I am watching this again in March of 2024. I am at a loss for words. The Twin Towers in the background......so so so much has changed in the world and not for the better. This is like a snapshot of a time I can only dream of living again. RIP to Robin and Maurice.
It is absolutely devastating to see one of my favorite groups of musicians, with the twin towers, and the same people who attacked us on 911 are marching our streets. What do we do? And please don't tell me to vote..... I want action now.....
It is May 2024 and I have never heard this song.....can't believe I have missed a Bee Gee's song ! I have been a fan for over 40 years. Gee, TWiN ToWERS in the background....what a memory that brings up. It is so sad that we have lost three of the Bee Gee brothers; and now two of the Eagles have left us as well.
Robin's voice is angelic! May he and Maurice rest in the security of heaven. 🙏❤🙏 I could listen to this song over and over again. I LOVE the Bee Gees!!! ❤❤❤
Me too. I actually did the other day. I went down the UA-cam rabbit hole and watched pretty much every video of them, but this one got played the most.
I'm amazed that I am still finding songs from the BeeGees even here in 2024 that I haven't heard before. I have been listening to them since the mid-1970s, when my mom, who absolutely loved them, would play their music all of the time. But yet I am still hearing their music and loving it some 60+ years later. Now that, in my opinion, makes the BeeGees a phenomenal success! There are not too many artists out there who can come close to what the BeeGees have achieved in this lifetime!❤ And I will forever consider myself a BeeGees fan!
No man will ever beat Robin's soulful vibrato voice; always straight from his heart to our hearts, and souls!😇 May Heaven's Angel Rest In Eternal Peace.🙏🌹🌌
There will never be another BeeGees. Their voices were unique. Robin is amazing in this video. May Robin and Maurice rest in peace. They left such a beautiful legacy with their music.
Work of art in verse!! Sublime....Their eternal flame will keep on burning....their voices still be heard for ever .SIR Barry Gib keep us company with your music for good!!....
So do I. I was in love with Barry like every other female back in the day. Now I've seen and heard Robin's unbelievable voice; and I love seeing him when he was happy then- singing, dancing adoringly, and his beautiful heart and soul.
If anyone in the future wants to know what all the fuss about Robin Gibb’s voice was, they need to listen to his parts on this song. He was great on Massachusetts and I Started a Joke, but absolutely nails it on this one. RIP Robin Gibb.
Luv the Bee Gees wish I would have been able to see them. I always thought of them by Barry's vocals but later realized that Robin was just at the top also in these sonfs
Robin Gibb on this one song has given one of the most powerful vocal performances in pop music history.....only Roy Orbison's "Crying" comes this close.
Absolutely! All 4 of the Gibb brothers possessed fantastic voices but my favorite has always been Robin. Massachusetts & I Started A Joke have topped my list from the get go!
A voz, do meu amado Robin, é linda! Unica, inconfundível, maravilhosa, deixa a gente boba! É como fazer um carinho ❤️ nos ouvidos da gente, voz gostosa de ouvir, daz a gente viajar, sair da realidade! Suave, afinada, forte, gostossima, te amo Robin, forever.. Descanse em paz meu amor! Você, era demais, essa voz , me faia derreter.
I’ve always been a Bee Gees fan, and I adore Barry, but I love Robin’s incredible voice being really showcased in this song. . He really commands attention on the chorus. Magnificent.
@@simonwhitworth6872 What makes you think that? I don't think the lyrics are what anyone would write for a brother. The whole song is addressing a lover .
Mine too. I get teary eyed listening to him singing. This song is beautiful and no one can match his voice. RIP Robin Gibb. Love them all but, he was my favorite Bee Gee.
I love this! Seeing them sing with the Statue of Liberty 🗽 and the Twin Towers in the background. It’s so symbolic that no matter how permanent, sturdy, or full of life things are, everything is precious and can be taken away at anytime. Take care of what we have and appreciate each other.
They would still be there if the airport security people would have profiled passengers from the middle east instead of worrying if they offended some Muslims.
I was wondering if those were the Twin Towers, because they scrub any evidence of the Towers out of videos. Sad that our history is not respected and preserved, but rewritten and scrubbed
@@annmarie6132. Barry said they had to move due to his fondness for starting fire. At times u can see like a clear bandage covering Barry's chest. He got some bad scars out of it. Ann Marie enjoy the holidays.🙂🇨🇦
I'm listening in 2021. Anyone else? It's a cold grey winter right now and we've been through so much. Beautiful, talented Bee Gees warm my heart and I hope this year will end better than it's started. Robin is spectacular.
@@Pamsmith59 24 yrs ago I nearly lost my lad who was 24 double Rd accident left for dead no hope left like a bit of red meat as he was taken to hosp by police and ambulance taken to the morgue as I saw them pounding on his chest too long a story told he would die 2 brain ops etc he survived I heard this song it made me cry when I came home after sitting with him for months he is still here but I've lost my older daughter and son since cruel world x
It just dawned on me that Robin is the soul of the group. Listen, and watch how you feel when he sings. The dynamic changes. Hit rewind, close your eyes, and just breathe..
Oh my gosh. That's was so beautiful. Made my heart break. Gave me goosebumps. Robin is awesome in this. Just like when I was a kid, I'm playing it over and over. Bee Gees are the greatest. Love, always ❤️.
É impossível não sentir vontade de chorar... Essa canção, esses caras, esse grupo, essa voz do Robin e do Barry... É meus amigos, esses são ETERNOS !!!
