What wonderful story for South Sudanese, Mkuruu the picture of Kevin in the story standing together with South Sudanese soldiers recall our Struggle I saw South Sudan President Mr. Salvir Khier Mayardit together with Kevin
I've been seeing that picture of a child and vulture on Facebook but today I've gotten the whole story. Thank you Mkurugenzi. You deserve the Nobel prize!
Teacher, teacher: The club's name was The Bang Bang Club and it consisted of 4 members. Back to the story: I think Kevin did what he thought was the best thing to do at that particular point with the information he had. I did a crash course in First Responder and one thing the instructors kept hammering onto us was: If you dont have the right gear or material for a situation dont respond ii) Always asses a situation and if you realize offfering help puts you in harms way then stop immediately. I'd hate to be in Kevin's shoe because sincerely I dont know what I would have done. It also break my heart that he had to take his life: that pic triggered an avalanche of humanitarian response which I think was a positive thing. Did the baby die, for those who know?
Such a tragic and sad story but just a thought… why couldn’t they give the child even a bottle of water and some little food to give the child some strength to reach where there was food?
The first time I heard this story my heart genuinely broke,I couldn't sleep for days,I wept for the kid.I wept for and blamed humanity.This is one of those stories that sticks with you.Forever.
I am a nurse and sometimes I over ride the Doctors Order and I go home with my licence at steak God has never left me . And one time I waited for the Doctor and the patient died I cannot bear it again and God is faithful so faithful.
You never know how you'll act in a certain situation until you're In it. Too many variables come into play. He did his job and it's sad that we live in such a broken world.
What a sad ending for Kevin.he was traumatized probably regretting he would have done things differently.rules are meant to be broken.Mkuru you have done justice to the story.beautifully narrated
It’s ok. He served his purpose. The problem is that UN , UNEP and other agencies are copied his strategy to collect money. Using a small group of suffering Africans for their own benefit. That is the tragedy 😢
The war in Sudan will forever remain a painful part of our history. All the people who witnessed it and survive try to explain the ordeal wanashindwa. None can explain it with dry eyes
Just read about this yesterday. Being human is such a strange weakness . Humans get affected when they see other humans suffer, especially when it's beyond their control.
If this story had been given without Kevin's history of standing for what's right regardless of the rules we would probably judge him different. I remember vaguely hearing a snippet of the vulture story and judging it as inhumane, but now I feel differently about it. Let's leave the judging to God because sometimes we don't know the whole story.
When I was studying journalism as an undergraduate we often discussed the ethics surrounding the photo...Some say it was wrong and others said that Kevin Carter did no wrong.
According to me, the mission, there was to take photos in order to attract aid but now you’ve got to one of the most precious photo according to your feelings at the same time. It is a life that you have to save, especially knowing that this is a toddler despite being under serious instruction not to touch or come to contact to the victims, now I think he could just sat down there and wait until the medics arrive before proceeding to the next destination. Better time wasted to save a life, than time saved to get content.
Remember as Mkuru has just said they were under strict instructions. And two, they had been ordered (not even asked I presume) to go where the plane was giving the aid to capture that. They had to be there. Otherwise may he Rest in Peace.
The whole point of taking the photos was to use them to sought aid to save the people of Sudan, was the child not part of the people they were looking help for? There is no excuse for not saving the girls life
Such a touching story Sometimes I watch news about some communities fighting, some hate speech from from our politicians and some citizens support such hate speech, and I am like, “these people do not know the value of the peace we enjoy in this country.” Refugee are just people who were living their normal lives in their country; teachers, bankers, healthcare practitioners, lawyers, engineers, business people, the jobless, etc., but something happened in their country and they could no longer live there. The fact that in most parts of this country, Nairobi for example, you can wake up, walk to the nearest bus stop, catch a bus to CBD, run your errands, and once done, catch another bus to your residence and find your house still intact, is a reason to thank God and do whatever it takes to keep that peace. I was moved by the criticism that eventually led to Kelvin committing suicide. And I can imagine in this generation with social media, such criticism can go even further. I think it is important to make an effort to understand the circumstances someone was in before judging them. In this spirit, Abel please tell the story of “The Lost Boys of Sudan.” It might not be such a headline hitter, but it is a touching story.
