Do get married and do not let anything or anyone get in the way...this is how one makes it. Never give up and of course one has to grow up! Evolve don’t revolve....HBD! YOU BOTH NEED KIDS. Marriage first! ;)
Dean I hope you appreciate all the gifts and love Caelynn gives you she is so in love with you. I hope you treat her like a Queen because she is so special.
Aw Caelynn, what a special birthday you created! Love seeing little Pappy, so precious. Happy birthday Dean! You two just seem meant for each other. ❤️
caelynn i love how much effort you put into his day. this reminded me of well,,,me! i think as super thoughtful people it is often easy to forget that we deserve that same if not more in return. i love you & dean together & just hope he truly does appreciate you as you should be! much love.
You guys are just the cutest! Caelynn you really know how to make Dean feel special. Your love for him is obvious and your gestures adorable. I hope Dean knows how special you are and how much he is loved.
Caelynn youre too good for him. He is not able to express joy, happiness, excitement, and appreciation. How is it possible to picture a life with that kind of person, I wish you the best.
@Love So meditation turns you into an emotionless zombie? Nope. I have friends who meditate regularly and they are able to express gratitude when receiving gifts. They take obstacles in stride, but they are still able to express how happy they are when things go well.
Omg what amazing thoughtful gifts! You can tell dean isn’t used to getting spoiled like that. He almost didn’t know how to react! Lol! Caelynn really went out of her way to make it such an amazing bday under the circumstances! Everyone needs someone like her in their life!!!! Happy bday dean!!!!
Caelynn, you are soooo amazing!!!!!! 💕💖💕 I love how you are so caring and kind and pay attention to the little details. You guys are so cute together and I’m rooting for y’all!!!! ⭐️
Watching your videos put a smile on my face the whole time. You two so down to earth and cute together. Love to see Pappi. Next I want to see you share your cooking ideas during this quarantine or Dean does your makeup 😃. It will be fun.
Dean. You are so awkwardly unappreciative. She is a Gem. An absolute beauty with a heart of gold. Any man on this Earth would put her on a pedastol as a queen where she belongs. And she's SMOKIN HOT LUCKYY MAN
Caelynn is so cute. Honestly he’s just an awkward person lol I think caelynn understands him so they make a good match. Or I could be completely wrong lolllll hopefully not
caelynn: sets up a perfect dinner arrangement with individually placed fruits that clearly took a lot of time dean: oh this is pretty cool... me: i set up this entire thing i expect u to cry and say u love me and give me hugs even though its your bday
OMG you Dean haters! Don't judge till you've been in his shoes. How comfortable would YOU ALL be expected to make out on camera 24/7?? Love is a private thing.
Hey Dean what about a BIG THANK YOU appreciate what you have because it may be gone she deserves to be treated with a little more respect any guy would love to have her thoughtfulness and creativity and most of all LOVE ....WAKE UP DEAN
Glad it wasn’t just me. He subtly put down all her gifts, wasn’t appreciative of her or her efforts, and just doesn’t seem to really care about her. I’ve been exactly here before.He’s self centered and loves himself more than he loves her. Run honey, as fast as you can!
I was married to a guy that had a tough upbringing like Dean and he also had many sides to his persona. Shyness especially when the attention was solely on him. I believe Dean is in truly in love with Caelynn - he's transparent about the changes in himself he's working on not only for himself but for Caelynn as well. He confessed he had trouble committing to one relationship at the beginning but he also made it clear he doesn't wish to live his private love life on camera. Let's be careful how we judge. I think they bring out the best in each other! 👁💕💘
Sounds like you're projecting. And the rest of your life will be unfulfilling because you think you know everything. You look at a pair of strangers and you think you know everything about them. Judging and deluding yourself allows you to feel superior, but alas - it is a delusion. And you will remain delusional and frustrated until you humble yourself.
Elviera Miyaka the man cannot be wowed no matter how hard you try 🙄😂 meanwhile you get caelynn a simple portrait puzzle and she’s jumping of happiness 🥺💛 but yes, it’s like someone doing nice things for him makes him uncomfortable idk if to be sad for him or to call him unappreciative 🤔 lol
Some people feel awkward when it comes to receiving gifts. I love giving gifts and go all out when it comes to that, but I never know how to act when someone gives me something! I do appreciate it though I’m sure he’s probably the same way.
@@CaelynnBell I'll trust you on this (lol, like I have a choice). I have always liked your Dean -- just hope he is willing and able emotionally to give you everything. Get married, for goodness sake!
