India's Reservation Bill for Women: All You Need to Know | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 вер 2023
- India's Reservation Bill for Women: All You Need to Know | Vantage with Palki Sharma
The Indian government has introduced the long-delayed women's reservation bill in the Lok Sabha on the first day of proceedings in the new House of Parliament.
The bill seeks to reserve one-third of seats in the Lok Sabha and state assemblies for women. Palki Sharma explains how the reservation will work.
---
India | Reservation Bill | House of Parliament | Women | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#reservationbill #india #houseofparliament #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
#Firstpost2Million: Thank you viewers for your trust! Leave a comment and let us know what more would you like to see on the channel.
Godi media ! 😂🤣🤣💯
Add subtitles in English please❤
Finally, India might be the second country in South Asia to have 33% seat reserved for women, but if used to only elect the wives and relatives of powerful men leader then it won't make a difference.
Truth of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Death needs to be brought out.
Palki Sharma and you are the problem.
Never let already elected members’ wives any chance to stand for elections. That would really be the justice to “other” women.
Very well said.
Nice throught bro. I was just wondering if the wife has a better leadership quality and strong governance than her husband, who was placed there. Shouldn't we support her?.
Let's forget about Sonia.
Isn't it injustice to them ? Btw you need to broaden your perspective about it . Elections aren't done without money no matter what laws or reservation is made unless their is big money involved these effects can't truly benefit. And reservation isn't the only way to empower women. It'll bring more demerits than merits
Wait another 10 years or so
@@Shivamkumar-oy4zmexplain how it brings more demerits to women than mertis
Reservations always backfire. It only works when it is extremely targeted, specified and time limited. Whether it is for race, religion, educational status, gender, age or anything else, it is the same.
Yes implementation is certainly an issue
If the basis of the argument is to equalize women in fields where 90% are male, such as politics and engineering, then what about fields where 90% are female, like doctors and caretakers? Would they also like to provide quotas for men?
What about hazardous chemical factories where 98% are male? Would they like to equalize that?
What about brick factories? Would they like to equalize those?
Seats should be given based on meritocracy and competence, not on the basis of quotas.
I think the dark age of democracy is just started now .
The Dangerous game of Equity that BJP is playing gonna have severe Consiqunces . BJP is now under Marxist Hand .
@@hwhahab8if women do as good of a job, they'd be elected irrespective of their gender by the public, no need to put a quota in all fields
@@mrnobody9473 exactly these days even peoples are voting for Transgenders.....But however My vote is my personal choice, whether I am going to vote for women, men, or transgender . No state should be telling me which one should i vote and how should i vote .
Then y put quota in somefields . I'm not against this . I have simple question . Tell me is experience and merit is important or the things that we in toilet is important . I still don't get the idea of quotas . Don't worry I'm not OC I'm a BC but I scraped my quota and write exams as other with out using my certificate .
It should have been.
20% for Educated
20% for Youth under 35
20% for women
20% for men
20% for Old people
Hopefully this truly helps India and does not become another tool for politicians to insert incompetent leaders in the name of Vote like they have done with the cast based reservation.
Pratibha Patil.... classic example 😅
That really haunts me as well
Hope for the worst.
My Experience says that when it comes to India, apply "Murphy's Law". That is, Whatever can happen will happen.
It will become that only .After 5 years, our feku will implement Igbt reservations too .Esko vote de k gaIti kr diya ,pasmanda appeasement or Igbt yehi sab krta rehta ha ye bhutni waIa .Delhi is full of Bangladeshi and Rohingyas, ye unko bhi reservations de dega or blame krega baad me Khujliwal ko .
On a side note, Mamta Banerjee does not really inspire confidence. I am cautiously hopeful.
Not everyone will be like that mumta sh1t
Here it's nothing to do with gender, Only Best should be appointed whether it's male or female .
Their job is to represent the interest of the population though…
Most andhbhakts in the comments won't understand this... 🙁
A country where lack of money still asks the girls to opt out of education we are very far from the fallacy you mentioned
Representation? That's what voting is for. Ideally, anyone capable should have a shot at representing their society if such is their aspiration. That's basic democracy. But reality is flawed so you need these flawed bills to negate that and do some balancing
@@calvinhoward3808If the basis of the argument is to equalize women in fields where 90% are male, such as politics and engineering, then what about fields where 90% are female, like doctors and caretakers? Would they also like to provide quotas for men?
What about hazardous chemical factories where 98% are male? Would they like to equalize that?
What about brick factories? Would they like to equalize those?
Seats should be given based on meritocracy and competence, not on the basis of quotas.
I think the dark age of democracy is just started now .
The Dangerous game of Equity that BJP is playing gonna have severe Consiqunces . BJP is now under Marxist Hand .
Yes one state has a unique CM .. unique in many ways!! God save India if this reservation brings this kind of leader
Which state
i think he is talking about bihar
@@meghanath5045bengal
@@samriddhidutta9016lol it's about didi. She has totally dumped the state of WB.
Tamilnadu had Jayalalitha too. It has one of the best indices in so many areas.
As a general category middle class male from UP(state quota doesn't work here) :-
I demand that govt should introduce 100% reservation, so that people like us at least have better clarity of what to do next.
Yes, I i agree
100% means removing it
@@sagarupadhyay6925 100% to SC ST and BC and no seats for general.
