Bret Weinstein Is A Total Charlatan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2022
  • Writer Robert Wright Tweeted About Something Bret Weinstein Recently Said, Where He Made The Claim That Democrats May Have Maintained The Vaccine Mandate For Armed Forces To Degrade Military Readiness. Wright Thought That Weinstein's Theory Was Completely Crazy, Despite Agreeing With Some Of Bret's Claims In The Past. Weinstein And His Wife Heather Heying Responded To Wright, And Said That This Was Not A Theory But A Hypothesis.
    Watch the Majority Report live Monday-Friday at 12 p.m. EST on UA-cam OR listen via daily podcast at www.Majority.FM
    www.house.gov/representatives...
    www.senate.gov/senators/senat...
    #MajorityReport #BretWeinstein #IDW #Democrats #politics
    SUPPORT the show by becoming a member: www.jointhemajorityreport.com/
    Download TMR's FREE app: www.majorityapp.com
    TMR MERCH: www.shop.majorityreportradio.com
    OTHER LINKS:
    Twitch: / themajorityreport
    Facebook: / majorityreport
    Twitter: / majorityfm
    Instagram: / majorityreport.fm

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @andrewebert6339
    @andrewebert6339 Рік тому +27

    If you’re going to tear people down for attention, at least be funny….

  • @griffindeluce
    @griffindeluce Рік тому +151

    "Great minds discuss ideas: average minds discuss events: small minds discuss people." -Eleanor Roosevelt

    • @joserodall7321
      @joserodall7321 Рік тому +17

      The altitud of your statement is to high for the heads in this comment section

    • @stophatingeachother9762
      @stophatingeachother9762 Рік тому +38

      That's literally all they do on this Channel is talk s*** on other people

    • @fatred777
      @fatred777 Рік тому +1

      Uhhhh do people actually listen to these guys? Talk about lack of content. 20:25 of my life pissed away.

    • @numberonepiston
      @numberonepiston Рік тому +7

      Well put, fittingly so.

    • @harrypalmer907
      @harrypalmer907 Рік тому +11

      exactly, which is all Sam Seder does, discuss and slander other people.

  • @jeffrobuck6338
    @jeffrobuck6338 Рік тому +47

    Cognitive dissonance is apparently alive and well in America.

  • @Madmartigan6
    @Madmartigan6 Рік тому +59

    Oh look, Sam's obsession with misrepresenting Brett continues. I find it so funny how Sam talks about people being taken out of context, then he goes ahead and takes Brett out of context constantly.
    Sam, you're way out of your league. The data was discussed, but you edited that part out because you're a shill 👍

    • @joserodall7321
      @joserodall7321 Рік тому +6

      Petty and envious

    • @lookbovine
      @lookbovine 2 місяці тому

      Was the data shown or alluded to? That’s what counts.

  • @ksb916
    @ksb916 Рік тому +5

    Politicians and law makers are not as wise as these people think.

  • @Noumenon4Idolatry
    @Noumenon4Idolatry Рік тому +110

    Well, he was right about gain of function and Wuhan. So he should at least be given credit for taking an unpopular position instead of being a sheeple.

    • @galvanaut7119
      @galvanaut7119 Рік тому +8

      No, he wasn't right about that at all. It's abundantly clear by now.

    • @Noumenon4Idolatry
      @Noumenon4Idolatry Рік тому

      @@galvanaut7119
      Your joking, right? First it started as a wild conspiracy theory. Why? Nobody knows. Maybe the CIA knows. This is back when Nancy Pelosi was in Chinatown hugging Asians on TV calling trump a racist for wanting to freeze Corona flights from China. It’s almost like the democrats wanted the virus here. Xenophobia = whatever. Then after that you were a psycho for saying the virus provably came from the lab in Wuhan. Even John Stuart called this out. It’s so obvious that John had to call it out. Now? The media and our social media censorship fact checker wannabe commie censorship psychos have had to accept that it’s a haha more then a possibility…but of course, thanks to the lunatic censorship from the left and whoever puppets them we didn’t get to do the research needed early in the pandemic
      Only more reason to laugh at how pathetic the censors are

    • @galvanaut7119
      @galvanaut7119 Рік тому

      @@Noumenon4Idolatry Why don't you try to actually learn something about this topic first and come back. It clearly came for a zoonotic origin and was spread through the wet markets. Just study the science. The ignorance of the Weinstein simps is so prevalent that it's pathetic. You need to understand science and apply critical thinking.

    • @Noumenon4Idolatry
      @Noumenon4Idolatry Рік тому

      @@galvanaut7119
      Your an idiot. Maybe you should go study it. I bet you believe everything your told. Dumbass. What’s your critical thinking? Your new God Fauci covered his tracks and told you so? Your naive.

    • @wellnesspathforme6236
      @wellnesspathforme6236 Рік тому +6

      @@galvanaut7119 Rachel Maddoe is not spewing science, champ.
      It is psyence for cash. At your expense

  • @Noumenon4Idolatry
    @Noumenon4Idolatry Рік тому +7

    I believe everything the government tells me. I don’t even ask questions.

    • @B-Nice
      @B-Nice Рік тому +1

      You'd be a horrible person if you didn't follow blindly!!

    • @Noumenon4Idolatry
      @Noumenon4Idolatry Рік тому +1

      @@B-Nice
      I stick my fingers in my eyes every day. 😄

    • @rhysperegrine5100
      @rhysperegrine5100 Рік тому +3

      I educated myself thoroughly by watching MMA commentators and anti-woke celebrities have deep, penetrating conversations on UA-cam

    • @Noumenon4Idolatry
      @Noumenon4Idolatry Рік тому

      @@rhysperegrine5100
      I completely ignored everything on UA-cam and I let the corporate captured media tell me whatever propaganda the government wants to feed me.

  • @dmttruth9060
    @dmttruth9060 Рік тому +70

    Brett Weinstein is a hero.

    • @utubepunk
      @utubepunk Рік тому +8

      Laughable.

