Wendy’s vocals were already top tear before joining SM. Over the years, she’s just getting better and better. A true artist who is mastering her vocal talent.
I like the fact that Winter and Wendy are kind of labeled as vocal sisters here. As expected Winter is SM hidden ace but I recently discovered that Wendy actually debuted with vocal nodules and do pull off the iconic "shine on me" is absolutely amazing. It's amazing that although Winter is in her 2nd year and Wendy is in her 9th I feel like we are yet to see their full potential. In the future I would love to see them on a track together probably r&b but I wouldn't mind a ballad too
@@eulalia3468 ningning herself said she isnt the main vocalist, they all said they dont have fixed positions and you would know that if you were a genuine fan of them 😂 they like to be considered all rounders, no one is better than the other. they're both equally talented. there's no reason to downplay member just because you have bias lmaoa.
@@jurindiction Ningning is a B- tier vocalist, winter is a C tier vocalist, Giselle and karina are both D+ tier vocalists, yeah there are differences in skills and Ningning is at the top as a vocalist, she's top 3 best vocalists this generation
the way the only reasons they could guve to reason this sht out is "There's no position in aespa" like dude how does that make this valid to exclude her when with position or not she's one of the best female main vocal in sm and if others below her is here why can't she?
Both Winter and Ningning are official main vocalists of AESPA. When Aespa entered Weverse in September last year, it was documented in the member profile. SM confirmed that Winter is a main vocalist of AESPA along with NINGNING. Before that, there was no official position.
Taeyeon is truly one of a kind in terms of her solo career. She has a voice that allows her to navigate multiple genres of music and fit well in them and you can hear how she takes advantage of that in each of her albums.
Not y'all ignoring the fact that Ningning is the main vocalist of aespa, no hate to Winter 'cause I love her, but once again koreans show their xenophobia. Ningning deserves better, but sadly suffers the hate for being chinese.
agree with the comment that Wendy’s style possess elements crucial to pop and r&b. 💙 I hope she explores more of the genre instead of being boxed as a ballad singer
idk SM is moving weird. giving ninging dance breaks when winter was introduced as the lead dancer, and treating winter as main vocalist when they said it was ningning.
Ningning is aespa’s main vocal. And maybe it’s because an sm girl group hasn’t had a chinese main vocal before that the channel didn’t realize but that’s what it is and she shouldn’t be discredited for that.
@@BP-tm6ye SM has never said that. A group of 4 cannot have two main vocalist. If it were a bigger group then sure. But when you look at their vocal techniques it is clear Ningning is the main vocal.
@@taybluejay gurl its normal like bp have 2 lead vocalist and (g)i-dle have 2 main vocalist without even a lead vocalist ning cant be the ONLY main vocalist bcz of her bad belting technique and mix and SM updated their profile on melon and it says winter MAIN VOCALIST and ning MAIN VOCALITS and if you think about it its true since SM has been giving winter the same high notes and vocal lines as ning (even more than ning)
While most international fans in twitter mock Taeyeon and make fun of her bring back issues from more than a decade ago to attack her, You should watch more clips from people in Korean industry, composers, critics, lyricists, even producers outside SM and you will notice how are they mostly a fan of TAEYEON. The rest of these hyped idols are fan driven success by mass bulk buy and stream, Taeyeon is still one of the very very few authentic recognized in the industry and Kpop.
saw it too but just don't mind them and don't interact with them that much. It's there loss they missed the opportunity in stanning such an amazing artist.
We'll Taeyeon is arguably the best vocalist of her gen and some bird app users has no say in that I mean we can't even keep count of the number of idols that sees her as their role model
Her success is very organic indeed. Just ignore them. I'm so tired and done to those people who can't seem to move on from everything that happened centuries ago.
I don't stan GG but I support SM gg only(because I stan one SM bg). But It's kinda sad that they ignore Aespa's actual Main vocalist(I like them all same way, there is no biasness) also it's kinda sad seeing when someone just tells them about their xenophobia without even shading Winter, Winter stans just shut them up?! Like one of your girls is clearly getting mistreatment because of her nationality, where is your moral?Both can get praise together.
