Harry Styles Vs. Justin Bieber: Vocal Battle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 гру 2022
- They both are pretty good vocally! 🔥
In vocal battles I compare two different singers or just one at different times and on THE SAME musical note. I also give my opinion and allow you to decide in the comments which one you prefer. The intention of this video is to entertain. Hope you like it!
The content of my channel is based on fair use, making modifications to give it an original touch.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
#harrystyles #justinbieber #singing #vocalanalysis #vocals #vocalbattle
I like Harry’s belting because his sounds more powerful and chesty
Harry ❤️
Justin voice my favorite 💜
Harry Harry and more Harry
Harry is by far the better singer. He’s an exceptional entertainer and has a much more pleasing voice. I don’t care at all for Bieber’s style.
You don't care is because jb is more better 😅😅
I have to disagree Justin was literally dominating in every category
you clearly came to this video just for harry and to disrespect jb, "I don't care at all for Bieber's style" you clearly bias.
Bieber es mejor yo no veo su fisico yo veo la voz yo me voy de lado de bieber😅
Bieber es mejor yo no veo su fisico yo veo la voz yo me voy de lado de bieber😅
Harry across the board
I loved the video
I am a fan of HS...I am not a fan of JB...of course I will choose HS no matter what but it is not nice to compare one person to another person...they are both good professional singers..HS and JB the same age only 1 month gap..so they can be praternal twin.
Harry just has the tone that is very pleasing to your ears.
Right and Harry high notes in one direction time . ALSO , he is genuinely genius in Music
low: harry
belting: tie
falsetto/headvoice: harry
Belting is definitely Harry to me I mean his a baritone being able to hit some of those belts and even hit a mixed F#5 and definitely shows a little more technique imo
F#5? Studio or live?
@@brixn studio in the beginning of Music For Sushi Restaurant
@@Christopher-xl1oq oh yeah a lot of potential to hit those notes live!
@@Christopher-xl1oqWhat makes you think he is a baritone? Because of how low he can go or where his tessiutra sits?
In my opinion I love Justin’s voice more versátil, but HS is very good too
I really liked Justin's voice
Harry no doubt. Not t just in song but his character his manners. He is the entire package. A true entertainer. He knows who put him there. Talented beyond !
Would there be a one d without Bieber?
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
Harry's natural tone is unparalleled
I love both
Believer and a Directioner
💓💓💓💓💓
Here because I'm one of those who had to double-take on Harry Styles. Not big on pop culture & was only vaguely aware of One Direction. For years, I'd hear Harry's early solo songs when forced to turn on the radio, and think, "Oh, that Bieber's gotten a lot better musically." Now, I'm basically one of the Hitties, or whatever. I don't hear as much of the pubescent cry in Harry's voice any more, just a pleasant smokiness. Whereas Bieber seems frozen in time. This video confirms for me that they sound so, so different. Apologies to the fellow Hitties to the right and left of me.
I love both, but I think Justin's voice has many resources and versatility, so Justin with no doubt.
I don’t think I see the versatility. I’m terms of what he sings well, that’s probably just rnb and pop. He doesn’t really do a lot outside of that, and if he does it’s not as natural as when he does rnb, which he’s one of the best at. But Harry can sing a lot of different genres, while still having the most unique tone. So I’d give it to Harry.
@@AGEE_95Justin Bieber does country, JAZZ, Spanish, and Hip Hop music he is more versatile.
