Your reviews are just getting better and better. You bring the attitude of the type of person that I'd like to drink some beers with. Funny, friendly, honest. Would love to know what your all time favorite games are sometime!
As a french canadian, the name Barrage is sounding good to me. (most of our electricity come from water/hydro generated by "barrages") It is very true that the component quality is subpar for a 100++CND game. We are talking about peeling cardboard, flimsy quality... and dont crank me up on the machine (grey and brown bits) that are too small in single unit. Same thing with the 1 credit tokens... too small! On the other hand, it is a heavy euro that is not buried under a f* tons of rules. Like water, the game is pretty streamlined. On the other hand (am I a 3 arms guy?!?), you can have a strong runaway leader if you didn't thought about your first couples buildings placement. In conclusion, as a solo player, big recommendation if you are more into gameplay than into quality of the bits.
I have started to question my eyesight when 10 years older cousing of mine asked me why I haven't painted a minor detail on a figurine and I wasn't sure if I can see it at all.
Just gotta point out that placing a worker on the space that allows you to access another players executive action doesn't count as your turn. You effectively take another action with their bonus for the cost of one extra worker (or one worker and 3 coins)
@@BoardGameBollocks the designer confirmed that it is a free action you can activate without consuming your turn. Tried to link the bgg thread but looks like youtube flagged it. But search bgg barrage mahiri
Really torn on this one. The theme and mechanics look great and the artwork is nice (strong Brass vibe and I have both Lancashire and Birmingham). The potential spoiler here is the production quality for a game costing the thick end of £60. I, too, read that KS backers were not too happy either. With a few tweaks to the production quality this would be a no brainer for me, even if it would be one of those rare-to-the-table titles that I would have to be in the mood for. To that end it would occupy a place similar to Brass, but Brass with its clay chips is just bloodly lovely even when you are not playing it.
I really like this one. Components are a bit shoddy but it’s the prospect of an exhausting experience that puts me off playing this one. Once you get going that’s fades until the end.
The retail version is pretty solid quality wise. If you like this kind of game, don't worry too much about it. I never regretted getting Barrage, and it has a sure place in my collection
It never occurred to me before, so I looked it up: BARrage (like "baggage", but with a bar) is a dam, which bars the waterway. As opposed to barRAGE (like the Indian Raj), which is a bombardment. I have never once heard anyone pronounce this game correctly! Should've just called it Barry and been done with it.
it took me a moment to focus on video to grasp the mechanics but it was easier than Arc Nova - so it must be the game itself that is demanding - especially since it's the kind where you actually follow up on what others are doing and have to react to it and possibly even predict in advance
Played this when someone suggested it was similar to Brass Birmingham, which I really like. Then, I played it and it left me a bit underwhelmed. Yes, it feels like a euro with a lot of player interaction, but contrary to Brass, I felt that the board was quite difficult to read and that it was very easy to make stupid decisions. I'm not the brightest bulb, so I didn't really want to go back to this game again. Anyhow, I like your content, but I can't watch your next video on Tuesday, Wednesday also fine?
This game is incredible on Board Game Arena but I had a feeling it would be more punishing on the table. I think that's probably true based on your 4.5 hr game! A solo game on BGA takes me 20 minutes...
So, it rises above SLEUG level by strong theme and player interaction and seems a clever design but the idea of playing 4 hours of constructing convoluted flowcharts to achieve victory points seems like water drop torture to me. (the view of the box side said 120 minutes but I infer that was as usual a lie). I will stick to Dos Rios I think.
Played Barry once so I can’t say my opinion is fair, but I found the theme dull. Making electricity power.yay.😶😶 I also found it over complicated, I didn’t like the fact that the wooden components were weird cement mixers 🙄 and I felt lost in terms of any strategy as just knowing what to do on my turn was hard work. I don’t enjoy games that feel like work. I also don’t like the stress that someone else who knows the game better can screw your over. I found the art too dark and now you’ve reminded me how flimsy the card is. Castles of Burgundy does have theme for me…I’m building cities, extending farmland, getting silver from mines, getting trade goods and cash when I venture into the shipping. And I love the simplicity of the the rules so lacking in Bowelrage, Barny Barry Barrage. Not for me. No.
