@@augustine.o6190 you are confusing the concept of freedom, with democracy. I will just tell you, that democracy is euphemism for ''''''rule of the biggest party(ies)''''''. In fact this type of democracy, always comes in colision with freedom, because if the (democratically elected) government wants A, but I personally want B, then I do not have the ability (freedom) to do it :) Of course, this is the best system we have found until now.
An almost lonely, brave an moraly honest voice in the desert. A voice that needs to be respected and understood..if our democracy will remain. Bravo!!!
The only way is to speak to Them in English, so the majority of well educated hence aware people any nationality could understand what is about with Poland case. Well done Mr Profesor!
Agree completely. It is better to speak English because when you speak your native the translators might mess up the words. It happened already, not once, not twice
As an English language teacher, I'm so distracted by his mastery of English that I often forget about the acuity of his thought: Thank you Professor Legutko for the service you are doing for all of us Europeans who wish to dismantle this EU behemoth.
sad that the uk guv dos not wont to leave and still try to help the e.u stop Brexit. we still have the Remona's blaming everything on this before it is started .
Yes Sir. I could see EU under (conservative) UK commandment, it’d definitely benefit and become a world power without even trying. Absolutely no chance to agree for this fake euro-German state that’s already crushing European economics.
Profesor zawsze mówi logicznie i na temat żeby więcej takich ludzi na świecie było świat stał by się piękniejszy iszlachetny dziękujemy panie profesorze.
He's brilliant and his English is excellent although it's obvious it is not his mother tongue. His vocabulary is better than vocabulary of most British politicians.
Yes 💯 Thank you professor Legutko! Well said good reminder to Euro Club! Listen 👂🎧 Unelected Ursula von der lier! Take notes from this Intellectual! You may learn a little!
He summed it up well. But the addressee of his speech knows these things well. It's not like they need to be helped to realise this. The question remains if exposing them openly will have any desirable effect?
One of the few sane, intelligent and decent people in the EU parliament Professor Legutko. The EU has shown itself to be completely lawless, a kleptocracy where they consider might is right and all dissenting voices are silenced and the national interests of constituent states are suppressed by threats or blackmail by the EU Commission.
GOD BLESS YOU MR.Legutko PROFESSOR!!!!AN OTHER AMAZING SPEACH!!!THANK YOU THAT YOU KEEP DOING THE RIGHT THING AND STAND UP TO AGAINST THE GIANTS!GOD IS WITH YOU AND BE WITH YOU ALWAYS!MORE PEOPLE IN THE POLITICS LIKE HIM WHO ACTUALLY CARES ABOUT EUROPE,AND THE EUROPEAN PEOPLE!!LOTS OF LOVE FROM HUNGARY
I think with a man of that calibre he came to the conclusions himself. Clearly he is of EXTREMELY high intelligence. His heart, like Nigel’s, is in the right place too. Excellent! 👍
The EU is not imposed on anyone. It is formed by people voting parties. Its policies are determined by the peoples of Europe. It is the people of Europe to blame for not voting wisely, or for not actually knowing what theiy vote for. The great majority of the electorates of Europe vote for parties that want to replace nation-states, with a european federation. Maybe not in Poland. But in Germany, France, Italy(less so), Spain, Netherlands, Belgium, Greece, Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Romania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Austria, Ireland. All these people systematically vote for what you see Prof Ryszard Legutko talk about in the video, and which is european federalism.
I'm from Ireland and we do not vote for federalism. The EU turn more authoritarian by the day and our government say yes to every diktat. When we joined eu it was trading block only. It has turned into a totally undemocratic and corrupt monster.☘
@@herculeskoutalidis1369 Well, no. The peoples of Europe vote for their representatives. These people then gather together in Brussels or wherever, then create a super committee, who then create all these restrictions. So to say that the people of Europe vote for all this stuff is absolutely nonsense. So to say that EU is not imposed on anyone defies the truth of the matter. And look at the tortuous processes UK had to go through to leave this CABAL. I have no doubt that the EU suits some people and some business interests, but this does not support your sweeping assertion that it is supported by "the people of Europe".
