Assalamualaikum sir, ap nai bataya kai prop firm hamaray mutabiq sahe hai magar mera swal yai tha kai ham prop firm ko konsai way sai trade kartay hai like i.e CFDs, future, binary or any other ways to trade. And about CFDs that there is no such possession to sir yai basically aik contract hai or modern economic kai mutabiq agar ap koi contract kartay ho to us ke physical possession zarore nahe domain name, UA-cam channel etc. As is in surah Al-Baqarah(2:282) : "When you contract a debt for a specified term write it down..." Iska matlab hai kai agar aik proper contract ho or ownership defined ho ( contract) to yai halal hai. Hope sir ap is par mazeed research karein gay. Jazakallah ❤
If you are on prop firm even then still you don't own it is physically and you don't know that wether that money is came from so that also raise a question.
Adnan Bhai Broker is equal to bank Huta Jo mene research ki Koch Log Bolty Hy Forex Ke Pechy Kj be ni ha Jabky Pechy institutional traders Huty Hy or Jb hm be trade lgaaty Hy to Beshak Euro Hmaray hath me Na Aya mgr Hmari amount Se Bohot Thora SA Frq Pra Ha Price me so Jo broker Tana tan Profits de Rhy Hy Wo Kaha Se de Rhy Hy ??
Bit sir apny sign to krdiya na contract ky bhiagr hm overnight hold kryngy tu hm Interest dyn gy . Ap de ni ey interest but you signed that if you hold tradr you must have to give interest so is kakya khyal hy apka
The underlying assets traded (e.g., forex, stocks, commodities) must comply with Islamic principles and be halal. Forex trading remains a debated topic in Islamic finance-some scholars consider it permissible if free of riba (interest) and gharar (excessive uncertainty), while others disapprove. In the case of prop firms, funded accounts often operate in a demo trading environment during all phases, including after passing evaluations. This means the trades executed do not involve actual ownership or trading of physical or real financial assets. Instead, the environment is simulated, and earnings are based on performance within a virtual setup. This raises questions about whether such profits, derived from non-realistic trades, align with the principles of Shariah, which emphasize transparency and tangible value in financial dealings.
Great explanation, I gathered a lot of questions and Haram stuff about forex from this video, And this is one of those questions, I think this is totaly considered Haram, as you mentioned there is no ownership only playing games And my other question raises that, He said swap accounts are halal, I understood about swap accounts that when day completes or closes and you don’t close trade so than you will be interested ( soud dena hoda ) but i think that is Haram because you are actually trading with the contract/concept which applies interest on you at the end if you fail to close trade, It is like i get a loan from someone and i tell him i will give it back to you within 15 days and i am confident on myself but somehow i couldn’t give it within 15 days but if i am not able to give you within 15 days, you should charge me interest, so does this contract or loan becomes Halal for me, in reality i have said that i will pay interest ( soud ) after 15 days.
Ma tora sa confuse hu jab apne Gold k bare ma kaha k wo CFD ha to ap sirf Gold k bare bat kr rahe te ya sare currency pairs jo FX ma ha wo sare bhi CFD ha or agr ma prop firm acc k bajai Live acc kolu to ows se trades lena mere permissible ha ya nhi?
Pehly meme coin ko haram bolo gay ....phir wohi khareedny ka bolo gay...🤡 Airdrops ko scam bolo gay...phir free airdrops ki videos bhi dalo gay🤡 Forex haram hai....ab be-tukkay reason deke khudse halal bol rahy ho....aur koi Fatwa bhi nhi hai. . Bss kisi tarah yeh prop firms ka dhanda chal jaye ksii tarah
We have given reasons and discussed use cases for everything, we are still learning about forex and wont launch it until we are fully satisfied, you can make your research about everything and do what you want to.
Adnan Bhai Ap Apni Research Ko Mzed Clearfy Krny Kylye UA-cam Channel Ha noman Chaudhary he is 11 yrs old In FOREX & Free Channels Py Indepth About Broker Work etc Many More Pra Hua
Bhy is m kuch points missing h jaisy AP 100k dollar ka acount buy kro gy tu us m apko 10000$ dollar hi mily gy sirf trade krny k lye aur uska 8%.8% ni hota real m wo 80% target hota h aur hr account ka laverage hota ab wo km ho ya zyada ye change ho skta h.
sir sorry to say this is absolutely wrong information regarding prop firm mechanism and cfd because if u just check out the running price of gold u can check that price in phsical market as well same for currency, over all I just want to say less knowledge is always dangerous
Adnan Bhai Cfd Ko Ap Ki Nzr Se Dekhty Hy Hr Ksi Ka Dekhny Ka Andaz Lg Huta Koj Log Bolty Hy Live Rate Hy Or Deen Be Yhi Kehta Ha Tum Jis My Kaam Kro Tumhy Pta Ho Wo Ha Kia Like Currencies Ka To Sbko Pta Ha
Ye podcast dekh ke mugay ye samag lagi ha ke only forex trading with propfirm is halal. Only with islamic broker jispe swap na ho halal. Otherwise haram ha i am correct?
