Kirsten added glamour and the full backgrounds, and KO with the beats, plus the masterful arrangement and Jason D. was so powerful! I never really got into this song until you did this comparison reaction and suddenly I was noticing all sorts of good stuff. Loved your comments!. Thx Jerod!
Great reaction! I also went and listened to the Shai version when I first heard this - and it's funny that you used the word "creepy" when talking about it, because that was my reaction to the Shai video. What was with the girl in the warehouse mopping, dancing around with the mop, wearing a see-through dress? I know the 90's had a different vibe about women in videos than the current one, but that was still bad. Anyway, I love the PTX version, and Avi's bass notes at the end "boom, boom, BOOM" sealed the deal.
Definitely keep doing the comparisons between an original song and a PTX version. I think it’s interesting to listen to the original songs and then listen to the PTX reincarnation.
It's funny. Practically every cover PTX does, i tend to like it more than the original. And I agree with you. It isn't because it's PTX, it's just because.. it's better -- I found myself wanting to move ahead in this because the other version seemed to drag on for me. PTX version, as always seems too short LOL. I got the baywatch reference but was not a fan of the show -- I too am *ahem* older. lol Great reaction/review. Enjoy your reactions Jerod!!
Jerod, this is not the Shai song I know, the one that played on the radio was actually a Capella. This is a remix. Here's the a Capella version: ua-cam.com/video/7py9ljHmgNo/v-deo.html I like it a Capella better, and Pentatonix based their cover on this one, but IMO, PTX blew it out of the water!
Not sure if I mentioned this before, but just in case, Scott does a cover of blowing on the wind with Mario and Julia Harriman. If you search Scott Hoying "blowing in the wind" it will come up. Harmonies are powerful. I think you will like it.
Honest reaction of this: there's NO comparison. Even without Mr. Derulo's lead and color notes this is miles away from the original, in a really good way. The original was good (for that time and place) but seriously...
Interestingly enough, as someone who normally prefers PTX over anyone, I do prefer the mellowness of the original here and this is the one song on the original CD I skip over from time to time because it's just a little too much in my opinion. Absolutely gorgeous vocals though!
Shai doing the acapella version is way better than this version like their voices and their Harmony or like adult world I think you should have listened to that version and then the Pentatonix version because that's the version that most people listen to when they listen to the original and they hit notes in the acapella version that they don't hit in this one
SEE !!! DIDNT WE TELL YOU THEY JUST MAKE EVERYONE SONGS SOUND BETTER.. ITS ONLY GETS BETTER. THEY ACTUALY DO SIDE BY SIDE VIDEOS WITH OTHERS YOU SHOULD CHECK THEM OUT KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK LATER JOE R.
Echoing everyone else, please keep doing the comparisons. I appreciate your comments not only because they are so good, but also because they come from come from your knowledge of music.
Have you heard the acapella version? It's way better than this sensual version, and makes it the comparison a bit fairer imo. It's Shai's acapella version that became a hit back in the day.
Loved the comparison. I love both versions being a fan of the original from Shai, but agree that the PTX collaboration with Derulo took it to another level. At some point it sounded like it had more of a Reggae beat which I enjoyed as I love listening to Reggae. Would love to see more comparisons. Can you react to Postmodern Jukebox ft Haley Reinhardt singing Creep or Postmodern Jukebox ft Vonzell Solomon singing "Every Breath You Take" (Gospel cover) 😊
I remember Shai's original, that was my teen years, and Pentatonix and Jason KILLED this track! So fantastic (as usual PTX are better than the original)
I'm so glad you did this. I've never actually heard the original. This song was on PTX's original album, so I was surprised to learn fairly recently that it's a cover. Only Pentatonix could take a song that boring and kick it up to a hundred!
