People be like "the black and white version is better, HNNNNGGGG!!!" It's like an army of Captain Obviouses or something. The shadow art version was about blending shapes between transitions, this video was made so you can see _who_ the characters are, not to try and 1-up it.
Yeah,i know this is bad,but i think this is still good btw.i can know who's the person behind the shadow,and then if u see the silhouete version u can imagine it.(this video is very helpfull for someone who curious about the char,and even the image is bad,but not that bad.because this is mmd. years when this mmd made is not same as now,so still use old graphic.but i domt care about it,because i have imagination ability)
@@arottedfruit "The shadow art version was about blending shapes between transitions, this video was made so you can see who the characters are, not to try and 1-up it."
People basing this video, please take into consideration the sheer DIFFICULTY of fully animating fluidly, finding all suitable models, finding appropriate effects, and later editing to look like the real thing is in such a limited program like Miku Miku Dance. This work should be applauded equally as much as the original, because it takes just as much time and skill to make something like this. It's easy to understand why non-MMD users would under appreciate this, but I mean, c'mon! It's AMAZING
Watching this after watching the original version, this feels like a Behind The Scenes video and it is so spectacular 🔥 Both versions are amazing in their own way 😎
lmao all these "better in B&W" comments the reason why it was in B&W was so that the transitions would be clever. furthermore, this doesn't use identical models, so a lot of things look off. this is just an example of an artist using a style well in order to create something truly unique and unreplicatable.
That and MMD is buggy as all hell when it comes to models like, Rwby, or an actual vocaloid. Physics tend to go out of whack. If they tried to 100% recreate this from memory, while its somewhat good it still could be better. But again, MMD physics suck balls. _moreso than a slaneeshi cultist_
I personally liked the shadow art better. But you know what? Animating in Miku Miku Dance is hard. It's fucking difficult to get everything right. I could never even understand how to get it to work in the first place, and this is one of the best animations I've seen. Can we all stop bitching about something so trivial as an animation? People are dying. (edit: read the timestamp and the 30 other comments saying the same thing u fuckin chuckleheads)
I know this is 6 years old but this is the stupidest comment ever 😭 like yeah people are always dying???? but we can express opinions and debate about other things too
People, people .. PLEASE Why are you comparing this video the original 2d one?? This is just a remake of the motion but in MMD! MMD is something advanced but not as advanced as real life is..and the original 2d video is drawn okay? So why are you comparing? I think this video is really epic since the author is able to animate like this. Sure it has some flaws but do you think you're any better if you just keep on yapping about how this video isn't the same as the original? Omg,some people..Finding flaws in MMD videos are just lame.Unless if it was too unnecessary.
Seriously it's hard to work out why there has to be complaints about them. I enjoy both versions as I love how the original is done but I also enjoy this since it's coloured. Guess though that there are very few people who are opened to accept both without issues unlike most...
Cauldraborn I also have no clue.. People think something like this can be done with just a snap of a finger! I love both version,they're the same yet seemed different. I wish people would just stop comparing..it's getting real annoying,honestly.
Stekino Mai I know, you see it all over the place these days. I'll admit that there are things that comparing is fine to an extent but not everything needs to be complained about and such for being compared or so.
Is Sour or YYB not MMD or have you just not been watching much MMD lately (lately as in when this was comment was made 6 months ago)- There were some really good ones made back when you made this comment, I'm not denying that this video itself is good, but 99% better is a bit of a.. stretch
Dude someone need to make a remake of this with today's technology we could so much improve the frame rate, smooth movement and characters in general this would be so awesome
You can do a lot with MMD today and a remake of this would be more than impressive since the program is a lot more complete and fluid now. Sad that this user is long gone
@@KatastrophicGlitzy ah yes they are channel i seriously dont know why people write stuff like that if people know what you mean i don't see why you need to correct them anybody fluent in english could tell instantly that's meant to be their channel and with closer inspection know that in their channel should be on their channel and what is with non-native english speakers always using commas i've lived in an english speaking country since october 10th 2013 and i still don't really know how to use them outside a list with 3 or more items and what's with them saying "sorry for my english" and then proceeding to have no flaws in what they say after that what's with them treating everything they say like it's for their job
Seeing all these characters in colour for the first time - really felt like I was looking at a whole new set of characters even though their silhouettes are the same.
Omg, I was eating an apple. Then some crazy shit went down... All of a sudden, I was wearing a witch costume and dropped an apple core onto someone's head! I'm sticking to pears.
@@theflightguy8726 there were a lot of computers with their own architecture back in the day. The pc-98 was one of them and it was from japan. It was the original home of the touhou franchise before it rebooted and switched to windows.
Not even going to lie, I am extremely impressed with the skill and talent put into this, If anything else the dedication! It may not be as smooth as the shadow-art, but it still shows how much someone cared to do a 3d full colored version of the video :) I thank this person that did the 3d art for it.
