Is Modern Neuroscience PROVING Carl Jung was RIGHT?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 кві 2024
- Carl Jung was slandered as a mystic quack for much of the 20th Century
He proposed crazy ideas in fairness:
- a living "unconscious" that could speak to you...
- a shared ancestral imagination
But two modern developments in Neuroscience may have shown that his CRAZIEST ideas were correct...
---
Subscribe to my Academy for Super Shows: uberboyo.com/
Build your own UA-cam Business with my Coaching: uberboyo1-1.carrd.co/
Try out my Ai Tutor that Teaches You to Speak Languages: langapp.carrd.co/
---
Listen to these Videos on Spotify, iTunes etc. | fanlink.to/boyoalert
Listen to My Music | podlink.to/uberboyomusic - Розваги
It's amusing to me how many of Jung's claims on things like archetypes seemed unscientific at the time yet have been sort of reinforced by modern science.
To be fair, Jung also very clearly think were in the psyche, in the sense that reality is taking place in the mind of God.
That something that Jungians are terrified to actually acknowledge.
Sort of reinforced? What does that even mean?
@@christopherhamilton3621well the lack of hyper literal and specific scientific language from Jung allows people to some what come away with different interpretations. So we are comparing two different vernaculars and we are saying these translate very accurately.
Intuition ftw. Science is fake and gay and only reluctantly tells the truth.
@@rolandrush5172Hi! Could you elaborate a bit more?
I ask this because some time ago i figured out that its ontological framework (the way we present things) that gives Jungs work a pseudoscientific look. But in fact when you as you say "translate" his works to scientific ontological framework his work blows your mind away and you can see that trully it is a gold mine for scientific research.
I am not sure if Jung just didnt have a better way of how to present his ideas other then trough Kantian/Platonic ontology but he trully had great insight
"Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate."
Jung
Can we really make unconscious conscious? I don't think we can or even if we can that would drive us crazy because of all those memories and experiences we got from past, i m not talking about memories of parents or any previous generations just our own memories would make us insane
@@AI_generation_1st . Ahh, I do agree with your sentiment and there is a reason why the other side of us isn't consciously aware, because we can't handle it, all at once that is.
The balance between the two sides I would personally call it a vacuum, a push and pull struggle. When we sift through its contents honestly and we process this information, it dissolves blockage, freeing up more space for our conscious awareness to occupy. The footwork of doing this also builds Psychological muscle needed to onboard a more taxing Psychic payload.
I bet 95% of people are basically walking around using no more then 5% of their inherent facilities, this leaves the 95% remaining, as a subconscious psychic driver in their day to day. These people are troubled and they are everywhere. They are an extreme degree of what I'm speaking about and they are highly manipulated, since they Religiously avoid self reflection they do not know themselves one ioda. If we don't know ourselves and our own Psychological baggage, wth are we even doing here? If we have the tools to dig into our inner clockworks, but we do not deploy these tools, our abilities atrophy and you can absolutely count on the fact that if we aren't driving our own bus, someone else certainly is (Ill stop there for times sake) . The only way to captain our own ship, is to know its components and then begin to sail first in smoother waters. The subconscious mind is autonomous by itself and trust me we want it working with us, if it is not, it is working against us. It is vital that we integrate this in baby steps if necessary.
If we incessantly retreat, the unconscious mind doesn't know how to retreat and it increasingly manipulates the controls, gaining dominion over our waking hours.
If we are aware, this means we possess the tools, thus we have the ability to shine our light into the dark places. I would say it is one of our most vital objectives to complete in this short life. If we don't know ourselves, what is the point of being conscious at all?
"The dawn of consciousness is a curse." Jung
I would add that it is indeed a curse, but the genie is now out of the bottle and we must deploy this weapon, or fall to the wayside. If that all sounds grandiose, it is because it is grandiose in every sense of the word. I hope that made sense, my thumbs hurt lol. Be well
Curing the underlying CAUSE of disease is bad for business
If you are unaware of your emotions, and you don’t believe them to matter or exist, those very same emotions are the puppet master behind ever “logical” decision we make.
Funny how that works, you just can’t outrun or escape the fact that emotion and the unconscious mind is always and forever a part of us.
In a way it’s what binds us together, it almost feels intuitive that, if we reject the shadow of our self; being only a fraction of who we are how could we accept others ourself and the world around us.
