🛑 Stop a Bad Marriage Before It’s Too Late: Dr. Sidharth Arora’s Take on Atul Subhash's Case!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 76

  • @upscunstoppables
    @upscunstoppables  Місяць тому +1

    🎯Free 9 Months of Subs on purchase of 9 Months of subs + Flat 50% off: unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=SIDLIVE
    For 9 Months: Free 9 Month Extensions
    For 12 Months: Free 12 Month Extensions
    For 18 Months: Free 18 Month Extensions
    Offer Ends on 23rd Dec! Don’t miss!

  • @UNIVERS_02
    @UNIVERS_02 Місяць тому +12

    Sir please continue Laxmikant series
    Please please it is very helpful for us 😢😢 Request 😢😢 please
    Try to understand our situation 😔😔

  • @anasimam7757
    @anasimam7757 Місяць тому +11

    BEFORE MARRIAGE --- AGREEMENT TO BE SIGNED ABOUT DOWRY ( WHETHER TAKEN OR NOT, IF TAKEN THEN HOW MUCH ) ,
    • SELF ATTESTED DECLARATION ABOUT THE STREEDHAN BY BRIDE INFRONT OF LAWYER THROUGH AFFIDAVIT. THIRD IS MARRY THOSE WOMAN WHO IS EMPLOYED AND LET HER DO JOB EVEN AFTER MARRIAGE SO THAT IF SHE DEMAND ALIMONY, THEN IT COULD BE WAY LESS FIX BY COURT THAN WHT COULD BE DEMANDED

    • @rockybalboa1958
      @rockybalboa1958 Місяць тому

      Your comment is better than entire video

    • @priyanshoosingh4299
      @priyanshoosingh4299 Місяць тому +1

      No bro court kahega ki ye aggreement ek raddi copy hai only if girl say something it's always true rather than what is

    • @harshtripathi2287
      @harshtripathi2287 Місяць тому

      Your solution is a good one but i believe it's just a mere fairytale.
      Imagine why will a theif declare himself as a thief??
      We already have a dowry prevention act to counter everything. Signing the agreement will put the taker in jeopardy.

  • @dipanshjain
    @dipanshjain Місяць тому +4

    I think there should be strong examples set against the misuse of the mentioned sections and laws by giving heavy punishments to women filing frivolous cases. Simultaneously, the burden of proof should be prudentially reassigned without prejudice and presumption of women's innocence and men's guilt.

  • @samareshpanda6009
    @samareshpanda6009 Місяць тому +3

    Lower court should be responsible to implement these laws and say no to corruption in lower court. Every state's high court could be monitor about the judgement of lower court with independent committee of retire judges . IF any party want to change the judge in lower court , then high court shall be granted permission after checking proper evidence .

  • @FineArtist-bq6rt
    @FineArtist-bq6rt Місяць тому +3

    No Marriage= Sukoon 🙏🙏

  • @nalinirastogi7
    @nalinirastogi7 Місяць тому +4

    Law should be implemented fairly . Women who r misusing should understand that they r very wrong. The executives should be fair and honest so that women cannot misuse these laws. These laws are for protection not to exploit . Solution right now is only to change mentality of women who misuse these because its very hard as u said to prove innocence of a honest man .

  • @p16r18
    @p16r18 Місяць тому +2

    Not only in this case, in any case both party should go through polygraphy test, justice should be given with in hours.
    Specially when the accused have no proof to prove, it's not his fault, should demand polygraphy test.

  • @BharatRay-x3w
    @BharatRay-x3w Місяць тому +2

    Thank you so much sir... for awesome discussion❤❤

  • @SATYENDRAVISHWAKARMA-n7t
    @SATYENDRAVISHWAKARMA-n7t Місяць тому +2

    for immediate solution we should sign a legal document protecting the interest of both the parties and in long run we should add this kind of case studies in the syllabus of Academics.
    Thankyou sir.