@@unknown.m.eyeah that's good idea
Haha
This is one decision I disagree with. Unlike the West, India has always had proactive women representation in govt, right to the top level. The candidate's merit must be the only criterion for any position. Creating such divisions based on gender, caste, religion etc. creates more polarization than unity. You need only look to the West or even our own history with reservations to see how such divisions can fracture society.
While you make valid points hope eventually we get the parliament you just described, but the fact of the matter is that the representation of women is abysmally low event after 75 years. Considering they form nearly 50 of the population. Should this status quo continue for the next 100 years? Regarding merit, just look at the MPs in parliament. How many of them are on merit. So many became MP on money power, family name etc.
@@stand4reasonwhy should there be 50% women representation in Parliament? Is this the kind of democracy I'm living in? Where's the meritocracy? FK this this is not the country I want to live in!
@@stand4reason there is one thing about people not coming in on merit because of circumstances, which need to be fixed, quite another when you make it a law. BTW, there is NEVER 100% representation of any particular community according to their population. That is an organic process. That was my point about the West, where now you have people clamoring for public office simply because they are LGBTQ+. India may not have had the representation, but we have proven that the doors to power are not closed to women. Our most powerful PM in history was a woman, and so are some of our most potent state-level leaders. Our current President is a woman. The solution to better representation is to encourage women's leadership and education. Passing such laws has never worked in favor of any community in history and has only sown divide. In a way, you are dictating to the people of the country who they can elect as a representative to parliament for them. This is antithetical to freedom of self-determinism.
@@Kushagra.j no not 50 percent. But solution need to be found to encourage women participation in the Lol, Rajya, and vidhan sabhas.
@@stand4reason potential solutions can be to reserve few seats at local level and lower or mid rank post and after that for higher ones it should be completely on merits . Open for all
33℅ women reservation in construction jobs
😂😂😂😂
oh lord
Bilkul sahi
The ideal would be giving girls equal tools to be the best, and then hiring the best. Reservation systems make for cases where you're not hiring the best necessarily.
Agree.
I'm a woman and I completely agree.
@@vishakhabh.6341 Of course, it's not male vs female, it's sensible and equal for all! Quotas just mean our country may not always appoint the best person for the job
I think this was done in regard with defection from parties in a hope women won't defect.
reservation in politics will not going to bring equallity but it will give upper hand to those who have reservations,as they can contest for every consecutive term, however those don't have reservation will unable to contest for consecutive term.it's not job that you can apply from anywhere on the basis of merit, it's election you have to contest from same constituency.
So,if one candidate going to contest for every consecutive election & another candidate going to contest periodically.
Then, obviously the who can contest consecutively going to get upper hand to influence people. and people too going to choose that candidate for consistency & political stability.
BJP should rather lead as example giving minimum 33% of their seats to women instead of making reservations laws cause history has taught us it just helps politicians but destroys nation
I think they already do, or close
@@AG-lz2gg Nope, they don't. If they did there was no need was this law as BJP is the biggest political party in the country and all other political parties would need to match it
@@kashyapkashyap6890 There is nothing I would like more than to end reservation everywhere be it for gender or caste but everyone loves it and demands special rights in name of Equality. There is no end in sight for this, the only probable solution seems to provide reservation to each and everyone
@@kashyapkashyap6890 This won't work because there is reservation for almost 70% of India's population, so who's getting benefit won't call out to other obviously and when you call it out you will be labelled Anti-SC/ST, Anti-women, against minorities and so on. People have been calling it out since ages but when masses support Evil for so long it ceases to be evil for society. If you will recall there have been many cases of mass protests, petition and students setting themselves on fire but nothing worked cause politicians won't even utter a word against it cause unreserved category is less than 30% population why would they go against majority of the population for it
India should not start to practice woke culture as Western countries are doing. There should be equality of opportunity not equality in outcome. If this bill is introduced, there would also be a demand for reservations from SC, ST, and OBC communities. And the parliament would be filled with incompetent members.
Reservation is one of the worst things that happened in India(and many other countries like USA). I hope the government do some meticulous planning behind this and not just put brute numbers like 33% reserved for women and rest can be competed.
What do you expect? How thoughtful have they been?
Any better alternative to reservation,which can ensure the social, economic and political participation of marginalised sections? So that it does not widen the persisting inequality more.
@@Rohan_Kumar___ i think we should not do reservation example would u like to get treated from a doc who is topper and deserve to be theree or from a doc who just manage to get there because of reservation choose on the basics of creadibilty nor gender or caste otherwise then it will simply lead to destructiom
@@Rohan_Kumar___ I feel the communities need political representation and not physical representation. In most of the cases, women political leaders goes to women and preach feminism when they need votes, and forget otherwise. Same with other marginalised SC, ST leaders. The only representation these places need is the representation of ideas, and not types of humans. That’s what I feel. If you ask me, there should be some kind of suggestion websites where you put in the ideas that you want your government to be discussing. There should be a voting system on what is supposed to be discussed. Is this a perfect idea? No, it can be explored more. But it’s certainly 10 times better then reservation.
@@jec_ecart tbh, I’m not expecting much. 2024 elections are close and if this bill passes before that, a huge vote bank Awaits them. 🤷🏻♂️
If you question time timing of all this it makes sense.
We want 30% youth representation.
Will not work in higher levels in Politics. (from MLA and above)
Once a person gain experience at lower levels such as Panchayaths or Party leadership and becomes atleast a MLA..He/she is not considered as Youth anymore..
Unless he is Rahul Gandhi.
