Good news! The motor used in this design had been elusive, but the community was able to identify the motor manufacturer and SparkFun had a bunch of these motors manufactured - the motors can now be purchased from SparkFun if you'd like to build your own! www.sparkfun.com/products/20441 SparkFun is an awesome company to support - they've been pushing the hobbyist and open-source electronics space forward for years! This isn't sponsored and I don't make any money from sales or anything like that; I just love what they're doing as a company. I've used a ton of their electronics boards in the past and I actually learned how to reflow solder at home by following Nate's old blog posts: www.sparkfun.com/tutorials/58 and www.sparkfun.com/tutorials/59 Very excited that they were willing to help make these motors more broadly available!
Those seems like a 3-pin version of old HDD motors. Currently thinking and looking into how this would be possible with an HDD drive motor and those ar also brushless motor's. Unfortunatly those are commonly in 3 phases.
When you're taking a product to market it is going to be stripped down for low-cost parts and manufacturing processes. While this knob is relatively low-cost, there are certainly drawbacks to making it the way this video shows you on a large scale.
UI tip: pick a font that has “lining numbers” in the OpenType feature set. All the numbers will have the same bounding box width, so they won’t jump around when you go from skinny numbers to fat numbers, like 11 to 12.
@@RuslanKoptiev lining numbers is different than monospace. Monospace gives every character the same width, lining numbers only applies to digits but leaves alphanumeric characters as-is.
This technology suits many markets but as soon as I saw it I couldn't help but imagine it in a car especially with the new minimalistic approach many manufacturers are taking. This really can be a game changer and an incredible solution for the fine balance between reducing cost and maintaining customer experience. Incredible work!
Exactly. Touchscreens are reliable and cheap but the lack of tactility is dangerous in some ways, if not extremely unsatisfying and soulless. A contactless system with simulated tactility is the way for the future.
For a car input I would loose the LCD. It would be hard to place the knob in the field of vision of the driver and the traffic. Instead I would include something like a vibration motor and maybe a few haptic fixed buttons. like home, select, quick menu (navi, radio,...)).
This is super cool! I built one similar to this about 24 years ago using a DC motor and an optical rotary encoder. It did not have an LCD display nor button. Watching your demo brought back memories and now I want to build one like yours!
@@omnianti0 Well, A pocophone f1 screen is 20$ (1080p ips with touch digitizer) So I bet this little screen is less. This looks like a smartwatch screen which are now mass manufactured.
I really like how he just went "ooh, I really like this motor, I wonder what it can do" and produced the single best DIY project on the entireity of youtube haha
Dude! I would love to see a "how to build" video or written series, this seems like such a fun project to learn and build something that is sooo tactile and useful in my real world. Appreciate your work Scott!
@@sparkie5571 basically my plan, I have home assistant set up on an always on PC. Planning on installing this in my light switch socket and using the mains for power with a phone charger, probably convection cooled for safety
I literally had the exact same idea for a project of mine went on designing it like 70 percent and see this video of yours in ky recommendation Why just why bro😅 Thanks for open sourcing it btw
This is one of those awesome ideas that make you wonder why nobody had them earlier. Totally blown away, I will definitely use this some day for one of my projects! =)
BMW's first IDRIVE System in the E60/E65 from around 2002 worked exactly like this. As the menu changed, the turning of the knob changed on the fly. Really cool
The idea isn't new. This is an extremely good implementation of an old idea I would say. Having a physical knob as additional input device for a computer has been there at least 10-15 years ago. The problem back then was that they just didn't find good use cases. I remember that it was marketed as tool for designers who work often with photoshop. The knob could be used to determine brush sizes and in general everything where you have a scrollbar. It sounds cool and I bet it is cool when using, but to be honest, there is no real benefit from it as using a mouse wheel also works pretty good already.
Designer: "We should put this really awesome knob customers will love it!" Engineer: "Ok how much does it cost?" Designer: "I don't know like $5" Engineer: "We're gonna go with the $0.20 knobs we've been using." Designer: "But...this will add value" Engineer: "You know what you're right, $0.25 knobs it is!"
Scott, you need to bring this to market or find a partner that can. I saw your videos on this years ago, and there still hasn't been something like it available. It has so many use cases and I can imagine it being used a ton by creatives, WFH, smart home enthusiasts, music fans, and movie/tv lovers just to name a few. The possibilities would be endless if it had integrations like the Elgato Stream Deck products. I know that you open sourced this (huge props), but a ton of people like myself don't have enough time / aren't smart enough to make anything of it and would be willing to pay top dollar for it prebuilt. Cheers!
Are you slow? You could say that about any company. I can tell that you don't know anything outside of games if elgato comes to your mind after watching this video. Grow up
How much does it cost? I can for sure get one integrated, at least the biggest features. With endless possibilities also comes endless integration.. possibilities!