I have no complaints about component quality. The only issue with components is that cement mixers and excavators with value 3 and 5 could have a number on them, so that is easier to understand what value are these.
AFAIK "Barrage" is an English word that means "Dam". So it is not an inappropriate name. The Kickstarter by the way had worse components; the water was represented by these little glass beads - even with good fingernails they were difficult to pick up, so you were reduced to pushing them around the board. And I remember the rotating construction track was annoying because the inner part was always popping out of the circle. Still, an ok game if a trifle overlong.
Your reviews are just getting better and better. You bring the attitude of the type of person that I'd like to drink some beers with. Funny, friendly, honest. Would love to know what your all time favorite games are sometime!
I’ve done a top 100…check the playlists 👍🏻
Great job on the quick concise rule overview for a pretty complex game. Also love the humor in your videos , good shit.
Looking at the new kickstarter for Barry. I love your reviews and this one genuinely made me laugh.
Great video. I love your style. Don’t think it will be enough for me to buy Barry though.
Most! Great review, quality of components is a put off.
As a french canadian, the name Barrage is sounding good to me. (most of our electricity come from water/hydro generated by "barrages")
It is very true that the component quality is subpar for a 100++CND game. We are talking about peeling cardboard, flimsy quality... and dont crank me up on the machine (grey and brown bits) that are too small in single unit. Same thing with the 1 credit tokens... too small!
On the other hand, it is a heavy euro that is not buried under a f* tons of rules. Like water, the game is pretty streamlined.
On the other hand (am I a 3 arms guy?!?), you can have a strong runaway leader if you didn't thought about your first couples buildings placement.
In conclusion, as a solo player, big recommendation if you are more into gameplay than into quality of the bits.
Always love it when weight/depth emerges from streamlined rules, rather than complexity for the sake of it
I’m still torn on whether to get this one. Good review and perfect amount of bullocks.
I don't see Sandra anywhere though
I see what you did there 😉
I have started to question my eyesight when 10 years older cousing of mine asked me why I haven't painted a minor detail on a figurine and I wasn't sure if I can see it at all.
Not sure if this helps with how you feel about the name, but there's a different pronunciation if the word relates to dams vs. bombardment
What’s that then?
@@BoardGameBollocks ˈbär-ij, so like bar, followed by the end of fridge. Although, I think it sounds worse. haha
Still sounds like Barry
If you haven't already big fulla, mutifocal glasses are the best thing I've bought for board gaming. For us 40 somethings with fading vision....
Im in a state of denial which is quite comfortable so please leave me alone 👍🏻 😉
Heheh🤓
Great video, thank you very much.
Just gotta point out that placing a worker on the space that allows you to access another players executive action doesn't count as your turn. You effectively take another action with their bonus for the cost of one extra worker (or one worker and 3 coins)
Not sure I follow. If you’re using a worker then it counts as your turn does it not?
@@BoardGameBollocks the designer confirmed that it is a free action you can activate without consuming your turn. Tried to link the bgg thread but looks like youtube flagged it. But search bgg barrage mahiri
Is "barrage" an esoteric word in the UK?
No not really
I really like Barrage even at 2 players..
Thanks for the video.
Really torn on this one. The theme and mechanics look great and the artwork is nice (strong Brass vibe and I have both Lancashire and Birmingham). The potential spoiler here is the production quality for a game costing the thick end of £60. I, too, read that KS backers were not too happy either. With a few tweaks to the production quality this would be a no brainer for me, even if it would be one of those rare-to-the-table titles that I would have to be in the mood for. To that end it would occupy a place similar to Brass, but Brass with its clay chips is just bloodly lovely even when you are not playing it.
I really like this one. Components are a bit shoddy but it’s the prospect of an exhausting experience that puts me off playing this one. Once you get going that’s fades until the end.