    • @berniethekiwidragon4382
      @berniethekiwidragon4382 Рік тому +2

      Not at all. He's a wannabe villain who has his hooks sunk into you and other people. He is not arguing in good faith. He is not arguing honestly.

    • @dmttruth9060
      @dmttruth9060 Рік тому +1

      @@berniethekiwidragon4382 nonsense

    • @berniethekiwidragon4382
      @berniethekiwidragon4382 Рік тому

      @@dmttruth9060 That which he is full of.

    • @dmttruth9060
      @dmttruth9060 Рік тому +1

      @@berniethekiwidragon4382 The Weinsteins are people of courage & honour - something you would not understand.

  • @befirmbefair6674
    @befirmbefair6674 Рік тому +11

    Beware of those who can raze a temple but cannot raise one in its place.

    • @lookbovine
      @lookbovine 2 місяці тому

      Pity those who raise temples for praise.

  • @gkilsetup442
    @gkilsetup442 Рік тому +6

    I'm currently serving- there is a mass exodus. Retention is suffering and 63k soldiers ( possibly more) are refusing. There for they can't fulfill their obligations- so they're gunna have to be discharged. I'm also a first responder in NYC and the hospitals been empty for this entire lie

    • @markpostgate2551
      @markpostgate2551 Рік тому

      Is that leaving things understaffed or is that an acceptable amount of staff to offload. I don't know what 63k would be as a percentage of the whole (Full disclosure: I'm totally a civilian. I can't even march in time! Conscripting me would be like a Woody Allen sketch from the pre-Mia era when he was funny). If it's only 10% or less they might be deliberately wheedling out non-compliant personality types. Hazing rituals, which are traditional in military outfits even though the modern military officially disapproves of them, must lead to some dropping out, but the point of the ritual is that those that remain are less likely to leave because they have undergone an ordeal that would have been for nothing if they left after having gone through it, so they become more committed to their membership of the group responsible for their hazing. Well, that's the theory at any rate. So given hazing must lead to some drop outs, is it a similar figure?

    • @gkilsetup442
      @gkilsetup442 Рік тому +1

      @@markpostgate2551 it's in unacceptable offload. Our rating in the army for man power is "marginal"- with other branches labeled " weak" . With a 25% debt to the next year. They claim it's " only this or that percentage "- as if they can afford the loss- but that's to save face and de- legitimize covid Injection resistance. They've been operating at low capacity for sometime and there's no elaborate " weeding out" or " non-compliant personality types" . Dont give them too much credit- they still think crossfit pt is good, and dont know how to web design.I served 20 yrs - kind of an asshole thing to imply "unsoldierly" personality type for those resisting an unlawful order. served in Iraq 2006 2007; special operations- I've been through " ordeals" you can't even grasp-earning so much- still, ill refuse and lose. Jail me; bad conduct discharges; I'm ready. I'll frame a letter of reprimand- most honorable thing i earned.
      and I don't know what " hazing" you're talking about, that's for rich highschool kid lacrosse teams. Or closeted football players.
      Id walk away with nothing and still would gain everything. Life is bigger than this. The military can't undue the service I already serve; they can't " unvet" me. I am what I am. I served to be a soldier. Just that. It's a culture thing. All they can try to do, is blacklist me, label me- that doesn't matter to my soul or to the world. This isn't the 1950s. It's an unlawful order- they had to alter the definition of vaccine- and what they claim isn't backed by anything- approved by unelected offices and panels. That's like renaming " genocide " to " administrative culling"- then providing an "explanation" that sounds official with " science" . Exactly Like Hitler. It's in the army core values to demonstrate PERSONAL COURAGE, at risk to comfort of career and self, to contest such unlawful orders. And to BEAR TRUE FAITH IN THE CONSTITUTION- the Supreme law of land - above the president and any elected offices

    • @markpostgate2551
      @markpostgate2551 Рік тому

      @@gkilsetup442
      I hope you don't think I was being an asshole; the idea that non-compliant personality types might be unsoldierly wasn't me expressing my opinion but speculating that that could be the opinion of an authoritarian government.

  • @jayjaychadoy9226
    @jayjaychadoy9226 Рік тому +79

    Bret is a brilliant and sane communicator, a kind, thoughtful, patient man, and I love Heather, too.

    • @jpw5029
      @jpw5029 Рік тому

      He might be a psychopath and a boring one

    • @good4gaby
      @good4gaby Рік тому +7

      a sane communicator

    • @nickromo8195
      @nickromo8195 9 місяців тому +5

      People are entitled to their opinions but you are wrong nonetheless

    • @JamLeGull
      @JamLeGull 9 місяців тому +6

      Brilliant, sane and thoughtful don’t mean much if they apply to Bojack Horsepaste

    • @HTHAMMACK1
      @HTHAMMACK1 9 місяців тому

      He's a wack job.

  • @Bubba-Stravinsky
    @Bubba-Stravinsky Рік тому +2

    The number of vaccines that the active military receive is in the teens at a minimum, especially if you were being assigned duty overseas

  • @landiepete
    @landiepete Рік тому +36

    There is only one charlatan here. It's not Bret.

  • @batgirlp5561
    @batgirlp5561 Рік тому +5

    Brought to you by the prager u school of debating.

  • @shawncollins1025
    @shawncollins1025 Рік тому +2

    The enrollment into the military has been dropping......vaccinations? Other jobs available? Obesity, people can't qualify for the military?
    Bigger issue than just vaccines.

  • @zac52
    @zac52 Рік тому +11

    So these people take a position on someone and then act smug about it while trying unsuccessfully to be funny. The algorithm has failed me on this one

    • @Mrs_Puffington
      @Mrs_Puffington 6 місяців тому +2

      That really seems to be all this channel is doing. To be fair, there are a lot of those out there.

    • @terrellwashington8507
      @terrellwashington8507 5 місяців тому +1

      Wow I'm only 2 min in and felt the same just couldn't internally express as well as you. Thanks

  • @darklumin
    @darklumin Рік тому +17

    4:52 is the upper right square laughing with him or at him? 🤔😆

    • @joshuaDstarks
      @joshuaDstarks Рік тому +2

      At the audacity of the notion.