I feel I’m speaking to other soft souls like myself so I’ll speak from the heart here, when I listen to “rings around the moon” & “ whom the bells tolls” both bring me up to this dimensional level & I can feel all the brothers beside me & it’s a spiritual feeling that is warm & pure & you just don’t want to leave it, but I know I must because Barry needs all of us to help him to continue & heal & play the music that will never end,,
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN A NUMBER ONE!!! If I had a nickel for every time you have watched this, I would be rich. I have posted many times; this song belongs to Robin!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Robin so perfectly owns this. Miss his perfect, soulful self each and every day. He is forever love by so many. Thank you Robin for all you gave us. 💕💕💕💕💕💕
Arrepiei... Ag..eu TBM penso igual..escuto TODOS os dias ❤amo tanto que chega DOER na minha alma essa música..até choro de baixo do choveirro escutando na minha caixa de som..no último de tanto que amo ❤😢😢
Que coisa monstruosa era este Robin quando abria esta garganta, meu deus até hoje já estou acima dos 70 e não consigo terminar de ouvir sem me emocionar!
Magnifique chanson, les voix sont superbes. C’est vrai c’est le meilleur groupe de tous les temps. Personne ne peut les égaler. Ils resteront toujours dans notre cœur. Qu’en pensez vous ? Moi je les écoute tous les jours sans jamais m’en lasser .❤
every time I watch the video for whom the bell toll makes me cry it's so passionately sung perfectly by the Bee Gees. wonder if they know how many hearts they have touch for many years. Thanks BEE Gees lots of love Titter.❤
I don’t know Barry’s doing pretty well solo! As did Andy. You’re right Robin is wonderful but so we’re all of them, wish God would of have let them all stick around as long as most of the Stones!
Yet with trio harmony, Robin voice shines. Three brorhers needed each other for completeness. As much as Barry is a great vocal, his twin brothers backed him up with harmonies. Their harmonies are so unique.
In one of the interviews with all three, the interviewer asked them who was the best singer of the 3 and simultaneously, Barry said "Robin" and Maurice pointed his finger to Robin. Robin was the lead singer in the earlier songs but Barry took the lead thereafter. I think they should have Robin sing more lead, as demonstrated in For Whom the Bell Tolls shows, Robin's voice is the dynamite of the group.
I feel like I have 'a hole in my soul' when I listen to this magnificent song and know we will never see Robin and Mo perform again. I am soooo GRATEFUL for all these wonderful videos we can watch over and over again. This is one of my all time favourites. Barry is also marvellous in this one.
They're miracles and extraordinary, missed Robin his vocals are so thrill, Barry's also. Theirs songs very much happy whenever heard, but so sad, how much we missed Robin, Maurice, Andy, RIP.
Eu não poderia deixar de fazer meu comentário aqui. Meu Deus do céu que saudades 😢! Eu cresci ouvindo Bee Gess , amei , sofri , chorei, dancei … enfim! Eu sou um privilegiado por ter vivido nesse tempo .
@@mariamarks bb. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. Bb. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. Bb. Bb. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. Bb. Bb. Bb. Bb. B. Bb. Bb. B. B. B. Bb. B. Bb. B. Bb bbb. B. B. Bb. B. B. Bb bb. B bb. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb bbb. B. Bb. B. Bb. B. B. B bb. B. B b. B. Bb. B. B. B bb b. Bb bbb. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. B b. B. B. B. Bb. Bb b. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. B. B b. B. B. B bb. B b b b. B b. B b. B. B. B. B b. B. B b b. B. B. B. B. B b. B. Bb. B. Bb. Bb bb. B bb. B. Bb. B b b. B b b. B bb. Bb. B bbb. Bb. B. B b. B bb b bb. B. B b b. B. B b b b b. B. B b b bb b b. B b b bb b b. B. B. B. B b. B b b b. B. B. Bbb b. B. B. B b bb bb b. B. B. B. B. B b b. B. B b b b. B. B bb. B b b b b. B b b. Bb bb b. B. Bb. B. B b. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. B b bb. B b b. Bb b bb. Bb. Bb. B. B. B b. B b b. B. B. B bb bb. Bb b. B. Bbbb b b. B. B b. Bb. B. Bb b b bb bb. B b b. B b. B bb b b bb b bb. B. Bb b bb. B. B b. B b bbb b. B bb bb b. B b b b b b b bbb b b. B. B. B. Bb b. Bb bb. B b b b b. Bb. B. B b b b b. B. B b b b. B b. B b b b. B b b. B b b. Bb. Bb b. B b bb. Bb. B bbbb b b b bb bb bb. Bb. Bb bb. B b bbb. B. B b b b b bb bb. B b. B bbb b b bbb bb b b bbb b bb. B. Bb. B bb bb bb b. Bb b bb. Bbbb. Bb. Bbb. Bb. B b b. Bb bb. B. Bb bb. Bbb bb b b b b b b b b bb. B. B b b b bb bb b bb. B bb. Bbbb. B. B b b. B. Bb b b bb. B. Bb. B. B. B. B b bb b bb b b. B b b b b b b b b b bb. B. Bb b b. B b. B. B b. B b. B b b bb. Bb b b. B. B b b b. B. B b. B b. B b bb. B b. B bb b b b. B b b b b b bbbb. B bbbb b. Bb b b b. B b b. B. Bb bb. B b. B bb bb b. B b bbb b. Bbb bb. B b bb. B b bb. B bb. Bb bbb b. Bb. Bb b. B bb bb bb. Bb. Bb b b. Bb. Bb. B b bb. B bb