Amigo ambos cantan espetacular sin duda pero la voz de Bieber y no la cambiaría ni por más guapo y talentozo que fuera Harry eso si que noo😊 ,.q@@AGEE_95
Low notes -
A2: Harry
Bb2: Harry
B2: Justin
C3: Justin ( cute run )
C#3: Justin
D3: Justin
Eb3: Justin
E3: Justin
Belts -
E4: Tie
F4: Justin
F#4: Justin
G4: Harry ( vibrato )
G#4: Justin
A4: Harry
Bb4: Tie
B4: Harry ( not a big fan of both tho )
Falsetto -
A4: Justin
Bb4: Harry
B4: Justin
C5: Harry ( Justin's wasn't bad )
C#5: Harry
D5: Justin
Eb5: Justin
E5: Justin
I'm a full blown harry stan but I'm gonna try to be unbias here. Both JB and Harry are very talented musicians who were both teen idols and since they've had their fair share amount of time in the limelight, this makes their stage presence undeniably calm. I think they both know what they're doing. However, harry excels in the lower range due to the fact that he is a baritone, yet both he and JB shine in falsetto. In terms of range and quality, Harry does have the more mature and bigger of the two. But both are very talented singers, with JB having strengths that Harry might lack, vice versa.
JB has the better falsetto and control
Lol what. One is a multi instrumentalist and writes his own melodies while the other one can't even play an instrument to save his life. Jb is clear of the 0 musical talent noob.
@@daemontargaryen4561
Where as Harry has more power and versatility
Harry is actually more of a low tenor. I used to think he was a baritone too but when you watch him over and over you start to notice that his low register isn't that of a baritone and he seems more comfortable in his mid range. His low notes do not have this power and weight that they should have if he was a baritone. I'm a baritone myself and my voice is much more comfortable and bigger around G#2s/A2 where Harry already struggles with projection and resonance. All in all, he's still a lower voiced singer than JB who sounds like a light lyric tenor.
Harry wins easily. Sadly, Justin had so much potential when he was 13-16, he could have been, at this moment, one of the best tenors out here. Drugs, style and illnesses sort of ruined it :(
Actually it was his lack of trying. Singers could sound good while doing drugs like Whitney Houston sounded great and she was doing things WAY before her career. He didn't care about his music after he turned 16 or 17. He puts no effort in his voice or music anymore. Illness didn't do anything some singers are still sick with problems and they still sing fine I mean not as great as back then but for sure they sound good.
@@whitneyhouston1122it's not lack of trying, puberty changed his voice so he cant hit some of those high notes anymore it was easier for him to hit high notes when he had a lighter voice almost effortless really. But he still has a pretty good tenor. ua-cam.com/video/P_lfS9puQFg/v-deo.htmlsi=e9-7q1naJxAA99Qn this video really showcases he still a really good singer. Also listen to him singing his song that should be me ft Eddie Benjamin 2 years ago compare it to his voice when he was 16 even though he didn't go as high as when he was younger he sang the song just as beautifully in my opinion. You don't have to belt out high notes to be a good singer.
@@whitneyhouston1122the only thing that piss me off is when he sing in that nasally tone voice, I feel like he sings better when he sings more open. But his voice is naturally so whiny I understand why people don't like his voice but say that but to act like he's not a damn good singer is something else. I always like seeing videos of him when he sings his slower songs vs his more upbeat ones especially when he's on tour.
@@taneshiac5744 Yea.
I think that both have good things, I love Justin high notes and I like a lot Harry low notes
But I prefer Justin’s music
Harry
Low: harry but i prefer justin’s tone a little more
Belting: i think jb win. harry is a baritone so it’s def harder for him, i wish he open his mouth more to relive the tension, anyway in terms of tone it’s a tie for me.
Falsetto: harry. i feel like his is more developed than jb
Only harry styles
This is what I think:
Low notes -
A2: Harry (Justin's is almost just air)
Bb2: Harry
B2: Justin (sounds pretty good!)
C3: Harry
C#3: Tie
D3: Justin
Eb3: Tie
E3: Harry
Belts -
E4: Harry
F4: Tie
F#4: Harry
G4: Harry
G#4: Justin
A4: Harry
Bb4: Tie
B4: Harry (Justin's sounds very squeezed)
Falsetto -
A4: Justin (that transition was GOLD)
Bb4: Harry
B4: Justin
C5: Harry
C#5: Harry
D5: Justin
Eb5: Harry
E5: Justin
Low notes - Harry (6) > Justin (4)
Belts - Harry (7) > Justin (3)
Falsetto - Tie (4)
Harry has 17 points and Justin has 11 points. Harry wins! Justin has a lot of potential though so I really hope he improves his technique.
