That first movement... what a stable, "symmetrical" structure, with intelligently developed themes woven within the structure. What a strong first opus this is!
@@knutheymann6919 Indeed Knut and for real, I totally agree. Then again here it's César Franck, so unfortunately not that well know in his own country (mine as well). But I reckon and understood that composers such as Debussy, Ravel etc. are much often played and listened abroad than they're here, so it comforts me ;-).
I just love Franck's approach to cyclic form. The moments where themes from different sections unite are so bloody satisfying. I know this is usually a thing with Franck's music, but this piece is just exceptional.
I don't think i'm mature enough to see how Franck's music is cyclic, to me it really looks like the kind of sonata form we can hear in Beethoven. But I feel like i'm missing something.
Anthony Cyrille Beethoven didn’t do do much cyclic chamber music, his Symphonies you can hear great examples. Cyclic refers to reusing themes directly that were first heard in earlier movements. Beethoven and earlier composers didn’t do direct quotations, mainly there would be subtle nods. Franck takes a more direct approach when he quotes passages from earlier works
Yes, roughly speaking, cyclic form is about reusing musical material to create a sense of unity within a mutliple-section work. In this piece it's all over the place but the most promiment example is arguably when the second theme of the first movement is repurposed (somewhat unexpectedly) as an exalted finale. You have this long, ecstatic dominant preparation and then finally comes release. And come it does.
Franck was so despised by virtually the entire musical establishment of Europe during most of his life that everything he did, including this absolutely stellar masterpiece, was denigrated and scorned. Only in his last, few years did he just begin to receive some positive recognition.
Hello, I've heard someone else say something similar, in that not only is this a great piece, but greatly educational for chamber composition. Can you explain what specifically makes this piece so educational?
This is my favourite piece because it is like a human. Sometimes very angry, sometimes happy, sometimes normal. So maybe I listen this piece 10 times a day and I never get bored. And Congratulations to these musicians who play this.
This is a most interesting work. While the Vincent d'Indy comments make one think this was God's gift to music, one cannot help but be mesmerized by the driving rhythms. For me, the most impressive part is how this written more in a double concerto, with the piano playing the role of the orchestra, complete with the orchestral color. This almost forsees Bartok's use of the piano as a percussion instrument, but the part is so much more pianistic in this.
This firstborn by César Franck is a piece which struck me with its passionate intensity, driving rhythms, the terseness of its main theme and the masterful way in which he structured each movement. Although the first theme left the impression of being monotonous, after listening to this several times, I cannot feel indifferent to how it has been woven into every aspect of this trio. This is a marvellous masterpiece that should be played more frequently.
Being only familiar with his violin sonata, Symphonic Variations and Symphony, I probably would not have guessed this was early Franck! This is really an intriguing work!
I have never heard this work before, and I have to say that I found especially the first two movements wonderfully captivating. A weird creepy feeling throughout, a hushed theme.
Are you sure ? There's so many and so many masterpieces... But sure somehow, since here's César Franck wonderfull work ang amazing, incredible strength...
Ce trio est plein de thèmes que César Franck réutilisera dans son merveilleux quintette au piano des années plus tard. Quel apprentissage en œuvre de base pour un jeune compositeur!
Well, he may not be in the top 10, but he is certainly in the top 20, and that is owing to his more ambitious and (some would say) more dexterous organ works.
Оошеломительное впечатление Звучит так,как будто, написано про нашу современную жизнь.Он просто гений,!! !!❤❤❤❤❤ Эта музыка вечна,потому,что вечно стремление человека к жизни.. какая бы она не была
I love Cesar Franck's chamber music. It's very original. And his Quintet for piano and strings ( in C Minor, I believe) is one of the best in the musical repertoire. Gabe Meruelo.
Cesar Franck,underrated composer.He is great.His simphonie in Re minor is one masterpiece.Too The poem simphonic The damned Hunter and too great Psiche.This is The more beatiful music.
Happens to me all the time when I want to listen to music while working. I always end up reading the score and/or googling the life of the composer and details of the piece. I need to switch to Justin Bieber, I guess.
As much as I love all three movements of this amazing piece of music, the middle movement is slightly my favorite. And, although, all three movement are very closely related, there is something about the second movement that is so invigorating....just love it. Shocking it was composed by an 18 year old....just WOW.