This is incredible!!! I would love to use something like this as some sort of universal control knob for different software. Imagine this being the volume knob for the PC by default but as you open up a particular software you can switch and control certain software features with it. Maybe with an added grid of simple buttons next to it to switch between different things you want to control. I know there are control decks out there for music making, lightroom etc but a knob with tactile feedback of this degree is simply something else. I have pretty much zero experience in electronics or programming/coding but I would definitely put money down on some sort of easy to built kit or pre-assembled product! As long as there are ways to configure it on an app by app basis.
You could also use it to control playback of videos and music. Have it motorized to turn at a steady pace, then the video speeds up / slows down or goes back wards if you adjust the speed or direction, like a DJ controlling a turntable.
Not exactly the same, but Microsoft has the "Surface Dial" which is basically a software defined knob. It changes uses based on the context of the app that it's in. I don't have any hands on experience with it, but from what I've seen, it's pretty neat. So the precedent for its sort of device is there.
I'm thinking this could work well with Home Assistant, or as a fancy jog wheel for video editing. Maybe mute and volume control for Zoom calls? What else would be cool?
Just posted this to the Home Assistant subreddit before seeing this comment. Yes, so much yes! I can envision so many possible uses for this. What an utterly fantastic project. Well done!
Love the FOSS implementation! You should look up the NODO Inertia Wheels. They're for the film industry and mega expensive, but they have a few extra features that could be fun to implement. You can adjust the "mass" and the "drag" of each wheel to change it's pretend moment of inertia. I think it's commutating the motor so that it slows down the deceleration.
id love if we started seeing these actually used like everywhere because this is the perfect line between digital and mechanical which giving the best of both worlds and making everyone happy no matter what you prefer
This is wonderful! I hope that some day these become available to purchase. While I do tinker a bit with electronics, I don't think my skills are good enough to do the soldering required for this project.
One way or another I'm getting these in every room. This is the best implementation of a thermostat/light/scene/volume/fan/everything controller that I've ever seen. I was eying the sonof ns panel with the home assistant custom component. But I'm really tempted to wait for/help with the mentioned revisions and start ordering parts for this.
This is what I'd like in my dream car. Imagine having maybe 2 or 3 knobs like this and being able to program them to do different things - heck, maybe even contextually. Imagine using those knobs to control multi-zone aircon and then switching to a different menu on your infotainment system and using the same knobs to control ambient lighting or select a driving mode. And of course the knob itself tells you what you're controlling, so that would be great for guest passangers. Now pair that with a couple of programmable buttons with simmilar LCD displays for binary inputs + add ligthing and sound cues to know when you enter a different preset. You get ergonomic and elegant dashboard with PHISICAL controls that can do everything. Say goodbye to touchscreens with no feedback that you can't operate without taking your eyes off the road.
The functionality and flexibility you’ve managed to get out of a DC motor to drive an interface device is actually amazing. This could honestly revolutionize the approach to building any kind of rotary input system since the BOM for the rotation elements is so low. I’d suggest also considering a knob+surrounding LEDs build if you’re looking to do further experiments with even smaller form factors. LED light intensity/color could be a feedback mechanism as well.
This knob has been in Mercedes cars since like 2015, same functionality too. It's quite amazing that the code for that is opensource, lots of different ideas/products can be made with this thingy alone.
It would be dope if this could be added as a matter device and be used and customized for actions in smartthings. Like managing light brightness or volume on something
As cool as this is I’d love to see an attempt at inertia! Give the wheel a flick and depending on detents and friction the wheel could spin a few revs before slowing to a stop. Video editors have mechanical shuttle jog wheels like this. It’s a gas watching a skilled operator flick them around with high speed and precision.
I was absolutely thinking about the applicability of this for video editing. I guess it can't be both jog and shuttle simultaneously, but it can switch back and forth easily enough, and that's pretty cool all on its own. And hey, if a 2-layer version could be made, then you'd have the full package -- PLUS the ability to make it do various other things, too. Very cool project!
Not sure why I got this on my recommendations but I sure am glad I did. This is some interesting stuff and I can already A LOT of cool ways to use something like this. Love it.
I liked the video before it had even started, but now I wish I could like it twice. I was expecting this to be something mildly interesting, but this was incredibly interesting. It's so cool that the haptics and end-stops are all managed by software, and that snapping of the dial is really neat too. I can imagine so many great uses of this system in modern and sleek designs. Great job!
I want this so much. I have no immediate use for it but I want it. There is something absolutely satisfying the way you show it and when you understand what goes into making it, the obsession is even more. Like others have said, this would be a perfect fit for home assistant.
This is brilliant! I've been wetting the bed in my dreams waiting for something like this... Ahem - I was too excited there and jumped the gun with that comment. Though, in all seriousness, this is an amazing project. Already have tons of ideas where I can implement it, and look forward to experimenting. Thank you for open sourcing this project!
I have no idea what I would use it for, but I absolutely love the idea and the implementation. One possible solution... an all in one controller for home automation. Changing temperature, lighting, etc... with the knob.