@@SupermonkeyPlaysMC For this reason Jung said we must all undergo the process of individuation
Carl Jung said things that resonated so deep down in me, that I cannot feel anything else but an enormous admiration for him. When I see him talk in videos I see just a wonderful human being with a huge compassion for everyone. As he very wisely said "We cannot change anything, until we accept it. Condemnation does not liberate, it opresses, and I am the opressor of the person I condemn, not his friend and fellow sufferer. If a doctor wishes to help a human being he must be able to accept him as he is, and he can do this in reality, only, when he has already seen and accepted himself as he is".
To accept the world is to SEE the world for what she is; I can’t have empathy for something I’ve condemned simply because I am not seeing it on its own terms.
By accepting myself, i am absolving the burden of judgements and moralization in favor of seeing the bigger picture.
I can see the why and the how; even if I don’t like it, simply accepting it gives me the opportunity to give that acceptance and appreciation to another.
If I am a councilor and or minister and I am helping someone who is condemned by society; I can’t connect with them if I am busy judging their character as the situation before me.
Although intentions may be to help, people almost “feel” that judgment as you speak with them and in a lot of cases it turns them off to what you have to say.
Too many times we let people’s past actions get in the way of genuine attempts at atonement or redemption
Or we might even “abuse” that vulnerability in some way because we feel justified in doing so, when mercy is the tool to break the cycles of oppression and violence.
Thank you for sharing the quote with us
He was also racist
Another version of religion
Jung only wrote books and research papers strictly for an academic audience. he had to be convinced by someone else to write at least 1 book for the public and so he wrote 1 book for laymen and it was his last book "Man and his Symbols". The idea that academics so often disregard him as a quack when he ONLY did his life's work for them and their eyes and brains alone, is very sad.
I like your icon photo thing . hmm... interesting observation; I didn’t know that, that he wrote so much simply as a part of his profession, and almost not at all for public consumption
And he didn’t write man and his symbols. I believe he only wrote one chapter. The rest is written by his students and successors.
@@avipinckney correct, but he agreed to have the complexities and nuances of his theories "dumbed down" for a generalized non-specialist audience, the only time he ever agreed to something like that.
Solving the underlying CAUSE of disease is bad for business. Managing symptoms is the big money.
Greed is Good. Jung is bad for business.
It's that simple. I'm a physician. I know.
it always bothered me that most ppl couldn't understand that basic primordial instinct is a core ancestral memory
Hey didn’t I just see you somewhere else
makes sense. That would explain why almost all kids are afraid of the dark as children, or even as adults.
It's a survival instict, because, since our species doesn't have a good vision in dark environments, it's a vulnerable place to be in, there could be predators hiding.
or it could really just be how our species evolved to be. since ancient times we learnt to stay away from darkness because there could be predators or unknown dangers there. maybe thus, through natural selection and evolution, we just evolved to associate darkness with danger and back off?
@@68plus1.could be but we’ll never know for sure, or maybe we will figure this out one day 🤷♂️
My left brain: *hears you say Joe*
My right brain: joe mama
Bofa mine did the same thing
🤣😭😭🙏🕊🙏😭😭🤣
Same here no 🧢
@@CESTLAFDTJEUNEPDBOFA DEEZE NUTZ
It is important to remember that Joe's brain was cut in half. "Joe" is not his left hemisphere surgically isolated from his right. "Joe" as he was born, and as nature intended (if you will), before this radical surgery, includes both hemispheres connected together - interconnected, and working together. The idea that the 2 hemispheres of his brain are inherently 2 separate people is what is "crazy". And further, the idea that the unconscious is one or the other hemisphere of the human brain is crackers, nuts, lunacy, IMHO.
"Say my name"
"You're walt whitman"
"You're god damn wrong"
stay gold, ponyboy
For some reason this 2nd dude within me is constantly scanning for spiders and if he detects one he flushes my body with adrenaline.
ha! . you & my sister would get along
There are more than two demons in your head.
Left and right brain consciousness and unconsciousness and the the bit inbetween would direct me to assume 6 lol
Well if he doesn’t do it, who will?
Jung would never have reduced the collective unconscious to the material. He saw psyche as fundamental. The cultural clothing of the archetypes are not the archetypes in themselves.