Thank-you for your insight. This is something people need to be told. Peace is so underrated. Especially in Kenya, it's almost as if some people work extra hard to bring chaos.
What killed Carter was the fact that a journalist told him that there were 2 vultures in the photo the bird and Carter.This ruined his life badly to the point of committing suicide.
Thank you...I finally understand this story and I feel guilty for judging Carter. We are not any better, I could have done the same 😢medics walikuwa wanakam after all🙂
I used to see this picture bt I couldn't comprehend more about it bt now I'm a ware of the ordeal behind it.Carter might have died of guilty bt what of Silva?This reminds us of how Humanity is complex devoid of other factors like Orders that this guy was following to the later and the awards he was chasing after.Empathy is key!
Carter did a good job as a photographer to show the world the extremes of life and he did his job well.I think that people missed the intention of his work .The conversation should not have turned against him but rather should have focused on the thousands of people suffering the same plight as the young girl.
A deep story. We live in a very opinionated time where pundits and bloggers are paid for their opinion notwithsanding the threshold of enough facts. We then proceed to harshly judge and condemn. May God save us.
Seems so simple for you I guess. There was danger of communicable diseases among the Sudanese and Kevin wasn't alone so he couldn't risk his friends' lives even if he would his. I'd like to hear your response based on these facts.
Thanks mkurugenzi for this story. All along I've been blaming Kevin not knowing deep down it tortured him for leaving that girl helplessly. So sad indeed
Well, thanks to Kevin Carter for that superb picture. Deep down aliumia kwenye roho but lets just agree that in this world, we have no any other option but to listen to our superiors
It is very funny seeing how people criticise the photographer for his actions about leaving the kid behind and then going I had to do his duties. And this other guy is out here screaming out loud that rules are meant to be broken, Just remember we’re all human beings and our first instincts we’ll always be to save ourselves first especially if it’s in a state of life and death situations.Bravo to the guy he did what took him there. If I were in his shoes I would’ve done the same thing. And rather keep 10 people safe than save one.
this is a very sad story indeed....mimi i thought venye walipata huyo mtoi hapo watamsaidia manze and i was like "fyuuks atleast" only for them to leave her there....that is so heartbreaking .
Have been seeing that picture for on social media from long time!have never knew the story behind it Am glad to here the story from you mkuru Big up meeen for being mtrue and delivering the best to our ears ❤❤❤❤❤❤
I literally cried after seeing that picture... Imagning it were my relative... Alrather me myself.. imagn what crossed the mind of the child seeing a person whose able to rescue her taking only a photo of her without helping her.. 😢😢😢 if it were me karter.. I could have done the same
Tragically, Carter committed suicide three months after the photograph was published and only a week after being awarded the Pulitzer Prize. Carter’s death is speculated to have been a result of one of two things: either he could not handle the fame that was brought on by the photograph and the award, or he could not bear the guilt of not helping the child in the photograph. In a Time magazine article following Carter’s tragic suicide, the piece relayed the guilt that Carter felt and how “even some of Carter's friends wondered aloud why he had not helped the girl” (MacLeod, 1994). The guilt he had felt afterwards for not helping the little girl seemed to be too much for the man to handle.
I guess from the suicide note, he explained why he had to end his life.....money, depression, horrible images of dead bodies and inability to help those in need
I believe that was the last straw,the trauma had been building throughout his life eventually exploded after the picture.I wish he hadn't spoken publicly about the details of the photo...if truly he called the UN immediately and was told the situation was being taken care of,then he would have never faced the public wrath. On the other hand,we don't know if the UN acted in the urgency that was required or that he was actually afraid of whatever disease the girl might have been carrying...and the guilt was overwhelming.Sad,sad,sad...I wish mental health services were as available as they are now.Im sure he has PTSD as well from everything he saw and experienced since childhood.