Shai was like the poor man's Boyz II Men.. Jodeci was the bad boy version of Boyz II Men... I miss 90s R&B... Shai did an acapella version of this song, too... a little less moaning in the background...;)
Oh wow! I had never seen the Shai video... hum... So much to say. I really didn’t like the strings in their version. It actually made them sound off key a lot. The tempo too slow. It made this beautiful song not sexy and sultry but douchey. The guys were a little too much (really not sexy to me) and MY GOD! What’s up with the girl MOPPING!!! (Barf, gag, gasp 🤮). Now PTX has class and totally gave this song the right vibe. Perfect tempo and beat (thank you Kevin), great vocals (all of them) and the BASS! Yes Avi! Now this song makes any girl feel beautiful. It speaks to our heart.
Honestly, I didn’t enjoy the Shai part. I mean I loved this song when it first came in the 90’s but it was acapella on the radio. I ended up fast forwarding to the Pentatonix version. Thanks though for trying something new.
When they performed this song on tour, kevin performed the high notes! Amazing!
I really liked this idea. Sometimes we don't always take the original into account because Pentatonix tends to blow us away. Hope comparisons become a regular feature. Nice suggestion, Jane!!
Shai does an a Capella version of the song that Pentatonix got the ooh-da-da-do-da-do and some of the blends... Pentatonix was great of course but comparing the acapella versions might be even better
Jason, Scott, & Kevin were amazing, but Avi made that song pop!!
When you dont have to list the 2 perfect people
Loved this! I've heard of Shai's original but never saw the video. PTX did great and so did Jason. What a good throwback right there.
V Reacts I agree! It was a fun contrast
Pentatonix didn’t just take it up a notch. They took it up about 10 notches. They bring this richness to everything they do.
I really enjoyed the comparison to the videos. I believe the Shari was a more of a sensuality during the 90s. The Baywatch reference had me snickering as I'm 55 and all I remember was Pamela Anderson. In the Pentatonix version Just throwing quick snippets if Kirsten just giving a look pulled the sensuality into play. Well done and a great idea.👍👍👍
Music like this is so beautiful and when other people sing it it’s soooo beautiful I’m listening to other people sing this song rn and it’s melting my heart 💙
I love the idea for this video. I'd like to see more comparison videos. As always, I tend to like Pentatonix's version a lot better. They always tend to raise the bar in my opinion.
One thing to note is that Shai has 2 versions of this song. The original (which is Acapella) and the remix which is the one you compared to. Pentatonix and Jason D incorporated both in this cover. The first half they did the Acapella version of Shai's song and the 2nd half where Scott comes in they were covering the remix version. Quite frankly i LOVE all 3 versions. Have always loved Shai and love PTX!
Other worldy?? Yes!! I think PTX took the tempo up a notch, too.
Chris Abel yes, which gave it a nice energy
"They're other-worldy, man!" Yup, that basically sums it up perfectly. That was fun watching the videos back to back. Thanks!
Beautiful
Isn't it ridiculous what Pentatonix can do with a cover? I always love their covers compared to the originals. I can't think of an exception, and this collab was off the charts. And I love that PTX doesn't need to be the center of attention in a collaboration. They let Jason Derulo shine (and Scott). Love the idea of comparing an original to a PTX cover!!
Shai killed this song "Acapella" which that song should have been used.
What I find interesting is that when ptx does a colab they let the guest shine, but they also bring out the best in the guest. You might say ptx sets up the guest for success.
I love the comparison format! We Pentaholics do generally feel that the PTX version rises above the original in most cases, so it would be interesting to get the opinion of someone well versed in the realm of music to put that conviction to the test.
I suspect the acid test might be "Bohemian Rhapsody", as even Pentatonix long avoided covering it because... well, hell... it's Queen! And they didn't want to do an unworthy cover. Whether it was better or not (and I'm sure there will be vocal advocates on both sides of that argument...), I'd definitely contend that it was, at the very least, worthy, and that Freddie would have approved.
I've never seen their (Pentatonix) version of this song!!! Thanks!!! New sub here now ☺
Jerod, this was a great idea -- comparing an original with a PTX cover. I LOVED the blues feel of Shai's version, but -- I may be slightly biased (LOL), PTX's version just rocks the planet!! The vocals and harmonies are much more prominent and clear. Both were good, but my heart is set on PTX. . . PS. Jason DeRullo just rocks it!!
