GHADA KARMI on the LESSONS of OCTOBER 7th.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 116

  • @FrankBarat77
    @FrankBarat77  3 дні тому +38

    Would love a thumbs up, a share and for you to subscribe to the channel, thanks ! 🙏

    • @annaeveline8814
      @annaeveline8814 День тому

      Israel has the FAR LOWEST civilian : combattant casualty figure in any war EVER.
      "Palestinian" leaders had a strong bond to Germany from 1933 on.
      As Islamo -fascists Amin Husseini & Co lived 1941- 45 in Germany busy killing Jews.
      Husseini was convicted as WAR CRIMINAL but unfortunately later set free by France. So he than initiated the genocidal war against the LEGAL state of Israel in 1948.
      Husseini was the mastermind of ALL charters demanding ALL FIRST AND ONLY the death of ALL Jews in the ENTIRE world.
      As the Iranian regime, for the Islamo- fascist "religious" believe, that the prophet will return, when ALL infidels are dead - including YOU.
      "Free Palestine ? No thanks !"/
      tra vel ingi s rae l.
      It was NEVER about the land.
      And the BIGGEST colonial power was the Ottoman Empire, NOT the Europeans !!
      'Slave' comes from 'The Slavs', an European white tribe.
      TWO million Europeans were taken into the by Barbarians pirates, with the highest price for girls= CHILDREN 💔thethe, during over 400 years !
      In 1803 France/America paid BILLIONS to the Barbarian leader in FALSE promise of safe coasts/shipping .
      So in 1830 "bad" France "colonised" Algeria and destroyed the biggest market place for European captives in Algiers.
      Europe had EVERY RIGHT to end this SAVAGERY and to protect European children.
      The trade of dhimmi- woman was LEGAL in Ottoman/Turkey till AFTER 1910, in Saudi till 1960 !!
      💔Their descentends, "locals" with blonde/red hair or blue eyes, can be seen from Morocco (Salma La lla), Egypt (Bassem Yous.), Gaza (Tamimi), Afghanistan, Saudi ETC.
      Since Oct seven OVER a MILLION died in Yemen/Sudan....YOU DON'T CARE obviously.
      So you're just another deranged entisomotic.
      Grinning menster....use your brain.

  • @tigerlily5318
    @tigerlily5318 3 дні тому +24

    Gaza is a tragedy for humanity our hearts and feelings have changed completely

  • @nadjatfergusson3375
    @nadjatfergusson3375 3 дні тому +24

    I’m impressed (as usual) by the high quality of your interviews, Frank! And the fantastic selection of your guests!
    Ms.Ghada Karmi is a “treasure” ! Respect and admiration !
    🕊️🇵🇸🇩🇿

  • @yolandeshuck5515
    @yolandeshuck5515 3 дні тому +25

    “This cannot be allowed to happen…” thank you Ghada Karmi for denouncing that as well as the “rotten order”. Thank you Frank for inviting Ghada Karmi an admirable lady! Yes, developing ideas if not for now, but for the future.

  • @patricklagendijk6920
    @patricklagendijk6920 3 дні тому +24

    So impressed with your show Frank

  • @mugepurvis2955
    @mugepurvis2955 3 дні тому +14

    It's heart breaking to watch the horror of Gaza. Poor people are like lambs waiting to be slaughtered and the whole world is watching and turning their heads to the other side. So sad!

  • @joaomiguelxs
    @joaomiguelxs 3 дні тому +30

    Ghada Karmi is a force of nature, the voice of reason for Palestine liberation. It is a honor and a pleasure to listen to her.

    • @victormeidan1062
      @victormeidan1062 2 дні тому +1

      Ghada is a force of nature - like a potent THART in an elevator.

    • @keithzandes-1991
      @keithzandes-1991 2 дні тому +2

      I completely agree❤

    • @annaeveline8814
      @annaeveline8814 День тому

      She's heavily deranged to support these Gazan=Hamas monsters.
      Esreel has the FAR LOWEST civilian : terrerest casualty number in any war EVER.
      So this chennel is N U T S !!

  • @paulglobus9999
    @paulglobus9999 3 дні тому +14

    Thank you for giving Ms. Karmi a platform. She is brilliant. Another hero.

  • @sandrajensen497
    @sandrajensen497 3 дні тому +19

    Ghada Karmi is brilliant, articulate, and a truly admirable human being! Thank you, Frank!