The EU organised the BRIDGE network, a 2 or 3 year "research" project that put together small panels of citizen volunteers across the EU to discuss how to handle the migrant crisis. The most brazen suggestion was not only letting illegal immigrants vote on immigration reform but TO GIVE THEIR VOTES MORE WEIGHT.
Poland places traditional values above those of much the modern world, particularly with regard to such fundamental matters as: protection of the unborn life, family as a union between a woman and a man, historical and cultural identity, redressing the imbalance produced by transition to market economy reform of crony, post-communist judicial system. These are primarily Christian and social values, but they appear to stand in contradiction to the increasingly ideological agenda pursued by EU institutions, and illegally imposed on all member states.
Sååå himla bra tal. Här fick EU Ursula höra hur illa unionen sköts o bestämmer över länderna utan ens kompetens. Tal i klass ned vår Charlie Reimers. Stort tack.😊👏👏👏
This man is brilliant in exposing the EUSSR for what it has become. The all powerful juggernaut intent on only getting its way. Thank goodness the UK left.
This is exactly why many people in the UK voted for Brexit. They could see the way the EU wanted to go and didnt like it. but rather than fight to improve and change what was wrong wiuth the EU they felt that it was a lot casuse and it was unlike to change so the only solution was we needed to leave instead.
Exactly. Most remainers in the UK whinge about the economics. They ignore the erosion and destruction of democracy. They ignore it because they have no answer for it!
Nah, they are just normal and deliberately unchained from the blinding wall you have built around you. I wouldn't have a government like Poland even if anyone paid me. I don't need a religion-devoted party to lead a country. Ironically, you complain about EU forcing leftist ideals into member states, but why is there nothing wrong with forcing religion down people's throats? Or aggrandizing the "family" ideal that means nothing to these worms other than money. Go live to North Korea if your arrogance justifies these measures, maybe u would be better served there. Amazing how half of the people criticizing the EU here are UK nationals, as if Brexit has brought them any improvement. For the memo, these idiots joined a club in the third round, and apparently refuse to follow or hear anything screaming "leftist" and "western" while still refusing to leave. Makes no sense to me, but whatever. I think it's like robbing, being warned not to do it again, but ignore all that and still repeat it, only to complain once more. The only logic that doesn't rly work is the one on your end. PS: Won't rly read any answers (no notifs), so feel free to waste your time answering this and aggrandizing your low-brained propaganda.
Very on spot 2 years after: NOTHING HAS CHANGED! SO WHAT? ENOUGH TALKS: ACTIONS NOW ! ! ! Change all this mess and put them all in jail. What are you waiting for?, more discourses, more laws, more immigrations, more money in their pocket? ENOUGH NOW!
The EUCJ finding states, ‘...in accordance with the court’s settled case-law, the principle of the primacy of EU law establishes the pre-eminence of EU law over the law of the member states. That principle therefore requires all member state bodies to give full effect to the various EU provisions.’ It is interesting that this ruling refers to case law, not treaty law. The primacy of EU law over national law is not stated explicitly in the treaties. The only time there was an attempt to write this primacy and the authority of the Court into treaty law - the 2004 EU Constitution - it was rejected in referendums in the Netherlands and France and consequently could not be enacted across the EU. When this constitution was rehashed and represented as the Lisbon Treaty, which did not require a referendum in any member state, this provision was dropped. No head of government would sign up to it; they all wanted an "out" and Poland is the first to use that loophole. And, by the way, who set the precedent in EU case law that the EUCJ was superior to national law? The Court itself!! Not an elected politician and certainly not the people. In all 27 member states - and one ex-member state - the fact that there is a 'top level' Supreme, High or Constitutional court in their national system, to which all other courts in the country are subordinate, is explicitly stated in their constitution.
