Director Reacts - (G)I-DLE - 'I Want That' MV

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 54

  • @red_girl
    @red_girl Рік тому +107

    I think u would enjoy 'Oh my god'

  • @kamishuhua
    @kamishuhua 8 місяців тому +22

    The mv is about an abusive relationship. When Minnie shoots the guy, it's like she avenges everyone who went through this. In the end, they are not together, but they are metaphorically together.

  • @siyu898
    @siyu898 Рік тому +41

    IM HYPED you reacted to g-idle! they have such amazing music and literally EVERY single thing in the book. every album is SO vastly different

  • @magdabrzozka5700
    @magdabrzozka5700 Рік тому +22

    Their song "oh my god" has a great storyline too, and the music video has a lot of metaphors and symbolism in it.

  • @Mamoritai1990
    @Mamoritai1990 Рік тому +16

    All of their MVs are iconic and artistic, but the most creative ones imo are "Oh my God", "Tomboy" and "Nxde".

  • @yongboksswife
    @yongboksswife Рік тому +7

    from their latest album 'I feel' their 2 mv's follow on from each other to create a story. you should watch 'allergy' first and then 'queencard'. they're really good!

  • @jocelynrodriguez4749
    @jocelynrodriguez4749 Рік тому +18

    They’re amazing! This album is a little different since the members didn’t write or produce any of the songs. And it’s all in English. Lion is great, as is Oh My God and Hwaa is one of my favorites

  • @WeisenheimerJack
    @WeisenheimerJack Рік тому +11

    This is a really good breakdown. A lot of people theorize that he killed the other 4 girls, but I don't actually think that's fully true. I think only 2 of them are dead, we see the one drown(Miyeon), we see the one that was in a car accident(Shuhua), but the other 2 leave. We see Yuqi walk away with the stairs then later burn her memories, and we see Soyeon daydreaming about him when he taps her head but she's actually alone. I feel like it's an expression that even if abuse doesn't kill you it can still be carried with you and while they're not dead the ghosts of their trauma are still there haunting them. I think this distinction is further expressed at the end just before the main girl(Minnie) wakes up, we see the 4 girls looking refreshed and happy, kind of free and lighthearted, and we see Miyeon and Shuhua together, the dead ones, and Yuqi and Soyeon together, the living but traumatized ones.
    I also like that the song wasn't written by them and is definitely characteristic of a certain romanticization of toxic love styles and materialism in current American pop songs, but when they went back to Korea to make the music video they decided to make a video that takes the core concept of the song and oppose it, showing examples of how those kinds of relationships damage you. They couldn't fully control the direction of the song and needed to play into popular trends for the English debut, but they could take the idea, write a potent counter narrative that could fit in with the beats and give a counter message!
    I'm sure many music videos exist that do this but the only other example I can think of of this is Koi Geba by the J-pop group Atarashii Gakko. Where due to the nature of the style of music they made they wrote a song of a young girl on the cusp of adulthood experiencing those emotions and falling in love with her teacher, but in the music video they show how toxic that relationship would be in practice.
    I love both those songs and groups and I think that idea is really cool!
    But maybe I'm just reading too much into everything -shrug-

    • @WeisenheimerJack
      @WeisenheimerJack Рік тому +5

      Also realistically Miyeon commits suicide and drowns herself she's alone the whole time, she puts flower petals in the water to make it beautiful. He doesn't need to be a murderer to be a monster. The things he does are damaging and ruin lives. (Though he definitely murdered Shuhua)

  • @sjsing9007
    @sjsing9007 Рік тому +43

    M/V directed by 'K seire - King the Land) Director.
    The M/V, it looks like she (Minnie )has a daydream after read the red book 'c'est la vie'. This video shows all women needed the deepest love but they found violence situation instead then each of them tried to escape this situation in different ways. So the head shot is not real, Minnie just erase him in her mind. (They are the same person in different personality, they wear the white outfit in intro and outro and the red book too).
    But some theory is about surviving domestic abuse. It's suggested the guy was in a toxic relationship with all of the girls. Only Minnie (Bride) survived the guy. The others are all trapped in their place of death. (Miyeon drowned and spirits wandered around the pond, Soyeon was strangled in the wall of the room, Yuqi was stuck falling down the stairs, Shuhua died in the car.)
    The white flower is the symbolic the use in Korean funeral and the colour flowers is symbolic to the graveyard🪦in Korean)
    Their spirits frees when Minnie shot him died. 😅 She may have been possessed by the four dead women to seek revenge.

  • @Anara1
    @Anara1 Рік тому +7

    Yess we need more idle reactions

  • @effyaddams
    @effyaddams Рік тому +3

    You almost got everything right. As I saw, the four girls are dead, they were killed by the man that the main character girl was gonna marry, and she took revenge for all of them. that's why she ends up alone.

