@@gloenigma Did you catch the "voices" part of my comment because you literally never know which Wendy you will get on a track! She's so agile and versatile!
eunha invented flower crowns True and I did the line distribution without the chorus part it here's the standings: 1: Wendy 71.24 Sec(42%) 2: Taeyong 38.24 Sec (23%) 3: Seulgi 34.16 Sec(21%) 4: Joy 14.36 Sec(9%) 5: Irene 9.12sec(5%)
Wendys voice matches this song SO WELL. I'm not trying to be mean and offend the other RV members bc i fricken love RV but this is like Wendys song. She looked the best in this song, sang legit almost the entire song and it just matches her so well. If you disagree i'm sorry i'm not hating or anything but its my opinion pls respect it. I LOVE RV!!
Its too difficult to put Yeri in this song because Joy and Irene got a few parts of the song and the parts of Seulgi and Wendy just suit on them. And the dance were sycronized for them to dance.
+Amanda Silva well I'm sure SM being SM they could add her in some way? Like they did happiness but it's fine if they don't put her in there I just thought I would be cool to see an updated version with her and see how different it would be
They probably won't perform this song again, or not with Yeri at least. The whole choreo would have to be changed. Yeri's voice wouldn't fit well & she wouldn't even get much parts since her voice is still improving. I honestly just can't even see Yeri pull off this concept.
+Amanda Silva yeah and let's hope SM doesn't wait 10 years until they finally get their stuff (meaning fandom name:because im getting tired of being a red velvet stan, a Concert, and lightsticks/color)
if wendy didn't have that many lines i'd actually get mad wendy is the oNLy member in rv with only one position. a single position. and that's main voc. she's main voc for a reason her voice fits this song the best amongst the members too.
I agree! Look what happened the first time they performed without her. Wendy's vocals fill in a lot of colors on their songs. Definitely the best vocalist among most of Kpop!
Because of Taeyong you had to move all members bars during the chorus xD, it's funny, but hey, at least you can see now how much your bias actually sings in the song, cause they sing it anyways :]
YAYYYY You acknowledge when everyone sings :D I've seen that other ld creators don't do that and it annoys me so much. In fact, do you have a play list of red velvet line distributions? It's fine if you don't, I'll have just as much fun looking them up on your channel lol
djChives95 Taeyong got more lines than Seulgi, Joy and Irene let alone Yeri, if you don't count the chorus. But I love his rap here and that's how the original song was.
did you moved their bars during chorus cause at the end, they would have far gap from Taeyong's lines? cause if not, Irene's and joy's lines are just about taeyong's level, I think? maybe just a bit more from him.
i never count the parts where everyone is singing, but in this case i did because tayong is just a feature and he didnt sing in the chorus. and if i didnt moved the bars just for the girls the ranking would be diferent. Maybe joy and irene would have less time than taeyong without the chorus
+Watasy Wahyo that's my point actually- I mean, if it clearly shows there that Irene's and Joy's part are lesser than Taeyong's , many would complain about the line distribution in the group.
i never count parts where everyone is singing, but in this case i did because tayong is just a feature and he didnt sing in the chorus. and if i didnt moved the bars just for the girls the ranking would be diferente
wendy's voice fits this song so much
btsvelvet yes
Wendy's voices fits every song 😂😂😂
@@eyebrowstj YES!
@@gloenigma
Did you catch the "voices" part of my comment because you literally never know which Wendy you will get on a track! She's so agile and versatile!
I loves her 😍❤️❤️
Taeyong the new member of red velvet
sophia noelle the member who sang more then yeri(cuz she's not here)
His official color is red. 😂
Yes. Also Suho will be the added member to Red Velvet xD
Obviously Wendy has a lot of lines
Bada voice is so strong in this song
And Wendy can pull his notes so good (as expected from the main vocalist)
You should write 'her' not'his'.
the good of Red Velvet is that each one has their own collor *.*
Literally ;)
Lee Motosuwa the good of Rainbow is the member got 7 complete color. Haha
Ire Armel 😂😂
if you didn't add the chorus and the extended ver of the song taeyong would have more lines than irene and joy
He'd even have more than Seulgi (like 5 secs more)
eunha invented flower crowns True and I did the line distribution without the chorus part it here's the standings:
1: Wendy 71.24 Sec(42%)
2: Taeyong 38.24 Sec (23%)
3: Seulgi 34.16 Sec(21%)
4: Joy 14.36 Sec(9%)
5: Irene 9.12sec(5%)
Drawe GT hidden member of Red Velvet lol
i agree, but this way kinda right already Taeyong didn't sing the chorus...
Wow I didn't know there was an extended version!!!
Wendys voice matches this song SO WELL. I'm not trying to be mean and offend the other RV members bc i fricken love RV but this is like Wendys song. She looked the best in this song, sang legit almost the entire song and it just matches her so well. If you disagree i'm sorry i'm not hating or anything but its my opinion pls respect it. I LOVE RV!!
cc02 I half Agree. I think all the members fit this though. Maybe not fully, but definitely have a portion that made them get their rightful spolight.