Wrong. Article 7 of the Lisbon Treaty specifically states that supremacy of the EU Law must be upheld. It even quotes a previous judgement, recognizing that while the treaty will not forecast any points to it, it stresses that for the EU to function normally, member states must abide by the directives, decisions and articles in order to form a natural cohesion in the European Community. Without such supremacy, the European Union could not function as any member state can just single handedly refuse to obey anything and kill the entire system.
@@esdeath7674 Wrong. Why? Nowhere is the word SUPREMACY used! This is exactly the problem with all the amendments and alterations that plague humanity since day 1 . Which is why , as an ancient example, the Jews created the Talmud so that it can interpret the Torah. Having been to Law School, I can attest thta the very first things to teach a student is the definition of "legalese" , "interpretation" and "argument" . Therefore, legislation is always open to debate and discussion , as a door remains open. Proof of this is the term "MAY" instead of "Does or will" . This is also known as an Own-goal, as the legislation is unclear what is national issues and EU issues , as well as where they supersede or not.
Cannot believe such few views ? This man has integrity and is speaking the TRUTH!
When are people going to wake up !
Thank you Professor 🇨🇦 🇬🇧
It is not Big Brother, that's why...
He absolutely nails it.
Professor Legutko uses beautiful English. I agree with what he says but it's an extra bonus that it is expressed in such a way.
He was absolutely amazing
It is absolutely brilliant and to the point. Budapest,2021.11.01.
Very wise and eloquent gentlemen!
Respect Poland! All the members should be treated equally.
Well done professor Legutko. The nonchalant supremacy of the EU law over the sovereign member's national law cannot be tolerated.
👍👏👏👏
I love the way how he expresses his thoughts.
means the EU is a Democratic system
@@augustine.o6190You can bet your life on it... All the brexitear bullshit means it. A great pile of bull excrements...
@@augustine.o6190 define ''''Democratic''''.
@@herculeskoutalidis1369 freedom of speech, to make your own decisions, and to be able to fulfill your goals.
@@augustine.o6190 you are confusing the concept of freedom, with democracy. I will just tell you, that democracy is euphemism for ''''''rule of the biggest party(ies)''''''.
In fact this type of democracy, always comes in colision with freedom, because if the (democratically elected) government wants A, but I personally want B, then I do not have the ability (freedom) to do it :)
Of course, this is the best system we have found until now.
Well said Prof. Legutko. Long live Poland!
An almost lonely, brave an moraly honest voice in the desert. A voice that needs to be respected and understood..if our democracy will remain. Bravo!!!
Lovely politician. Polish old school of expression.
The only way is to speak to Them in English, so the majority of well educated hence aware people any nationality could understand what is about with Poland case. Well done Mr Profesor!
Agree completely. It is better to speak English because when you speak your native the translators might mess up the words. It happened already, not once, not twice
As an English language teacher, I'm so distracted by his mastery of English that I often forget about the acuity of his thought: Thank you Professor Legutko for the service you are doing for all of us Europeans who wish to dismantle this EU behemoth.
Yes Sir. This explains better than I can why the UK was correct in climbing out of the cesspit that is the EU.
sad that the uk guv dos not wont to leave and still try to help the e.u stop Brexit.
we still have the Remona's blaming everything on this before it is started .
Yes Sir. I could see EU under (conservative) UK commandment, it’d definitely benefit and become a world power without even trying. Absolutely no chance to agree for this fake euro-German state that’s already crushing European economics.
Brawo! I am proud to be Polish! Thank you Professor!
Dziękuję Panie Profesorze!
Respect to the Polish 🇬🇧
Don't ever let them make you take on the euro currency 💱 keep your sovereign money
Bring him back Pls! He was a daylight for all the cavemen there! From a hungarian..
