@@soulofislam1796 Do you have any non prapaganda videos ? Most of those pro islam videos are too heavily edited with too many special effects. Just read sahir el buhari(one of the most important books after the koran) and you will be onboard with the jihad. 97% of the Jihad(yes - it was counted) mentioned there is referring to war. You just believe the one that spins the ideas the way you like it. Too much echoe, too loud singing in the background. Can't listen till the end.
@@Humanaut. Ibn Warraq is a major propagandist. His own secrecy about his past really makes me think whether or not he really does speak a single word of Arabic, or like many Pakistani/Indian Muslims, he was just taught to read it phonetically without actually knowing what the words mean.
Ryad Derdar If you are so confident of your religion why do you dislike when people leave it or criticize it, you shouldn't even be watching this video if it hurts your sensibility
james thomas only a part of what he sayed is biaised, especially Islam during middle ages which was not worst than other religions. But what he says about muhammad and nis compaignons is right.
Islamic Scholar?! Ibn Warraq said he dont even make Salah!Prayer! He said he is not a Muslim, sir! What are you talking about?! It seems you are subjective in your comments and not objective. Ibn Warraq is a Kaafir sir, a non-Muslims, the worst of creatures! Sura Al-Bayyinah. And feel free to quote me!
@@abunamr1037 : U are gutter just like Muhammad the Muslim prophet. Allah was a minor pre Islamic God. Allah is a pagan moon god and good for nothing.
There are fundamental problems with Islam , I can not recognize it as a “ God “ given religion , I can not recognize Muhammad as “ a mercy to mankind “, I can not recognize Islamic laws as divine . Everything is questionable and I suspect deception and pretend to be something Islam is not .
Quite interesting that he had only a very mild Muslim background and wasn't 'rebelling' against a strict upbringing or anything. But we got half an hour about his childhood and then nothing about the in-depth researches that led to his famous book and the strong feelings against Islam that they must have caused for him to write it...
The Quran is less of a "Book of God" and more a "Transcript of God via Muhammad". It's not chronologically arranged, it's arranged from longest to shortest so it could be memorized easier. You have to remember that Arab culture was a oral culture and that the Quran(means The Recitation) were passed on word of mouth until over 100 years later when it was finally compiled.
@@synczy7307 there are 26 variants, is incomplete without fulfillment of prophecies lots of plagiarism from fake sources as Talmud Gnosticism and Jewish mysticism given by a very corrupt man
@@albusai lol it’s funny cause if you read the Quran you would know that prophet Muhammad pbuh knew nothing about this stuff until prophet hood and plagiarism from how he couldn’t read or write and as a matter a fact the Quran actually corrects a lot of stuff in the Jewish scripture like historical and Scientific facts don’t let these atheist deceive you the devil themselves teach these people this stuff
Take away: He was already far from islam the day he was born, following local traditions rather than religion itself. Eventually he realizes these TRADITIONS are flawed and instead of researching about the religion he decides to give up, blaming islam as incompetent and illogical. The biggest reason for the downfall of Islam in eye of the public is because of the same reason mentioned above, people dont wanna go the hard way, which is reading about the religion, rather choose the easy way out, which is listening to their guardians and preachers. The problem is that EACH AND EVERY person will tell you something else. Thats why Quran was revealed, to have a standardized copy of the teaching.
"without Arab advance in astronomy, there would be no space advances now…" Do not make me laugh : in 1200 years, the Arabs who had a kind of rudimentary algebra, clear sky and an interest in astronomy NEVER DISCOVERED Newton's law, and not even Kepler's ones. All they did was to give NAMES to stars, not a very complicated operation. And what was left to discover since the Babylonian had discovered the equinoxes precession ?
No one denies the contributions that different cultures have shared knowledge with other cultures: but let’s not play the same broken record of a narrative over and over without recognizing that fact
At (Surah 18:89-98) Alexander the Great was a devout Muslim and lived to a ripe old age. Historical records however show that Alexander the Great died young at 33 years of age (b. 356 B.C. - d. 323 B.C.), and believed he was divine, forcing others to recognize him as such. In India on the Hyphasis River (now Beas) Alexander erected twelve altars to twelve Olympian gods. The Quran shows errors in historical and religious fact.
@@Mulberry2000Mohammed pretended to know where the end of the world was, by saying Alexander the Great went there and back. This saying originated from the Alexandrian myths. Quran uses many local myths from that time, and has nothing timeless at all.
The reason a Muslim wouldn't waste time listening is because a Muslim wouldn't normally capitalise financially by slagging off another religion in writing a book.
Only 1/5th of the world population in 1400 years ? Would not one call that a strange failure ? 100% of the world, for instance, use Euclid's geometry (while knowing also when NOT to use it, as in Minowski-Poincaré's spacetime). 100% of the world use Euclid's (a Greek) algorithm, Thales' (an egyptian) theorem, and Bayes (a Britannic) relationship. Knows about the equinox precession discovered by Babylonians, the zero by indians, integer, negative and rational exponents by European mathematicians?
@wowamonn they raise money by selling bonds then buying the same bonds?! ( referring to the $600 billion deal) ?! this doesnt make sense at all!! please explain further!
No? So the Hadith is nonsense? OK...I will accept that and applaud you for denouncing it as a sick work of fiction for stating he did have sex with a child. Is the Qur'an correct though?
Irrelevant. We are not discussing here about personal matters concerning the speaker (on which you have no grounds to draw conclusions except your own wishful thinking, if anybody buys it), but about what is said by the speaker. Do not mix everything up if you do not want people to come to the conclusions that islam has "a very strange relationship with reason", as pope Benedict XVI said in a very diplomatic way :-)
Did Jesus come for peace? Luke-ch-12-vs-51(Jesus speaking) Do you imagine I came to give peace on the earth? No, indeed, I tell you, but rather division.52-for from now on there will be five in one house divided, three against two and two against three. 53-they will be divided, father against son and son against father, mother against daughter and daughter against her mother, and mother-in-law against her daughter-in-law and daughter-in-law against her mother -in-law.
The eternal problem of all man made religions: intolerance and fear mongering (= control over the masses). Yeshua, our lord and Savior, reveals and gives freely a liberating loving salvation, to have a personal relation with Him through His Spirit. Those of us that have been blessed in this regard understand and experience the amazing transformation that He brings. When John writes in the Book of Revelation: let him who has wisdom calculate the number of the beast, for it is a human number. The only Greek word with a number of 666 is paradosis. Which is translated as Tradition. The word is used 13 times in the NT (5 times by Paul, 5 times by Matthew and 3 times by Mark). 🙏
Just name ONE contribution of muslim countries to science since the 13th century, so we can laugn. Even Omar Khayyam, a real genius, expressed in his poems the disgust he had for religious people already in his time, before the lon idlamic night on thought began. He died in 1131. Read him (he was translated in arab too, though Toussain's translation is quite readable).