Caelynn I’m so glad you followed your heart in BIP. In my opinion, you made the right choice. In a way, Colton led you straight to your 💛. Love you guys separately, love you even more together. ✨
This was sooo cuteee❤️❤️ i think dean has a different way of expressing himself. Hes not used to someone treating him the way caelyn does which might explain the way he comes off on camera. But u can tell hes thankful! ☺️❤️
windowsdown i dont think so. Hes not “trapped” he knows what he has. I think its a self-esteem issue. He even said it in the show that he didnt feel good enough for her and that being her bf was gnn be horrible for her. Thats because he thinks of himself poorly.
Carlynn you did a great job but he seemed unappreciative and didn't even look exciting and happy you are kind I would have put the cake in his face lol
i hope its just awkardness around cameras (but.... this guy was on reality tv so not so sure about that) but he seem so unappreciative of your hardwork. This is so so cute and it made me sad to watch him make snide remarks.
You don't have to be too rich to be happy.Money isn't all, but the thought behind the little ones. They are good for each other Caellynn is down to earth wife with a good tease.Dean cut your hair for her and count yourself blessed for her.❤️❤️❤️
I don’t think Dean is being unappreciative I just think he’s not a very materialistic person and he appreciates the little things in life. He doesn’t think that you have to have expensive things to be sustained and happy in life. So give him a break y’all. Btw I love you guys so much🥰🥰🥰
love you guys so much!keep doing what you loved and enjoyed and ignore all the negativity(which i know you do)!keep doing amazing and great videos✨love from Singapore🇸🇬❤️
She's seems like a really good person, but he has zero incentive to marry her. They are living together, obviously sleeping together and she treats him like a king all without him having to put a ring on her finger. So why would he marry her when she is already acting like a wife? He's getting all of the perks of having a wife without having to make a commitment.
Great job Caelynn! I'm thinking of doing something like this for my husband's birthday (technically it was April 11 but he was away at work and I threw a fake funny birthday for him when he was not there...video on my channel) but I plan on throwing him a birthday now that he's home:-)
Caelynn an unsolicited tip for your man's next birthday/Christmas, mix up the practical (like waterproof camera bags and something to find keys?) with some sentimental/thoughtful gifts. You can tell what kinda gifts someone might like to receive by what they themselves give. He was heavy on the sentimental. Maybe that's why he's a bit 'meh' to a bunch of stuff he could have ordered himself, online.
Caelynn seems like such an attentive girlfriend, the little things like putting his favourite picture on the popsocket - so cute :')
yes, unlike you..
you spelled favourite wrong
@@achless1 I'm South African, that's how we spell it x
Jimmy lol most of the world spells it that way, you idiot
@DERRITY WHITEBOY why do you assume that ?!! You said meth over and over. Messed up to write this. You don't know them
Dean: breaks up with her on her bday
Caelynn: this amazingly planned quarantine birthday
Aww.... didn't even think of that! Sad😢
Do get married and do not let anything or anyone get in the way...this is how one makes it. Never give up and of course one has to grow up! Evolve don’t revolve....HBD! YOU BOTH NEED KIDS. Marriage first! ;)
🙃😊😉😎🌈😇
I was just thinking the same thing - hope Dean does not break up with Caelynn on her birthday after this!
Rosa Ungaro he’s already publicly stated that he does not intend to marry her.
Dean I hope you appreciate all the gifts and love Caelynn gives you she is so in love with you. I hope you treat her like a Queen because she is so special.
Caelynn wins best girlfriend award!!!
Aw Caelynn, what a special birthday you created! Love seeing little Pappy, so precious. Happy birthday Dean! You two just seem meant for each other. ❤️
caelynn i love how much effort you put into his day. this reminded me of well,,,me! i think as super thoughtful people it is often easy to forget that we deserve that same if not more in return. i love you & dean together & just hope he truly does appreciate you as you should be! much love.
You guys are just the cutest! Caelynn you really know how to make Dean feel special. Your love for him is obvious and your gestures adorable. I hope Dean knows how special you are and how much he is loved.
Caelynn youre too good for him. He is not able to express joy, happiness, excitement, and appreciation. How is it possible to picture a life with that kind of person, I wish you the best.
@Love So meditation turns you into an emotionless zombie? Nope. I have friends who meditate regularly and they are able to express gratitude when receiving gifts. They take obstacles in stride, but they are still able to express how happy they are when things go well.