I agree! Wendy’s vocals has a jazzy feel to it on this track and she sounds amazing!
Booming System Up Uh TY TRACK TY TRACK
I want Taeyong on Russian Roulette hahahah
I read it with Haechan's voice 😂😂
And same it would be amazing!
Flower Hana I SANG IT WITH HAECHAN'S VOICE OMFG THAT KID XD
what time is it
Imagine if Yeri sang this though? I can't imagine what parts she would get. Possibly half of Seulgi's bit when they do the chair bit
She would probably get one of Irenes or Joys little bits
She'll probably sang for only like 5 seconds
MryellowKy Haha. YERI should just rap here. She would be like "Boomin system my up. YERI track. YERI track." Haha
CJ Offline Hahaha. No probs 😂😂
MryellowKy they could give her the rap
*Wait, Taeyong is in NCT? I thought he was only in Red Velvet.*
I'm not sure whether you're being sarcastic or not.
Yeri sure looks different here 👀
Sometimes I wish they could do a little updated version with Yeri but I guess whenever they have their first concert they will lol
Its too difficult to put Yeri in this song because Joy and Irene got a few parts of the song and the parts of Seulgi and Wendy just suit on them. And the dance were sycronized for them to dance.
+Amanda Silva well I'm sure SM being SM they could add her in some way? Like they did happiness but it's fine if they don't put her in there I just thought I would be cool to see an updated version with her and see how different it would be
I think that too but it'll be too difficult. Anyway I'll wait for this updated version
They probably won't perform this song again, or not with Yeri at least. The whole choreo would have to be changed. Yeri's voice wouldn't fit well & she wouldn't even get much parts since her voice is still improving. I honestly just can't even see Yeri pull off this concept.
+Amanda Silva yeah and let's hope SM doesn't wait 10 years until they finally get their stuff (meaning fandom name:because im getting tired of being a red velvet stan, a Concert, and lightsticks/color)
#1 Wendy
#2 Seulgi
#3 Joy
#4 Irene
#5 Taeyong
wendy truly owns this song her voice is so good for it
Wendy's vocals are so damn versatile and agile. Listen to her blow! Man, those vocals on another level!
lol I like that you put Taeyong's line into consideration also !!!
Thanks a lot for this. Keep up your great work.
BOOMING SYSTEM UP UP! TY TRACK! TY TRACK! HAECHAN WHY DO I IMAGINE U IN DIS ONE?
if wendy didn't have that many lines i'd actually get mad
wendy is the oNLy member in rv with only one position. a single position. and that's main voc. she's main voc for a reason
her voice fits this song the best amongst the members too.
I agree!
Look what happened the first time they performed without her. Wendy's vocals fill in a lot of colors on their songs. Definitely the best vocalist among most of Kpop!
Thank you so much! Red Velvet is my favourite girl group💖
TY TRACKK
Wendy toke the whole song XD
Abby Colly she deserves it cause her voice fits the song lol HAHAHA
@@biancaglennise
So true!
So may start crying and call it 'unfair' but I don't care I love this song exactly how it is
Literally Wendy gets 3 minutes.
Give her 3 more. And throw in those vocals she did for the members solo stage at their concert.
I'll take 3 minutes of Wendy in every song 😂😂😂
@@yungwells6549
Ikr! Wendy's vocals are on point 👌 👌 👌
I luv their debut era
2:43 The king comes
if irene and joy didnt get to sing in the chorus then taeyong will have more lines than them
The title should be: Seuldy and Taeyong ft Joy, Irene
Wendy, Seulgi and Taeyong Ft. Joy and Irene*
automatic by rv pleaseee :)
check ultimate kpop channel
+Watasy Wahyo I didnt find this channel
search "ultimate kpop line distribution" and you should be able to find it
Ranking
1.Wendy : 192.7 Seconds
2.Seulgi : 149 Seconds
3.Joy : 124.7 Seconds
4.Irene : 114.8 Seconds
5.Taeyong : 46.2 Seconds
hey , can u do a pie chart / bar graph at the end to round things up ? thanks ^^
I love this song so much Thank you.^^
The thumbail too. Why you killing me?😭💖💖
Why the chorus is even in the line distribution
yes remove that please
Is because Taeyoung didn't sang this part, only the Girls. If Watasy don't put the Chorus, the lines will became desproportional.
let me explain, withou the chorus the ranking would be different because taeyong dont sing that part
TY Track
never even listened to red velvet, click because of the Thumbnail looks bae
YAS I LOVE THIS SONG THANK YOU
Okay BoOMinG SystEM!!
My favorite RV track, it’s so sad to know that people never talk about the Be Natural era ;u;
This song its amazing!
*still waiting for the shinee distribution that wont ever happen*
And daym i missed this song ♡♡
This song is perfect as it is
but Irene bby
Wendy ft Red Velvet and Taeyoung
piano man by mamamoo pleaseeee
agree!