bb. B bbb b bbbbbb b bbb. B. Bb. Bb bb. Bb b bb bbbb b. B b bb b. B b. B b b bb. B. B b b b. B bb. Bb. B b. B b bb bb b. B. B b. B. B b b. B b. B. B. B bb b. B b. B b. B. B b b. B b b b. B b b. B bb. Bb b b bb. B bb b. B b b. B. B b b b b b. B b b b bb b bb. Bb b b b bb b b b bbb bb b. Bb bb b. Bb bb b b bb. B b b bbbb bbb bbb bb bb bb. B bb bb bbbbb b. B. B. B b bb. B bb b. Bbb b b b bb. Bb b. B b bb b b b b b bbb b. Bb. B b b b b b b b bb. B. B. B bb b. B b b b b. B b b b bbb. B b bb. B b bb b. B bbbb. B b. B. B bb b bbb. B bb. B. Bb bb bb bb b bb. Bb bb bb b. B. Bb. Bb b. Bbb bbb b bbbbbb. Bb bb b b b. B. B. B bb bbb b b. B. B bbb b bb bb b b b. B. Bb bbbb b. B b bb b b. Bb. B b b. B. B b b b b. B b b. Bb. B b. Bb. B. B bb b b b. Bb bb b b b. B bb bb b b b. B b b bb. Bbb b b bb. B b b b bb. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. B b b b bb b. B b b. B. B b. B. B. B b. B. B. B. B b b b b. B. B b. B b b. B bb b b. Bb bb b. B b bb. B b b b b b b b b b. B b b. Bb bb. Bb bb b b bb. B. B. B bb. B bb b. B b b b b bb. Bb b. Bb. B bb b b b bb b b b. B. B bb bbb. B b b bb bb. B b. B. Bb. B b b b bb b b. B. B b b b. B. B. B. B b b b. B. B b. B b b. B b bbbb bb b b b b b. B b b b b b. Bb bb b. Bb. B. B bb bb b b b b b b. B b b b b bb b. B b. B. B. Bb b. B b b b b b b b b b. B b b b. B b b b bb. B bb b b b bb bb b. B b. B b b b b bb b. B b bb. B. B b. Bb bb b b. B bb b b. Bb b bbb b b b bb b bb b b b b bb b b bb b bb b b b b b. Bbbb. B. B bb. B. B bb. Bbb b. B b b b b b. B b. B b. Bb. Bb. U. U iijjkn. J jjjj j. Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii kkkkkil o n nm8m
I am watching this again in March of 2024. I am at a loss for words. The Twin Towers in the background......so so so much has changed in the world and not for the better. This is like a snapshot of a time I can only dream of living again. RIP to Robin and Maurice.
I couldn’t of said it any better ….😢
Great Words such a sad world we live in today
It is absolutely devastating to see one of my favorite groups of musicians, with the twin towers, and the same people who attacked us on 911 are marching our streets.
What do we do? And please don't tell me to vote.....
I want action now.....
Good commentar, yes we missing the TWINS (both)
@@Phantom1963
God Bless NY, Greetings from Germany 🍀
There is no words to describe Robins voice. Straight to the soul.
Tudo passa,somente a palavra de Deus permanece para sempre.
@@Marquinhos-w8i, that is right
Verdade
So true. His voice suits this song so well. I want to listen to him sing it all day.
I agree. I get a chilling feeling listening to him sing. I hope he knew how many people loved him and loved his unique and beautiful voice. ❤
Very beautiful song.Who's with me?
Me!
Me too!!!
Awesome song.
🙋♀️ 🎼 🎶 💖 Me
beautiful song! real song!
I am
I am a 55 yr old woman who's listened to the bee gees all my life. Robin's voice in this still gives me goosebumps
I'll always miss my Songbird Robin's voice that came from his heart💖 and soul; every single time! 🙏😇🥲♥🎵🎼🌈🌠
55 years, NOT old, best time 🍀 and the bell toll 😉
@@JanWhorton
Nice to meet you again, good night 🌔 and greetings from Germany 😉
@@Colombo70 Gotta figure out how a chatroom works myself. 🙃 💁 🌠🍀 Have a good evening, you and your wife.
It is May 2024 and I have never heard this song.....can't believe I have missed a Bee Gee's song ! I have been a fan for over 40 years. Gee, TWiN ToWERS in the background....what a memory that brings up. It is so sad that we have lost three of the Bee Gee brothers; and now two of the Eagles have left us as well.
Unfortunately, a certain era ends, people pass away and the world changes.
Robin's voice pierces through your soul...
I can’t stop listening….
@@marioalvaro469 😇🌈♥ Me neither!📀
@@marioalvaro469 Me neither @marioalvaro469. Robin Gibb tribute playing now. Already played Massachusetts! 🌈🎵
@@marioalvaro469 Neither can I; but right now I'm Not Getting Too Much Heaven! Love all The Bee Gees songs. 🕗 📀 🎚🎶
Robin's voice is angelic! May he and Maurice rest in the security of heaven. 🙏❤🙏 I could listen to this song over and over again. I LOVE the Bee Gees!!! ❤❤❤
Me too. I actually did the other day. I went down the UA-cam rabbit hole and watched pretty much every video of them, but this one got played the most.
One of my favorites ❤
My favorite from them...play it on repeat all the time❤
I listen to it over and over
Muitas saudades e recordações! ❤
I'm amazed that I am still finding songs from the BeeGees even here in 2024 that I haven't heard before. I have been listening to them since the mid-1970s, when my mom, who absolutely loved them, would play their music all of the time. But yet I am still hearing their music and loving it some 60+ years later. Now that, in my opinion, makes the BeeGees a phenomenal success! There are not too many artists out there who can come close to what the BeeGees have achieved in this lifetime!❤ And I will forever consider myself a BeeGees fan!
Я слушаю Би Джис с 80 года, мне 62 ,Росся 🇷🇺,Кузбасс
Me too...
