Điện Biên Phủ ending scene
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
- The Battle of Dien Bien Phu (French: Bataille de Diên Biên Phu; Vietnamese: Chiến dịch Điện Biên Phủ) was the climactic confrontation of the First Indochina War between the French Union's French Far East Expeditionary Corps and Viet Minh communist-nationalist revolutionaries. The battle occurred between March and May 1954 and culminated in a comprehensive French defeat that influenced negotiations over the future of Indochina at Geneva. Military historian Martin Windrow wrote that Dien Bien Phu was "the first time that a non-European colonial independence movement had evolved through all the stages from guerrilla bands to a conventionally organized and equipped army able to defeat a modern Western occupier in pitched battle."
The movie:
Diên Biên Phu (French for Điện Biên Phủ) is a 1992 film written and directed by French veteran Pierre Schoendoerffer. With its huge budget, all-star cast, and realistic war scenes produced with the cooperation of the French and Vietnamese armies, Dîen Bîen Phu is regarded by many as one of the more important war movies produced in French filmmaking history. It portrays the 55-day siege of Dien Bien Phu (1954), the last battle by the French Union's colonial army in the First Indochina War during the final days of French Indochina, which was soon after divided into North and South Vietnam. This was a prelude to the Second Indochina War, known in the United States as the Vietnam War.
This movie was made by Pierre Schoenderffer, a former French army cameraman who requested to be dropped on Dien Bien Phu even though the outcome of the battle was pretty much decided, to document the battle for later generations. Unfortunately the films he made during the battle were lost or destroyed, so he made this movie. It is incredibly emotional and presents the battle as he saw it (we don't even see any vietnamese soldier until this very scene). For added realism, it was entirely filmed on location (not in Dien Bien Phu itself, but not far), with the vietnamese army helping with the recreation of the battle by building hills and digging trenches to mimic the french positions. It is a gritty and realistic portrayal of what that battle was like. Rain, mud, an invisible enemy, death everywhere. That's how every war movie should be.
@JHyun - they were a part of a Vietnamese puppet government that later on became the RVN under US control. They used the same flag. Three red horizontal stripes on a yellow background.
Thats why normal war loving American dont understand how they lose. They reused a corpse.
@@maxiejohnson8356 Far more complicated than you think. Those Vietnamese fought with French some for money because they were poor farmers some were members of Vietnam Quoc Dan Party (VNQDD)that Ho Chi Minh had tried to destroy back in 1920's. They met in Hong Kong for a political meeting but their political agenda was different. VNQDD was slowly weaken without financial and weapon support compared to Communist HCM with strong military, financial, personal support from Russia and China.
@@thumtlnguyen3626 Because reactionaries are weak due to being screwed by their masters tho
@Elron Then why you people go to the war distant for ten thousand miles from your country? To battle against "communism"? How can such poor country like post WW II Vietnam threat to United States? Pretty pointless.
Thumtl Nguyen the nationalists once tried to overthrow DRV government in 1945 which at that time not only consist of the communists. It is no surprise they want to get rid of them
Ông của tôi đã nằm lại ở điện biên phủ. Hai bác cũng hi sinh ở mặt trận biên giới Việt Trung , tôi rất tự hào về người thân gia đình tôi có truyền thống yêu nước
Xin được gửi lời cảm ơn biết ơn từ tận đáy lòng mình đến ông và các bác của bạn đã hi sinh. Xin được cảm ơn gia đình bạn đã sinh ra những người ông cha con cháu anh dũng như vậy. Thật lòng kính chúc gia đình bạn sức khoẻ và may mắn.
Xin được cảm ơn ạ.
Tôn vinh gia đình ban❤
UN GRAND PEUPLE QUI A SURVÉCU S'EST BATTU ET A VAINCU
Nhân dân Trung Quốc sẽ không quên tình đồng chí, tình anh em giữa hai nước trong các cuộc kháng chiến chống Pháp và Mỹ vì những xích mích xảy ra giữa hai nước ở Trung Quốc, chúng ta đều đổ lỗi cho Tập đoàn Lê Duẩn về việc này. Lê Duẩn là người thân Liên Xô, khi Trung Quốc và Liên Xô mâu thuẫn, Liên Xô cần một tác nhân giúp họ kiềm chế Trung Quốc, và Việt Nam là một lựa chọn tốt. Xem xét thời đại đó, việc chúng tôi đánh bạn là điều thực sự bất lực.
Trung Quốc đã giúp đỡ Việt Nam rất lớn, không chỉ về vũ khí, trang bị mà còn về nhiều cơ sở hạ tầng. Khi đó, Trung Quốc cũng đang gặp khó khăn lớn về kinh tế. Hơn nữa, các đồng chí Việt Nam Võ Nguyên Giáp, Trường Chinh, Hoàng Văn Huân và các đồng chí khác đều đã góp phần xây dựng tình hữu nghị Trung-Việt mà nhân dân Trung Quốc không bao giờ quên.
As an American who studies this war to no end, I'm very happy that both countries are moving forward and good relations are being established. I do hope to visit that beautiful country one day.
Remember to visit those who got bombed and gased.
KKsan fuck those commies
Don't forget Mongolia and Cambodia Pol pot
well Vietnam has really no alternatives.Western investment ( the US) and free market economy has made this country wealthy and its people prosperous and raised its standards of living . We did the same with china and created a genie that cannot be put back in the bottle without a military option.Vietnam is weaker militarily especially their navy ,leaves them vulnerable to china,s aggressive control of the island and strategic shipping lanes in the south china sea. Vietnam is great my wife and I visited it in 2016. ho chi mi n city was like Vegas, party city..went into a bar got a makers and coke for pretty much nothing..asked the manager about seeing some of the battle sites or finding a tour ,since iam into the history of the war..she pretty much said no cares or talks about much .."long time go...bad for business". So a free market economy with voting rights for city councils, and what would be a governor or premiere .They are terrified of the Chinese and need the US and their Asian partners to protect them
@@snowblind9065 That's very interesting, thank you. What alot of people don't know is that after America withdrew and the South fell, it was a united Vietnam that invaded Cambodia to stop the genoceide of the Khmer Rouge. The two countries were never friendly. But Vietnam did a service to the region from that action even if there were more motives than just stopping the killing.