Scott I'm literally losing my mind that I hadn't seen much of your work before now. This is amazing and the fact that you are making it an OS project screams! I don't know where you are located but if you ever want to lean on our workshop for collaborating on something we would be game! I immediately have so many ideas for your rotary knobs and can't wait to make some.
This is unbelievably fascinating. i was baked asf watching this and thought it was just a cool fidget thing that could change, but man well done this is quite an incredible piece of tech u have made!
5 seconds in and I absolutely LOVE THIS! I have worked on a diy project with cheap rotary encoders and the result was garbage. this looks so unbelievably amazing! great job! I would also happily buy one if you decide to sell them!
Holy cow this is amazing. Not often do I get legitimately excited on youtube but today I am EXCITED. Can't wait to dig into this. Thank you for sharing.
I've been looking for something like this literally fucking forever! I'm so glad to see someone finally show off an essentially feature complete version. I'm definitely going to need to build this!
Holy smokes man! This is incredible stuff! I would definitely would love to see an overview of putting together this project. Keep up the great work!!!
This kind of thing should be used in new cars. For whatever reason, more and more manufacturers are deciding that it’s a good idea to force the driver to take their eyes off the road just to do something simple like change the radio station or turn on the AC, by using a touchscreen rather than physical controls. Technology like this however, could make use of both sides. Since everything is software controlled, the same knob could be used for different things in different situations. And since the knob is still physical rather than just a touch screen, the driver can keep their eyes on the road while using it.
Wow! I could see this making a HUGE impact on Amateur Radio imagine being able to setup the main rotary encoder (VFO knob) to your exact requirements of feedback on CW/SSB but also then it automatically select itself to Detent mode for FM/AM use! Then if you had a radio with a Menu system of settings it would be useful for that too. How long before someone uses one in a uBITX HF kit ? 😁#KD8CEC #uBITX
or even using several of these encoders on an advanced rig not just for the vfo but also for clarifier, af&rf gain, if shift/width, DSP control and then dynamically change them to rf power/drive, mic gain/compression/eq, CW keyer speed when going tx or adapt knob usage depending on the selected mode. That would cut down fiddling with the menu during the QSO and get rigs closer to a full hardware control like with dials and knobs on classic analog rigs. Modern rigs, albeit with better performance, became a bit cumbersome to operate compared to the old ft-902dm or ts-830s
Very inspiring! I've been working on a musical instrument controller based off a Teensy and a AS5601, along with some haptic feedback. Really love the addition of the motor and display here. Curious how "smooth" the motor feels when just spinning/rotating it. Ordered a few off Aliexpress to have a play with.
This motor is basically completely smooth when unpowered, which is relatively rare - I've ordered and tried a LOT of different motors from AliExpress and most have noticeable cogging.
@@scottbez1 Fantastic! For my controller I put a fair amount of time into getting really smooth skate bearings, and some offset weights (ala fidget spinner) so it tends to skate along quite smoothly on its own. I look forward to it arriving and playing with it. I've not dug that deep in Teensy-land (motor drivers), but the interface options are pretty staggering.
Love this project! Immediately I want to take a bunch of these in a grid and make a software configurable MIDI controller! Is the size arbitrary or does it need to be that big due to all the parts? For a MIDI controller, half or quarter size would probably be perfect assuming screens are available, but even a grid of full size knobs would be cool. I could also see a use case in controlling custom stage lighting effects and other music-tangential use cases!
I was just looking up micro brushless motors for a midi controller like this when I came across this video haha. I think the key to making it small enough would be a different screen layout (or getting rid of it entirely). I was thinking maybe one screen with a bunch of knobs and each knob just has an led ring to indicate position and notches, then the screen could show actual values.
I second this. Being able to configure if a thing is a knob or endless encoder depending on context is probably next generation of midi-controller hardware.
It looks like majority of the hardware he's got physically inside the knob, but it doesn't have to be that way. If the depth of the device isn't as important, there's no reason you couldn't pack all the hardware further back into the enclosure and just have the knob extending out into the front. Getting the screen functional with that setup would be the only challenge.
I just saw the Xmas switch and this...brilliant. I am going to go through the video and see what else I can marvel at and realize how far away I am from being able to do.
For the first time, I like a project where a round screen is used. I used to think, why is it released? Are people going to make homemade watches? What kind of clock will be cumbersome and slow? And in this project everything is perfectly balanced. The idea is great. I want such a device))
I don't know if this has been mentioned before, but if you can find a 2013 or so Lexus CT200h it needs to have the little square joystick on the console. It uses something similar to this for its menus. The joystick has "detents" depending on what screen you are on and only allows the joystick to move to those spots or full freedom of movement. I have always tried to explain this to people when I owned one, but never knew what to call it until I could show them in person. I always geeked out about it and it was one of my favorite unique features of that car.