Yeah if we could measure them we‘d probably see them as wave structures or smth of the kind
well said
I'd say that these genetic changes correlated with ancestral memories are the material representations of fundamental events in universal consciousness.
Consciousness is fundamental, but we can observe its activity as transformations in matter.
It will just have to be another 50 years before the scientists turn around and say the panpsychists were right.
Of all your videos, this might be the most important you've done so far. Contemplating and adopting these ideas will make you a dangerous man. And I mean it in the most positive way possible. Thank you and best regards to everyone watching and commenting.
thank you!
🙏⚔️📖💛🕊💛⚔️🙏 JESUS IS KING !!!!! 👑
Our Boyo is back!
Great thinkers are invariably labeled as insane heretics by the arrogant masses of thoughtless individuals
And sometimes conspiracy theorists.
Many of these thinkers like Giordano Bruno found themselves being born during the inquisition
@@kelleemerson9510. A Detective is also a "Conspiracy Theorist," until it becomes self-evident that it is no longer a theory.
Good comparison @@BlackestSheepBobBarker
Most of the time what seems weird and crazy, it is just pointing the obvious. A long time ago whoever thought the Earth was not the center of the solar system was targeted as crazy.
Your content is extremely helpful for this TBI/PTSD vet…many thanks!
"The law of synchronicity has to be understood. This is one of the greatest contributions of Carl Gustav Jung to modern humanity: the law of synchronicity.
Science is based on the law of causality. The law of causality is mechanical. You heat water to a hundred degrees - it evaporates. Where you heat it is irrelevant - in the temple, in the church, in the mosque, it doesn’t matter; in India, in Tibet, it doesn’t matter. If you heat water to a hundred degrees, it evaporates; the water has no say in it. The water cannot say, “Today I am not feeling like it.” Or, “Today is Sunday and I am on a holiday, and I am not interested in becoming vapor.” Or, “Today I am not in the mood, and you can go on heating and heating and I will not evaporate.” Or, “Today I am suddenly feeling very generous towards you so I will evaporate at fifty degrees. I will favour you.” No, the water has no choice. The law is mechanical, it is causal. If you create the cause, the effect has to follow. And it is without any exception.
Because of this law of causality, science cannot believe in the existence of soul, in the existence of consciousness, in the existence of God - because they are non-mechanical phenomena. The very methodology of science prevents it from accepting them; they cannot be absorbed in the scientific world. They will disturb it, they will destroy its whole edifice. They have to be kept out - God, soul, consciousness, love - they have all to be kept outside the temple of science. They cannot be allowed in. They are dangerous: they will sabotage its whole structure. They are causal. But they must be following some other law.
The credit goes to Carl Gustav Jung. The law has been known down the ages, but nobody had named it exactly. He called it ‘the law of synchronicity’. It suddenly happened to a scientist: A scientist a hundred years ago was staying in an old house. In that old house there were two old clocks on the same wall. He was surprised to see that they always kept exactly the same time, second to second: “Old clocks, and so perfect? Not even a single second’s difference?”
Being a scientist he became curious. He put one clock five minutes back, and after twenty-four hours in the morning when he looked again, they were again keeping the same time. Now it was a great puzzle. He enquired… nobody had changed, nobody had touched anything. He tried again and again, and again and again they would come to the same rhythm. Then he tried to find out: “What is happening? - something strange. They are disconnected!”
Then he observed more minutely and he came to conclude: “The vibration of the one clock, which is more powerful, the bigger clock, goes through the wall - just the vibration - and keeps the other clock in tune. It is a subtle rhythm. Nothing is visible.”
That was the beginning of a new phenomenon… then many many more things happened. And by the time Carl Gustav Jung started working on how things happen in consciousness, he came to conclude that the vibe of one heart, if it is powerful enough, can change the rhythm of another heart - just like the bigger clock was changing the smaller clock.
The vibe is invisible. There is not yet any way to measure it, but it is there. It is not tangible, but it functions. It is not causal."
I click like before I watch the video. And I am always right. It's a special talent. 😊
i feel the power!
Yup
😂❤ I love it
@uberboyo - Stef, Jill Bolte Taylor’s work is another example of neuroscience corroborating Jung’s model of the psyche. She says her model of 4 characters overlays exactly onto Jung’s 4 archetypes: persona (conscious left), shadow(unc. left), anima/us (conc. right) self (unc. R)
She also names the parts of the brain where they’re located.