I'm happy to hear the country is prospouring and our relations with them inproved. From that you described it sounds like a democratic process as far as elections. Is it still considered a real communist countryy?
Tự hào xong cũng thật đau thương. Hai người chú của tôi đã hi sinh và nằm lại đồi A1. Chúng ta hãy trân trọng hòa bình đang có.
Tri ơn anh hùng liệt sĩ
Cám ơn hai người chú của chú, đã hi sinh để dành lấy chiến thắng và để cho thế hệ sau này như chúng cháu được sống trong hoà bình. Xin tri ơn các anh hùng liệt sĩ.
Đời đời biết ơn anh hùng liệt sĩ!
Memoria e riconoscenza eterna ai combattenti per la libertà, caduti e sopravvissuti❤
@@caybutnghethuat656
Sono stati anche i nostri eroi.quando Nixon è venuto in Italia è fuggito su un elicottero😊😊tutto il centro di Roma era pieno di giovani in rivolta contro la sua visita
The plan was to lure the Vietnamese out, thinking that they don't have artillery? somebody either forgot its not the 19th century or they seriously underestimated the Vietnamese.
Bạn sai rồi. Họ biết Việt Nam có pháo. Nhưng họ không tin Việt Nam có thể kéo pháo lên các dãy núi để bao vây trận địa, và Pháp cho rằng chúng tôi không thể tiếp tế với 500km đường vận chuyển. Nhưng chúng tôi kéo pháo vào trận địa rồi lại kéo ra 1 lần nữa để chuẩn bị lại. Các chuyên gia cố vấn Trung Quốc khuyên chúng tôi đánh nhanh thắng nhanh. Nhưng đại tướng vĩ đại của chúng tôi đã chọn cách đách chắc tiến chắc. Thắng mới đánh, không thắng không đánh
Deuxième Bureau of trouble .
Valley strongpoints are a REALLY bad idea.
@@kweinberg34 worked good for the US actually, but they left from not so good war support at home.
They did. And they paid for it.
My Grandpa died in this war but respect to the Vietnamese who fought for their independence from France. 🇲🇫
It was French Goverment mistakes. R.I.P your grandpa. Hope u can go Vietnam and visit this battle field.
Have you read Street Without Joy by Bernard B. Fall? If not, I recommend it along with his other book that details Dien Bien Phu specifically. The French government and military generals largely mismanaged the war and constantly underestimated the strength and morale of their opponent.
@@Razzy1312 true
It is Chales de Gaules misstake, not your grand papa.
@@JohannPachelbel81 de gaulle was not the french président in 1954...
All vietnamese will not forget war from France, america, korea and japan! But thats history. And now we can shake the hands and grow up together !
Love from the United States
bad Good So what part of your asshole did you get those "stats" from?
@bad Good ironic coming from an american i assume
Vietnam forgive Japan
Vietnam forgive UK
Vietnam forgive US
While China
China hates UK
China hates Japan
China hates US
The majority hates China
The North murdered 2,000,000 South Vietnamese when they took over and forced millions more to flee. A lot of then live where I live here in East Texas because the weather here is somewhat like what Vietnam is, humid and such. They despise you and for good reason. The North were murderers and thieves and the Vietnam they've created is a sh*try poor country with child labor and other evils.
Had America won the freedom would have bright would have turned South Vietnam into South Korea.
thật vinh dự ÔNG TÔI LÀ 1 NGƯỜI LÍNH PHÁO BINH CỦA TRẬN ĐIỆN BIÊN PHỦ NÀY..
ông Cố mình cũng thế , có khi 2 người là đồng chí .
vào quân đội thì ai cũng là đồng chí cả mà :3
Thế ông mày đi bán muối chưa
Ông tem còn sống
Ông mình năm nay 89t rồi...
Man,Respect to the indomitable spirit of the Vietnamese people!!They fought against Japan,then France,then with the U S.A. and lastly with China and managed to defeat all of them!!This kind of valour is simply unheard of in this modern era.
And Khmer Rouge
But they can't fight with Thai. After Saigon broke, Vientiane broke, Phnom Penh broke and Vietnam's army invaded to Thailand, at the meanwhile all of American G.I. is run away from Thailand escapes Viet Cong to Singapore and Philippine. It is only Thai's soldiers fighting alone. And Thai's soldiers get a victory in every battlefield such as Chong Bok, Non Mark Moon, Romklao etc.
Only Thai's soldiers can stop Vietnam's soldier.
But today Thailand and Vietnam we already became one of a sincerely friend.
@@thasspongthapsang6769 Yeah, all those raids because you supported Khmer Rouge. Haizzzz.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnamese_border_raids_in_Thailand
They Didnt Defeat China Its Still Here
@@thasspongthapsang6769 lol. bitch ass twat support the khmer rouge to bite us in the ass, dont cry at UN or ASEAN then, 1v1 ez
Khi sang Đài Loan, tôi rất tự hào khi kể về VN, rất tự hào với những trang lịch sử vàng, đầy vẻ vang, tôi rất từ hào khi nói đến văn hóa, truyền thống của ng VN cho những ng bạn Đài của tôi. Và tôi rất tự hào khi là người VN mà còn là 1 quân nhân đứng trong hàng ngũ Quân y.
I haven’t met any Taiwanese so far that like communists.
đời đời ghi nhớ công ơn của các anh hùng đã nằm xuống cho đất nước VN 😭
Đời đời khinh bỉ đám 3 que phản bội dân tộc
@@3quexolanguyno232 chuẩn :))
vous futes nos amis et nos freres.............honte au communisme
@@thierrylegaulois9709 còn tao thì cảm thấy xấu hổ về chủ nghĩa tư bản chuyên đi cướp đất xâm lược nước khác
@@thierrylegaulois9709 Communism saved Vietnam from the French. You should be ashamed for yourself for supporting the colonisers.