Diane Stewart agree❤️
Jerod hope you have time to make more videos like this
One of these days I'll be first! Lol
PS...I really like this type of reaction. Especially if it's PTX!
Tracie Nichole you were pretty close! Lol.
Weird thing about Shai's version of this is the music. They were originally an acapella group, this song had no music until it was re-released. I liked it better without to be honest. The "vibe" was 100% 90's..lol.. over sexed with heavy bass feels like it's been a million years but I was in high school bk then. I like the PTX version better! ❤ your reactions!😍😍
I do like this format, Jerod. I typically prefer what PTX does over the original artist predominantly because I don't listen to a lot of pop/r&b type music simply because it's a lot of looping and autotuning. Once PTX's version is burned in my brain, it's hard to accept any other version. When Papaoutai came out, I decided to seek out the original first and then watched the PTX version. Now I do that for ever cover song I encounter. It deepens my appreciation for what PTX does, how gifted they are at deconstruction, reconstruction and elevation of the original without losing the original intent. I agree whole heartedly that Jason's voice was more powerful than Shai's and the collab pushed this one over the top! Thank you again for your reaction.
I didn’t. I stated that I don’t listen to a lot of pop/r&b. Here’s a grammar lesson on the use of forward slash between words:
“To Indicate Or”
Often, when a slash is used in a formal or informal text, it is meant to indicate the word or.
Grammarly › blog › slash
Slash: Grammar Rules About How to Use a Slash
I remember this song first time round (Yes I'm THAT old 😱) it was HUGE (I'm in Ireland and only huge hits made a dent over seas and this was really popular due to mtv branching out over here on our national broadcaster on a sunday) I LOVED this song back then and PTX version is AMAZING. Shai was of their time obviously and they did a version with the start that PTX use here (The do dada do do do) but PTX just killed it, and Jason's voice is spectacular
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Hi Jerod! You should watch Drop the mic with the Pentatonix vs Bell Biv Devoe
I would have recommended "Valentine" but you already did it. The original is... not sure what to call it. Unique, maybe. I would never have listened to it if not for the PTX cover. Just like with this one, I like both versions and I typically like the PTX better on their covers.
YEP, No question which group was the best. I used to do these comparisons more than I do now but it is almost always PTX that comes out on top. And, with just five voices and no instruments. They are the masters at what they do. Incredible talent and they all have an attitude of giving 110% for everything they do.
I mean the acappella version of the original is actually like crazy
Never heard of ptx,they were great,however I disagree that ptx won..what was missing and integral was Shai's sensuality...this song was never about power and in your face...
I never watched Shai's video but now that I've seen it I can definitely say that I prefer PTX's version!
Btw are you going to react to their cover of Praying (that's on their new album) soon? :) It's gonna blow your mind!
This wasn’t a fair comparison. Shai does an A Capella version of their song which is the version Pentatonix came with. I love both groups but I’m an 80’s baby so Shai won me over back when I first heard this as it was magical during its time. Pentatonix added a bit more, but Shai hit it in the element that it was in.
You need an addendum with Shai's acapella version of this song. Actually, that would have been the better original comparrison. Now that you've heard the PTX version, Shai's is a step down though still one of my favorites in the day. I had a cassette single copy. Still have it, in fact. ☺
I avoided the acapella one because while pentatonix is only acapella, they are filling in beats and bass. Shai's acapella version is good, but the comparison was different because it lacked the low end and beat.
Im sorry but Shai is still better the tone of the music fits better Pentatonix sound like a pop version if i didnt read who sings the other version i would of guess back street boys or Nsync.
Exactly ,they sound like a boy group.
I like Pentatonix but I don't really like this version of the song it's so soulless compared to the original. This song is about losing somebody you thought was the love of your life a swearing off love ever again unless you can find that one special love. It's sad and mournful not peppy and aria's to show of your vocal skills. It's passion not playtime.
