How Long Should One's Beard Be? | Shaykh Dr Yasir Qadhi {Animated}
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лип 2024
- Growing a beard is an issue that has approximately 7-8 different opinions regarding the maximum and minimum length. Some people get judged when they keep their beards long and then cut it after. Others get judged when they choose not to have a beard. So who is right or wrong?
Watch the video above as Shaykh Yasir explains!
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits
Animated By: Free Quran Videos (UA-cam)
Channel Link: / nakcolle. .
Intro Nasheed: 'Allah is My Lord'
Link: • Allah is My Lord - Bea...
Outro Nasheed: 'The Good is Still Alive'
Link: • The Good Is Still Aliv...
Timelapse Footage
From: Timestorm Films
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official UA-cam Channel
Subhaana Allah! I was shocked when I saw Sh Yasir with a full beard teaching fundamentals of faith. Mann that was nice, I never thought he’s grown his beard to such length, until I saw it with my 2 eyes.
Which video
m.ua-cam.com/video/2bSxOmcyI18/v-deo.html
Salam alaykum Yasir. This was very nice and covered quite a bit of research. Do you think it is a good idea to mention about the one whose beard just doesn't grow? For instance, oriental Muslims and those who have had chemotherapy, etc. Maybe mention not shaving or cutting nails in 10 days of Dhul Hijjah? Also, about those who have to shave for the military. I was presented with these questions 3 decades ago, and had to really talk to the scholars of Islam (long distance to Egypt and Saudi) to get the right answers. Keep up the good work. We all appreciate your efforts and sacrifices for this deen. - Jazakallah khair for your duas and commitment to Islam. Yusuf Estes
Those whose doesn't grow hv nothing in their hand, so they r following this sunnah in the very same manner as those who hv full lengths.
But below one fist is sinful indeed. U can't find a single sahabi who trimmed below this length.
I just want to know why someone would want to join a military group that forces you to go against the Sunnah of the messenger (SAWS) MAKE IT MAKE SENSE.
Salaam. Jazakallahukhairan for succint information.
Halal Digest: Zabiha Food Reviews unbelievable
I disagree with this view because its opposite of what the Sahabbh did (the righteous people who followed the Prophet) they trimmed at fist length, the fist length is the minimum, not one of the sahabah trimmed less than fist, so i disagree with brother Yasir qadhi on this issue, may Allah guide him and guide us all
How do you know not one of the sahaba trainees less than that? There are only 3 reports and thousands of sahaba you don’t know what you’re taking about. There is actually a report of the roman sahaba shaving his beard but I suspect that was before the command. But you didn’t know that did you so you’re taking about things you don’t know which is forbidden.
A beard is fard, the first length is proven from some very genius sahaba so yes it’s excellent but it doesn’t make it fard, to say a thing is fard is a big statement and there is opinions from both sides it’s been debated for centuries between the madhabs and Emran Hafez from Facebook is going to solve it for us all ?
That’s what you follow khair insh’Allah You’ve got the right to agree or disagree with a sheikh Based on evidence or for another view and similarly someone will disagree with the sheikh yiu have followed and followed another sheik now leave it and learn your deen and don’t let the shaytan distract you from using your energy for gaining more reward
I agree it’s safer no disagreement but one thing I love the cleanliness of the salafi in not associating or doing Bidah etc but they end up removing a lot of Allah’s mercy from the deen in my opinion Alahu’Alim and it’s not a good thing.
Rasul’Allah sws was good if he was harsh with the Muslims he would have turned them away.
What’s halal is What’s permitted in Allah’s book and what is haram is what’s forbidden in Allah’s book and what Allah SWT stayed silent about is a mercy this is a principle of Islam.
I’m not saying go easy but I’m saying to you if you go on a path that you make too extreme you won’t be able to continue in that way and it will hurt you and I know Salafi converts that apostates audu’billah.
Be sincere brother go with the middle opinions and protect yourself from Allah’s anger but also from making things too hard so you won’t be able to maintain.
The beloved deed to Allah is the consistent on even if it’s small a lot of people go very full into deen then fall away, be consistent brother and every year get better and move always forward.
Please take my experience brother and make things easy within the permitted Rasul’Allah sws said if there was 2 halal choices he would pick the easier one, and Allah wishes is no hardship this is the spirit of Islam and why I make a point to say that it’s in my sincere belief that where Allah made a mercy always take it we never can do without His mercy, no one can enter Junnah by his deeds only by Allah’s mercy so don’t deprive yourself of that as Allah SWT says I am as my slave thinks of me.
It may have been a custom for them to trim the beard to such a length. Scholars say this is a good recommended length to follow, but not mandatory, because the evidence should be drawn from the messenger of Allah (saw)'s specific commands regarding the length of the beard for it to be compulsory. In this case there is no specific text here, nor did the sahabas, who used to cut the the beard to one fist length, gave any instructions in regards to what exact length one can cut or not cut.
The same with the wearing amamah (head dress); it was custom and habit for the sahabah wearing amamah & no one has narrated that he saw any of the Sahabah walking the streets with no amamah according to scholars. The wearing of the amamah by the sahabah does not make it an obligation and no scholar had ever claimed that just because the Sahabah used to wear amamah, we are all obliged to do so.
