Weather the SC or other courts are following the Justice delayed is justice denied principle? How many cases are pending in these courts. Even after the petitioners death? What action the SC has taken? It should self introspect before questioning the President of India.
Judiciary 's thinking .,.. right but not in cases dealing with terrorists.. Cases of such magnitude if done at domestic level petition could be consumed. Courts too , should avoid becoming arbitrary.
What about the moral constitutionality of the supreme COurt's delay to decide hundreds of thousands cases pending, actually 76% cases. What about the moral constitutionality of the supreme COurt's delay to decide hundreds of thousands cases pending, actually 76% cases.
Justice delayed is Justice denied Wah wah, why justice is delayed on Cases related to politicians and religion Eg: case against Gandhis for National Herald looting Case against Muslims on Gyanwapi
ग़लत। विधायिका के ऊपर कुछ नहीं। जनता सर्वोपरि। न्यायपालिका कभी कभी अपने को सर्वोपरि मानती है और संविधान की मूल प्रकृति को बदलने नहीं देता। यह ग़लत है। १९५७ और २०२४ में विचार बदला है।
@sreenivasanpn5728 न्यायपालिका खुद को सर्वोच्च इसलिए मानती है क्योंकि वह संविधान को डिकोड( व्याख्या) करती है। केशवानंद भारती केस में विधायिका, कार्यपालिका और न्यायपालिका तीनों संविधान की शक्ति का बटवारा करे गए। अतः संविधान सर्वोच्च है। आसान भाषा में। विधायिका - ब्रह्मा देव कार्यपालिका - विष्णु देव न्यायपालिका - भगवान शिव संविधान - माता आदिशक्ति
Maharaj phle Constitution, Comstitutional law padho fir jan lena, upar unhone jo kaha h wo sahi h hindustan me teeno institutions barabar h ar samvidhan se bada kuch nahi@@sreenivasanpn5728
@@anandsharmaas3600bhai tumhari upar wale baar se to sehmat ho pr desh ke nyaypalika uadahran ke lie bhi bhagwan tulya nahi h Jinhe Kashmir ke Pandito ka dard nahi dikhta, Badi hui community ke logo ki jansankhya nahi dikti, jo lagatar hamare astitv ko samapt krne ke lie Sabari mala, Natej Singh jaise judgements pass krte h, ise use bail dete firte h, un dushto ke sath hmare devtao ki tulna unka apmaan h
The President of India is need to care on all citizen of India in equal proposition who when help sought from President of India to go in to the matter in detail and if any lapse on the side of giving justice to any individual it can be revoked from President of India on mercy it become so responsible to deal as head of the country.
Why time frames for deciding mercy petitions only? How long does the high court/ supreme court take to decide appeals against convictions including capital punishments?
Whether positive or negative the President should decide the petition constitutionally and dispose it. The President can suspend fundamental rights but rights under Article 20 and 21 supersedes the Presidents control and authority hence the court is not wrong in passing orders in this context.
ask SC why lakhs of cases are pending from decades .. what accountability they are showing for delaying justice to common man what morality they have got to question this mercy petition/president of India.. one simple cheque bounce case runs for 5/6 years where is the accountability..?
I never understand SGMC's soft corner for such terrorist/criminals.Why did they file a mercy petitions on behalf of him? SC is right about the delay thing,it is not acceptable.
Charity should start from home. It is deplorable to keep the cases for decade by the time mercy seeker may have breathed last. Pendency in SC is also a mateer of concern and it is expected that new CJ will take drastic steps to reduce the pendency of age old cases.
There must total Impartial justice for ABYA. No deals, No Bribery, No nothing of the sort . This was a COLD BLOODED MURDER in HOSPITAL time to Cover up has gone .
If death sentence convicted prisoner cannot be executed within a certain specific time then it's certainly something terribly wrong somewhere in the Justice system!! PS: Can anyone throw some light on the above subject which are the countries with best of legal systems and the rule they follow...
When Hon'l SC concludes a case,it is the end of a prolonged legal procedure.In case of capital punishment the verdict is referred to Hon'l Presisdent of India for consent.The cosent will be 'yes or no' and it should be time framed.