    • @ZERO_O7X
      @ZERO_O7X Рік тому +4

      And what's up with the dude in the lower right sides jaw? 😂 Bro looks like he's been chewing nothing but boot leather for decades.

    • @joshuaDstarks
      @joshuaDstarks Рік тому +1

      @@ZERO_O7X I think he’s the last Jawcersizer around.

    • @darklumin
      @darklumin Рік тому +2

      @@ZERO_O7X If Big Ed was in the Marine Corps 🤣

    • @leonardobautista2647
      @leonardobautista2647 Рік тому +1

      That was actually funny lol

  • @RoodiniCats
    @RoodiniCats Рік тому +17

    "I think I saw him at the Louvre, glueing his hand to the wall"
    😂😂😂

  • @captain_crunk
    @captain_crunk Рік тому +125

    "We're logic-ing all over the place." - Emma Vigeland, 2022

    • @okie38yahoocom
      @okie38yahoocom Рік тому +1

      Logic. LOL, for a GOPPer?

    • @scottlaux6934
      @scottlaux6934 Рік тому +5

      She is awesome.

    • @scottlaux6934
      @scottlaux6934 Рік тому

      @@guyincognito8440 you trumpists are always "incognito". Scared and insecure.

    • @vgold4286
      @vgold4286 Рік тому

      Who?

    • @underscore8256
      @underscore8256 Рік тому

      Just some high level military lawyers who fought and won the cause for the anthrax vaccine the wrecked havoc on service members around that time

  • @bushfingers
    @bushfingers Рік тому +78

    Just to be clear - Brett and Eric and considerably brighter than every one of you :)

  • @stoniblue3569
    @stoniblue3569 Рік тому +74

    This will not age well…

    • @calstevensen1996
      @calstevensen1996 Рік тому +27

      Member when everyone made fun of Bret for saying it looked like the virus came from a lab?

    • @williamerdman4888
      @williamerdman4888 Рік тому +4

      You are correct!

    • @williamerdman4888
      @williamerdman4888 Рік тому +7

      @@calstevensen1996 Yep.....

    • @gxlorp
      @gxlorp Рік тому +14

      They are deep down scared, that stuff Bret is saying may be true. Sooner or later our society will have go face the music en masse. It's better to just get it over with, rip the bandaid off.

    • @ThePrairieFairymb
      @ThePrairieFairymb Місяць тому +1

      Correct. Did not age well at all.

  • @ReederCasey
    @ReederCasey Рік тому +4

    Robert Wright is definitely NOT intellectual dark web adjacent. He somehow managed to be interested in a lot of the same stuff but without partaking of any of the same values or attitudes.
    He's been on the 'maybe Brett Weinstein is a complete charlatan' beat for a while, but he bends over backwards to be charitable, and so was withholding any final public judgement.
    He's also always been a non-interventionist and constantly emphasizes the importance of 'cognitive empathy', and seeing foreign policy from the other country's perspective.
    The more I think about it, Robert Wright is kind of what you get if someone actually proceeded with the kind of intellectual principles the Sam Harris types only pretend to espouse.

    • @christopherhamilton3621
      @christopherhamilton3621 10 місяців тому

      I dunno… RW is just as opinionated & defensive as any of these guys.

  • @landonech
    @landonech Рік тому +25

    Kind of bummed that everyone on the show was unfamiliar with Robert Wright’s work. A “Skeptic/science blogger” who operates in a space that is “definitely where Weinstein came out of” is a pretty irresponsible characterization. I’d recommended listeners of this show to subscribe to his Non-Zero newsletter where he has previously been quite critical of the Weinstein’s as well as offer quite good coverage of the Russia/Ukraine war and the American response to it, among many other things. He somewhat recently interviewed Ben Burgis (friend of this show) on his Hitchens book, whom Wright previously clashed with on the Iraq War. Hold you to a high standard: do better.

    • @coreyander286
      @coreyander286 Рік тому +1

      Calling him "quite critical" of the Weinsteins is underselling it. Half of Wright's career the past decade has been opposition to the New Atheists and IDWers, from a leftwing, anti-interventionist perspective.

    • @rwe1334
      @rwe1334 Рік тому +4

      Just made the same comment! I was also very surprised and disappointed.

    • @tdb517
      @tdb517 Рік тому +5

      This video, like this comment section made me lost a few iq points. Your comment helped me recover one or two.

    • @mrtambourineman6107
      @mrtambourineman6107 Рік тому +1

      I love Rob Wright ❤️

    • @nickromo8195
      @nickromo8195 9 місяців тому

      People change and doing one thing does not cancel out another

  • @johnnybravo123ab
    @johnnybravo123ab Рік тому +3

    Echo-chamber: "an environment in which a person encounters only beliefs or opinions that coincide with their own".

    • @tdb517
      @tdb517 Рік тому +5

      You mean like this channel and this comment section?

    • @joserodall7321
      @joserodall7321 Рік тому +1

      @@tdb517 I don’t see any other contextual explanation

  • @scorch4299
    @scorch4299 Рік тому +3

    listening to this video actually made me dumber.

  • @ZERO_O7X
    @ZERO_O7X Рік тому +13

    Bert Wisenheimer is by far the most boring of all the current lineup of conservative grifters.

    • @joshuaDstarks
      @joshuaDstarks Рік тому +1

      Easily the worst, as in blandest.

    • @LinkRocks
      @LinkRocks Рік тому +3

      Prager is really dull too.

    • @daviebananas1735
      @daviebananas1735 Рік тому +2

      @@LinkRocks Nah, at least Prager does batshit stuff like calling Anne Frank a bad jew, or making bizarre videos about incest. I’ve never laughed at Bret Weinstein. He’s just dull and makes nonsense arguments.

    • @diluvialdrifter4332
      @diluvialdrifter4332 Рік тому

      Huh. I guess you can swing like that.
      Your form is poor, but whatever man.
      If life is to be lived, may as well live it easy.

