the vanishing of ethan carter Unreal Engine 3 vs 4 (PC)

petit comparatif de la mise a jour de the vanishing of ethan carter passant de unreal engine 3 a la version 4.
pas mal de petites améliorations notamment la gestion de la lumière, nouvelle anti crenelage (TAA: temporal anti aliasing) particulièrement très efficace face a du 4xMSAA voir meme 8x,MSAA en revanche etrange changement pour l'eau où les reflets ne sont en calcul en temps réel.
parametre graphique:
1080p/60fps
flou mouventent/motion blur: désactivé
profondeur de champ/depth of field: desactivé
materiel de test:
GTX 970
intel core i7 3770K
8Go ram
SSD 500Go

[@jussivalter]

UE3 looks way more natural and photorealistic in terms of nature: 2:25 I like UE3's color sciense also.

[@termozoid6248]

You can change that in both engines to you liking btw, so you can't reality compare color. I am sure you already now this, i am just saying.

[@magicschoolbus8417]

OW SHIET
UE3 IS MORE REALISTIC 4 ME

[@MrGuitarJockey]

TRINATRON STUDIOS Or maybe you just don’t know shit :)

[@enzoesposito952]

ue3 is cooler than ue4 but ue4 is more realistic

[@dissidentjv5887]

UE4 version has not planar reflection on water

[@blackprince1637]

@@dissidentjv5887 no it has. You are blind

[@leskroloko2025]

Tout a été fait sur l'Unreal au niveau luminosité ?

[@dissidentjv5887]

je comprend pas ta question, la luminosité de quoi ?

[@leskroloko2025]

Tout ce qui est lumière /ombre etc... ça a été fait sur l'unreal engine 4 directement ou avec un logiciel de rendu (genre vray)?

[@dissidentjv5887]

ah, ba je vois pas pourquoi il y aurait un autre logiciel pour fairer ca, c'est le moteur graphique qui fait tout, et pour ce jeu tout est déjà précalculé par Unreal

[@holymoly7118]

4 under-gammas the water to the point of tackiness

[@_yuuthz2141]

what name that song ??

[@anindyaroythetechmaster]

Unreal engine 3 doesn't show the sun effect on water

[@anindyaroythetechmaster]

I mean sun effect much

[@ssquarepants04]

bro for real. UE 3 looks more realistic.. UE 4 looks too cartoony for me

[@anonymouschristianbranch6572]

i'm slowly getting enough of unreal editor 3 crashes
you need to make the editor user friendlier
when it comes to saving packages the editor needs to make a duplicate of the original being left inside the original
and SLAP us in the face and crash the hell out of us out when we want to open a specific package
in the generic browser or not even boot up at all after making a fatal save upon a package
i want to call it not such a generous generic browser from now on
you see it ? fix or i leave
oow i see you don't even care when one l;eaves the scene aaw ok

[@gustsomeguywithamustachebu5067]

Unreal engine 2 looks better

[@omegafala720]

No

[@pwned2ice]

I understand there's a lot of love out there for UE3, but UE4 obviously looks better, although not by much. Mostly in lighting.

[@Beanibirb]

UE3 is also no longer being supported by Epic Games, UE4 forever!

[@Test-bi5nm]

No one needs programs to be supported, people managed to create Unreal Engine 3 based games many years ago with very old versions, so stop your bullshit

[@oozly9291]

Test Huh?

[@GamingTaylor]

At 1:22, UE3 looks way better than UE4

[@dissidentjv5887]

UE3 use planar reflection and UE4 cube map reflection

[@Gmodfan750]

except for the sun reflecting

[@Contagious946]

Unreal 4 has some ugly ass water

[@dissidentjv5887]

yes UE3 use planar reflection and UE4 use distant reflection volume, and the colors of the trees are more bland

[@darty367]

Hello, sais tu qu'elle est la différence entre ce que tu appels le planar reflection et le distant reflection volume ? Je trouve la version sous ue4 meilleur sous certains points mais l'eau par contre c'est vraiment dommage d'autant que ue4 gère aussi le planar reflection.

[@dissidentjv5887]

le Planar Reflection c'est le vrai reflet en temps réel et le Distant Reflection Volume ou Sphere Reflection Capture ou alors Local Reflection Volume (c'est un peu pareil) c'est compliqué a expliquer mais ca donne grossièrement une image en 2D dans une sphère ou cube.
regarde cette video a partir de 26:40
ua-cam.com/video/B0sM7ZU0Nwo/v-deo.html

[@marwintawerson7867]

now i want a comparaison with ue5

[@jackharpe3rd233]

As cool as this is, I am still waiting for Unreal 4 to blow me away. I haven't been impressed by it sence Hatred with it's house destruction physics and not much has wowed me sence. Instead they seem to be playing it safe. Destruction has been only used for fences, windows, doors, and pillars which has all ready been done with Gears of War and Killing Floor 2 on Unreal 3. And most of the lighting used her is kinda misleading. The use of lighting and reflection in 4 I recall seeing in Batman Arkham Knight at Max setting which too used 3 even though it's launch was broken on PC. Come on Epic Games, Wow me all ready!

[@secretyui2038]

Life is strange true colors is still running on ue4 in 2021 you should check it out

[@Okejka_b]

ue 3: realistic water. ue 4: genshin impact water 😂

[@benjaboscatto6540]

I don't know but I like the unreal engine 5 better

[@Mini-Mose]

J'aime bien la différence

[@holymoly7118]

3 looks much nicer in it's subtleties

[@iori7370]

3 looks garbage

[@zarasajjad3206]

Ue 3 is more realistic

[@tristan7950]

UE4 IS BETTER

[@dissidentjv5887]

For anti aliasing and performance yes, but for water, reflections, and colors, no. For the rest it's the same

[@Test-bi5nm]

@@dissidentjv5887 performance is worse as well.

[@johnny5805]

UE3 still looks better than Unity 5.

[@Test-bi5nm]

Well duh?

[@jussivalter]

How UE3 looks? Or how Unity 5 looks? Used both for games and I know how beautiful graphics using those tools can be produced. But I dont know how those looks. Maybe you meant UI?

[@peterslade3015]

Song ? Música ?

[@sdsbm]

Wonderful video

[@AndroidPukanov]

How i can license UE3?

[@dissidentjv5887]

it's on Steam

[@arinthorn9842]

your song so loud

[@bigbootylatina130]

It looks like bf3 vs bfv4