  • @somtA-g6z
    @somtA-g6z 3 дні тому +12

    What an insightful lady.merci beaucoup!!!

  • @celticali1
    @celticali1 3 дні тому +10

    Wonderful channel ,amazing guests so much respect for you both.Thank you for all you do💪❤️🇵🇸❤️

  • @citlalli9
    @citlalli9 3 дні тому +12

    Gracias Frank 🇲🇽 ♡ 🇵🇸

  • @cao-sm3lj
    @cao-sm3lj 3 дні тому +15

    she is absolutely right.

    • @somtA-g6z
      @somtA-g6z 3 дні тому +2

      Fear to lose comfortable (iliusionary) lives

  • @illlumination
    @illlumination 3 дні тому +15

    Another beut Frank. Merci Gada!

  • @suzannerouleau6127
    @suzannerouleau6127 3 дні тому +9

    Thank you for your last words, explanations Madame.

  • @mireillevaucoret5496
    @mireillevaucoret5496 3 дні тому +15

    I am as despaired as she is, with the new developments, but for one thing. You talked about the culturecide, but not only has the Palestinian culture continued in books, movies, poetry, but its dissemination was growing before the genocide, and now people around the world have discovered it, and will cherish it and spread it because of the attachment and the admiration they have developed for the Palestinians in Gaza.

    • @victormeidan1062
      @victormeidan1062 2 дні тому

      What is fakestinian culture ?
      Suicide bombings, mass rapes, stabbings and shootings?
      No thanks !

  • @catherinemallet9180
    @catherinemallet9180 3 дні тому +13

    Thank you very much to Ghada Karmi, I share your analysis and your positions like one land, but I share also your fears about Syrie and Iran.

  • @TheButterphoenix
    @TheButterphoenix 3 дні тому +8

    thank you both

  • @Vjaffacake-c6t
    @Vjaffacake-c6t 3 дні тому +8

    Thank you.

  • @JoëlleZoghbi
    @JoëlleZoghbi 3 дні тому +4

    Merci Milles fois, enrichissant

  • @ashleyKennedy5
    @ashleyKennedy5 3 дні тому +13

    My vote goes to Ghada Karmi and Avi Shlaim as Prime minister and President of Palestine.

  • @gladispetitdemange3333
    @gladispetitdemange3333 3 дні тому +4

    Shukran ktir❤ bravo Frank 👏👏👏👏

  • @JacquelineDeschamp-xv4ww
    @JacquelineDeschamp-xv4ww День тому +2

    Merci pour cet entretien si inspirant

  • @mercedesruiz3356
    @mercedesruiz3356 2 дні тому +3

    Muchas gracias Frank y Gada.

  • @adelag.garcia4654
    @adelag.garcia4654 3 дні тому +5

    Gracias infinitas, Frank, por acercarnos a gente tan grande, conocedora e íntegra como Ghada Karmi, estoy impactada, me inclino ante ella... ¡Oh, qué podríamos hacer, me pregunto, cómo unir nuestra energía desde todos los confines del mundo para que en medio de esta realidad profundamente tenebrosa estalle pura e inocente como un niño, una niña palestina la flor de la esperanza?

  • @bidaarsho2938
    @bidaarsho2938 День тому +1

    Thank you…an enlightened & original Palestinian guest/ lady 🙏🏿

  • @vickyscrivener5708
    @vickyscrivener5708 3 дні тому +3

    Thankyou so much for this great interview with Dr Karmi, Frank: painful as it was; and the fall of Syria - which is a massive blow to the resistance - but the resilience of the Palestinian people and the love, respect and cognition worldwide for their struggle will continue always.

  • @HankaGrupinska
    @HankaGrupinska 3 дні тому +2

    Frank, thank you!

  • @nancymartin1551
    @nancymartin1551 День тому

    Thank you, Frank, for introducing me to a group of thinkers that I had not known before. Thoughtful, knowledgeable people that I have enjoyed listening to and I have learned from their expertise. I really love your compassion. It shines brightly and makes me feel a bit better.