Caelynn, seriously!! You did an awesome job! I hope Dean appreciates you!
Omg what amazing thoughtful gifts! You can tell dean isn’t used to getting spoiled like that. He almost didn’t know how to react! Lol! Caelynn really went out of her way to make it such an amazing bday under the circumstances! Everyone needs someone like her in their life!!!! Happy bday dean!!!!
Wow I'm really impressed. You did an amazing job and especially considering the circumstances. He's very lucky to have you! Best wishes to you both.
Caelynn, you are soooo amazing!!!!!! 💕💖💕
I love how you are so caring and kind and pay attention to the little details. You guys are so cute together and I’m rooting for y’all!!!! ⭐️
Watching your videos put a smile on my face the whole time. You two so down to earth and cute together. Love to see Pappi. Next I want to see you share your cooking ideas during this quarantine or Dean does your makeup 😃. It will be fun.
Dean. You are so awkwardly unappreciative. She is a Gem. An absolute beauty with a heart of gold. Any man on this Earth would put her on a pedastol as a queen where she belongs. And she's SMOKIN HOT LUCKYY MAN
Yes
This is beyond adorable!
Caelynn is so cute. Honestly he’s just an awkward person lol I think caelynn understands him so they make a good match. Or I could be completely wrong lolllll hopefully not
In. NO way did he show her any kind of love or respect in return . This shows what a real tool he is
caelynn: sets up a perfect dinner arrangement with individually placed fruits that clearly took a lot of time
dean: oh this is pretty cool...
me: i set up this entire thing i expect u to cry and say u love me and give me hugs even though its your bday
He seems so ungrateful and she seems soooo freaking sweet and thoughtful. not even a thank you???? wutthe?
OMG you Dean haters! Don't judge till you've been in his shoes. How comfortable would YOU ALL be expected to make out on camera 24/7?? Love is a private thing.
"HE'S 34"
*DEAN'S SHOOK*
"JUST KIDDING. HE'S 29 AND SO FINE"
AHAHHAAHHAHAAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHA TRUEEEEEEEE LOLOLOL
Oh Mu God I Love them together!!! My favorites on the bachelor! You 2 are perfect together! You go Dean you finally found her! 😁🥰😍💘
Hey Dean what about a BIG THANK YOU appreciate what you have because it may be gone she deserves to be treated with a little more respect any guy would love to have her thoughtfulness and creativity and most of all LOVE ....WAKE UP DEAN
This is awesome! GOALS! Happy Birthday, Dean!
You’re such a great girlfriend! I’m sure he appreciates you a whole lot.
So adorable 😍 love you two together. You guys look very happy!
Yall are THE BEST bachelor couple ever. It's real love...I can see it...I hope yall have beautiful babies and a happy forever together.
YOU GUYS ARE SO CUTEEEEEEE. MY FAVORITE COUPLE FROM BACHELOR NATION EVER. THE ONLY COUPLE I CARE ABOUT
You my girl are a gem!! Beautiful inside and out! Be sure that this man realizes that.
Love this Caelynn! Happy Birthday Dean, miss ya buddy
So glad you two are still together! Caelynn, you're amazing!! ...Oh! Happy belated birthday Dean!! :)
Dean doesn’t seem to know how to express his emotions to her
"FOR MY BIRTHDAY LAST YEAR DEAN WROTE ME TWO SILLY POEMS, SO I WROTE HIM A COUPLE FOR HIS." AWWWWWWWW THAT'S SO CUTE. I LOVE YOU GUYS SO MUCH TOGETHER
Happy Birthday Dean!! You both are awesome, including Pappy!!!
Happy Birthday Dean! Catelyn you did and awesome job!
I love ❤️ them together! Happy birthday Dean and good luck 😉
You people are making me cry now, love you so much.❤️❤️❤️❤️
I can’t believe they’re still together!
You guys are so cute together - Happy birthday Dean
Yall are the sweetest couple. You can see and feel the love, not even Dean can hide it XD
Glad it wasn’t just me. He subtly put down all her gifts, wasn’t appreciative of her or her efforts, and just doesn’t seem to really care about her. I’ve been exactly here before.He’s self centered and loves himself more than he loves her. Run honey, as fast as you can!