31:23 This practice, known as the swap commission is a form of interest or is bank centralised and traditional banking is prohibited as per ISLAM.However, considering the Quranic stance against interest, it becomes evident that Islam does not permit Forex trading....End Of Discussion So Say No To FOREX!
सिफारिश की सराहना करता हूँ! मैंने XAI17A खरीदा, 10x मुनाफे की उम्मीद कर रहा हूँ। प्रमुख एक्सचेंजेस लिस्टिंग की पुष्टि कर रहे हैं। आपकी जानकारी हमेशा सटीक होती है। इस निवेश के भविष्य को देखने के लिए उत्सुक हूँ, मूल्यवान सलाह के लिए धन्यवाद!
Assalamualaikum sir, ap nai bataya kai prop firm hamaray mutabiq sahe hai magar mera swal yai tha kai ham prop firm ko konsai way sai trade kartay hai like i.e CFDs, future, binary or any other ways to trade. And about CFDs that there is no such possession to sir yai basically aik contract hai or modern economic kai mutabiq agar ap koi contract kartay ho to us ke physical possession zarore nahe domain name, UA-cam channel etc. As is in surah Al-Baqarah(2:282) :
"When you contract a debt for a specified term write it down..." Iska matlab hai kai agar aik proper contract ho or ownership defined ho ( contract) to yai halal hai. Hope sir ap is par mazeed research karein gay. Jazakallah ❤
So basically.... Prop firms is also a kind of contract,
If you are on prop firm even then still you don't own it is physically and you don't know that wether that money is came from so that also raise a question.
XRP और XAI17A साझा करने के लिए धन्यवाद। 💯
It was very insightful 💯
Thank you inspired analyst team. Much needed video
Adnan Bhai Broker is equal to bank Huta Jo mene research ki Koch Log Bolty Hy Forex Ke Pechy Kj be ni ha Jabky Pechy institutional traders Huty Hy or Jb hm be trade lgaaty Hy to Beshak Euro Hmaray hath me Na Aya mgr Hmari amount Se Bohot Thora SA Frq Pra Ha Price me so Jo broker Tana tan Profits de Rhy Hy Wo Kaha Se de Rhy Hy ??
Kindly forex ke subription me kuj discount kare
अभी-अभी आपका वीडियो देखा जिसमें XAI17A पर चर्चा की गई है और मैं इसको लेकर बहुत उत्साहित हूँ।
Adnan bhai physical possession ko detail me explain karden
Great discussion ❤
I love you inspired analyst ❤
Great initiative
Thankyou Sufyan bhai!
Phase 1 pass ratio is 6%
Phase 2 pass ratios is 12%
Payout reached 1%
Bit sir apny sign to krdiya na contract ky bhiagr hm overnight hold kryngy tu hm Interest dyn gy . Ap de ni ey interest but you signed that if you hold tradr you must have to give interest so is kakya khyal hy apka
I want to give you interview in detail i got 100k in payouts with propfirms
The underlying assets traded (e.g., forex, stocks, commodities) must comply with Islamic principles and be halal. Forex trading remains a debated topic in Islamic finance-some scholars consider it permissible if free of riba (interest) and gharar (excessive uncertainty), while others disapprove.
In the case of prop firms, funded accounts often operate in a demo trading environment during all phases, including after passing evaluations. This means the trades executed do not involve actual ownership or trading of physical or real financial assets. Instead, the environment is simulated, and earnings are based on performance within a virtual setup. This raises questions about whether such profits, derived from non-realistic trades, align with the principles of Shariah, which emphasize transparency and tangible value in financial dealings.
Great explanation, I gathered a lot of questions and Haram stuff about forex from this video, And this is one of those questions,
I think this is totaly considered Haram, as you mentioned there is no ownership only playing games
And my other question raises that, He said swap accounts are halal, I understood about swap accounts that when day completes or closes and you don’t close trade so than you will be interested ( soud dena hoda ) but i think that is Haram because you are actually trading with the contract/concept which applies interest on you at the end if you fail to close trade,
It is like i get a loan from someone and i tell him i will give it back to you within 15 days and i am confident on myself but somehow i couldn’t give it within 15 days but if i am not able to give you within 15 days, you should charge me interest, so does this contract or loan becomes Halal for me, in reality i have said that i will pay interest ( soud ) after 15 days.
And spot forex kesy kryn
Thanks Sir for your efforts 🫡🫡
It's my pleasure!
Which platform to trade forex
Adnan Bhai Gold Ke Elava Currencies Me Trade Nai Kr Skty Like Cad-GBP-Jpy etc
Ma tora sa confuse hu jab apne Gold k bare ma kaha k wo CFD ha to ap sirf Gold k bare bat kr rahe te ya sare currency pairs jo FX ma ha wo sare bhi CFD ha or agr ma prop firm acc k bajai Live acc kolu to ows se trades lena mere permissible ha ya nhi?
same question to @inspired analyst
Pehly meme coin ko haram bolo gay ....phir wohi khareedny ka bolo gay...🤡
Airdrops ko scam bolo gay...phir free airdrops ki videos bhi dalo gay🤡
Forex haram hai....ab be-tukkay reason deke khudse halal bol rahy ho....aur koi Fatwa bhi nhi hai.