@lkaml1 I sense the usual self-righteous narcissism underneath the usual whining of "he/she know nothing about islam...." that comes out of self-denial to admitting that there's something wrong some with your religion's principles and claims or simply the inability to criticize yourself as well as the inability to open yourself to criticism. Ibn Warraq started learning arabic and reading the quran since he was a boy and is a top historian on Islam and Arabic!
Stange : when Arabs are supposed to be in advance (which was the case before the Turks conquered them, nor Crusaders), their civilization is "superior" (which was true for a while). But when the islamic world is, like the Ottoman empire, scientifically and technically 60 years to 200 years (and which 200 years !) behind Europe, it has suddenly "no sense saying that a civilization is superior to another". How strange ! :-D
Two reasons when Islam started it was very open to new ideas and peoples. That's is how the managed to assimilate different peoples into Islam. The Arabs at the time of Islam was very backward and had no clue in running empires. So they let the locals do the running and did not impose Islam on the population. If they did their rule would soon end. Some say they were brutal and some rulers were but they did not last long. Brutal rulers never do last, the romans were the exception but they offered caveats for local populations, if they accepted roman rule eventually they come roman citizens. Of course the elites in Rome did not want that as it meant a challenge to their power. The Arabs felt the same so they did not want people to convert, well not fast enough. So for 300 years the Islamic empire was a rough diamond, it has most of the world's Christian population, but not many Muslims. Of course over time as taxes grew people just converted to Islam to avoid them, or did it out of fear or conviction. Eventually the Muslims got so good at civilisation they felt they had learnt all that was and closed the door to more learning. The door to ijtihad was closed - the door to reasoning. The Muslim world eventually ran out of steam and with nothing new coming up the pipe line declined. If you think the Muslim world is barbaric and yes in some parts they are, but compared to the West, they are nice guys who love not to kill people.
"it's arranged from longest to shortest" Except the first one, I think. But yes, I checked that on Linux with the ls -l command, imported the results to make an LibreOffice graph, and it is clearly statistically true.
@bozzeed " He bucked when Muhammad came to mount him. The angel Jibril (Gabriel) put his hand on his mane and said: "Are you not ashamed, O Buraq? By Allah, no-one has ridden you in all creation more dear to Allah than he is." Hearing this he was so ashamed that he sweated until he became soaked, and he stood still so that the Prophet mounted him "
@bozzeed Matthew 7: 1 Judge not, that ye be not judged. 2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged... Matthew 6: 14 For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you: 15 But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses. John 8: 7 He that is WITHOUT SIN among you, let him first cast a stone at her. Sharia law is the HIGHWAY TO HELL.
@bozzeed Oh please stop with the strawman statment you HAVENT provided ANY rebuttals to anything that I posted. When Mohammed ' flew ' to Jerusalem and tied his horse to the ring the prophets used. You do know that there existed no temple in Jesusalem in the 7th century right? the second jewish temple was destroyed almost six centuries earlier.
@elmirasahar the punishment for adultery is mentioned in sura24:2 for non married couple. as for married couple their punishment is stonned to death. there is an ayah called ayah al rajm. i dont know the number but there are hadiths that prove that who commit adultery when married is to be stonned.
@wowamonn well i did explain that taking interest and usury is prohibited in islam because it makes the rich wealthy and the poor under constant debt just as what is happening to the third world countries today who are struggling to pay the interest ALONE of their principal loans which they got from world bank. in islam also the rich will HAVE TO pay zakat (tax) to the poor (not governments) to reduce the range of wealth between the rich and the poor. so definitely it is a better system
@bozzeed If you cheated on your wife does she have the right to file for a divorce from you since you were the one who commited adultry and what are the consequences for you since you commted the act.
Its good that you are not Muslim, i am not Muslim because the background of islam and what its sources say, when they say that the Islamic prophet Muhammad thought that he was demon possessed and became suicidal when he received the Revelations from the angel. This is a huge problem because when God appears or an angel does, its undeniable. God is good and His angels, pure and holy. If Muhammad could not see that then its a problem, it diminishes god and his knowledge to be able to come across well and anticipate. Allah couldnt anticipate well if Muhammad became suicidal and tried to kill himself.
Quran: (SURAH-3-THE FAMILY OF IMRAN-VS-19) Surely the (true) religion with allah is Islam, and those to whom the book had been given did not show opposition but after the knowledge had come to them, out of envy among themselves; and whoever disbelieve in the communications
Did you ever read Omar Khayyam ? OK, he was said to have powerful protections, like VERY intelligent men often do. He wrote about what he thought about believers he could see around him, and about the obvious lack of interest of God - if God existed - towards the humans. A genius of his times, unfortunately exiled in a time of history and country he was not made for. He belong to OUR world, not the one of his contemporaries.
If the word "Allah/al-Ilah" is of pagan origin, then so is the Judeo-Christian term for God-"El/Eloah/Elohim" which are all dervided from the same root word as the Arabic. Does the fact that Jesus is known as "Immanuel" ("El/Al is with us") by certain Christian accounts really negate its meaning to his followers? And Arabic was written...in fact, there were a wide variety of Arabic alphabets, and dialects at the time.
@bozzeed " Then he [Gabriel] brought the Buraq, handsome-faced and bridled, a tall, white beast, bigger than the donkey but smaller than the mule. He could place his hooves at the farthest boundary of his gaze. He had long ears. Whenever he faced a mountain his hind legs would extend, and whenever he went downhill his front legs would extend. He had two wings on his thighs which lent strength to his legs "
@bozzeed I would file for divorce because obviously she does not appreciate the campionship of her husband end of story, no revenge, no pissed off behaviour just a logical end to a bad relationship.
@lkaml1 Nope, no narcissism from my end. No, you don't believe in all the other religions. In Islam there is only one god (allah) and his messenger, which is muhammed, the last and final prophet. All other prophets in the jewish and christian religions are mentioned in the quran but are not deemed as the true messengers Believing in another religion whilst being a muslim is "haram" or prohibited as it is heresy and according to most muslim scholars, even apostacy
Ibn Warraq says we need to stand up for our values without apologies. I completely agree. But in order to do that, we need to have values. Do we have any values left? Or have they all been killed by hedonism and the stretching of envelopes? As in any dialectic, go too far to one extreme, and the opposite extreme will rear its ugly head. (cont.)
1 John 2: 7 Brethren, I write no new commandment unto you, but an old commandment which ye had from the beginning. The old commandment is the word which ye have heard from the beginning. => 1 MOSES 4: 15 Whosoever slayeth Cain (who killed his brother Abel), vengeance shall be taken on him sevenfold. And the LORD set a mark upon Cain, lest any finding him should kill him. Galatians 1: 9 If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed.