Ive spoken to her! shes lovely!
@@uberboyo 👍
Uberboyo and Jung are like peanut butter and jelly
...and the world is dat white bread. Where the whole wheat, the rye, the pumpernickel at?
Frank Herbert addresses these ancestral memories in his Dune novels
in what way
@@Danny-qt5vt in Dune everybody has all memories of their ancestors locked inside them. By drinking the water of life during a ritual Bene Gesserit sisters can unlock these memories. In Denis Villeneuve's new movie Dune Part 2 Paul's mother Jessica (and later someone else) undergoes this ritual. In the following volumes of Dune this becomes more relevant.
Or the memories are in the water???
@@martd1352 I don't think so because after they drink the water they can only access the memories of their specific ancestors.
"up there in hyperborea with all the boys" lol
Juicy boyo spitting that jargon!...
I dug into R-Haplogroup in terms of mapping genealogy and was surprised to learn that Etruscan proto-Romans also possessed it. They seemingly popped up out of nowhere.
Plato spoke as well of the hyperboreans.
What’s your point?
02:10 this sounds as if you suggest to force affirmations and other forms of "positive thinking" onto ourselves. Although Jung said something like "I'd rather be bad than unauthentic", meaning you don't affirm something onto yourself, if does not come from your real self.
Never been early too a video. Just watched the why you must embrace our modern era vid and gained a new perspective. Thank you for sharing your wisdom boyo
My crazy speculation is that buddhist enlightened is the process of moving the seat of consciousness out of the left brain into the right brain.
No, it is gaining full control of the default mode network (DMN), the internal monologue, or voice in your head. A pillar of Buddhist belief is no-self, the that the "you" in "who are you" is an illusion. Meditation is the mental excersice of silencing the DMN and focusing your attention at a single point, such as your breath. With enough meditation, the brain changes structurally and voluntary control of the DMN is acquired. See the work of Daniel Ingram.
Moving into right-brain consciousness would be more akin to magical, shamanistic, or animistic consciousness. Enlightenment is more of a bypassing or muting of left-brain consciousness without necessarily moving into a right-brain frame of thinking
No you are already enlightened you just refuse to see it > it’s not left brain right brain anything > more connected to the pineal gland endocrine system and kundalini >>> also a great Buddhist saying is before enlightenment chop wood carry water after enlightenment chop wood carry water
I think its more like syncing both hemispheres. "You" basically recognicing the dualety inside yourself.
Best one in ages, keep up the good work boyo!
Let’s gooooo, been waiting for you to upload
From Uberboyo to UberMagus....stay forever Jung! Great channel, video and talk. Cheers, from Canada.
Don’t sleep on “UberMaestro” either !!! 💋👅👁👄👁👅💋
I missed an upload. Gonna binge watch the channel
Thanks, I really enjoyed that. Really makes you think. Well done for making those complex ideas so accessible.
I'm happy you're back and this video is great
thank you!
Well done.
Greetings from Mississippi.
Carlos Gustavus Jungus The Juicy !
big jungus
EL** Carlos Gustavus Jungus, put some respect on his name, son !!!! 😅😅😅
The Jungus among us
Just found this, man this channel has some gems.
Loved the deep breakdown of the topic! Thank you for the vid
God bless Ireland❤️
I don’t know how Jung understood these things without psychedelics. They granted me clarity on so many of his ideas. I thought I understood them, but after a few dozen visits to grandmother’s realm I truly understood.
I appreciate your work so much. I love how you explain things. Thank you!
thank you!
Well done boyo doing a great job of synthesising this knowledge and turning it into a very digestible story 👏
You are a gifted orator, my friend. First time watching and I’m about to sub. Such a unique and impactful way of weaving together information in an engaging way. You belong on UA-cam 👏 👏 👏
Frank Herbert infused his Dune books with 'Jung"
Any particular motifs? I will check!
Sauce??
@uberboyo the entire premise of the books is that the main characters get access to the entire genetic memory of their ancestry and their future lineage.
Or he was just a reciptical for the collective to project their energy. Example; a radio is not the signal but a means to access the signal. Switch the radio off and the signal is still there ready for another to pick up the signal. The question is were does the signal come from we will never know!!!!