  • @davidrrussell1
    @davidrrussell1 Рік тому +5

    You show your allegiance to Big Brother too much. For anyone who believes Bret is a fraud, your mind has been captured by the real frauds. If you listen to him with an open mind, there is nothing about his opinions that are anything outside the realm of reasonable.

    • @acetate909
      @acetate909 Рік тому

      Sam Seder runs a cult. These people are hopeless and even though they pretend to be progressive they attack anti war leftists who are critical of big pharma and the CIA.

  • @algi1
    @algi1 Рік тому +3

    Oh, no, people might leave the military because they don't want to follow orders?

    • @markpostgate2551
      @markpostgate2551 Рік тому

      Yeah, it's more likely the maintaining of mandates in institutions even after they have been found to be nonsensical is as a test of obedience. The military has always preferred cookie cutter conformists; a government doesn''t want mavericks or independent thinkers at the bottom end of a chain of command. That's a more likely explanation.

  • @Andrewkroesen
    @Andrewkroesen Рік тому +11

    Sam didn't call it WWF. I am shook.

  • @texparker4407
    @texparker4407 Рік тому +1

    I bet no animal would fall asleep on the lap of these shills.

  • @moebiusandtheironhide6399
    @moebiusandtheironhide6399 Рік тому +1

    There was not substantive critique here. Just mockery.

  • @yabutmaybenot.6433
    @yabutmaybenot.6433 Рік тому +5

    Love the angry old man face of the guy in the lower right.

    • @wg5735
      @wg5735 Рік тому +2

      so.... what's is your point?

    • @jonhamilton5789
      @jonhamilton5789 Рік тому

      @@wg5735 Apparently your point is on the top of your head.

    • @wg5735
      @wg5735 Рік тому +1

      @@jonhamilton5789 👎

  • @deoxyribomorph99
    @deoxyribomorph99 Рік тому +224

    I liked his meltdown over being asked not to eat nuts on a plane, I feel like that whole incident really tells you everything you need to know about Bret Whinestein.

    • @galvanaut7119
      @galvanaut7119 Рік тому +35

      The level of total confidence coupled with absolute ignorance is his hallmark.

    • @davidhughes4089
      @davidhughes4089 Рік тому +23

      ​@@galvanaut7119 the Dunning-Kruger effect embodied

    • @galvanaut7119
      @galvanaut7119 Рік тому +12

      @@davidhughes4089 Spot on.

    • @ComradeCatpurrnicus
      @ComradeCatpurrnicus Рік тому +1

      "First they came for my nuts and the left said nothing, then they came for our RIGHT to infect others with a virus by having us wear masks and the left said nothing... then they came for you!"

    • @letsgobrandon9867
      @letsgobrandon9867 Рік тому

      The vaccine never prevented the spread and Pfizer and Anthony Fauci knew this from day 1.

  • @mindasb
    @mindasb Рік тому +18

    - I'm 6:51 in the video and not a single counter argument was provided.
    - 8:30 a counter argument was provided: military gets weaker because the job market "is tight". I have missed the part where Bret was denying that or how his points negate that. So it's not a counter argument.
    - 10:00 Yes there is somewhat of a problem with people refusing forced vacination in the military.
    - 13:35 He did not say that he drew that hypothesis from data. Pure fiction, you made it up.
    So it seems like you took an imprecise statement, took it however you wanted and make a joke out of it.
    Then Steven Crowder will do the same from the other side.
    Seems like I'm the crazy corner of the internet again.

  • @ernststravoblofeld
    @ernststravoblofeld Рік тому +26

    He's just like Jeepers. Respected professor with a great career. But found he could make more money as a professional victim.

    • @SuperAmericanSam
      @SuperAmericanSam Рік тому +6

      "i fOuNd a waY tO MoNeTizE sOcIal juStiCe wArrIOrs" - An expert in everything he starts talking about

    • @gagaplex
      @gagaplex Рік тому

      Jeepers Creepers, I like that for Jordy Be Pee. Hadn't heard it before. 🤔

    • @LeeH688
      @LeeH688 Рік тому

      They were never respected in their fields and did not have successful careers in academia.
      They were popular with a lot of their students because they would talk bullshit about Disney movies for an entire lecture and ask nothing of their students.

    • @ernststravoblofeld
      @ernststravoblofeld Рік тому

      @@LeeH688 Ok.

    • @LesserMoffHootkins
      @LesserMoffHootkins Рік тому +1

      He was forced out of his career path by your psychotic mob

  • @alst4817
    @alst4817 Рік тому +3

    There are a great many things to criticise Bret Weinstein about. In short, he seems to have very quickly fallen into full blown paranoia over the last couple of years. This clip is not a criticism however. It appears to show, let’s be charitable, a group of not very bright people shouting at the screen in an attempt to appear funny. I will not be back.

  • @gerardovenegas4610
    @gerardovenegas4610 Рік тому +14

    Keep trying and laughing one day maybe you will be lucky enough to understand

  • @Supremelilbear
    @Supremelilbear Рік тому +34

    If he's a "Scientist" that notices "patterns" , why didn't he notice the pattern of the military vaccinating for everything, for as long as my eldest family members have been alive, I take it he never got 15 vaccines at one time like all military personnel have, even before covid.

    • @patrec7638
      @patrec7638 Рік тому

      It's true that the military are used as guinea pigs when it comes to testing new medicines. What's changed is that the military personal no longer trust the compromised leadership and takes time to inform themselves before agreeing to being a test case anymore. Maybe they breed them smarter these days?

    • @frankdayton731
      @frankdayton731 Рік тому +4

      And that's good??

    • @bionic_woman77
      @bionic_woman77 Рік тому

      @@frankdayton731 would you like them getting yellow fever and typhoid?

    • @bionic_woman77
      @bionic_woman77 Рік тому +2

      Yes! My grandpa has pictures getting multiple shots at 1 time before going to korea

    • @chrisdaniel6095
      @chrisdaniel6095 Рік тому +7

      @@frankdayton731 It is if you get exposed to smallpox, anthrax, hepatitis, dengue, typhoid, yellow fever, and several others.