If I was in Carter's shoes ningeambia colleagues to go ahead nibaki na mtoi. Then I'd carry her to where the food ilikuwa. Before releasing my colleagues, I'd tell them to radio medics equipped in this high risk situation wanikute kwa njia in case the place where food is being distributed ni mbali. Because as my uncle who was in Red Cross used to say, " No one gets left behind."
What wonderful story for South Sudanese, Mkuruu the picture of Kevin in the story standing together with South Sudanese soldiers recall our Struggle I saw South Sudan President Mr. Salvir Khier Mayardit together with Kevin
Eish lucky me today kukua top ten kwa comment section manze keep up the spirit we love and get inspire by you
Hawa wasee wa Nobel peace prize hawaezi nominate Mkurugenzi na yeye ashinde hii kitu...
He is doing more than enough kutuentertaine...
You are the next Kenyan taking the Nobel prize bro✨
Sure
I've been seeing that picture of a child and vulture on Facebook but today I've gotten the whole story. Thank you Mkurugenzi. You deserve the Nobel prize!
You are welcome!
@@Mkurugenziii check out my comment
Teacher, teacher: The club's name was The Bang Bang Club and it consisted of 4 members. Back to the story: I think Kevin did what he thought was the best thing to do at that particular point with the information he had. I did a crash course in First Responder and one thing the instructors kept hammering onto us was: If you dont have the right gear or material for a situation dont respond
ii) Always asses a situation and if you realize offfering help puts you in harms way then stop immediately.
I'd hate to be in Kevin's shoe because sincerely I dont know what I would have done. It also break my heart that he had to take his life: that pic triggered an avalanche of humanitarian response which I think was a positive thing. Did the baby die, for those who know?
correct
✅✅
No the baby survived but died 14years later from Malaria
Such a tragic and sad story but just a thought… why couldn’t they give the child even a bottle of water and some little food to give the child some strength to reach where there was food?
@@beatykairu5331 probably they'd run out of them by the time they got to where the kid was.
The Bang Bang Club
The first time I heard this story my heart genuinely broke,I couldn't sleep for days,I wept for the kid.I wept for and blamed humanity.This is one of those stories that sticks with you.Forever.
I am a nurse and sometimes I over ride the Doctors Order and I go home with my licence at steak God has never left me . And one time I waited for the Doctor and the patient died I cannot bear it again and God is faithful so faithful.
Have been in your shoes before
You look nice sweetie momaa
@@KelvinLekipaiya thank you
Pp0pp😊p😊p
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊p0
Watu apa njei wakifurahia kupewa punan mimi nafurahia notification ya mkuru stories
What a sad and memorable story of Kevin Carter.😢
Thank you Mukuru for sharing this.
BANG-BANG CLLUB!!!
You never know how you'll act in a certain situation until you're In it. Too many variables come into play. He did his job and it's sad that we live in such a broken world.
KAMA MKURUGENZI HAUNGEKUWA SAA HII NINGEKUWA NARANDARANDA TU BUT YOU STORY OPEN MY MINDS SANA LEANING MORE God bless you Mkuru❤️🙏
What a sad ending for Kevin.he was traumatized probably regretting he would have done things differently.rules are meant to be broken.Mkuru you have done justice to the story.beautifully narrated
It’s ok. He served his purpose. The problem is that UN , UNEP and other agencies are copied his strategy to collect money. Using a small group of suffering Africans for their own benefit. That is the tragedy 😢
I dont know how but abel you became to be my role model ❤through you i believe i can do it 🤗in life😂adi mimi ninunue machine🚘
I believe you can, keep grinding
The war in Sudan will forever remain a painful part of our history. All the people who witnessed it and survive try to explain the ordeal wanashindwa. None can explain it with dry eyes
The fact that kuna watu hawajui how picha zilikuwa zinaungwa makes me feel old😢😢😢😢
The biggest lesson I've learned from this is that the Law should never be above Humanity.
If i were kevin i wouldn't have left before the UN medics arrived at the scene.he should have saved the kid first.
