The worst advise to give - Responding to NEW JK Rowling claims

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 24

  • @jennymcdonough2095
    @jennymcdonough2095 4 місяці тому +13

    I would never allow my child to make such an important decision before the age of reason kicks in.

    • @AmazingRebel23
      @AmazingRebel23 4 місяці тому +1

      I am trans and agree 100%, you never know whether your kid was touched etc or why they want to make such drastic decisions. Kids are really quiet at that age and some girls just want to be like their brothers.

  • @AmorinhaXD
    @AmorinhaXD 4 місяці тому +6

    "it does look like we have JK rolling making more claims and accusations which do not make any kind of sense"
    *Proceeds to show claims that makes a lot of sense*

  • @gghs9162
    @gghs9162 4 місяці тому +3

    Listen my man, denying that puberty blockers and cross sex hormones can have severe irreversible consequences for kids is not good fam. Let alone gender reassignment surgery. Also, the ability for a kid to make informed consent on the matter is severely low and they're ability to differentiate between gender dysphoria and gender non conforming behavior also comes into question. Therefore they can't give consent to a procedure that would have irreversible consequences.
    There is evidence of gender dysphoria going away in puberty, though of course how solid the actual rate stands at is unknown since some valid criticism has come of the sample of participants. Of course it doesn't mean it cannot persist. And to be clear, it's not like I'm advocating for every transgender child to be left to fate and let puberty pass without any sort of help or platform of support to lean on as they deal with these feelings. Because indeed, trans people are a community with a very high deletion rate and it's alarming. Also, I understand many trans kids (and adults) have co-ocurring psychiatric conditions like severe anxiety disorders, depression, clinical depression and some higher nuerodivergent rates among them. So I do see it as absolutely crucial that they can access proper psychotherapuetic and pyschiatric care from people specialized in dealing with this demographic and these conditions. Ignoring or suppressing these feelings are of course bad for the person who is feeling them and they shouldn't be cast aside for expressing them. Also I get it that usually when it does persist after puberty it amplifies in intensity and it's permanent; that much we can absolutely agree. So I understand if a young adult, ages preferably 20 and above that have a proper diagnosis of gender dysphoria and have access to transparent health facilities that provide ample information on the different procedures can undergo the surgery or hormone therapy to lead a new life. Rowling is not making unreasonable comments my dude, however obsessed with the topic she may be.

  • @NamaeAidiaNai
    @NamaeAidiaNai 4 місяці тому +10

    idc

  • @melanysmith3023
    @melanysmith3023 4 місяці тому +5

    Im so sorry but you cannot change your chromosomes, i pray for you😢

  • @gypsypixie4566
    @gypsypixie4566 4 місяці тому +4

    Go clean your room girl

  • @M1984FA
    @M1984FA 4 місяці тому +4

    And why did you disable the dislike button?

    • @francovalentino
      @francovalentino  4 місяці тому

      the video has 5 likes and 18 dislikes, so the dislikes are available.

  • @wheresyourscooter1628
    @wheresyourscooter1628 4 місяці тому +5

    Girl go to bed

    • @JackedLantern-yt
      @JackedLantern-yt 4 місяці тому

      It is a female but this world is so effed looking at this thing in the video calling it girl😂

  • @melanysmith3023
    @melanysmith3023 4 місяці тому +3

    You must be from another country, in the us all you have to say is I want a sex change and your given hormones first visit

    • @AmazingRebel23
      @AmazingRebel23 4 місяці тому

      In Canada you just have to breathe and they will take your uterus no matter the lasting complications. On the same visit I got testosterone my doctor wanted to sign me up for the wait list on any surgery I wanted. I said I wanted to wait but she tried to push me on it. This was only years ago, I can only imagine now that there are more surgeons…