Post-independence in 1947, Bengal was partitioned into West Bengal (India) and East Bengal (later East Pakistan, now Bangladesh). Under Indian rule (1947-1971), West Bengal faced: Economic Discrimination: The central government in India neglected West Bengal’s development, leading to significant underinvestment in infrastructure and industry. Resource Drain: Revenues generated in West Bengal were largely spent in Cow Belt, exacerbating regional disparities.
@@grdainylung5216 Modi doing everything after proper allocation of development fund. Didi using development fund for Madrasa Education and Imam Bhata etc.
Why West Bengal didn't take Ayushman scheme? Conditions of OBCs is worst in West Bengal. West Bengal is upper caste ruled state. Entire Muslim community is under OBC A in West Bengal. Can anyone challenge these facts as untrue?
@@uttamkapri6794 why NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal? Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage. Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent? Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal? Can u deny these?
Mr. Sarkar you are a good orator. But you never mentioned the theft at all levels. Your government is highly communal. Why don't you go to the Supreme court for injustice to West Bengal? Sorry to say, you are also a stooge of Mamta
Some people are not satisfied even if PM works 24x7 without sleep for 10 years. Some Bhajpa walas don't know the GDP per capita of India because they are illiterate.
tmc is the worst kind of government west Bengal have people here removed left so that mamta could uplift the state but here she is only uplifting there bank balance each and every party member each and every councillors
British Exploitation: The economic decline of Bengal began with British colonial rule. The British East India Company and later the British Crown systematically exploited Bengal's resources, leading to: Deindustrialization: The destruction of Bengal's thriving textile industry as British manufactured goods flooded the market. Resource Extraction: Heavy taxation and resource extraction impoverished local communities. Famine: Policies like forced cultivation of indigo and the diversion of resources contributed to famines, notably the Great Bengal Famine of 1943.
The same slogan Kendra is depriving Bengal economically was on air since left front govt came to power in Bengal and ruled for 34 yrs.. Then congress was ruling in center. Now both are replaced by TMC and BJP respectively. Say something new .
Moneys are available for statue parliament pm aircrafts but never provided bengals due share.shame feudal minded bjp rss.bjp instigates communal provoking.
Declare President rule in Punjab & WB immediately. It's already too late. Looks like Namunkin Modi doesn't want to learn his mistakes even after getting reduced minority government
For whom who always bengal is burning. Why NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal? Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage but it happens in every states Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent? Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal? Can u deny these?
I am from WB and the state is plagued by limitless corruption. E-tender has virtually been abolishe d and syndicate-raj as per directive of ministers is the rule. Want to see oligarchy without any business, see the portfolio holders of TMC. You and BJP are two sides of same coin
Mr. Sircar, give a good reason for not getting the economic blockade. If educated people like you support this highly corrupt party then Bengal is in the drains.
😮Probably he is right, but when he was an active bureaucrat i.e. in service in West Bengal during the left front regime he never uttered anything though at that time discrimination was also abysmal. This power crazy, anti worker retired bureaucrat has no credibility. If BJP assures him more of the facilities he would shift towards them.
Being an ex burocrat he should appreciate that central fund is allotted not for squandering but for proper utilisation .State Govt has failed to furnish accounts as per procedure . Mr Sarkar better advise TMC Govt to follow rules and procedures .
NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal? Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage. Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent? Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal? Can u deny these? Amader bangla onek bhalo.
Waste bengal facing blockade..being said from 1947..discrimination..may it be a mental problem..ruling elite of wb was left always ..no work,red flag,,kanu sanyal..break everything..taka mati,,mati taka...said one gadadhar chattor ji..now again haihai
Has this channel shown mob lynchings incidents that happened since 7 days in Bengal. Specially a woman paraded naked in coochbehar,and uttar dinajpur beaten publicly on Street. No why this selectiveness.
why NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal? Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage. Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent? Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal? Can u deny these?
@@NewEraThought I didn't comment against any minister. I commented about whole northies population. Bengal has worst ministers. But bengali community don't do these evils which i mentioned. And u don't have any counter points to that.
@@SeekerSeeker we are fighting for healthy Democracy and against intimidation in Bengal where we can put views,Do u know how many political killings happened in Bengal since 2006,pls research on Bengal politics how violent it was,it is,and it gonna be till 2026 assembly elections. Pls Google or UA-cam. 1970 Sainbari case. Bengal.Congress is in power in state and central. 2010 Deganga riots Left was in power in state and UPA was in central. After Bihar Bengal is the second largest state in terms of labour force supply to other states.