This is really cool! I’ve never played the game so seeing the animated characters in color gave me some context to understand Bad Apple better! I’m gonna get into this fandom if I can 😂🙏🏻
I don't really know if people have already written the character names in the video but I'll re-write them again. Reimu Hakurei (Highly Repsonsive to Prayers, reappeared in all of the official game, I think) Marisa Kirisame (Story of Eastern Wonderland also reappeared in all of the offical games, I think) Patchouli Knowledge (Embodiment of Scarlet Devil, reappeared as ending no.8 in PCB, IaMP, IN, PoFV, STB, SWR, playable partner in SA, Toho Hisoutensoku standalone, background character in HM, UN) Remilia Scarlet (Embodiment of Scarlet Devil) Sakuya Izayoi (Embodiment of Scarlet Devil) Flandre Scarlet (Embodiment of Scarlet Devil) Youmu Konpaku (Perfect Cherry Blossom) Yuyuko Saigyouji (Perfect Cherry Blossom Komachi Onozuka (Phantasmagoria of Flower View) Eiki Shiki Yamaxanadu (Phantasmagori of Flower View) Fujiwara no Mokou (Imperishable Night) Keine and her Hakutaku form (Imperishable Night) Eirin Yagokoro (Imperishable Night) Kaguya Houraisan (Imperishable Night) The Prismriver sisters ( Lunasa Prismriver , Lyrica Prismriver and Merlin prismriver. ) (Perfect Cherry Blossom) Chen Yakumo (Perfect Cherry Blossom) Ran Yakumo (Perfect Cherry Blossom) Tewi Inaba (Imperishable Night) Reisen Udogein Inaba (Imperishable Night, playable at PoFV, SWR, LoLK, PS4 version of ULiL 14.5) Momiji Inubashiri (Mountain of Faith, reappeared in DS) Sanae Kochiya (Mountain of Faith, extra stage midboss in SA, playable at UFO, Toho Hisoutensoku, TD and LoLK) Hina Kagiyama (Mountain of Faith, a target os stage 2 of DS and was shown in a background of HM) Kanako Yasaka and Suwako Moriya (Kanako: Mountain of Faith, target on stage 11 of DS, reappeared in SHoSS *Suwako* : MoF, reappeared in Touho Hisoutensoku ) Yukari Yakumo (Perfect Cherry Blossom, playable at IN, partnered w/ Reimu at SA, was playable in the fighting games but not in HM) Tenshi Hinanawi (Scarlet Weather Rhapsody, reappeared in AoCF, appeared as a target in DS) Aya Shameimaru (Phantasmagoria of Flower View, reappeared as main protag in STB and DS, stage 4 boss in MoF, playable and partnered w/ Reimu in SA, Playable at SWR, Day 6 boss at ISP. HSiFS ) Suika Ibuki (Immaterial and Missing Power and SWR, shes also a supporting character for Reimu in SA) Alice Margatroid and her Doll, named (Mystic Square, reappeared in PCB, playable at IN and SA, IaMP, SWR, Touhou Hisoutensoku 12.3) Nitori Kawashiro (Stage 3 boss in MoF, became playable in SA, a 6 boss in ISP, became playable again in HM and ULiL 14.5 ) Yuuka Kazami (Lotus Land Story reappeared in PoFV) Elly ( in PC-98 ) (Lotus Land Story) Reimu and Marisa in PC-98 version. Just in case someone doesn't know where/where the Touhou game they come from.
As someone who knows nothing about Touhou, I can confidently say that the actual characters look nothing like how I expected. Except for a certain Goblin...
This animation is great. The transitions are just as good as the original. It was nice to see the 3d version but the original made the transitions on some parts easier on the eyes. But no hate on this though.
@@lilawashere4703 Source please? Been looking for a genuine behind the scenes of video for years. Would love if someone had an actual source for me. :/
I’ve literally never seen the characters in Bad Apple in full colour looking like how they’re supposed to, so I LOVED this version! Mad respect, 3D animation is really really freakin hard! (Only unit in my college course I screwed up on)
People comparing shadow art version with MMD version. Bitch please if you really want the creator of this video to improve his/her work, go to NicoNico instead of complaining about how the characters are stiff here
this looks incredible, not only for 12 years ago but also for now!! so much mmd work today looks about this quality for fluidity im a decade late to the party but AMAZING WORK
2:26 The original Bad Apple was released between the release of Mountain of Faith and Scarlet Weather Rhapsody. Those characters are Renko and Maribel.
My bad, that actually is Tenshi. I didn't notice the rainbow streak on her dress in the original video. It was a close month date though, I simply expected if SWR was released, they probably would've featured Nagae Iku as well. The rivalry of Tenshi and Yukari works just as well, though.
Tails The Fox Look up the video WHAT IS TOUHOU? An informational video, by Illogical Pine. That's pretty much everything you need to know. Also, you can download Touhou games from some sites like Moriya Shrine and Doujin Style, but some of the newer games haven't been patched into English yet.
might as well do this stop complaining that b&w is better reasons are that it makes the transitions better, but this one just shows who the characters are, and this is well made too. keep your opinion to yourself unless people ask for it.