  • @chourouk8820
    @chourouk8820 Рік тому +18

    I would like to see you react to "Allergy" and "Queencard" ( there a connection between them ) its self made producing by soyeon the leader of the groupe 😊

  • @chris_tyt
    @chris_tyt Рік тому +3

    For Idle’s art.. please go for “Oh my god”. It’s epic. And also “I Do” which is also from this English EP, is a wholesome 80’s sci-fi movie.

  • @gaiapiazza5329
    @gaiapiazza5329 Рік тому +8

    More Idle please, they are geniuses 🥰

  • @sjsing9007
    @sjsing9007 Рік тому +9

    You may explore their titles, single and some B-side songs in Dingo Killings Voice.
    There are stories in all their M/V. (See Allergy then see Queencard)
    Even if you didn't see the M/V, just see their choreography, you can know the vibe or feelings of the song (see HANN (Alone), HANN ( Alone in Winter), and HWAA.
    LATATA M/V, tell us about their personality because it's their debut song.
    LION and OH MY GOD are the most artistic M/V of them.
    For LION and PUT IT STRAIGHT (Nightmare ver.) You should be seen performed in Queendom year #1 too.
    And also listen to the PUT IT STRAIGHT (regular version and see the Halloween version )
    Señorita (Servive in all circumstances)
    Dumdi' Dumdi (Summer vibe)
    TOMBOY M/V,
    MY BAG dance practice and performance.
    NXDE
    Change
    X-FILES (DARK)
    .......
    See them performed in Mnet PRIME SHOW.
    95 % of I-DLE songs, they wrote, composed and produced by themselves and in these 95% , 90% is belong to Soyeon who is the Mian producer, main rapper, sub-vocalist and Leader.
    ,........
    English EP. M/V
    I DO
    I WANT THAT

  • @LittSlash
    @LittSlash Рік тому +2

    This MV is so deep, we think a lot of possibilities

  • @HyperactiveSloth79
    @HyperactiveSloth79 Рік тому +10

    I Want That isn't bad. I like it. ...but compared to the rest of their discography it's about a 4 out of 10.
    Senorita and Dumdi Dumdi are fun songs I think you'd really like. Hwaa and Hann (Alone) are musical masterpieces. Oh My God and Lion are absolutely killer in every way!

  • @Peter.Cotoncalida
    @Peter.Cotoncalida Рік тому +4

    I would go for the revenge theory, you see one drowned, one in car full of funeral flowers etc, only reason I disagree with dream theory is she has blood on her dress in the end, I think he killed the other 4

  • @yongboksswife
    @yongboksswife Рік тому +2

    my other favourite gidle mv's are 'oh my god', 'tomboy' and 'queen card'. you should give them a watch!

  • @1oldcrow350
    @1oldcrow350 Рік тому +1

    This could mean so many things-maybe it's up to the listener to relate to what it says to them. C'est la vie is such is life and maybe she is dreaming of an adventurous kind of love and it's possibility of going sideways because c'est la vie. Very interesting MV

  • @Mikaylaftw
    @Mikaylaftw 10 місяців тому

    YESSS, ROSCOE STARTS THE I-DLE JOURNEY!!

  • @aquayeolmae
    @aquayeolmae Рік тому +1

    Yesss.. I actually waiting for the day u react to them 😭.. because i enjoy ur reaction.. finally!! More (G)-idle please.. because Soyeon (the leader) is the producer..and she make all of idle title track..and they nailed every concept!

  • @Crusnik_02
    @Crusnik_02 Рік тому +1

    This is their first all English song

  • @robertthomas2312
    @robertthomas2312 Рік тому +1

    Concept, music, lyrics, and production by 88 RISING. This is off their new album, HEAT, and their first venture into all English tracks. Usually gidle self-produces, in addition to writing, arranging and developing concepts. They are in my top 3 kpop girl groups. Soyeon, the leader, is brilliant. Her imagination and creativity are off the hook. She always develops interesting and unique store lines and then delivers them in such an artful stage.
    More gidle, please react to their mv's SENORITA, UH OH, HANN ( Alone), and HWAA, just for starters.

  • @dexonxd2011
    @dexonxd2011 Рік тому

    at first when I watched the MV I also though each girl represents different personality or so, but after reading comments about this music video, looks like it was just 5 realtionships, 4 other girls are dead and Minnie at the end is the only one who survived and killed the guy, great reaction and talk, thanks

  • @annetteskort4784
    @annetteskort4784 Рік тому +1

    Next to Stray Kids, (G)I-dol is my next favorite Kpop group.
    You'll need to watch Queencard, Tomboy, and Nxde

  • @melantha7
    @melantha7 8 місяців тому

    WE DEFINITELY NEED MORE GIDLE REACTIONS THO!!