Very well spoken and expressed. We really must think about these facts and muse on the real condition of the economy . And the huge damage that "AJA" types have done to the country .
"Cellular jail sanjeev sanyal bengali" Ya likhe google e main twitter ka ek post milega. Janha pe bharat sarkar ka ek document hy it shows in cellular jail out of 585 inmates 398 was bangali
Former beaurocrat turned politician who "apparently" represents the people of Bengal but has never bothered to come down to ground zero and hear the voices of the common man. He can be seen only in elite gatherings and celebrity parties. His flowery speeches are simply empty words with zero credibility. Two faced opportunist of the worst kind.
Post-independence in 1947, Bengal was partitioned into West Bengal (India) and East Bengal (later East Pakistan, now Bangladesh). Under Indian rule (1947-1971), West Bengal faced:
Economic Discrimination: The central government in India neglected West Bengal’s development, leading to significant underinvestment in infrastructure and industry.
Resource Drain: Revenues generated in West Bengal were largely spent in Cow Belt, exacerbating regional disparities.
West Bengal Govt should move Supreme court and pray for fund release.....like Kerela and karanataka did
@@playandwatch3129 They cannot because they are the ones who userp the funds for themselves.
Mr. Sarkar only thinks about his bright future not for West Bengal.
Well said, Mr. Sircar.
Jawar sir we are glad to hear you
Mamata distributing money for vote and asked for central fund.
Modi also do it not only Didi,all political parties do it.
@@grdainylung5216 Modi doing everything after proper allocation of development fund. Didi using development fund for Madrasa Education and Imam Bhata etc.
TMC is the reason why Bengal is suffering, A gas chamber of Political violence
Why West Bengal didn't take Ayushman scheme?
Conditions of OBCs is worst in West Bengal.
West Bengal is upper caste ruled state.
Entire Muslim community is under OBC A in West Bengal.
Can anyone challenge these facts as untrue?
@@uttamkapri6794 why NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal?
Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage. Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent?
Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal?
Can u deny these?
Mamata begum destroyer of WB. She playing leading roles to destroy WB. 😅😅😅
Bengali is muslim rastra as per a Uttar Dinajpur TMC MLA
I am glad to hear your speech. Regards
Mr. MP knows well that Bengal lives on begging CG only😅
what a innocent face of TMC looters!!!!!
All suppoters and leaders looters in mjp(modi julum party) and clearly voters of India's did vote against mjp.
After a long days a good speech in our Parliament.
Jaise hi TMC ka mp khada hua bolne, dhankar bhaag Gaya🤣
Appeasement politics in Bengal
Mr. Sarkar you are a good orator. But you never mentioned the theft at all levels. Your government is highly communal. Why don't you go to the Supreme court for injustice to West Bengal?
Sorry to say, you are also a stooge of Mamta
2and half hour of modi speech was like in slums fighting for water the launguage has dignity.
Some people are not satisfied even if PM works 24x7 without sleep for 10 years. Some Bhajpa walas don't know the GDP per capita of India because they are illiterate.
Om birla was like a bakht while Modi's speech. While Rahul ji speech was burnt.
Why is this hatred for Bengal?
Very well argument Mr. Jawhar Sircar
tmc is the worst kind of government west Bengal have people here removed left so that mamta could uplift the state but here she is only uplifting there bank balance each and every party member each and every councillors
British Exploitation:
The economic decline of Bengal began with British colonial rule. The British East India Company and later the British Crown systematically exploited Bengal's resources, leading to:
Deindustrialization: The destruction of Bengal's thriving textile industry as British manufactured goods flooded the market.
Resource Extraction: Heavy taxation and resource extraction impoverished local communities.
Famine: Policies like forced cultivation of indigo and the diversion of resources contributed to famines, notably the Great Bengal Famine of 1943.
The same slogan Kendra is depriving Bengal economically was on air since left front govt came to power in Bengal and ruled for 34 yrs.. Then congress was ruling in center. Now both are replaced by TMC and BJP respectively. Say something new .
Moneys are available for statue parliament pm aircrafts but never provided bengals due share.shame feudal minded bjp rss.bjp instigates communal provoking.
Declare President rule in Punjab & WB immediately. It's already too late. Looks like Namunkin Modi doesn't want to learn his mistakes even after getting reduced minority government
For whom who always bengal is burning.
