Villette by Charlotte Bronte Discussion

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @betinaceciliafeld9854
    @betinaceciliafeld9854 2 роки тому +6

    Great video! I must be a sick puppy because I loved M. Paul 🙈 Not at the beginning, of course, but when he starts to show himself more compassive (when Lucy starts to describe him so, I should say)... I felt in love with him. I mean, he's generous and he loves Lucy for what she is and he helps her get started as a teacher and he brings her books! I was heartbroken by the ending but I fully understand Lucy would not have the same independence as a wife. He will always be the man that loved her and gave her her independence this way 🥺

  • @Phorquieu
    @Phorquieu 10 місяців тому

    Great description of the contents and contexts connected to this book! Your discussion was very detailed and knowledgeable - you've done the book justice and convinced me why I should put this title on my list of books to read.

  • @STAR0SS
    @STAR0SS 4 роки тому +3

    Good review, maybe a word or two on the style - which I thought was most excellent - would have been a good addition. There's so many awesome passages.
    "Religious reader, you will preach to me a long sermon about
    what I have just written, and so will you, moralist; and you, stern
    sage: you, stoic, will frown; you, cynic, sneer; you, epicure, laugh.
    Well, each and all, take it your own way. I accept the sermon,
    frown, sneer and laugh; perhaps you are all right: and perhaps,
    circumstanced like me, you would have been, like me, wrong.The
    first month was, indeed, a long, black, heavy month to me."

  • @fanyfiction8265
    @fanyfiction8265 4 роки тому +9

    I found Monsieur Paul kinda funny, I did like him, also I couldn't help myself from relating to Lucy in a lot of things, so even though that he is not mr right, (Monsieur Paul) he was also not that bad, I see why she fell for him.

  • @chaucerflanders7918
    @chaucerflanders7918 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you, Caroline:
    I just would say you were so sweet in your discussion.
    and you do us all a favour to make us understanding hard classics like villette .
    I couldn't thank you enough, can you please do videos about George Elliot style and novels as I found her a bit hard
    Thank you carloineXX

    • @CarolineSutphin
      @CarolineSutphin  2 роки тому

      Thanks for watching! I recently got some George Eliot on my shelf and plan to read Middlemarch soon.

    • @chaucerflanders7918
      @chaucerflanders7918 2 роки тому

      Thank you Caroline Looking forward to it xx

    • @alashen
      @alashen 7 місяців тому

      Is there a movie or series about this vision?

  • @sarahgolden2948
    @sarahgolden2948 Рік тому +2

    Why is everyone saying villette is in France omg bc they speak French 😢? It’s in Belgium pls 😢😢 (I’m Belgian so I guess it hurts more ahaha) whatever loved your review on the book ❤

  • @donalgallagher8643
    @donalgallagher8643 2 роки тому

    Charlotte Bronte is the GOAT

  • @tribhuvankarki3625
    @tribhuvankarki3625 2 роки тому

    I seen dram and i was wearing shirt and thatt shirt hav! Lok and theier qirte villete ao that will find out where made it so price so i m searching in the google but not apeqr and i m traying so plz info m about this plz

  • @pbtraveler694
    @pbtraveler694 3 роки тому

    Not bizarre----but rather essentially an autobiographical story of Charlotte Bronte's relationship or infatuation with M. Heger.

    • @CarolineSutphin
      @CarolineSutphin  3 роки тому +1

      Of course, but can it not be both autobiographical and delightfully bizarre? The plot has basis in real life, but that is complicated and made more strange/intriguing by a withholding narrator, supernatural elements, and a host of side characters not based in any reality. Though, you're right, the autobiographical piece offers an interesting perspective on the story and the passion that was probably controversial at the time.

  • @premonitionforboding9641
    @premonitionforboding9641 4 роки тому

    I wonder how the colour of hair keep changing...

  • @maryylsoviare5965
    @maryylsoviare5965 8 місяців тому

    Please may you tell me if it has any kisses or 18+ parts because I’m sensitive to such things ; I would read it if it has none!

    • @alashen
      @alashen 7 місяців тому

      There is no such thing no kisses

    • @maryylsoviare5965
      @maryylsoviare5965 7 місяців тому

      @@alashen are u sure miss no kisses ?