I only know marisa and the "maid servant with unlimented suplie of knifes" Playing a lot of slay the spire which is full of touhou mods. There r great mods btw
@@welcometodowntowncoolsville When I watched the original one - which only using black and white color - , I thought she was walking forward while showing her back. but after watching this video, it turns out she was walking backwards while facing the camera.
A little bit of info for some people since... idk just want to say it lol. This's a (tried to) recreation in non monochrome mmd by different artist. Some people actually thought this's the original without the monochrome. While as far as I know, the original artist didn't even tell what kind of software or model they used to make it. I mean, it's pretty obvious from the model and how rough the movements are.
Hey, thank you for creating this gem. I can finally see how those girls look like. It is amazing job, I'm sure it took much effort to do it. Unfortunately they aren't look like I have imagined, so I like original version more, but still! Thank you very much for creating it and for letting me know how they look! I wish you all the best!
![Touhou - Bad Apple [English vocal by Cristina Vee]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rG-Fs7de_9o/mqdefault.jpg)
Bad Apple but they turned the lights on
Lol
DUOLINGO I DID MY JAPANESE LESSONS PLS DONT KILL MY FAMILY@@Bolt-Action_Rifle
@@Sheilajustnormal OML IF U I DIDN'T ILL SEAL THE BODYS AWAY
Lmao
Hes not duolingo
People be like "the black and white version is better, HNNNNGGGG!!!" It's like an army of Captain Obviouses or something.
The shadow art version was about blending shapes between transitions, this video was made so you can see _who_ the characters are, not to try and 1-up it.
Yeah,i know this is bad,but i think this is still good btw.i can know who's the person behind the shadow,and then if u see the silhouete version u can imagine it.(this video is very helpfull for someone who curious about the char,and even the image is bad,but not that bad.because this is mmd. years when this mmd made is not same as now,so still use old graphic.but i domt care about it,because i have imagination ability)
Right, and that's the exact reason why i watch this version, i wanted to know who is who
@@arottedfruit "The shadow art version was about blending shapes between transitions, this video was made so you can see who the characters are, not to try and 1-up it."
@@arottedfruit youre missing the whole point
@@arottedfruit Bruh -_-
reminder: this was literally made from scratch so i gotta give credit to the person who made this
aye. and people think to forget the video is quite old
@@Mima_the_vengeful_spirit and still they keep saying this is bad
@@Android-nk5ew from scratch not in lol
@@theunknown1760 when will they realise that you can never make bad apple actually bad
Also, I think MMD back then has a lot of limitations.
For the fact that it's 10 years old and made in MMD, it's actually very impressive.
Wasn’t very old in that time, I’ll have to take your word for it
Oh gods, I remember how weird MMD was to adapt to back in the day.
Definite props for that.
indeed
12 years old now
jsut another funyn fact reimu looks behind her she dosent looks at us ajajaj
People basing this video, please take into consideration the sheer DIFFICULTY of fully animating fluidly, finding all suitable models, finding appropriate effects, and later editing to look like the real thing is in such a limited program like Miku Miku Dance. This work should be applauded equally as much as the original, because it takes just as much time and skill to make something like this. It's easy to understand why non-MMD users would under appreciate this, but I mean, c'mon! It's AMAZING
Comment from 10 years later: I agree
It's been 10 years. Technology has gotten better, I think. Imagine what it'd be like if it was done today. It'd be amazing.
Okay but it still suxx in comparisson xD
What if they do all that and still think it's garbage?
@@friendlyreptile9931let’s see you do it, then.
I love how Reimu's face in the beginning goes from "this looks delicous" to "dafuq is this shit?" In 2 seconds flat XD
@@thetexc make it 6 weeks
LOL THATS NOT HOW I IMAGINE IT IN THE SHADOW VERSION
Lol
@@beepyboro what
@@retsreinyrelgeinthrelaveri1456 nice name
this makes me want to throw an apple in the air and see what happens
Did you see what happened now?
@@beepyboro LMAO
_Wow this comment is so old._
@Hilton Gaming90 _the apple has not yet fallen._
I tried it
But nothing happened because I'm not reimu
In the time 3d animating was hard.. Respect
Still is
@@Someone-sq8im No
yet there are people throwing shit
Agreed
Homie said was as if it was easy now
How Reimu tells whether an apple is good:
Toss it in the air. If it's good, it will not come down.
Because Marisa "borrowed" it
Czardonyx marisa stole the precious apple
But if its good she wont be able to eat it sadly...
the nagito N pfp..
if its bad it'll be thrown down at her because of Marisa
only a true fan can tell the characters from the silhouettes, I am not one of those
@FURĂTOAREA DE CEREALE hey same
same, i have no idea who they are but i still love the game
I never played the game but i've binged a bunch of bad apples
And i don't know any of the charcters .-.