@drarunaj According to khangress spokespersons Rahul Gandhi became matured now a person became matured at the age 56 years we all should appreciate Sonia bar dancer for giving her son 55 years to become mature tho kaam Kab karega chutiya 😂😂😂😂
@@drarunaj😂😂😂
@@drarunajhaha 🤣
not the drug addicts please
As a women ...i vehemently oppose this reservation... we can have a preference but reservation based on simply gender sets the wrong precedent...
Very few people vote for women when there are male candidates. This is a good thing. Women are less corrupt, are hard working, and a good number are more honest than men, and these are all traits that we need. You're a prime example of women being the worst enemies to other women. Shame on you, madam.
Thanks you and need more like you rather than a spineless populace which asks for gender , race , caste based reservatiom becuase they dont want to work for it.
I dont hate BJP but their appeasement politics often gets in the way of Meritocracy. I am astonished seeing little to no opposition to this though
That's called being woke
I will vote for someone based on their ability to govern, ability to do the job not based on their reservation status, I don't care if it's man, woman or even a statue, but governing requires the best in their field.
Reservation system has been the bane of India when people are chosen by their identity than by their ability such a country would have the most incompetent governing the country thus making India what it is today.
The only solution is to leave india. I'm going to go to dubai if this keeps happening. Reservation for all kinds of people be it women, sc/St, muslims, LGBTQ, etc when in reality all these groups have done nothing but been a burden on our country and held us back. I'm not giving any govt my tax rupees who engage in this degeneracy
Your condition will be worse in Dubai. You would be less than secondary citizen coz u can't be their citizen. Women have even lesser role/participation in civil duties.
@@Kushagra.j you can't settle in Dubai, you will return back to India anyway, next, groups don't keep us back as you could find capable people in any group, but putting reservation system doesn't get the most able in position, it keeps the most incompetent in position. Anyway a good amount of your tax rupees is going straight to those same incompetent politicians pockets.
@@hilander2909 Reminds me of an Indian friend when he was a student, who was on a transfer flight through Dubai, his flight got delayed due to weather, and he couldn't catch his transfer flight, so they gave 1 day visa to everyone except him and was in airport and very angry on the Dubai government, he returned back to India, wrote letters to Dubai government to ask for this explanation, got no reply from them.
Later he is working in a senior position in a company and he got to hire people into the company, found one of the recruits he had to interview is a UAE national, he told the recruit you are not qualified for this job, despite having all qualifications and told him to leave. I hope we have more Indians like this how have standard and respect and he told me directly that he will never work with someone who shows no respect.
@@Kushagra.jdubai itself is a islamic country and you guys hate muslims lol😂
Make 33% in army & BSF in the name of equality also😂
Bro also include this professions
01 Power Lineman
02 Lumberjack
03 Bridge Building/Painting/Repair
04 High Rise Window Washer
05 Deep Sea Welder
06 Sewer Worker
07 A/C Installation/Repair
08 Auto Repair
09 Plumber
10 Electrician
11 Land Surveyor
12 Brick Layer
13 Road Building/Paving/Repair
14 Roofer
15 Landscaper
16 Quarry Worker
17 Stone Mason
18 Uber/Lyfte/Cab Driver
19 Trash Truck Driver
20 Heavy Equipment Operator
21 Fishing Boat/Trawler Worker
22 Window Installation/Repair
23 Furniture/Appliance Delivery
24 Heating Installation/Repair
25 Swimming Pool Building/Installation/Repair
26 Cable TV Installation/Repair
As a woman i agree, pls do so, bcq i felt really bad when i wanted to know the requirements to apply for a military position and saw "men only" above everything
@@kerorikun8910 yeah, definitely we need more women to repair tyre punctures🤣
Why are these women quotas not implemented in military combat roles? Why is it always in high paying white collar jobs and positions of power?
Surprise! They were even denied the permanent commission in armed forces, for which they faught and eventually SC had to intervene and grant them the permanent commision. So the women wants participation in armed forces too.
Because feminism doesn't want equality. Feminism wants power.
history has witnessed how the world burnt when women or weaker men are given the charge or to lead,civilisations destroyed and wars fought with unprecedented destruction,…and u say better country? Give women equal opportunity yes but reservation? …Give women platform ,encourage women,provide other assistance to negate difficulties but staraight away giving someone what they aren’t capable of or not deserving?ex-pratibha pail,Indira Gandhi.etc..like Indira Gandhi gifted an island for free to srilanka without any consideration,this island was essential for strategic and economic stance,ppl in south go these sores for its richness in fishing,but it was gifted,just like this there is many more…Aren’t we reinforcing this idea of discrimination ,caste system and gender biasness by these? Instead of doing the right thing,we taking this easy way out simply to please certain groups and …procure politicians get all the votes in their bank bcoz its evident how in local elections,women act as a puppet to their husband
@@prameshsahu1957 Some examples of women being disastrous throughout history? Since I can give you examples of Rani Laxmibai, Sarojini Naidu, usha mehta, pritilata wadeyar, kalpana dutt, sushma swaraj ma'am etc. And if you consider Indira Gandhi as disastrous then what about Nehru, he was a man and you must be knowing what he has done in terms of china, unsc seat, kashmir.( Although I may not subscribe to your opinion on Nehru). So it's not about gender but individuals. Don't pick women categorically because there are successful women also.