HONORABLE SC,, & HIGHLY RESPECTED PRESIDENT MADAM OF INDIA.. & Then Why even past 4 YEAR'S. NO BAIL NOT GRANTED TO UMAR KHALID. WHY NOT CONSIDER HIS CASE TOO,, !!.. THEN WHY & WHEN OUR INDIAN DEMOCRACY CONSTITUTION.. WILL,, UMAR KHALID GET JUSTICE'S..⁉️.. JAI HIND 🇮🇳 JAI SAMVIDHAN 🇮🇳
Whether it be the President or the Prime Minister of the country, a citizen's rights under Article 20 and 21, can not be undermined. It the Constitution of India that guarantees our freedom, rights vise verse. No one is above the Constitution.
President has to act in accordance with the constitution. Holding decisions without any reasons for long time is a clear dereliction of duty bestowed upon the seat they hold
President's discretionary power u/ Art.72 of the Constitution is ought to be desirably disposed of reasonably & fairly within a period of 3 years of maximum outer limit. In no case, it can be withhold for unlimited period....simply because of political angles and suitability of the party in power. Supreme Court, being the sentinel of the Citizens right to life & liberty is competent to pass any such order in tune with the Constitutional spirit.
If Article 370 goes to The Hague Even the president of India could be asked to appear before the bench as without the signature of the President law can not be implemented
S.k.Pandey sir, Let us not underestimate the "wisdom" of Hon'ble Supreme court---[Having levied punishment upon due deliberation in the case sir. Regds.
The President should put the judiciary to it's place. Sounds idiotic that the judiciary which has a backlog of several decades is now wanting the President to expedite her decision. It's high time our lame duck judiciary got the boot
SC is saviour of constitution. If executive does not take timely decisions or appears to be arbitrary, the SC has powers to order executive to act in a timely manner so as to executive's act does not smak arbitrary. Even President is also duty bound to perform his functions directed by the constitution. Ultimately constitution is Supreme and all those holding constitutional posts are it's creatures.
president ko seeng hai kya galat galat hai😅😅kaam sab ko samay par hi karna chahiye janta ka paise se khel nahi karne ka😅😅aisa nahi hona kaam murga kare anda fakir😅😅
There are many cases pending from years ruining the lives of innocents.
Hope the new judicial group thinks about them too
Our court fails in delivering justice.
Ask B R Gavai how can cases go on for 100 years ?
If president has to listen and act according to supreme court...will not chief justice become supreme...who is the first citizen of the country...
SC is supreme in terms of justice, I think.
What about life and liberty of citizens?
Weather the SC or other courts are following the Justice delayed is justice denied principle? How many cases are pending in these courts. Even after the petitioners death? What action the SC has taken? It should self introspect before questioning the President of India.
Judiciary 's thinking .,.. right but not in cases dealing with terrorists..
Cases of such magnitude if done at domestic level petition could be consumed.
Courts too , should avoid becoming arbitrary.
Collegium system must go, for sometimes now
What about delaying cases 30 years isn't that against right to justice see yourself first
What about the moral constitutionality of the supreme COurt's delay to decide hundreds of thousands cases pending, actually 76% cases.
What about the moral constitutionality of the supreme COurt's delay to decide hundreds of thousands cases pending, actually 76% cases.
It is high time that Govt of India should curtail the power of the supreme court
Justice delayed is Justice denied
Wah wah, why justice is delayed on Cases related to politicians and religion
Eg: case against Gandhis for National Herald looting
Case against Muslims on Gyanwapi
Are there no innocent lives that needs intervention and application of Article 21?