Wow - absolutely brilliant
BRAWO PROFESOR LEGUTKO
Profesor zawsze mówi logicznie i na temat żeby więcej takich ludzi na świecie było świat stał by się piękniejszy iszlachetny dziękujemy panie profesorze.
He's brilliant and his English is excellent although it's obvious it is not his mother tongue. His vocabulary is better than vocabulary of most British politicians.
Bravo Professor Legutko! Bravo indeed sir! God bless you, and press on with speaking truth to power!
Dobra robota, majster. 👍
Prawdziwy patriota, jeden z nielicznych👍🇵🇱
Jestem Niemka. Jestem szczesliwa, co slucham . Niewiaregodnie, co EU tymczasem pozwala sobie. Pilnie potrzeba, ograniczyc wladzy EU.
Yes 💯 Thank you professor Legutko! Well said good reminder to Euro Club! Listen 👂🎧 Unelected Ursula von der lier! Take notes from this Intellectual! You may learn a little!
I love this guy
Mee to 😊 he is fantastik 💕👏👏
There is still a hope...
Brillant! Proud to be Polish!
Absolutely fantastic speech.
He summed it up well. But the addressee of his speech knows these things well. It's not like they need to be helped to realise this. The question remains if exposing them openly will have any desirable effect?
BRAVO. YOU ARE TELLING THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH !!!!!!!!!
So proud of profesor Legutko👍❤️
One of the few sane, intelligent and decent people in the EU parliament Professor Legutko.
The EU has shown itself to be completely lawless, a kleptocracy where they consider might is right and all dissenting voices are silenced and the national interests of constituent states are suppressed by threats or blackmail by the EU Commission.
Brilliant…..! that completely sums up the EU project they are commis ..!
Poland strong
🇺🇸♥️🇵🇱
GOD BLESS YOU MR.Legutko PROFESSOR!!!!AN OTHER AMAZING SPEACH!!!THANK YOU THAT YOU KEEP DOING THE RIGHT THING AND STAND UP TO AGAINST THE GIANTS!GOD IS WITH YOU AND BE WITH YOU ALWAYS!MORE PEOPLE IN THE POLITICS LIKE HIM WHO ACTUALLY CARES ABOUT EUROPE,AND THE EUROPEAN PEOPLE!!LOTS OF LOVE FROM HUNGARY
You really have to applaud the Polish government. Fighting the good cause.
Excellent. Unfortunately most remainders are unable to understand what he is saying.
I often wondered about this person he was always sitting next to Nigel Farage in the EU parliament.
It seems something may have rubbed off on him.
I think with a man of that calibre he came to the conclusions himself. Clearly he is of EXTREMELY high intelligence. His heart, like Nigel’s, is in the right place too. Excellent! 👍
You are my hero
Time to live this Utopian project
Actually it looks more and more like a dystopia to be honest.
Leave rather
Brilliant truth from a brilliant mind. This glorious man is truly AWESOME!
You have my 100% support amongst so many, but , your beautiful speech is directed to the hard of hearing in that shameful chicken house🤣🤣👋🇪🇸🇬🇧
What a polite speech.Not one word about current state of anti democratic unitarian NWO
well said this man 👏
pieknie powiedziane i prosto w te butne mające gdzies ludzi twarze
Great Again
...z sensem i na temat..stara dobra szkoła..
I was supporting eu but not anymore. Its a beginning of the End
The EU is not imposed on anyone. It is formed by people voting parties. Its policies are determined by the peoples of Europe. It is the people of Europe to blame for not voting wisely, or for not actually knowing what theiy vote for. The great majority of the electorates of Europe vote for parties that want to replace nation-states, with a european federation. Maybe not in Poland. But in Germany, France, Italy(less so), Spain, Netherlands, Belgium, Greece, Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Romania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Austria, Ireland. All these people systematically vote for what you see Prof Ryszard Legutko talk about in the video, and which is european federalism.