Robins voice was beautiful
No man will ever beat Robin's soulful vibrato voice; always straight from his heart to our hearts, and souls!😇 May Heaven's Angel Rest In Eternal Peace.🙏🌹🌌
There will never be another BeeGees. Their voices were unique. Robin is amazing in this video. May Robin and Maurice rest in peace. They left such a beautiful legacy with their music.
Músicas que simplesmente estão além do tempo...
Your correct we don't have talent like this anymore. Bee gees forever
Work of art in verse!!
Sublime....Their eternal flame will keep on burning....their voices still
be heard for ever .SIR Barry Gib keep us company with your music for good!!....
Very beautiful
Banda q nunca vai morre na memória mundial
Oh Robin Robin what a angelic voice you had.
Terrific song....but Robin’s vocals - UNBELIEVABLE. Such a voice! Forever missed. The Bee Gees are the best! No one can compare to their talent.
i totally agree wth you .
Ich stimme vollkommen zu!
Robins Stimme ist einmalig und keiner wird ihn je übertrumpfen können.
Agree 1000%. The best band ever.
Susan Smith - absolutely. Such emotion and purity -
Chime Shim Shaharah fungi fongah finding yung yongh links links links links Giant panty panda shire Gaourda wang hung Donald Kong doing Midland, MAJONG MIA JUNG AYAY.
Robin Gibbs voice.... simply undambelievable ! One of the greatest ever !
Supernatural voice
@@wendydubois3872 Yes ! ... sort of like exotic looking eyes he had an exotic sounding voice !
Robin forever,músician,good vibe
Eu amo os Bee gees
The greatest voice ever, in my opinion. Their Mother even said Robin had the best voice of all of her 4 sons! Mothers know best too! 🥰😇😇🌈🏅🎶🌌🌹🙏🎠🌠
Robin's voice is magnificent, it is impossible for me not to cry when I hear him. RIP Robin and Maurice
Beleza
Thank you Matias, your words are beautiful and so true. Robin was the glue...RIP MY TWO 💘
Beautiful voices love Bee Gees
I agree. When listen to him I get goose bumps.
Bella canción la amo y sus voces bellas
Started listening in the 70s, still listening in 2023, the hits just kept coming.
👍👍❤❤
LEGENDS!!!!!!
Robin has a voice that sends you to another place...R.i.p😢
Yes he did. To me his voice was better Barry's. B
Even Barry thought that.
Robin's voice sends me to heaven and back. Perfection
Agreed... I hate coming back to reality after bing watching him.
Love Robin's voice amazing
So do I. I was in love with Barry like every other female back in the day. Now I've seen and heard Robin's unbelievable voice; and I love seeing him when he was happy then- singing, dancing adoringly, and his beautiful heart and soul.
Same here, @estherb822! 😇🌌🎵🌈♥
If anyone in the future wants to know what all the fuss about Robin Gibb’s voice was, they need to listen to his parts on this song. He was great on Massachusetts and I Started a Joke, but absolutely nails it on this one. RIP Robin Gibb.
My favorite song where Robin owns the entire song is... Close Another Door. Gives me chills. ❤️❤️Robin Gibb ❤️❤️
Totally agree! Im 24 and I couldn’t believe his vocals. Just if the BeeGees and his voice came out today.
I Agree, sir!!!!
Totally
Luv the Bee Gees wish I would have been able to see them. I always thought of them by Barry's vocals but later realized that Robin was just at the top also in these sonfs
Robin Gibb on this one song has given one of the most powerful vocal performances in pop music history.....only Roy Orbison's "Crying" comes this close.
Absolutely! All 4 of the Gibb brothers possessed fantastic voices but my favorite has always been Robin. Massachusetts & I Started A Joke have topped my list from the get go!
Robin really belts this one out. Such a phenomenal voice that shake's your soul. We lost a treasure when we lost Robin. 🕶️
I never knew Robin had such a powerful voice.
@@wendydubois3872😢
Robin’s voice!♥️♥️♥️it’s absolutely heavenly♥️ what a fabulous song
I could listen to this over and over and Robin's voice still gives me goosebumps. I love all 3 of them but Robin just kills me in this. ❤❤❤
I totally agree with you❤ I melt when I listen to his voice❤
I know he is just special. Love him and miss him and Maurice and Andy. May they Rest In Peace.
@@Yazmin578
I know. It still gives me goosebumps. 💕💕💕
Robin, a sweet prince with a unique voice!
A voz, do meu amado Robin, é linda! Unica, inconfundível, maravilhosa, deixa a gente boba! É como fazer um carinho ❤️ nos ouvidos da gente, voz gostosa de ouvir, daz a gente viajar, sair da realidade! Suave, afinada, forte, gostossima, te amo Robin, forever.. Descanse em paz meu amor! Você, era demais, essa voz , me faia derreter.
Robin's voice is so powerful ❤
Robin's voice is so gorgeous in this song. I can't believe any other sound could match it's beauty.
It couldn't
I’ve always been a Bee Gees fan, and I adore Barry, but I love Robin’s incredible voice being really showcased in this song. . He really commands attention on the chorus. Magnificent.
Bee Gees maior banda que ouvi na vida.
As does Mo some forget how Mo brings them all together. Mo was one of the best artists
verdade
Essa voz do Robin arrepia!
You are so right I love the bee gees I play them every night I love robin he has a great voice they are great love Barry
Robin's voice just breaks my heart!!! RIP Robin and Maurice
And Andy Gibb he was the young brother not in the band,he died young OD,this song is about Andy x
And Andy xx
And ANDY too
@@simonwhitworth6872 What makes you think that? I don't think the lyrics are what anyone would write for a brother. The whole song is addressing a lover .