One of the great former Imams who knew the differences of opinions among the scholars and Ijmaa’, Ibn Jareer At-Tabari - who died in 310 A.H. - narrated the difference of opinion in taking from the beard regardless of whether it is limited to the fist’s length or not.
Fath Al-Baari, authored by Ibn Hajar may Allaah have mercy upon him reads, “At-Tabari narrated a difference of opinion about what is taken from the beard, whether or not there is a limit for it, so he reported from a group that the limit is to take what exceeds a fist. It was also narrated from Al-Hasan Al-Basri that one takes from its length and width what is not considered aberrant. The same thing was related from ‘Ataa’. These scholars interpreted the prohibition to mean prohibiting what the non-Arabs used to do in cutting the beard and lightening it.”
@@MohsinKhan-me4mo You’re asking me if I have a problem with sahee Hadith? That’s like asking if someone if they are a disbeliever audu’billah if you said that to my face you would have a problem brother, work on Islamic character not accusing your brothers who follow established opinion, this is the opinion of a whole madhab and of Al nawawi, the video explains the evidence.
These men of knowledge have interpreted the Hadith that you aren’t capable of interpreting or deriving a hukm from so stay in your lane akhi and promote love between your Brothers not division may Allah guide us.
@@MohsinKhan-me4mo so you found ignorance and arrogance in me saying to a man trying to debate about the ahadith of Rasul’Allah sws when the scholars have already spoken on it extensively and established the opinions so that you should follow your opinion and let people follow theirs and not try and cause division? This is ignorance and arrogance? If you want to convince people of your view you don’t use insults to do it.
I can tell a lot about you brother from the way you talk but I won’t take the sin Insh’Allah, men don’t insult from hidden places behind a phone and people with Adhab islami don’t accuse their brothers for no reason, that’s twice now and for what following the opinion of an established madhab, even if I’m wrong it doesn’t warrant that, people with your attitude only hurt themselves. Salaam.
amazing effort 👍🏽
Ya Allah bless our Sheikh a humble place in Jannah.....Ameen
Mashaallah shikh thanks you, may Allah reword you
Aameen
Sincere question sheikh,
If it is optimal to have a fistful, why do you keep your beard much shorter? Would you consider growing it back at least to a fistful, not as long as you had it before but at least longer than it is now. I think you'll find so much more respect among all of the groups, even the moderates. Allaah knows best
hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh May Allah guide you, length of a beard is not significant, as long as you have some facial hair on your face to make you look manly - is enough. What, you would like every Muslim to look like Hazrat Dumbledore looooooooooooooool
@@Yaqeenan21 ua-cam.com/video/vxu2augAyUc/v-deo.html
@@Yaqeenan21 Sheikh al-Dumbledorullah
@@Yaqeenan21 you can shave it my friend bcz your only concern is to look manly and you can look manly only by having some mustaches. We are speaking about sunnah and those who want to follow it, should grow it at least fistful.
@@Yaqeenan21 you are so ignorant. Let me ask you two questions:
Was the Prophet ﷺ a man?
Did the Prophet ﷺ have a full beard?
Walahi that’s the most fair and balanced opinion I ever heard on the beard, this was never an issue because a beard was understood as a beard, the Sahaba were busy changing the world not disputing about exact details, this cane later, the fact no reports ever came of anyone asking about this just one command and understood shows it wasn’t a matter of detail Allah’Alim
The sahaba disputed many exact details. Based on the actions of the Prophet PBUH and the sahaba though it seems YQ is wrong. Wallahu alm.
If you read this;
Say "SubhanAllah" 33x
Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x
Say "Allahu akbar" 34x
May Allah reward you.
Mashallah tabarakallah Jzkallah Sheikh Yasir for the in-depth explanation and informative!
Thank you
Asc my fellow Somali sister
follow what companions of Rasul sallallaahu alyhi wassallam have followed because they understood it better of keeping the beard..the minimum length can be found from hadith is one fist of length otherwise prophet alyhi salam has obligated it leave as it's...
sheikh says that some scholars say even if it grows upto floor . no, instead Allah says " La yukallifullaaha nafsan illaa wus'aha"
wallahu Alam
That's "your" opinion on what the minimum is, he clarified that some say this is the minimum, but he believes in the optimal but not wajib.
what if you can't go facial hair? should we get a beard transplant, I think might be a good idea
no bro u get the revord of beard even if it not growin
i'faa' and tawfeer of the lihya indicate a reasonable amount that shows length
Can't unsee hamza for eyes
We also need to talk about keeping hearts clean when speaking about beards......as Allah said successful is the one who purifies himself..... Definitely by keeping ones a'maal correct.
This topic is about the beard, so he is taking about the beard
@@delaman4991 You've clearly not read the comment properly, if you have then the issue may be with comprehension.
Pretty sure it’s been edited Allhu’alim from memory it was talking about the importance of other issues hence I said afar I said. This is what I remember and makes sense but if I’m wrong I’m wrong Allahu’Alim
for a bare minimum bear "when you look at someone and think its a beard than its a beard" wth? thats not a well researched claim because everyone has different opinion of beard, someone might call facial hair as stubble and other one might call it beard. so what would it really be considered?