It is an intense masterpiece that heals the thirst and lament of the human soul . 🍎 From effulgent Tokyo in profound Japan in winter Which national are you watching this video ？
cool to see how much his use of cyclic form was with him from the very beginning... although the cyclic form here seems a little more forced than in some of his later works (in particular, bringing back the scalar chorale-like theme [originally in F# major] in the second movement seemed a little too much too soon imo)... but WOW when it comes back in the 3rd movement, that moment is easily as satisfying as his most successful cyclic form moments-like, say, the C major climax of the last movement of the violin sonata, or the return of the chorale theme in the prelude choral & fugue. It's worth listening to the whole piece through just for the sheer satisfaction of moments like those
You say: "Although this isn't the same breathtaking, classic performance by Richter, Kagan and Gutman posted earlier on my channel...." Sorry chap I strongly disagree with you on this point. I happen to like this version more than the one produced by our great Russian friends....Above all, the tempo in this rendition seems to be much more suited and better for this lively and energetic work. ( Incidentally, the Russian edition you uploaded does not have all the three parts of the work???)
Sounds sometimes as a continuation of Beethoven's late oevre, but it is also completely his own. Franck was a misunderstood, underapprciated visionary and not just a virtuoso.
OP 1?? my god what a genius
HEY CAN HISPANICS KILL U2
😁
Teenager's Music...❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
That first movement... what a stable, "symmetrical" structure, with intelligently developed themes woven within the structure. What a strong first opus this is!
I can't believe this is only a trio. It seems to have more power than many symphonies.....
I agree. It is truly very orchestral. You can hear it from the start.
many trios have more power than some symphonies....
@@knutheymann6919 Indeed Knut and for real, I totally agree. Then again here it's César Franck, so unfortunately not that well know in his own country (mine as well). But I reckon and understood that composers such as Debussy, Ravel etc. are much often played and listened abroad than they're here, so it comforts me ;-).
I just love Franck's approach to cyclic form. The moments where themes from different sections unite are so bloody satisfying. I know this is usually a thing with Franck's music, but this piece is just exceptional.
I don't think i'm mature enough to see how Franck's music is cyclic, to me it really looks like the kind of sonata form we can hear in Beethoven. But I feel like i'm missing something.
Anthony Cyrille Beethoven didn’t do do much cyclic chamber music, his Symphonies you can hear great examples. Cyclic refers to reusing themes directly that were first heard in earlier movements. Beethoven and earlier composers didn’t do direct quotations, mainly there would be subtle nods. Franck takes a more direct approach when he quotes passages from earlier works
Yes, roughly speaking, cyclic form is about reusing musical material to create a sense of unity within a mutliple-section work. In this piece it's all over the place but the most promiment example is arguably when the second theme of the first movement is repurposed (somewhat unexpectedly) as an exalted finale. You have this long, ecstatic dominant preparation and then finally comes release. And come it does.
He was Belgian & at first , great Virtuosity Pianist--Organist! I believe that Organ 's maner Influenced his Composer's style, too!😮
One of the greatest chamber music works I've ever listened to, and I've listened to many.
Franck was so despised by virtually the entire musical establishment of Europe during most of his life that everything he did, including this absolutely stellar masterpiece, was denigrated and scorned. Only in his last, few years did he just begin to receive some positive recognition.
Naturally as he was not a factory made composer.
the ones that push the envelope always seem to be hated for it. change is a scary thing after all...
His music was lacking and uninteresting, his opus one including.
This piece can teach more about composition than a year of university.
I thought the same as soon as the piano started with that symmetric motif
Hello, I've heard someone else say something similar, in that not only is this a great piece, but greatly educational for chamber composition.
Can you explain what specifically makes this piece so educational?
You are so right!!!!
Completely agreed!!
I don't think terrible beaming like at 13:00 is something composers should be taught
This is my favourite piece because it is like a human. Sometimes very angry, sometimes happy, sometimes normal. So maybe I listen this piece 10 times a day and I never get bored. And Congratulations to these musicians who play this.
Yes, I think the same thing too!
@The Most İmportant Thing At World is Education are you a musician?
@@cevdetminalay2280 Yes
Amazing music, the first movement is absolutely out of this world..
HEY CAN SAPNISH KILL U2
The section from 6:43 to 7:50 gives me chills every time.
When you’re right you’re right!!
Oh my god that vibrato when the cello first comes in. Goals.
새삼 세상은 넓고..
내가 몰랐던 아름다운 것들이 많다는걸 느낀다...
Once again, I feel there are plenty of beauty in this world..
This is a most interesting work. While the Vincent d'Indy comments make one think this was God's gift to music, one cannot help but be mesmerized by the driving rhythms.
For me, the most impressive part is how this written more in a double concerto, with the piano playing the role of the orchestra, complete with the orchestral color. This almost forsees Bartok's use of the piano as a percussion instrument, but the part is so much more pianistic in this.
Franck's sense of musical architecture was with him from the very beginning. It never failed him.
The third movement's theme is very addictive and quite fitting for the end. It is so triumphant, so majestic, so breathtaking!
The third movement has the most beautiful theme ever, in my opinion.
