I cannot understand the need of bringing a person from a political party. There were no presentation of views from his side, rather he lacked even constructive criticism. Give me one example, where his views mattered and were agreed by even one person on the panel. It was completely avoidable. I hope the Producers would take this into consideration in future by not letting the political groups participate in these nice debates.
I agree with you. The producers shouldn't have brought manish tiwari. But manish tiwari was completely in the right here. He is a Congressman and appreciating modi in anyway would have between a betrayal to his party. What he did was his job. In fact we shouldn't expect any valuable opinion from him .
Good suggestion unless we somehow magically get an intelligent politician who is willing to admit faults with his party and praise the other party for doing good.
Genaardhan B Vijayan Maybe do some research and provide data instead of spreading false rhetoric? we have a reputation of being peaceful as a founder of the non alignment movement. We have never supported or propogated enmity and have always prioritised peace, because of Nehru. No doubt when national security or the notion of democracy was at stake we have stood strong (Kargill, freeing of Bangladesh from Pakistan)I don't know about you but I think that's a significant effort to improve our "image" as you say. I speak a student of history and political science, my views or not biased, but I think it's time the modi fanatics cut the crap and look at the facts, both negative and positive, regarding the Congress track record
Wow! Finally a discussion where the journalist does not interrupt the panel members every 5 seconds. I thought all these types of journalists were extinct. Nice discussion! Keep it up.
Bhushan did a good job of drawing the best out of the panel. Flip flops on Pakistan is a non-issue. Key is the structural change in the relationship with Pakistan. I enjoyed the depth of Indian foreign policy talent here.
In place of Manish Tiwari, RSTV could have invited Commodore C. Uday Bhaskar for the Defence perspective on Foreign Relations. Tiwari speaks partisan bias.
All the ambassadors explained the foreign policy very well with facts where it is heading, except Manish Tewari. Big Cheers to MODI Government!!!!!! Manish Tewari had the biased opinion because of obvious reasons. I don't know why he was in a debate. All the baseless discussion with improper knowledge e.g. Russia support in CPEC. He didn't accept the facts that UPA government was not able to implement the Foreign policies during its 10 years government. Manmohan Singh policies were good but they couldn't implement those. NDA government made very good progress in most of the areas. This government is improving the image of the INDIA in global diaspora. I hope this government will take the INDIA to big heights with a new and innovative program like MAKE IN INDIA.
Political poison in a panel discussion of importance brings out the worst indigestion,as in this case, how Manish Tiwari has demonstrated himself in this panel. It should be a lesson for those who select a panel for future discussion. Politician by and large can create heat in a discussion, but seldom can shine any light!
Politician is always politician his views are only to defend congress rather than accepting the truth? Inviting neutral policy makers and thinkers to this kind debate is good. Finally A very good debate on foreign policy.
A/to Tiwari, only congress can uplift d face of India. hv these educated ppl sold their sensibility to mad ppl. lk his leader hs done?? the Y gen. demands no-nonsense from our august ppl.
if you want to put a neutral discussion, is it necessary to put a seat there for a Congress spokesperson, because after this debate, one can surely tell he was unable to distinguish the good deeds done by PM, constantly criticising him when his own govt did nothing except dreaming and setting various goals which could not be accomplished by his govt. He seems like representing his Congress party rather than taking part in discussion.
I categorically rejecting the view of Manish Tiwari on CPEC. CPEC can not be beneficial for India. How can we accept CPEC, it passes through our territory (Violation of India sovereignty) without our permission, for others strategic gain.success of CPEC is failure of India.
There is important question always not given due attention.. Are we bureaucratically ready to take massive foreign engagements. Foreign policy not just made by leaders... what leader sign is in paper, but to take it to reality you need focused foreign official, focus monitoring group. Present government didn't spend much on increasing the number of quality foreign officials, IFS officers. Indian foreign office has huge man power shortage, even NRI or PRO are not getting better services from Indians embassies. . Tourism been long been ignored in our foreign policy due to lack of vision in Indian embassies across world. Without building strong bureaucracy/Institution, everything will just born and die in paper, many advantage of so called bigger foreign policy success would never give a due advantage. Every one cares about news articles and popularity but reality is kind of looking different.