I don’t understand why the SC is always worried about the convict but not about the victim…
Right court must also punish the victims
@@RishavRoy-r3jhahhaa
भारत में विधायिका,कार्यपालिका और न्यायपालिका से भी सर्वोच्च संविधान है।
ग़लत। विधायिका के ऊपर कुछ नहीं। जनता सर्वोपरि।
न्यायपालिका कभी कभी अपने को सर्वोपरि मानती है और संविधान की मूल प्रकृति को बदलने नहीं देता। यह ग़लत है। १९५७ और २०२४ में विचार बदला है।
@sreenivasanpn5728 न्यायपालिका खुद को सर्वोच्च इसलिए मानती है क्योंकि वह संविधान को डिकोड( व्याख्या) करती है।
केशवानंद भारती केस में विधायिका, कार्यपालिका और न्यायपालिका तीनों संविधान की शक्ति का बटवारा करे गए।
अतः संविधान सर्वोच्च है।
आसान भाषा में।
विधायिका - ब्रह्मा देव
कार्यपालिका - विष्णु देव
न्यायपालिका - भगवान शिव
संविधान - माता आदिशक्ति
Maharaj phle Constitution, Comstitutional law padho fir jan lena, upar unhone jo kaha h wo sahi h hindustan me teeno institutions barabar h ar samvidhan se bada kuch nahi@@sreenivasanpn5728
@@anandsharmaas3600bhai tumhari upar wale baar se to sehmat ho pr desh ke nyaypalika uadahran ke lie bhi bhagwan tulya nahi h
Jinhe Kashmir ke Pandito ka dard nahi dikhta, Badi hui community ke logo ki jansankhya nahi dikti, jo lagatar hamare astitv ko samapt krne ke lie Sabari mala, Natej Singh jaise judgements pass krte h, ise use bail dete firte h, un dushto ke sath hmare devtao ki tulna unka apmaan h
The President of India is need to care on all citizen of India in equal proposition who when help sought from President of India to go in to the matter in detail and if any lapse on the side of giving justice to any individual it can be revoked from President of India on mercy it become so responsible to deal as head of the country.
Why time frames for deciding mercy petitions only? How long does the high court/ supreme court take to decide appeals against convictions including capital punishments?
Whether positive or negative the President should decide the petition constitutionally and dispose it. The President can suspend fundamental rights but rights under Article 20 and 21 supersedes the Presidents control and authority hence the court is not wrong in passing orders in this context.
Supreme Court my lords talking about delays??? What an irony !!! 😂 Cut down your summer, winter vacations first instead of partial workday jumlas 😂.
ask SC why lakhs of cases are pending from decades ..
what accountability they are showing for delaying justice to common man
what morality they have got to question this mercy petition/president of India..
one simple cheque bounce case runs for 5/6 years
where is the accountability..?
May prez dismiss this dilapidated Judiciary and build new.
But they can hear a case for a few generations even. Decades are a very short time to hear those cases.
A mercy petition to be considered or rejected must be decided within a time bound period say, not more than six months.
I never understand SGMC's soft corner for such terrorist/criminals.Why did they file a mercy petitions on behalf of him?
SC is right about the delay thing,it is not acceptable.
Charity should start from home.
It is deplorable to keep the cases for decade by the time mercy seeker may have breathed last.
Pendency in SC is also a mateer of concern and it is expected that new CJ will take drastic steps to reduce the pendency of age old cases.
There must total Impartial justice for ABYA. No deals, No Bribery, No nothing of the sort . This was a COLD BLOODED MURDER in HOSPITAL time to Cover up has gone .
Wonderful order by the SC
No one is above law! No one means in simple English, None.
In special cases the SC can direct any executive as far as life of a person or fundamental right of freedom is denied.
If death sentence convicted prisoner cannot be executed within a certain specific time then it's certainly something terribly wrong somewhere in the Justice system!!
PS: Can anyone throw some light on the above subject which are the countries with best of legal systems and the rule they follow...
When Hon'l SC concludes a case,it is the end of a prolonged legal procedure.In case of capital punishment the verdict is referred to Hon'l Presisdent of India for consent.The cosent will be 'yes or no' and it should be time framed.
HONORABLE SC,, & HIGHLY RESPECTED PRESIDENT MADAM OF INDIA.. & Then Why even past 4 YEAR'S. NO BAIL NOT GRANTED TO UMAR KHALID. WHY NOT CONSIDER HIS CASE TOO,, !!.. THEN WHY & WHEN OUR INDIAN DEMOCRACY CONSTITUTION.. WILL,, UMAR KHALID GET JUSTICE'S..⁉️.. JAI HIND 🇮🇳 JAI SAMVIDHAN 🇮🇳
Whether it be the President or the Prime Minister of the country, a citizen's rights under Article 20 and 21, can not be undermined. It the Constitution of India that guarantees our freedom, rights vise verse. No one is above the Constitution.