@@martd1352 You probably going to love the morphic resonance theroy ^^
Morphic resonance is a process whereby self-organising systems inherit a memory from previous similar systems. In its most general formulation, morphic resonance means that the so-called laws of nature are more like habits. The hypothesis of morphic resonance also leads to a radically new interpretation of memory storage in the brain and of biological inheritance. Memory need not be stored in material traces inside brains, which are more like TV receivers than video recorders, tuning into influences from the past. And biological inheritance need not all be coded in the genes, or in epigenetic modifications of the genes; much of it depends on morphic resonance from previous members of the species. Thus each individual inherits a collective memory from past members of the species, and also contributes to the collective memory, affecting other members of the species in the future.
Glad to know you are alive bro 😂❤
BOYO BACK
Easily the greatest neuroscientist to ever live
Thank you for sharing this information! I am currently taking history of psychology and seriously could not understand any of it but this helped SO much.
BOYO ! Been a while since the algo tossed you my way bro. Keep it comin!
Almost at 100k let’s fucking go Stef
Very cool video!
This was grade A mid day Saturday content sir! 🤜❤️
Excellent. Very interesting, good discussion and explanation. Good use of academic articles to support topic.
Came over from American journal. Harrison shared one of your videos.
Left and right have always had universal values disconnected from language just like up and down.
Up=heaven (god)
Down=sheol (satan)
Left=sin/left hand path (evil)
Right=morals/right hand path (good)
I find it interesting how universal these general values attribuyed to mere physical directions seem to be regardless of culture/time/or location
🤔
its spelled ' Stan'
Because they dictate time/culture/location
The upper régions upon which we depend entirely
They come from the metaphysical language
uberboyo is back les gooo
For some reason i was drawn to carl jung
life can be magical when we give ourselves the permission to be guided by what draws us, what calls us
Hey Steff, I can explain it all to you, I live it, and it's INCREDIBLE 😮🎉
Totally fascinating!
This is all very heartwarming
This notion of the unconscious hemisphere being a background process that observes subtlties, nuances and patterns...A guiding spirit. A "Daimon". This idea comes from Greek philosophy. It is where the idea of a theological demon comes from. And the psychological demon. But just because we don't understand quite how this guiding spirit works doesnt mean it is evil...We can thank some dogmatic religious beliefs for that ridiculous notion.
A daimon/daemon/demon is certainly not evil. It just becomes more powerful and self-destructive the more you try to pretend it doesnt exist within you. The more you pretend that your conscious mind is in complete control, the louder and crazier the demon becomes. It needs to humble the ego (the left brain) when it becomes arrogant and domineering. It does this in ways that are profoundly unpleasant, so of course egomaniacal people are quick to label it is "bad" or "evil".
This is also why in computer science a "daemon" is a background process that is not under the direct control by the user.
😊me love me some daimon
Ian’s work is in all honesty has been life changing for me. The matter with things is one of the most important books ever written.
Hi Stefon, long time no see!
Your narration of the “guardian angel” sounds a lot like my socially anxious thoughts 🥲
My boy is back.
I wrote my bachelor’s thesis many thanks to your Aion series. Now I’m graduating from Trinity College Dublin’s Psychoanalytical Studies MPhil. Many thanks:)
Yes. One hundred agree with the statement. I finished my final exam from college with collective unconscious as main research. Specifically about how collective unconscious can be explained with scientific studies, genetic memory, and epinegetic process
Thank you! ✨💚✨🌠✨
Your random Deepak Chopra quote:
"Eternal stillness opens unique miracles" _
Big ol' shout out to James P D at 45min. Your videos on Aion were my gateway to Stef
Greate video! And btw. On this theme conscious vs unconscious i think you would appreciate NLP and milton erickson spesifically
Now add Jungs monism and his work on the paranormal which suggests that the human psyche can have an effect on the physical world.
LOVE YOU STEF BOYO 🙏💐😇💛😇💐🙏
PS: your eyes are SO SPARKLEY !!!!!! 💖💖💖
And yes, braziers do hamper women’s emotional state 😅 lol jk women can’t even climax… 🤣😂🤦♀️🥳🤦♀️😂🤣
Lol, the subtitles can't handle your Uberboyo accent "Carol Yong was..."