The command means an ample beard Allahu’Alim, when you look generally there’s a point that it goes from stubble to a beard, most people can have the same definition of a full beard, a short full beard or a long full beard, his point is we are commanded to grow a beard and the command is not as specific as made out by some in his opinion, Allahu’Alim it was quite clear what he was saying
Ali javed: the minimum is looking at what the Sahabah did, minimum was the fist length
@@emran011 The minimum length of the beard was never specified by the prophet (saw) and the trimming of the beards of the companions are just general indications that trimming is allowed whatever length (although lengthening is praiseworthy but not mandatory) this is how some scholars understood this and Dr YQ took this view.
Abdullah ibn Umar was known to follow the Sunnah in almost every action and he's known to have his beard upto a fist length. Allah knows best.
He trimmed it only during Hajj.
It was only for Hajj
@@farhaanrasheed2005 so during hajj it’s ok to do haram things like cutting the beared
@@homer1273 Most correct opinion according the most Scholars is that it is obligatory to let the beard grow, because of the general words of the Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him).
"Trim the mustache and leave the beard to grow"
Also, there's only one daleel on Abdullah Ibn Umar that he cut his beard upto the fist length and was also only during a Hajj
@Farhaan Rasheed you said "it was only for hajj" so does that mean that it's haram to cut the beard except during hajj
some people especially in east and south east asia can't even grow a beard but they can always grow the hair on the chin.
Then they leave it as it is. Prophet Muhammad (saw) didn't say to grow the beard he said to leave it alone and not shave it.
There are people who genetically have shorter than a fistful beard. Some hardly even have any beard.
So don't just jump to conclusions from seeing the size of someone's beard.
The word grow wasn’t used , it never said to grow to or to lengthen, it says to leave (to leave May mean to leave its width , keep it full and do not go into its width and make shapes ect but no where does it say grow or lengthen
There is the wording: وفروا اللحى
which indicates that
I have my beard as long or as short as life dictates. Right....what about no growth somesome ppl just don't have. What about over growth. It can weigh 20lbs and hurt you if your hair is healthy and thick. IT GETS CUT
The question is did the prophet trim or cut it or shaped it. if you have difference opinion over an issued does not the quran instruct us to return to Allah and his messenger.
Shaikh gave his personal opinion better to follow sahabh and tabai to be on safe side. seems beard definition kept on changing. later line beard may become acceptable based on new definition
100% salaf knew best
The fact and insight that Muslims are not allowed or encouraged to follow other faith traditions or any kind of celebs what and what not and highly recommended or clearly told to protect their originality, you could've mentioned this issue.
Secondly, you should've encouraged the best practice , the best one in line of sunnah and intention, Jajakallah..
This video doesn't clarify anything but creates more confusion regarding the definition of a beard. He didn't give any definition in cm but then he mentioned a mm. Also, what is the definition of "Majority of the Scholars"? And why would all of the sahaba R.A. (the best of Muslim generations) grow a beard to at least a fistful without any reason?
Mustahab if 3 sahaba did it? What about the other thousands that didn’t trim it
We follow prophet muhammad saw in any case! We have the clear ruling from ahadith not to touch beard and trim mustache.
Follow prophet is the way which will lead to jannah!
Sorry brother if you say not to touch the beard then why did some of the best of the companions trim their beard. The truth of the matter is the prophet (saw) commamded to grow the beard but has not specified the length. There is no revelation or text from the prophet (saw) to specify the length. The trimming of the companions are understood by some scholars to be a good length to keep but not compulsory and also a general indication that trimming is allowed.
@@MohsinKhan-me4mo Have you read commentary about this hadith ... THis hadith says DON"T IMITATE idolaters ... THe idolators used to to GROW moustache and shave beard ... So the opposite of it is to grow beard and trim moustache ... IBN UMAR cut it to a fistful NOT PROPHET(PBUH) ... What SAHABAS did doesn't not make it a legal ruling ... The Prophet(saw) said DON"T TOUCH the beard and let it grow but IBN UMAR(ra) still trimmed it ...
Prophet Muhammad saw actions are called sunnah which if you follow you get rewarded and not follow not get punish.
I listen to him often and like his references but this time i don't think he is right. If the prophet ordered to grow the beard and the sahaba understood it as fistful then this is what we should follow and Allah knows the best.
I agree with you. I like this sheikh but sometimes I don't agree with him.
Hmm but i think what Yasir Qadhi meant is from a linguistic point of view, the hadith tells us to just have a beard. It doesnt tell us not to trim it. If the sahabi trimmed the beard to a fistful, and if the hadith were understood as it is nowadays, didnt that mean that the sahabi disobeyed Allah?
@@aaaaaaaaaaaa9023 you did not understood the whole argument. The sahaba understood it very well. And when they kept a fistful and trimmed below that point, it means that is what you should keep at least as a beard. We all have short comings. Yasir Qadhi had long beard before ten years. What he have now is not a beard at all according to ahlus sunnah. I haven't seen any scholar so far with this much short beard. I do respect him for his knowledge but this action of him is not something to be praised or trusted.
@@innocentfriend I totally agree with you brother!
Kill means shave .you can leave it to upto chest .even at the prophet death his Beard was upto to chest.
I have an unrelated question to the video, but this is the most recent one so I suppose I will get the most answers here.
How can humans have free will if god already knows the outcome of the universe?
Firstly, doubts should be taken at face value, they are like open questions. Doubt in X may not necessarily mean that you reject Y. As Y may be a question of faith (For example does God exist? Some may doubt his existence but others may accept his existence on the grounds of faith). Furthermore, doubt in X may take on a meaning which has very little to do with rejecting Y.