Mine too. I get teary eyed listening to him singing. This song is beautiful and no one can match his voice. RIP Robin Gibb. Love them all but, he was my favorite Bee Gee.
Ouvindo em 2023. A voz de Robin é mágica e apaixonante. Voz de 😇❤
Amoooo
An golden era gone forever. The bee gees and the twin towers in the background. It's heavy
It is, but I focus on Robin loving performing the song, in the scenic outdoors there! 😇 ✌ 🎵
Robin's voice goes and returns from another place in the universe.. amazing
That is a lovely way to describe his voice. It's truly beautiful
What a great comment thanks
I love this! Seeing them sing with the Statue of Liberty 🗽 and the Twin Towers in the background. It’s so symbolic that no matter how permanent, sturdy, or full of life things are, everything is precious and can be taken away at anytime. Take care of what we have and appreciate each other.
so very true x
One of the best comments under this video.. It's so true. Love to all and God bless you!
They would still be there if the airport security people would have profiled passengers from the middle east instead of worrying if they offended some Muslims.
@@Mostopinionatedmanofalltime because somebody wanted to drop bombs in the middleeast!
I was wondering if those were the Twin Towers, because they scrub any evidence of the Towers out of videos. Sad that our history is not respected and preserved, but rewritten and scrubbed
The "beauty " of the Bee Gees voices can still bring tears to my eyes. Loved them in grade school. Love them at 71 ❤
They are the best!❤️❤️❤️
Did you know these legends when they were boys? I imagine there was never a dull moment.
@@annmarie6132. Barry said they had to move due to his fondness for starting fire. At times u can see like a clear bandage covering Barry's chest. He got some bad scars out of it. Ann Marie enjoy the holidays.🙂🇨🇦
Me too !! They will never be replaced !!
Hoje em dia só tem porcaria eles são eternos inesqueciveis!
Me! I Love Robin Gibb more than any singer in my life!!❤
What ?? This is my favorite Bee gees song . My God iconic beautiful music .
Songbird Robin's soulful voice can never be matched!😇💯💜🌷🎵✡✝
I'm listening in 2021. Anyone else? It's a cold grey winter right now and we've been through so much. Beautiful, talented Bee Gees warm my heart and I hope this year will end better than it's started. Robin is spectacular.
Now March of 2022. The BeeGees are timeless.
Eu amo essa banda, saudações do Brasil 🇧🇷😊👍
@@Pamsmith59 april
@@Pamsmith59 24 yrs ago I nearly lost my lad who was 24 double Rd accident left for dead no hope left like a bit of red meat as he was taken to hosp by police and ambulance taken to the morgue as I saw them pounding on his chest too long a story told he would die 2 brain ops etc he survived I heard this song it made me cry when I came home after sitting with him for months he is still here but I've lost my older daughter and son since cruel world x
June 1, 2022
One of the best bands I’ve ever heard, and Robin he’s got a unique, beautiful voice I could never get tired of listening to this band
Robin had such a fantastic voice
Amo amo me leva para o passado
Robin is my favorite bee gees cuz he sings more beautiful.
Beautiful Robin Maurice rest in peace. We love and miss you.robin God really give you the talent of song.
This video is bittersweet.
The loss of Robin, Maurice and the loss of the twin towers in the background.
It just dawned on me that Robin is the soul of the group.
Listen, and watch how you feel when he sings. The dynamic changes.
Hit rewind, close your eyes, and just breathe..
Robins voice was so beautiful!
Robin's voice was beautiful and no one sang like him..
Just beautiful!
Robin your voice is like no other❤ Love you all!!
Robin has such a powerful voice,beautifull lyrics👌👌👌👌👌❤
O poder vocal que o Robin colocou nessa música alcançou limites estratosféricos. Simplesmente excepcional! ❤️❤️❤️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Realmente amigo
Magnífico
profssores do rock sempre
Shakes the core of my soul
Verdade mano. Essa música é uma das mais massa das romântica.
Easily the most underrated Bee Gees song!
Absolutely agree with you!
This is a live breathtaking performance!
2024 and STILL gives me goosebumps,! Who else??
12 of 10 points
I know right! Like one my all time fave❤
A voz de Robin Gibb é fantástica!!!!👏👏👏
Whos watching in 2024
Yo...26 / 05/ 2024...desde Chile 🎉🎉🎉
06/01/2024 in Sacramento, California USA 🇺🇸
June 1 2024❤
June 3, Germany, and 2025 too
June/04/2024
Skcoly
Beautiful song featuring Robin's amazing voice. 💜
Top
Your beauty dazzles my vision
My heart melts at the sound of Robin’s voice. That beautiful tone and vibrato... bliss.
Oh my gosh. That's was so beautiful. Made my heart break. Gave me goosebumps. Robin is awesome in this. Just like when I was a kid, I'm playing it over and over. Bee Gees are the greatest. Love, always ❤️.
É impossível não sentir vontade de chorar... Essa canção, esses caras, esse grupo, essa voz do Robin e do Barry... É meus amigos, esses são ETERNOS !!!
Dito 😢
Linda,linda, linda ❤
Sim sem exagero tenho 43 anos mas foi a melhor banda que vi em minha existência tamo junto e isso aí cantam com a alma asn Eliseu 🧐🧐🤯😝😄😃😄🤪
Cara, você falou tudooo
Chorar ñ mais tomar uma é inevitável
Robin's voice just gives me chills. No one can compare to the brothers Gibb.
Gives me a chill and a tear on my face. RIP beautiful boy.