I’m a violinist and would be playing this concerto soon, so I wanted to know the scene so I could soak it up. What a sadness...
Wow, I would like 2 listen your concerto, Where can we find it?!
@@fuelveggiediner2127 you can find it, in her bra..
Fuelveggiediner me too
Do you have your recording somewhere? Could I listen to it... many thanks 🤗
Sadness for the oppressors, happiness for freedom people.
Привет из России, всему, великому, вьетнамскому народу!
Thank Cccp.
I'm from Vietnam 🤗 love from USSR
🇻🇳❤🇷🇺
thanks CCCP, Russia🥰🥰🥰
Huraa ❤️
フランス軍に傭兵として従軍したタイ人部隊も全滅したんですよね。
Merci Monsieur Pierre Shoendoeffer . Grâce à vous la mémoire de cette horrible guerre ne mourra jamais. Elle laisse des victimes innombrables, de toutes couleurs et de toutes religions. Votre témoignage est le plus bel hommage, sincère, humain, universel, qu’il eut été possible d’en donner. Merci 🙏🏼
As an Irishman I salute the Vietnamese people for fighting for their homeland. I also lament the loss of life for both sides, especially the french soldiers sent there to fight.
french soldiers fight for Truman's containment of communism and fucking banks like Indo-Suez, they died for nothing, and i really complain for Hmong people
Đất nước chúng tôi đã có cả 1000 chống các cuộc sâm lăng của các đế quốc như Trung Quốc mông cổ pháp mỹ. Vs pháp cũng không ngoại trừ. Dân tộc chúng tôi cũng 1000 năm Trung Quốc chiếm lĩnh vs chúng tôi vẫn nhớ mãi chúng tôi là người Việt Nam và đã không bị đồng hóa cho dù Trung Quốc họ chiếm dữ 1000 năm
The war was a Catholic war The Vatican did not want to lose their toe hold in Indo China All the political leaders were Catholic trained in Jesuit schools even ho chi Minh went to Jesuit school (same as Mugabe of Zimbabwe) America just took over where France left off... Ukraine now catholic war on the Russian Orthodox church/people.....
@@RaoulLeDegueu When the French arrived in the region Truman had not even been born.
dear irishman...something about the horrors of communism...hmmm.
Salute to Vietnamese who endured the horrors,numerous death of war and manage to win with strong heart.
Besides the joy of victory of the Vietnamese soldiers, I still see somewhere bewildered, a little afraid there are white French soldiers, French African soldiers. They are wondering and thinking about something, are they wondering: We lost, why we lost.
Or are they bewildered, do not understand why they were arrested, what did they fight for, who fought for, is their death worth it?
I'd say they were wishing they had won, so they could sweep under the rug the crimes they had committed. Now they had to face them.
They thought that the USA would help France but they didn't, 20 years later the US were fighting against vietnam too...
the self-determination of the Vietnamese people warms my heart, long live all the peoples who fought for their emancipation. embrace of Brazil (independent since 1822)
Independent on paper.
Independent without shooting a single shot.. you never fought for your freedom, it was given away by Portugal unlike mozbique and Angola
Cảm xúc thật khó tả.
Cảm ơn các thế hệ đi trước đã dành cuộc sống tươi đẹp này cho chúng con.
Long live vietnam from algeria africa we fought the same colonizers
dân ta đã chết hơn 4 triệu quân lính.. bom mỹ pháp thả gấp đôi thế chiến thứ 2. tổng gần bằng 400 quả hạt nhân..
ngày xưa gần 80 90 mù chữ thiếu đói..
để độc lập như hôm nay.. dân tộc VN đã đổ bao xương máu..
mong sao đất nước luôn hòa bình.. dân tộc VN càng lớn mạnh..
dân tộc VN luôn tự hào dòng dõi rồng tiên
Trình Music Daklak Vlog làm gì mà đến 4 triệu quân hả ông,cả nước có khoảng gần 1 tr 2 liệt sỹ thôi.Nếu nói là 4 triệu người VN chết thì còn tin đc.
Chắc cộng cả nạn đói năm 45 nữa.
Bởi vậy những han đc như bây h ko bít quí còn a dua theo 3/ chê VN đủ thứ. Trong khi 3/ sợ chết tuột quần chạy ko bít nhục sao.
@@cuonghoang5510 mẹ ko bít còn sủa. 45 Pháp đô hộ VN lương thực bao nhiêu nó đem về Pháp. Tới khi Nhật vô thì bắt ko trồng lúa.bắt trồng cây mây để làm đạn ko cho trồng lúa thì chết đối thôi sao đổ Cộng sản.
@@luanminhtran6264 có nói gì đến cộng sản đâu mà chửi người ta vậy ông.
Today is an economically fast-growing country, a friendly person who wants to live peacefully with the world, but is willing to fight all invading enemies
Vietnam does not have the strongest military in the world, but I am always proud that my country has conquered the world's most powerful enemies. My country 🇻🇳
Dịch bài viết của haxuan : Việt Nam không có quân đội mạnh nhất thế giới, nhưng tôi luôn tự hào rằng đất nước mình đã chiến thắng những kẻ thù hùng mạnh nhất thế giới. Đất nước của tôi
The USA could have easily dropped a couple of nukes on North Vietnam and it would have been a quick & easy victory
There was no desire for conquest or even regime change in Hanoi unlike Japan which Vietnam easily surrendered to.
You olympic team sucks btw
Vietnam old enemies Japan, America and France are now good friends, while China, who’s was supposed a friend, turned out to be an enemy, who even takes vietnam territorial waters. Stay strong, Vietnam, you are not alone.
Well China and Vietnam are not that close for 2000 years.