I'm sorry but I think you're not an audio expert because you mixed up so many things
I've been in this field for decades, and I know what I'm talking about
I love both of them, but we have to say JB has a much more controlled, layered and much better voice than Harry
@@alexmari88 I’m not a vocal expert. But I am a trained singer. I know what I’m talking about. The fact that you’re insisting that Justin is a better vocalist makes it very clear that you’re lying about being in the field for decades because any true vocal expert would say otherwise. Neither of them are great but Harry is objectively a better vocalist. He has a much better lower register and, even though he doesn’t belt as high as Justin, he is able to support his lower belts. Meanwhile, Justin has a better controlled falsetto and has a more agile voice. Harry Styles is as good as Justin Bieber, if not better. And I’d argue that he’s better.
@@varunravi27 You are the one who makes me doubt you. You are not well trained because in this way you spread your wrong thoughts. You need to study again in this field. I'm an expert in vocal warm-ups. I know Harry very well. I also know Justin. Harry needs a lot of training in order to perform, and he does a vocal warm-up, unlike Justin, where he sings randomly without preparation and training, and here talent and voice control appear, especially since justen deals with a larger audience. However, he does not warm his voice because he has divine talent and does not continue to develop it. He also does not like to perform at parties due to psychological reasons and often performs. However, he performs well. I was never a fan of Justin, but his vocal abilities made me look forward to researching his performance
@@varunravi27 Because his performance here in the video isn't the best of them all. Try to look for a much better performance than that and there's a lot for Harry, that's his level. He can't do better than this.
Also try looking for audio experts on UA-cam and if you want to I can contact you on WhatsApp about it and tell you a few things, but not now because I'm currently busy with production.
I guess you're biased towards Harry, but the fact that Justin's talent is better and he can master many notes and vocals, you can't deny it, especially the falsettos , riffs, and runs
Your comment about Harry and Justin proves that you don't know Justin very well and I wish you good luck 😄
@@alexmari88 YOU'RE the one who's spreading wrong thoughts and YOU clearly don't know what you're talking about. No one can randomly sing without preparation and training. And his "talent and voice control" definitely do not appear when he performs. He uses autotuned mics, which is why people think he's singing on key all the time. And, honestly, the fact that you don't notice that he lacks support in any part of his range and, yet, you go on about how he has a lot of vocal ability, just shows that you're lying about being a vocal expert. He is a talented singer but he is definitely not as good a vocalist as you're making him seem.
If you want to lie about being a vocal expert, at least make it look believable. You're not fooling anybody.
HARRRRRRRRRRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Sin ofender pero Justin gana aquí es más acá para harri un 90 para jus un 100%,.
Harry won. I like Justin’s voice too, but Harry has more variety in his voice and he is a better entertainer.
harry superior
They both are good but Harry styles is the better one.
Justin bieber prince of pop
Harry atw.
Who can do the most types of music? Justin. Who sounds more smooth? Justin. Who has a better belt? Justin. Falsetto? Justin by MILES I don’t think Harry’s really capable without hurting his voice. I LOVE Harry and he is my #2 to Justin. In the end they both have 2 totally have different styles. But where Justin wins is what’s more important and relevant.