So the gap between doubt and disbelief is very wide and one day we may find the answers to the doubts we may have. Doubts which having noting to do with rejecting the faith of Islam rather doubts which trouble the intellect and occur due to our limited understanding.
More to the point, the questions presented are very difficult questions indeed. As you may know, philosophers have battled with these sorts of questions for a very long time ( for example the problem of evil and other similar problems). We can try to come up with logical answers to these problems but as you are aware, not all things in fate follow the rules of logic. Sometimes there is a hidden logic. Further, I don't think that our intellect will ever be satisfied if we use our limited understating to comprehend questions which may require the direct input (The KUN) of Allah. The better approach is to have trust in Allah, acknowledge that Allah is the Most Wise and the Most Just and use this information to satisfy the soul. The things we fail to understand in this world will be made clear to us on the day of Judgement. This donyah is a test.
In Surah Baqarah we learn that When Allah created Adam he said to the Angels, "...Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successive authority." The Angels responded by saying, "Will you place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?" It seems that the Angels could not comprehend why Allah would do that. Allah then said: "Indeed, I know that which you do not know." “And He taught Adam the names - all of them. Then He showed them to the angels and said, "Inform Me of the names of these, if you are truthful." The Angels then said, “…Exalted are You; we have no knowledge except what You have taught us. Indeed, it is You who is the Knowing, the Wise." Allah then said, "O Adam, inform them of their names." And when he had informed them of their names, He said, "Did I not tell you that I know the unseen [aspects] of the heavens and the earth? And I know what you reveal and what you have concealed."
If we are people happy to believe in the unseen ( Allah, the Angels the devil the Jin, life after death and so on) then believing in Qadr should not really be that problematic. Further, ( as mentioned above) we believe that Allah is Most Wise and the Most Just and that A Most Wise and Most Just Lord would not do things that are Not Wise and or Not Just.
So have trust in Allah and work on building your relationship with Allah. Once you have that special relationship with Allah, you will find that sakoon in your soul no matter what comes up in your life.
Salam
Consider this I not using any Islamic knowledge as far I know just human reasoning. What exactly is the contradiction? I do not see the contradiction. We humans unknowingly assume The Creator perception is similar to ours. It is beyond time & space at the very least. Humans have limited senses & perception that do not see the inner realities of things without using reasoning & scientific process to get closer to it. Studying Einstein's Relativity & quantum theory help me understand these things better. And qadr seems very logical using current theories today.
Safraz Mohammed the contradiction is that we supposedly have free will and are able to make our own decisions, but god supposedly knows everything, including my decisions, contradicting the supposition that I have free will.
Manneduintevet even if god knows what you will do you are still the one doing it out of your free will
Manneduintevet even if god knows what you will do you are still the one doing it out of your free will
💜
I love Yasir qadi but him and NAK have a tendinsy to twist and exaggerate the other options "leave it even if it grows to the floor" common.....
The question is, how long the beard was grown by Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). Was it less than a fist in length? If not, then I think it is not allowed to having a beard less than this. What I know and heard is that Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) had a long beard.
The point is brother the command is Non specific, because something is sunnah it’s means it’s excellent and recommended at least but not always fard.
His position is to grow a short beard fulfils the command and is not sinful but to have the length of Rasul’Allah sws is best.
Some now might find that hard and Allah SWT makes ease in Islam and rulings in Islam on things like these are not normally very rigid, Allah knows His creation and what they face and leaves room in the deen for difference in opinion Allahu’Alim
But if you can grow the length of Rasul’Allah sws may Allah make that easy and grant you success
DeLaMan no its fard akhi, its fard because its a direct command of the Prophet Muhammad, may Allah guide you and guide us All :)
I agree the beard is fard but that is debated as the length, you cant say no it’s fard akhi, its the opinion you follow yes and I agree but it’s an opinion and Allah knows best who is right or wrong about the specifics the command to grow a beard is a command therefor it’s very hard to argue that’s fard the point made is no length was specified
@@delaman4991 In other to determine length, look at what Sahaba followed after Prophet. Did any Sahaba have beard less than one fist, the answer is no.
The answer is you don’t know that’s the answer, but again that doesn’t make it fard what’s fard is to grow a beard. You’re not a sheik so dont give rulings out brother it’s not your role, or mine, opinions of the madhabs are clear for everyone to read and a person has to follow what he thinks is correct from the evidence.
I follow the position of imam al nawawi that a beard is fard but to keep it shorter is makruh not haram.
Rasul’Allah sws never specified a length there was not much detail given to me this indicates there was scope, I don’t believe it’s correct to make a length fard when it wasn’t specified this is my view and it’s supported by a whole Madhab.
So brother there isn’t imam al nawawi and the Shaffi Madhab says this but syed from UA-cam says it’s not, you don’t know even the sheiks don’t know that’s why there is scope of opinion, this is how fiqh works.
Allah knows best what the specifics of the command are but we don’t because we weren’t told so the shayuk interpret, it’s not anyone position to say what’s right and wrong they can give their opinion and that’s it. Salaam alaykum, Ramadan Mubarak and you’re beard is top mash’Allah May Allah protect and increase your handsomeness.