Re. Rushdie, speaking as an agnostic ex-Christian, who's fairly well informed about Islam, writing a book satirising a religion can certainly never justify violence, however I recently read the Satanic Verses and it reads like he deliberately set out to infuriate Muslims. It had a large amount of content based on the life of Mohammed that ridicules him and deliberately picks out especially embarrassing stories from the Islamic histories to dwell on. It also contains things like all the prostitutues in a brothel deciding to name themselves after Mohammed's 13 wives. It also specifically satirises the Ayatollah Khomeini. So, he must have known it would anger and annoy, but got more than he bargained for.
***** He made use of obscure stories that are theologically embarrassing to Islam, not necessarily things that are 'morally bad'. There are plenty of those in the sayings and histories too, but he didn't make use of them to the extent he could have if he'd wanted to just show Mohammed as being a 'bad person'. But the story he named the book after, for example, which is also an important episode in the book, wasn't known by a lot of Muslims before he did it, and is embarrassing because it shows Mohammed making a concession to polytheism - saying in a Quran verse to the Meccans that it's OK to worship their goddesses as intercessors with God, and then he changed his mind and said it didn't come from God but Satan made him say it instead... Strict monotheism is the most fundamental thing of all in Islam. No, I think people should be free to criticise or satirise Islam, but I'm just saying that when I read the book, having studied Islam a bit, I realised that it does contain a lot of elements that he would have known would piss Muslims off and that seem selected to do so. It doesn't excuse violence and threats towards him, but at the same time people shouldn't act surprised that Muslims were offended by it.
@bozzeed According to the Quran Alexander the great lived to be an Old man But Greek History recorded that he died at the age of 32 from malaria why was the Quran wrong on this very proven historical fact?
Continue: you will find no real biography of anyone { not even of prophet}, there is no story of his ministry, no history of their religion can be found in the book of the Muslims. The book seems to be 114 scrambled chapters of rules/ instructions on how to live a primitive barbaric life back almost 2000 years ago and what the punishment would be for anyone who fails to comply with the words in this book and its barbaric god.
@bozzeed " i have explaind that this was figure speaking the jews uses in their language " Exactully what comment I brought up was a figure of speech used in the Hebrew language? Its funny you muslims claim to follow the Jewish god yet do not follow any of the jewish traditions. You hold the Jeiwsh text sacred yet ignore the Jewish history mentioned in this text. I recommend you actually READ the Jewish text before you make any claims about it.
@wowamonn (2/2)But that is not the point, the point is why do you think the US government spends more than it brings? Even though not much of that money goes to the health care education social security?and to whom the US government owe the national debt?!
Of course Muslims do cause your book asks you to do so! You judge all religions and orders you to fight non-muslims! Which is not in any religion of the world but Islam. Honestly, The Terrorists show what the real Islam is!? Also, everyone has the right to say what does he think about!! Why Muhamed wanted to say everything he wants and replaces his words in Madina and no one said to him what are you doing?
@bozzeed " i did read some of the jewish text " The Jewish Text was accepted in its present form by the man Jesus form where he supposedly quoted from it hundreds of times thefore since he is a prophet according to your beliefs the Entire OT should be accepted by muslims. But you claim your holy book represents the final words of the jewish god but many of the Teachings of Jewish god is contradicted in the Quran.
Christians who convert to Islam don't know the Gospel. Matthew 7: 1 Judge not, that ye be not judged. 2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged... Matthew 6: 14 For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you: 15 But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses. People who don't forgive but judge "eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth" are on the Highway to Hell.
@bozzeed You do know that Moses supposedly wrote the Laws of the OT given by his god (by the way the same god you follow) and Jesus followed his peoples traditions since he was a jew but muslims do not practice the Jewish laws given by one of the jewish gods ( and your god since you worship the jewish god). Its funny how muhammed took Jewish beliefs and claimed them for his own adding his own twist to an already established religon.
I have read his book. It's basically a collection of comments and quotes of detractors of Islam apart from his tutor M.Watt. He makes no mention or discusses counter arguments. Ibn Warraq fails to understand the central core of Islam is 'Imaan" or faith. I doubt whether he was ever a practicing Muslim during his adult life in England or offered salah which is the essence of Islamic practice. The problem with " imaan" is that you cannot analyse it without taking it in first. It's like describing the taste of orange without actually tasting it. Salah - ordinarily a three minute of body movements gives an overwhelming sense of peace and even joy if done correctly as taught by Prophet Muhammad. Salah also "stops" the person from forbidden acts like gazing at a nude person or lying, which I have observed happens when one offers salah correctly and this happens even to new Muslims offering their first salah and are not even aware that Muhammad taught salah achieves that for the believer. The first verse of the Quran's main chapter starts with the verse: "This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for those conscious of Allah -Who believe in the unseen, establish prayer, and spend out of what We have provided for them" Quran (2:2-4) I will like to know whether Ibn Waraq ever performed salah experienced that and then abandoned Islam.
Of course Ibn Warraq never experienced Islam. Atheists and X Muslims do not understand that belief in God and faith is a PRIVILEGE and a function of the EFFORT the believer puts into it.“Take one step towards me, I will take ten steps towards you. Walk towards me, I will run towards you.. Ibn Warraq and many other X muslims put ZERO IN and got ZERO BACK. QURAN 50:16, Q10:25
"'Mohammedanism' is thus a misnomer because it suggests that Muslims worship Muhammad rather than God" Not more that "aristotelianism" supposes that philosophers "worship" Aristotle's. There are (thanks God ? ;-) ) other things in life than worship or contempt, than strength and submission relationship, than alienating one's mind to the teachings or Mr So-and-so (peace on him if he needs it !). Adult attitudes DO exist too. Feel free to adopt them whenever you are ready.
@bozzeed Also why does the Quran state Mary was the daughter of Imran who was also the father or Moses and Aron was muhammad confusing Miriam with Mary Surah 19:28, 3:33-36.
Early scientific methods were invented by Greeks (measurement of Earth's diameter, for instance). Modern algebra (with integer, negative and fractional exponents, and complex numbers, and all of matrix algebra) and probabilities by European mathematicians. Arabs never gave a sign of discovering Kepler's laws with their algebra, much less Newton's law. Paper came from China, philosophy - the word as well as the thing - from Greece long before Mahomet was born. So please stop lying :-)
Persians and Urdu did adopt Arabic alphabets but that does not mean Urdu-speaking people and Persian-speaking people can read Arabic. To be able to recite the Quran, these Urdu-speaking people and Persian-speaking kids were taught reading Quran without understanding the meaning in Arabic but being explained what the verses meant in their native lanaguge. People like this guy with no credible skills find ways to make money is disgusting.