Right
Fax
Maybe i just haven't listened to enough of his music recently to know this, but I don't think Justin does sing that many different types of music. Mainly rnb and pop. And he's great at, don't get wrong, but it's not much. Harry mostly does different types of rock-influenced music, but recently he's switched up his vocal style to sing more rnb/funk-style music, with Fine Line and HH. I'd say his voice is more versatile, especially since he has more range. Yet it's still unique, whereas Justin's vocal tone is pretty common in the pop/rnb genre. All of those comparison are more subjective though. I think what's actually more relevant is technique, and I'll grant Justin that he is more agile, has a better falsetto and a bit better vocal control. Harry has better low, mid, and high belts. His vocals are more powerful, he's more emotive, and has more depth and dynamics to his voice. Justin hasn't really taken any risks with his vocals or pushed himself vocally, as of late. Harry's voice is constantly evolving and he's always playing with different vocal styles.
Here's the thing Harry has a darker voice that's what makes his low notes better than Justin's and Justin has a lighter voice since the beginning of his career which makes his voice naturally easier to hit higher notes with ease because of his light 'high' voice.
Yeah but that still can't change the fact that both of them are lies on lighter side of tenors. Both voices are considered naturally very bright and high for male standard at default, It just that harry relatively sounds darker in tone compared to Justin who has already very bright light voice himself. In classification, harry is most comfortably likened/tagged to chesty light (or perhaps just a regular tenor with very forward, edgy and strident approach which had add certain brightness to his timbre considerably) due to his fairly youthful that's ultimately sufficient to put him as one despite his darker fuller sound at times (some of the weight he display purely has to do with his rounded formant coupling, veristic style or solid chest coordination) while Justin is a high tenor which is the highest, sweetest (in timbre) form of tenor, so it make sense why would he still sound easily brighter than Harry's who already would be better describe as sound like a woman in her 50s belting/speaking at the top of her lungs. This comparison is very similar to pace's sisters where duranice (matured light soprano, although I can seee why some peeps try to assume she's just a reg soprano, but she just seems to have wonderful vocal/chest voice development which would had deceptively convince people to label her as simply just a mid soprano aside from her old age which would enchance automatic slight warmth and smokiness to the qualities imo. I mean whenever she bring her chest voice up there in belting mode, she just sound kinda morbidly girlish and bright asf not to mention the amounts of her ease that she can't be confused as nothing else other than decent example of light soprano. Regular soprano is ofc possible but it's essentially a stretch to get away with it blindly given that I've heard alot of light soprano generate same level depth at any notes within their chest voice even regardless of age and health condition (minus registration development in this case), especially at lower areas) would represent harry while lashun/young melonda represent Justin's direct feminine counterpart in this sort of situation. If there's even such terms like soubrette soprano (I read on some sites that refer 'spieltenor' as the parallel equation to soubrette sopramo but any more valid reliable and informational data related to it is vaguely defined and not as commonly nagging about at the center of public), then that would fit Justin bieber the most likely really. Incredibly light, magnetically boyish, crisply agile and most importantly, very high tessitura (akin to mid/high mezzo and even some sopranos tessitura wise). Notice how similar they both sound when compare their voices from side to side, it just lashun still had ever slightly delicate texture and extra natural brightness in scale while anice sounds quite more timid, cavernous and lush.
ok pero harry tiene un registro mas bonito/agradable tmb
Justin Bieber fan!!! But HS has a good voice also.
current harry wins
prime justin destroys prime harry tho
prime justin tone was just smooth
Harry is in his prime right now, so Justin definitely ain't beating that. 14-15 year old Justin beats 15-16 Harry, but that's about it.
@@AGEE_95 dawg i was talking about 19 yo justin
JB
Harry doesn’t have falsetto like Justin. Harry wins with low rang but other than that Justin wins vocals.
Harry stlyes have singer hit high nots all good can not soend 🍰😻🐭🚨
Harry for sure. His tone alone destroys Justin, it’s just a lot more pleasing to listen to.
Hahaha, you guys are funny. If you're a vocal expert, don't say Harry has a better voice than Justin. Because it is true that Justin Bieber is more talented than Harry and masters many vocal layers and notes
@@alexmari88 that person just might be a vocal expert, because they chose correctly. Justin's voice has zero layers. He's still good though, but let's not get carried away.