.
Bss kisi tarah yeh prop firms ka dhanda chal jaye ksii tarah
We have given reasons and discussed use cases for everything, we are still learning about forex and wont launch it until we are fully satisfied, you can make your research about everything and do what you want to.
Nice brother.... This is a great discussion
Much appreciated!
Assalam O Alikum! Adnan bhai. Can you provide some prop firm website which is genuine?
Sir aik prop firm ya broker ka name bta dein jo ownership of asset de
I don’t understand how the issue of ownership was answered ? We trading the CFDs and not the ‘actual’ currency. How is it halal?
We will share our further researches in the coming videos.
*Very Informative*
Glad it was helpful!
Bilkul sahi information pheli baar kisi ne sach kaha . highly appreciated 🙌🏻
Adnan Bhai Ap Apni Research Ko Mzed Clearfy Krny Kylye UA-cam Channel Ha noman Chaudhary he is 11 yrs old In FOREX & Free Channels Py Indepth About Broker Work etc Many More Pra Hua
Adnan bhai, physical possession wali baat samaj nahi ai
So doing long is halal and short is haram in prop firms acc
Physical possession ka smjh nhi aya
Bhy is m kuch points missing h jaisy AP 100k dollar ka acount buy kro gy tu us m apko 10000$ dollar hi mily gy sirf trade krny k lye aur uska 8%.8% ni hota real m wo 80% target hota h aur hr account ka laverage hota ab wo km ho ya zyada ye change ho skta h.
Adnan bahi i love i bought ALGO ON 0.40 NOW PRICE IS 0.52
great!
@@InspiredAnalystTp 0.98 rahka howa ha many apna kya man thik hun
Apas mai masla hal karrahay hoo.
Bhayya include Ulma .... Mufti into this.
They are the expert to advice.
sir sorry to say this is absolutely wrong information regarding prop firm mechanism and cfd because if u just check out the running price of gold u can check that price in phsical market as well same for currency, over all I just want to say less knowledge is always dangerous
Adnan Bhai Malaysia Translation Me Senior Mufti Allama Yusuf Al Qardawi Ne Isko Declear Halal Kaha Or Fatwa Be Dea Or Wo Khud Broker Ke Owner Hy
Adnan Bhai Cfd Ko Ap Ki Nzr Se Dekhty Hy Hr Ksi Ka Dekhny Ka Andaz Lg Huta Koj Log Bolty Hy Live Rate Hy Or Deen Be Yhi Kehta Ha Tum Jis My Kaam Kro Tumhy Pta Ho Wo Ha Kia Like Currencies Ka To Sbko Pta Ha
Swap free account koi broker deta hi naai
Please propfirms ko tora aur achey tarikey sey explain karey.
inshaallah we will do it in the coming videos
Ye podcast dekh ke mugay ye samag lagi ha ke only forex trading with propfirm is halal. Only with islamic broker jispe swap na ho halal. Otherwise haram ha i am correct?
Adnan Bhai Senior Doctor Obaidullah About Forex Trading Online fatwa Wo Ap Google Krlyn Bohot He Authentic Economist Hyn Wo
Please tell me Forex trading broker
XAI17A अभी भी अत्यधिक कम मूल्यांकित है।
Dr Obaidullah Arab Ke Senior Islamic Financial economist Hy Onho Ne Eski research ki ha or Isi base Pe Qatar or SA Ne Esko Halal Qaraar Deaa
27:47
31:23 This practice, known as the swap commission is a form of interest or is bank centralised and traditional banking is prohibited as per ISLAM.However, considering the Quranic stance against interest, it becomes evident that Islam does not permit Forex trading....End Of Discussion So Say No To FOREX!
7 trillion not 70
Lagta hai analyst bhai ki forex sey kamai shuru ho gai hai....isliay issy ab halal farma rahy hain😂
we are still learning and doing our research on it
Or mobile py subscription nyi li ja rahi
Please contact our moderators for that.
आपका वीडियो देखने के बाद मैंने XAI17A खरीदा, बहुत उत्साहित हूँ! 💰
मैं XAI17A के आपके चयन पर भरोसा करता हूँ। इसमें बहुत संभावनाएं हैं 🚀
सिफारिश की सराहना करता हूँ! मैंने XAI17A खरीदा, 10x मुनाफे की उम्मीद कर रहा हूँ। प्रमुख एक्सचेंजेस लिस्टिंग की पुष्टि कर रहे हैं। आपकी जानकारी हमेशा सटीक होती है। इस निवेश के भविष्य को देखने के लिए उत्सुक हूँ, मूल्यवान सलाह के लिए धन्यवाद!
सलाह के लिए धन्यवाद! मैंने XAI17A खरीदा, बहुत उत्साहित हूँ! 🚀
XAI17A जैसे वास्तविक जीवन में उपयोगी प्रोजेक्ट्स को देखना बहुत कठिन है 🥳🥳🥳