After listening to the last remarks by Mr. Tiwari, I thought it was only me who felt very irritated when he termed the gathering of NRI's by PM Modiji as a "Tamasha". If it looks like a "Tamasha" to him than he is missing the essence of message to NRI and it is time for him to watch each and every video several times with a notebook in his hand than come back to panel to see if he heard anything which has a positive message for everyone on this planet. For me personally his message has been consistent that of clear vision for economic development of the nation and her neighbours as well. Mr. Tiwari if you want to learn something new than do leave your e-mail and I will contact you to teach everything you want to learn about PM Modiji's vision for India. I have tons of words of wisdom and hope you are open to learn from a person who has only education upto F.Sc. I hope you will be careful before making negative comments without facts to prove your point of view. Silence is always golden.
Why is Manish Tiwari part of this panel? he even did not give any prudent view on policy, his inclusion in panel diminished the personality of other members. He proved that political members can not be neutral, they can not appreciate good move of any governments. you should not take political members in any such pragmatic discussion.
flip-flops on Pakistan and some issue with China otherwise good implementation of decision which is not shown by previous government in terms of political decision
Need a dedicated China policy guy in the Govt. Looks like most experts don't understand China and mostly come from very western view of China or a misunderstanding of their rise.
Manish Tiwari is a disgrace in the name of foreign policy expertise....doesnt deserve to be given a seat at such intellectual forum...spewing out his venom using distasteful words...represents the termite ridden congress mindset...
Had not barath intervened,manoj would not have answered that last question also...he should understand he comes to such show,he should protray his individual views rather than criticizing the government of the day.
awesome discussion, but why shouldn't opposition just praise the good things going on or conducted by the government, why they become "Dhrutrastra"? ooo so -ve vibe coming from congress representative
omg that MPhil student in international studies have an awful English & no eloquence at all, it begs the question as to how they got there in the first place!
It is funny.... all the intellectuals on stage and in audience... failed to discuss BRIC! ..... an acronym given by an economist about emerging economies..... BRICS borrowed the acronym but failed to address the anachronism.
So all this talk about foreign policy highlighting the triumphs of this govt, of which there have been a few; But no mention of the Mongolia Fiasco or our issues with Nepal, where public and political opinion has become heavily anti India. Although Tiwari was being a 'congress man' but he was balancing the Modi love from all the panellists here.
Recently Saudi Arabia has announced it will invest 10 Billion $ in Sunni Maldives to build navel ports and airports Jointly with China. This deal is brokered by Pakistan. All Madrasas in Maldives have Pakistani mullahs running them and last year millions of Chinese tourists visited Maldives. This development has been a major failure of Indian Foreign policy under Modi.
Rajya Sabha TV is top-notch news channel
I cannot understand the need of bringing a person from a political party. There were no presentation of views from his side, rather he lacked even constructive criticism. Give me one example, where his views mattered and were agreed by even one person on the panel. It was completely avoidable. I hope the Producers would take this into consideration in future by not letting the political groups participate in these nice debates.
Mr. Manish Tewari practically tried to spoil the show.
I agree with you. The producers shouldn't have brought manish tiwari. But manish tiwari was completely in the right here. He is a Congressman and appreciating modi in anyway would have between a betrayal to his party. What he did was his job. In fact we shouldn't expect any valuable opinion from him .
Good suggestion unless we somehow magically get an intelligent politician who is willing to admit faults with his party and praise the other party for doing good.
Vivek Shukla
only one bad things in debate is Manish tiwari,. +rajayasabhatv plz not invite politician in good debate
Awesome exchange of intellect. Mr. Tiwari please seperate politics and personal vandeta from it!
For 70 years congress government had done little or nothing in international relations to improve india's image yet tiwari criticised Modi.