And again...... It's not sinfully if it can't grow but JUST LET IT GROW TILL ITS NO LONGER REASONABLE. witch seems to be roughly a fist full or so more or less. Why is this complicated
It’s not about having a nice or big beard. JUST LEAVE IT ✅
K-K that’s what I mean is that many men from Africa like me don’t get lots of beard hair, even if we leave it. So many young men shave it thinking it doesn’t look nice to have a few hairs on the cheek. Rather the prophet ordered us to leave it. That’s my point barak Allah feek
@@user-kn7if4ob5g And the majority of the companions and Ulamah understood him alyhisalaam as stating that you can trim it i.e. to an extent. You got to respect the opinions of the companions, they were his companions at the end of the day.
So the prophet grew his beard and kept it as long as it reached his chest.
Some sahabas used to trim excess hair over a fistful, the four imaams followed the Sunnah of our prophets which was also followed by the sahabas.
Did any of them cut short their beard less than a fistful?
Yasir Qadhis opinion is different and contrary to the Sunnah of our prophet, different from the sahabas, different from the eminent four imaams and the vast majority of Ulemas.
Opinion V the evidence.
Simple choice.
Many of the scholars - who held the view that keeping the beard is wajib (necessary) also held the view that lengthening the beard is Mustahab (praiseworthy), but NOT mandatory. They distinguished the 2 rulings a. keeping the beard (wajib) b. lengthening the beard (Mustahab). These Ulema(s) understood that lengthening of the beard to be command of recommendation or sunnah of habits, but not legal mandatory sunnah. The prophet (saw) did NOT specify any length of beard, there is NO text to specify any specific length and the practice of the companions are just general indications to show that trimming is generally allowed. This is how these Ulemas understood this.
@@faysalahmed9157
According to the most of the imaams who were the most knowledgeable in their fields of wisdom and knowledge, non have classed keeping a beard mustahab, rather Sunnah or emphasised Sunnah.
The recent Salafi scholars have degraded this Sunnah.
Non of the prophets or Sahabas have kept such a small beard.
Either it is the equivalent to what our prophet kept it or permitted to cut it to a certain length or it's just a beard in terms of definition.
If any Sahabas kept such a beard and evidence is available, one should provide such evidence.
Trimming and cutting of beard are two different things.
When the beard grows to the length of the chest, ulema agree upon trimming it to no less than a fistful.
If you trim anymore than that, it is not trimming, it is cutting.
Muslim (2344) reported that Jaabir ibn Samurah (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: “The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to have a very hairy beard.”
An-Nisaa’ (5232) reported from al-Baraa’ that he (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) had a thick beard; according to another report, he had a bushy beard; according to another report, he had a wide beard.
Al-Nawawi said: the best is to leave it as it is and not touch it or shorten it at all. (Tuhfat al-Ahwadhi, 8/39).
“Indeed in the Messenger of Allaah (Muhammad) you have a good example to follow for him who hopes for (the Meeting with) Allaah and the Last Day…” [al-Ahzaab 33:21]
“And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad) gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it).” [al-Hashr 59:7]
Thus cutting the beard to such lengths is controversial and no Sunnah compliant.
Allah knows best.
@@exsalafi393 Brother there is diffefences in this matter and we have to respect the differences. One of the principle in Islam is "There is no condemnation in matters of Ijtihad".
Great classical scholrs like Imam Nawawi, Ibn Hajar Haythami, Imam Razi, Imam Ghazali, Qadi Iyyad and held that full beard is recommended but not obligatory. The website link you pasted only shows one side of the view and surprisingly mentions Imam Nawawi (ra) on some suspects but not other aspect i.e. he (imam Nawawi held the beard was recommended sunnah and not manadatory sunnah.
To see other views:
questionsonislam.com/question/beard-fard-or-just-sunnah
@@faysalahmed9157
Yes, indeed there are difference of opinions.
The fact remains that no one is really claiming it like Salaah being obligatory and no question about that.
You will not that I have mentioned Sunnah and emphasised Sunnah so please note I have not used obligatory for the beard.
What are the facts?
The facts are that the beard that is kept by the speaker above does not conform to the Sunnah of any prophet.
It just meats the definition of a beard and nothing more.
The qouted I provided you are sahih and sound narrations.
So if you believe that such a beard conforms to the Sunnah, you are mistaken.
Those who follow the exact traditional Sunnah as kept by our prophet are the ones who are not controversial and stand in the true group of the followers of the Sunnah.
@@exsalafi393 I would not look at like it like that. An individual who keeps a beard as long as what he what he kept constitutes a beard, has fullfilled an element aspect of the sunnah if not full.
it seems as if some one is trying to justify the size of his beard.
He is not the autherty to decide the lenth and he is mis guiding to all ask him about majorty of sahaba and rasool Allah did they use to trim their beard??? And what is the order in hadeeth let the beard grow.
Inna Lillah e wa inna Alhe rajaoon
He is one of those alim who is also mensioned in one sahi hadees.
Leaving the actions of Sahaba and adopting linguistic meaning, is this Islam?
Yes, those people who trim more than a fistful is sinful. IN FACT, this brother Qadhi is SINFUL. All he does is twist islam.
Is the separated heads an underlying hint to something?😬😬
It is Haram to draw images of living beings, thats why they seperate head from body so its disconnected and not a surah.