@wowamonn well my friend you seem to know about the Quran more than i do. can you please show me where exactly it mentioned Alexander the great? and where does it say that he lived to be old man? also you should know that the jews use metaphoric words ofthen. aaron was metaphoric that virgin marry was like aaron in worshipping god. also can you show me please where the Quran says marry is sister of Moses? :P thanks
No, I know all about it. It was also custom to worship idols but apparently that was immoral but pedophilia was not. Of course the "custom of the times" defense requires people to believe that pedophilia is not severely sick and evil and simply a sign of the times? It can't be "refuted" at length...Adults don't find little children attractive unless they are sick and disturbed no matter what time they live...or is there a long explanation that would refute it?
@bozzeed Unfortantly when you are in an Army you cannnot pick and Choose what war you can fight. The Biggest holder of U.S debt is the U.S govenment itself believe it or about 25% is owed to foreign govenments.
You will find this types speak only alone. Let's have a debate, an ex Muslim with a current Muslim and let the people hear both sides. But they can't do that, because to succeed as a con artist, everyone should never know that you are a con artist.
@gangstakiller1905 Taqyyah means not telling the truth about Islam to the non-Islamic people. Islam is violent to non-muslims. That's what muslims have to hide when we disagree with stoning, telling our way of living to muslims, ex-muslims that aint certain of their lives (not much of freedom of religion, because freedom of religion also conludes the freedom not to believe in Islam). Than there is Islam as political ideology, that's why all Islamic cultures end up with dictatorship.
@bozzeed Because the U.S government spends more than it brings in thats simple logic. By the way I have been to your country and Qatar and Baharain when I was in the Army stationed during the second gulf war I saw some of the remants also of the first gulf war when Iraq invaded your country but I was not there when the U.S forces drove out the Iraqis in 1991.
@wowamonn well no body can prove physically that God exists. thats why we BELIEVE that God exists. there is plenty of evidence that he exists but not to those who close their eyes and allow seculars to rip them off!! other example, suppose you are married, and caught your wife cheating on you with another married man, how would you feel and what is the legal action (seculars law) that you can take?
So sad that he 'goes on so much' and loses the audience. You should never read from your notes verbatum when giving a lecture. A good subject and interesting, made boring - shame!
@bozzeed Most money spent by the U.S is spent on the Defense over 1 trillion dollars is spent a year on the U.S military bases all over the earth AND nearly 700 billion is spent on research purcashing new equipment and of course the U.S involvment in the 2 wars in the Middle East.
@bozzeed I pay Taxs because a better Civilization for our species and to free them from religous bondage that has enslaved humans for thousands of years.
@wowamonn actually, morality comes by nature from instinct since people follow God with their instinct. immorality comes when satan delude people. you by not drinking nor going clubbing are following the teaching of God. which is a superb thing considering the common immorality in the world today. yet it is sad that you dont believe in God.
Now please WHAT dit the Arabs do ? Ibn Khaldun tells un that whenever they came somewhere, they destroyed the signs of the past, and that they had event tried to do it with the Pyramids, giving up when seeing that 4 months later they were barely scratched. Read him instead of just using his name without knowing his works !
Jeez, I"m halfway through and he's still just going on about his childhood (which wasn't even very religious at all). He's not got on to anything about his rejection of Islam. Badly structured talk and not good that he keeps reading, hardly looking up, and saying 'I think I'll skip a bit now' etc. I'm sure we were somewhat interested in what his background was, but we don't need every tiny detail of his childhood, we want to know why he, a famous critic of Islam, rejected Islam. Get to the point!... :-/
Ibn Warraq speaks better English than I do! A scholar and gentleman!
Gary Cox ibn warraq forgot to mention these important points ua-cam.com/video/IheHpUFTp84/v-deo.html
@@soulofislam1796 Do you have any non prapaganda videos ?
Most of those pro islam videos are too heavily edited with too many special effects.
Just read sahir el buhari(one of the most important books after the koran) and you will be onboard with the jihad.
97% of the Jihad(yes - it was counted) mentioned there is referring to war.
You just believe the one that spins the ideas the way you like it.
Too much echoe, too loud singing in the background. Can't listen till the end.
He was cited over a dozen times by the Norway shooter in 2011.
@@Humanaut. Ibn Warraq is a major propagandist. His own secrecy about his past really makes me think whether or not he really does speak a single word of Arabic, or like many Pakistani/Indian Muslims, he was just taught to read it phonetically without actually knowing what the words mean.
You can't be religious any more when you start using your mind.
why do you Muslims feel the need dislike every video critical of your cult? why dont you address some of the criticism?
Ryad Derdar If you are so confident of your religion why do you dislike when people leave it or criticize it, you shouldn't even be watching this video if it hurts your sensibility
What did he say that was wrong?
james thomas
only a part of what he sayed is biaised, especially Islam during middle ages which was not worst than other religions. But what he says about muhammad and nis compaignons is right.
lmaoyourekiddingme
Not Jesus, but Christian leaders, and especially, Church !
Ryad Derdar Love it...keep killing each other///it lovely!!! That's your fate!
I've read both "Why I am not a muslim" and "Leaving islam. Apostates speak out" and I can highly recommend them to anyone
I definitely don’t. The man is a fraud who lies or quotes vague texts (interpreted by him) and enemies of Islam.
Ibn Warraq is easily one of the most lovable of Islamic Scholars.
Islamic Scholar?! Ibn Warraq said he dont even make Salah!Prayer! He said he is not a Muslim, sir! What are you talking about?! It seems you are subjective in your comments and not objective. Ibn Warraq is a Kaafir sir, a non-Muslims, the worst of creatures! Sura Al-Bayyinah. And feel free to quote me!
@@abunamr1037 are u Muslim?
@@abunamr1037 You don't have to be a Muslim to be a scholar of Islam...goodness
Because he tells you what you want to hear?
@@abunamr1037 : U are gutter just like Muhammad the Muslim prophet. Allah was a minor pre Islamic God. Allah is a pagan moon god and good for nothing.
There are fundamental problems with Islam , I can not recognize it as a “ God “ given religion , I can not recognize Muhammad as “ a mercy to mankind “, I can not recognize Islamic laws as divine . Everything is questionable and I suspect deception and pretend to be something Islam is not .
Quite interesting that he had only a very mild Muslim background and wasn't 'rebelling' against a strict upbringing or anything. But we got half an hour about his childhood and then nothing about the in-depth researches that led to his famous book and the strong feelings against Islam that they must have caused for him to write it...
The Quran is less of a "Book of God" and more a "Transcript of God via Muhammad". It's not chronologically arranged, it's arranged from longest to shortest so it could be memorized easier. You have to remember that Arab culture was a oral culture and that the Quran(means The Recitation) were passed on word of mouth until over 100 years later when it was finally compiled.
So it's the speeches of god. Or lies of a conman?
You are the biggest liar ever.
The Quran was compiled in 632. And no, the Quran wasn’t passed on for over a 100 years, you made that up you liar.