Why NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal?
Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage but it happens in every states Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent?
Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal?
Can u deny these?
I am from WB and the state is plagued by limitless corruption. E-tender has virtually been abolishe d and syndicate-raj as per directive of ministers is the rule. Want to see oligarchy without any business, see the portfolio holders of TMC. You and BJP are two sides of same coin
Well researced speech must be preserved by the students of politics and economics
Mr. Sircar, give a good reason for not getting the economic blockade. If educated people like you support this highly corrupt party then Bengal is in the drains.
Good speech supported by facts and figures.
Good Mr sarkar.. 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍
Recruit safety of railways.
If it is true then it is a very good news.
Most mis managed state in India .
😮Probably he is right, but when he was an active bureaucrat i.e. in service in West Bengal during the left front regime he never uttered anything though at that time discrimination was also abysmal.
This power crazy, anti worker retired bureaucrat has no credibility. If BJP assures him more of the facilities he would shift towards them.
Being an ex burocrat he should appreciate that central fund is allotted not for squandering but for proper utilisation .State Govt has failed to furnish accounts as per procedure . Mr Sarkar better advise TMC Govt to follow rules and procedures .
To Sanjib Sanyal those Gujus have immagination aspiration ! 😅😆😃🐕
NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal?
Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage. Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent?
Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal?
Can u deny these?
Amader bangla onek bhalo.
Loot is going on.
What data base speech .
MP SAHEB, HAVE YOU HEARD ABOUT SANDESHKHALI???? CHOPRA INCIDENT???? DO YOU KNOW OUR 140 CR PEOPLE..????
Sandeshkhali is a fiction created by BJP IT cell, all false !
❤❤❤
Tmc hatao West Bengal bachao
your so much shout was not needed if W.B.Govt responded to CAG report
Waste bengal facing blockade..being said from 1947..discrimination..may it be a mental problem..ruling elite of wb was left always
..no work,red flag,,kanu sanyal..break everything..taka mati,,mati taka...said one gadadhar chattor ji..now again haihai
12:15😢😢
10:12
Has this channel shown mob lynchings incidents that happened since 7 days in Bengal.
Specially a woman paraded naked in coochbehar,and uttar dinajpur beaten publicly on Street.
No why this selectiveness.
why NCRB show caste hatred is least in West Bengal?
Write "honour killing in haryana/bihar/Andhrapradesh/bengal etc" All state one by one and see the news section. Only in West Bengal there is no honour killing in intercaste marriage. Just four days ago u would find a news of girls got killed fir marrying a dalit in haryana. Why ur godi is silent?
Why 2cr female foeticide happened in cow belt as per 1991 and 2011 census but not in Bengal?
Can u deny these?
@@SeekerSeeker sorry won't comment anything bcs heard a news that a person got arrested as he has commented in facebook live against a minister.
@@NewEraThought I didn't comment against any minister. I commented about whole northies population.
Bengal has worst ministers. But bengali community don't do these evils which i mentioned. And u don't have any counter points to that.
@@SeekerSeeker we are fighting for healthy Democracy and against intimidation in Bengal where we can put views,Do u know how many political killings happened in Bengal since 2006,pls research on Bengal politics how violent it was,it is,and it gonna be till 2026 assembly elections.
Pls Google or UA-cam. 1970 Sainbari case.
Bengal.Congress is in power in state and central. 2010 Deganga riots Left was in power in state and UPA was in central. After Bihar Bengal is the second largest state in terms of labour force supply to other states.
West Bengal Govt should move Supreme court and pray for fund release.....like Kerela and karanataka did
The channel has proved it is unable to see in any other direction,other than left.
Choose one from millions of godis, no one complaining.
Very well spoken and expressed. We really must think about these facts and muse on the real condition of the economy . And the huge damage that "AJA" types have done to the country .
If BJP is right, we must change the definition of right.
The CAG reports tell otherwise.
"Cellular jail sanjeev sanyal bengali" Ya likhe google e main twitter ka ek post milega. Janha pe bharat sarkar ka ek document hy it shows in cellular jail out of 585 inmates 398 was bangali
Former beaurocrat turned politician who "apparently" represents the people of Bengal but has never bothered to come down to ground zero and hear the voices of the common man. He can be seen only in elite gatherings and celebrity parties. His flowery speeches are simply empty words with zero credibility. Two faced opportunist of the worst kind.