The most beautiful voice I have ever heard
Awsum vocals by him rip Robin 🙏
I feel I’m speaking to other soft souls like myself so I’ll speak from the heart here, when I listen to “rings around the moon” & “ whom the bells tolls” both bring me up to this dimensional level & I can feel all the brothers beside me & it’s a spiritual feeling that is warm & pure & you just don’t want to leave it, but I know I must because Barry needs all of us to help him to continue & heal & play the music that will never end,,
If only I could sing like Robin 😇
One of my favorite songs I never tire of hearings. I love Robin's voice.
Robin's voice is ethereal
Your beauty dazzles my vision
Robin´s vocals r out os this world. RIP mate
Bee Gees,na minha opinião esse planeta não verá mais um grupo com tanto talento.Simplismente magnífico, marcou minha geração!!!
A harmonia dos caras....
Concordo plenamente!
São os maiores gênios que já viveram neste planeta. Quanta qualidade em umas músicas.
Pura verdade
Assino em baixo pra mim os maiores
Amo nunca vai existir outro em especial Robinn❤
I was surprised that this song never went to number one.
It was a bit of a sleeper and took a long time to catch on, very beautiful, both Robin and Barrys voices, a real tear jerker...
Edinalia quem que como eu está ouvindo essas músicas lindas?
Edinalia São Paulo quaresma mês de setembro
Robin’s voice in this! Sends chills down my spine.
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN A NUMBER ONE!!! If I had a nickel for every time you have watched this, I would be rich. I have posted many times; this song belongs to Robin!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wow, you can really hear the beauty of Robin's voice, absolutely one of a kind!
Wokal Robina niesamowity.Jeden z najlepszych wokalistów XX wieku.
Man Robin's voice was beautiful. I can't listen to him without shedding a tear. Rip to the bgs that have passed on. Andy as well.
It's the same for me, so many tears :(
👍👍👍😍😍😍
these brilliant individualists make one of the worlds best groups , your music will never die bee gees , i cried for you absolutely fantastic
Only Barry is left!
Me too, I don't know why I keep upsetting myself watching him.. Lol
The Bee Gees and NYC… what a dream! 😍
P.S.- this song is a truly MASTERPIECE! 👏👏
2022..i am in nyc wearing a bee gees tshirt coincidently and listening to this beautiful song and voices❤
Se existe um Nobel da música, essa seria a música...
Com certeza amigo!
Você falou tudo e mais um pouco, essa música é foda.
Linda demais
Lindíssima!!! Mas te pergunto: - Bee Gees tem música ruim?
Sandra M. da Luz Constancio k
One of my favourite beegees songs
A minha também
Robin is so special ! Best ever lived ...ever will be!!!! All of them...those voices and accents !!! Love love love!!!
Yes he is the best!
lolpoo
Poo
Brilliant lady
Robin so perfectly owns this. Miss his perfect, soulful self each and every day. He is forever love by so many. Thank you Robin for all you gave us. 💕💕💕💕💕💕
Soulful voice
@@SandeepGupta-hk8dr Yes. Unbelievably beautiful.
He's singing his heart out ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️❤️❤️💯💯👍👍💕💕💕
RIP Robin Gibb. Such a talented voice.
Nunca vai ter na terra cantores como eles
Don't forget Andy and maurice.
You forgot the oldest and the most creative head behind bee gees
La voz de robin me toca el alma
Uma música que marcou muito a minha história….
O que se ouve de Robin Gibb é o coração. A voz é só pra nós podermos compreender com palavras.
Arrepiei... Ag..eu TBM penso igual..escuto TODOS os dias ❤amo tanto que chega DOER na minha alma essa música..até choro de baixo do choveirro escutando na minha caixa de som..no último de tanto que amo ❤😢😢
Se eu pudesse ter um pedido a Deus, eu pediria que trouxesse o Robin e o Mauricio Gebbs por mais uma temporada na terra. SAUDADES ETERNAS!
Trabalharam muito querida.
Concordo plenamente!!🎵🎶🎵🎶🎹
Perfeito...
poxa .... ouvindo agora e sempre
poxaaa ouvindo agora e sempre
Que coisa monstruosa era este Robin quando abria esta garganta, meu deus até hoje já estou acima dos 70 e não consigo terminar de ouvir sem me emocionar!
We all get emotional at some point, and fair play to your age and yes robin was brilliant 👏 here.
Me also
Jorge
O Robin era emocionante
ele era singular
somos privilegiados
de termos vívido bons tempos 👍
Faço minhas as suas palavras, vivemos o melhor dessa terra.
To think the time of the bee gees are over breaks my heart. I hope countless young people discover there music. And keep it going.
Robins voice gives me goose pimples. Very smooth and angelic voice, very meaninful lyrics love this song much ❤️❤️❤️
Esses caras foram o máximo !
Até hj, eles superam tudo que já conheci .
Leaco Brandon
melhor de todos
Sim são maravilhosos
@@mariaveronica7443 de pleno acordo
oh boy where do I even start ..............what vocals, lyrics presentation ...... impossible composition... a masterpiece
Alguém em 2022 ouvindo essa obra de arte simplesmente apaixonada nessa voz Robin 👏😍
Eu
Todos os dias
SEMPRE E MUITO BOM OUVIR .......
Eu
Always !!! They are unforgetable!!
Alguém escutando em 2024👏👏
Belíssima música , sempre linda.
Sou brasileiro vou amar bidss sempre
Que perfeição de música como eu amoo ouvir as músicas de beegees.
Obrigado Deus por me permitir o privilégio de poder ouvir uma canção tão linda como essa, cantada por vozes mais lindas ainda..😀
That's fine. Free speech
Exatamente, essa música me traz lembranças boas de mais, meu pai que já se foi e amigos que já se foram, época boa de mais.