  • @Ritika-o7s9f
    @Ritika-o7s9f Місяць тому +5

    for Issues relating to alimony .......A maximum limit should be set

  • @kritika6012
    @kritika6012 Місяць тому +1

    Sir as you always say " laws should be written and clear" similarly, terms in legislation like
    "Satridhan" etc should be written clear + better implementation of these laws + double penalty on false cases + awareness among people + awareness among educated youth ( special point )
    Thank you sir

  • @madhavdondapati7594
    @madhavdondapati7594 Місяць тому +1

    Bringing laws doesnt matter unless law is better implemted, more important is to consult every stakeholders to overcome challenges &everyone needs to work on nation building then everything takes backstep from corruption to misuse of power-everything!!

  • @himaandagar
    @himaandagar Місяць тому

    1. Anticipatory bail
    2. No alimony if women have a job that can support herself
    3. Separate joint fund for the kids' education and health (contribution from the spouse that doesn't have the custody of the kids, which are generally father)
    4. If Siblings and extended relatives are not the residents of the same house the victims lives in marriage then they cannot be accused of harassment and cruelty.
    5. No discretion of females in choosing the court in which divorce case will be fought

  • @k.k.1273
    @k.k.1273 Місяць тому +1

    Yes sir, even in today's modern society, it is very important for women to have security, as they are still not far from being in a vulnerable situation, especially at the grassroots level. For marriage to function as an institution, certain key terms should be defined in women-centric laws, such as "Stridhan," and to prevent its misuse, strict clauses can be added in cases of misuse. The government can legalize prenuptial agreements and these agreements can be given weight in divorce proceedings.

  • @Keshav-s1
    @Keshav-s1 Місяць тому +1

    1. Good Suggestion for ALIMONY - If the woman do 2nd marriage after divorced, then it should be stop/cancel with an Immediate effect of 2nd marriage date. Alimony should be given untill/unlessl the woman get married after divorce and even accordingly her maintenance only not muh mangi. (DECISION FACTOR - calculate her maintenance before marriage and mention in affidavit. & If the consequences made in future multiply with that accordingly or just 1.5times of it only.)
    2. DOWRY - Pre Evidences (gift,stridhan,etc..) clearly mentioned in an affidavit with both party content.
    3. COUNCELLING - A complete all possibilities of afterwards situations discuss among both parties.

  • @siddhantsharma1059
    @siddhantsharma1059 Місяць тому +1

    Always excellent explain sir.

  • @bhaskarkumar6423
    @bhaskarkumar6423 Місяць тому +1

    Provided how difficult is to prove yourself innocent in these cases, we can provide detterance that can stop from filing false cases. Like if a women files false case and the other party is able to prove that case filed is false, that women should be punished with same penalty as that man would have been punished if case was right

  • @vaishnavichopade4787
    @vaishnavichopade4787 Місяць тому

    Sir generally in our education we didn't study about the social institution like marriage so basically we should aware about that marriage is not a business it's an social institution where two people spend their life happily ever with each other support . Today's we have legal provisions for bad marriages but we didn't have pre preparation for good n happy healthy marriage which came from the awareness by concerning about why we should accept such marriage institutions and awareness come by including such values are norms in our family n education too where we should teach our future generations not about just gender discrimination but the see everyone with an eye of humanity.i think marriage is very important institution than everything other because this makes you feel complete and give strength for doing professional work too

  • @nppatel978
    @nppatel978 Місяць тому

    TRIBALS are more progressive in terms of marriage ,so we should look after that customs

  • @Had-ShAke
    @Had-ShAke Місяць тому +1

    Very nice class sir

  • @PriyaAgarwal-e5x
    @PriyaAgarwal-e5x Місяць тому

    The effort should be :
    1) set up an neutral and independent holistic assessment committee for the need of gender neutral law and the impact of existing law
    2) social awareness should be for formal marriage
    3) judiciary role for proper guidelines under article 142 is also needed

  • @SV010-p5t
    @SV010-p5t Місяць тому +1

    Just include provisions of punishment along with legal compensation if the party filling the petition comes out to be falsely accused. It's happening not because of the gender centric laws, but, due to too much access to legal power without any responsibility. Men don't have issue with women centric laws, men have issue with the non- gender neutrality of the provisions.
    Hold the women accountable, and, everything will be fine