One of those items where you cant immediately think of a place/use/purpose for it, but you know someone out there will love it. I can see it being used in the AV / Production Studio / Sound Recording world.
this has a lot of potential just on top of my head i could see it being used in cars! imagine 1 knob that could adjust anything from AC, heated seats, etc as well as home in stove or something
First thought: mini turntables! You've got the needed precision and a motor. With some open source dj software (or customizable midi inputs) this is totally doable!
over 35 years ago (precisely in 1989) Canon released two camera lenses - the 85mm f/1.2 and 50mm f/1.0 that had the electronic coupling between the focus control ring and the motor and oh boy... it's so satisfyingly accurate! it feels like the ring is really physically connected but it's not. I only know that they are using the ultrasonic motor, I think it is still the pinnacle of the encoder+motor engineering. I mean, they did it in 1989, and we are coming closer only now...
Good news! The motor used in this design had been elusive, but the community was able to identify the motor manufacturer and SparkFun had a bunch of these motors manufactured - the motors can now be purchased from SparkFun if you'd like to build your own! www.sparkfun.com/products/20441
SparkFun is an awesome company to support - they've been pushing the hobbyist and open-source electronics space forward for years! This isn't sponsored and I don't make any money from sales or anything like that; I just love what they're doing as a company. I've used a ton of their electronics boards in the past and I actually learned how to reflow solder at home by following Nate's old blog posts: www.sparkfun.com/tutorials/58 and www.sparkfun.com/tutorials/59 Very excited that they were willing to help make these motors more broadly available!
came here after seeing Sparkfun posted the part. I'm very excited to try my hand at one of these really cool knobs. Thanks for providing this.
Those seems like a 3-pin version of old HDD motors. Currently thinking and looking into how this would be possible with an HDD drive motor and those ar also brushless motor's. Unfortunatly those are commonly in 3 phases.
Thanks for posting that video. Today been pondering how to do that without a slip ring, so thus glad to find that video and project!
Ooooohhhh, a special type of motor where the shaft is around a stationary center. Thus it doesn’t need a slip ring
surely there is way less costly possibility to get haptic feedback, by using some more generic and lower tech brushless motor.
why are open source designs always far superior to anything commercially manufactured. This is so impressive.
Because they are innovative and are not controlled by “industrial design” bosses
Because an open source design is designed with the goal of developing a good product rather than how much money can we squeeze out of the consumer
also patents
When you're taking a product to market it is going to be stripped down for low-cost parts and manufacturing processes. While this knob is relatively low-cost, there are certainly drawbacks to making it the way this video shows you on a large scale.
Because these people didn't have to be paid to do the thing. They just loved it so much they did it for free!😊
Bro really dropped the coolest knob I’ve ever seen in a less than 3 min video, and open-sourced it. This is awesome.
and never came back
This is absolutely brilliant. Thank you for open sourcing it! I would love to see a build video.
Me too!
Yes, a build video would be cool. Get them extra view stats up!
Me 3
Yes please build video
Oh please, do please upload a build video. I would love to make this knob for myself, too. 😁
You gave us an insanely cool project and then abandoned us.
Please, come back!
I second this. Something like this has so many use cases in productivity and needs to be on the market!
probs got hired
@@JAt0mor he got abducted and iced
UI tip: pick a font that has “lining numbers” in the OpenType feature set. All the numbers will have the same bounding box width, so they won’t jump around when you go from skinny numbers to fat numbers, like 11 to 12.
monospace fonts
@@RuslanKoptiev lining numbers is different than monospace. Monospace gives every character the same width, lining numbers only applies to digits but leaves alphanumeric characters as-is.
@@areox27 that’s cool! thanks for the info
yeah any monotype will do the trick
@@nebsu_ every monotype is number lining, but not every nunberlining is monotype
This technology suits many markets but as soon as I saw it I couldn't help but imagine it in a car especially with the new minimalistic approach many manufacturers are taking. This really can be a game changer and an incredible solution for the fine balance between reducing cost and maintaining customer experience. Incredible work!
Exactly. Touchscreens are reliable and cheap but the lack of tactility is dangerous in some ways, if not extremely unsatisfying and soulless. A contactless system with simulated tactility is the way for the future.
Vw Phaeton had this feature decades ago 😉
@@TheBurnout96 bmw idrive in pre 2010 cars had this
imagine it on an Fueltech
For a car input I would loose the LCD. It would be hard to place the knob in the field of vision of the driver and the traffic. Instead I would include something like a vibration motor and maybe a few haptic fixed buttons. like home, select, quick menu (navi, radio,...)).
I can cross a similar project off my todo list. this has everything I wanted! Well done!
So you were the reason it got recommend to me
fancy spotting you here Bitluni
lol
everything a knob can be, awesome project !!
Maybe you can add software futures and help with his RAM problem
Same, very well done!
We definitely NEED this in synthesizers
or CC automations
YESSSSS
I love the relative simplicity, yet deep complexity of this device!
Absolutely a masterpiece of ingenuity.
Simple products, require deep complexity. My manager still not understands that.