Todas as músicas deles são lindas só amo fala com o coração ♥
FAÇO MINHAS SUAS PALAVRAS 👋👋👋👋
@@marcelomariano2110teletransportando para 1993 18 horas , novela Sonho meu , tema de Lucas e Cláudia, eu tinha 8 anos .
Magnifique chanson, les voix sont superbes. C’est vrai c’est le meilleur groupe de tous les temps. Personne ne peut les égaler. Ils resteront toujours dans notre cœur. Qu’en pensez vous ? Moi je les écoute tous les jours sans jamais m’en lasser .❤
bien d'accord
Moi aussi.
J'ai passé ma jeunesse avec ces rois de la musique.
Ils sont les meilleurs de l' histoire pour moi
Pas trop "reconnu".....en France.... Dommage
Me too ❤
I can’t imagine how much Maurice and Robin would enjoy reading how many people loved them. Such a shame they are gone before UA-cam....
Robin wasn't gone before UA-cam lol
I love all those guys. Missing Maurice and Robin. Hope there singing in heaven.
They were great .still love them could listen to them forever.
But their songs will continue to live by all means..
I enjoy watching the younger generation discovering all of the great music my generation grew up listening to.
Robin es todo un príncipe azul, con una voz de angel que te hace tocar el cielo ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Uma obra de arte cantada em versos ❤ inesquecível Robin Gibb ❤
YESSS!!!!!
Absolutely beautiful harmony they were and will always be a soul sounding group that will live through ages. Love The Bee Gees!!!!
This is a beautiful song and I love hearing Robin's heavenly voice.
Sem sombra de dúvidas o grupo mais inesquecível daquela época!!!! Inesquecível!!!!!!!!!!!
Algum brasileiro ouvindo esse hino maravilhoso em 2021? Brasil ama Bee Gees!
Eu em 2022
2022 amo💜
2022 =)
Eu 2022
Janeiro 20 2022.💞um ano maravilhoso p ti💖
these are what i call real musicians not like the garbage thats out now these had pure talent
Too right!
Exactly these were so talented in every sense of the word, Robin's voice is something else
What is cabbage what do you mean by that?
Exactly
every time I watch the video for whom the bell toll makes me cry it's so passionately sung perfectly by the Bee Gees. wonder if they know how many hearts they have touch for many years. Thanks BEE Gees lots of love Titter.❤
lindo
Robin Gibb, é prova de que as pessoas são únicas e inimitáveis, e mais, nenhum de nós vem a este mundo por acaso !!!❤❤❤
Eu admiro muito ele, pena que já partiu😢
Grande Rob Gibb,grande Bee Gees!
Amo eles marcaram a vidas de muitos saudades 😢😢😢
Robin’s voice is absolutely great and fantastic! The Bee Gees would be nothing without his magic input!
Agree
I don’t know Barry’s doing pretty well solo! As did Andy. You’re right Robin is wonderful but so we’re all of them, wish God would of have let them all stick around as long as most of the Stones!
Yet with trio harmony, Robin voice shines. Three brorhers needed each other for completeness. As much as Barry is a great vocal, his twin brothers backed him up with harmonies. Their harmonies are so unique.
In one of the interviews with all three, the interviewer asked them who was the best singer of the 3 and simultaneously, Barry said "Robin" and Maurice pointed his finger to Robin. Robin was the lead singer in the earlier songs but Barry took the lead thereafter. I think they should have Robin sing more lead, as demonstrated in For Whom the Bell Tolls shows, Robin's voice is the dynamite of the group.
Robin is indeed great but I still love my Barry more.
Beautiful songs, beautiful voices, beautiful people. Now only left one beautiful person. Sigh.. how sad😔
I feel like I have 'a hole in my soul' when I listen to this magnificent song and know we will never see Robin and Mo perform again. I am soooo GRATEFUL for all these wonderful videos we can watch over and over again. This is one of my all time favourites. Barry is also marvellous in this one.
My favorite Bee Gees song, LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS!!!!
Que preciosa voz la de Robin espectacular manera de interpretar, Dios lo tenga en su gloria!!!
I love this song so much! Just beautiful. And Robin's vocals were absolutely fantastic!!!
Linda música. Quando Robin entra meu coração dispara. Amo 😍saudades😢🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Afffff!!!!? Quanto o Barry guib entra meu daí pela boca lindoooooo.🌺🌟🌹
They're miracles and extraordinary, missed Robin his vocals are so thrill, Barry's also.
Theirs songs very much happy whenever heard, but so sad, how much we missed Robin, Maurice, Andy, RIP.
Robin the best
Robbin é o melhor
Simm 😭
A melhor voz sem dúvida era de Robin Gibb, saudades eternas
Bee Gees é fantástico, atemporal! A voz do Robin é maravilhosa❣️
Fuera de serie hermoso
Concordo com você.👍👍👍
Concordo em gênero número e grau 👏👏👏
Amo também a combinação das vozes dos três. São incríveis.
Such a hauntingly beautiful song against the skyline of a pre-spoiled New York at a time when beauty in music and lyrics mattered.
It would be still unspoilled if the yanks did not mess with the arabs. The chickens came home simply to roost..
Nicely said
@@yyz0013 it goes way deeper than that my brother
Bee Gees pra sempre,Robin simplesmente maravilhoso
Wow what an amazing song
Eu não poderia deixar de fazer meu comentário aqui. Meu Deus do céu que saudades 😢! Eu cresci ouvindo Bee Gess , amei , sofri , chorei, dancei … enfim! Eu sou um privilegiado por ter vivido nesse tempo .