Japan is not friendly
Vietnam you are alone
Bạn nói hay lắm 👍
Thank❤❤❤
Respect et Compassion au libre peuple du Vietnam. Ở Pháp, thực dân có tiếng xấu (chế độ nô lệ) và Hồ Chí Minh được coi là một nhà cách mạng giỏi đã dẫn dắt dân tộc mình đến với tình huynh đệ, bình đẳng và tự do. Tổ tiên của bạn là những người khổng lồ tự hào. Một ngày nào đó chúng ta sẽ tập hợp tất cả những người khổng lồ trên trái đất.
Together🤝
Glory to the heroic people of Vietnam. To beat the Japanese, French, and the Americans in your struggle for independence is truly an incredible feat, Greetings from Belgrade, Serbia
Братушка-серб, не сдавайся , держись, в 90ые мы много не могли, а сейчас не дадим в обиду NATO✊✊✊... KOSOVO E CERBIЯ✌✌✌
@@user-te3jj2zr9j Спасибо, брат
Thanks. Thank Russia and community county for your help. We will never forget that day.
@@vvtv2318 oh, that's something new that I've learned. I never knew Russia helped Vietnam lol
Lol today's vietnam is just a globalized liberal country like another one, industry of tourism and occidental culture are everywhere. Fought all these wars for the communist ideology and have the economy owned by foreign occidental bankers is the best joke of the history.
How can you say " i win the war " when you lost so many people, have a civil war, be dominated by the chinese regime and have economics problems ? Ridiculous. Also I'm not defending colonialism.
Paix au peuple vietnamien et français 🇻🇳🇫🇷
Alexandre TRAN Paix au peuple Vietnamien libre a Saïgon.
@@ALR1275 sài gòn đầu buồi là thành phố Hồ Chí Minh
@@3quexolanguyno232 Bộ lạc /// Nó còn ảo tưởng về phụt kuốc =)) toàn các cụ U70 sắp xuống lỗ suốt ngày tấu hài 😂
@@3quexolanguyno232 Mày đéo biết gì thì đừng chửi về Sài Gòn quê tao và Bác Hồ
Sài gòn hay thành phố Hồ Chí Mình đều được cả người miền Nam quen nói Sòi gòn hơn và ngắn hơn
The writing was on the wall for America to read, except nobody bothered reading it!
Rain Coast - That's not right. A major in US foreign intelligence in 1945 said "French Indochina is on fire." He saw that Vietnam was on the way to independence, and any involvement would be troublesome. Truman was distracted by the USSR's threat to the situation in Europe, and needed French goodwill, and they played hardball, wanting their empire back. The US helped France stab Vietnam in the back then, and mishandled the entire Asian situation. Any bad things that happened in Asia, and the US probably had a hand in it. We had people who knew what was going on, but the people in charge weren't paying attention.
David Smith
How true!
Mao Communist was the match lighting the fire. However, State Dept. was misled by the pro left staffs in U.S. embassy in China who were seduced to adultery by leftist Chinese college girls, some girls even have access to her American husbands' files to know the attitude of U.S. government before hand. King, Wu-Tai in CIA was a deeply rooted Communist spy planted then as neutral journalist.
Communist in China, Korea, Malaya, Indonesia, Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, just like domimo, only Malaya and Thailand have been curbed by British and Nationalist Chinese.
Ah who gives a fuck *fortunate son begins to play obnoxiously loud*
GET OUT of VIETNAM China
Don't you know that your famous General Giap was actually supported by Mao Communist troops, especially the artillery was supplied and pulled uphill by 2nd field army of Mao Communist thus to shell the valley of Diem Bien Phuh.
GET OUT of VIETNAM China
Pity for your ignorance!
You are the one has been brainwashed so clean by Minh.
Thương các ông, nhớ ơn các ông, đã đổ máu, đã hi sinh, đã phấn đấu để giành lại tự do đến khi quỳ gối xuống, con tim ngừng đập và những giọt máu rơi thì các ông ko thể nào cầm súng được nữa thì thôi, yêu các ông đã cho chúng con tự do ngày hôm nay 😢😢
my grandfather was member logistic foods weapon and bullets for battle Dien Bien Phu..my father and 2 uncles was soldier Viet Nam military joint war against USA and China(1979).. i'm proud about them protect and dedication for freedom of my country.. i'm sr my english so bad .>
Freedom? Under communism? What a joke
I salute the Vietnamese Patriots for the relentless fight for their freedom against all the world powers that wanted them slaves, from imperial France and Japan to expansionist China and USA.
You dont need to be a communist to respect the patriotism of Nation, no matter what the ideological flag it was conducted under.
The question, does Vietnam have freedom today? NO!, Why are million of Vietnamese risk their lives to flee the country?
@@thhdhn2 haha who left are traitors, they followed USA and killed Vietnamese people. And Vietnamese people live very comfortably, freely and happily right now.
@@thhdhn2 why do millions of iraqi and koreans left their country? Aren’t they enjoying the “freedom” and “democracy” that America gave them ?
@@thhdhn2 I want to ask you the same questions about why some Americans, Europeans and quite a few foreigners from different countries decided to settle in Vietnam today even tho America and Europe were considered to be the best places to live on Earth. I can link you to a few channels of these foreigners here but unfortunately UA-cam will think Im a bot spam acc and will just axe this comment. So for your own good, go search some videos on UA-cam made by Alison Linh, Ninja Teacher, Angee Floyd or CeeJay Official about their lives in Vietnam.
@Fd_x well, communist Vietnam is better than communist russia and China. Atleast they still had freedom
Cái giá phải trả khi dám động tới cả 1 dân tộc
Em gái Linh Ka 🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳
Người Con Đất Việt Dân Tộc Việt Nam Chúng Ta Không Bao Giờ Khuất Phục Trước Bất Kỳ Kẻ Thù Xâm Lược Nào
Vậy mà gặp TQ chỉ biết " Quan ngại "
@@nguyencao8688 nghe giọng điệu mày thế nào ấy nhỉ? Thấy cuộc chiến năm 1979 chưa? Mày nghĩ đất nước mình đủ mạnh, dân đủ giàu và sung sướng để lúc nào cũng sẵn sàng tuyên chiến ??? 1 câu nhé. Óc cứt
@@nguyencao8688 mày biết 1974 ko vnch chạy tụt cả quần làm mất hoàng sa đấy HQ5 bắn chìm luôn HQ10 bắn cháy HQ16 bó tay vnch hay lắm dmCH
The sound engineers on this film did an outstanding job.