I really like winter's vocal tone and colour and that makes her standout more for me. the way you can never tell which voice would she use when singing a song makes it exciting too. she can hit those high notes and slay those low tones in the same song and would slay both and the fact that she can do that live too. Everything about her makes me want to look forward what she's about to bring in the future
@@eulalia3468 not you commenting here too LMFOAOA you're that desperate under a video that has nothing to do with competition 😭😂 winter wouldn't be in the group if she couldn't sing at a bit, and since when were you a vocal coach like the women in the video? you're not thats the thing, i didnt think so 💀 karina is a vocalist, ningning is a vocalist, winter is a vocalist and giselle is a vocalist. just because you don't enjoy the technique she was TAUGHT doesn't make you a professional vocalist. you have absolutely no clue what you're saying LMFOAOA saying due this and shit 🤣 these are the funniest comments ive seen all morning.
@@eulalia3468 Lol you're just jealous, case Ningning isn't in this video when her fans say that she's the "main vocalist" but what you guys don't understand is that Aespa have said that they have no positions and that they are all equal, which means that they don't have a main vocalist.
@@bubblywinter6729 they do have fixed positions SM published their positions in naver magazine before their official debut, besides skills wise they aren't equal, Ningning is the best she's a B- tier vocalist, winter a c tier vocalist, Giselle and karina are both D+ tier vocalists
@@halo6766 your dream Ningning is a much better vocalist than winter, duhh annoying and nasal high notes are so bad that's why her lungs collapsed she can't support high ranges
@@eulalia3468 Winter is much better than ningning. She messes up every live performance, her voice is cracked so easily, she can’t control her vocal she sings falsetto high notes. Winter is the main vocalist of aespa for reasons
It's fascinating how WINTER is able to use different styles and tones to match the vibe of different songs she sings Her vocal ability is so unique and she is so versatile with her voice unlike the others who sing in the same tone WINTER is definitely one of the best and most talented vocalists of this generation and fun fact is she got scouted by SM for her dance skills and only started training as a vocalist after she got into SM! I can't wait for her to release a Solo album! She's not just the Main vocalist but also a Visual ACE!
@@vaanshichauhan9868 no, aespa doesn't have official positions but Winter has always been referred as one of the Main vocalists of aespa by K and J medias and even on their naver profile SM never confirmed their positions to begin with it was just fandom assuming it by themselves based on intro teasers
@@winterlife0112 but Ningning is better vocalist so it's obvious she is main vocalist. Now if Winter has improved that's different idk but rn i think Winter is lead vocalist while Ningning is main and everyone knew it and during Knowing Bros when they asked who is main vocalist ,members themselves said Ningning.
@@vaanshichauhan9868 On an interview when they were asked to list their positions they said they don't have official positions and want it written as all-rounders and MBC entertainment introduced Winter as Main vocal when she guested their show and also Winter was featured as Main vocal on all the articles covering her recent collabs like Priority and floral sense And for your point calling Winter as Main vocalist doesn't mean the other one is not a Main vocalist
@@winterlife0112 well i am saying as perspective of who is better vocalist which i feel is Ningning. But Winter might have improved seeing her performance in concert but still i think Ningning is better vocalist so shouldn't she be main vocalist. It's already huge debate in sns and now this. Winter is popular in Korea while Ningning internationally that's why always this fan war. Atleast in this video they should have included Ningning too
I love Winter's vocal tone so much! She's my favorite female tone in kpop. And she's very versatile as well. Light tone, strong tone, vibrato, growls, high notes, runs riffs. Her voice can fit any Genre as well. And my favorite is her light tone that's perfect for rnb & lullabies.
I love WINTER's voice. As soon as I listened to her voice, I realized I was falling in love. The voice is amazing The voice stuck in my brain and my heart After that, I fell even more in love with her when I heard various voices. She might not be the best but you can't deny that her voice is charming and impresses many people. Her voice was strong and soft at the same time. I never get tired of listening to her voice and I will love her forever. I'm proud of you, Kim Winter. ⭐️❄️
@@eulalia3468 Since their debut, their official position has never been announced until September of last year. It's just that Ningning's akgaes, especially Chinese fans, insisted that Ningning was the one and only official main vocalist. Winter is pushed by sm? Lol Let’s say that is true so what? The official position is decided by SM, not you.
There's just something unique about Winter's vocal tone. Emotions are there, can easily hit high notes, voice control is insane. Top main vocalist not only in sm but also in 4th gen. I dont follow other kpop generations so I wouldnt know but to think that shes here with top vocalist from their respective gens already says a lot.
I adore everything about winter and she’s a VERY talented singer, but if I’m not mistaken (which i’m not), ningning is the main vocalist of Aespa. Why isn’t she in the video? I don’t wanna say SM is biased towards winter, but they do have a history of favoring their Korean members over any other foreign member so take that how you will. absolutely NO hate to winter at all, and I’m not discrediting her talent either, but ningning is without a doubt the main vocalist.