I watched this 2 years ago and even 2 years later i find this really freaking cool
This is super cool! I built one similar to this about 24 years ago using a DC motor and an optical rotary encoder. It did not have an LCD display nor button. Watching your demo brought back memories and now I want to build one like yours!
the nutton seem cheap to add but the screen is like 80$ and take bunch of space inside
@@omnianti0 Well, A pocophone f1 screen is 20$ (1080p ips with touch digitizer) So I bet this little screen is less.
This looks like a smartwatch screen which are now mass manufactured.
@@omnianti0 Just checked a circular OLED is ~25$
You can get by using a rectangular one if you don't fill it with color.
@@omnianti0 LOL, so wrong.
@@HAWXLEADER you meam the screen without controller what is of few use here
I really like how he just went "ooh, I really like this motor, I wonder what it can do" and produced the single best DIY project on the entireity of youtube haha
This is neat, what really amazes me is how intuitive the configurations are and how you smoothly fuses everything together in a clean design.
Dude! I would love to see a "how to build" video or written series, this seems like such a fun project to learn and build something that is sooo tactile and useful in my real world. Appreciate your work Scott!
I don't have a project for this yet but need one in my life! VERY cool! 👍
I need lik 500
this could be useful to control lights and other smart home devices
@@Shadow__X could combine this with a raspberry pi and homeassist to make an awesome control panel
o kinda wish to use only as a fidget toy, Imagine you can configure lots of modes just to spin the knob around with different feedbacks.
@@sparkie5571 basically my plan, I have home assistant set up on an always on PC. Planning on installing this in my light switch socket and using the mains for power with a phone charger, probably convection cooled for safety
I literally had the exact same idea for a project of mine went on designing it like 70 percent and see this video of yours in ky recommendation
Why just why bro😅
Thanks for open sourcing it btw
This is one of those awesome ideas that make you wonder why nobody had them earlier.
Totally blown away, I will definitely use this some day for one of my projects! =)
BMW's first IDRIVE System in the E60/E65 from around 2002 worked exactly like this. As the menu changed, the turning of the knob changed on the fly. Really cool
The idea isn't new. This is an extremely good implementation of an old idea I would say.
Having a physical knob as additional input device for a computer has been there at least 10-15 years ago. The problem back then was that they just didn't find good use cases. I remember that it was marketed as tool for designers who work often with photoshop. The knob could be used to determine brush sizes and in general everything where you have a scrollbar. It sounds cool and I bet it is cool when using, but to be honest, there is no real benefit from it as using a mouse wheel also works pretty good already.
Designer: "We should put this really awesome knob customers will love it!"
Engineer: "Ok how much does it cost?"
Designer: "I don't know like $5"
Engineer: "We're gonna go with the $0.20 knobs we've been using."
Designer: "But...this will add value"
Engineer: "You know what you're right, $0.25 knobs it is!"
Sony rds tuner had that 30 years ago, albeit in hardware.
Scott, you need to bring this to market or find a partner that can. I saw your videos on this years ago, and there still hasn't been something like it available.
It has so many use cases and I can imagine it being used a ton by creatives, WFH, smart home enthusiasts, music fans, and movie/tv lovers just to name a few. The possibilities would be endless if it had integrations like the Elgato Stream Deck products.
I know that you open sourced this (huge props), but a ton of people like myself don't have enough time / aren't smart enough to make anything of it and would be willing to pay top dollar for it prebuilt. Cheers!
This seems like the sort of thing I could imagine Elgato selling
Elgato ForceKnob
Are you slow? You could say that about any company. I can tell that you don't know anything outside of games if elgato comes to your mind after watching this video. Grow up
Hi chippy
chippy chippy chappa chappa
You know where I'd love to see this? Big chonky control knobs on the front of high-end HI-FI gear.
I realllly hope that this will be implemented to Home assistant. This is a killer device for smart home! Glad I opened my recommendations today.
YES
How much does it cost? I can for sure get one integrated, at least the biggest features. With endless possibilities also comes endless integration.. possibilities!
exactly what i was thinking
Thermostats, smart control, remote control fan, etc. There's so many stuff to use it for too
yes. this I dont know how I'm going to use this. but i want to build it. i wish we had a collection of theses physical UIs for home assistant
You show here the solution to what the car manufacturers got wrong with their touchscreen only concept. Amazing, I can't wait to see this in action.
my tesla is awesome and i never need to use the screen while driving anyway, it is so smart, depending on who enters, everything adapts.
@@JohnSmith-pn2vlnobody asked about your tesla
@@JohnSmith-pn2vl press agree to send elon musk your soul
This has got to be one of the coolest projects I’ve ever seen
Man, you ought to be selling this to a company because this is absolutely astounding.
Volkswagen had this in their Phaeton decades ago 😉
This is incredible!!! I would love to use something like this as some sort of universal control knob for different software. Imagine this being the volume knob for the PC by default but as you open up a particular software you can switch and control certain software features with it. Maybe with an added grid of simple buttons next to it to switch between different things you want to control. I know there are control decks out there for music making, lightroom etc but a knob with tactile feedback of this degree is simply something else. I have pretty much zero experience in electronics or programming/coding but I would definitely put money down on some sort of easy to built kit or pre-assembled product! As long as there are ways to configure it on an app by app basis.