@@humandog3240 aight time to drag you down the rabbithole then
and no you cant refuse cause im forcing you :D
go search Touhou project
the end
Im only watching this so I can see the actual characters
Me too I can barely recognise anyone
some are recognized easily, mostly revealed by things they have with them, or parts they have that others don’t
@@someonerandom7398 I didn't even know there were a few different characters
same
The hats are my only clue to knowing who the fuck these people are
Watching this after watching the original version, this feels like a Behind The Scenes video and it is so spectacular 🔥 Both versions are amazing in their own way 😎
This is the actual behind the scene: www.nicovideo.jp/watch/nm3601701
@@supreme_xenon 👍
Also it’s amazing for its age
lmao all these "better in B&W" comments
the reason why it was in B&W was so that the transitions would be clever. furthermore, this doesn't use identical models, so a lot of things look off. this is just an example of an artist using a style well in order to create something truly unique and unreplicatable.
That and MMD is buggy as all hell when it comes to models like, Rwby, or an actual vocaloid.
Physics tend to go out of whack.
If they tried to 100% recreate this from memory, while its somewhat good it still could be better.
But again, MMD physics suck balls.
_moreso than a slaneeshi cultist_
And also so you know who the characters are lmao
Also its made by one guy, 10 years ago lmfao
@@sid6645 now 11 and _i'm necroposting_
I bet tons of people don't realise this is an mmd
@Fluffy Cheese Miku Miku Dance
@Fluffy Cheese miku miku dancer
dancer- 🗿
@@sparkletoenies ITS NOT DANCER?
@@bruhdude779 no... its just dance 😔
This aged remarkably well for something made 12 years ago in MMD
Well, 2008 was a golden era of MMD, either shitpost, short film or dance video
元がいいって言ってる人はMMDの大変さを理解していない…
これは再現できてるだけでもかなり凄いことなのだ
たしかに難しそう
@@atetsu3941 呑気かよw好きだわw
Police.
元もいいってことや
@@myrondabosscat
警察？
10年前の動画でここまで再現出来る技術がすごい…
見入ってしまった…
ほんとそれ
0:01 reimu
0:15 Marisa
0:28 Patchouli
0:36 Remilia
0:46 Sakuya
0:51 Flandre
0:57 Youmu
1:03 Yuyuko [The tree is Saigyou Ayakashi at 1:03]
1:12 Komachi
1:18 Eiki
1:24 Mokou
1:32 Keine | 1:34 Demon Keine
1:39 eirin
1:46 Kaguya
1:51 prismriver sister
1:56 Lunasa
1:57 Merlin
1:58 lyrica
2:00 Chen
2:01 Ran
2:02 Tewi
2:03 Reisen
2:05 Momji
2:08 Sanae 2:11 Hina
2:13 Kanako | 2:16 Suwako
2:22 Yukari
2:28 Tenshi
2:32 Yukari
2:33 Tenshi
2:34 Yukari | 2:34 Tenshi
2:36 Aya
2:42 Suika
2:49 Alice
Shanghai
2:55 Nitori
3:03 Yuuka
3:10 Elly
3:19 Reimu- PC98
3:23 Marisa-PC98
3:26
Marisa-PC98
Reimu-PC98
3:30 YinYang
Credit: LofDoom channel
Link :ua-cam.com/video/BEutktB7KNY/v-deo.html
J 🍌
Link to the original when I watched it: ua-cam.com/video/BEutktB7KNY/v-deo.html
Forgot about Saigyou Ayakashi 1:03
0:44 should be Rumia
@@MARindrivonGER yup but in this video there isnt rumia so i didnt put it
霊夢と魔理沙から始まって、最後に靈夢と魔梨沙に還る演出にこの物語の基幹はここにあるという深いこだわりを感じる
@@恥さらしマン 旧作も魔"理"沙で合ってますよ〜。梨が使われてたのはただのプログラムミスなので、旧作の方も魔理沙で大丈夫です。(多分！)
ま あ 正 直 ど っ ち で も い い
最後のシーンを旧作のレイマリにするの
ほんとセンスあると思う
@@road4214 確か字コンテを参考にしたかと
@@アッヒホ へー、そうだったのか
この時代でこの再現度はスゴすぎる
これを是非とも今の最新MMDモデル
で作って欲しいなぁ,,,
日本の人だぁ
すけ式、にがもん式、アールビット式は今でもmmd動画作ってる方は良く使ってますよねぇ。確かに新たなmmd版のバッドアップル観たいなぁ。
I personally liked the shadow art better. But you know what? Animating in Miku Miku Dance is hard. It's fucking difficult to get everything right. I could never even understand how to get it to work in the first place, and this is one of the best animations I've seen. Can we all stop bitching about something so trivial as an animation? People are dying.