@@synczy7307 there are 26 variants, is incomplete without fulfillment of prophecies lots of plagiarism from fake sources as Talmud Gnosticism and Jewish mysticism given by a very corrupt man
@@albusai lol it’s funny cause if you read the Quran you would know that prophet Muhammad pbuh knew nothing about this stuff until prophet hood and plagiarism from how he couldn’t read or write and as a matter a fact the Quran actually corrects a lot of stuff in the Jewish scripture like historical and Scientific facts don’t let these atheist deceive you the devil themselves teach these people this stuff
i bought "why i am not a Muslim' from a book shop in toronto as it was not available in pakistan...
no there is no freedom of speech in pakistan!.
what are you trying to say.
i am not spreading any lies man.
Danial Tanvir that’s the difference between a secular system and a Theocracy
yes i know.
When my girlfriend asks me not to talk about religion, but her parents brought it up
Not because I am a fanatic of Islam, but because I watched a blank speech for 25 minutes, I disliked.
I totally agree. I’m 5 minutes in to this video and he said nothing.
Really profound. Thanks for sharing.
the introducer addresses him as Ibn, which means just SON :) "when Son wrote his book..."
Leaving Islam and Why I'm not a Muslim are two books I have.
Take away: He was already far from islam the day he was born, following local traditions rather than religion itself. Eventually he realizes these TRADITIONS are flawed and instead of researching about the religion he decides to give up, blaming islam as incompetent and illogical.
The biggest reason for the downfall of Islam in eye of the public is because of the same reason mentioned above, people dont wanna go the hard way, which is reading about the religion, rather choose the easy way out, which is listening to their guardians and preachers. The problem is that EACH AND EVERY person will tell you something else. Thats why Quran was revealed, to have a standardized copy of the teaching.
Standardise abrogations? And you believe all that?
You've clearly not read the book, or are being disingenuous.
A good talk by a ex-muslim
" The divorce between Athena and Medina explains much of what went wrong in the Muslim world."
"without Arab advance in astronomy, there would be no space advances now…"
Do not make me laugh : in 1200 years, the Arabs who had a kind of rudimentary algebra, clear sky and an interest in astronomy NEVER DISCOVERED Newton's law, and not even Kepler's ones. All they did was to give NAMES to stars, not a very complicated operation. And what was left to discover since the Babylonian had discovered the equinoxes precession ?
No one denies the contributions that different cultures have shared knowledge with other cultures: but let’s not play the same broken record of a narrative over and over without recognizing that fact
Sacred 'beliefs' - Light years away from anything resembling the TRUTH.
حَتَّىٰٓ إِذَا جَآءَ أَحَدَهُمُ ٱلْمَوْتُ قَالَ رَبِّ ٱرْجِعُونِ
لَعَلِّىٓ أَعْمَلُ صَـٰلِحًۭا فِيمَا تَرَكْتُ ۚ كَلَّآ ۚ إِنَّهَا كَلِمَةٌ هُوَ قَآئِلُهَا ۖ وَمِن وَرَآئِهِم بَرْزَخٌ إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ يُبْعَثُونَ
فَإِذَا نُفِخَ فِى ٱلصُّورِ فَلَآ أَنسَابَ بَيْنَهُمْ يَوْمَئِذٍۢ وَلَا يَتَسَآءَلُونَ
فَمَن ثَقُلَتْ مَوَٰزِينُهُۥ فَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلْمُفْلِحُونَ
وَمَنْ خَفَّتْ مَوَٰزِينُهُۥ فَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ ٱلَّذِينَ خَسِرُوٓا۟ أَنفُسَهُمْ فِى جَهَنَّمَ خَـٰلِدُونَ
تَلْفَحُ وُجُوهَهُمُ ٱلنَّارُ وَهُمْ فِيهَا كَـٰلِحُونَ
أَلَمْ تَكُنْ ءَايَـٰتِى تُتْلَىٰ عَلَيْكُمْ فَكُنتُم بِهَا تُكَذِّبُونَ
قَالُوا۟ رَبَّنَا غَلَبَتْ عَلَيْنَا شِقْوَتُنَا وَكُنَّا قَوْمًۭا ضَآلِّينَ
رَبَّنَآ أَخْرِجْنَا مِنْهَا فَإِنْ عُدْنَا فَإِنَّا ظَـٰلِمُونَ
قَالَ ٱخْسَـُٔوا۟ فِيهَا وَلَا تُكَلِّمُونِ
إِنَّهُۥ كَانَ فَرِيقٌۭ مِّنْ عِبَادِى يَقُولُونَ رَبَّنَآ ءَامَنَّا فَٱغْفِرْ لَنَا وَٱرْحَمْنَا وَأَنتَ خَيْرُ ٱلرَّٰحِمِينَ
فَٱتَّخَذْتُمُوهُمْ سِخْرِيًّا حَتَّىٰٓ أَنسَوْكُمْ ذِكْرِى وَكُنتُم مِّنْهُمْ تَضْحَكُونَ
إِنِّى جَزَيْتُهُمُ ٱلْيَوْمَ بِمَا صَبَرُوٓا۟ أَنَّهُمْ هُمُ ٱلْفَآئِزُونَ
Wtf is it ?
Praise Jesus Christ for this man. JESUS IS GREAT.
You cannot be born as a muslim. In fact, you are the child of god!
At (Surah 18:89-98) Alexander the Great was a devout Muslim and lived to a ripe old age. Historical records however show that Alexander the Great died young at 33 years of age (b. 356 B.C. - d. 323 B.C.), and believed he was divine, forcing others to recognize him as such. In India on the Hyphasis River (now Beas) Alexander erected twelve altars to twelve Olympian gods. The Quran shows errors in historical and religious fact.
No that is an interpretation no one knows who Ⱬul-Qarnain is. Some say he is Alexandra the great others say he is a different person.
@@Mulberry2000Mohammed pretended to know where the end of the world was, by saying Alexander the Great went there and back. This saying originated from the Alexandrian myths. Quran uses many local myths from that time, and has nothing timeless at all.
@@mariussielcken oh really lol
That makes Islam the most confused religion on earth.
He looks like Eugene Levy--I can't stop cracking up! Great and interesting upload.
And now islam is the fastest growing religion in this world. Thanks ibn warraq❤
Don't thank him for it
This tells you the number of stupid people are growing in the world.
Interesting, nobody seems to reply from either side, Muslim or the West.
The reason a Muslim wouldn't waste time listening is because a Muslim wouldn't normally capitalise financially by slagging off another religion in writing a book.
Only 1/5th of the world population in 1400 years ? Would not one call that a strange failure ? 100% of the world, for instance, use Euclid's geometry (while knowing also when NOT to use it, as in Minowski-Poincaré's spacetime). 100% of the world use Euclid's (a Greek) algorithm, Thales' (an egyptian) theorem, and Bayes (a Britannic) relationship. Knows about the equinox precession discovered by Babylonians, the zero by indians, integer, negative and rational exponents by European mathematicians?