Just read about this yesterday. Being human is such a strange weakness . Humans get affected when they see other humans suffer, especially when it's beyond their control.
You are mistaken , not all human gets affected when others suffer cuz if that was to be the case, most of the poloticians would be affected the most.
Yo mkuru big fan wako sana....Much appreciated ❤❤❤
If this story had been given without Kevin's history of standing for what's right regardless of the rules we would probably judge him different. I remember vaguely hearing a snippet of the vulture story
and judging it as inhumane, but now I feel differently about it. Let's leave the judging to God because sometimes we don't know the whole story.
The intro short stories always make the entire episode even more jyuucieer❤❤❤❤
Weeh my favorite....headline hitters 🎊🎊🎊
The Bang Bang journalist club
Daktari abdiwahab son of former kadhi ma men😅😅
What a coincidence joh I've seen your comment in my screen aii kuwangalia hio picha ni ww
F kiss my ass nimekutafta sana..eeh ile day ntakupata ntakukamua BTW ulimaliza internship
Wewe kwani ushamaliza assignments 🤧
@@AhmedAden-zy8dh unaonaje nikupee namba ya daktari
Mkuruge-----nziii ⛽⛽ gas iko full twende kazi
next tuchapie story ya 1 hour please. I usually listen to you narrations while working and I find it short when it is 30 mins.
I know you can do it
When I was studying journalism as an undergraduate we often discussed the ethics surrounding the photo...Some say it was wrong and others said that Kevin Carter did no wrong.
What about you....what do you think
Superb story Mkurus.........bt kidooogo, kdogo tu, Hujaingiza iyo story vle inafaa.
Bang Bang club 😁 :Am From South Sudan 😢 our American school pastor from Grace Baptist church Nakuru told us this same story that you told us 😭
Angeendea food amuekee hapo😂didn't have to touch her. Much love from Finland🇫🇮
According to me, the mission, there was to take photos in order to attract aid but now you’ve got to one of the most precious photo according to your feelings at the same time. It is a life that you have to save, especially knowing that this is a toddler despite being under serious instruction not to touch or come to contact to the victims, now I think he could just sat down there and wait until the medics arrive before proceeding to the next destination. Better time wasted to save a life, than time saved to get content.
My thoughts exactly...
Remember as Mkuru has just said they were under strict instructions. And two, they had been ordered (not even asked I presume) to go where the plane was giving the aid to capture that. They had to be there. Otherwise may he Rest in Peace.
The whole point of taking the photos was to use them to sought aid to save the people of Sudan, was the child not part of the people they were looking help for? There is no excuse for not saving the girls life
Wewe na dj Afro mnatupelekaga places😊
Niliacha kukushow eti I love u ju wameru wananielewa vibaya 😄😄😄🤭Respect
😂😂😂hiyo ya picha imeweza kwanza kwa kuungua..weeh mob love
Such a touching story
Sometimes I watch news about some communities fighting, some hate speech from from our politicians and some citizens support such hate speech, and I am like, “these people do not know the value of the peace we enjoy in this country.” Refugee are just people who were living their normal lives in their country; teachers, bankers, healthcare practitioners, lawyers, engineers, business people, the jobless, etc., but something happened in their country and they could no longer live there. The fact that in most parts of this country, Nairobi for example, you can wake up, walk to the nearest bus stop, catch a bus to CBD, run your errands, and once done, catch another bus to your residence and find your house still intact, is a reason to thank God and do whatever it takes to keep that peace.
I was moved by the criticism that eventually led to Kelvin committing suicide. And I can imagine in this generation with social media, such criticism can go even further. I think it is important to make an effort to understand the circumstances someone was in before judging them.
In this spirit, Abel please tell the story of “The Lost Boys of Sudan.” It might not be such a headline hitter, but it is a touching story.
Thank-you for your insight. This is something people need to be told. Peace is so underrated. Especially in Kenya, it's almost as if some people work extra hard to bring chaos.
iyo club ilikuwa inaitwa BANG-BANG CLUB
Yoo mkuru I've been your biggest fan si uniamulie hio t-shirt ya wakurugenzi
"He felt overwhelmed at the time, he felt like he needed to do something."