@@prameshsahu1957do not put weak men and women under the same bracket. women are much stronger than you give credit for. Equating weak men to women itself says why we even need some reservation for them
Reservation for minorities is juastifiable but reservation for women when they have sizeable population and also enjoying all rights and living a independent life proudly in democratic india is just feels wrong if it's about equality then tomorrow in the name equality transgender,gay, lesbian,person with disability,youths,old age groups, etc this all will also want reservation for their representatives then what parliament will run on reservation with no proper competition in election
Reservation for anyone is unjustified. 100% open field best candidates will win out. Those who cry that we're underprivileged and come from difficult background; well that's your fault and your problem. Should have done better deeds in past lives so that you don't get put in an unfortunate situation.
they want empowerment along with reservations too. which is nothing but god level privilege.
history has witnessed how the world burnt when women or weaker men are given the charge or to lead,civilisations destroyed and wars fought with unprecedented destruction,…and u say better country? Give women equal opportunity yes but reservation? …Give women platform ,encourage women,provide other assistance to negate difficulties but staraight away giving someone what they aren’t capable of or not deserving?ex-pratibha pail,Indira Gandhi.etc..like Indira Gandhi gifted an island for free to srilanka without any consideration,this island was essential for strategic and economic stance,ppl in south go these sores for its richness in fishing,but it was gifted,just like this there is many more…Aren’t we reinforcing this idea of discrimination ,caste system and gender biasness by these? Instead of doing the right thing,we taking this easy way out simply to please certain groups and …procure politicians get all the votes in their bank bcoz its evident how in local elections,women act as a puppet to their husband
I think there already is reservation for person with disability, old ppl(as ex salarymen), and talks about reservation for transgender
1/3 rd is a big number.. 1 in 5 seats should be reserved. rest 4 seats must be fought competetively.
True.
1/3 is not a big number. Women represent half of the country, we should have 50% seats reserved for women, because it will force all parties to empower and send women candidates.
@@user-xk7ms8rf7c Please learn to write in English, your comment doesn't make any sense.
@@grimoirehe4rtuneducated girl
Fight on merit
Deserved candidate>>> reservated candidate
Sharam nahi aati ham 50% hain toah hame 50% reservation dedo
Reservation weak ko diya jata hain aur mahila weak hain iss liye unhe diya hain aur ye bass 15 saal tak hi rahega baat main hat jaayeg
As you can see, no one said
"women are strong and independent as well as capable of handling their own life."
The only category left now that no one cares about and are open for exploitation is 'Young General class Males (especially Engineers) with Indian citizenship'😅.
Hopefully all other types of reservations other than the one mentioned in this video's title get abolished, otherwise inequality, even though is very minimal currently compared to other countries, will increase at a ridiculous pace. Equality will become even more idealistic.
We have to revolt. Take power back from these weird people
@@Kushagra.j Revolt ? No, thanks.
We can just let our government know, through proper medium, what we think would be best for our society as a whole, and hope that they implement that change.
Stop voting on party basis rather vote for your interests
@@Kushagra.j I agree with all your comments brother. The reason why punjabs cm is a jat sikh when majority of the population is not even a jat sikh is because they do riots like khalistan and violent threats. Its been decades and only jat sikh can be cm of punjab.
@@JuneTempest You are what we call a chutiya just hope that other people will do everything for you. Your vote is not going to be heard only 30% of the population is general even less of them are males your a very small vote bank whose vote doesn't matter to the politicians. Wake up and face reality
The one ugly side effect of this policy is those elected women were just a puppet of their husbend.
This is happening in my locality 2 time elected local leader can not fight for 3rd time coz the seat got reserved for woman only and then he made his wife his proxy and she was just a face he faught again and won again and the wife is just a figure head even in the office he sits and his wife name is used .
Totally agree. Even in my village there is a women mukhiya and women sarpanch but all the decisions, meetings, panchayat sessions are conducted by their husband. The real representative is just there to sign the documents.
So true You speak my mind .
35% QUOTA FOR WOMAN IN BSF
Lets go for it. Also in menial jobs.
Women's reservation in important given the disparity in seats but we Indian citizens also need a Commission for Men. A bill like this should be passed by the Parliament.
Very unlikely cause we the men find our ego to be bigger than our problems and don't speak up nor do we support other men who do cause its not manly
Gender neutral laws should be the first priority.
संसद मे महिलाओ की संख्या ज्यादा होगी तो पुरुष विरोधी कानून और आसानी से पास होंगे।
जेंडर न्यूट्ल कानून तो भूल जाओ।
Bhen, no type of reservation is important. Everything must be based on merit and talent must be respected otherwise our India will remain a 3rd word nation with no innovation and nothing.
@@mohitdhanwani6431🤡
In India merit takes the back seat for every important policy or decision.
If this isn't stopped, with farsightedness, it would create a Frankenstein in coming days
It already has!!
The Monster haven't woken up yet
why must we add reservation? its gonna decrease the efficiency of our legislative body. While encouraging women to enter politics is good, adding reservation is not gonna yield the outcomes we'd want. Meritocracy must be maintained in such high office.
Do you think men are meritorious? ?? Why do you think they can find meritorious women.
Its already working well in Odisha.
And who told you meritocracy would be compromised? What explains the gender inequality in india ( 127th rank out of 146 countries)?
The reservation is there to provide them a level playing field against their male counterparts. The political parties doesn't even give them the seat tickets to contest election through which they can show their merits.
@@I09862p we are not saying only men are meritorious, we are saying whoever is capable of becoming leader should get chance, .
reservation is a disease.
@@Rohan_Kumar___ they can fight as independent candidates, .