As much as I love winter getting compliments for her vocal talent but the title says "vocal trainer reacts to sm main vocal line". Isn't ningning the main vocalist in æspa? I know winter is a main vocal material but at least include ningning as she is given the role of main vocalist in her group.
I like this video, but I am confused. Does Ningning just not exist in AESPA. She is THE Main Vocalist of AESPA. Where is Ningning... I love my bias Winter getting so much recognition that she deserves because of her powerful voice, but where is Ningning. Y'all gonna do her like that. Damn!!
The amount of comments disrespecting Ningning is just saddening. They keep telling Winter is the most stable but when it comes to versatility and technical skills, Ningning overtakes Winter by miles. But because she is not Korean and does not meet korean beauty standard, everyone disregards her. Winter deserves the praise but she is not the main vocal for aespa no matter how stable she is in live singing. Stability can be developed but versatility is not something everyone has.
I'm glad they praise Wendy's powerful, technical voice. We know that she is the best vocalist of the 3rd gen. However, I feel like she hasn't shown her true potential yet, her company has stagnated her for so long, therefore i can't wait for her next album, i need her album to explore other concepts, such as the R&B genre because she has it in her blood. If SM will bet on her and promote her properly as theirs other artists, I'm really sure that she'll succeed in the american market, Not for nothing, but I prefer her pre-debut style whe she didn't have the vibes of SM. Sincerely whichever path Wendy chooses I will support her :)
AESPA HAS A REALLY STRONG LEAD VOCALIST IN WINTER BUT YOU ARE IGNORING NINGNING THE MAIN VOCALIST OF THE GROUP JUST BECAUSE SHE IS NOT KOREAN LIKE WINTER?
I love the comments about WENDY. Although I feel like SM have yet to maximize her full potential. Obviously, with her powerful voice, she’s good with ballads. But SM keeps on locking her to that genre only (except on group songs) when she could actually do ALL genres the she wants, especially r&b. Hopefully, she gets to do another genre for her 2nd album. 💙
This is so disrespectful towards Ningning she is the main vocalists of Aespa tho, they should've at least mentioned and include her in this video this is clearly xenophobic. These vocal trainers not spotting and acknowledging how good a vocalists Ningning is just so low of them and I refused to acknowledged them as such.
I don't think their intent was to discriminate against Ningning because of her nationality. IMO, their perception that Winter is the main vocalist is based on the fact that she usually gets the highlight or climax of their songs, especially title tracks, despite Ningning being OBJECTIVELY better than Winter. Lack of research on the trainers' part, perhaps. But xenophobia? I don't think so. Ps. If I were you, I would not jump into conclusions and accuse someone of committing a xenophobic act all because of one video.
@@ardentthoughts9750 I might have been too much with that xenophobic comment but it doesn't change the fact that Ningning is the main vocalist of Aespa, they should've respect that and include her on the video like that is not too much, their caption is also ABOUT main vocalists of SM so it just irks me why they exclude Ningning.
@@g.1030_ Aespa fans acknowledge that, for sure. However, you also can't blame casual listeners if they think differently, because personally, I am beginning to believe that there are two main vocalists in the group: Ningning (based on skills and designation) and Winter (based on the song parts she's been getting). But I get where you're coming from. Since this is a published video by professionals, they should've verified the information beforehand. IMO, rather than xenophobia, this is an issue of their reliability as content creators.
@@ardentthoughts9750 the problem is SM who keeps doing this. they know what they're doing. it's just annoying to see videos like this continue to perpetuate the problem they causdd
@@danissegomez7953 Don't be here if your opinion differs. This post discusses winter. Your comment doesn't change the fact that the vocal trainer in the content chose Winter as the best vocalist
![[C.C.] WENDY singing alone to Red Velvet's ⟪Psycho⟫ #REDVELVET #WENDY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Hep4nm8YNHU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C.] WENDY singing alone to Red Velvet's ⟪Psycho⟫ #REDVELVET #WENDY](/img/tr.png)
![보컬 트레이너들이 말하는 태연 Vocal coach reactions and analysis to Taeyeon [Eng sub]](/img/n.gif)
태연 보컬은 아이돌판에서도 전무후무하다고 본다
단순히 고음을 잘낸다 기교나 음색이 좋다로 표현할 수 없는 수준임
웬디도 가진게 많은 가수고 솔로 커리어가 더 쌓였으면 좋겠음
Racist
Our baby Winter
Wendy’s vocals were already top tear before joining SM. Over the years, she’s just getting better and better. A true artist who is mastering her vocal talent.