Buda umenichomea umetoa option ya kudownload kuna watu utegemea WiFi za mosque tunawatch later
Kesho KICC😁😎😍
siko sure I think ni Bang Bang club
Bang-bang club 😂 no wonder the emphasise ya Mkuru😂😅
No wonder tumeachiwa tupige research 😂😂😂
Hee umenikumbusha tukipiga picha zinakuja na negative
Tumetoka mbali walai
Abel you are a good story teller.
io ilikuwa ni bang bang club (journalism club)
Kevin Carter was like the late Mohammed Amin the photographer from Kenya
What killed Carter was the fact that a journalist told him that there were 2 vultures in the photo the bird and Carter.This ruined his life badly to the point of committing suicide.
waaah
Thank you...I finally understand this story and I feel guilty for judging Carter. We are not any better, I could have done the same 😢medics walikuwa wanakam after all🙂
Bang bang club kiongos, nunua soda tafadhali😁
Mkuuuuu, the president must be a fan. Ametumia hii stori kwa national prayer breakfast kudrive point
Nimechelewa kiasi.Makosa ni yangu😂
Nko hapa leo on time
Yeah!! I love to listen to this story millions times. Actually nilicomments utuchapie ii story na umetufikia. Thanks mkuru🙏🙏
Such brilliant story teller,may God bless you mkurungezi
Niko rada na Mkuru kama Moha, watchie wetu hapa mtaa ya Doni hahaha. FAVORITE STORYTELLER I DON'T NEED ANOTHER I'M GOOD FR!!!!
I used to see this picture bt I couldn't comprehend more about it bt now I'm a ware of the ordeal behind it.Carter might have died of guilty bt what of Silva?This reminds us of how Humanity is complex devoid of other factors like Orders that this guy was following to the later and the awards he was chasing after.Empathy is key!
In my eyes she is a Hero...her young life made a difference
Mkuru sijawahi kushow, we ni mziii manze. God akubless.
Bang bang club
💐🌹🌷💝Giving Mkurungezi and his amazing team all their flowers. Thank
you for giving us your very best always.
Waa!! I shouldn't have watched this in the morning!! So sad!!
What a story
Always keeping us Happy with the stories
from tanzania kurugenzi nipe like naku kubali sana
Carter did a good job as a photographer to show the world the extremes of life and he did his job well.I think that people missed the intention of his work .The conversation should not have turned against him but rather should have focused on the thousands of people suffering the same plight as the young girl.
Mkurugenzi gat the yuuuuice❤️❤️
Walai nakam kukusaka day nakuja Nairobi 😊😊
Ndege ya minji 😂🤌😭
This is very sad for Carter.... May his soul rest in Power. Alafu, mkuru umewacha jyuuce 🍹
A deep story. We live in a very opinionated time where pundits and bloggers are paid for their opinion notwithsanding the threshold of enough facts. We then proceed to harshly judge and condemn. May God save us.
A story beautifully told. Rules are meant to be broken if I was in Kevin ' s shoes
We always know the answer until the question strikes you without warning 😢
Seems so simple for you I guess. There was danger of communicable diseases among the Sudanese and Kevin wasn't alone so he couldn't risk his friends' lives even if he would his. I'd like to hear your response based on these facts.
Am loving it........❤😊......nilikuwa nimengoja sana
Hio background story ya how photography ilikua inaHappen Iko on point sana 😊
Kevin Carter was a member of the Bang Bang club
Very nice south Africa stories always lit being in Cape town also you mentioned Robin island been there kuja mkuru utupee live hizi
Thanks mkurugenzi for this story. All along I've been blaming Kevin not knowing deep down it tortured him for leaving that girl helplessly. So sad indeed
I remember the picture it was so famous :What a sad experience and ending for Kevin.