@wowamonn they raise money by selling bonds then buying the same bonds?! ( referring to the $600 billion deal) ?! this doesnt make sense at all!! please explain further!
Jiyo mere Bhai...greeting from Mumbai
No? So the Hadith is nonsense? OK...I will accept that and applaud you for denouncing it as a sick work of fiction for stating he did have sex with a child.
Is the Qur'an correct though?
Irrelevant. We are not discussing here about personal matters concerning the speaker (on which you have no grounds to draw conclusions except your own wishful thinking, if anybody buys it), but about what is said by the speaker. Do not mix everything up if you do not want people to come to the conclusions that islam has "a very strange relationship with reason", as pope Benedict XVI said in a very diplomatic way :-)
leaving Islam is dealt with certain death. That's enough to find out Islam sucks
You are welcome :-)
Did Jesus come for peace?
Luke-ch-12-vs-51(Jesus speaking)
Do you imagine I came to give peace on the earth? No, indeed, I tell you, but rather division.52-for from now on there will be five in one house divided, three against two and two against three. 53-they will be divided, father against son and son against father, mother against daughter and daughter against her mother, and mother-in-law against her daughter-in-law and daughter-in-law against her mother -in-law.
33:53 "I was accepted to study essentially European arse history at Edinburgh University" o_0 OK then
The eternal problem of all man made religions: intolerance and fear mongering (= control over the masses).
Yeshua, our lord and Savior, reveals and gives freely a liberating loving salvation, to have a personal relation with Him through His Spirit. Those of us that have been blessed in this regard understand and experience the amazing transformation that He brings.
When John writes in the Book of Revelation: let him who has wisdom calculate the number of the beast, for it is a human number. The only Greek word with a number of 666 is paradosis. Which is translated as Tradition.
The word is used 13 times in the NT (5 times by Paul, 5 times by Matthew and 3 times by Mark).
🙏
@bozzeed stoning as a form of punishment for adultery is NOT IN THE QURAN. what did you think i meant?
@Liebhabaer1974 why the sharia law is the highway to hell?
Just name ONE contribution of muslim countries to science since the 13th century, so we can laugn. Even Omar Khayyam, a real genius, expressed in his poems the disgust he had for religious people already in his time, before the lon idlamic night on thought began. He died in 1131. Read him (he was translated in arab too, though Toussain's translation is quite readable).
@lkaml1 I sense the usual self-righteous narcissism underneath the usual whining of "he/she know nothing about islam...." that comes out of self-denial to admitting that there's something wrong some with your religion's principles and claims or simply the inability to criticize yourself as well as the inability to open yourself to criticism.
Ibn Warraq started learning arabic and reading the quran since he was a boy and is a top historian on Islam and Arabic!
Stange : when Arabs are supposed to be in advance (which was the case before the Turks conquered them, nor Crusaders), their civilization is "superior" (which was true for a while). But when the islamic world is, like the Ottoman empire, scientifically and technically 60 years to 200 years (and which 200 years !) behind Europe, it has suddenly "no sense saying that a civilization is superior to another". How strange ! :-D
Two reasons when Islam started it was very open to new ideas and peoples. That's is how the managed to assimilate different peoples into Islam. The Arabs at the time of Islam was very backward and had no clue in running empires. So they let the locals do the running and did not impose Islam on the population. If they did their rule would soon end. Some say they were brutal and some rulers were but they did not last long. Brutal rulers never do last, the romans were the exception but they offered caveats for local populations, if they accepted roman rule eventually they come roman citizens. Of course the elites in Rome did not want that as it meant a challenge to their power. The Arabs felt the same so they did not want people to convert, well not fast enough. So for 300 years the Islamic empire was a rough diamond, it has most of the world's Christian population, but not many Muslims. Of course over time as taxes grew people just converted to Islam to avoid them, or did it out of fear or conviction. Eventually the Muslims got so good at civilisation they felt they had learnt all that was and closed the door to more learning. The door to ijtihad was closed - the door to reasoning. The Muslim world eventually ran out of steam and with nothing new coming up the pipe line declined. If you think the Muslim world is barbaric and yes in some parts they are, but compared to the West, they are nice guys who love not to kill people.
"it's arranged from longest to shortest"
Except the first one, I think. But yes, I checked that on Linux with the ls -l command, imported the results to make an LibreOffice graph, and it is clearly statistically true.
@bozzeed " He bucked when Muhammad came to mount him. The angel Jibril (Gabriel) put his hand on his mane and said: "Are you not ashamed, O Buraq? By Allah, no-one has ridden you in all creation more dear to Allah than he is." Hearing this he was so ashamed that he sweated until he became soaked, and he stood still so that the Prophet mounted him "
@bozzeed
Matthew 7:
1 Judge not, that ye be not judged.
2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged...
Matthew 6:
14 For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you:
15 But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.
John 8:
7 He that is WITHOUT SIN among you, let him first cast a stone at her.
Sharia law is the HIGHWAY TO HELL.
@bozzeed Oh please stop with the strawman statment you HAVENT provided ANY rebuttals to anything that I posted. When Mohammed ' flew ' to Jerusalem and tied his horse to the ring the prophets used. You do know that there existed no temple in Jesusalem in the 7th century right? the second jewish temple was destroyed almost six centuries earlier.
@elmirasahar the punishment for adultery is mentioned in sura24:2 for non married couple. as for married couple their punishment is stonned to death. there is an ayah called ayah al rajm. i dont know the number but there are hadiths that prove that who commit adultery when married is to be stonned.
@wowamonn well i did explain that taking interest and usury is prohibited in islam because it makes the rich wealthy and the poor under constant debt just as what is happening to the third world countries today who are struggling to pay the interest ALONE of their principal loans which they got from world bank. in islam also the rich will HAVE TO pay zakat (tax) to the poor (not governments) to reduce the range of wealth between the rich and the poor. so definitely it is a better system
@GeorgiaIsOnMyMind He don't even know what he is't talking about he also did't understand the book that he is't talking about ! ( Qu'Ran)
He didnt or you didnt?
As far as a Muslim is concerned, Jesus is just as important a prophet as Mohammed - sorry: - Mohammad.
@bozzeed If you cheated on your wife does she have the right to file for a divorce from you since you were the one who commited adultry and what are the consequences for you since you commted the act.
Its good that you are not Muslim, i am not Muslim because the background of islam and what its sources say, when they say that the Islamic prophet Muhammad thought that he was demon possessed and became suicidal when he received the Revelations from the angel. This is a huge problem because when God appears or an angel does, its undeniable. God is good and His angels, pure and holy. If Muhammad could not see that then its a problem, it diminishes god and his knowledge to be able to come across well and anticipate. Allah couldnt anticipate well if Muhammad became suicidal and tried to kill himself.