Fr I remember one time before she even auditioned for sm she hit a C#5 and supported it!!
@@Wandiii_luvshe actually supported a C6 too once..
Thank you for complimenting Winter
winter, you will always be famous
I like the fact that Winter and Wendy are kind of labeled as vocal sisters here. As expected Winter is SM hidden ace but I recently discovered that Wendy actually debuted with vocal nodules and do pull off the iconic "shine on me" is absolutely amazing.
It's amazing that although Winter is in her 2nd year and Wendy is in her 9th I feel like we are yet to see their full potential. In the future I would love to see them on a track together probably r&b but I wouldn't mind a ballad too
Ningning is the main vocalist and a much better vocalist than winter
@@eulalia3468 ningning herself said she isnt the main vocalist, they all said they dont have fixed positions and you would know that if you were a genuine fan of them 😂 they like to be considered all rounders, no one is better than the other. they're both equally talented. there's no reason to downplay member just because you have bias lmaoa.
@@jurindiction Ningning is a B- tier vocalist, winter is a C tier vocalist, Giselle and karina are both D+ tier vocalists, yeah there are differences in skills and Ningning is at the top as a vocalist, she's top 3 best vocalists this generation
@@eulalia3468 On their Weverse profiles, Winter and Ningning are both documented as main vocalists.
@@eulalia3468SM confirmed that both winter and nn are the main vocalists through aespa’s weverse profile
Always proud of Winter
Winter have such a lovely unique tone. I hope she gets more solo works and collaboration in the future. Thank you for recognising her.
the way the only reasons they could guve to reason this sht out is "There's no position in aespa" like dude how does that make this valid to exclude her when with position or not she's one of the best female main vocal in sm and if others below her is here why can't she?
Ningning is main vocal of 4th gen though. no hate to Winter, she's amazing, but Ningning is literally main vocal
BOTH Winter and Ningning are main vocals lol aespa doesn’t have official positions.
@@AJ-te6tf ningning is main vocalist in aespa .. she is the best in aespa technique wise too
Ningning main vocals from the begining sis
gurl both of them ning can't hold the main vocalist with her haedy and really light belts 💀 winter should be by her side
Both Winter and Ningning are official main vocalists of AESPA. When Aespa entered Weverse in September last year, it was documented in the member profile. SM confirmed that Winter is a main vocalist of AESPA along with NINGNING.
Before that, there was no official position.
winter shes so good omg😍
Winter 😍😍
Taeyeon is truly one of a kind in terms of her solo career. She has a voice that allows her to navigate multiple genres of music and fit well in them and you can hear how she takes advantage of that in each of her albums.
I would love a collaboration between Wendy, Winter, and Taeyeon! 🥰 "Priority" was already amazing
I’m afraid all we’re gonna get is got the beat 😭
I REALLY like Taeyeon, Wendy & Winter’s voices.. true everyone have their own preferences, and they are my favs so far ❤ SM’s vocal never disappoint
Winter amazing 😍😍😍
Baby Winter proud of you💜
Thank you for complimenting winter's vocal.
Not y'all ignoring the fact that Ningning is the main vocalist of aespa, no hate to Winter 'cause I love her, but once again koreans show their xenophobia. Ningning deserves better, but sadly suffers the hate for being chinese.
BOTH of ning and winter are main vocalist SM comfort that
Winter and Ningning are both documented as main vocalists on their Weverse profiles. Before that, they didn't have fixed position.
If you don’t like this video, make your own thing dealing with only ningning
WENDY and WINTER are truly TAEYEON’s daughters.
Winter❤❤❤❤
Winter is part of the future of Korean pop. Homegrown talents like boa bada taeyeon make Koreans proud and winter will continue on the path
agree with the comment that Wendy’s style possess elements crucial to pop and r&b. 💙 I hope she explores more of the genre instead of being boxed as a ballad singer
REAL, like we need her in a rnb album, like her vocal really suit many type of rnb
나는 윈터의 목소리를 정말 좋아한다
나도 좋아한다
나도
Just here to remind you that Ningning is aespa's main vocalist and not Winter.
Here to remind you that there’s no official positions in Aespa, and if anything, BOTH Winter and Ningning are main vocals.