  • @Life_of_officer
    @Life_of_officer Місяць тому

    Sir i think it would be not impossible but difficult for people who abuse law, if administrative and judicial mechanism becomes more vigilant.
    Especially police and lawyers. As Supreme Court took measures to stop false PIL ,something kind of this must be done for abuse of women centric laws. I
    It is very necessary for other laws also like rape,molestation etc. The abuse of these laws not only harms men but also halts women from seeking justice who actually suffered in life.
    To address this issue is equally important for both men and women.
    It's new Era It's high time now to give relief to men from unnecessary pressure. They are also human being and do have emotions. 🤲

  • @Fantasticnews-de1gt
    @Fantasticnews-de1gt Місяць тому

    Solution for this case
    No.1. Photography of all gifts whose knows stridhan.
    No.2. On marriage time compulsory required fews man and woman for witness
    Like as Muslims ' marriage
    No.3. After marriage one a legal written document by bride for stridhan

  • @DHarish818
    @DHarish818 Місяць тому +2

    Sir please continue the laxmikant series

  • @KshitijRai53
    @KshitijRai53 Місяць тому +1

    Sir you all have wide and huge Sources for to raise voice for men like you all did in Coaching flood matter. Otherwise noobs are just busy in Constitution and Politics untill this problem became problem of them too.

  • @charusharma5361
    @charusharma5361 Місяць тому

    In the case of alimony - husband ki monthly income and uski current financial condition ko perameter bnana chahiye or reasonable alimony honi chahiye
    And.....in the case of stridhan sadi se phle ya turant baad atleast jewellery and property ke legal documents ko lekar rule hona chahiye....to us document me jitna stridhan include ho ....
    And। Agar wife ki job hai to us case me alimony minimum honi chahiye.......

  • @AbhishekKumar-qt2iv
    @AbhishekKumar-qt2iv Місяць тому +3

    Sir i think iska solution yay hai ki iske liye ek alag police station hona chahiye jha pr kayol marriage related hi case ko dekha jaye ground level se unke aas pass k log ko pta hota h ki glt kon hai aur inke ghr m kaisa chal raha ya phir dono log k baat sun kar phle investigation ho uske baad hi court m judge k pass jaye aur women ko bhi aise case glt hone p koi bda saja dene k law hona chahiye jisse ki unhe bhi dar bna rahe ki aisa krna glt .

    • @prasadsolanke1219
      @prasadsolanke1219 Місяць тому +1

      @@AbhishekKumar-qt2iv what if investigating officer is corrupt? ( Truth is kalyug is evil; you cannot eradicate the evil which lies in humans (not all).

  • @rockybalboa1958
    @rockybalboa1958 Місяць тому

    Alimony and maintenance should be only for dependent women and not for earning modern women. This law is misused by independent women

  • @soumyadeepghosh8776
    @soumyadeepghosh8776 Місяць тому

    Corruption is the main issue. We need independent organisation to act on corrupt judges like cases of Mr Atul. Its nearly impossible to proof a judge is corrupt, they have no fear. This independent organisation will act like IB to identify corruption in the Judiciary system.

    • @soumyadeepghosh8776
      @soumyadeepghosh8776 Місяць тому

      That organisation can also be corrupted but atleast people can complain outside Judiciary. There's a reason why people avoid court cases. Its not like they afraid of anything but the harrasment is real.

  • @IASaspairant
    @IASaspairant Місяць тому +1

    Sidharth Sir. Aap ke wife bahat khubsurat hain 😊❤

  • @ANCHALSINGH-kw6py
    @ANCHALSINGH-kw6py Місяць тому +1

    dont remove the law but make sure women should not deside alimony it should be desided by court as per the aay certificat and property of man and parents of man before marry to the girl. because she should not marry to king or rular she should marry to a man.

  • @sciencetech2115
    @sciencetech2115 Місяць тому +2

    Mujhe koi aisi chahiye jo mujhe paal posh ske🙂🙂... Mere liye wahi good h ....