(edit: read the timestamp and the 30 other comments saying the same thing u fuckin chuckleheads)
Ikr even like the transitions are amazing considering what software they used
people are dying? pft i am from 2021 and we have corona virus killing millions
I know this is 6 years old but this is the stupidest comment ever 😭 like yeah people are always dying???? but we can express opinions and debate about other things too
bro this was made so you could see the characters thats kinda it
you guys i was like 12 lets leave this comment from 2013 in the past 😭😭
People, people .. PLEASE
Why are you comparing this video the original 2d one?? This is just a remake of the motion but in MMD! MMD is something advanced but not as advanced as real life is..and the original 2d video is drawn okay? So why are you comparing? I think this video is really epic since the author is able to animate like this. Sure it has some flaws but do you think you're any better if you just keep on yapping about how this video isn't the same as the original? Omg,some people..Finding flaws in MMD videos are just lame.Unless if it was too unnecessary.
Seriously it's hard to work out why there has to be complaints about them. I enjoy both versions as I love how the original is done but I also enjoy this since it's coloured. Guess though that there are very few people who are opened to accept both without issues unlike most...
Cauldraborn I also have no clue.. People think something like this can be done with just a snap of a finger! I love both version,they're the same yet seemed different. I wish people would just stop comparing..it's getting real annoying,honestly.
Stekino Mai
I know, you see it all over the place these days. I'll admit that there are things that comparing is fine to an extent but not everything needs to be complained about and such for being compared or so.
Cauldraborn True! MMD dramas can be so goddamn annoying.
***** No it's not. It's just some manipulation of the MODELS. That were modeled.
Say what you want about this, but this animation is still 99% better than any MMD videos on youtube nowadays
Is Sour or YYB not MMD or have you just not been watching much MMD lately (lately as in when this was comment was made 6 months ago)-
There were some really good ones made back when you made this comment, I'm not denying that this video itself is good, but 99% better is a bit of a.. stretch
ITS YOU
Dude someone need to make a remake of this with today's technology we could so much improve the frame rate, smooth movement and characters in general this would be so awesome
You can do a lot with MMD today and a remake of this would be more than impressive since the program is a lot more complete and fluid now. Sad that this user is long gone
@@KatastrophicGlitzyWhat happened to the creator?
@@zhappy The creator quit, as you can see there's no activity in they're channel
@@KatastrophicGlitzy ah yes they are channel
i seriously dont know why people write stuff like that
if people know what you mean i don't see why you need to correct them
anybody fluent in english could tell instantly that's meant to be their channel and with closer inspection know that in their channel should be on their channel
and what is with non-native english speakers always using commas i've lived in an english speaking country since october 10th 2013 and i still don't really know how to use them outside a list with 3 or more items
and what's with them saying "sorry for my english" and then proceeding to have no flaws in what they say after that
what's with them treating everything they say like it's for their job
@@xxGreenRoblox I ain't reading allat
元のシルエットの方が良いという意見は絶対多いと思うが、敢えてカラー化にトライしたというのは面白い志向だと思います。
僕は違う意味で面白いと思います。どこかと言うとわからないキャラもいたのでこっちもシルエットの方も面白いと思います。
ㅋ 일본 나라 사람이넼ㅋ
@@효리-d8d 韓国人 笑
Seeing all these characters in colour for the first time - really felt like I was looking at a whole new set of characters even though their silhouettes are the same.
These are characters from 2002 to 2007 with one character from 1998. In total there are 155 Touhou Project characters.
@@HyperVanilo That's a lot of characters damn.
For me it all begun making sense lol I could barely tell apart the clothes and accessories before
使用されてるモデルに時代を感じる…その中でも今でもメジャーなISAO式やルシール式はすごいなぁ
2:57- "...But she trips over a shoelace and falls into the sea" XD
That's all I can think about now
💀💀💀💀
Based off a parody video where the lyrics describe what happens in the original video
LOL SAME
This is amazing especially from someone who doesn't know much about the franchise it's really cool to see all the characters and where they are
I can't help but point out that Cirno was a character since Touhou 6, which was released in 2002, predating this video by a few years.
Hoi Hoi good evening
@@robloxisanime6233 good evening
I can't help but point out that Bad Apple was a song since Touhou 4, which was released in 1998, predating this video by a few years.
Well hello there, took 8 years for a reply huh ...
Dude r u still alive?
MMDでここまで動かせるのは凄い
It's so cool being able to actually see the characters behind the silhouettes!
These are 34 out of 150+ Touhou characters, they are from 2002 to 2007 with one character from 1998
The heck... people are actually complaining about this?
this was posted 9 years ago we need a remake
Yes
Too bad we will not have one. This person's last video was from 7 years ago. They will not be making content any time soon.
@@ohhellno7437 I meant remake of the same type of video
Whoever makes it doesn't mattter
10 years now
Totally
imagine the 2021 version of this
so, "Bad Apple but everyone wears a mask"?