Vietnam, if you’re listening, please make more movies about how you defeated the most powerful Nuclear Power Armed Forces on the planet Earth. I’m tired watching Hollywood movies. I can’t believe how an army on bicycles defeated the United States, they think they own the planet, they are doing what we didn’t want Hitler to do.
Yeah they own planet. But when the last vietnamese down :)
They didnt defeat them, the media, the social controverse and the poor south vienamese govern were defeated, usa created one of the most effective kill ratio in History killing as many 1 to 10 enemy soldiers
ua-cam.com/video/FFAY8V2NroU/v-deo.html
@@BlackpilledNihilist they lose, war is not all about who suffers alot of casualties
They failed to get what they want to vietnam
So the north vietnamese won this war
@@BlackpilledNihilist well what was the end result ? Certainly doesn t look like a victory to me. Body counts is only a small part of a war. Political, economical and social victories are just as important if not more important than just body counts.
More brave that french soldiers is not possible . Your are our hero
Defending motherland
Bahahahaha france only knows defeat in war, what would you expect from a gaulois anyway
Jeremiah Boyd je suis pas mexicain, tu peux pas nier que les 3 dernières vrai guerre de la France se solde par 3 défaites lamentables : 2ww Indochine Algérie. On vas même pas parler de vichy parce que sa pue...
@@josephguevara9511 3 guerres face aux dizaines d'autres que l'on a gagné. L'algérie n'est meme pas une defaite militaire en plus. La france s'est relevée après la 2nde guerre mondiale et elle est toujours dans le top 10 des forces armées. Je sais pas si t'es français mais si c'est le cas, cracher sur l'honneur de ton pays comme ça c'est vraiment pitoyable.
C SIMON non je suis pas français lol, si l Algérie n est pas une défaite militaire, c est clairement pas une victoire militaire non plus. Faut accepter hein quand vous avez été du mauvais côté. Indochine et Algérie c étais vs les allemands et eux c étais la résistance. Maintenant si t es pas d accord JE MENS FOUS. L empire c est fini et avec de la Chance la francafrique aussi seras fini
Who make the war. Please should love each other. Please stop the war then and now.
Vinexa Jailoy the jews
Tell that to the Viet Minh who liberate the south
Goemon Ishikawa. Liberated the South ? from what ?
You see vietnames the war how you think i dont want to war but again i think same my father can to figting
US & Soviet lol
Xúc động quá! Tự hào quá VN ơi.
Có cả những người nước ngoài họ cũng đang xem kìa.
Those who invaded Vietnam never understood one thing: no matter how lost or unsuccessful at first or how we will continue to fight, fight until the country of Vietnam is Vietnamese. Our generation of parents did not win, our generation will continue, our generation will lie down, the generation of our descendants will continue, fighting until the land of Vietnam is yours. Vietnam.Other countries and nations can fight 10.20 or even 30.40 years but our nation can fight for thousands of years, which is undeniable reflected in the nation's history. I am proud of my country and if my country is invaded again, I am ready to fight and sacrifice for my country.
It should be said no one won that conflict.
An all i need to do is point to the very openness of the Vietnam economy today.
As well as the fact no major battle was one.
To be frank both sides lost all those lives for nothing.
@@thewingedhussar4188 You bring an army to occupy a country and when you cannot take it you say: this war no one wins, the war is nobody wants but there will always be loss and sacrifice, it is important that they What goal did my grandfather die in the fight against France, he believed he was defending the country and my father was hit by 2 bullets in his left shoulder during the war with America but luckily Luckily still alive, he also believes that he is protecting the country, we just want to make peace and be friends with everyone, if people come to Vietnam to travel and learn culture, we always welcome But if someone comes with tanks and bombers, they pay the price
@@trungle4966 Your grand father surely fought justly against France. That isn't in doubt.
The US was telling France at that time that empire was over. If anything we gave them stuff because they were allies and we told them it was stupid and pointless for empire. We helped them with what we did because of alliance agreements.
As for your father being hit. Yeah that was pointless. In fact the US soldier being their was pointless.
Do you not wonder why the US entered Vietnam in the first place?
@@thewingedhussar4188 The US funded France up to 80% in the postwar period, after World War II, after the Dien Bien Phu, the Geneva Agreement was signed to unify the country by general selection. but anyone who lived at that time understood that if the general election happened, then Ho Chi Minh would surely be elected, so the southern government led by Ngo Dinh Diem at that time organized the election. Vote vs 97% votes, there were more than 10,000 votes but in fact all the votes of the South combined less than 3000, a settlement was too obvious and everyone knew that the government was just a puppet, the US gave advice. I came to the South to support the South and in 1954 officially brought my army and allied countries such as Korea, Australia, ... I understood my country's history quite well. Every book is written in bone and blood, if you do not believe you can learn the history of my country from 2000 years ago, it would be uncomfortable to have a neighbor next door. but 'bad' y next to
@@thewingedhussar4188 The war is over, I just hope the two countries can be friends now.Abraham Lincoln once said: every time a bullet goes through a soldier's heart, it's going through a mother's heart. is never a good thing
Respect for Vietnam!
i'm glad the viet won but please respect the french soldeirs there. none of them wanted to be there.. most of them.
The ones that wanted were here for their comrades not to maintain anything.
I know many Vietnamese people who were on the losing side of that war and had to flee from the communists and seek refugee status. They are not happy the north won at all.
