Courage Under Fire: ASP Shehrbano Naqvi on the Punjab College Incident and Controversy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @Tasmiavoice
    @Tasmiavoice Місяць тому +5

    It must be admitted that the police did not handle the situation properly but made the whole matter worse as USUAL 🙄

    • @sheerazgill7300
      @sheerazgill7300 Місяць тому

      Don't you think UK has a better investigation agencies, Law & Order situation and Police Accountability than Pakistan?? When they can't handle a misinformation scenario in their country, how can Pakistani Police can while we are a developing country lagging far behind than UK and it's investigation agencies. The point is, these days, social media have is a disaster when its not controlled well.

    • @Tasmiavoice
      @Tasmiavoice Місяць тому

      @@sheerazgill7300 In the UK, the specific event you're referring to involved people from different religions, and the issue revolved around discrimination and hate, which offended various groups. However, in the Lahore PGC incident, it's a completely different scenario. It's not about social hate but rather about students, just 15-16-year-old kids, protesting against the authorities and government for mishandling the situation. Instead of addressing their concerns, you are hitting them with sticks and using tear gas on them. The students are frustrated because key details, like CCTV footage, have not been made clear, and there are conflicting statements from the principal, teachers, and even government ministers. This lack of transparency is what's fueling the unrest.

    • @sheerazgill7300
      @sheerazgill7300 Місяць тому

      @@Tasmiavoice The point is, issue Originated from misinformation on social media... isn't it?

    • @Tasmiavoice
      @Tasmiavoice Місяць тому

      @@sheerazgill7300 If this was truly misinformation, then it was still mishandled by authorities. By not addressing students' concerns early on, they allowed frustrations to build and push students to social media. If they'd listened and clarified from the start, things may not have escalated. Just my view-respect yours too!

    • @sheerazgill7300
      @sheerazgill7300 Місяць тому

      @@Tasmiavoice I think we can't predict at that time if this is Being done accurately or not. Like Education Minister tried to control the mob by ensuring them if this one is a true incident, we will accountable them(Pgc Authorities). Now here the misinformation spread out, Education Minister took Students Side at that time and Our Social Media Activist highlighted perfectly that see, CCTV videos are deleted and the education minister has confirmed it. Now apart from it, I give you a very simple example. We all have our lives, everyone owns one life, right. We make many decisions for ourselves, but do all these decisions go in the perfect direction? No, they don't. But when we were taking the decision, we thought this specific decision is the perfect one. So, If Education Minister didn't came there at that time, perhaps the students had burnt the whole campus building and maybe many public buildings too. So, I think at that time, taking their native to calm them down, was the best thing. Now, the media has the responsibility and the students too that they should access the Parents of that girl and try to take their narrative.

  • @AizazAtif
    @AizazAtif Місяць тому +1

    This country is grappling with the repercussions of power struggles among various intelligence created factions and the coercive tactics they deploy to dominate one another. A case in point is Punjab College where fee hikes and other disputes reveal underlying clashes between sectors, one wielding greater influence over the other. These conflicts serve as tacit messages to management akin to orchestrated incidents like the attack on a police station or the assault on lawyers at PIC. Each incident appears meticulously staged to assert dominance and manipulate public perception. Honest police officers are disillusioned, weary of a synthetic and deeply entrenched crime industry that seems impervious to dismantling an endless unwinnable game.

  • @KomalNoman
    @KomalNoman Місяць тому +1

    Come on topic

  • @Honda-_Zone
    @Honda-_Zone Місяць тому +3

    Madam sahiba saboot talash karna aap ka kaam hy nak students ka, aap kis maraz ki dwa hy

    • @sheerazgill7300
      @sheerazgill7300 Місяць тому +1

      Us ny clearly bola haii k joh saboot hmary pas hein unk according koi Rape hua hi haii... Toh Police kahan sy Saboot ly k aaaye? AI sy generate krly?? Obviously un sy hi maangy gi nah joh iss sb k bawjood keh rhy hein k Hmaary pas Saboot hein (mera mtlb students hein). Jb unko bola jata hai k hamein saboot handover kr dein, woh aagy sy screenshots bhej dety hein Instagram Accounts aur Chats k, k hamein yahan sy pta chala...! So are these proofs?

    • @Honda-_Zone
      @Honda-_Zone Місяць тому +1

      Seedhi c bat hy lrki k test krvai r test report dikhai but aisia q kry gi gi Madam, cover kon kry ga, crime report ka to yhi kaam hota hy chupai gai saboot ko dhoondh nikalna, Etny sary students jhoot bool rhy hain kia

  • @NidaNadir-w4x
    @NidaNadir-w4x Місяць тому +1

    Stop stop what she said,??kissi ko samajh aii 😢?ho through 7:46 private school 😢😢😢😢sharam ani chahiya sawal ya banta hy k govrt school kiyon nahin???

  • @Joana-k4v
    @Joana-k4v Місяць тому

    To perform in smelly society, very difficult

  • @sairaafridi8846
    @sairaafridi8846 Місяць тому +2

    Madam miss information kiu hui? Punjab police agar shuro din se clear kar deti to itne bache mar na khate. Madam apka khayal hai ke koi saboot lay ke ap ke pas aye ga aur taqatwar usko chor den gay . Ap ne aaj tak kisi taqwar ko jail ke peche dekha hai oun sab ke peache kisi taqatwar ka hath hota hai sirf ghareeb ki takar agar ameer se ho jaye to ghareeb har jata hai ap jasay log khamosh kiu ke ap bhi oun se lar nahi sakti. Farz karen malik ke baty ne kuch kiya kya ap giraftar kar len ge? Ap sirf itna kar den duniya news ke malik ko kehen ke tv pe a kar jaldi act na karne ki mafi mang len.

    • @sheerazgill7300
      @sheerazgill7300 Місяць тому

      Saboot hein hi naii toh koi laaye ga kesy?? Students keh rhy hein k hmaary pas saboot hein, jb un sy saboot maangy jaty hein toh aagy sy Screenshots share krty hein Facebook/Instagram accounts k jinho ny misinformation di... Don't you think ik Batch ki 30-50 students ki strength hoti haii, agr apk batch k kisi student k sath aysa incident ho, apko Atleast uska name toh pta hota haii, apko usk parents ka tob pta hota haii .. Lekin kisi student k pas koi information hi naii haii..! Joh log keh rhy hein k yeh Fake Parents hein job Screen py aaye, toh bae Students unk Real Parents k pas chaly jayein... Woh Saaary Lawyers joh iss sb ko support krrhy hein, Lawyers Parents k pas kyu naii chaly jaaaty? Lawyers kyu nai jaaaty?