I'm from Ireland and we do not vote for federalism. The EU turn more authoritarian by the day and our government say yes to every diktat. When we joined eu it was trading block only. It has turned into a totally undemocratic and corrupt monster.☘
@@herculeskoutalidis1369 Well, no. The peoples of Europe vote for their representatives. These people then gather together in Brussels or wherever, then create a super committee, who then create all these restrictions. So to say that the people of Europe vote for all this stuff is absolutely nonsense. So to say that EU is not imposed on anyone defies the truth of the matter. And look at the tortuous processes UK had to go through to leave this CABAL.
I have no doubt that the EU suits some people and some business interests, but this does not support your sweeping assertion that it is supported by "the people of Europe".
Bravo!
The EU organised the BRIDGE network, a 2 or 3 year "research" project that put together small panels of citizen volunteers across the EU to discuss how to handle the migrant crisis. The most brazen suggestion was not only letting illegal immigrants vote on immigration reform but TO GIVE THEIR VOTES MORE WEIGHT.
Leyen understood half of it, but it still made her ashamed. Good.
Delightful.
I enjoy listening to this man speak 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Bravo ! ❤️🙏
So well said sir
Bravo Legutko!!!!!
Brilliant speech
Poland places traditional values above those of much the modern world, particularly with regard to such fundamental matters as:
protection of the unborn life,
family as a union between a woman and a man,
historical and cultural identity,
redressing the imbalance produced by transition to market economy
reform of crony, post-communist judicial system.
These are primarily Christian and social values, but they appear to stand in contradiction to the increasingly ideological agenda pursued by EU institutions, and illegally imposed on all member states.
Jeszcze Polska nie zginęła
wow truth
Bravo!!!
Hope there are more like him .
Sååå himla bra tal. Här fick EU Ursula höra hur illa unionen sköts o bestämmer över länderna utan ens kompetens. Tal i klass ned vår Charlie Reimers. Stort tack.😊👏👏👏
Excellent
And there is no framework to get rid of EU leaders or their judges
Didn't see this in the mainstream media
So true for anybody who knows the treaties
An amazing wakeup voice in the wilderness of hubris and narcissism!
Right on! 😀👍
"Might is NOT Right"
The strong and powerful get it wrong too.
Professor Legutko is Brilliant !!!!! For many reasons we do not accept UE !!!!
Finally some with common sense. It is very rare these days.
Total soutien à cet homme.
Merci bien.
Bravo
A great man
Brilliant brain!
I agree with almost every comment that has been made. Professor you are absolutely fantastic.
This man is brilliant in exposing the EUSSR for what it has become. The all powerful juggernaut intent on only getting its way.
Thank goodness the UK left.
Well done!! Bravooo!!
LET'S DISSOLVE THIS EU!
This is exactly why many people in the UK voted for Brexit. They could see the way the EU wanted to go and didnt like it. but rather than fight to improve and change what was wrong wiuth the EU they felt that it was a lot casuse and it was unlike to change so the only solution was we needed to leave instead.
Exactly.
Most remainers in the UK whinge about the economics. They ignore the erosion and destruction of democracy. They ignore it because they have no answer for it!
Thank God the UK voted to leave the EU and leave this tyranny behind.
great speech to a very threatening situation: to limit the rights to self-determination by individual States. in the EU Parliament.
Brilliant! 👍
Economic Union European is like Soviet Union .
The EU is voted by the people. It is not imposed by anyone. Blame the people for not voting wisely.
Respect👏👏👏
Bravo Polen 🇵🇱 Bravo Ungarn 🇭🇺 weiter so schöne grüsse aus ruhige christliche Demokratie Land Ungarn Bravo Orban Bravo Ungarn
Well finally someone is standing up and telling the EU a few home truths
Now perhaps more people will understand why Britain left that den of iniquity
Prof Legutko is the man!
Excellent statement but left wing don't take it
they are too primitive to understand it.