@@Cha4k And I also know many of them that returned there and have a good life. The old government was doomed for failure because it was a french puppet government. As expected both side (north and south) deploy propaganda to sway their citizens away. I mean they have a reason to go, the south viewed them as blood thirsty monsters and the north viewed the south as traitors to the country
@@Cha4k Yeah, lemme guess, they're Hmong? No shit, when you collectively side with the foreign oppressors there tends to be a reckoning when all is said and done.
@@Cha4k Because they were traitors who collaborated with the French, ethnic Ming Chinese who are loyal to China? Yeah of course they're not happy, but we Vietnamese people are and that's all that matters.
Les guerres n'ont jamais rien apporté, a par la tristesse et la mort...... Mais les jeunes soldats français, qui ont combattu a dien bien phu, ne se battaient plus pour un pays, ou une forme de politique, ils se battaient pour le copain a côté, dans le même trou, la même tranchée, mais surtout dans la même merde...... Car face a un peuple qui recherche sa liberté, on ne peu rien.... Pierre shoendorfer la bien fait ressentir, dans ce film que j'affectionne tout particulierement, car j'avais été le voir, avec mon père, a l'époque et j'en garde un vif souvenir......
Interesting movie. There’s also a book titled “Dien Bien Phu 1954” by Martin Windrow which gives a good detailed read about this historic battle.
vietnam nunca se rindio en su historia, gran pais.
Khi mà cả châu âu phải quỳ gối trước móng ngựa của đế chế mông cổ thì Việt Nam lúc đó đã 3 lần đánh bại quân mông cổ bằng chiến thuật lấy ít địch nhiều,
@@hoangtuat9381 Vietnam siempre indomable. En Europa tuvo el milagro de no se sometido ya que su Gran Kan habia muerto y el general y su ejército se fueron.
The Vietnamese People's Army is not the strongest military force in the world, but there is no strongest army in the world that can defeat the Vietnamese People's Army. Simply because our Vietnamese People's Army fights for the longevity of our nation, against foreign invaders, it is different from an army that invades another country.
They won their independence fair and square , without any condition imposed by their former colonial rulers , albeit at a high cost . And they were to repeat this giant slaying feat when they saw off America . Small physiques , big hearts . Congrats , Vietnam .
Except they got their asses routinely handed to them by Americans. The NVA and VC never once won an engagement larger than company level against the US. We left and it still took them two more years to accomplish their goals of subjugating the south and enslaving the South Vietnamese people. Now the country is united in communist dictatorship and the people are all vassals of their communist masters. Wow, what a victory. Who wants that freedom anyway?
Bạn hãy đọc cuốn sách của Người Mỹ. Chân Trần chí thép
L'ignorance dans les commentaires...
Vive la France, Dien Bien Phu reste et restera un exemple de baroud d'honneur et d'abnégation pour nos hommes !
Et d'idiotie des généraux français
Enfin non de l'ignorance de la métropole
Cảm xúc thật khó tả, tự hào quá dân tộc Việt Nam tôi.
Sau nầy nếu đất nước buồn thì hãy gọi cho t. T kô húa sẽ làm đất nc vui nhưg t sẽ nguyện sống chết vì tổ quốc
Rất hay.
Đất nước đừng buồn!
behind us is our homeland, old mother, wife and young children, in front of us are monsters. War is painful but if it happens a thousand times, they still choose to stand up and crush that monster.
Respect to the brave and freedom loving people of Vietnam
Thương lắm Việt Nam ơi.
An outstanding victory. Well done, Vietnam.
Notre France !!!!
Quelle histoire depuis 1500 ans !!!!
la France à 1500 ?? la bonne blague !
Ce qui n'est pas faux, depuis la bataille de Tolbiac...
It is said that among the French soldiers there were many former German soldiers of the wehrmacht and waffen ss.
It is just said
And about the Politics Commissars in the Viet army, do you want to speak about ? They were many germans in the foreign legion, which was considered and commonly accepted (by many) to be the second (the last) chance of redemption. The fact you "worked" for France was meaning (still means) alot for guys which have done "bad" things. All legionnaires aren't forcely bad guys, but there are many which were before and they were only a few to be after having joined the FFL.
If you want a good account of this battle including the French units involved, read 'Hell In A Very Small Place' by Dr. Bernard Fall.
Βetween 45 and late 60s the 70%+ of the Foreign Legion were former SS- Nazi germans. They committed unspeakable atrocities towards civilians in Vietnam and Algeria a few years later.
@@mixalismasaoutis1798
Do you have any source about that? It's not that I'm not trusting you: I'm just curious to read more about this topic
Uma das maiores vergonhas da França. O colonialismo francês desmoronou como um castelo de cartas. Só falta agora, a Guiana Francesa se tornar independente, e assim encerrar de vez se encerrar a presença na América do Sul.
one of the biggest humilliations of the XX century against a global major power
feels so good to see vietnam win :D
Againts his opressor,againts a big enemy,againts everyone that attemted to kill him.
VIETNAM is TRULY STRONG!
Ngày xưa thôi , chú bây giờ còn gì nữa đâu.!!!
@@tenkhong6343 bây giờ quân đội vẫn rất mạnh và là một trong 5 quốc gia nhỏ khó xâm lược nhất trên thế giới. Có thể bây giờ giới trẻ không được như xưa nhưng đến khi chiến tranh xảy ra, người Việt sẽ lại vì nước quên thân, Việt Nam sẽ lại sản sinh những nhân tài dẫn dắt kháng chiến, cho dù là mấy bao nhiêu năm đi nữa
Thank you
@@tenkhong6343 kiki :)
Un nombre Nada mas you forgot that the vietnamese have tortured these guy, and these prisonner never came back home. And after that Vietnam became a communist dictatorship which oppress his people. Traitor
For your achievement of driving the French artists to use all their emotions and sensations to commemorate their last colonial struggle, I congratulate you, Vietnamese.
there is more again later, and even more films about it; the Algeria struggle was a conflict better known by the french of the main land than the one in Indochina, and so, it inspired many movies (albeit first censored)
Ce film est sacré et la musique qui l enveloppe brillamment sublime et effrayante car on atteint l ultime...l infiniment éternel!!...