Genaardhan B Vijayan Maybe do some research and provide data instead of spreading false rhetoric? we have a reputation of being peaceful as a founder of the non alignment movement. We have never supported or propogated enmity and have always prioritised peace, because of Nehru. No doubt when national security or the notion of democracy was at stake we have stood strong (Kargill, freeing of Bangladesh from Pakistan)I don't know about you but I think that's a significant effort to improve our "image" as you say. I speak a student of history and political science, my views or not biased, but I think it's time the modi fanatics cut the crap and look at the facts, both negative and positive, regarding the Congress track record
Genaardhan B Vijayan
ohh! then it was u who did all for our foreign policy
No political party statesman please
Wow! Finally a discussion where the journalist does not interrupt the panel members every 5 seconds. I thought all these types of journalists were extinct. Nice discussion! Keep it up.
We're very lucky to have such a good quality non partisan government news channel. Not all countries are so lucky.
Bhushan did a good job of drawing the best out of the panel. Flip flops on Pakistan is a non-issue. Key is the structural change in the relationship with Pakistan. I enjoyed the depth of Indian foreign policy talent here.
Skip over a couple of minutes whenever you see Manish tiwari about to open his mouth.
Thank me later lol
In place of Manish Tiwari, RSTV could have invited Commodore C. Uday Bhaskar for the Defence perspective on Foreign Relations.
Tiwari speaks partisan bias.
All the ambassadors explained the foreign policy very well with facts where it is heading, except Manish Tewari.
Big Cheers to MODI Government!!!!!!
Manish Tewari had the biased opinion because of obvious reasons. I don't know why he was in a debate. All the baseless discussion with improper knowledge e.g. Russia support in CPEC. He didn't accept the facts that UPA government was not able to implement the Foreign policies during its 10 years government. Manmohan Singh policies were good but they couldn't implement those.
NDA government made very good progress in most of the areas. This government is improving the image of the INDIA in global diaspora. I hope this government will take the INDIA to big heights with a new and innovative program like MAKE IN INDIA.
Well conducted and enriched conversation....
Has any1 else found questions from students more relevent??
Hats off guys..Your observation is commendable.
Political poison in a panel discussion of importance brings out the worst indigestion,as in this case, how Manish Tiwari has demonstrated himself in this panel. It should be a lesson for those who select a panel for future discussion. Politician by and large can create heat in a discussion, but seldom can shine any light!
quality discussion..thanks rstv
What was the need to bring in a Congressman?
Politician is always politician his views are only to defend congress rather than accepting the truth? Inviting neutral policy makers and thinkers to this kind debate is good. Finally A very good debate on foreign policy.
I think, the quality of discussion is diluted by 25% , thanks to Manish Tiwari .
No need of politician....anyways great discussion as expected from RSTV
good discussion best news channel
good discussion sir thank u...
haha. by inviting manish tiwari rstv has insulted others....sashi tharoor would have been a better choice.
why politician in panel , if you want some person criticise Mr modi try and find some non partisan person
Agreed.... RSTV if our comments are seen by u.. Plz heed to it..no politicians in panel.... Mr.Tiwari has not added any quality point.... !!
I think they just wanted to show that even a government channel can criticize the ruling party.
its run by ansari ex congress politician
I really couldn't understand about what point Manish Tiwary was trying to make. It was all confusing.
so nice discussion
what kind of an expert is manish tewari???????
very good discussion ......................
A/to Tiwari, only congress can uplift d face of India. hv these educated ppl sold their sensibility to mad ppl. lk his leader hs done?? the Y gen. demands no-nonsense from our august ppl.
South Indians Rock. Raja Mohan.
if you want to put a neutral discussion, is it necessary to put a seat there for a Congress spokesperson, because after this debate, one can surely tell he was unable to distinguish the good deeds done by PM, constantly criticising him when his own govt did nothing except dreaming and setting various goals which could not be accomplished by his govt. He seems like representing his Congress party rather than taking part in discussion.
insightful discussion !