Supreme Court has requested to President of India only in this case , please don't misinterpret it.😢😢😢
Make it happen Supreme Court. We need it.
President has to act in accordance with the constitution. Holding decisions without any reasons for long time is a clear dereliction of duty bestowed upon the seat they hold
President's discretionary power u/ Art.72 of the Constitution is ought to be desirably disposed of reasonably & fairly within a period of 3 years of maximum outer limit. In no case, it can be withhold for unlimited period....simply because of political angles and suitability of the party in power. Supreme Court, being the sentinel of the Citizens right to life & liberty is competent to pass any such order in tune with the Constitutional spirit.
It's called a VETO . Read about it
Where is constitution is there that president has to listen to Supreme court ?
Even in dreams .. 0:38 They order President or PM...aaukaat hai? Joke of Collegium!
If Article 370 goes to The Hague Even the president of India could be asked to appear before the bench as without the signature of the President law can not be implemented
But we don't give a shit about the Hague jurisdiction 😂
@thinkingbeings3925
If it goes,then you'll know
President gives oath to CJI n President is supreme not B R Gavai
We need strong punishment in cases of such heinous crime.
S.k.Pandey sir,
Let us not underestimate the "wisdom" of Hon'ble Supreme court---[Having levied punishment upon due deliberation in the case sir. Regds.
mere according supreme court har trah kay constitution violence ko thk skta hai amd pesident ki powwrs and immunity ko ko limited rakhna chaiye
Hereinafter capital sentence will be executed without delay, I think
The President should put the judiciary to it's place. Sounds idiotic that the judiciary which has a backlog of several decades is now wanting the President to expedite her decision. It's high time our lame duck judiciary got the boot
life sentence ke badh keay right to life hota hei? kuch confusion hai.
Court ki overreach hai ye to 😂😂😂😂dekhne me maja aayega
What a comedy 😂😂
Ho hi nhi skta
President of india bahut achi hi. Kuch bhi hojayee kitna bhi problem ate madam kuch nahe kahati bahut achi hina madam. bjp jo prapose kiya tha.
Congress appointed presidents kya kehthathaa? Indepenent dicision liyaataa? Emergency kaise ayaatha?
@sundararamans654 isee liye har gaaye . Bolo aab evm hata ke ballot box votingkarenge kyaajj.
Mi Congress ko support nahe karta
Best time for president to ask for list of pending cases with judiciary since 60 yrs. Dood ka dood pani ka pani ho jayega
Order President?????😅
Mylords are talking about delay. It's nothing but a vikas for me 😂tbh
SC is saviour of constitution. If executive does not take timely decisions or appears to be arbitrary, the SC has powers to order executive to act in a timely manner so as to executive's act does not smak arbitrary. Even President is also duty bound to perform his functions directed by the constitution. Ultimately constitution is Supreme and all those holding constitutional posts are it's creatures.
Supreme court always order President , but not Vice versa
Discretionary power is not arbitrary power. Well said!
कोई भी कानून के ऊपर नहीँ है.
I think we should also talk about judicial accountability. This subject is just as important.
Balwant Singh is not a terrorist it's guru nanak Gobind or Shri guru granth sahib fighter
Hope judiciary shows spine and make President accountable and responsible. 🎉
Presidents to koi ummid karna bekar hai.
President must not be a Yes man but also take public opinion in every thing done' by PM cares funds raffle Pegasus ki enquiry keon nahin Hoti
Kyuki koi tark nahi hai jaanch krne k liye
Aare desh to had main jai abhi to Supreme Court khudko desh ka raja samajh raha hai.
president ko seeng hai kya galat galat hai😅😅kaam sab ko samay par hi karna chahiye janta ka paise se khel nahi karne ka😅😅aisa nahi hona kaam murga kare anda fakir😅😅
THANK YOU MY LOURDS . TJM. 7.