MERCIIii & TRÈS RESPECTUEUSEMENT.
OMG this scene is so realistic, they even used live fire.
The French baited the Viet Minh into a decisive battle; it worked.
BubbleBreak just da result was not not like what they want
TheFandrian yup
They got they ass whooped and had no business there. People are tired of ya'll shit. You got over ran. That's there country and it was proven. How would you like for them to do that in your country. Huh??? You lose.
@TheFandrian Problem is, the Maginot line worked, the german came crossing Belgium.
@@travissimmons3746 Where are you from? UK? US? The same thing can be said about these countries
When will this be available in English?
it won't be.
knowing how PC they are now never play this movie cuz it might offended someone
i t hink there is a english sub on the net
there is an English sub bootleg available online but there is next to no way to view it legally in the US
Vietnamese are tough people...hats off to them...
They defeated 3 mongol invasions too...
Over thousands of years, my people had to fight continuously against enemies in the north invaders and foiled invaders' attempts to assimilate this nation.
@@Alvin66329 Mongolia, China, France, Japan, US,Cambodia. Any enemy else.
I feel bad for both side,.french soldier even worse to, when home instead, being called for hero, respect they being disgrace and mock.
@TheFandrian Indonesia never was French colony?
it was worse actually. Nobody even aknowledged them.
That's what happens when the war is not supported at home.
Dân tộc việt nam anh hùng! Chủ tịch hồ chí minh vỹ đại sống mãi trong sự nghiệp của chúng ta !
Đến tên riêng còn không viết hoa mà tự hào
Ông bạn chỉ huy pháo ở tuyến nào. Bác ruột mình là đại đoàn trưởng ở mặt trận điện biên.
làm gì có đại đoàn, trung đoàn rồi lữ đoàn, sư đoàn, quân đoàn
Việt Hà thời chống pháp , tổ chức quân đội lớn nhất là đại đoàn gồm 6 đại đoàn : 308,316,312, 304,320,325
Đây là một chiến thắng lịch sử của dân tộc Việt Nam. Nhưng tôi ko có cảm tình với cái clip này. Có lẽ đây là một người nước ngoài họ làm đạo diễn. Họ ko hiểu trận này thế nào và tương quan lực lượng thế nào. Có lẽ họ cho rằng Việt Nam lấy thịt đè người trong trận chiến này. Tôi còn nhớ trong một tài liệu lịch sử có viết về một tướng pháp đã tự sát trong trận này . Trước trận chiến này vị tướng này đã nói "tôi sẽ đánh cho pháo binh Việt Minh ko mở miệng ra được "ông ấy cũng là tướng pháo binh và cũng ko phải là tự kiêu khi nói điều đấy. Ở trận chiến này thì Việt Nam ko có không kích mà chỉ có pháo cao xạ và pháo mặt đất. Còn pháp họ có ko kích và pháo binh. Tôi không có cảm tình với cái clip này vì họ cho rằng Việt Nam lấy thịt đè người
ở điện biên phủ, tướng pháo binh pháp còn tự tin nói rằng: Chúng tôi thừa pháo rồi. Và sau khi Việt Minh tấn công, ông ta tự sát sau 1 tuần =))
J
Clip ko chuẩn từ dựng cảnh
Đúng là clip sai nhưng trận điện biên quân số phía việt nam đông áp đảo là thật , huy động cả gần 100.000 người cho trận này đấy , chỉ là thua kém về hỏa lực thôi , còn quân số áp đảo hoàn toàn , và chỉ huy pháo binh pháp hình như là 1 thiếu tá chứ ko phải tướng , pháp chỉ có 1 tướng duy nhất là đờ cát thôi
Phước Nguyễn 54 ngàn thôi bạn ,còn lại là hậu cần
Thật vinh dự khi ông nội tôi là một chiễn sĩ Điện Biên
Parabéns ao povo vietnamita que nunca se curvou a tirania dos países invasores!
US and FR were in a wrong war in VN.
They had fought with CN in this battle field for 20 years.
VN soldiers , CN commanders and weapons , and SOV oral support . These were US and FRA ' s real enemies in VN.
Bộ phim này do người Pháp quay trên lãnh thổ Việt Nam, dựng phim lại về Đien Bien Phu. Chắc cũng phải hơn 20 năm rồi
Quay ở sơn tây những năm 90 ở sơn tây và có vài người đã chết khi nhảuly dù ở hòa lạc đó bạn
Phim tên j ạ
Phim này xem lâu lắm rồi
@@thuanang516 tên phim gì vậy bạn
@@tiemtran235 tên phim gì vậy bạn
At the time 1944, In northern jungle, Ho Chi Minh and Vo Nguyen Giap recruit first 34 soldiers for Viet Minh Army. The army will defeat the 4 majors superpower in brutal wars in next decades.
Parabéns ao povo vietnamita pela sua liberdade e soberania. À custo de suor, sangue e lágrimas 👏👏👏
maximo respeito
Вьетнамцы самые лучшие воины во всей Азии
Was Gen. Navarre taken prisoner? The battle was his blunder: never hole up in a valley and never allow the nemy to put artillery on the hilltops
Ông ta đã bị bắt làm tù binh. Lúc đầu ông ta còn ngạo mạn cho rằng mình vẫn là chỉ huy. Cho đến khi có 1 sĩ quan của chúng tôi nói mọi tù binh đều như nhau. Và sau đó có 1 vài tiếng xì xào và mọi thứ được vào trật tưk. Ông ta vị tướng của Pháp đã phải xếp hàng di chuyển như những tù binh khác
Navarre never activelly participated in the battle. De Castrie was in command in Dien Bien Phu, but the whole idea was Navarre's.