@ipsitadas-yk7qh Historically speaking yes, men have proven to be meritorious. If you spout corruption/nepotism, it's not a monopoly held by men. People in position of power might abuse it, if it so happens to be a man doesn't prove anything. Women also misuse their powers. As long as women fight election via party or independently and win, then there should be no problem. If you want to create quotas, make it compulsory for parties to put forward 30% women candidates for the election, but don't create a direct quota in the parliament itself. That doesn't help with growth of the nation. It will most likely be abused to put sub par candidates into the post and worsen our legislative bodies.
I think we should stop giving reservations .
If people want to choose women leaders, they would simply can choose, .
If anyone truly want equality of opportunity then we should stop giving reservations to anyone.
If that's the case we will never get gender equality.
This reservation system will keep going on in our country as long as selfish people will keep on making most of the benefits out of it.
It's not possible in a country like india where every political party has its own vote base
Agree 💯
MODI ISN'T MODI OF 2024 ANYMORE HE IS SOFT NOW WE NEED STRONGER LEADER NOW I HOPE MODI DOESN'T GO FOR THE POLLS IN 2024 BECAUSE I WILL NOT VOTE FOR HIM OR ANYONE ELSE
But the political parties don't even give them the tickets in first place. That's the issue this bill tries to address.
Wrong bill
No reservation plz
Correct discrimination with more discrimination. Wow! RIP Logic
But why ??? Already its favoring women and its bill is an addition!!!!!
and also make reservations in this professions
01 Powerlineman
02 Lumberjack
03 Bridge Building/Painting/Repair
04 High Rise Window Washer
05 Deep Sea Welder
06 Sewer Worker
07 A/C Installation/Repair
08 Auto Repair
09 Plumber
10 Electrician
11 Land Surveyor
12 Brick Layer
13 Road Building/Paving/Repair
14 Roofer
15 Landscaper
16 Quarry Worker
17 Stone Mason
18 Uber/Lyfte/Cab Driver
19 Trash Truck Driver
20 Heavy Equipment Operator
21 Fishing Boat/Trawler Worker
22 Window Installation/Repair
23 Furniture/Appliance Delivery
24 Heating Installation/Repair
25 Swimming Pool Building/Installation/Repair
26 Cable TV Installation/Repair
Those are not government ventures. Lmfao
@@Sailed_away That has got nothing to do with the point. If you want 1/3rd reservation, have it everywhere
@@narendrajade5086what we can do about this bro... Go and tell Modi ji
@@atreyeedasgupta8782 You are right. We can't do anything about it, the same way we couldn't do anything about removing caste based reservation. Petrol prices might go down one day but reservation is not going down just up.
The women already were rejected when they literally asked for commision in the army. They actually wanted to serve and die for their country and were rejected
Thanks palki ji... For summing it up for us...
Who is stopping a women in india to become key decision makers? All the laws favour mostly the women and so if a woman contest election and wins then she will be in the parliament so y this reservation bill needed I don't know, its vote bank politics
Equality and 33% doesn't go hand in hand.. does it?
It's not 33% ... it's atleast 33%... in other 67%, anyone can come... so it's reasonable to assume that about 17% among those 67% seats will also be won by women...
@@RajivKumar-xp9qn I did not know that.. can you explain in detail or share some source where I can understand this better..
Greatest programme
Can anyone explain why in central medical institutes like aiims, 80% of nursing staff positions are reserved for women???
It's not.... it's just more women enter in this field
It's the other way around, if it's not curbed at 80% it will become 100% women in nursing.
@user_suwjhwhqjakoaoq reservation doesn't mean that women representation cant be more than 80%. It means that it has to be atleast 80%, irrespective of any other factor. Personally, i know many dedicated hard-working male nursing staff. There is no reason to penalise them like this. If at all reservation is needed, 50% should be enough.
@aadyadubey379 it is. Its an actual rule by central government. Currently being applied.
@@kashyapkashyap6890why not 💯 women they know it's not possible. I don't know why sexist bill are considered as gender neutral
Hopefully it works.Because at local level mostly elected women work as a puppet of their husband.
MODI IS SOFT NOW INDIA NEED STRONG LEADER WHICH IS NOT MODI
@@user-go7yi8ye7jSource- Come to my village bro..
In my village both mukhiya and sarpanch are women but it's their husband who takes all the decisions and those so called women representatives are working like any other housewife.
That means those women aren't capable or can't be in power without husband . So whats the point in holding those positions?
@@user-go7yi8ye7jcome to faridabad bro will show you the same in civil body and mla working here same is happening
@@Rohan_Kumar___+1
- It startles me when feminists applaud the inclusion of reservation for women in all the white collar positions and also demand for equal pay and equal rights in competitive roles (they already have all the laws in favor). Already there are unspoken quotas for women in the selection criteria to balance diversity, nobody talks about them.
- I understand that every country is male dominated and these kind of reservations help women to climb up the ladder. But why do these pseudo feminists show hatred towards men in competitive fields.
- It won't be a surprise if women are given reservation even in IT companies (that too only for managerial roles. lol).
- None of the politicians in India are inspirational, but now I predict more incompetent people will be given a chance because of these reservations. Ultimately, people who work responsibly will suffer and face more work pressure while the others infiltrate based on quotas. GREAT!!
what an amazing expressing power
never let feel boring.
smooth and fluent in English
I hate the concept of reservation 🥴
You should equally hate the hundreds of years of atrocities & discrimination against the vulnerable community which has led to their social, economic & educational backwardness, for which the reservation was brought.