  • @alexithymia9337
    @alexithymia9337 Рік тому +9

    Bret may miss on this one, but overall he has been far more accurate, and honest, than sorry sack of crap Sam Seder.

  • @liamsloan5410
    @liamsloan5410 Рік тому +154

    How can this man have a PHD and not know that deductive reasoning is not how we do science?

    • @lisaratley4858
      @lisaratley4858 Рік тому +33

      He may know it’s not sound reasoning. He’s interested in fame, power, money, views…

    • @noosphericaltarzan
      @noosphericaltarzan Рік тому +13

      It's literally how we do science. We had to solve the induction problem. See Karl Popper. Induction outside mathematics is fallacy. Not that I am defending Brett Weinstein here. Just don't confuse inductive reasoning with anything but fallacy unless you are using induction to prove some mathematical proposition.

    • @soulknife20
      @soulknife20 Рік тому +5

      @@noosphericaltarzan You can start with inductive reasoning.

    • @noosphericaltarzan
      @noosphericaltarzan Рік тому +4

      @@soulknife20 You'd be starting with a fallacy so you'd need to stop doing that and work from a model. You should check out Karl Popper's solution to the induction problem. Induction in most of its forms is fallacious. For instance, the black swan fallacy is currently a famous version of how induction goes wrong.

    • @bertthompson4748
      @bertthompson4748 Рік тому +16

      @@noosphericaltarzan the problem of induction is that we cant ground it in any epistemic foundation.
      That doesnt mean its a fallacy since.
      1. Induction works
      2. It contains no logical contradiction.
      Now if youre talking about the black swan fallacy, yeah that can be a fallacy but thats induction applied without testing which isnt science.
      For instance a scientist would make an observation, that swan is black, and from that generate a hypothesis.
      All swans are black and then test it. If we tag all swans known to exist they will all be black.
      The conclusion would then be limited to the tagging area which would mean inductively you could say "if i see a swan its probably going to be black" and be correct.
      Logically and outside of science a person will observe swans being black and say "all swans are black" which is fallacious.

  • @justinreilly1
    @justinreilly1 4 місяці тому +1

    Why all the uproarious laughter when he said he’s a scientist? He is a former prof. of evolutionary biology and recently published a book on the subject. He doesn’t currently practice, but still I’d say “I’m a scientist” isn’t a false statement; certainly nothing at which to laugh.
    In any event, Weinstein is generally right and more importantly thinks like the excellent scientist he is and they’re wrong about him.

  • @davidjohnson7484
    @davidjohnson7484 Рік тому +2

    The moment you guys called Brett Weinstein an anti-vaxer I knew that you have no idea what you’re talking about. If you’re going to criticize someone, you may want to know who and what you are talking about.

  • @georgemcnally4473
    @georgemcnally4473 Рік тому +8

    The 'wack jobs' that these commentators speak of are long-serving members of the military who have refused to take the mandated medical intervention and seen their careers adversely affected. The sheer snobbery of the commentators, particularly the guy, is pretty awful.

  • @mugenkayashi453
    @mugenkayashi453 Рік тому +24

    „He‘s siencing“ 😂😂

  • @irishlady30
    @irishlady30 Рік тому +2

    A word salad that means absolutely nothing...

  • @IcemanJuice
    @IcemanJuice Рік тому +1

    The guy with the American flag and cop stash lmfaoooooooo god what’s wrong with America.

  • @henryherbert
    @henryherbert Рік тому +3

    Ad hominem attacks, no deepdive into the claims

    • @henryherbert
      @henryherbert Рік тому

      @@Cussy69_420 well, did they address the claims made? Or did they just dismiss the panel of military servants as "crazies" and proceed to just push their point of view

  • @Silverfang447
    @Silverfang447 Рік тому +52

    He's able to appeal to conservatives, the people with baby brains. Thinking isn't their strong suit.

    • @frankslade33
      @frankslade33 Рік тому

      Conservatives are all stupid and can't think? LOL

    • @Silverfang447
      @Silverfang447 Рік тому +1

      @@frankslade33
      Yep. Thanks for keeping up with the comment. 👍

    • @johnsonsandra8069
      @johnsonsandra8069 Рік тому +1

      True Dat!

    • @johnsonsandra8069
      @johnsonsandra8069 Рік тому

      @JoeBidenSniffsHair yes men can get pregnant ...males cannot ...there is a difference

    • @mrblonde1264
      @mrblonde1264 Рік тому +7

      Indeed probably the same types think he's a fantastic intellectual are the ones upset their candy isn't as "sexy" as it used to be.

  • @harrypothead42024
    @harrypothead42024 Рік тому +1

    There is zero evidence that the lower left hand of Bret's screen is not populated by a cardboard cutout.

  • @dizzolve
    @dizzolve Рік тому +2

    Seder you should debate this Weinstein foo!

  • @kofiamoako3098
    @kofiamoako3098 Рік тому +62

    I was expecting a quality critique. Guess I’ll have to look elsewhere for that

  • @trimetrodon
    @trimetrodon Рік тому +5

    Counting on Netanyahu’s judgement to decide on the safety of the vaccine is some seriously shoddy reasoning.

    • @hajinezhad3
      @hajinezhad3 6 місяців тому

      assuming that Netanyahu was the chief scientist in charge of deciding the safety of the vaccine is even shoddier reasoning.

  • @AgapeLove878
    @AgapeLove878 Рік тому +2

    It's interesting to me to see the absolute low level comments in this thread. It's like reading low intelligence middle school bullies thoughts on their opinions on the teacher that makes them work the hardest. And in the trying to sound smarter but having actually not a single collective synapse of actual critical thinking amongst you all... You resort to name calling.
    And this may dear fellow humans is what is discrediting you. The Weinsteins do not have to even address it because it's so below them...and well your responses kind of speak for themselves.

    • @blindprophet182
      @blindprophet182 Рік тому +1

      What discredits Sam is with over 1m subs, he needs to use the names & thumbnails of others to get decent views. There's 2k likes, & 1k comments here. If this video has

  • @orsoncart802
    @orsoncart802 6 місяців тому +1

    Don’t forget to take all your boosters - the more the better.
    Think of the children!