Những thước phim chân thật quá rất cảm ơn người đã quay lại được những thước phim này! Cảm ơn ad
Đời đời nhớ ơn những chiến sĩ dân tộc Việt Nam đã mãi mãi nằm lại trên đất Điện Biên năm ấy
It's just a holiday! You can watch it endlessly! Glory to the Vietnamese soldiers! Glory to Ho Chi Minh! Glory to Ziap! This is for Borodino!
you shitty cmmunist
Причём здесь Бородино? Там все отползли и никто никого не победил.
History will ever remember your name !
0:22 at one side of the "muong thanh bridge "is one of 4 barrel 14,5mm (like ZPU-4 ) it belong to france, an it's still there until now
The French and Vietmanese veterans of that conflict will be very old men now I hope there is no ill feeling between the former foes
.. ce film c'est bien plus que du grand cinéma... ce film c'est un hymne à l'honneur, l'honneur gagné par tous ceux qui se sont battus là bas et l'honneur que la France a perdu en les oubliant...
des colons
@@baptistebrigand5882 c'était le temps des colonies
"100 quả trứng' năm ấy đã sinh ra những người con lỗi lạc nhất.
50 thôi
French generals: "we got it terribly wrong in Vietnam and were fully defeated... no army could be as uncompetent as us"
US generals: "hold my napalm bombs..."
Then ?
then??
The one's I feel most sorry for here are those who were conscripted from the African countries... colonized, and forced to fight and die in a war halfway around the world they had nothing to do with...
كان عمي رحمه الله في هذه الحرب ضد الفيتنام أخذته فرنسا بالقوة مجبرا على حمل السلاح معها و قتال الفيتناميين، عمي أسره الجيش الفيتنام في الخندق مع الكثير من الأسرى الفرنسيين لكن عفى عليه الجيش الفيتنام لأنهم عرفوا انه بريئ من الجزائر اجبرته فرنسا على القتال في صفوفها، لكن ما حدث للمجرمين الفرنسيين من طرف الجيش الفيتنام لا يعلمه إلا الله وحده جراء ما فعلوا بابرياء الفيتنام من قتل و حرق و تشريد في و طنهم الذي يبعد آلاف الكلمترات عن فرنسا المجرمة،،، 1952 ذكرى حرب ديان بيان فو تبقى راسخة في ظهر الجيش الفرنسي المجرم إلى الأبد...
Honneur aux soldats français tombé au combat
Colonialists, imperialists and many other ists
@@veaccara и всякая шваль из иностранного легиона
@@veaccara en français s'il vous plaît
Manger mon merde.
@@veaccara blablabla colonialist blabla blabla
Beaucoup d'étrangers qui insultent dans les commentaires ( et bizarrement même des ricains ), respect éternel à nos anciens mort au combat ou en captivité dans les camps viet minh et memoire à ceux qui ont survécu pour raconté cette guerre et cette bataille 🤚🇫🇷
👍👍👍👏👏👏👏 .
10,000 were taken prisoner and the vietnamese give 3300 back 5 month later ! Sadly this brave soldiers paid the price for 1 century of occupation.
That right, it was began by Kito Roman. Fuck.
Và sau đó đến lượt Mỹ xa lầy vào cuộc chiến tại Việt Nam. Họ giống như những đứa học sinh hư hỏng nên Việt Nam phải cho chúng 1 bài học
Yes, we have a great history and over the past 1000 years we have beaten the United States, France, Japan, China and other neighbors,
Vietnam's biggest enemy is us China we cherish the Chinese people
But we are deeply grateful to the leader of the Chinese Communist Party. We love you very much, and thank you for expressing our love to us, letting the country and people live in Vietnam. In peace and happiness I love you as well as my Vietnamese
💟👍👍
nope, china supported Vietnam in the vietcong war, china is the biggest friend to Vietnam
C'est grâce à cette défaite que le Maroc et la Tunisie ont acquis leur indépendance: en effet la France , trop affaiblie, s'est retrouvée obligée de lacher quelques possession pour préserver le plus important, à savoir l'Algérie. Les vietnamiens se sont battus à la place des marocains et des tunisiens en grande partie.
Napoleon was doing push-ups in his grave....
@TheFandrian The only way you can say such a bulshit is because you are dumb.
@@makky6239 haha its true, france's greatest general was a corsican.
@@bardgold4553 and corse was and is french .... ah boy you are desperate !
@@MrFuckthechicken italian was the official language of corsica till 1859. That's how French corsica was.
@@bardgold4553 it was the language of my people where i live before 1860 and yet we always near of the french culture like corsican during history, always between italia and france ... (And she was franck during charlemagne's reign and first part of middle age ... )
Respect From S.korea So brave country..
khiếp thật chứ , hơn 4 vạn con người cầm súng biết rỏ mình đang làm gì đi đâu đánh ở đâu, đó phải là sự đoàn kết và kỹ luật tuyệt vời
Watching this clip from the US, how can I see this movie? It looks great but I couldn’t find a version for US coded DVD players.
A few day ago we celebration 67 years victory of dien bien phu,a slap straight to the brutal francis empire and it is a excuted for that empire,an empire never can defeat a glorious country,we opened for all colonies in the world find freedom and independent,love all african-asia-american country who fight again imperialism,glory VietNam !!
Why philippines can't protect their own country???
They don't have Ho Chi Minh
Because they have dutete
Việt nam muôn năm.chiến đấu hết mình vì chính nghĩa
The Vietnamese army is very agile, brave and brave
Ông Nội tôi sinh năm 1924 đã từng là dân quân tải gạo lên chiến trường Điện Biên Phủ
Where can I find this movie? It's supposed to be a well made film about a major historical event, and is well regarded as one of the most important war films of French cinema. But I can't find it anywhere. I've checked UA-cam, Amazon, Hulu, and every pirate website I could think of. Pirate Bay and Putlocker are dead, so no luck there. I even looked for DVDs and came up empty. Any ideas? It's like the earth swallowed this movie and it won't be rediscovered for thousands of years like the Rosetta Stone. Goddammit!