Quran:
(SURAH-3-THE FAMILY OF IMRAN-VS-19)
Surely the (true) religion with allah is Islam, and those to whom the book had been given did not show opposition but after the knowledge had come to them, out of envy among themselves; and whoever disbelieve in the communications
@wowamonn i didnt say you ara American, i said you are from the US :P still you do pay tax. do you know to whom you are paying tax?
They live in a glass house.
@wowamonn also please explain how the US government is going to buy $600 billion bonds to raise fund!!
Did you ever read Omar Khayyam ? OK, he was said to have powerful protections, like VERY intelligent men often do. He wrote about what he thought about believers he could see around him, and about the obvious lack of interest of God - if God existed - towards the humans. A genius of his times, unfortunately exiled in a time of history and country he was not made for. He belong to OUR world, not the one of his contemporaries.
If the word "Allah/al-Ilah" is of pagan origin, then so is the Judeo-Christian term for God-"El/Eloah/Elohim" which are all dervided from the same root word as the Arabic. Does the fact that Jesus is known as "Immanuel" ("El/Al is with us") by certain Christian accounts really negate its meaning to his followers? And Arabic was written...in fact, there were a wide variety of Arabic alphabets, and dialects at the time.
@bozzeed " Then he [Gabriel] brought the Buraq, handsome-faced and bridled, a tall, white beast, bigger than the donkey but smaller than the mule. He could place his hooves at the farthest boundary of his gaze. He had long ears. Whenever he faced a mountain his hind legs would extend, and whenever he went downhill his front legs would extend. He had two wings on his thighs which lent strength to his legs "
@bozzeed I would file for divorce because obviously she does not appreciate the campionship of her husband end of story, no revenge, no pissed off behaviour just a logical end to a bad relationship.
@lkaml1 Nope, no narcissism from my end. No, you don't believe in all the other religions. In Islam there is only one god (allah) and his messenger, which is muhammed, the last and final prophet. All other prophets in the jewish and christian religions are mentioned in the quran but are not deemed as the true messengers Believing in another religion whilst being a muslim is "haram" or prohibited as it is heresy and according to most muslim scholars, even apostacy
Ibn Warraq says we need to stand up for our values without apologies. I completely agree. But in order to do that, we need to have values. Do we have any values left? Or have they all been killed by hedonism and the stretching of envelopes?
As in any dialectic, go too far to one extreme, and the opposite extreme will rear its ugly head.
(cont.)
1 John 2: 7
Brethren, I write no new commandment unto you, but an old commandment which ye had from the beginning. The old commandment is the word which ye have heard from the beginning.
=> 1 MOSES 4: 15
Whosoever slayeth Cain (who killed his brother Abel), vengeance shall be taken on him sevenfold. And the LORD set a mark upon Cain, lest any finding him should kill him.
Galatians 1: 9
If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed.
Re. Rushdie, speaking as an agnostic ex-Christian, who's fairly well informed about Islam, writing a book satirising a religion can certainly never justify violence, however I recently read the Satanic Verses and it reads like he deliberately set out to infuriate Muslims. It had a large amount of content based on the life of Mohammed that ridicules him and deliberately picks out especially embarrassing stories from the Islamic histories to dwell on. It also contains things like all the prostitutues in a brothel deciding to name themselves after Mohammed's 13 wives. It also specifically satirises the Ayatollah Khomeini. So, he must have known it would anger and annoy, but got more than he bargained for.
***** He made use of obscure stories that are theologically embarrassing to Islam, not necessarily things that are 'morally bad'. There are plenty of those in the sayings and histories too, but he didn't make use of them to the extent he could have if he'd wanted to just show Mohammed as being a 'bad person'. But the story he named the book after, for example, which is also an important episode in the book, wasn't known by a lot of Muslims before he did it, and is embarrassing because it shows Mohammed making a concession to polytheism - saying in a Quran verse to the Meccans that it's OK to worship their goddesses as intercessors with God, and then he changed his mind and said it didn't come from God but Satan made him say it instead... Strict monotheism is the most fundamental thing of all in Islam. No, I think people should be free to criticise or satirise Islam, but I'm just saying that when I read the book, having studied Islam a bit, I realised that it does contain a lot of elements that he would have known would piss Muslims off and that seem selected to do so. It doesn't excuse violence and threats towards him, but at the same time people shouldn't act surprised that Muslims were offended by it.
@bozzeed According to the Quran Alexander the great lived to be an Old man But Greek History recorded that he died at the age of 32 from malaria why was the Quran wrong on this very proven historical fact?
Continue:
you will find no real biography of anyone { not even of prophet}, there is no story of his ministry, no history of their religion can be found in the book of the Muslims. The book seems to be 114 scrambled chapters of rules/ instructions on how to live a primitive barbaric life back almost 2000 years ago and what the punishment would be for anyone who fails to comply with the words in this book and its barbaric god.
@bozzeed " i have explaind that this was figure speaking the jews uses in their language "
Exactully what comment I brought up was a figure of speech used in the Hebrew language?
Its funny you muslims claim to follow the Jewish god yet do not follow any of the jewish traditions. You hold the Jeiwsh text sacred yet ignore the Jewish history mentioned in this text. I recommend you actually READ the Jewish text before you make any claims about it.
Please do not talk like that. Muslims are not taught to use that kind of language.
@wowamonn (2/2)But that is not the point, the point is why do you think the US government spends more than it brings? Even though not much of that money goes to the health care education social security?and to whom the US government owe the national debt?!
Moderate Muslim give me a break where are the moderate Westerns ?!!
Of course Muslims do cause your book asks you to do so! You judge all religions and orders you to fight non-muslims! Which is not in any religion of the world but Islam. Honestly, The Terrorists show what the real Islam is!?
Also, everyone has the right to say what does he think about!! Why Muhamed wanted to say everything he wants and replaces his words in Madina and no one said to him what are you doing?
@bozzeed " i did read some of the jewish text "
The Jewish Text was accepted in its present form by the man Jesus form where he supposedly quoted from it hundreds of times thefore since he is a prophet according to your beliefs the Entire OT should be accepted by muslims. But you claim your holy book represents the final words of the jewish god but many of the Teachings of Jewish god is contradicted in the Quran.
Christians who convert to Islam don't know the Gospel.
Matthew 7:
1 Judge not, that ye be not judged.
2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged...
Matthew 6:
14 For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you:
15 But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.
People who don't forgive but judge "eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth" are on the Highway to Hell.
@bozzeed You do know that Moses supposedly wrote the Laws of the OT given by his god (by the way the same god you follow) and Jesus followed his peoples traditions since he was a jew but muslims do not practice the Jewish laws given by one of the jewish gods ( and your god since you worship the jewish god). Its funny how muhammed took Jewish beliefs and claimed them for his own adding his own twist to an already established religon.