The retail version is pretty solid quality wise. If you like this kind of game, don't worry too much about it. I never regretted getting Barrage, and it has a sure place in my collection
It's not true the board has the same problem.@@kriba6755
Barrage is a Top 3 game for me. It's excellent.
as usual, great video
Everyone I played this game with liked it a lot. I on the other hand hated it so much every time I played my brain wanted to explode
Played this on BGArena. Reminds me of Scythe. Really enjoy Barrage but so far have been utterly useless at gaining VP.
It never occurred to me before, so I looked it up: BARrage (like "baggage", but with a bar) is a dam, which bars the waterway.
As opposed to barRAGE (like the Indian Raj), which is a bombardment. I have never once heard anyone pronounce this game correctly! Should've just called it Barry and been done with it.
😂👍🏻
it took me a moment to focus on video to grasp the mechanics but it was easier than Arc Nova - so it must be the game itself that is demanding - especially since it's the kind where you actually follow up on what others are doing and have to react to it and possibly even predict in advance
Played this when someone suggested it was similar to Brass Birmingham, which I really like. Then, I played it and it left me a bit underwhelmed. Yes, it feels like a euro with a lot of player interaction, but contrary to Brass, I felt that the board was quite difficult to read and that it was very easy to make stupid decisions. I'm not the brightest bulb, so I didn't really want to go back to this game again.
Anyhow, I like your content, but I can't watch your next video on Tuesday, Wednesday also fine?
C U Next Weds doesn’t have the same ring to it
Love the look of this game, but it’s going to be too heavy for my usual game group.
This game is incredible on Board Game Arena but I had a feeling it would be more punishing on the table. I think that's probably true based on your 4.5 hr game! A solo game on BGA takes me 20 minutes...
So, it rises above SLEUG level by strong theme and player interaction and seems a clever design but the idea of playing 4 hours of constructing convoluted flowcharts to achieve victory points seems like water drop torture to me. (the view of the box side said 120 minutes but I infer that was as usual a lie).
I will stick to Dos Rios I think.
120 minutes is setup 😳
Never took us four hours. Even our first game with 4 players.
2, max 3 hours it will play. Depends on your group
Never 2 hours with 4…porky pies mate
Never 2 hours with 4…porky pies mate
That's why I said 2, max 3 hours.
My gaming time does not include setup, etc. Just pure playing time. 2.5 is doable
Played Barry once so I can’t say my opinion is fair, but I found the theme dull. Making electricity power.yay.😶😶 I also found it over complicated, I didn’t like the fact that the wooden components were weird cement mixers 🙄 and I felt lost in terms of any strategy as just knowing what to do on my turn was hard work.
I don’t enjoy games that feel like work. I also don’t like the stress that someone else who knows the game better can screw your over.
I found the art too dark and now you’ve reminded me how flimsy the card is.
Castles of Burgundy does have theme for me…I’m building cities, extending farmland, getting silver from mines, getting trade goods and cash when I venture into the shipping. And I love the simplicity of the the rules so lacking in Bowelrage, Barny Barry Barrage.
Not for me. No.
I have no complaints about component quality. The only issue with components is that cement mixers and excavators with value 3 and 5 could have a number on them, so that is easier to understand what value are these.
Some components were missing and the publisher never bothered to get back to me about it. Poor form.
play if you smart... and not just street smart :D
AFAIK "Barrage" is an English word that means "Dam". So it is not an inappropriate name. The Kickstarter by the way had worse components; the water was represented by these little glass beads - even with good fingernails they were difficult to pick up, so you were reduced to pushing them around the board. And I remember the rotating construction track was annoying because the inner part was always popping out of the circle. Still, an ok game if a trifle overlong.
It’s actually borrowed from the french Barrage (barrier). I just don’t like the way it sounds.
Barrage. Sounds a little bit like F… Puts me off and all.
Bollocks!
I'll go out on a limb and bet you're not a fan of the Legendary Box art.
No
@@BoardGameBollocks I've commented in the campaign asking them if they could give backers a poll with other options. Thanks for the sanity check!
'Barrage' makes me think of something to do with a bombardment. If it was an American game it might have been.