  • @darharharhar1484
    @darharharhar1484 Рік тому +1

    Just got to the point where you finished watching the video and started trying to figure out the meaning behind it and I have to say I like this style of reaction.
    Personally I subscribe to the theory of him being abusive to the point where he eventually kills the other girls and the 5th girl ends up finding out about his past and ends up killing him.

  • @keehoyoon-d2t
    @keehoyoon-d2t Рік тому

    you should watch their another music video, cause ALL OF THE MV IS WORTH TO WATCH

  • @Nilty1
    @Nilty1 9 місяців тому

    I took it as all the Girls are the same Person but different personality aspects. You see Minnie there at all the Love spots. You see Yuqi being quiet and abused as he rages.. You see the others being more vocal and arguing back.. You see them all holding the gun as She is just fed up with being abused and wont' take it anymore.

  • @leadumbrella3210
    @leadumbrella3210 Рік тому +1

    g-idol's got a very strong, I don't know how to say, mood? There are some repeating themes generally around female empowerment, but musically they're pretty broad. In terms of videos with a lot going on for you to dig into, I'd suggest "oh my god" or "hwaa". Musically I don't think you can really go wrong with any pick, but some of the videos are much more straightforward (which is fine, just a different experience).

  • @deejohnson4793
    @deejohnson4793 Рік тому

    More (G)I-dle, superb artists. Earlier work is classic, Lion, Oh My God m/v's plus others. Hwaa and Hann m/v's are related. Soyeon, leader, tremendous talent. See Soojin's, former members, work too.

  • @Saerisacc
    @Saerisacc Рік тому

    You have to react to their other Songs! They’re incredible and different. „I Want THat“ ist good but their other Songs like „oh my god“ and „lion“ are on a different level. „Nude“, „Tomboy“ and „Hwaa“ are also amazing.

  • @lililalalisa_m2894
    @lililalalisa_m2894 Рік тому +1

    Next i do , nxde, queencard,tomboy and hwaa

  • @dawnelehman2592
    @dawnelehman2592 Рік тому +1

    Best songs of theirs are “Tomboy” and “Nxde”

  • @reuxkishi9257
    @reuxkishi9257 Рік тому +3

    new subscriber, more gidle pls

  • @pummichell
    @pummichell 3 місяці тому

    Now that I read the coment of the theory that he killed the others, rewatching the MV, I can see it tho

  • @Nevi_Neverlander
    @Nevi_Neverlander Рік тому

    (G)I-DLE💖💖💖💖💖💖
    Grate 😁👍

  • @moonl1ght138
    @moonl1ght138 Рік тому

    I love idle

  • @VenusAway
    @VenusAway Рік тому

    Кстати у Димаша есть выступление в Китае , тоже называется Never Land.

  • @drizzo4669
    @drizzo4669 8 місяців тому

    Story wise all of them were in relationships and sbused. Whether physical, mental or emotional and theygot out by leaving or in one case "ending the guy".
    Some of the girls were part of a dream inspired by the book but the blood on her foot in the beginning suggest a different story for the one girl who was left at the alter.
    G-idle likes to unalive men in there videos 😆
    Its kind of their thing.

  • @jamesfui5942
    @jamesfui5942 Рік тому

    highly recommend react to (G)I-DLE killing voice #dingomusic ❤

  • @ali_gamming2516
    @ali_gamming2516 8 місяців тому

    I guess that Minnie is alone and the crew was only in her mind

  • @Teaa-d9g
    @Teaa-d9g Рік тому +1

    react to taemin's new song guilty, you would love it

  • @gothicutau7508
    @gothicutau7508 10 місяців тому

    please react to Allergy and QueenCard by (G)Idle (In that order cuz it follows a story line)

    • @gothicutau7508
      @gothicutau7508 10 місяців тому

      And Tomboy and Nxde!! ( I really think you'll like them!)

  • @Apriqott
    @Apriqott Рік тому

    you should react to oh my god nude and lion!!

  • @TamaraPanera
    @TamaraPanera Рік тому

    💜💜

  • @habarlewungaju7182
    @habarlewungaju7182 Рік тому

    please reaction 510 The last suffer Rock band from indonesian 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩

  • @sandraglezlova9756
    @sandraglezlova9756 Рік тому

    Please react to BE:FIRST - Mainstream, the BEST boy group in Japan

  • @maritzaromero-kathalynas9493

    could you react to Ateez San's dance performace to Imagine Dragons-Warriors please

  • @chanela8909
    @chanela8909 10 місяців тому

    react to g idle lion