There are many deviant words of yasir qadhi
Astagfrullah why you mention cartoon face with muhmmad saw name why????
he wasn't imaging the prophet salla allahou alayhi wa sallam as i understood , just a man with a beard while explaining the hadith
In the 6th century, sharp shaving blades like the way we have today were not invented. Keeping the beards is sunna, show muscling and as a symbol for Muslim men. I don't think it is sinful to not keep the beards. The prophet recommended to keep it for various reasons. If you don't wash regularly the beards can develop some skin rushes or fungus underneath. I think trimming is the best way to keep beards clean and healthy. The best is to do good deeds. You may have beards just to lure people that you a good Muslim while you do bad and sinful deeds. The beards will not guarantee you Jannah. Jazak Allah Kheir!
It’s a command to grow the beard It’s a command and they had sharp shaving instruments they shaved they’re heads for hadj
Rubbish they shaved there heads and public hair.
No they didn’t public hair was plucked
@@delaman4991 they did pluck aswell as shaving, if you don't know don't assume. What was there swords made from where they not sharp. Now I'm going to have to give you references regarding your ignorance.
@@delaman4991
Al-Bukhaari (5079) and Muslim (715) narrated that Jaabir ibn ‘Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: We were with the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) on campaign, and when we approached Madinah, we wanted to enter the city straight away, but the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Delay it until we enter at night, so that the one who is dishevelled may tidy herself up and the one whose husband is absent may shave her pubic hair.”
Al-Haafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) said in Fath al-Baari: This refers to the woman whose husband is absent. What is meant is so that she may remove her pubic hair, and the word used in this hadith refers to shaving, because that is the usual method of removing hair, but that does not mean that it is not allowed to use something other than a razor.
How about innocently clean shaving and being upon islam
It's not a deep issue
Soloist94 being upon Islam is listening to Allah’s commands correct? Guess what :) Allah Said in Quran to Obey the Prophet (thats a direct order) and the Prophet Commanded to grow the beard. He ordered the believers more than few times. This is called being upon Islam
I cant grow it on the lihya
Only slight goatee
Gotta trim it down keep it neat
I don't understand how this is considered an obligation when there is an entire continent of men that don't grow facial hair well if at all! Our chinese and korean brothers don't have beards.
You don't need to take supplements and boosters or transplant to get facial hair; just let it grow, don't shave/trim it; just leave it as they're
They do have beards...
but anyone that can't then they don't have any sin upon them
This is with any obligation
Asalamulaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatu i repect your thoughts but this seems like creating lot of confusion. The hadith is very simple just let your beards grow. Means let it grow. No cutting and shaving. Those of you who fear that what if IT grows upto the feet dont worry brothers Allah SWT does not burden a soul beyond its capacity. Those of you who are pleased with the sheikh's thoughts i would say that you guys dont lyk growing beard and your looking for someone knowlegable to tel you its permissable. Rather than taking the words of our beloved Prophet (ﷺ) serious as it is an order and the four greatest Scholars of islam also stated that its fard, cutting n shaving is not permissable and Allah SWT knows the best . Jazakallahu khairan
The speaker here is not denying that it's an command to keep the beard. But the length of the beard has not been specified by the prophet (saw), there is no revelation or text to specify the length. The trimming of the beard of some of the companions is taken to be a good length to keep but not compulsory, since these companions who trimmed did not discuss how much you can trim or not trim, their actions are taken as general permissibly for trimming the beard regardless if it's after 1 first or before 1 first. This is how some scholars understand this and it's in harmony with the directives (non-specific beard length) command of the prophet (saw). Also, it is not agreed about the beard cannot be trimmed at all among the 4 imams.
One of the great Imams who knew the differences of opinions among the scholars and Ijmaa’, Ibn Jareer At-Tabari - who died in 310 A.H. - narrated the difference of opinion in taking from the beard regardless of whether it is limited to the fist’s length or not. Fath Al-Baari, authored by Ibn Hajar may Allaah have mercy upon him reads, “At-Tabari narrated a difference of opinion about what is taken from the beard, whether or not there is a limit for it, so he reported from a group that the limit is to take what exceeds a fist. It was also narrated from Al-Hasan Al-Basri that one takes from its length and width what is not considered aberrant. The same thing was related from ‘Ataa’.
Faysal Ahmed Yes the length ismt mentioned because the prophet clearly said let your bears grow.Let it grow.
@@faizan_blue No doubt about the command of letting the beard to grow. The discussion is about trimming/cutting the beard - since number of companions and successors have trimmed the beard there is an understanding that trimming the beard is allowed generally. As long as one has "ample beard" (does not matter about the exact length, on his face) this person has grown the beard.
Faysal Ahmed You think the prophet wouldve been a bit more specific about it then?Think about it,he said let your heards grow.If he wouldve let us trim im sure he wouldve hinted towards that but him saying let your beards grow is very specific of letting it grow and not trimming them.Allah hu alam
@@faizan_blue The companions and the successors have trimmed their beard and that shows they understood the length issue to be broad & flexible - whether you want to leave it and not touch at all or trim it - there is flexibility here. The most you may say it's best to leave it.
IN THIS MASALA YOU R NOT RIGHT MY DEAR SHEIKH BCZ IF IT IS PERMISSIBLE TO TRIM AFTER FISTFUL WHY ANY SAHABA NEVER TRIM AFTER FISTFUL SHOW ONLY ONE SAHIH HADEES THAT ANY SAHABA DONE THIS? there is no doubt in the fact that the practice of the Mercy of both worlds, the Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him & give him peace) and his Companions (Allah be pleased with them all) was that of keeping and growing the beard to at least a fistful.