This reservation of constituency should be in rotation basis.. Every constituency should get a WOMEN MP & MLA once in 15 year...
Otherwise 1 area ppl cant elect a male mp even if they r extremely competent...
this is already in play for Pradhan elections(Gram Pradhan ). but in my personal opinion that is less effective.
If the basis of the argument is to equalize women in fields where 90% are male, such as politics and engineering, then what about fields where 90% are female, like doctors and caretakers? Would they also like to provide quotas for men?
What about hazardous chemical factories where 98% are male? Would they like to equalize that?
What about brick factories? Would they like to equalize those?
Seats should be given based on meritocracy and competence, not on the basis of quotas.
I think the dark age of democracy is just started now .
The Dangerous game of Equity that BJP is playing gonna have severe Consiqunces . BJP is now under Marxist Hand .
Its gonna bite India in the long run.
@@dutybound5079 Exactly ! What if tomorrow transgenders come up and say they are not properly represented in parliament? What if tomorrow religions like Buddhism, Jainism, Islam, and Christianity come up and say they are not properly represented in parliament? What if castes like Rajput, Brahmin, Kayastha, etc., come up and say they are not properly represented in parliament? What govt gonna do about that?
I'm very shock to see that no media said anything about this bill in a critical way . They're totally biased towards This government .
@@hwhahab8 this is a slippery slope and India will be fkd. Its a shame that India doesn't have a capable opposition.
And no one in this world is gonna speak against women or feminism in official capacity. So wait for a masculine force to tear up the feminine hypocrisy and decimate the so-called civilized world. This has happened throughout history and this will happen again for sure, if we continued down this path. Europe is facing this force in some capacity. India will face it too.
@@hwhahab8iss kuredaan se bhaago
@@hwhahab8in salo se satta kheech lo 🤬🤬🤬 general wale ke liye bardasht se bahar hai... reservation caste ke base PE nahi individual ki condition ke base par milna chahiye...
Nicely explained 👌 👏 👍
Hope this would lead to more participation of women in politics, rathering than just being a tool for political mileage.
Quota/Reservation based on sex , religion, caste is not good for the country.
Maybe in the current context , it may make sense , later it will be written in stone and no government can go back .
The government should give a fair chance to the hardworking and the talented.
Not to demean our Indian women/Men - degradation of the core values and ethics .
This can put the wrong people on the top .
So discrimination based on sex, religion & caste good for the country? What does explain the huge gender inequality in india ( rank 127th out of 146th countries)? What does explain the social, economic & educational backwardness of lower castes in india?
Reservation is there to provide them a level playing field which they were denied for hundreds of years based on sex & caste.
@@Rohan_Kumar___yes. I don't care
@@Rohan_Kumar___reservation doesn't help its core problem you need to change the condition rather than system. Trying to achieve equality in the name of decrement in quality of system. Quota has no value over merit it affects the smooth functioning other steps should be taken to achieve equality
@@ayushmishra9450 The reservation is there to change the conditions only, which are discriminatory towards vulnerable sections like women, lower castes etc. As it is said “If development is not engendered, it is endangered”. So providing equality to women does not compromise meritocracy.
It's gonna be another reason for men to not participate in politics and later revolt against the gynocentric order.
I loved how she subtly put it as Wuhan virus pandemic instead of COVID... So cheeky😊
God bless India.
Very good decision
Facts about women empowerment in India
Bhartiya women ( in percentage terms)
-Population---48.5%
-Army -03%
-Navy -06%
-AirForce-13%
-Parliament-15%
-workforce-27%
Youth literacy (15 to24 years)gender ration 101%women to Men
Bharat needs to work on ecosystems on ground than pass legislations.
Parliament is also a kind of ecosystem. Bharat needs to work on ecosystems along with passing this bill.
Do you understand the difference between "Top Down" and "Bottom Up" approach?
MODI IS DESTROYING INDIA'S FUTURE WITH THIS BILL
Dude you want women in combat military , if assholes of Pakistan hold them you know what they do to Kashmir war gouge out eye of Khalia & mutilated. That very risky business
Now compare this with America...... No country has 10% women in defense Forces 2:51
Hopefully this truly helps India and does not become another tool for Politicians to insert incompetent leaders in the name of vote like they have done with the cast based reservation.
It's politics, it inevitable it will degrade into a tool for the political leaders wife's and daughters to get into the Lok saba
I am a woman but I oppose this. The prime importance should always be given to INDIA. Reserved candidates are not that meritorious, WE NEED DESERVED ONES NOT RESERVED ONES.
The last Line hits out ''the new ERA for the Indian Democracy'' ✌🏻
It's good, but how do we make sure their husband's do all their work. Happened in the past.
Eligibility to work independently is most important and such leaders must be selected by all parties. Not just simply supporting the bill. ❤
Hope it will be ensured that people do not abuse this along with other reservations.
Yes woman sjpuld be giben reservation
Palki SHARMA my favorite news reader, thanks Mam
But, will Modi led Govt announce it's next PM candidate as Nirmala Sitaraman?
😊😊😊
Unfortunate day for India. There is should be equality of opportunity not
equality of outcome.
india cannot have new constituencies until 2025 due to a bill in 1980s
Yes, this was a need
Great job🎉
What a great initiative...women empowerment...if one woman is empowered with power and position, she will uplift ten others of her kind.