Taeyong has more lines than Yeris’ lines in all of their tracks :| dafuq SM?
michael khoury Maybe because he is a better rapper and that's how the original song was?
I was saying to me that i found strange the fact that there's not Yeri but i forgot she wasn't here at this moment
where did u get the 1:30 - 2:03 ? its not from the mv
and its the very first time i hear it
Thank you so much :)
I love joy💚💚💚
JUSTICE FOR TAEYONG
AMO
Love this! Will you do some more screen time distributions for bigger groups like Twice and Oh My Girl? :)
Because of Taeyong you had to move all members bars during the chorus xD, it's funny, but hey, at least you can see now how much your bias actually sings in the song, cause they sing it anyways :]
Do you have the Line Distribution of this song without counting the chorus, I want to know the real ranking.
I like this
YAYYYY You acknowledge when everyone sings :D I've seen that other ld creators don't do that and it annoys me so much. In fact, do you have a play list of red velvet line distributions? It's fine if you don't, I'll have just as much fun looking them up on your channel lol
Wow, Taeyong got more lines than Yeri SM what are you doing
djChives95 Taeyong got more lines than Seulgi, Joy and Irene let alone Yeri, if you don't count the chorus. But I love his rap here and that's how the original song was.
where did you get 1.30 - 2.03 ? its not from the MV and its my first time listen that part
He added the part from the full song in there
If you take choruses out, the they sing around:
Irene: 9 secs
Joy: 17 secs
Seulgi: 42 secs
Wendy: 85 secs
Seulgi's voice tho😍😍
rewatching the mv i resized it’s taeyong from nct
what is this version? I've heard it before on the sm superstar game but I didn't think they had released it! how can I find it on normal speed :)?
Exoslight write on UA-cam red velvet be natural longer version
can't imagine if yeri is in this mv. also rv has some several haters before ice cream cake is release.
Y is the song different?is there another version??
this is the full version
In this song Wendy sounds like Seulgi and Seulgi sounds like Joy lol
Taeyong from NCT !!!
TaeYong do Nct?
Sim
sim é :)
lol without the chorus Joy and Irene will sing like 10s
Was the chorus counted because everyone sang except Taeyong??
TW Track!
Why is there an extended version of this song?
did you moved their bars during chorus cause at the end, they would have far gap from Taeyong's lines? cause if not, Irene's and joy's lines are just about taeyong's level, I think? maybe just a bit more from him.
i never count the parts where everyone is singing, but in this case i did because tayong is just a feature and he didnt sing in the chorus. and if i didnt moved the bars just for the girls the ranking would be diferent. Maybe joy and irene would have less time than taeyong without the chorus
+Watasy Wahyo that's my point actually- I mean, if it clearly shows there that Irene's and Joy's part are lesser than Taeyong's , many would complain about the line distribution in the group.
I think this is wrong I am pretty sure Taeyong sings the chorus too
It makes no sense to add the chorus in the line distribution.
Wait, why did you count the chorus?
oh come on i already explained xD
I can't find a comment from you but someone else said this:
"taeyong didn't sing the chorus. If he did, the chorus wouldnt add on."
Is it that? lol
a lot of RV recently :P
maybe you should do like happiness screen time
i tought about that. but is almost the same as the line distribution
+Watasy Wahyo fun fact, yeri also gets screen time in happiness XD
+Watasy Wahyo If I'm correct she's the first face to show up in the mv
yes youre right ahah :)
omg yeri is getting so many lines😍😍😍😍
its jk pls
whaen i saw taeyongs lines i think of yeri☹️
is it true the exo lay choreographed this song ???
I think it's not.
nope aha
Wow, Taeyong has more lines than Yeri
Please do EXO What is love!
is it taeyong from nct?
yes!
+Watasy Wahyo thanks
Poor yeri that CAN'T gets 1:00,00 in this song
Please don't add the parts they sing together... line distributions are supposed to be how much they sing separately
you are right bit in this case you havê taeyong and he doesnt sing in the chorus
but... but... taeyong isnt the member.... he's only featuring rapper... but its up to u...
Lee Taeyong FanBoy i know. but if didnt count the raking would be completly diferent
i never count parts where everyone is singing, but in this case i did because tayong is just a feature and he didnt sing in the chorus. and if i didnt moved the bars just for the girls the ranking would be diferente
Watasy Wahyo ohh, okk... :)
Yash
1:30-2:01 Sounds like SES
just put Yeri.I am more used to it.
No Yeri singing is unfair for no reason though...
+I'M A KPOPPER this was before yeri was in the group
Yeri wasn't a memeber of Red Velvet at this time so there is no reason for her to be listed here.
lol this mv is released before yeri join rv lmao
I honestly hope Yeri never performs this song. The choreo would have to be changed and her tbh, her voice wouldn't fit well either..
The distribution is actually fair tbh
i think seulgi's voice fits this song than Wendy's, idk
Nah, boo!
Wendy all the way.