  • @zaphodbebop105
    @zaphodbebop105 Рік тому +85

    Well yeah, he’s a conservative.

    • @Gregorypeckory
      @Gregorypeckory Рік тому +16

      I think it's time to retire that word; It's completely lost its meaning. What are currently called conservatives aren't conservative by any stretch of the imagination. We should start referring to them as what they are; extreme right wing fascists and zealots.

    • @charlesbrown9749
      @charlesbrown9749 Рік тому +17

      Actually, he’s a liberal. You’re just so far left he appears conservative to you

    • @jnnnx6586
      @jnnnx6586 Рік тому

      @@Gregorypeckory agreed.

    • @Occam31
      @Occam31 Рік тому

      @@charlesbrown9749 yes, a liberal who just so happens to only critics Dems and aligns himself with republicans. You know, that kind of liberal.

    • @markzuckergecko621
      @markzuckergecko621 Рік тому +2

      @@Gregorypeckory you're an actual crazy person.

  • @HunterPhenomMakoy
    @HunterPhenomMakoy Рік тому +4

    Speaking of religion in the Middle East, I’m trying to find your videos on the women’s revolution in Iran. Can someone help me find those?
    There’s an Iranian rock climber that people are worried about her safety because people saw her hair. I’d think that’d be more important than how harshly Ben Shapiro denounces Kanye or what Herschel walker paid for.

  • @markfelton8170
    @markfelton8170 Рік тому +3

    To clarify Sam’s statement about U.S. military spending. The US spends more on defense then the next 9 countries on list combined. 7 of which are ally’s. 800 billion a year. China who is number 2 on list 277 billion. This accounts for 10 percent of the US’s GDP and nearly half of the US’s discretionary spending. Wonder why more hard working Americans are becoming homeless and living pay check to pay check

    • @bertthompson4748
      @bertthompson4748 Рік тому

      The military acts as a jobs, healthcare and education provider.
      If you want to cut funding to the military instead propose an increase to other services.

    • @soulknife20
      @soulknife20 Рік тому

      @@bertthompson4748 Well. My question is how much is spent on the things you mentioned and how much is spent on R&D.

    • @bertthompson4748
      @bertthompson4748 Рік тому

      @@soulknife20 a lot more on R&D. But thats used to justify the massive personal otherwise we would have a huge, poorly equipped military which is worse then a huge, well equipped military.
      If you dont like it propose jobs, education and healthcare plans to replace the u.s populations dependence on the military, dont just wipe out the military budget or youll create more homeless and uninsured

    • @markfelton8170
      @markfelton8170 Рік тому

      @@bertthompson4748 infrastructure projects akin to those that created our nations interstate, bridges, and power grid that got us out of the Great Depression that are crumbling and becoming insufficient, that would be projects that would give jobs, and major boast to our economy. But instead wasted on aircraft carriers, more wars that solve nothing , just keep chasing the newest boogy-man the defense industries manufacturer to justify more and more spending.

    • @soulknife20
      @soulknife20 Рік тому

      @@bertthompson4748 Oh no no. I'm not proposing that at all. I'm a veteran. I get what the US government does to its veterans after it uses them. I'm fully on board with cutting R&D and investing it into educatio and jobs and Healthcare

  • @aaron___6014
    @aaron___6014 12 днів тому

    The Internet is full of arm chair experts. Weinstein, Charlie Kirk, Sam Harris, etc.

  • @glenneric1
    @glenneric1 Рік тому +1

    Step 1: Steal Underpants, Step 2: ???, Step 3: Profit

    • @vanpeters9751
      @vanpeters9751 Рік тому

      Step 2: change made in China tag to made in America

  • @jamesjackson8652
    @jamesjackson8652 Рік тому +9

    Well this aged well...

  • @miltz76
    @miltz76 Рік тому +112

    The outburst of laughter @ “I’m a scientist ..” was priceless lol

    • @matthewashooh9758
      @matthewashooh9758 Рік тому +5

      Same! I spit out my coffee!

    • @tectorgorch8698
      @tectorgorch8698 Рік тому +11

      Even the lady couldn't help smirking at that!

    • @letsgobrandon9867
      @letsgobrandon9867 Рік тому

      Given I was telling everyone on this channel that the 'vaccine' never prevented the spread from day 1, the only 'scientist' around here is me.
      I am smarter than all of you combined.

    • @VagusDoc
      @VagusDoc Рік тому +9

      Dude the girl even cracked. Everyone knows.

    • @CMA418
      @CMA418 Рік тому +5

      I don’t get it. He is a scientist. No?

  • @polozov
    @polozov Рік тому +1

    I’ve never seen so many misinformed strawman arguments stacked on top one another in one place…

  • @adar7993
    @adar7993 Рік тому

    His claim to be a scientist would be more credible if he wore a white lab coat all the time.

  • @briancardio6567
    @briancardio6567 Рік тому +32

    His wife has the nurse Ratched vibe going strong.

    • @aurelo54
      @aurelo54 Рік тому +1

      Thanks for saying that, she scares me... a lot.

  • @adamrisch
    @adamrisch Рік тому +13

    He blinded them with science

  • @smokeAndMirrors74
    @smokeAndMirrors74 Рік тому

    That guy in the bottom right looks like he ate two loaves of bread, mashed potatoes, and has to deuce any second now.

  • @jamesp5408
    @jamesp5408 8 місяців тому

    Bret Weinstein published 1, that is ONE, peer-reviewed article to the scientific literature when he was in graduate school and has published ZERO since completing his PhD in 2009. PhDs in evolutionary biology who refer to themselves as "scientists" generally publish 5-15 articles each year to document their scientific work. If we are very generous, up to this point Weinstein has done about 7% of the work that he'd need to do to call himself a "scientist."

  • @trimetrodon
    @trimetrodon Рік тому +15

    Brett is spot on on the COVID crisis and on the dangers of the mRNA vaccines. Laughing at him about this stuff is childish & idiotic.

    • @mfg1035
      @mfg1035 Рік тому +2

      True.