@@cheekibreeki904 no thats 2020
The 2021 version of this?
amogus
I wanna remake it with my characters but I don’t have Miku Miku dance 🗿
@@belovedrena9977 too bad lmfao
This is surprisingly good. It's clear that a ton of effort was put into staying as faithful to the original as they could manage.
Omg, I was eating an apple. Then some crazy shit went down... All of a sudden, I was wearing a witch costume and dropped an apple core onto someone's head! I'm sticking to pears.
I-
@@renthewizard this was 7 years ago...
@@ckarts5784 cool
You're Marisa Kirisame and dropped the apple onto Patchouli Knowledge.
Pears!?
あと諏訪子が見ている時の目がにらんでるように見えて怖い: _ :
やっと、日本人居たぁ！神曲だなぁこれは
2:18 Dat little girl's face
She's over 100 years old...
premium cancer Yeah, seems like she is...
zzMakomanzz ™ She's an Earth goddess. So yeah. She's a couple of fucking centuries old.
lol
+premium cancer
東方はいいぞ❗
ガルパンはいいぞ❗
This feels like reading a manga you've read many times but in color.
2:54 YOU DID THE RUN LEGIT PERFECTLY I LOVE THIS SO MUCH
1:53 nice piano. flying.
I see nothing wrong with it
12 years ago????? Wow.... this animation is amazing!! Well done :D long live Touhou!
people are forgetting that this was animated on scratch using miku miku dancer, IT IS LITERALLY FROM A DECADE AGO.
Kids nowadays probably never heard of MIkuMikuDance or MMD
I didn't expect the old reimu and marisa and ELLY but why not, to the end, that's her stage's theme.
*Elly
@@HashiNuke thx
I have to say, I liked the decision to make the yin-yang Reimu and Marisa the PC-98 versions of them. It fit really nicely.
Lol, in the shadow animation you can tell they're PC98 ReiMari
What's a PC-98?
@@humandog3240 an operating system?
@@theflightguy8726 there were a lot of computers with their own architecture back in the day. The pc-98 was one of them and it was from japan. It was the original home of the touhou franchise before it rebooted and switched to windows.
@@wertyxq3468 why did you tag me there? You should have tagged human dog but okay
Not even going to lie, I am extremely impressed with the skill and talent put into this, If anything else the dedication! It may not be as smooth as the shadow-art, but it still shows how much someone cared to do a 3d full colored version of the video :)
I thank this person that did the 3d art for it.
Sup, just bringing you nostalgia
Wow all the characters look so different from what I imagined them to look like from their silhouttes in the original vid
These characters are from 2002 to 2008 with one from 1998
Bro never Heard of touhou?
They worked hard on this; this doesn't deserve negative comments~ And all of the characters are freaking colorful...
影絵を見慣れてる人にとってはカラーだったりで違和感があるかもしれないけど、10年以上前でこのクオリティと再現度は凄い。
…とりあえず凄さとパチェさんが美しいという事は分かった。
パチェさん美しいのはわかりみが深い
@@marinshiba4181 あなたも同志のようで嬉しい
This is really cool! I’ve never played the game so seeing the animated characters in color gave me some context to understand Bad Apple better! I’m gonna get into this fandom if I can 😂🙏🏻
If you're interested in Touhou lore, keep in mind that you must read the in-game dialogs, the endings, and the printworks.
14 years ago this well animated, mad crazy
i really appreciate this
and wow, it just shows how good the transition in the original is
with everything blending perfectly
Is that broom peirced right through her at 00:21?
Wyntre Faust lol editing error I'm guessing the original is in shadow art so it's probably harder to edit it in color
It’s really interesting to see the full character designs, thanks for taking the time to do this!
Fyi, this is not his works
from 13 years ago AND made from scratch this is fucking awesome.
How do you know it's made from scratch?
本来は、こうなるんだよね？
まあ、これはこれで好き。
I don't really know if people have already written the character names in the video but I'll re-write them again.