Would love to see Uberboyo in diagologue on some major podcasts. We need to rally for this
Experienced the long night of the soul after a major life change, and it felt like waking up from being unconsciously driven most if not all of my life. I say this as someone completing a PhD. I knew the ideas were important, but I couldn't see the whole shape of how they connected. Now I do, after doing the work to recondition myself following that wake up call.
His work is notoriously complicated. I heard so much too about how confusing it is that I haven't seriously considered trying to read and understand it
World love to see you talk about the ancient Indic/hindu philosophy of Advaita vedanta.
fascinating discussion.
Oh snap! UBERBOYO is alive. Or is it AI?
Nice video & discussion!
The other aspect of Jung that you did not emphasize enough is the idea of the Collective Unconscious.
Amazing. Really curious how to communicate with that unconscious side. Seems like a super power to be able to integrate the shadow.
In your sleep
You can develop and train imagination, synesthesia, ~schizophrenia, and if you start to paint or draw without thinking and keep doing it for weeks or months you will start to see messages. If you will sing your favorite songs you will start to hear messages as if it was singing you but from the other side of the mirror. You have to move, it loves bizarre irrational behavior. Watch Everything Everything - The Mad Stone. Soon thinking with images kicks in and it starts to feel like moving and zooming around a fractal of concepts. You start to see messages in every art and start having problems with communication with direct language. It's good sign to hear that you are crazy. Jacobs Ladder concept helps and something that brings a lot of emotions. Discover that you can act with emotions on emotions. You will start responding to your unconscious because it was speaking to you the whole life. Find beauty and faith. Communication with other people is required to speed up the spiral of imagination.
It might require developing own inner religion of sort. Or rather discovering it.
I found a Carl Jung book in a box of old stuff when I was 16, about 30 years ago. Not sure why I read it and I am sure I had no real understanding of what I was reading, still it changed my life.
Its crazy how much playing a game like Assassins Creed while growing up, proves itself as an allegory and symbolism for psychology, DNA, Religion and ancient archeology and culture, in a very odd way of connecting these elements as hidden truths, albeit wrapped in a fictionalization. This very thing is one example, as explained from the get go in the very first game in the series, the animus (device) reads the memories of your ancestors from your DNA, which encodes everything that occurs during the course of your life, in order to pass down instincts.
The map is not the territory.
I have to say, I really like your symbol . I wonder what it represents . also: are you a writer?
@@rmschindler144 Thanks it's from the game Nier: Automata. The symbol for YoRHa, the military force made by humans to fight the invading aliens and machine life forms. It's a masterpiece of a game. Also yes I'm a writer =]
@@Orpheus063 pretty cool that I asked if you’re a writer, hey? . the impulse to comment was associated simply with the goal of asking about your symbol . then it’s as if suddenly my hands started typing the question about your being a writer . very cool
and I wonder: do you yet share your writing in some form, publicly?
as for the symbol, I shall have to check out that game :)
Well hello darkness my old dead RAW friend
Great video! I was a charismatic Christian for most of my life and I was deeply spiritual and really believed I had a personal relationship with Jesus and that I could hear his voice speaking to me in my spirit, and receive visions from him in my minds eye, and a bunch of other stuff too.
The crazy thing is that no one taught me “how to hear God’s voice”. It’s just something I figured out on my own when I was a teenager by “going into myself” and quieting my normal thinking mind, until I could hear a still small voice that felt like it was coming from someone else, and often gave me novel information or novel takes on things. And it wasn’t one dimensional. I would feel “the anointing” on my body, and other things that are hard to explain.
Of course, when I got older, I picked up a lot of the charismatic lore about how to do this stuff and make sure you aren’t “deceived”, but fundamentally, it’s just something I figured out by myself. It was just an innate ability. Also, as a fairly lonely kid, I think Jesus became my imaginary friend, and for the most part it’s the only socially acceptable form of imaginary friends for adults today.
A good book on this is “The Illusion of God’s Presence” by Stephen Wathey who is a biologist. In it, he gives examples of how many animals have innate knowledge before they are ever born, like how baby sea turtles just know to go towards the light, because that’s where the moonlight on the water normally is, and how today they can get confused by city lights.