  • @yhamilajojo8847
    @yhamilajojo8847 3 дні тому +2

    Thank you so much to this analysis on the area. It is the voice in the middle east. ..., pacience is our best tool

  • @djess9882
    @djess9882 3 дні тому +3

    Frank tu es exceptionnel je t'admire ❤

  • @jayneyaghmour7320
    @jayneyaghmour7320 День тому +1

    Such a wonderful lady ❤

  • @fafasardi6136
    @fafasardi6136 3 дні тому +7

    1er lik et 1er commentaire pouvez vous traduire svp Franck 👍👍

    • @FrankBarat77
      @FrankBarat77  3 дні тому +1

      désolé, pas le temps de faire ça, mais si vous connaissez des gens qui peuvent faire ça, je me ferai un plaisir d'inclure les sous titres en français biensur.

    • @3475-m9e
      @3475-m9e 3 дні тому +2

      Moi je mets les sous-titres automatiques en français et ça marche pas mal

    • @3475-m9e
      @3475-m9e 3 дні тому

      Le résultat du 7 octobre c’est que maintenant la majorité des peuples du monde qui auparavant ne s’intéressaient pas à Israël ont aujourd’hui la haine d’israël pour le génocide qu’il commet. Je ne sais pas à quoi cela aboutira mais cela laissera des traces qui ne seront pas en faveur des israéliens

  • @mtsanga3421
    @mtsanga3421 3 дні тому +2

    Amazing interview ! Thanks a lot !

  • @kot3291
    @kot3291 2 дні тому

    thank you for your show especially this interview. One of the few times i had the chance to listen to Mrs. Karmi and immediately clicked on the video. She's proof of the great culture people that Palestinians ARE!

  • @keithzandes-1991
    @keithzandes-1991 2 дні тому +3

    I'm reeling with shock and complete dismay,as well, Ghada. I've been and am extremely depressed and utterly forlorn, too; however, please remember that this geographical area (Syria) has always been notoriously used for smuggling. Viva la résistance.❤ 🎉BOOM 🎉❤

  • @fuckbankers
    @fuckbankers 3 дні тому +8

    Didn't the UN tell the settlers to get out of the occupied West Bank?

    • @najaahamari4199
      @najaahamari4199 3 дні тому +1

      Exactly, that can't be ignored. They have to decolonize, retreat or be expelled, end the occupation and the apartheid.

  • @marijanavonbahr9594
    @marijanavonbahr9594 День тому

    Thank you both.

  • @GillianRose-ok7ig
    @GillianRose-ok7ig 17 годин тому

    Thank you Frank, really appreciate your interviews, always so insightful ❤

  • @user-rn1jo5zq2h
    @user-rn1jo5zq2h 3 дні тому

    ❤❤❤merci.

  • @TheTruthwillOut442
    @TheTruthwillOut442 3 дні тому +4

    The outlook is very bleak. It looks like evil has won. Heartbroken for all the lost lives.

  • @ngonsainti
    @ngonsainti 20 годин тому

    Wow. Thank madame.

  • @jhafkuhkjhfksdbhdsfb
    @jhafkuhkjhfksdbhdsfb 3 дні тому +1

    Ghada

  • @fredericbrochard3383
    @fredericbrochard3383 3 дні тому +1

    Bonjour de France ✊ 🇵🇸

  • @BilginKurt
    @BilginKurt 3 дні тому +2

  • @kot3291
    @kot3291 2 дні тому +2

    i think cultureside crimes has always gone hand in hand with genocide, chauvinism, ethnic cleansing, invasion - thru war or peace such as recently with regime/system changes.

  • @mobena1322
    @mobena1322 3 дні тому +3

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

  • @MoSec9
    @MoSec9 День тому +1

    I like Ghada’s realistic attitude. We all would love to see the zio state disappear and be replaced with something more normal, but I don’t like the baseless optimism. I live in the US and we all know very well that just because the colonial project based on the elimination of indigenous people is wrong and inhumane etc. that doesn’t mean it couldn’t succeed. Who talks about native Americans now. Yes, these are different times, but not that different. Something has to change real quick, something as big as October in the whole Arab world especially in Egypt and other neighboring countries.

  • @batuach100
    @batuach100 20 годин тому

    🎉🎉🎉🎉😊

  • @suzannerouleau6127
    @suzannerouleau6127 3 дні тому +5

    I read that according to their DNA, the Jews of Israel are indeed of predominantly European ancestry

  • @HuskyKing-q2l
    @HuskyKing-q2l День тому

    The question everyone should be asking is how the UN has done nothing since it broke up Palestine with its 1947 Partition Plan for Palestine where two countries were to be created from one Palestine (then under British Mandate when Britain stole the land from the Ottoman empire). Israel took theirs in 1948 and then colluded with the US and Britain for nearly 80 years to keep Palestine as only a dream. The UN and namely the US and UK owe the world a public apology for their outright evilness.