Well, thanks to Kevin Carter for that superb picture. Deep down aliumia kwenye roho but lets just agree that in this world, we have no any other option but to listen to our superiors
It is very funny seeing how people criticise the photographer for his actions about leaving the kid behind and then going I had to do his duties. And this other guy is out here screaming out loud that rules are meant to be broken, Just remember we’re all human beings and our first instincts we’ll always be to save ourselves first especially if it’s in a state of life and death situations.Bravo to the guy he did what took him there.
If I were in his shoes I would’ve done the same thing. And rather keep 10 people safe than save one.
Good story.... Ningekuwa Voke ningerisk nichukuwe mtoi since ilikuwa easy kuaccess medical attention haraka
Bang bang club
Mkuru ni Noma. National prayer breakfast and the story kelvin Cater 'heat' the headline
Mkuuu bana tufanyie moja ya El padrino Escobaa
Good old days. Mtu wa picha alikua anaitwa Ambrose 😂😂😂
this is a very sad story indeed....mimi i thought venye walipata huyo mtoi hapo watamsaidia manze and i was like "fyuuks atleast" only for them to leave her there....that is so heartbreaking .
aki i still see the guy who used to pigaa us pictures those days. He still uses the bike i new him with and mind you,it never changes
He did the right thing. Ata me ningefuata Sheria .
Have been seeing that picture for on social media from long time!have never knew the story behind it
Am glad to here the story from you mkuru
Big up meeen for being mtrue and delivering the best to our ears ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mkurugenzi ... the baby is back home
I literally cried after seeing that picture... Imagning it were my relative... Alrather me myself.. imagn what crossed the mind of the child seeing a person whose able to rescue her taking only a photo of her without helping her.. 😢😢😢
if it were me karter.. I could have done the same
Tragically, Carter committed suicide three months after the photograph was published
and only a week after being awarded the Pulitzer Prize. Carter’s death is speculated to have been
a result of one of two things: either he could not handle the fame that was brought on by the
photograph and the award, or he could not bear the guilt of not helping the child in the
photograph. In a Time magazine article following Carter’s tragic suicide, the piece relayed the
guilt that Carter felt and how “even some of Carter's friends wondered aloud why he had not
helped the girl” (MacLeod, 1994). The guilt he had felt afterwards for not helping the little girl
seemed to be too much for the man to handle.
did that little girl die?
I guess from the suicide note, he explained why he had to end his life.....money, depression, horrible images of dead bodies and inability to help those in need
I believe that was the last straw,the trauma had been building throughout his life eventually exploded after the picture.I wish he hadn't spoken publicly about the details of the photo...if truly he called the UN immediately and was told the situation was being taken care of,then he would have never faced the public wrath. On the other hand,we don't know if the UN acted in the urgency that was required or that he was actually afraid of whatever disease the girl might have been carrying...and the guilt was overwhelming.Sad,sad,sad...I wish mental health services were as available as they are now.Im sure he has PTSD as well from everything he saw and experienced since childhood.
@@home254ke I just read in some comment up there that apparently she didn't die but later succumbed to death at 15 years of age due to Malaria
A. W. O. L Ni Absent Without Official Leave
Mkuru in my favorite color. That photograph traumatised my childhood
Nikiwa maupishi za supper pale, I like to put on this channel. Good stuff dude! Keep up.
The Bang bang club🤠
Soo emotional story mkuruu😢,,,but kama kama ningekua kevin,then ningetuma uyo aliyekua friend and partner aendee food nikikaa hapo kuchunga mtoi
Bang bang club, Ile club yakina Kevin Carter
If I was in Carter's shoes ningeambia colleagues to go ahead nibaki na mtoi. Then I'd carry her to where the food ilikuwa. Before releasing my colleagues, I'd tell them to radio medics equipped in this high risk situation wanikute kwa njia in case the place where food is being distributed ni mbali.
Because as my uncle who was in Red Cross used to say, " No one gets left behind."
kevin carter club was BANG BANG makofi kwangu
😂😂😂😂😂😂mkuru thank umenikumbusha mambo ya picha nimelike big up👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Eeeeiiish mkuruuu hauogopi tutapata diabetes with all this jyuuuuce