@@AJ-te6tf me when i lie
우리 민정이가 잘해서 정말 눈부신 메인보컬이에요
Ningning is the main vocalist of aespa
@@eulalia3468 Both Winter and Ningning are main vocalists of AESPA. It was documented in the member profile on Weverse.
@@eulalia3468So is winter
@@eulalia3468 are you chinese??
@@argxoxo7326 no from Switzerland
I wasn’t a fan of K-pop before but I fell in love with Wendy’s vocal. She is really amazing singer.
Wendy, taeyeon, luna and winter ❤️❤️❤️
I wonder why they didn’t talk about Ningning? She’s the Main Vocal of aespa, right?
idk SM is moving weird. giving ninging dance breaks when winter was introduced as the lead dancer, and treating winter as main vocalist when they said it was ningning.
Because they hate Chinese people
what do you expect from a country full of racists and xenophobic people
Cause she’s chinese
@@regularhuhh5216 Let's be honest gurll.SM NEVER gave them ofc position!Go and check their website!
Ningning is aespa’s main vocal. And maybe it’s because an sm girl group hasn’t had a chinese main vocal before that the channel didn’t realize but that’s what it is and she shouldn’t be discredited for that.
Actually, aespa doesn’t have official positions. But if anything, BOTH Winter and Ningning are main vocals.
@@AJ-te6tf that would be true had this been around their debut time. but articles have come out since then announcing their positions so.
SM said that both of them are main vocalist
@@BP-tm6ye SM has never said that. A group of 4 cannot have two main vocalist. If it were a bigger group then sure. But when you look at their vocal techniques it is clear Ningning is the main vocal.
@@taybluejay gurl its normal like bp have 2 lead vocalist and (g)i-dle have 2 main vocalist without even a lead vocalist ning cant be the ONLY main vocalist bcz of her bad belting technique and mix and SM updated their profile on melon and it says winter MAIN VOCALIST and ning MAIN VOCALITS and if you think about it its true since SM has been giving winter the same high notes and vocal lines as ning (even more than ning)
Visual Ace Winter, you will always be in the spotlight
Kim winter❤❤❤❤❤
Taeyeon, Wendy and Winter are great vocalists from each generation.
Ningning is better though
When did Winter is better than Ningning?
@@eulalia3468 winter's live vocal is much more stable than ning2
@@niangao-ko2bt yeah and Ningning is stable too, they are both stable, but this has nothing to do with being a good vocalist actually
@@niangao-ko2bt but we find Ningning sounds prettier
WINTER is such a pretty talented and humble idol in this generation
It's unfair how she can be so perfect🤍
I'll do anything to get a WINTER/TAEYEON/WENDY vocal unit! That would be absolutely insane
If in the future we get more GOT The Beat content like another album, maybe we can also get unit covers or songs. That would be amazing
@@z_hange Ikr? That'd be great
Yess winter my girl, she's talented 😍
Wendy is just an all arounder like Taeyeon. They both can sing all genres and are amazing singers with great vocal technique.
I hope they get to collab sooner
While most international fans in twitter mock Taeyeon and make fun of her bring back issues from more than a decade ago to attack her, You should watch more clips from people in Korean industry, composers, critics, lyricists, even producers outside SM and you will notice how are they mostly a fan of TAEYEON. The rest of these hyped idols are fan driven success by mass bulk buy and stream, Taeyeon is still one of the very very few authentic recognized in the industry and Kpop.
saw it too but just don't mind them and don't interact with them that much. It's there loss they missed the opportunity in stanning such an amazing artist.
We'll Taeyeon is arguably the best vocalist of her gen and some bird app users has no say in that
I mean we can't even keep count of the number of idols that sees her as their role model
Her success is very organic indeed. Just ignore them. I'm so tired and done to those people who can't seem to move on from everything that happened centuries ago.
Winter's vocal is so unique and healing ❤️
Ningning is the main vocal of aespa, may e next time try hiding you are sinophobic as heck
winter's vocal never disappoint
EVERYONE KNOWS NINGNING IS THE MAIN VOCALIST IN AESPA
XENOPHOBIA AT ITS WORST!!
There’s no official positions in Aespa. BOTH Winter and Ningning are main vocals.
Define xenophobia. Coz she wouldn't be in a kpop group in korea if there's xenophobia.