  • @fashioncitymetaverse
    @fashioncitymetaverse 19 годин тому +1

    Its obvious having a one state Israel won't work you can tell thats the case because of how Israel is acting towards neighbor country's think about it 🤔. A 2 state is not acceptable by Israel ots obvious Israel said it doesn't want a Palestine 🇵🇸 state on Palestine land that Israel was created on. Let's try going back to a one state Palestine state like it was before the creation of Israel on Palestine land by the UN, it was more peaceful.

  • @fidomusic
    @fidomusic День тому

    I respect both Frank and Ghada. But the fact that Assad was a brutal distac¥ater should not be left out of the analsys.

  • @OliveTree-dd5vp
    @OliveTree-dd5vp 2 години тому

    Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤

  • @roisinmalone3015
    @roisinmalone3015 12 годин тому

    Tx
    They can't destroy the witnesses this time because we are all witnesses to the horror.

  • @joelbitton
    @joelbitton 20 годин тому +1

    I am a 73 year old man and I have spent the better part of my life trying to understand why I seem to always feel a certain sadness in my heart. Then I thought, maybe this had something to do with it. Hopefully this story brings out others like me. In 1963 Zionists came to my home in Casablanca Morocco, to convince my parents to send me and my little sister to Israel without them. I was 12 and my sister 9 when we started our miserable journey to the "Promised land". It destroyed our family and left me and my sister with long lasting scars neither one of us has been able to heal. Being from Morocco made it even more difficult to live in a more racist country than Morocco ever was. We had a very peaceful life as Jews living amongst Muslims in Morocco. We understood each other and helped each other. To this day, the principal advisor to King Mohamed is a Jew. But the Zionists needed boddies to fill Israel and slowly claim more and more land from the Palestinians they kept displacing. The people running Israel are not Jews. True Jews would have helped the Palestinians evolve and share in their fortunes, like we did for centuries in the Arab world. Israel claims it is defending itself? Against whom? The people they have been displacing and opressing for 80 years? Israel, my advice to you, if you want to survive, get rid of the religious zealots who run your government and join the 21st century.

  • @leroitiaks
    @leroitiaks 3 дні тому +1

    It is not correct to be so pessimistic when fighters are dying in Gaza. Syria was a burden to the Resistance in the last decade, and that is why Iran and Russia had disengaged.

  • @warmperson2007
    @warmperson2007 3 дні тому +3

    By the way, I just learned that Druze Syrians from the Golan Heights are making every effort to obtain Israeli citizenship, just like their Israeli Druze brothers who are fortunate to have been born in a democratic Israel, enjoying all its benefits. Does this woman and the guy interviewing her really understand the Middle East ?

    • @redparrot448
      @redparrot448 3 дні тому +2

      what like the Druze living in Occupied Golan who refuse to give up their Syrian nationality??

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 3 дні тому +1

      @@redparrot448 You’re talking about a few elderly people. The young people all want to become Israeli, and I understand them!

    • @redparrot448
      @redparrot448 3 дні тому +2

      @@warmperson2007 not sure where your stats for that are? 2018 figures I have read based on the Israeli Population and Immigration Authority show that only 6.5% applied for Israeli citizenship since 1967. There is only one area where the majority have taken citizenship. Otherwise its about 12% of Syrians that have taken citizenship, most of whom by birth, marriage and change of address.

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 2 дні тому +1

      @ Things are changing rapidly in this region. When was the last time you visited the Golan? The Druze are enlightened and aren't afraid to switch sides when it suits them better. It is clear that the situation of Arab Israelis is far better than that of other Arabs: unemployment benefits, social security, retirement, along with the right to express themselves freely without fear and the ability to travel the world with their Israeli passport. Again : when was the last time you have been there ?

    • @redparrot448
      @redparrot448 2 дні тому +1

      @@warmperson2007 do you have any updated statistics?

  • @janapender4989
    @janapender4989 3 дні тому

    What does she think?If it is not genocide, is it a celebration of Palestinians?