100
hands down Pentatonix is better but then I'm a Pentaholic
Never heard of the second group other than Jason Derulo tbh and while listening I was disappointed with the cover that the second group did because I feel like they did way too much. When I hear this song I expect something romantic and soft and smooth the second group can sing but I was not a fan of the cover. The second group was too loud and just ruined the whole vibe for me. Sometimes we need to leave classics alone because knowing how to sing does not mean you would sound good in just any song. Sorry not sorry
Ok, how can you compare the two. One came out with the original song in 1992, Plantonix basically copied everything Shai did. The original song will always be the best version because it let Plantonix copy each note and just add their touch to it. If Plantonix was the original singers than you can say they were best but all they did was speed up the beat and make it more of a dancing song. Shai version was a r&b slow jam. Plantonix did not add anything to it but a beat box. They copied every note Shai did
How can I compare them? Because one group sang it and then another one sang it. I want to see how each group interpreted the song and how they delivered the vocals. One group did it without any beat, Pentatonix* did it with a beat. That’s the point of the comparison. Not to say one is better or worse but to hear the two side by side.
@@JerodM but that's not true. The original song by Shai was done without a beat. That's why Plantonix did a remix. Shai performed it acapela without any beat boxing or anything. They sung it with no music at all. No disrespect to you but that's why Plantonix or Jason didn't change a note because it was already done before almost 20 years ago. I give them respect because they didn't messed up the remix and they sped up the tempo. Shai has always been known for singing acapela. Just like boys to men. Trust Plantonix is following in those people steps. They are a good group but they are nothing we haven't seen before in r&b
I absolutely despise the original, and I never liked it even back then. Pentatonix's is just so much cleaner and their harmonies are 110% better.
And of course Jason Derulo also nailed it.
Shai has that version and the acapella version, both are great but I remember growing up listening to the acapella one on the radio! Damn I miss the 90s lol
I was expecting the acapella version from Shai. That's a better comparison choice imho.
@@JP-hz4tg yeah I totally agree! It's so much more better
This is me with music and PTX.
Original Song: "Ooooh, I really like that!! Great song!"
PTX version: "Holy ***!!!! WOW, that's........it's.........dude, they're INCREDIBLE!!!"
Yeah. Every single time.
They do a concert vrs of this too with K.O. singing the high notes...awesome city.
Pentatonix always stand out. I don't knw why i love them always. Scott😱😱😱😱
Awesome! I'm so glad you liked my idea. Thanks for fulfilling my request so soon. The first time I watched this video, I didn't like the Shai version very much. I'm listening again right now, and this time I do. It's not fair to compare a recording and video from--what, 1992, was it?--with a recent one, but I do really prefer the clarity and "cleanness" (is that a word?) of the PTX/JD version, as opposed to the soft, kind of fuzzy texture of Shai's version. The solidity of Avi's bass provides an anchor. Little nitpick--Jason's highest notes sound a bit shrill to me. He's right on pitch, though, and really amazing. All the rest of the time his voice is beautiful. I wouldn't mind another collab. I wonder why, whenever PTX does a collab with another soloist, the PTX soloist is always Scott. (Since I wrote "always," somebody is sure to tell me about an exception.) Finally--I really love the effect of the stripes of colored lights. The green on Kevin's face is breathtaking. Jerod, PLEASE do more comparative videos when the opportunity arises!
janetranslates thanks again for the great suggestion!
Based on Jason Derulo's most popular songs you wouldn't really think he was as talented as he really is because those are some ridiculous silly songs they are catchy but still didn't show his talent like this one did and also when he was on sytycd that showed how talented he is in dance. This was definitely better than the original it was just so full and awesome. mitch even said that Jason could sing higher than him I thought that was funny. Also it was Kevin that saw Jason at one of the awards shows and just walked up to him and said hey we're pentatonix and we should do something together and then this happened! :)
Please keep doing this comparisons! I love the idea and was already excited when you explained it, but now I've seen it and it was amazing! And as a viewer not just your comparison is very interesting, but I was also comparing them while watching and when you talked about, I could see if you also noticed different things and stuff like that, so it was a really interesting and nice video!
I don’t think I’ve heard a PTX cover yet that I don’t prefer to the original. They nail it every time.
I would like to see you check out their cover of Ride. It’s not on their official channel, it’s on Nova FM.