You could also use it to control playback of videos and music. Have it motorized to turn at a steady pace, then the video speeds up / slows down or goes back wards if you adjust the speed or direction, like a DJ controlling a turntable.
@@superfluidity Wow! EXACTLY! What an awesome idea.
Not exactly the same, but Microsoft has the "Surface Dial" which is basically a software defined knob. It changes uses based on the context of the app that it's in. I don't have any hands on experience with it, but from what I've seen, it's pretty neat. So the precedent for its sort of device is there.
If I would say "that's brilliant" it would be terribly inaccurate. This is straight up perfect and I'm also glad you open sourced it!
I'm thinking this could work well with Home Assistant, or as a fancy jog wheel for video editing. Maybe mute and volume control for Zoom calls? What else would be cool?
This would be a next level spacemouse for 3D CAD designing 😱
Or possibilities for an opensourced smart watch with tactile feedback.
Just posted this to the Home Assistant subreddit before seeing this comment. Yes, so much yes! I can envision so many possible uses for this. What an utterly fantastic project. Well done!
Open source Nest-style thermostat perhaps?
Also see my other longer comment, but these would be great for a MIDI controller for audio work!
Since two years i keep coming back to this just to check if i finally can purchase it.
Mister, just finish it and ull be a millionaire.
I'm actually amazed by the number of modes possible. Perfect OS Nest base. Great job!
UA-cam still recommending this to me every 6 months, and every time I watch it and love it. So damn cool
Love the FOSS implementation! You should look up the NODO Inertia Wheels. They're for the film industry and mega expensive, but they have a few extra features that could be fun to implement.
You can adjust the "mass" and the "drag" of each wheel to change it's pretend moment of inertia. I think it's commutating the motor so that it slows down the deceleration.
you could see a demo of what I'm talking about at video _fZKYHZE4mg timestamp 1:40
id love if we started seeing these actually used like everywhere because this is the perfect line between digital and mechanical which giving the best of both worlds and making everyone happy no matter what you prefer
This is wonderful! I hope that some day these become available to purchase. While I do tinker a bit with electronics, I don't think my skills are good enough to do the soldering required for this project.
I have dreamed of this device for so long
One way or another I'm getting these in every room. This is the best implementation of a thermostat/light/scene/volume/fan/everything controller that I've ever seen. I was eying the sonof ns panel with the home assistant custom component. But I'm really tempted to wait for/help with the mentioned revisions and start ordering parts for this.
Same I really want to add this to home assistant and make it like a dashboard
And it can be controlled by 1 knob. A press for mode change
"Controls multiple spaces with one haptic knob" would be cool to see one in action
This is what I'd like in my dream car. Imagine having maybe 2 or 3 knobs like this and being able to program them to do different things - heck, maybe even contextually. Imagine using those knobs to control multi-zone aircon and then switching to a different menu on your infotainment system and using the same knobs to control ambient lighting or select a driving mode. And of course the knob itself tells you what you're controlling, so that would be great for guest passangers.
Now pair that with a couple of programmable buttons with simmilar LCD displays for binary inputs + add ligthing and sound cues to know when you enter a different preset. You get ergonomic and elegant dashboard with PHISICAL controls that can do everything. Say goodbye to touchscreens with no feedback that you can't operate without taking your eyes off the road.
The functionality and flexibility you’ve managed to get out of a DC motor to drive an interface device is actually amazing. This could honestly revolutionize the approach to building any kind of rotary input system since the BOM for the rotation elements is so low.
I’d suggest also considering a knob+surrounding LEDs build if you’re looking to do further experiments with even smaller form factors. LED light intensity/color could be a feedback mechanism as well.
I have seen a similar knob today on a trade fair, but the list price was 800 euro upwards. So glad, that you're version is so much cheaper.
It's great to finally see an open source implementation of this. This is something that I always wanted to do (ever since I saw BMW'S iDrive knob).
I have no idea why this was in my recommended, but this is pretty neat. Open source projects are awesome.
This knob has been in Mercedes cars since like 2015, same functionality too. It's quite amazing that the code for that is opensource, lots of different ideas/products can be made with this thingy alone.
My mind is completely blown away, never have I needed something more than this.
This is so well implemented and built. Amazing stuff. This is definitely going to become a norm for new knobs in general.
Love the samsung watch wheel treatment of the knob. The interface is really good-looking with a lot of functionality
i don't think people realize that this is truly amazing
I never thought I would be so enthralled and impressed about a video literally about a knob
It would be dope if this could be added as a matter device and be used and customized for actions in smartthings. Like managing light brightness or volume on something
The scripting, narration, and demo was even better than the device itself. Thank you and kudos!