  • @christiansmith-of7dt
    @christiansmith-of7dt 3 дні тому

    They treated my grandfathers alot better than they treated me

  • @ChrisRegan-on9tx
    @ChrisRegan-on9tx 2 дні тому

    CF

  • @jasonbrambach6957
    @jasonbrambach6957 3 дні тому

    Short term gain and long term loss for 🇺🇸🇮🇱It’s not that “might makes right” isn’t ravaging our planets resources with ‘success’ but, rather, that the planetary consequences are absolutely unavoidable. I think that we, as a species, look narrowly at racial,religious, national conflicts and ignore our species ubiquitous akiles heel. Namely, that we tend towards supremacist ideology. Yes, we are ‘intellectually’ superior to other species and can annihilate them. We are ‘winning’ so to speak, but with 2/3 of the other species extinct and 97% of the biomass on earth made up of people and their livestock our ‘superiority’ and self aggrandizing ideas of ‘Gods favorite animal’ are going to be revealed as utterly meaningless when the fabric of ages of natural interconnected evolution is in tatters. 😢I really don’t see a way out for humanity. Most of our mindsets are ‘at war’ and the imaginary peace between world wars is only a diminution of the scale of the violence. The transformation of our species needed to happen long ago if we were going to avoid Armageddon. So enjoy what you have now and be as blissful and COMPASSIONATE as possible because THAT is all one can really do. (Hope someone enjoys my essay!! LOL)😂

  • @honeyho9890
    @honeyho9890 3 дні тому +2

    You ask for it. You started the war. Peaceful religion? My toes are laughing

  • @bh1935
    @bh1935 4 години тому

    Praising Oct 7. Your sick

  • @talksmoke1190
    @talksmoke1190 3 дні тому +2

    What awful guests you have

  • @warmperson2007
    @warmperson2007 2 дні тому

    The lessons of October 7th ? I see only one : "Do not do to others what you do not want done to you," or "You don't throw stones at your neighbor's house when you live in a glass house." That's what we tell our children. The people of Gaza had a good life before October 7, 2023.

    • @fidomusic
      @fidomusic День тому

      Gaza was a concentration camp before October 7, 2023. Israel controlled all borders and everything going in and out of the strip, even down to the number of calories Palestinians consumed. The only mystery is why something like Oct 7 did not happen before.

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 22 години тому

      @ Concentration camp? Really? Do you seriously believe that? Who told you this-Norman Finkelstein? Miko Peled? This is exactly the kind of fake news that those who hate Israel concoct! While these individuals propagate numerous falsehoods, the one that stands out to me is their use of the term 'concentration camp' to describe the Gaza Strip. Firstly, this term is far from trivial, and they are fully aware of its implications. What we are witnessing is a perverse manipulation of language. Secondly, it’s difficult to understand how they can equate a place with one of the highest birth rates and population growth in the world with a place where people supposedly die by the thousands every day from distress and deprivation. Thirdly, due to the considerable influx of funds into Gaza, along with its moderate climate, beautiful beaches, and stunning sunsets, we can confidently say that life in Gaza (before October 7, 2023) was significantly better than in many dark major cities in Europe and the United States. Individuals like Miko Peled and Norman Finkelstein are constructing an alternate reality in an effort to persuade us, and it seems to be resonating with inexperienced students who have never had the opportunity to visit the region.

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 19 годин тому

      @ Gaza? A concentration camp? Are you sure you have access to reliable information? I think you might be getting brainwashed by some malicious propagandists. Gaza is a region of the world with one of the highest birth rates and population growth rates globally. That says it all !

  • @mrno.7366
    @mrno.7366 День тому

    Israel belong to the Jewish people who are the true owner of the holy land ❤

    • @MichelleNewit-xd1nl
      @MichelleNewit-xd1nl День тому +1

      No you are not the semites, ashkenazi jews are not from the tribe of israel,you love maki g up history zio shill.

  • @maryking5051
    @maryking5051 3 дні тому +1

    I hope you live to see your vision manifest, Ghada

  • @maryking5051
    @maryking5051 3 дні тому

    Ghada you talk perfect sense

  • @aae8783
    @aae8783 22 години тому

    HISTORY KRONOLIGI GIOPOLITICK OSMANLI TURKIC TURKIYE 💫say spiko ⚰🪦📚📖TC R T Erdogan ♟Sah Mat ✍✅