I love avi's undertone throughout the chorus each time. And his little rift in the middle.
The original version was done Acapella by shai.
Not Shai"s best version.
Scott!!!!!!!!!! WOW
I loved the comparison! This video/song has never been my favorite... I still enjoyed it, it just wasn't my favorite. Doing the side by side like this made me appreciate it on a totally different level. Thank you! 🙂
They got this from Shai's acapello verison. I prefer Shai
According to most these people on here Shai can't sing.unbelieveavle,how bias they are.i should'nt be surprised.
Ptx always adds so many flavors to a song: in this one, Avi’s beautiful bass, Scott’s lead with his runs, Mitch even had a little run section that was SO cool and unexpected, Kirsten added glamour and the full backgrounds, and KO with the beats, plus the masterful arrangement and Jason D. was so powerful! I never really got into this song until you did this comparison reaction and suddenly I was noticing all sorts of good stuff. Loved your comments!. Thx Jerod!
Very good reaction - is it possible you did not see "Imagine", yet? That is definitely a video of PTX that you should check out...
Back in the day it wasn’t weird that the one guy didn’t have a shirt on. Now... I’m just wondering why? 🤔
Both was great but nothing like the original
Great reaction! I also went and listened to the Shai version when I first heard this - and it's funny that you used the word "creepy" when talking about it, because that was my reaction to the Shai video. What was with the girl in the warehouse mopping, dancing around with the mop, wearing a see-through dress? I know the 90's had a different vibe about women in videos than the current one, but that was still bad. Anyway, I love the PTX version, and Avi's bass notes at the end "boom, boom, BOOM" sealed the deal.
@2:34 he then realized hes a shai fan lol
Omg, both sound good!
Naw i don't care for the new group doing the cover, they took away everything that 90s r&b was...thats what's wrong with this new generation
There version wasn't better than Shai's. Where's the soul?
Original is always better. Especially a capella version.
I agree.most of these people are very bias on here.
Definitely keep doing the comparisons between an original song and a PTX version. I think it’s interesting to listen to the original songs and then listen to the PTX reincarnation.
It's funny. Practically every cover PTX does, i tend to like it more than the original. And I agree with you. It isn't because it's PTX, it's just because.. it's better -- I found myself wanting to move ahead in this because the other version seemed to drag on for me. PTX version, as always seems too short LOL. I got the baywatch reference but was not a fan of the show -- I too am *ahem* older. lol Great reaction/review. Enjoy your reactions Jerod!!
You can do this for can't help falling in love . The original may not have a video t hough
Loved doing the double comparison!!
This is bullshit, Shai version is way better. And they have their acapella version.
The covered one is working too hard
They are both good.
Also ..fun fact...they did this with Mario at one of their live concerts
Hello I'm interested honestly I'm just getting my feet in? And will always be willing to take helping advice that's not negative?
Jerod, this is not the Shai song I know, the one that played on the radio was actually a Capella. This is a remix. Here's the a Capella version: ua-cam.com/video/7py9ljHmgNo/v-deo.html
I like it a Capella better, and Pentatonix based their cover on this one, but IMO, PTX blew it out of the water!
Not sure if I mentioned this before, but just in case, Scott does a cover of blowing on the wind with Mario and Julia Harriman. If you search Scott Hoying "blowing in the wind" it will come up. Harmonies are powerful. I think you will like it.
Honest reaction of this: there's NO comparison. Even without Mr. Derulo's lead and color notes this is miles away from the original, in a really good way. The original was good (for that time and place) but seriously...
Interestingly enough, as someone who normally prefers PTX over anyone, I do prefer the mellowness of the original here and this is the one song on the original CD I skip over from time to time because it's just a little too much in my opinion. Absolutely gorgeous vocals though!
You screwed this up by not doing the Shai accapella version. Its better than the Pentatonix version
Also, Superfruit did something on their channel called "the mashup game" with Tori Kelly that you should check out (stay through the bloopers)
Shai doing the acapella version is way better than this version like their voices and their Harmony or like adult world I think you should have listened to that version and then the Pentatonix version because that's the version that most people listen to when they listen to the original and they hit notes in the acapella version that they don't hit in this one
SEE !!! DIDNT WE TELL YOU THEY JUST MAKE EVERYONE SONGS SOUND BETTER.. ITS ONLY GETS BETTER. THEY ACTUALY DO SIDE BY SIDE VIDEOS WITH OTHERS YOU SHOULD CHECK THEM OUT KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK LATER JOE R.