As cool as this is I’d love to see an attempt at inertia! Give the wheel a flick and depending on detents and friction the wheel could spin a few revs before slowing to a stop. Video editors have mechanical shuttle jog wheels like this. It’s a gas watching a skilled operator flick them around with high speed and precision.
I was absolutely thinking about the applicability of this for video editing. I guess it can't be both jog and shuttle simultaneously, but it can switch back and forth easily enough, and that's pretty cool all on its own. And hey, if a 2-layer version could be made, then you'd have the full package -- PLUS the ability to make it do various other things, too. Very cool project!
yes indeed and imagine if it had 4 way push so you can spin to a point, pull down to drop cut video to line, push up to delete etc
inertia without mass! great idea!
the mx master mouse 3 has this
The wheel will need to be heavier to effect inertia, but that smooth tactical feedback😭😭🥹🤲🏽❤️❤️
I have ZERO use for this personally, but this is one of the coolest things I've ever seen. Best Knob Ever!
I never knew that I absolutely can't live without such a knob. Well after this video I know my life is incomplete without this glorious device ❤
Not sure why I got this on my recommendations but I sure am glad I did. This is some interesting stuff and I can already A LOT of cool ways to use something like this. Love it.
Didn't realize how much I wanted to do a haptic feedback project! This is pretty exactly up my alley. So many possibilities!!
You basically took stepper motor tech, and put it thru a star trek makover. Very nice work. Thanks for showing us and teaching a bit.
This is what technological advancements should look like, high tech yet natural and satisfactory to the human mind.
Wow, great job, looks super clean! Can see a ton of potential uses for this!
it's like the flic twist but better
Oh hi Lewis, how are you doing
maaaaaaan this is EXACTLY what I was looking for like 2 years ago!! Thanks for this! cant wait to start playing around with it!
I liked the video before it had even started, but now I wish I could like it twice. I was expecting this to be something mildly interesting, but this was incredibly interesting. It's so cool that the haptics and end-stops are all managed by software, and that snapping of the dial is really neat too. I can imagine so many great uses of this system in modern and sleek designs. Great job!
You can like it twice but that would negate it you should like it three times
Use your backup/throwaway Gmail account to view this video ;)
I want this so much. I have no immediate use for it but I want it. There is something absolutely satisfying the way you show it and when you understand what goes into making it, the obsession is even more. Like others have said, this would be a perfect fit for home assistant.
Incredible, please make a video on the internals and how it comes together!
This is brilliant! I've been wetting the bed in my dreams waiting for something like this... Ahem - I was too excited there and jumped the gun with that comment. Though, in all seriousness, this is an amazing project. Already have tons of ideas where I can implement it, and look forward to experimenting. Thank you for open sourcing this project!
that's so cool! I'd love to see more inside on how it works
I have no idea what I would use it for, but I absolutely love the idea and the implementation. One possible solution... an all in one controller for home automation. Changing temperature, lighting, etc... with the knob.
Scott I'm literally losing my mind that I hadn't seen much of your work before now. This is amazing and the fact that you are making it an OS project screams! I don't know where you are located but if you ever want to lean on our workshop for collaborating on something we would be game! I immediately have so many ideas for your rotary knobs and can't wait to make some.
honestly i have watched this atleast 10 times and i love it so freaking much. i wish every rotary input device would be this.
Wow this is insane. Thanks for sharing this. I would like to see a build video too!! 🔥🔥
this is pure genius using a motor to emulate feedback and springs
*With tears in my eyes*
This is the future I was looking forward to.
This is unbelievably fascinating. i was baked asf watching this and thought it was just a cool fidget thing that could change, but man well done this is quite an incredible piece of tech u have made!
I've always wanted to do something like this, but it seemed too far out of reach. You've made this look amazing!
This is 100% going to start popping up everywhere next year.
5 seconds in and I absolutely LOVE THIS! I have worked on a diy project with cheap rotary encoders and the result was garbage. this looks so unbelievably amazing! great job! I would also happily buy one if you decide to sell them!
Holy cow this is amazing. Not often do I get legitimately excited on youtube but today I am EXCITED. Can't wait to dig into this. Thank you for sharing.
This is super cool! I'd love to see an integrated modular product.
I've been looking for something like this literally fucking forever! I'm so glad to see someone finally show off an essentially feature complete version. I'm definitely going to need to build this!
Holy smokes man! This is incredible stuff! I would definitely would love to see an overview of putting together this project. Keep up the great work!!!
This kind of thing should be used in new cars. For whatever reason, more and more manufacturers are deciding that it’s a good idea to force the driver to take their eyes off the road just to do something simple like change the radio station or turn on the AC, by using a touchscreen rather than physical controls.
Technology like this however, could make use of both sides. Since everything is software controlled, the same knob could be used for different things in different situations. And since the knob is still physical rather than just a touch screen, the driver can keep their eyes on the road while using it.