When I deconstructed and lost my faith several years ago, I started really thinking about what all of those experiences actually were. And learning about many of the things you talked about in this video was very helpful. And a few mushroom trips opened my eyes to how vast the inner realm of experience is.
I also want to try DMT one day. It’s so crazy to know that a mere molecule can make normal reality dissolve around you and suddenly you are in a different place altogether. To me, that’s more than ancestral memory and is something that really needs to be studied more like they are doing in the DMTx experiments.
It really makes me question methadological naturalism and the usual evolutionary accounts of how and why consciousness evolved. What’s the evolutionary purpose of being able to be mentally transported into an entirely different reality? But like all things in this area, I don’t know if the biases of scientists are ready to question materialism enough to take on this question and it might just remain in the domain of the “yoga bunnies” as you put it :)
Supposing consciousness DID evolve and come after matter. We're not certain of that, and many throughout history, from the Eastern traditions to ancient Greek philosophers such as Plato, have argued that it's rather in the direction of the reverse. That consciousness/mind is fundamental and existed long before physical, conscious beings did.
One thing people who have visited the DMT realm often say, is that it feels familiar, like they've been there before (or even like they've come home), despite it being so alien. And that it feels more real than this material world. It's not impossible that these realms existed before the physical universe.
@@-RXB- I'm very open to that idea even if I remain somewhat skeptical. I like the approach of advaita vedanta where consciousness is not your individual consciousness but that in which everything takes place like a movie screen on which things are projected on.
Also panpsychism is an interesting philosophy where consciousness is an integral part of reality. Lots of interesting ideas, but how to test them?
@@hypergraphic Yes exactly, I see you're already familiar with these ideas. That's a good question, there's still so much we don't understand about consciousness that I guess it'll be a matter of what one finds most convincing, until (or if) we get something more conclusive from a scientific perspective.
I understand the need to take an Occam's razor approach and assume that it is something that has evolved and is generated by matter (such as a brain), rather than the reverse. It's an interesting idea that would explain a lot of things though.
Yes blood memory is definitely a thing.
Traced my family tree back to the 1700s in Lusk, Ireland. They came to Canada in 1831. Loved learning about them. Something very profound and sacred about coming upon your great, great, grandfathers gravestone ❤
As a science polymath, I incorporate what has been universal and what is now universally missing, such as the ability to sing and have familiarity with singing in large groups. Learn vocal mastery by becoming an overtone singer
Worked as an Occupational Therapist at a brain injury rehab program and had a patient with alien hand syndrome. Witnessed a variety of things and one in particular that I wonder if it has been scientificly described.
I got “alien left hand syndrome” immediately after I was Baptized in the Holy Spirit and I really didn’t even know what was going on at the time!! Like sometimes my hand will clench a fist or scratch a random itch on my body, and I’m pretty sure it is your body is trying to communicate with your mind on a reciprocal macro level, because I can always interpret a meaning from it, better that tarot. I pick up litter on the river bank too and that is better that tarot also because as your stream of conscience is dialoging, you can interpret meaning in the 3D reality all around you. Like Jesus said about, pondering the birds or counting sheep. And now I see apparent objects that just pop up at random, JESUS IS TALKING WITH YOU EVERY MOMENT, HE IS THE LOVER OF YOUR SOUL !!!! 👑
@@smokymountainangoras so cool! . it’s heartwarming to read that you’re keen enough or wise enough to dare to interpret the things & events of life as if it were a divine language . & I agree, that Christ is every instant communicating with every one of us
Very interesting explanations! I already was exposed to most of the ideas in the first 20’, except for the science video with the patient, but you summarized it very nicely. Would you consider making this into 3 20’ videos. Im at 39’ now. Most youtubers have about a 20’ max attention span. It might work, too 👍
I love your channel! A lot of great material to help us live well. Do you have any videos concerning the integration of death into the psyche? Is accepting death the same as integrating the shadow?
One sense I get about jungianism- granted it’s a layman’s “sense”- is that it ignores death. It ignores the inevitability of the end of experience in this physical body. Are there any materials about jungian psychology on death?
We should all know why Jung was actually dismissed, but that, too, is being reconciled.
Hmmm ... Why?