Reimu Hakurei
(Highly Repsonsive to Prayers, reappeared in all of the official game, I think)
Marisa Kirisame
(Story of Eastern Wonderland also reappeared in all of the offical games, I think)
Patchouli Knowledge
(Embodiment of Scarlet Devil, reappeared as ending no.8 in PCB, IaMP, IN, PoFV, STB, SWR, playable partner in SA, Toho Hisoutensoku standalone, background character in HM, UN)
Remilia Scarlet
(Embodiment of Scarlet Devil)
Sakuya Izayoi
(Embodiment of Scarlet Devil)
Flandre Scarlet
(Embodiment of Scarlet Devil)
Youmu Konpaku
(Perfect Cherry Blossom)
Yuyuko Saigyouji
(Perfect Cherry Blossom
Komachi Onozuka
(Phantasmagoria of Flower View)
Eiki Shiki Yamaxanadu
(Phantasmagori of Flower View)
Fujiwara no Mokou
(Imperishable Night)
Keine and her Hakutaku form
(Imperishable Night)
Eirin Yagokoro
(Imperishable Night)
Kaguya Houraisan
(Imperishable Night)
The Prismriver sisters
( Lunasa Prismriver , Lyrica Prismriver and Merlin prismriver. )
(Perfect Cherry Blossom)
Chen Yakumo
(Perfect Cherry Blossom)
Ran Yakumo
(Perfect Cherry Blossom)
Tewi Inaba
(Imperishable Night)
Reisen Udogein Inaba
(Imperishable Night, playable at PoFV, SWR, LoLK, PS4 version of ULiL 14.5)
Momiji Inubashiri
(Mountain of Faith, reappeared in DS)
Sanae Kochiya
(Mountain of Faith, extra stage midboss in SA, playable at UFO, Toho Hisoutensoku, TD and LoLK)
Hina Kagiyama
(Mountain of Faith, a target os stage 2 of DS and was shown in a background of HM)
Kanako Yasaka and Suwako Moriya
(Kanako: Mountain of Faith, target on stage 11 of DS, reappeared in SHoSS
*Suwako* : MoF, reappeared in Touho Hisoutensoku )
Yukari Yakumo
(Perfect Cherry Blossom, playable at IN, partnered w/ Reimu at SA, was playable in the fighting games but not in HM)
Tenshi Hinanawi
(Scarlet Weather Rhapsody, reappeared in AoCF, appeared as a target in DS)
Aya Shameimaru
(Phantasmagoria of Flower View, reappeared as main protag in STB and DS, stage 4 boss in MoF, playable and partnered w/ Reimu in SA, Playable at SWR, Day 6 boss at ISP. HSiFS )
Suika Ibuki
(Immaterial and Missing Power and SWR, shes also a supporting character for Reimu in SA)
Alice Margatroid and her Doll, named (Mystic Square, reappeared in PCB, playable at IN and SA, IaMP, SWR, Touhou Hisoutensoku 12.3)
Nitori Kawashiro
(Stage 3 boss in MoF, became playable in SA, a 6 boss in ISP, became playable again in HM and ULiL 14.5 )
Yuuka Kazami
(Lotus Land Story reappeared in PoFV)
Elly ( in PC-98 )
(Lotus Land Story)
Reimu and Marisa in PC-98 version.
Just in case someone doesn't know where/where the Touhou game they come from.
Well, because of the upload date pretty sure there are dozen of people dropped the character list
Dang
i think it works better in black and white.
spaalonebabuguuscooties me too
yep this just looks like shitty rwby
Ardock i know good show but shitty animation
MMD is way below RWBY. not saying that RWBY's animation is good though.
In RWBY's defence, the animation has improved a fair bit since it started 3 years ago
As someone who knows nothing about Touhou, I can confidently say that the actual characters look nothing like how I expected.
Except for a certain Goblin...
Suika Ibuki is a Japanese ogre aka oni 👹, Japanese goblin aka tengu 👺 would be Aya Shameimaru
1:24 I thought the hair would be dark Purple or black
This animation is great. The transitions are just as good as the original. It was nice to see the 3d version but the original made the transitions on some parts easier on the eyes. But no hate on this though.
Funny that the original also 3D animation
@@lilawashere4703 Anira never said it's 2D but made to looks like 3D
@@lilawashere4703 isn't it the opposite
@@lilawashere4703 Source please? Been looking for a genuine behind the scenes of video for years. Would love if someone had an actual source for me. :/
神的だわ…
惚れ惚れする！
…ただ、やっぱ影絵じゃないと無理がある所も多々あるね…
I’ve literally never seen the characters in Bad Apple in full colour looking like how they’re supposed to, so I LOVED this version!
Mad respect, 3D animation is really really freakin hard! (Only unit in my college course I screwed up on)
im surprised someone made something so good 10 years ago
People comparing shadow art version with MMD version.
Bitch please if you really want the creator of this video to improve his/her work, go to NicoNico instead of complaining about how the characters are stiff here
This MMD of Bad Apple is definitely the most fit MMD-version of the soundtrack...
*NICE JOB!*
妖夢の刀がライトセーバーにみえるw
それな
それな
this looks incredible, not only for 12 years ago but also for now!!
so much mmd work today looks about this quality for fluidity
im a decade late to the party but AMAZING WORK
ちゃんと旧作のキャラも作れてるのは凄い。
本当にちゃんと東方を調べた上で尚且つMMDでここまでしっかり作れたのは尊敬します(_ _*))
しかも11年前だからね…
ヤバイよね(語彙)
2:10 that leaf tho
2:26 The original Bad Apple was released between the release of Mountain of Faith and Scarlet Weather Rhapsody. Those characters are Renko and Maribel.
Kirbachu5 If you can good sir I want to be a part of the Touhou fandom but I don't know crap so please tell me ;-;
You mean 3:26, right?