If she is capable of doing things, reservation doesn't help her in anyway!! She can do it without the reservation as well.. I am not just saying about women reservation, in fact there should be no reservation at all.. That doesn't help country to grow.
Uh
@@rameshsingamsetti9690 right
@@rameshsingamsetti9690unless we see the changes on ground these opinions are fallacy
@@rameshsingamsetti9690Don't you think a non-discriminatory society is a prerequisite to reservation less society. The USA is not going to remove affirmative actions unless there is no racial decriminalization against the blacks nor the indian government until and unless there is caste based discrimination
Isn't the local reservation enough empowerment? Why to reserve top position if the candidate has potential and has done great at local level she should make her way to top depending on her competency. These reservations will promote incompetent.
but this will encourage women like me
history has witnessed how the world burnt when women or weaker men are given the charge or to lead,civilisations destroyed and wars fought with unprecedented destruction,…and u say better country? Give women equal opportunity yes but reservation? …Give women platform ,encourage women,provide other assistance to negate difficulties but staraight away giving someone what they aren’t capable of or not deserving?ex-pratibha pail,Indira Gandhi.etc..like Indira Gandhi gifted an island for free to srilanka without any consideration,this island was essential for strategic and economic stance,ppl in south go these sores for its richness in fishing,but it was gifted,just like this there is many more…Aren’t we reinforcing this idea of discrimination ,caste system and gender biasness by these? Instead of doing the right thing,we taking this easy way out simply to please certain groups and …procure politicians get all the votes in their bank bcoz its evident how in local elections,women act as a puppet to their husband
Love you speech ❤
I think it's a great and healthy step, provided that (hopefully) worthy and talented candidates get to contribute to do service for the country
Healthy step by discriminating based on gender? Bro, Reservation and talent are opposite sides of coin. If one exists the other doesn't. Both can't exist at same time
@@friendlyneighborhoodhuman Bro, what you are saying doesn't get to apply directly in Political context. Probably, you are not aware but the current political scenario is hugely dominated by Male politicians which is definitely not because of talent or something and also the validity of reservation is going to be valid for 15 years only (not forever)
Its lucid and insightgul coversge of women res bill, is appreciated. Indeed its historic and unfoubetedly a trajectory in progressive path.Kudos to present GOI for moving ahead with the bill.
As a feminist, when we are asking for equality, giving us reservation doesn't seem right.
Such feminists are few & far in between.
i assume, you're not just feminist but leftist as well. if solidifying 33% of MPs doesn't seem to uplift women then you're just feminist for the sake of it
@@neerajcrespo don't expect everyone to support this stupid move. Reservations has never solved anything.
@@jec_ecart idiotic bill?
sorry, we already have reservations on the basis of caste which no government including BJP can even dare to remove. so if reservations ain't going anywhere, what's wrong with guaranteeing more women representation at top level and decision making positions. i have a gut feeling that women representatives will more responsible and raise real life concerns of people and not digress the parliament in hindu Muslim and caste politics
@@neerajcrespoand that's a shame. What a garbage country this is. All reservations no merit
Palki,
You are number one anchor in India.
Palki Sharma's presentation is very professional
Yeah, she said there are 28 states in India.
That is the reason why absolute majority is important while electing government!! Many thugs dont want Bharat to grow!!
I am women, and i am against any kind of reservation.
So you want the gender inequality in india to reach the bottom in the index ( WEF Gender gap report 2023- 127th rank of india out of 146 countries).
I agree to this. There shouldn't be any form of reservations in the country. But i believe this woman's bill seems good atleast it will bring more woman candidates to the political structure and it will empower woman in India
@@Rohan_Kumar___yes
@@Rohan_Kumar___merit doesn't care about your social identity, as long as you're capable of doing a job you're hired for it. Being a muslim, woman, ST or some other artificial bs division shouldn't give you an upper hand. Cope
@@THE_CROISSANT_EVERONE_WANTS That's my point they are being denied to be the capable ones in the first place. And it is done by the same bs division which has been created through oppression and exploitation of their rights historically,which still has an impact on their socio-economic status.
Good But why only 33%....Make it 50%
50-50
We are giving women 33% reservation and men 0% reservation...
So we are basically hoping that among 67% remaining seats, women will win 17% on their own, which is a reasonable assumption in my opinion.
@@RajivKumar-xp9qn I See... That's why
A leader should solely be elected based on his ability to 'lead'.. The leader's cast, race, ethnicity, gender etc. should NEVER come into picture.. It is sadly a fact that this is nothing but vote-bank politics.. Very sad to hear anytime I hear any form of reservation in India... Let quality of candidates alone dictate their ability to acquire into positions..
Edit: We listen to you @Palki Sharma, not because you're a woman or because you're of a specific cast or reservation class or your looks.. We listen to you only because you're a good anchor and explain things well as a reporter... Why bring in reservation at places where it is not necessary...
This would encourage more women to go into politics which is mostly crowded by men, it's not that hard to see.. but it's only the first step. But it should be applauded that India is doing something about the ratio problem of women in leadership positions.
women are more interested in making instagram tiktok REELS to get likes instead for votes🤣🤣🤣
@@srinathshettigar379 Not all women saying that would be a huge generalization. But anyways what's wrong with that..? these things can coexist, social media is a part of our daily lives even political leaders use it. You can have a serious job and still make reels stop stereotyping people.
@@dearuniverse4091 when did i say "all" woman? You are the one generalizing things😂.
Priviledge is invisible to those that have it.