Privilégio irmão
Eu tbm ❤️
Para mim os irmãos Gibb possuem as mais belas vozes que já ouvi.💋❤😍
Concordo👋👋
A voz é linda.... Mas você já viu a letra? Meu DEUS, sem dúvida alguma a música mais triste que já ouvi. 😭😭😭
@@mariamarks bb. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. Bb. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. Bb. Bb. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. Bb. Bb. Bb. Bb. B. Bb. Bb. B. B. B. Bb. B. Bb. B. Bb bbb. B. B. Bb. B. B. Bb bb. B bb. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb bbb. B. Bb. B. Bb. B. B. B bb. B. B b. B. Bb. B. B. B bb b. Bb bbb. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. B. B. B. B b. B. B. B. Bb. Bb b. B. B. B. Bb. B. B. B. B b. B. B. B bb. B b b b. B b. B b. B. B. B. B b. B. B b b. B. B. B. B. B b. B. Bb. B. Bb. Bb bb. B bb. B. Bb. B b b. B b b. B bb. Bb. B bbb. Bb. B. B b. B bb b bb. B. B b b. B. B b b b b. B. B b b bb b b. B b b bb b b. B. B. B. B b. B b b b. B. B. Bbb b. B. B. B b bb bb b. B. B. B. B. B b b. B. B b b b. B. B bb. B b b b b. B b b. Bb bb b. B. Bb. B. B b. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. Bb. B b bb. B b b. Bb b bb. Bb. Bb. B. B. B b. B b b. B. B. B bb bb. Bb b. B. Bbbb b b. B. B b. Bb. B. Bb b b bb bb. B b b. B b. B bb b b bb b bb. B. Bb b bb. B. B b. B b bbb b. B bb bb b. B b b b b b b bbb b b. B. B. B. Bb b. Bb bb. B b b b b. Bb. B. B b b b b. B. B b b b. B b. B b b b. B b b. B b b. Bb. Bb b. B b bb. Bb. B bbbb b b b bb bb bb. Bb. Bb bb. B b bbb. B. B b b b b bb bb. B b. B bbb b b bbb bb b b bbb b bb. B. Bb. B bb bb bb b. Bb b bb. Bbbb. Bb. Bbb. Bb. B b b. Bb bb. B. Bb bb. Bbb bb b b b b b b b b bb. B. B b b b bb bb b bb. B bb. Bbbb. B. B b b. B. Bb b b bb. B. Bb. B. B. B. B b bb b bb b b. B b b b b b b b b b bb. B. Bb b b. B b. B. B b. B b. B b b bb. Bb b b. B. B b b b. B. B b. B b. B b bb. B b. B bb b b b. B b b b b b bbbb. B bbbb b. Bb b b b. B b b. B. Bb bb. B b. B bb bb b. B b bbb b. Bbb bb. B b bb. B b bb. B bb. Bb bbb b. Bb. Bb b. B bb bb bb. Bb. Bb b b. Bb. Bb. B b bb. B bb bb. B bbb b bbbbbb b bbb. B. Bb. Bb bb. Bb b bb bbbb b. B b bb b. B b. B b b bb. B. B b b b. B bb. Bb. B b. B b bb bb b. B. B b. B. B b b. B b. B. B. B bb b. B b. B b. B. B b b. B b b b. B b b. B bb. Bb b b bb. B bb b. B b b. B. B b b b b b. B b b b bb b bb. Bb b b b bb b b b bbb bb b. Bb bb b. Bb bb b b bb. B b b bbbb bbb bbb bb bb bb. B bb bb bbbbb b. B. B. B b bb. B bb b. Bbb b b b bb. Bb b. B b bb b b b b b bbb b. Bb. B b b b b b b b bb. B. B. B bb b. B b b b b. B b b b bbb. B b bb. B b bb b. B bbbb. B b. B. B bb b bbb. B bb. B. Bb bb bb bb b bb. Bb bb bb b. B. Bb. Bb b. Bbb bbb b bbbbbb. Bb bb b b b. B. B. B bb bbb b b. B. B bbb b bb bb b b b. B. Bb bbbb b. B b bb b b. Bb. B b b. B. B b b b b. B b b. Bb. B b. Bb. B. B bb b b b. Bb bb b b b. B bb bb b b b. B b b bb. Bbb b b bb. B b b b bb. B. B. B. B. B. B. B. B b b b bb b. B b b. B. B b. B. B. B b. B. B. B. B b b b b. B. B b. B b b. B bb b b. Bb bb b. B b bb. B b b b b b b b b b. B b b. Bb bb. Bb bb b b bb. B. B. B bb. B bb b. B b b b b bb. Bb b. Bb. B bb b b b bb b b b. B. B bb bbb. B b b bb bb. B b. B. Bb. B b b b bb b b. B. B b b b. B. B. B. B b b b. B. B b. B b b. B b bbbb bb b b b b b. B b b b b b. Bb bb b. Bb. B. B bb bb b b b b b b. B b b b b bb b. B b. B. B. Bb b. B b b b b b b b b b. B b b b. B b b b bb. B bb b b b bb bb b. B b. B b b b b bb b. B b bb. B. B b. Bb bb b b. B bb b b. Bb b bbb b b b bb b bb b b b b bb b b bb b bb b b b b b. Bbbb. B. B bb. B. B bb. Bbb b. B b b b b b. B b. B b. Bb. Bb. U. U iijjkn. J jjjj j. Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii kkkkkil o n nm8m
🥰👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Sao diferenciados muito marcante as vozes deles
La voz de Robin me llega al alma❤
Sim
Светлая память Морису и Робину. Их песни шедевральны. Мне 63 года и я обожаю этих парней ❤❤❤
❤❤❤