Sheikh Yusuf estes on this topic: ua-cam.com/video/Cc3_e5AgCI8/v-deo.html
Dr Zakir naik on this topic : ua-cam.com/video/vxu2augAyUc/v-deo.html
Abdullah bin Umr ra did it... Bukhari 5892
@@shaibazibnkhalil6438 He left one FISTFUL. He used to hold his beard( one fistful) with his hand then trim: Sahih Bukhari Hadees # 5892
حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ مِنْهَالٍ ، حَدَّثَنَا يَزِيدُ بْنُ زُرَيْعٍ ، حَدَّثَنَا عُمَرُ بْنُ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ زَيْدٍ ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ : خَالِفُوا الْمُشْرِكِينَ ، وَفِّرُوا اللِّحَى وَأَحْفُوا الشَّوَارِبَ ، وَكَانَ ابْنُ عُمَرَ إِذَا حَجَّ أَوِ اعْتَمَرَ قَبَضَ عَلَى لِحْيَتِهِ فَمَا فَضَلَ أَخَذَهُ .
Narrated Nafi`: Ibn `Umar said, The Prophet said, 'Do the opposite of what the pagans do. Keep the beards and cut the moustaches short.' Whenever Ibn `Umar performed the Hajj or `Umra, he used to hold his beard with his hand and cut whatever moustaches. Ibn `Umar used to cut his moustache so short that the whiteness of his skin (above the upper lip) was visible, and he used to cut (the hair) between his moustaches and his beard.
Sahih Hadees
S Khan: Exactly Brother, 100% you said it, we follow the Prophet and Sahabah, JazakaAllah kheiran for standing up for the Truth
You say it because you do not have beard upto one fist
beard like Supreme Leader Ayatollah khaminaei ❤️🥰
Astaghfirullāh. He speaks to confuse people. Cites lexicographers as if they are fuqaha.
But the fuqaha derive rulings based on the language given by lexicographers? Please learn more because espousing nonsense
Allah does not care of the length of your beard. Allah is great enough not to care about your beard.
The Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) indicates that it is obligatory to let the beard grow and that it is haraam to shave it or cut it. It was narrated in al-Saheehayn that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Cut the moustache and let the beard grow; be different from the mushrikeen.” (al-Bukhaari, al-Libaas, 5442; Muslim, al-Tahaarah, 382)
@lucharward alhamdulilah someone who uses reason and logic
@@mahmoudkeels5897 But... don't you know there are many Mushrikeen also had beard including Abu jehel.
What's would you say then.. ?
@@Javed918 what is the evidence for that?
Aienul Javed The saheeh ahaadeeth from the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) indicate that it is prescribed to trim the moustache. For example, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Trim the moustache and let the beard grow; be different from the mushrikeen.” (Agreed upon). And he (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Trim the moustache and let the beard grow; be different from the Magians,” and in some versions it says: “Trim the moustache.
This is the funny thing about GOD.
By defination god is something we dont know about surely. But this guys thinks they almost certainly know what kind of facial hair God likes.
Sorry,the speaker never said what God wanted us to have a beard or not!!...most Islamic scholars gave their opinions based on what the prophet Mohamed (pbuh) own personal beard...it is a matter for us Muslims to follow the prophet mainly in action and yes in his appearance
God sent someone as messanger who instructed to follow him in appearnce, praying for him for peace (he is in need of peace offcourse) everytime taking his name.
Thats a great choice from god
Sorry,I reacted to your statement:**this is the funny thing about God**, there's nothing funny about God...I agree with your reply.
Why not? God is our creator. Therefore, He knows what is the best appearance and the most noble.
And it follows that the messenger that He sent, would have the exact appearance to God wanted humanity to have. This is why we strive so hard to follow the appearance of the prophet (pbuh).
Salaam All,
No there are no real authentic hadith which oblige the growing of beard , there are only 2 sahih hadith concerning beard . The rest are all no Sahih . Imam shafei did not say beard is obilgatory because there is no hadith indicating such thing . You can keep it if you want , It is only Sunnah . we have to clean our fiqh a bit , our brothers are dying and what we have to do is to check how long is the beard should be , well that a well tuned Ummah !
The Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) indicates that it is obligatory to let the beard grow and that it is haraam to shave it or cut it. It was narrated in al-Saheehayn that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Cut the moustache and let the beard grow; be different from the mushrikeen.” (al-Bukhaari, al-Libaas, 5442; Muslim, al-Tahaarah, 382)
@@mahmoudkeels5897 the beard is mustahab , it is authorised to shave and is recommended. It is Ibn Taymiyyah who did this thing that Beard is obligatory , all the Salafis followed him , Salafis are dumb so , ...One opnion in the school of thought is Hanbali is the Beard is not Sunnah or obligatory , the Hadith you mentiioned has no indication of an obligation , you keep the beard if you want , but do not look down at others.Imam Hassan al-basri ,Muahammad ibn sireen , THere are only three hadith , one reported by Abdullah ibn Umar , Abu huraira and Abi Ummamah .the Aghfur means to shave, many scholar interpretes it differently which means let it .