@@AGEE_95 he is so good
Justin Bieber 💚
Lol
with a green heart...let me guess..you are a fan of JB but you still like HS a little bit..Thank you then.
Yess, Justinn
Justins lowest note is a E3!
There’s no way y’all thing Harry has better vocals than Justin there’s no way 18-21 year old Justin can pursing Harry. He still can. Justin doesn’t like to perform anymore
Justin for sure❤
I like Harry's vocals but I'm a belieber and I think Justin's voice is better
In My Opinion:
A2 - Harry
Bb2 - Harry
B2 - Justin
C3 - Justin
C#3 - Harry
D3 - Justin
Eb3 - Justin
E3 - Justin
E4 - Justin
F4 - Justin
F#4 - Justin
G4 - Harry
G#4 - Justin
A4 - Harry
Bb4 - Harry
B4 - Harry
A4 - Justin
Bb4 - Harry
B4 - Justin
C5 - Harry
C#5 - Tie
D5 - Tie
Eb5 - Harry
E5 - Justin
Somewhat well done
But there are few things Justin is better at than Harry
Like harry sond better jb
for me it's Justin
I love justin bieber✨💪 🔥🔥❤❤
Justin forever
The clips you used of Justin high vocals were not even him trying or even his best. his falsettos runs and riffs are better than hairy since he 17-21 he beats any Harry high range. Harry got him beat on low but other than that Justin beats Harry
Justin is King and Harry is poor 😂 why you compare with King
Nah you're just a retard. JB couldn't hit highnotes like harry does.
Justin Bieber the goat
Justin is better his voice is awesome❤
Lol ofc justin, harry jusrt sounds like every other guy, also justin biebers falsetto is as smooth as butter. Everyone saying harry is definitely biased.
Justin sounds like every other guy, despite having a smooth voice. But his tone is very common and almost kind of basic. Harry has one of the most unique tones of any male singer today.
@@AGEE_95 hes the opposite of everything you said. Even his fashion, his style, his stage presence, his charisma. This is everything it takes to be a star not just vocals and he has everything. Theres a reason why hes always been on the top of his game whether you like it or not☕️
@@PrettyboiYThen’s the last time Justin was even relevant, in the music industry or pop culture. Last time he was at the top of his game, as a true star was during the Purpose era. I’m not taking anything away from his accomplishments, and I’m not a hater. I was a huge Belieber once, but I fell off a long while ago. Tbh as a pop culture figure today, he’s not as popular as he once was. In many of those things that you said it takes to be a star, Harry has surpassed him. Many artists that came after him have actually. But to each their own. I’m not trying to get into a long debate, I just disagree with the opinion that Justin is still as good as he once was, vocally or as a completely artist. 🤷♀️
@@PrettyboiYTdelusional asf Harry’s out here selling out stadiums and winning grammys and getting praised by critics whereas the last time justin was relevant was 2015. he will forever be known as a teen pop star. justin sings like every other white boy from the vine era but only got so famous because of scooter braun. he has not grown artistically at all and is now pretty much just an influencer meanwhile harry is being compared to the greats like david bowie and elvis
this! harry sings very good don't take me wrong but very generic, bieber is way more unique
Harry and Selena looks good together. Harry please. Just talk to Taylor before going to Selena
Pero es gay no lo creo Selena ya tiene novio no la mueles,.
harry won. argue with the wall.
Justin's high and falsetto are better
Justin Bieber easily
It's justin for me
I think Justin's live singing is now the bestest cuz he was drunken but sang "Stay" in live far better than the studio version. But harry's live version is never beyond studio version. You can check it. I ain't kidding.
Edit: ua-cam.com/video/FlS6KslKiAU/v-deo.html
Tell me you've never heard Harry sing live without telling me you've never heard Harry sing live. Girl, Justin lip syncs most of the time. Harry has never.
Justin bieber prince of pop