Winter and Ningning are both documented as main vocalists on their Weverse profiles,
I don't stan GG but I support SM gg only(because I stan one SM bg). But It's kinda sad that they ignore Aespa's actual Main vocalist(I like them all same way, there is no biasness) also it's kinda sad seeing when someone just tells them about their xenophobia without even shading Winter, Winter stans just shut them up?! Like one of your girls is clearly getting mistreatment because of her nationality, where is your moral?Both can get praise together.
I really like winter's vocal tone and colour and that makes her standout more for me. the way you can never tell which voice would she use when singing a song makes it exciting too. she can hit those high notes and slay those low tones in the same song and would slay both and the fact that she can do that live too. Everything about her makes me want to look forward what she's about to bring in the future
Ningning is a much better vocalist than winter though, winter's voice is annoying in the high register due to lack of support actually
@@eulalia3468 not you commenting here too LMFOAOA you're that desperate under a video that has nothing to do with competition 😭😂 winter wouldn't be in the group if she couldn't sing at a bit, and since when were you a vocal coach like the women in the video? you're not thats the thing, i didnt think so 💀 karina is a vocalist, ningning is a vocalist, winter is a vocalist and giselle is a vocalist. just because you don't enjoy the technique she was TAUGHT doesn't make you a professional vocalist. you have absolutely no clue what you're saying LMFOAOA saying due this and shit 🤣 these are the funniest comments ive seen all morning.
@@eulalia3468 Lol you're just jealous, case Ningning isn't in this video when her fans say that she's the "main vocalist" but what you guys don't understand is that Aespa have said that they have no positions and that they are all equal, which means that they don't have a main vocalist.
@@bubblywinter6729 they do have fixed positions SM published their positions in naver magazine before their official debut, besides skills wise they aren't equal, Ningning is the best she's a B- tier vocalist, winter a c tier vocalist, Giselle and karina are both D+ tier vocalists
@@eulalia3468 No gurll.SM never do that.Aespa was confirmed on 1theK channel that they're didn't have official position
I love winter’s vocal it’s so good
Winter's voice is so pure and it so beautiful ..
Ningning is the main vocalist of aespa being sinophobic isn't going to change that from the map and she will always be thee 3rd gen vocalist .period!
Winter is one of the best vocalist in 4th gen
Ningning is better
@@eulalia3468oh shut up
@@eulalia3468in your dream
@@halo6766 your dream Ningning is a much better vocalist than winter, duhh annoying and nasal high notes are so bad that's why her lungs collapsed she can't support high ranges
@@eulalia3468 Winter is much better than ningning. She messes up every live performance, her voice is cracked so easily, she can’t control her vocal she sings falsetto high notes. Winter is the main vocalist of aespa for reasons
감사합니다 손혜린님이랑 김희경님이 my favorite sound is Winter’s voice 😊
If you classify winter as main vocalist you should have put Ningning as well. Y'all really want to disregard international members 😀
It's fascinating how WINTER is able to use different styles and tones to match the vibe of different songs she sings
Her vocal ability is so unique and she is so versatile with her voice unlike the others who sing in the same tone
WINTER is definitely one of the best and most talented vocalists of this generation and fun fact is she got scouted by SM for her dance skills and only started training as a vocalist after she got into SM!
I can't wait for her to release a Solo album! She's not just the Main vocalist but also a Visual ACE!
Isn't Ningning main vocalist
@@vaanshichauhan9868 no, aespa doesn't have official positions but Winter has always been referred as one of the Main vocalists of aespa by K and J medias and even on their naver profile
SM never confirmed their positions to begin with it was just fandom assuming it by themselves based on intro teasers
@@winterlife0112 but Ningning is better vocalist so it's obvious she is main vocalist. Now if Winter has improved that's different idk but rn i think Winter is lead vocalist while Ningning is main and everyone knew it and during Knowing Bros when they asked who is main vocalist ,members themselves said Ningning.
@@vaanshichauhan9868 On an interview when they were asked to list their positions they said they don't have official positions and want it written as all-rounders and MBC entertainment introduced Winter as Main vocal when she guested their show and also Winter was featured as Main vocal on all the articles covering her recent collabs like Priority and floral sense
And for your point calling Winter as Main vocalist doesn't mean the other one is not a Main vocalist
@@winterlife0112 well i am saying as perspective of who is better vocalist which i feel is Ningning. But Winter might have improved seeing her performance in concert but still i think Ningning is better vocalist so shouldn't she be main vocalist. It's already huge debate in sns and now this. Winter is popular in Korea while Ningning internationally that's why always this fan war. Atleast in this video they should have included Ningning too
winter vocals are very entertaining
winter is so talented and her visuals are so pretty
love u sooo much minjeong ah~
winter deserves those praises🤍
Our talented baby Winter
I love you Kim winter!!!