This firstborn by César Franck is a piece which struck me with its passionate intensity, driving rhythms, the terseness of its main theme and the masterful way in which he structured each movement. Although the first theme left the impression of being monotonous, after listening to this several times, I cannot feel indifferent to how it has been woven into every aspect of this trio. This is a marvellous masterpiece that should be played more frequently.
6:32 to 8:45
9:25 to 14:24
15:54 to 23:25
23:32 to 24:39
25:15 to final
The fugue in the middle of the second movement is fantastic! It is so simple yet so great!
I ve listened to many classical music so it’s hard to surprise me but this piece manages to do that, especially the 1st mov! Amazing
let alone their opus 1 as well
César Franck:fisz-moll Zongoratrió
1.Andante con moto 00:00
2.Allegro molto 10:12
3.Finálé:Allegro maestoso 17:32
Oleg Kagan-hegedű
Natalia Gutman-gordonka
Szvjatoszlav Richter-zongora
Köszönöm az értékelést
This might be the best last movement of any piano trio I've heard so far.
SURYA KILLS U2
Being only familiar with his violin sonata, Symphonic Variations and Symphony, I probably would not have guessed this was early Franck! This is really an intriguing work!
The opening has a feeling of Bruckner, especially the beginning of the 5th symphony.
И снова БРАВО!❤ слушаю третий день, не могу наслушаться!❤
I love the mysterious and somber quality of Franck’s music, still passionate, very special ❤️
I have never heard this work before, and I have to say that I found especially the first two movements wonderfully captivating. A weird creepy feeling throughout, a hushed theme.
best trio i ever heard in my life.
Are you sure ? There's so many and so many masterpieces... But sure somehow, since here's César Franck wonderfull work ang amazing, incredible strength...
Rachmaninoff trio elegiaque,,? The best one..
Rachmaninoff...
rachmaninoff...
Mendelsohn D minor, Arensky D minor trios -- I think the best
Ce trio est plein de thèmes que César Franck réutilisera dans son merveilleux quintette au piano des années plus tard. Quel apprentissage en œuvre de base pour un jeune compositeur!
YOUTH GROUP HATES MAGGIE/MARY AND ADDIE
heard this in the past, but did not remember it was this beautiful
CAN ASANS KILL THE MAGGIE/MARY ADDIE
Awesome. I love his piano music so much too. I don't get why he is less famous than so many other composers.
Well, he may not be in the top 10, but he is certainly in the top 20, and that is owing to his more ambitious and (some would say) more dexterous organ works.
@@PETERJOHN101 the Violin Sonata is quite popular
This just gets better with every listen. I'm glad this is top on the search results for piano trio.
ka3beelo i find new things in every listen too!
Whenever I return to this video (which I do frequently), the main themes stay in my head haunting me for days. Amazing composition.
Thanks - that really hit the spot. The piece takes my breath away.
One of the few forms in which Franck felt like writing more than one piece!
Оошеломительное впечатление Звучит так,как будто, написано про нашу современную жизнь.Он просто гений,!! !!❤❤❤❤❤ Эта музыка вечна,потому,что вечно стремление человека к жизни.. какая бы она не была
This is rapidly taking on the title of Best Chamber Work Period to me.
Explendido - fantastica música me gusta como suena - Cesar Franck.
[24:11] and [29:35]: motif in Tchaikovsky's Adagio from Souvenir de Florence.
Merci
I love Cesar Franck's chamber music. It's very original. And his Quintet for piano and strings ( in C Minor, I believe) is one of the best in the musical repertoire. Gabe Meruelo.
Correction; the quintet is in F Minor.
... cuando apenas contaba diez y ocho años en 1840, inspirado y distante de su camino definitivo en la vida. Música de cámara, es la gloria ...
Cesar Franck,underrated composer.He is great.His simphonie in Re minor is one masterpiece.Too The poem simphonic The damned Hunter and too great Psiche.This is The more beatiful music.
Beuty,beutifull.
Beautiful.So nice.🌠
What a music!Amazing! Thank you,grazie
superbly executed, I'm always marveled by the neat and elegant scores by franck
How different; a mystery path throughout. Franck certainly wrote enticing music. Thank you for this treasure.
CATHE KIM WILL BEAT UP UR BUTTS IN BUSINESS PROFESSIONALS OF AMERICA MAGGIE/MARY ADDIE
One of the best pieces of chamber music ever
Een ongelooflijk werk! Ik ben het nu zelf aan het inoefenen met een paar vrienden. Geweldig!!!! Het mooiste stuk voor pianotrio ooit geschreven! :D
Dries de haas Een prachtig meesterwerk, niet verkeerd als je zoiets op je 18de schrijft!
One of the must incredible works i have ever seen
Outstanding performance !!
NI NENG BU NENG KUAI DIANR COMMIT SUICIDE MAGGIE..MARY / ADDIE
Dont't knew this composer till now but it seems to be quite a beautiful work!
neither did I and I'm really glad to know him now!