Nah, they are just normal and deliberately unchained from the blinding wall you have built around you. I wouldn't have a government like Poland even if anyone paid me. I don't need a religion-devoted party to lead a country. Ironically, you complain about EU forcing leftist ideals into member states, but why is there nothing wrong with forcing religion down people's throats? Or aggrandizing the "family" ideal that means nothing to these worms other than money. Go live to North Korea if your arrogance justifies these measures, maybe u would be better served there.
Amazing how half of the people criticizing the EU here are UK nationals, as if Brexit has brought them any improvement.
For the memo, these idiots joined a club in the third round, and apparently refuse to follow or hear anything screaming "leftist" and "western" while still refusing to leave. Makes no sense to me, but whatever. I think it's like robbing, being warned not to do it again, but ignore all that and still repeat it, only to complain once more. The only logic that doesn't rly work is the one on your end.
PS: Won't rly read any answers (no notifs), so feel free to waste your time answering this and aggrandizing your low-brained propaganda.
Smart move keeping her mask on
Pearls before swine and sows.
Very on spot 2 years after: NOTHING HAS CHANGED!
SO WHAT?
ENOUGH TALKS: ACTIONS NOW ! ! !
Change all this mess and put them all in jail.
What are you waiting for?, more discourses, more laws, more immigrations, more money in their pocket?
ENOUGH NOW!
very nice thank you ecr
This guy only speaks the total truth
The EUCJ finding states, ‘...in accordance with the court’s settled case-law, the principle of the primacy of EU law establishes the pre-eminence of EU law over the law of the member states. That principle therefore requires all member state bodies to give full effect to the various EU provisions.’ It is interesting that this ruling refers to case law, not treaty law. The primacy of EU law over national law is not stated explicitly in the treaties. The only time there was an attempt to write this primacy and the authority of the Court into treaty law - the 2004 EU Constitution - it was rejected in referendums in the Netherlands and France and consequently could not be enacted across the EU. When this constitution was rehashed and represented as the Lisbon Treaty, which did not require a referendum in any member state, this provision was dropped. No head of government would sign up to it; they all wanted an "out" and Poland is the first to use that loophole. And, by the way, who set the precedent in EU case law that the EUCJ was superior to national law? The Court itself!! Not an elected politician and certainly not the people. In all 27 member states - and one ex-member state - the fact that there is a 'top level' Supreme, High or Constitutional court in their national system, to which all other courts in the country are subordinate, is explicitly stated in their constitution.
Wrong. Article 7 of the Lisbon Treaty specifically states that supremacy of the EU Law must be upheld. It even quotes a previous judgement, recognizing that while the treaty will not forecast any points to it, it stresses that for the EU to function normally, member states must abide by the directives, decisions and articles in order to form a natural cohesion in the European Community. Without such supremacy, the European Union could not function as any member state can just single handedly refuse to obey anything and kill the entire system.
@@esdeath7674 Wrong. Why? Nowhere is the word SUPREMACY used! This is exactly the problem with all the amendments and alterations that plague humanity since day 1 . Which is why , as an ancient example, the Jews created the Talmud so that it can interpret the Torah. Having been to Law School, I can attest thta the very first things to teach a student is the definition of "legalese" , "interpretation" and "argument" . Therefore, legislation is always open to debate and discussion , as a door remains open. Proof of this is the term "MAY" instead of "Does or will" . This is also known as an Own-goal, as the legislation is unclear what is national issues and EU issues , as well as where they supersede or not.
brawo Panie Profesorze! Wystarczyło spojrzeć na von der Leyen - była wkurzona, że ktoś odkrył jej perfidną grę!
We should leave this cesspit as soon as possibile.
Super!!!
Where is the President's reply to the question?
So what specific laws or litigation does Poland want or doesn't want to follow that the EU wants or doesn't want for Poland?
Brilliant and sensible totally unlike his audience who are biased and can't see past America