Winter sopan bgt suaranya adem bgt
SO PROUD OF WINTER 💞
I love Winter's vocal tone so much! She's my favorite female tone in kpop. And she's very versatile as well. Light tone, strong tone, vibrato, growls, high notes, runs riffs. Her voice can fit any Genre as well. And my favorite is her light tone that's perfect for rnb & lullabies.
I love Winter
Winter and Taeyeon collab 'Priority' was so good
Winter voice tone is soothing, it helps my mental health 💜💜💜
Taeyeon is truly something else. A very special vocalist
I love WINTER's voice. As soon as I listened to her voice, I realized I was falling in love. The voice is amazing The voice stuck in my brain and my heart After that, I fell even more in love with her when I heard various voices. She might not be the best but you can't deny that her voice is charming and impresses many people. Her voice was strong and soft at the same time. I never get tired of listening to her voice and I will love her forever. I'm proud of you, Kim Winter. ⭐️❄️
I think Ning Ning is the main vocalist of Aespa
Winter is the main vocalist of aespa as well. Their weverse profiles say both winter and nn are the main vocalists
Thank you for praising Winter. She is a very lovely vocalist indeed. ♥️
탱구 최고져
잘봤습니다
매우 많이 공감합니다
WINTER IS MY FAVORITE 🌟💞
NINGNING IS THE MAIN VOCAL??@!@!@! YALL TOO SCARED SHE WILL ATE SO BAD
Thank you for praising my girls TAEYEON, WENDY and WINTER. The triplets and holy trinity trio! 😍
Ningning is the main vocalist of aespa
@@eulalia3468aespa has two main vocalists
@@halo6766 at that time it was just Ningning and be real Ningning is still a much better vocalist than winter, let's just say she's just pushed by SM
@@eulalia3468 Since their debut, their official position has never been announced until September of last year. It's just that Ningning's akgaes, especially Chinese fans, insisted that Ningning was the one and only official main vocalist.
Winter is pushed by sm? Lol Let’s say that is true so what? The official position is decided by SM, not you.
Baby winter sooo talented 💗
There's just something unique about Winter's vocal tone. Emotions are there, can easily hit high notes, voice control is insane. Top main vocalist not only in sm but also in 4th gen. I dont follow other kpop generations so I wouldnt know but to think that shes here with top vocalist from their respective gens already says a lot.
Winter's vocal is the best among 4th generation idols i've ever known
Winter ❄️
You’ve got a natural talent for singing.
태연은 유영진이랑 거의 상관 없지. 워낙 타고난 부분이 많고 그게 또 너무 독보적인 사기캐릭터라서 모든 걸 흡수하고 흡수한 모든 걸 태연하게 '태연'으로 표현할 수 있지. 한마디로 태연은 그냥 태연일 뿐.
Hexogonal ace Winter😍
Winter is amazing, her voice is so beautiful 🥰 great video ❣️
I adore everything about winter and she’s a VERY talented singer, but if I’m not mistaken (which i’m not), ningning is the main vocalist of Aespa. Why isn’t she in the video?
I don’t wanna say SM is biased towards winter, but they do have a history of favoring their Korean members over any other foreign member so take that how you will. absolutely NO hate to winter at all, and I’m not discrediting her talent either, but ningning is without a doubt the main vocalist.
At 221215, winter and karina in a live on Instagram said that the members of aespa have no official position
SM did not give the exact positions of the members of aespa, only Karina is the leader, thank you
I really like winter vocal tune. And her vocal range is insane. She can pull any genre. Her voice is my fave among all the vocalist in gen 4
sameee
Indeed
As much as I love winter getting compliments for her vocal talent but the title says "vocal trainer reacts to sm main vocal line". Isn't ningning the main vocalist in æspa? I know winter is a main vocal material but at least include ningning as she is given the role of main vocalist in her group.
oh i see ningning is Chinese and I think the creator of this vid is korean. Hmmm xenophobic
first don't use winter as ur pfp lmao. begging the admin to include ur fave in this video 😂 lmao so desperate
@@unknown0r calm down ur so mad for nothing😂
I like this video, but I am confused. Does Ningning just not exist in AESPA. She is THE Main Vocalist of AESPA. Where is Ningning... I love my bias Winter getting so much recognition that she deserves because of her powerful voice, but where is Ningning. Y'all gonna do her like that. Damn!!