I was married to a guy that had a tough upbringing like Dean and he also had many sides to his persona. Shyness especially when the attention was solely on him. I believe Dean is in truly in love with Caelynn - he's transparent about the changes in himself he's working on not only for himself but for Caelynn as well. He confessed he had trouble committing to one relationship at the beginning but he also made it clear he doesn't wish to live his private love life on camera. Let's be careful how we judge. I think they bring out the best in each other! 👁💕💘
Ouch!! Brutal! They are still together and she's no dummy, that says a lot. C'mon give them the benefit of the doubt.
I don't think he loves himself. His favorite movie is interstellar.
Happy Birthday, such cute idea you gave him.
You guys can't judge a relationship by what it looks like from the outside to us. Let them live, they are the cutest! Dean is probs just shy
This is adorable Caelynn!!! You're so thoughtful! :)
May this couple last ,they are so polar opposite but like 2 puzzle pieces- complete each other.the gifts are so nice and so thoughtful.
You’re such a good girlfriend Caelynn. So thoughtful and sweet 🖤 Dean’s lucky to have you.
Happy Birthday Dean! Love and peace.
You are the sweetest, I really hope you know that, love. He is really lucky to have you
Caelynn fan since day 1. Dean fan since day 1. Funny that they ended up together!
This video filled me with so much joy, beautiful!
This is the cutest!! You guys are my favorite couple to come out of Bachelor Nation ❤️
He subtly puts her down constantly. He never says thank you. Never kisses her to show his gratitude. These relationships are so unfulfilling.
He's a douche for sure here. What she did was just so thoughtful and kind and beautiful. He seemed so unappreciative
We never hnow off cam though...
Sounds like you're projecting. And the rest of your life will be unfulfilling because you think you know everything. You look at a pair of strangers and you think you know everything about them.
Judging and deluding yourself allows you to feel superior, but alas - it is a delusion. And you will remain delusional and frustrated until you humble yourself.
Wow is it just me or does he look uncomfortable and comes off a bit... unappreciative of her efforts?
Elviera Miyaka ; yep. I would have a hard time with his negative depressed attitude.
Elviera Miyaka the man cannot be wowed no matter how hard you try 🙄😂 meanwhile you get caelynn a simple portrait puzzle and she’s jumping of happiness 🥺💛 but yes, it’s like someone doing nice things for him makes him uncomfortable idk if to be sad for him or to call him unappreciative 🤔 lol
I think he’s just awkward/ doesn’t know how to properly react to it since he had a rather messed up family life as i understand it
i'm sure he is appreciative. that's just dean.
Some people feel awkward when it comes to receiving gifts. I love giving gifts and go all out when it comes to that, but I never know how to act when someone gives me something! I do appreciate it though I’m sure he’s probably the same way.
This is so cute and thoughtful Caelynn!!!
You did such an amazing job, Caelynn. I hope he's appreciative when he's off camera.
So cute!! Glad to see you are in an apartment
Dean is cute and all, but Caelynn deserves someone who ADORES her, and I feel like he just "likes her a lot." Don't settle, Caelynn. Life's too short.
Marlyn Riedel yea I feel sad for her, I don't know if he will truly realize how great she is and just how much she loves him. O well
He is the most incredible boyfriend ever! We both don't know how to react to surprises, presents, etc. We're both awkward at receiving gifts.
Caelynn Miller-Keyes oh good 😊 ya makes sense...and you're an awesome gf!!! 👌🏼 xo
@@CaelynnBell I'll trust you on this (lol, like I have a choice). I have always liked your Dean -- just hope he is willing and able emotionally to give you everything. Get married, for goodness sake!
I agree he didnt appreciate it very much. She did an amazing job.
You know the Word thank you and i love you... It's terrible, she's the cutest
Omg just say thank you'
Very nice, Caelynn!
So he better bring it when it’s her birthday!!! She’s so sweet! He’s adorable, but better continue to treat her right.
Hello Dean & Caelyn I’m happy for you both and Dean we have the same birthday.... Take care of each other god loves you both ! Happy birthday Dean
You’re both so good to each other. Cute vlog!
Nice vlog..l am no. 1 fan here in the Philippines I really like you both.. Dean and Caelynn... forever....