Hey mate, good video. Iain McGilchrist's work has been helping me quite a bit throughout this existential depression / crisis of meaning I'm going through. I have never directly read Jung, however, I am familiar with Jordan Peterson and he is a Jungian, so I know some stuff that I find quite cool. I've been deeply questioning the meaning of life for 6 months now, and I always have thoughts like "wow, if I could believe in the jungian ideas and I could step out of the materialist-nihilist drudgery, I would extract so much meaning out of life". And, boy, having some evidence and discussion around the collective unconscious and on the value of storytelling and symbols livens me up somewhat. I am prone to think that all thoughts are the self, and the self is an illusion, and that is all completely irrelevant, any meaning you distill out of that is a willing dream that you submit yourself to. I could just decide to be happy, and I've been trying for a while now, but it is not easy when you feel the imposition of that "Truth" all the time upon yourself. But then again, people like McGilchrist and discussions like you present us with in your video make me a little bit happier. It makes me want to write again, which is A LOT. Thanks man.
One of the very best Jung videos I have seen. I've read Jung for about 50 years now, in English and German, and must say that this video did a fairly astounding job of explaining archetypes and other aspects of Jung's fundamental concepts. My Irish genes (there are many) cheered all the way thru the video and are rooting for more such videos in the future. [I also appreciated the comment on the tendency of many of Jung's followers to tie themselves up in obscure and jargon-ridden escapades into the subtleties of Jungian thought. They remind me of hikers who climb Mt. Everest and then retire to the pub to discuss the "intriguing" chemistry of the snowflakes they found on the summit.]
Let's go my dudes!
Stay Ripped, Follow your instincts and denounce Abrahamic nonsense!
It's like we are finally breaking up with our jealous Arab boyfriend, who has been gaslighting and manipulating us for 2 millennia.
If you break up with me you will die and go to a fiery torture world!
Stockholm syndrome to the point you believe your kidnapper created the universe 😂
To call something nonsense is to not truly understand where it's inception came from. All knowledge is intertwined, no matter how far removed it is from the current teachings. We remember not learn, this is platonic and also a belief echoed by Jung. The more you understand, the more you realise you actually know nothing about this so called life.
@@VCRAGE All Abrahamist's get the millstone.
I dunno. If you read Matthiu Pageu's "The Language of Creation", he sort of states that the point of our lives, and what the bible is about, is for us to be moving towards an agreement between Heaven and Earth, which in the individual would be akin to an agreement between the head and the body. That would actually mean for you to honestly express yourself, as the Truth is The Way, and the new covenant between "heaven" and "earth". I think that would also be akin to the synchronization of the left and right hemisphere, and of the individuation process. Really recommend that book (to those who are interested) as it provides a lense through which you can understand not only the bible, but the symbolic patterns of history, ourselves, and the world.
“I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else.” -CS Lewis
@@rubyboobieee you forgot the part where you have to worship some middle Eastern guy and believe that the Jewish people are holy and chosen by God. And your ancestors were evil Pagans cursed by God.
Everything you said is not unique to Christianity. And was already part about European thought and religion prior to Christianity. So, it seems more like Christianity added the worship of foreign people for no reason.
The boyos are back in town!
The boys are back! The boyos are back!
Enjoying this video mate---needs to include Schopenhauer in the invention of the unconscious ("will"), etc....Henri Ellenberger has a good history of the unconscious
1st, never forget Emma. Her family $ allowed Jung to be grounded and free. She also was key communicator to Frued. See also best Jung bio in Peter Gay's FREUD 1989. One deeply German cultured humanist interpeting 2 others.
After getting my degree in logic, accidentally, I became a fan of mystery and by poking my nose in everything I soon discovered an astonishing amount of science is built and taught with no evidence.
Interesting. Could you please give an example?
Great content. I have previously listened to Iain McGhilchrist talks. I'm fascinated by the idea that the Left - RIght hemisphere behavior balance has been derailed in the modern world.
As for ancestral memories, I wonder if some of that includes the creation of Nightmares. Not just old fears to haunt you, but to Train you for survival. It's also interesting to wonder if the Monster is the 'avatar' of the Mind's Shadow in your Nightmare Dream and you have to overcome it.
I vaguely recall having some Lucid Nightmare experience where I killed the monster.
You are very good. Bravo. I can find no fault.
Hate him or love him but McGilchrist's latest interview with Jordan Peterson is pretty good.