@@mahmoudkeels5897 ua-cam.com/video/nzx_FE9qRlA/v-deo.html
If you understand French, if not ask someone to translate it for you , this is one of the greatest Scholar of all time
@@SROUMALD you are showing arrogance by claiming Salafis are dumb. Be civil. Remember hadiths in Sahih Bukhari and Muslims are the most authentic ones. If they are there, it's enough. It's clearly mentioned in the hadith that the prophet Sallahu Alahi Wasalam ordered us to grow the beard and therefore it is an obligation.
@@SROUMALD remember from whom you take your knowledge from as this deen is knowledge. We are not here to pick and choose any fatwa that suit our desires, we are to look for which one sounds the strongest according to Qur'an and sunnah
And for those who CAN NOT grow a beard ?
Length of BEARD IS RIDICULOUS!
We have MORE SERIOUS issues to DEAL WITH !
Granny Reynolds lmao that’s just common sense. If you can’t grow a beard due to genetics, YOU CAN’T GROW A BEARD. That person has no fault upon him. Like he’s not expected to pull the bloody hairs from his face otherwise he’s gonna be sinful. This is a really stupid argument.
@Granny Reynolds 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Who cares!?
Everyone but you it would seem
@Ahmed Usul blind followers who regurgitate what was spoon fed to them care 🤦🏾♂️
@@quranical-lyspeaking9019 Or reasonable people who accept the truth when they recognize it. You can be critical, so long as you accept the truth when you see it.
May Allah make it easy for me and you to see the truth as truth and follow it, and see what's false as being false and abstaining from it. Ameen.
@Samatar Hussein on the last day what will facial hair matter, and I’d like for you to give me an answer from a logical standpoint here we are in front of rubbill-aalameen, Allah, our creator and times up explain to me where does a beard fit into our meeting with him?....
@@quranical-lyspeaking9019My dear brother the issue isn't the beard in and of itself or the hijab or something else. But it is submission which is the key concept here - Islam is built on it. Everything in our faith is based on it. When the messenger of Allah commands something, we must follow it. Regardless of what it is. That is what we will be asked about by Allah in the day of judgement. When he commanded us, did we obey him?
Why cartoon in serious matters?
This “religion” never ceases to amaze me smh. This scholar said this, this scholar said that, there’s a narration that says this, there’s a narration that says that. Mannnn all that is ridiculous! From evidence in the Quran(the only book we’re COMMANDED to follow btw) Allah is not going to ask you about some damn hair on your face! There’s poverty in the world, racism, materialism, substance abuse, lust and you make a video about some hair that grows on your face? 🤦🏾♂️. It’s funny Allah doesn’t give not ONE physical description of a messenger/prophet in the Quran but we muslims LOVE the superficial stuff!
tread softly young one, this is an issue that if you continue on its specific path I am afraid you will end up humiliated in front of Allah SWT on Judgement Day.
About the issue about him making a video about hair. Haven't you seen how diverse this man's content is?
The path of following the Quran as opposed to scholar opinion and hadith? The only text with authority is The Quran. These aren’t my words this is what Allah says. We’re not even commanded to follow the Sunnah of the Prophet, matter fact Allah doesn’t ever say to follow the prophet nor the messenger at all in the Quran...
@@quranical-lyspeaking9019 you must not have read it a d must be trolling
@@quranical-lyspeaking9019 We have sent you bearing witness, bringing good news, and warning so that you might all believe in Allah and His Messenger as well as honor, respect, and glorify Him in the morning and the evening. Those who pledge their allegiance to you pledge allegiance to Allah. Allah`s hand is over their hands. Those who break their pledge only break it against themselves. But as for those who fulfill the contract they have made with Allah, We will give them an immense reward. (Surat al-Fath: 8-10)
@The NORTH I’ve read the Quran several times I even learned Arabic grammar to read in Arabic and I’m telling you there is not ONE verse where Allah says follow the messenger or prophet only thing Allah says is OBEY the messenger. Which doesn’t mean make up hadith and attribute them to our prophet Muhammad but obey anyone who carries/brings you a message/concept of Islam. Allah is very precise in his wording not like us as humans where we use words interchangeably
Dear friends, these outward signs, these traditions of men, cannot make you right with God. He is concerned with your purity. His standards are 100% perfection. I don’t come close. You don’t come close. We need a Saviour who will stand in our place and offer us his perfect righteousness as a gift. We need Jesus. Please turn to him while you may.
God bless you in your search.
Thats false.
Hi Ahmed,
Which bit is false? Are you 100% pure? I know I’m not. But God is. So how can I ever be accepted by him? Not by anything I do.
God offers me salvation, to be made pure by him, not by any works I do. That’s the best news ever. That’s the gospel. It’s too good to dismiss it without carefully examining the case for Christ.
Why not do that? There’s a very short book called The Case For Easter. You could probably read it in half a day or less. But it could change your life and your eternity. Be blessed.
@@markpibworth2604 When did ANY Muslim advertise being 100% pure? That's literally a strawman. I don't have to be pure for God's love and forgiveness and grace to accept me as so long as I try. In Islam, God's mercy is what saves us. But an evildoer who does evil deeds and purposefully doesn't do good works isn't showing faith at all, hence doesn't deserve to be saved. i.e. Good works are crucial, but we aren't working our way into heaven, ultimately its God's grace and mercy.
Likewise
1+1+1=1??? No thanks, i still have 2 neurons alive in my brain.
allah and mommmed are both confused