I have read his book. It's basically a collection of comments and quotes of detractors of Islam apart from his tutor M.Watt. He makes no mention or discusses counter arguments. Ibn Warraq fails to understand the central core of Islam is 'Imaan" or faith. I doubt whether he was ever a practicing Muslim during his adult life in England or offered salah which is the essence of Islamic practice. The problem with " imaan" is that you cannot analyse it without taking it in first. It's like describing the taste of orange without actually tasting it. Salah - ordinarily a three minute of body movements gives an overwhelming sense of peace and even joy if done correctly as taught by Prophet Muhammad. Salah also "stops" the person from forbidden acts like gazing at a nude person or lying, which I have observed happens when one offers salah correctly and this happens even to new Muslims offering their first salah and are not even aware that Muhammad taught salah achieves that for the believer. The first verse of the Quran's main chapter starts with the verse: "This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for those conscious of Allah -Who believe in the unseen, establish prayer, and spend out of what We have provided for them" Quran (2:2-4)
I will like to know whether Ibn Waraq ever performed salah experienced that and then abandoned Islam.
Of course Ibn Warraq never experienced Islam. Atheists and X Muslims do not understand that belief in God and faith is a PRIVILEGE and a function of the EFFORT the believer puts into it.“Take one step towards me, I will take ten steps towards you. Walk towards me, I will run towards you.. Ibn Warraq and many other X muslims put ZERO IN and got ZERO BACK. QURAN 50:16, Q10:25
everyone wants to explain something
"'Mohammedanism' is thus a misnomer because it suggests that Muslims worship Muhammad rather than God"
Not more that "aristotelianism" supposes that philosophers "worship" Aristotle's. There are (thanks God ? ;-) ) other things in life than worship or contempt, than strength and submission relationship, than alienating one's mind to the teachings or Mr So-and-so (peace on him if he needs it !). Adult attitudes DO exist too. Feel free to adopt them whenever you are ready.
@bozzeed Also why does the Quran state Mary was the daughter of Imran who was also the father or Moses and Aron was muhammad confusing Miriam with Mary Surah 19:28, 3:33-36.
So sad 😢 story 😥 is reality 💔 so nice so good challenge
Early scientific methods were invented by Greeks (measurement of Earth's diameter, for instance). Modern algebra (with integer, negative and fractional exponents, and complex numbers, and all of matrix algebra) and probabilities by European mathematicians. Arabs never gave a sign of discovering Kepler's laws with their algebra, much less Newton's law. Paper came from China, philosophy - the word as well as the thing - from Greece long before Mahomet was born. So please stop lying :-)
Persians and Urdu did adopt Arabic alphabets but that does not mean Urdu-speaking people and Persian-speaking people can read Arabic. To be able to recite the Quran, these Urdu-speaking people and Persian-speaking kids were taught reading Quran without understanding the meaning in Arabic but being explained what the verses meant in their native lanaguge. People like this guy with no credible skills find ways to make money is disgusting.
Good expose of the cowards Roald Dahl and John Le Carre in the Rushdie affair
@wowamonn well my friend you seem to know about the Quran more than i do. can you please show me where exactly it mentioned Alexander the great? and where does it say that he lived to be old man? also you should know that the jews use metaphoric words ofthen. aaron was metaphoric that virgin marry was like aaron in worshipping god. also can you show me please where the Quran says marry is sister of Moses? :P thanks
No, I know all about it. It was also custom to worship idols but apparently that was immoral but pedophilia was not. Of course the "custom of the times" defense requires people to believe that pedophilia is not severely sick and evil and simply a sign of the times? It can't be "refuted" at length...Adults don't find little children attractive unless they are sick and disturbed no matter what time they live...or is there a long explanation that would refute it?
@freemind1981 Why he is not delusional. That should really be the title. That is really his message.
@bozzeed Unfortantly when you are in an Army you cannnot pick and Choose what war you can fight. The Biggest holder of U.S debt is the U.S govenment itself believe it or about 25% is owed to foreign govenments.
You will find this types speak only alone.
Let's have a debate, an ex Muslim with a current Muslim and let the people hear both sides.
But they can't do that, because to succeed as a con artist, everyone should never know that you are a con artist.
@gangstakiller1905 Taqyyah means not telling the truth about Islam to the non-Islamic people. Islam is violent to non-muslims. That's what muslims have to hide when we disagree with stoning, telling our way of living to muslims, ex-muslims that aint certain of their lives (not much of freedom of religion, because freedom of religion also conludes the freedom not to believe in Islam). Than there is Islam as political ideology, that's why all Islamic cultures end up with dictatorship.
@bozzeed Because the U.S government spends more than it brings in thats simple logic. By the way I have been to your country and Qatar and Baharain when I was in the Army stationed during the second gulf war I saw some of the remants also of the first gulf war when Iraq invaded your country but I was not there when the U.S forces drove out the Iraqis in 1991.
very very interesting.............
@wowamonn well no body can prove physically that God exists. thats why we BELIEVE that God exists. there is plenty of evidence that he exists but not to those who close their eyes and allow seculars to rip them off!! other example, suppose you are married, and caught your wife cheating on you with another married man, how would you feel and what is the legal action (seculars law) that you can take?
So sad that he 'goes on so much' and loses the audience. You should never read from your notes verbatum when giving a lecture. A good subject and interesting, made boring - shame!
Thanks for that. Really adds a lot. Now, back to reality.
@bozzeed Most money spent by the U.S is spent on the Defense over 1 trillion dollars is spent a year on the U.S military bases all over the earth AND nearly 700 billion is spent on research purcashing new equipment and of course the U.S involvment in the 2 wars in the Middle East.
@bozzeed I pay Taxs because a better Civilization for our species and to free them from religous bondage that has enslaved humans for thousands of years.
@wowamonn actually, morality comes by nature from instinct since people follow God with their instinct. immorality comes when satan delude people. you by not drinking nor going clubbing are following the teaching of God. which is a superb thing considering the common immorality in the world today. yet it is sad that you dont believe in God.
Now please WHAT dit the Arabs do ? Ibn Khaldun tells un that whenever they came somewhere, they destroyed the signs of the past, and that they had event tried to do it with the Pyramids, giving up when seeing that 4 months later they were barely scratched. Read him instead of just using his name without knowing his works !
Jeez, I"m halfway through and he's still just going on about his childhood (which wasn't even very religious at all). He's not got on to anything about his rejection of Islam. Badly structured talk and not good that he keeps reading, hardly looking up, and saying 'I think I'll skip a bit now' etc. I'm sure we were somewhat interested in what his background was, but we don't need every tiny detail of his childhood, we want to know why he, a famous critic of Islam, rejected Islam. Get to the point!... :-/
***** I have done and thought it was good, so I was a bit disappointed that he doesn't come across better in person; or at least in this talk
Totally agree. I was thinking the same Was interested in what made him change or his experience but just too much of nothing.
@bozzeed Big Investors and Foreign Govenments do the same, except on a larger scale.
great video.. thx for posting this.