@@srinathshettigar379 You didn't specify a thing in your comment you just said women that is generalizing and I get it you are trying to be funny but you just come across as insensitive.
Becoz its men who are more active in politics and facing lathi charges and brutal police attacks in political activism... So no wonder...
And this reservation is unnecessary... Elect based on quality and efficiency... Not gender...
6:23 i am a woman and i know this is the worst decision. Please dont pass this bill .
I wish I could see you as MP becoming voice of women's of this nation.
No she is a misandric person. She is saying female privilege should be a law , sexist
This is called women appeasement 😢
I appreciate this reservation 🎉
Understand the scope of it and appreciate please stop appreciating when u don't understand it
@@vijayreddyyeredla8989 On what factor u decided that i don't understand the scope of this amendment??
I mean,did I say that?
What did u appreciate and why?
Such a ridiculous decision.....
Instead of working towards ending reservation politicians are more focussed on increasing reservation😢😢
There are great women leaders too…Palki can also enter politics, she has great speaking skills
It's delayed until the eleventh hour in order to gain political mileage. Nevertheless, this is a great step in the right direction.
very good decision ❤..
Old mate spotted ❤️
@@Indian_Rajput😁
Kudos to the government for passing the bill ..
Reservation quota must be completely removed from India & it should always be in merit basis only except for some who really are from the backward community & could manage only one meal a day. Not for all backwards communities.
All seats should be reserved for lgtb ..so that there is no fight between men and women😊
All I know is this that we are on a very dangerous path.
palki the way she explains .
@Firstpost the figures you flagged on women's representation in panchayats are promising. What irks me is the grassroots reality of their husbands proxying for them, known as 'mukhiya pati'. They take all decisions and attend social events as though they are the elected reps, on behalf of women mukhiyas, their spouses. They don't allow women to exercise their mandates in local governance. Everyone knows about this phenomenon including the govt, and accepts it, tacitly. So in practice, it is the men calling the shots, particularly in the Northern States. I see similar trends in municipal elections also. Can you do anything about it?
Totally agree. Even in my village there is a women mukhiya and women sarpanch but all the decisions, meetings, panchayat sessions are conducted by their husband. The real representative is just there to sign the documents.
The Trends are reversing as per latest researches. Rohini Pande of Harvard has shown as to how women have now started asserting themselves. Also women led panchayat have fared better on almost all parameters.
Aa gai men hating Igbt feminazi .Ye majority feminazi boycut wali kyu hoti hain? 🤔
I think this might be the case in the beginning. But, it will not last because giving women more power and representation will, well, lead to women having more power and representation.
history has witnessed how the world burnt when women or weaker men are given the charge or to lead,civilisations destroyed and wars fought with unprecedented destruction,…and u say better country? Give women equal opportunity yes but reservation? …Give women platform ,encourage women,provide other assistance to negate difficulties but staraight away giving someone what they aren’t capable of or not deserving?ex-pratibha pail,Indira Gandhi.etc..like Indira Gandhi gifted an island for free to srilanka without any consideration,this island was essential for strategic and economic stance,ppl in south go these sores for its richness in fishing,but it was gifted,just like this there is many more…Aren’t we reinforcing this idea of discrimination ,caste system and gender biasness by these? Instead of doing the right thing,we taking this easy way out simply to please certain groups and …procure politicians get all the votes in their bank bcoz its evident how in local elections,women act as a puppet to their husband
reservations of any kind for any class of society is bad. Affirmative action just went down in the US where I live. India is a free country where the vision of a secular united nation thrives, reserving seats creates resentment against the general class and in a free society anyone men or women, of any religion or caste can rise up if they put their mind to it whether that be in the upper or lower house of parliment or in the executive branch. India has had so many great women leaders during its time as a republic. This is just not a good policy imo
Please enhance the audio volume
Thank you...
The way mr.Modi talks is so attractive and confident
Now the entire parivar family will bring their wife, sisters, sister in laws, their aunty as candidate. All parivar politcians use this bill for family
Ancient thoughts all over world that women does not fit very well for leadership role, so people hesitant to elect them. These reservation gives opportunity to those women who really do well leadership roles. But it can also go wrong, if people misuse it. Women as leaders helps all women to inspire them in good way and to keep the culture strong becoz women are now becoming financially independent. In this time, good inspiration is necessary for all young women.
I'm not living under women leaders bro. Gtfoh I'm packing my bags to dubai
Nothing will change reservation will only create more problems to women Because society will always be male dominating.. 50 percent of country's population is belonging from rural or semi urban.. Government enforced marriage age of 21 but go and see many girls still getting married at 16..Nothing will change only rich people who have money will able to contest... Many families will never support women because of jyoti maurya type cases.. So it is only for rich class Or upper middle class
Congrats, PMji..
Yes
No reservations please 🤷
We already have this in odisha. This is actually good.
Its disgusting that people in comment section think/assume women aren't meritorious.
meritorious need reservation like SC/ST
Why only women? Children and youth need representation too
@@bvssrsguntur6338children in parliament?😂😂😂
The bill says that women are weak and lack merit. Its opposers want the women to play on equal grounds. After all, reservations are for the weak and downtrodden. If women are equal to men, why do they need reservations?
The supporters of this bill are disgusting for suggesting that women are incapable.
Indeed , odisha govt have done this in 2019 .
Whoever thinks that womens are not capable i want to ask them
Does lalu yadav genuinely deserves to be a cm ??