Wow! I could see this making a HUGE impact on Amateur Radio imagine being able to setup the main rotary encoder (VFO knob) to your exact requirements of feedback on CW/SSB but also then it automatically select itself to Detent mode for FM/AM use! Then if you had a radio with a Menu system of settings it would be useful for that too. How long before someone uses one in a uBITX HF kit ? 😁#KD8CEC #uBITX
You can be the one!
Wow, that's a really nice idea!
or even using several of these encoders on an advanced rig not just for the vfo but also for clarifier, af&rf gain, if shift/width, DSP control and then dynamically change them to rf power/drive, mic gain/compression/eq, CW keyer speed when going tx or adapt knob usage depending on the selected mode. That would cut down fiddling with the menu during the QSO and get rigs closer to a full hardware control like with dials and knobs on classic analog rigs. Modern rigs, albeit with better performance, became a bit cumbersome to operate compared to the old ft-902dm or ts-830s
All that work just so you could say knob. I admire your persistence. Seriously thought very very cool, thank you!
Very inspiring! I've been working on a musical instrument controller based off a Teensy and a AS5601, along with some haptic feedback. Really love the addition of the motor and display here. Curious how "smooth" the motor feels when just spinning/rotating it. Ordered a few off Aliexpress to have a play with.
This motor is basically completely smooth when unpowered, which is relatively rare - I've ordered and tried a LOT of different motors from AliExpress and most have noticeable cogging.
@@scottbez1 Fantastic! For my controller I put a fair amount of time into getting really smooth skate bearings, and some offset weights (ala fidget spinner) so it tends to skate along quite smoothly on its own. I look forward to it arriving and playing with it. I've not dug that deep in Teensy-land (motor drivers), but the interface options are pretty staggering.
Scott, you don’t even realize that you are pure genius.
Love this project! Immediately I want to take a bunch of these in a grid and make a software configurable MIDI controller!
Is the size arbitrary or does it need to be that big due to all the parts? For a MIDI controller, half or quarter size would probably be perfect assuming screens are available, but even a grid of full size knobs would be cool.
I could also see a use case in controlling custom stage lighting effects and other music-tangential use cases!
I was just looking up micro brushless motors for a midi controller like this when I came across this video haha. I think the key to making it small enough would be a different screen layout (or getting rid of it entirely). I was thinking maybe one screen with a bunch of knobs and each knob just has an led ring to indicate position and notches, then the screen could show actual values.
I second this. Being able to configure if a thing is a knob or endless encoder depending on context is probably next generation of midi-controller hardware.
It looks like majority of the hardware he's got physically inside the knob, but it doesn't have to be that way. If the depth of the device isn't as important, there's no reason you couldn't pack all the hardware further back into the enclosure and just have the knob extending out into the front. Getting the screen functional with that setup would be the only challenge.
I just saw the Xmas switch and this...brilliant. I am going to go through the video and see what else I can marvel at and realize how far away I am from being able to do.
For the first time, I like a project where a round screen is used. I used to think, why is it released? Are people going to make homemade watches? What kind of clock will be cumbersome and slow? And in this project everything is perfectly balanced. The idea is great. I want such a device))
I won't have the know-how to build this, but want to thank you for sharing such a cool design.
this is something that's so specific but really cool for no reason
I absolutely need to make this because this is not only a functional knob that could be put to good use but it would also be an amazing fidget toy
First thought - This would improve the Nest thermostats UI significantly.
Awesome project - thanks for open-sourcing it. Subscribed.
I don't know if this has been mentioned before, but if you can find a 2013 or so Lexus CT200h it needs to have the little square joystick on the console. It uses something similar to this for its menus. The joystick has "detents" depending on what screen you are on and only allows the joystick to move to those spots or full freedom of movement. I have always tried to explain this to people when I owned one, but never knew what to call it until I could show them in person. I always geeked out about it and it was one of my favorite unique features of that car.
One of those items where you cant immediately think of a place/use/purpose for it, but you know someone out there will love it. I can see it being used in the AV / Production Studio / Sound Recording world.
this has a lot of potential
just on top of my head i could see it being used in cars!
imagine 1 knob that could adjust anything from AC, heated seats, etc
as well as home in stove or something
I cannot stand how much I genuinely need this kind of thing on my desk. The detail is so wonderful 🤤
holy crap dude this is genius, thanks so much for making it open source, thats awesome
This is actually so cool! I can see this as a great project when integrated with home-assistant devices.
That's so gosh damn cool. A standing ovation to you Sir.
Crazy nice.
The fact that this is open source is amazing
One word, Awesome!
First thought: mini turntables! You've got the needed precision and a motor. With some open source dj software (or customizable midi inputs) this is totally doable!
over 35 years ago (precisely in 1989) Canon released two camera lenses - the 85mm f/1.2 and 50mm f/1.0 that had the electronic coupling between the focus control ring and the motor and oh boy... it's so satisfyingly accurate! it feels like the ring is really physically connected but it's not. I only know that they are using the ultrasonic motor, I think it is still the pinnacle of the encoder+motor engineering. I mean, they did it in 1989, and we are coming closer only now...