I can't help to feel that it's xenophobia/nationalism that makes some koreans favor Winter over NingNing
I really like winter’s vocal and her vocal colour is my fav tone ever.
The amount of comments disrespecting Ningning is just saddening. They keep telling Winter is the most stable but when it comes to versatility and technical skills, Ningning overtakes Winter by miles. But because she is not Korean and does not meet korean beauty standard, everyone disregards her. Winter deserves the praise but she is not the main vocal for aespa no matter how stable she is in live singing. Stability can be developed but versatility is not something everyone has.
Good morning Stan winter for a better life ❤️
WINTER 🤍
winter I love you I like voice you it is amazing
Vocal Queen WINTER❄️
winter omgggggg
I really love Winter voice Winter vocals is healing me thank you for your appreciation
I'm glad they praise Wendy's powerful, technical voice. We know that she is the best vocalist of the 3rd gen. However, I feel like she hasn't shown her true potential yet, her company has stagnated her for so long, therefore i can't wait for her next album, i need her album to explore other concepts, such as the R&B genre because she has it in her blood. If SM will bet on her and promote her properly as theirs other artists, I'm really sure that she'll succeed in the american market, Not for nothing, but I prefer her pre-debut style whe she didn't have the vibes of SM. Sincerely whichever path Wendy chooses I will support her :)
love you winter you are the best vocalist💗💗💗
I love Winter praise 💕
I love Winter and Taeyeon
AESPA HAS A REALLY STRONG LEAD VOCALIST IN WINTER BUT YOU ARE IGNORING NINGNING THE MAIN VOCALIST OF THE GROUP JUST BECAUSE SHE IS NOT KOREAN LIKE WINTER?
Winter😊😊😊😊
I love the comments about WENDY. Although I feel like SM have yet to maximize her full potential. Obviously, with her powerful voice, she’s good with ballads. But SM keeps on locking her to that genre only (except on group songs) when she could actually do ALL genres the she wants, especially r&b.
Hopefully, she gets to do another genre for her 2nd album. 💙
she’d definitely devour soul r&b 😩
This is so disrespectful towards Ningning she is the main vocalists of Aespa tho, they should've at least mentioned and include her in this video this is clearly xenophobic. These vocal trainers not spotting and acknowledging how good a vocalists Ningning is just so low of them and I refused to acknowledged them as such.
Winter is a very good vocalists and I really love her voice but they should've really include Ningning
I don't think their intent was to discriminate against Ningning because of her nationality. IMO, their perception that Winter is the main vocalist is based on the fact that she usually gets the highlight or climax of their songs, especially title tracks, despite Ningning being OBJECTIVELY better than Winter.
Lack of research on the trainers' part, perhaps. But xenophobia? I don't think so.
Ps. If I were you, I would not jump into conclusions and accuse someone of committing a xenophobic act all because of one video.
@@ardentthoughts9750 I might have been too much with that xenophobic comment but it doesn't change the fact that Ningning is the main vocalist of Aespa, they should've respect that and include her on the video like that is not too much, their caption is also ABOUT main vocalists of SM so it just irks me why they exclude Ningning.
@@g.1030_ Aespa fans acknowledge that, for sure. However, you also can't blame casual listeners if they think differently, because personally, I am beginning to believe that there are two main vocalists in the group: Ningning (based on skills and designation) and Winter (based on the song parts she's been getting).
But I get where you're coming from. Since this is a published video by professionals, they should've verified the information beforehand. IMO, rather than xenophobia, this is an issue of their reliability as content creators.
@@ardentthoughts9750 the problem is SM who keeps doing this. they know what they're doing. it's just annoying to see videos like this continue to perpetuate the problem they causdd
winter deserved all the praise ❤️❤️❤️
That's right Taeyeon is Taeyeon. Her singing abilities so amazing, powerful, soft and emotions. I love Taeyeon vocal very much.
Winter the best vocalist gen4
nope. its Ning
@@danissegomez7953 both
@@danissegomez7953 Don't be here if your opinion differs.
This post discusses winter. Your comment doesn't change the fact that the vocal trainer in the content chose Winter as the best vocalist
Winter is a Average tier vocalist, 4th gen has vocalists 2 whole tiers above her💀💀
NOPE, IT'S NINGNING AND LILY!