Caleb Nash But those are Marisa and Reimu, not renko and maribel
My bad, that actually is Tenshi. I didn't notice the rainbow streak on her dress in the original video. It was a close month date though, I simply expected if SWR was released, they probably would've featured Nagae Iku as well. The rivalry of Tenshi and Yukari works just as well, though.
Tails The Fox Look up the video WHAT IS TOUHOU? An informational video, by Illogical Pine. That's pretty much everything you need to know. Also, you can download Touhou games from some sites like Moriya Shrine and Doujin Style, but some of the newer games haven't been patched into English yet.
The fact that this is 12 years old and still perfectly animated in MMD makes it a piece of talen and hard work
There are a lot of MMD animations like this back then
これが10年前とか、、東方ってめっちゃハイカラやん（褒め言葉
This is so
So COLORFUL OMG
Their colors are way more vibrant than I thought
That's Jun'ya Ota for you
might as well do this
stop complaining that b&w is better
reasons are that it makes the transitions better, but this one just shows who the characters are, and this is well made too.
keep your opinion to yourself unless people ask for it.
2:16 ngl, the character on the right looks wholesome
Suwako Moriya, Extra Stage boss of Touhou 10 (2007)
@@HyperVanilo oh thats their name!, ok i don't know any touhou characters so thanks
@@AsmarahKhanJust so you know- she is a god who is.. i think more that 2000 years old?
finally people who are not familiar with touhou know whos the characters in this video, really helpful!
I only know marisa and the "maid servant with unlimented suplie of knifes"
Playing a lot of slay the spire which is full of touhou mods. There r great mods btw
Woah this made 9 years ago was top notch for real.
0:01 I thought she was walking forward before watching this video
Huh
@@welcometodowntowncoolsville When I watched the original one - which only using black and white color - , I thought she was walking forward while showing her back. but after watching this video, it turns out she was walking backwards while facing the camera.
これ元が影絵だから表情とか自分で考えないといけないだろうし、原作のほうは白と黒だけだしアニメーション（おそらく）だからいろいろ繋げるのも大変なはずなのにほとんど違和感を感じないことがとてもすごいとおもいます。（小並感）
元がいいって言ってる人は、この表情管理とかしっかりとした繋げ方、原作通りの表現方法を完全にMMDでやっているとしっかりと認識したほうがいいと思います
長文失礼しました
Crazy how none of the characters looked how i exepected them to look 😇
A little bit of info for some people since... idk just want to say it lol.
This's a (tried to) recreation in non monochrome mmd by different artist. Some people actually thought this's the original without the monochrome. While as far as I know, the original artist didn't even tell what kind of software or model they used to make it.
I mean, it's pretty obvious from the model and how rough the movements are.
サムネの慧音が可愛過ぎて観てしまった
同じく
10 year old me saw this thinking “mane where tf cirno at”
where's the cirno???
Sadly, shes not here
I feel so bad for the animator’s hand, i can somehow feel their pain.
does they feel accomplished after?
Thanks, I just needed a confirmation on who they were
“Throw an apple core and it turns to a woman”
-that one British guy that sang the song but it describes what happens
You mean Gasman?
@@HyperVanilo yah
The effort of trying to make transition smoth are amazing and well made
The 100 people that disliked this video must not know how difficult and time consuming it is to make one of these mmd animations.
Oh nothing just bringing you nostalgia
A wild english comment appears!
lol
+Ariabunny's Bunny World lol
Gotta catch it
Lol
Do you speak fluent japanese now?
I love Reimu's expression change at the start so much
13年前でこの再現度は凄すぎだ、、
現代のハイクオリティCGでも見てみたい気持ちもあるけど作るのめちゃ大変やろしね、、
By far the best attempt i have seen.
in 3:33 they used the older versions of reimu and marisa
The idea exist since the storyboard that uploaded in 2008
I cant unhear"wave a massive sword at a tadpole in the sky,but it swims out of the way,well in that case nevermind"
Someone came from Gasman
>2024
>Realize that this exists
>"This has truly been... Our Bad Apple"
THE LIGHTSABERS!!!!
PumperNickles your gabe picture doh
U replaced the pic of gabe
That girl is a jedi😂😂😂
とても良い！けど個人的には影絵の方が好きかな？
じゃあ見なければいい。そういうコメントよく見かけるけどそう思ってもいちいちコメントに書かなくてもいいんじゃないですか？w
そんなに批判的じゃないからええじゃないか
@@ゆっくり咲良 一回見てみてそう思ったからコメントしただけ。コメントは思ったことをコメントする場所。
僕もMMDも悪くないけど思いますが、やはり影絵のほうがカッコいい気がしました！
i've always thought Reimu was facing the other way
It could be, but the creator made her face towards us
Hey, thank you for creating this gem. I can finally see how those girls look like. It is amazing job, I'm sure it took much effort to do it. Unfortunately they aren't look like I have imagined, so I like original version more, but still! Thank you very much for creating it and for letting me know how they look!
I wish you all the best!
This was reuploaded from NicoNicoDouga. Original upload link is in the description