I categorically rejecting the view of Manish Tiwari on CPEC. CPEC can not be beneficial for India. How can we accept CPEC, it passes through our territory (Violation of India sovereignty) without our permission, for others strategic gain.success of CPEC is failure of India.
nice n fruitful discussion
There is important question always not given due attention.. Are we bureaucratically ready to take massive foreign engagements. Foreign policy not just made by leaders... what leader sign is in paper, but to take it to reality you need focused foreign official, focus monitoring group. Present government didn't spend much on increasing the number of quality foreign officials, IFS officers. Indian foreign office has huge man power shortage, even NRI or PRO are not getting better services from Indians embassies. . Tourism been long been ignored in our foreign policy due to lack of vision in Indian embassies across world. Without building strong bureaucracy/Institution, everything will just born and die in paper, many advantage of so called bigger foreign policy success would never give a due advantage. Every one cares about news articles and popularity but reality is kind of looking different.
After listening to the last remarks by Mr. Tiwari, I thought it was only me who felt very irritated when he termed the gathering of NRI's by PM Modiji as a "Tamasha". If it looks like a "Tamasha" to him than he is missing the essence of message to NRI and it is time for him to watch each and every video several times with a notebook in his hand than come back to panel to see if he heard anything which has a positive message for everyone on this planet. For me personally his message has been consistent that of clear vision for economic development of the nation and her neighbours as well. Mr. Tiwari if you want to learn something new than do leave your e-mail and I will contact you to teach everything you want to learn about PM Modiji's vision for India. I have tons of words of wisdom and hope you are open to learn from a person who has only education upto F.Sc. I hope you will be careful before making negative comments without facts to prove your point of view. Silence is always golden.
Informative
Why is Manish Tiwari part of this panel? he even did not give any prudent view on policy, his inclusion in panel diminished the personality of other members. He proved that political members can not be neutral, they can not appreciate good move of any governments. you should not take political members in any such pragmatic discussion.
Manish tiwari shd not be on panel!
thanks
flip-flops on Pakistan and some issue with China otherwise good implementation of decision which is not shown by previous government in terms of political decision
Need a dedicated China policy guy in the Govt. Looks like most experts don't understand China and mostly come from very western view of China or a misunderstanding of their rise.
please upload the video of year review 2016 broadcast Ed on 31st Dec at 4.30 pm. plz
why the hell you brought a political person manish tiwari....??
Manish Tiwari is a disgrace in the name of foreign policy expertise....doesnt deserve to be given a seat at such intellectual forum...spewing out his venom using distasteful words...represents the termite ridden congress mindset...
INDIAN GOV OR MODI GOV IS DOING WELL IN FOREIGN POLICY BUT IT IS MATTER OF TENSION THAT RUSSIA IS GOING TOWARDS PAKISTAN....
Had not barath intervened,manoj would not have answered that last question also...he should understand he comes to such show,he should protray his individual views rather than criticizing the government of the day.
awesome discussion, but why shouldn't opposition just praise the good things going on or conducted by the government, why they become "Dhrutrastra"?
ooo so -ve vibe coming from congress representative
49:18 that face :D
skipped tiwari ....
Jnu main foreign policy bi discuss hoti hey.. Mujje laga sirf azadi k nate lagtey hey haha..
omg that MPhil student in international studies have an awful English & no eloquence at all, it begs the question as to how they got there in the first place!
It is funny.... all the intellectuals on stage and in audience... failed to discuss BRIC! ..... an acronym given by an economist about emerging economies..... BRICS borrowed the acronym but failed to address the anachronism.
So all this talk about foreign policy highlighting the triumphs of this govt, of which there have been a few; But no mention of the Mongolia Fiasco or our issues with Nepal, where public and political opinion has become heavily anti India. Although Tiwari was being a 'congress man' but he was balancing the Modi love from all the panellists here.
Recently Saudi Arabia has announced it will invest 10 Billion $ in Sunni Maldives to build navel ports and airports Jointly with China. This deal is brokered by Pakistan. All Madrasas in Maldives have Pakistani mullahs running them and last year millions of Chinese tourists visited Maldives. This development has been a major failure of Indian Foreign policy under Modi.
sir please not invite poltician
What was the need of bringing this foolish person of political nature? I believe value-neutral discussion would have been a good one.