Caelynn I’m so glad you followed your heart in BIP. In my opinion, you made the right choice. In a way, Colton led you straight to your 💛. Love you guys separately, love you even more together. ✨
Y’all so cute! Favourite bachelor in paradise couple
how are you guys surviving quarantine together???? and LOVE this surprise - you guys are so cute
So sweet Caelynn
This was sooo cuteee❤️❤️ i think dean has a different way of expressing himself. Hes not used to someone treating him the way caelyn does which might explain the way he comes off on camera. But u can tell hes thankful! ☺️❤️
Esmii Fernandez he honestly would have been happy playing video games the whole time. He’s trapped and he knows it. She deserves better
windowsdown i dont think so. Hes not “trapped” he knows what he has. I think its a self-esteem issue. He even said it in the show that he didnt feel good enough for her and that being her bf was gnn be horrible for her. Thats because he thinks of himself poorly.
@@windowsdown3684 pi
Best girlfriend ever!
Man he seems so not interested in all she has done... I feel bad for her!! If you aren’t happy leave!! She obviously loves you!!
Been there.
Lee Blair I don’t think he can go right now, quarantine time is safest to stay where you are.
@@julietteSoul he lives in a van he can indeed leave n be on his own
Carlynn you did a great job but he seemed unappreciative and didn't even look exciting and happy you are kind I would have put the cake in his face lol
i hope its just awkardness around cameras (but.... this guy was on reality tv so not so sure about that) but he seem so unappreciative of your hardwork. This is so so cute and it made me sad to watch him make snide remarks.
Katja Babcock ya that was cringe
I think with how he was raised I don’t think he realizes he’s doing it
God he seem so nagative on everything she got him.
I feel like we're the same person! These are the same ideas I wanted to do for my boyfriend. Love love love it!
It is incredible that you two are still together. Hopefully y'all get married and have babies
Deanie babies!
"happy birthday schnooka" LOVE THAT YOU GUYS HAVE NICKNAMES FOR EACH OTHER. SOOOOO CUTEEEEEE
You guys belong together ❤️❤️ Love the video!
Caelynn, you are a beautiful, thoughtful, sweet & intelligent young woman. I truly wish you the best in life.♥
Wow! Great birthday!!
Omg...This is the sweetest thing ever!!And u guys r the cutest ❤️
Be grateful, Dean!!!
Happy Birthday Caitlyn ....God Bless....
You don't have to be too rich to be happy.Money isn't all, but the thought behind the little ones. They are good for each other Caellynn is down to earth wife with a good tease.Dean cut your hair for her and count yourself blessed for her.❤️❤️❤️
I think these two make such a great couple because they seem like they understand each other and bring out the best in one another. I hope they last 💜
So sweet! Great couple!
LOVE YOU GUYS TOGETHER!
The cutest Bachelor couple for me!
I don’t think Dean is being unappreciative I just think he’s not a very materialistic person and he appreciates the little things in life. He doesn’t think that you have to have expensive things to be sustained and happy in life. So give him a break y’all. Btw I love you guys so much🥰🥰🥰
Impressive and thoughtful!.
Oh....it’s Dean bday.....happy birthday Dean.....From Durham New Hampshire
love you guys so much!keep doing what you loved and enjoyed and ignore all the negativity(which i know you do)!keep doing amazing and great videos✨love from Singapore🇸🇬❤️
Luv watching you guys be a couple.
Dean has to be the most unappreciative boyfriend lol... caelynn you’re the greatest!!!! So thoughtful and sweet
You guys are the cutest!
Wow she’s put so much effort into the finer details and he just brushes them off! I’d of married her by now, she’s one in a million
Hes an idiot lol
She's seems like a really good person, but he has zero incentive to marry her. They are living together, obviously sleeping together and she treats him like a king all without him having to put a ring on her finger. So why would he marry her when she is already acting like a wife? He's getting all of the perks of having a wife without having to make a commitment.
You guys are so cute!!!!
Great job Caelynn! I'm thinking of doing something like this for my husband's birthday (technically it was April 11 but he was away at work and I threw a fake funny birthday for him when he was not there...video on my channel) but I plan on throwing him a birthday now that he's home:-)
Happy Birthday to Dean thank you for another amazing vlog and can you please do a makeup video pleaseeee
Caelynn an unsolicited tip for your man's next birthday/Christmas, mix up the practical (like waterproof camera bags and something to find keys?) with some sentimental/thoughtful gifts. You can tell what kinda gifts someone might like to receive by what they themselves give. He was heavy on the sentimental. Maybe that's why he's a bit 'meh' to a bunch of stuff he could have ordered himself, online.
Happy Birthday Dean!
You’re the most beautiful and precious couple of the world..🥰👍...really. God bless you always 🙏🏻