RIDICULOUS ENOUGH TO SLEEP U2
I love the fact that it has minimalism forms in some sections. It even reminds me of Arvo Part
I found this trio , and composer, in Pablo Neruda's memoirs book, published 1973 ..
And he described it to be his life in music form ..
I just wanted to listen to this while reading manga but then I kinda got stuck reading the score o.o
Happens to me all the time when I want to listen to music while working. I always end up reading the score and/or googling the life of the composer and details of the piece. I need to switch to Justin Bieber, I guess.
same. I was trying to do my homework.
Always happens to me :/ Now, I can't even listen a music from youtube without score
Oh wow, the conversation between the instruments starting at 2:04... it's like a fractal
Beautiful interpretation of this amazing piece
ear-gasm
As much as I love all three movements of this amazing piece of music, the middle movement is slightly my favorite. And, although, all three movement are very closely related, there is something about the second movement that is so invigorating....just love it. Shocking it was composed by an 18 year old....just WOW.
HOLY SHIT HE'S 18 YO WTF FRANCK YOU'RE MY IDOL
YOUR BRAINS DON'T WORK U2
A symphony for a trio
Fantastic
precioso, intenso -sobre todo el 3er movimiento-
Vaya que interpretacion !
Браво!❤
Extraordinaria obra! Ritmo muy sugestivo, fuerza y lirismo sin declinaciones. Gran interpretación. Bravo!!!
Thanks to this video I had to go and buy the whole album. While I didn't have a choice, I didn't mind either.
I too will do this. It is quite humbling to realize it was written by an 18 year old. It is a great work.
@davidrehak3539
5 年前
César Franck:fisz-moll Zongoratrió
1.Andante con moto 00:00
2.Allegro molto 10:12
3.Finálé:Allegro maestoso 17:32
Oleg Kagan-hegedű
Natalia Gutman-gordonka
Szvjatoszlav Richter-zongora
Best Performance I Ever heard -- Love it !!!
The theme at 1:28 is hauntingly beautiful.
Franck was 19 when he wrote this. Hints of the great things to come.
It is an intense masterpiece that heals the thirst and lament of the human soul . 🍎
From effulgent Tokyo in profound Japan in winter
Which national are you watching this video ？
Thanks for this.
25:10 an epic moment in the history of music
very wonderful!
This composition can teach you more about music than college
This is awesome
Beautiful...
Longing...for smoke
bravo!
Increíble
cool to see how much his use of cyclic form was with him from the very beginning... although the cyclic form here seems a little more forced than in some of his later works (in particular, bringing back the scalar chorale-like theme [originally in F# major] in the second movement seemed a little too much too soon imo)... but WOW when it comes back in the 3rd movement, that moment is easily as satisfying as his most successful cyclic form moments-like, say, the C major climax of the last movement of the violin sonata, or the return of the chorale theme in the prelude choral & fugue. It's worth listening to the whole piece through just for the sheer satisfaction of moments like those
helaas een stuk dat te zeer vergeten is!
Congratulations
morceau qui vaut d'être écoutée, réécoutée comme les vagues d'une marée...
This trio is full of themes which Franck will re-use in his wonderful quintet with piano, years later. What a masterwork for such a young composer.
Pierre Bonnechere diii
CAN U SHUT UP MAGGIE/MARY ADDIE
06:43
there's something very schubertian about the 1st movement
THE SECOND MOVEMENT HAS A REFERENCE TO BEETHOVEN 5!!!!!!!!!!!! OMG! :-)
Erstaunlich was der jugendliche Komponist aus diesem noch äusserst einfachen Tonsatz und Melodik herausholt.
29:03 reminds me of Grieg sonata in E, last movement (left hand) :D
You say: "Although this isn't the same breathtaking, classic performance by Richter, Kagan and Gutman posted earlier on my channel...." Sorry chap I strongly disagree with you on this point. I happen to like this version more than the one produced by our great Russian friends....Above all, the tempo in this rendition seems to be much more suited and better for this lively and energetic work. ( Incidentally, the Russian edition you uploaded does not have all the three parts of the work???)
ECCELLENZA GIUSTO FRANCO
How the hell does he make three instruments sound like an entire orchestra
18 años...
Sounds sometimes as a continuation of Beethoven's late oevre, but it is also completely his own. Franck was a misunderstood, underapprciated visionary and not just a virtuoso.
bello
This is amazing composition for someone only 18yo
Thanks for the link to Richter / Kagan / Gutman which is so intense that it feels like a punch in the stomach....
I have read that Liszt held this composition in high esteem.
18:08 forced Chopin Op.10 no.5 ending 🙃😂
It sounds french, makes me think of mustached mice and cheese ...but I like it
I'm no expert just my experience
He should be more famous
좋다
great piece, slightly awkward ending tho lol