I agree 100%
Echoing everyone else, please keep doing the comparisons. I appreciate your comments not only because they are so good, but also because they come from come from your knowledge of music.
Jean Caldwell thank you
Scott got me feeling some type of way...just sayin'...
You should compare it to shai's acapella version
You should react to Poaupotui pentatonix
pentatonix going too fast no soul LOL
Let's hear you do better lmao hater! Gtfo with yer negativity. Ye wish ye were half as good as PTX. Bye Felicia 😂
@@ExotiicButter sallllllteeeeeeeehhhhhh
Exactly they think when some people hit a high not they are better.people don't realize soul is important.some people have it and others don't.
Very much beautiful ❣️
PTX! They nailed it, as always!
i really like this idea
Have you heard the acapella version? It's way better than this sensual version, and makes it the comparison a bit fairer imo. It's Shai's acapella version that became a hit back in the day.
I have. I chose to compare this version because of the use of percussion and bass. It mor closely resembled what PTX did.
shai wasnt the original , the original was by a british band called east 17 in 1996
Shai version came out in 1992
When I was about 22 I loved shai , today PTX is better
I disagree.they don't have the soul or feeling of Shai.
Loved the comparison. I love both versions being a fan of the original from Shai, but agree that the PTX collaboration with Derulo took it to another level. At some point it sounded like it had more of a Reggae beat which I enjoyed as I love listening to Reggae. Would love to see more comparisons. Can you react to Postmodern Jukebox ft Haley Reinhardt singing Creep or Postmodern Jukebox ft Vonzell Solomon singing "Every Breath You Take" (Gospel cover) 😊
I remember Shai's original, that was my teen years, and Pentatonix and Jason KILLED this track! So fantastic (as usual PTX are better than the original)
I, too loved this idea.. had never seen the Shai version but had heard it .. loved PTX version... it was like an awesome dessert
Amazing reaction! Could you react to “flashback”. They’re also an acapella group. Preferably react to their cover of “you don’t do it for me anymore”
No offense to the original but, woooo PTX 😀.. May have watched the PTX video 100 times or more LOL
Loved this modern version SO MUCH!!
I'm so glad you did this. I've never actually heard the original. This song was on PTX's original album, so I was surprised to learn fairly recently that it's a cover. Only Pentatonix could take a song that boring and kick it up to a hundred!
Boring 😂😂 try again
Love this ❣️
Shai was like the poor man's Boyz II Men.. Jodeci was the bad boy version of Boyz II Men... I miss 90s R&B...
Shai did an acapella version of this song, too... a little less moaning in the background...;)
Wow!!!you really know how to insult a group of talented singers.thank goodness people that know music knows otherwise.
Oh wow! I had never seen the Shai video... hum... So much to say. I really didn’t like the strings in their version. It actually made them sound off key a lot. The tempo too slow. It made this beautiful song not sexy and sultry but douchey. The guys were a little too much (really not sexy to me) and MY GOD! What’s up with the girl MOPPING!!! (Barf, gag, gasp 🤮).
Now PTX has class and totally gave this song the right vibe. Perfect tempo and beat (thank you Kevin), great vocals (all of them) and the BASS! Yes Avi! Now this song makes any girl feel beautiful. It speaks to our heart.
This was such a great reaction Jerod! Cant wait to see more!
FragaGurl10 awesome! Good to see your comment. 😁
Jerod M lol. I was working out while watching your videos. Helped pass the time.
FragaGurl10 haha! Nice. Now I can add that to my resume. "Workout motivator."
Honestly, I didn’t enjoy the Shai part. I mean I loved this song when it first came in the 90’s but it was acapella on the radio. I ended up fast forwarding to the Pentatonix version. Thanks though for trying something new.