  • @RADHEFITNESS27
    @RADHEFITNESS27 Місяць тому

    Sir jii polity ki videos continue kro plzz

  • @ShivamSingh-j7v
    @ShivamSingh-j7v Місяць тому +1

    I think sir there should be first ground level enquiry to cross checking k allegations sahi bhi hai ya nahi
    And education of women if she is qualified to earn then she can maintain herself if not so there should be maintenance
    In the court judge should listen both side of argument
    Last society should be intelligent to learn laws and should not have dowry and not cruel to any women

  • @parthaojha1
    @parthaojha1 Місяць тому +1

    My suggestion may sound funny but invoicing of marriage gifts ( Stree dhan ) should be there.
    Even dowry is a sort of black money for bride groom family 😄, no issue in keeping an official record !!
    Secondly, if wife can avail a fixed amount of alimony from husband no matter what his financial condition is then there should be provision of financial assistance to husband from wife, if she is educated, working or has a steady flow of income. But before such claims, husband should prove his bankruptcy as legitimate.
    Thirdly, there must be a reasonable justification for the claimed amount of alimony.
    Just imagine if even alimony amount is fixed before marriage. It can be a legal contract that wife will need that amount to justify here standards of living as it was before marriage in case couple splits in future.

  • @sagarbarik6966
    @sagarbarik6966 Місяць тому

    Sir please continue Laxmikant series

  • @Niveditaa_6
    @Niveditaa_6 Місяць тому +1

    Jai hind sir❤

  • @soumyadeepghosh8776
    @soumyadeepghosh8776 Місяць тому

    Misleading title. There is no solution.

  • @SatishYadav-ru8vb
    @SatishYadav-ru8vb Місяць тому +1

    Good evening sir ji 🙏 sir mera ek question hai agar wife' job me ho aur husband na ho us condition me agar divorce ho... to kya wife husband ko alimony Dengi?????

  • @princevegeta3751
    @princevegeta3751 Місяць тому

    I believe making prenup legal can fix so much.
    Just an Opinion 😊

  • @nasierali8331
    @nasierali8331 Місяць тому

    Sir when you are going to resume the m laxmikant revision series

  • @Dark_horse_no.1
    @Dark_horse_no.1 Місяць тому

    Streedhan ka affidavit lena jaruri hai...

  • @singhmanvendra9678
    @singhmanvendra9678 Місяць тому +1

    We want men commission

  • @NoSeal-Nodeal
    @NoSeal-Nodeal Місяць тому

    Salmon bhai fan - No marriage No problem

  • @mikkidrive8769
    @mikkidrive8769 Місяць тому

    Promote humanity........

  • @hyperindia
    @hyperindia Місяць тому +22

    Sir mai shadi nhi krunga kbhi

    • @himanshukashyap8325
      @himanshukashyap8325 Місяць тому

      Thoda bada ho ja bro ...

    • @hyperindia
      @hyperindia Місяць тому

      @himanshukashyap8325 21 ka hu 2025 1st attempt h

    • @himanshukashyap8325
      @himanshukashyap8325 Місяць тому +2

      @@hyperindia isliye hi keh rha hu ..thoda aur bada ho ja

    • @FC2plays
      @FC2plays Місяць тому

      Actually ​@@himanshukashyap8325

    • @AnonymousCitizen7
      @AnonymousCitizen7 Місяць тому +4

      @@hyperindia Sahi decision bhai
      Ye jo himanshu bhain hain inhe thoda aur bada hone do
      Fir wo tumse agree krenge

  • @champions8663
    @champions8663 Місяць тому +1

    logo ko boliye western culture chodiye or Bhagavat Gita padhiye 🙏

  • @Certifiedh
    @Certifiedh Місяць тому

    Steps to save us males:
    > Double the dowry
    > Don’t be mauga
    > Letting her meet her family only during festivals
    > if she is earning, let her pay for day to day household expenses
    > If she is not earning, just give her minimum money
    > Tell her to do pooja paath daily
    > 1 kutai per quarter

  • @priyanshoosingh4299
    @priyanshoosingh4299 Місяць тому

    Sir bas ek hi solution hai ki es kanoon me ek line aur add kar de ki if your allegation false the you punish by going to jail ifor 5 year