    • @diluvialdrifter4332
      @diluvialdrifter4332 Рік тому

      Both childish, and idiotic is western politics.
      These fools are just thinking about their bottom line.

    • @trimetrodon
      @trimetrodon Рік тому

      @@diluvialdrifter4332 What bottom line is that? Who do you think they are being bought by? He isn’t a Congressman, a lobbyist, or a pharma advocate. Those are the people you should suspect of being paid for the harm they’ve unleashed on everyone.

    • @diluvialdrifter4332
      @diluvialdrifter4332 Рік тому +1

      @@trimetrodon You assume much, and speak blindly.
      There is much money in popularity. Hence why people go to great lengths to acquire it.
      He has a brand to maintain; Shallow, and of little character, as most brands necessarily are.

    • @trimetrodon
      @trimetrodon Рік тому

      @@diluvialdrifter4332 Some people are so clueless there is nothing you can do.

  • @muskyoxes
    @muskyoxes Рік тому +12

    "They're doing this so that nobody will find out. I found out. I'm a random shmuck."

  • @Ozhull
    @Ozhull Рік тому +28

    12:35 this grifter technique of speaking quietly and measuredly is so grating.

    • @johnsonsandra8069
      @johnsonsandra8069 Рік тому +8

      I agree...Tulsi gabbard has that kind of voice ....it's like she trying on purpose to speak in a low key voice like her bullshit sounds more rational when she speaks in that way

    • @BasedKungFu
      @BasedKungFu Рік тому +4

      It's a technique I use as a teacher as well.
      It serves to make you focus and listen closer to the speaker. It's useful when you want all your students to really pay close attention to a small part of your lesson.
      They're just signaling to the grown children in the audience to pay close attention.

    • @beeragainsthumanity1420
      @beeragainsthumanity1420 Рік тому +3

      @@BasedKungFu
      I was a youth counselor at a rehabilitation center.
      I used this technique also, but not all the time or it loses its effectiveness.

  • @raydavison4288
    @raydavison4288 11 місяців тому

    Can you imagine having to take a class taught by BW? 😬

  • @trevorvanloon1125
    @trevorvanloon1125 Рік тому

    They started both-sidings on climate change but claim to love the Amazon jungle. Make that make sense.

  • @waterfrodo4304
    @waterfrodo4304 Рік тому +12

    Mr. Square Jaw staring down into a corner is too perfect.

  • @HalfBackCrack
    @HalfBackCrack Рік тому +3

    A conservatives charlatan? Im shocked!

  • @texparker4407
    @texparker4407 11 місяців тому +1

    Talk to Bret, I'm sure he'd chat with you on his show. Unless you're afraid he'll make you look like even bigger fools.

  • @LesserMoffHootkins
    @LesserMoffHootkins Рік тому +2

    Seder doesn’t know what a theory is.

  • @blevens7251
    @blevens7251 Рік тому +57

    Brett proves that you should never mistake a lack of affect for actual rationality. Apparently you can have a slow steady pulse and also be a complete kook.

    • @villedocvalle
      @villedocvalle Рік тому +7

      Quality comment

    • @xbabu142x
      @xbabu142x Рік тому +2

      My mom tells me a PhD stands for Permanent Head Damage and is attained by slamming your head into a wall till you break through. She has two earned ones and three honorary ones.

    • @alexl4342
      @alexl4342 Рік тому +2

      Bret makes grandiose, conspiratorial claims to stay relevant. Thats all it is, he is probably hurting for cash.

    • @ryrez4478
      @ryrez4478 Рік тому

      😄

    • @iamPROTOTYPE
      @iamPROTOTYPE Рік тому

      you dont listen to him obviously

  • @philipcullin983
    @philipcullin983 Рік тому +29

    What an utter waste of 20 minutes. San Seder again generates more heat than light and snark than substance.

    • @toohak2782
      @toohak2782 Місяць тому

      So Bret isn’t a charlatan? Let’s not get ahead of ourselves

  • @thomasmullen644
    @thomasmullen644 Рік тому +1

    What is it with these older men and those terrible looking toupees?

    • @coreyander286
      @coreyander286 Рік тому

      Lay off, he's Orthodox, it's his religious expression.

  • @davecarrier2978
    @davecarrier2978 Рік тому +2

    I don't even want to know what happens if the guy on the bottom right of his video unbuttons the top button of his polo. Frightening. 🤣

  • @mendelhorft
    @mendelhorft Рік тому +9

    Hey Sam, Myocarditis. Seems to be effecting males between 12 and 40. Could this have an effect on our military readiness?

    • @amandamcgovern5744
      @amandamcgovern5744 Рік тому +3

      @@Cussy69_420 wow killer argument.. defn a Seder fan😂..
      “Was force the vote actually a good idea? Since we see his conservatives actually extracted significant policy concessions?”
      Let me guess your answer:
      “No.” *End of argument*..

    • @berniethekiwidragon4382
      @berniethekiwidragon4382 Рік тому

      "Affecting", and no, it is not true that there are more cases of myocarditis or pericarditis occurring after vaccination compared to after a COVID infection.

  • @georgebamforth7372
    @georgebamforth7372 Рік тому +3

    You guy's need to back up your claims but I doubt that would be possible, Brett and Heather wipe the floor with you. Childish reporting.

  • @1973deepee
    @1973deepee 4 місяці тому

    Straight out of the rulebook: Rule 5: Ridicule is man's most potent weapon. There is no defense..." Rule 13: "Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it." (Rules For Radicals; Saul Alinsky) So here we have a non-scientist ridiculing an actual scientist for using the scientific method to evaluate what the gov't. and its institutions were/are advising and, finding them flawed at best and malevolent at worst, providing evidence to his audience, giving them tools to research and evaluate on their own such they might make rational choices. This guy's strategy seems to be, kill the researcher/messenger; do whatever the state and its institutions tell you to do even if it's irrational and dangerous. I think I know whom to trust.

    • @windfall
      @windfall 4 місяці тому

      How did he use the “scientific method” to gauge the political plan of the Democratic Party to decrease military readiness via the vaccine? Explain pls

  • @tectorgorch8698
    @tectorgorch8698 Рік тому +9

    Robert Wright is actually a really smart guy; not full of shit at all.

    • @coreyander286
      @coreyander286 Рік тому +5

      It's some fucking bizarro world shit to hear the MR crew scoff at Robert Wright as if Wright is some kind of IDW logic bro when his whole career for the last ten years has been essentially the opposite of New Atheism and the IDW... all based on their bad intuition guessing from book titles.

  • @catherinebrower3560
    @catherinebrower3560 Рік тому +5

    emma gets it, blue team is turning people into cell phone towers

  • @deirdredowling2251
    @deirdredowling2251 Рік тому +1

    Why does Sam Seder rarely listen or respond to what his female colleague contributes?

    • @KD-rs6xx
      @KD-rs6xx 15 годин тому

      because he's an asshole

  • @vgaportauthority9932
    @vgaportauthority9932 Рік тому +1

    Just cause Sam mentioned it:
    Biggest air force in the world: The US Air Force.
    Second biggest air force in the world: The US Army.
    Fourth biggest air force in the world: The US Navy.
    7th biggest air force in the world: the US Marine Corps
    Here are the stats for those interested. They might not be up to date, but seeing as the US upped their defense budget, it's probably not been equalized.
    1: United States Air Force - 5,217
    2: United States Army Aviation - 4,409
    3: Russian Air Force - 3,863
    4: United States Navy - 2,464
    5: People's Liberation Army Air Force (China) - 1,991
    6: Indian Air Force - 1,715
    7: United States Marine Corps - 1,157
    8: Egyptian Air Force - 1,062
    9: Korean People's Army Air Force (North Korea) - 946
    10: South Korean Air Force - 898
    That's 13247 aircraft for the US.
    10475 for the rest of the top 10.
    Just the air force and the army alone would be more than the rest of the non-US nations on the list combined... The fucking NAVY has more air crafts than china's air force.. They're on the ocean! And they have more planes than China's air force....
    To a lefty, that's just insane stats that prove that there's immense waste in military spending.
    To a conservative, that's just bad-ass! Muricah! Bad education, but awesome weapons! Hell yeeearh!

  • @zmo1ndone502
    @zmo1ndone502 Рік тому +11

    This is a sad sad show

  • @fuberlin1
    @fuberlin1 Рік тому +7

    Ok, guys, I watched the Bret video. You do not do a good job of representing well the message of the argument, that was made in this video, nore the line of though, that was going on in this discussion. FYI - I am not from the US. Watching this... it is baffeling and concerning, how these ppl cannot understand and represent a point correctly, before they try to argue against it. (Here I am referring to the first video of Bret. I then stopped watching the rest.) I can try to explain what the actual line of thought in the video was, but what would be the point. These ppl seem to stay away from nuanced reasoning.

  • @dweingast
    @dweingast Рік тому +2

    spiteful attacks on fellow UA-cam shows I’ve seen the young turks do it and now these guys or do it it’s so low class I usually get everything wrong like this one

  • @roberth9814
    @roberth9814 Рік тому +1

    Weinsteinian Gaslighting is a special kind of gaslighting.

  • @waltmccarthy9837
    @waltmccarthy9837 Рік тому +7

    I thought this was a news channel.
    This isn’t news.

    • @waltmccarthy9837
      @waltmccarthy9837 Рік тому +4

      @@the.bog. No, I was making a joke about the thumbnail of Brett Weinstein being a total charlatan. That’s been an established fact for awhile.

  • @nuqwestr
    @nuqwestr Рік тому +3

    Will you change your name to "The Minority Report" after 2022?

  • @Basieeee
    @Basieeee Рік тому +2

    You guys are delusional. Arent you supposed to get your 4th dose? Because it worked so good.

  • @stuffnuns
    @stuffnuns 10 місяців тому

    I am not a scientist, but merely a performrer. As a performer, I want to commend Prof. Weinstein on his choice of wig.

  • @mcapello8836
    @mcapello8836 Рік тому +52

    "If we're logic-ing all over the place..." She's funny.

    • @cartercartercartercar
      @cartercartercartercar Рік тому +3

      @@taranullius9221 come on. people are allowed to think something someone on a radio show said was funny

    • @alexl4342
      @alexl4342 Рік тому +3

      Bret makes grandiose, conspiratorial claims to stay relevant. Thats all it is, he is probably hurting for cash.

    • @alwaysovercomingbear4809
      @alwaysovercomingbear4809 Рік тому

      @@alexl4342 what grandiose, conspiratorial claims are you referring to? 🤔
      Sincerely asking...

    • @alexl4342
      @alexl4342 Рік тому +1

      @@alwaysovercomingbear4809 Nearly all of his rhetoric is of a conspiratorial click bait fashion but in terms of this video see topic at 11:00 . Of course he couches everything with "I posed it as a hypothesis...". That is a great way to bring up any bat shit crazy topic that comes to mind without being attached to the answer. Did Hillary Clinton fund a bio lab that started covid? I am just posing the hypothesis, lets discuss...

    • @warpath8453
      @warpath8453 Рік тому

      @@alexl4342 Believe it or not people can speak, if he wants to bring up batshit crazy things. Whats it to you?
      The podcast robert and bret did about it put it all into place really.
      I know you don't know his argument. I know Sam well enough to know he won't bring up his argument in good faith.
      I guess you're a lost cause.

  • @brian22lsu
    @brian22lsu Рік тому +27

    Sam Seder's ignorance is only outdone by his arrogance. If mockery, name calling, and hyperbole were markers of intelligence, this group would surely be called upon to solve the problems of the world. Unfortunately, they'll just have to settle for being part of the problem.

  • @roisinnifhaolain7520
    @roisinnifhaolain7520 Рік тому +1

    This will not age well

  • @blindprophet182
    @blindprophet182 Рік тому +1

    When you have 1.25m subs, yet need other names and pictures to get respectable views & interaction.

  • @dalejames486
    @dalejames486 Рік тому +3

    This commentary gave me brain damage