“It Was Someone She KNEW” The Shocking Truth Behind Claudia Lawrence's Murder

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 кві 2024
  • It's been 15 years since Claudia Lawrence disappeared - but after numerous appeals, arrests and searches, her body has never been found.
    Could there still be someone out there who knows what happened to the 35-year-old chef?
    Joining former Met detective Peter Bleksley in the latest episode of Crime Suspect is criminologist and author James Treadwell, journalist and author Neil Root, Steeple Times editor Matthew Steeples and former police inspector and visiting lecturer at Leeds Trinity University Martin Holleran.
    Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
    If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
    #crime #truecrime #peterbleksley #claudialawrence #talktv

КОМЕНТАРІ • 648

  • @ros9673
    @ros9673 Місяць тому +405

    Her poor father tried so hard to find the truth

    • @Elleking1812
      @Elleking1812 Місяць тому +44

      And her Mother.

    • @Felicity2121
      @Felicity2121 Місяць тому +5

      @@Elleking1812I thought her mother was still alive.

    • @sike44
      @sike44 Місяць тому +13

      A proper father, so sad.

    • @Elleking1812
      @Elleking1812 Місяць тому +22

      @@Felicity2121 Yes she is, but they BOTH tried so hard to find the truth and I'm sure her mother still is.

    • @JaniceKing-dy6wc
      @JaniceKing-dy6wc Місяць тому +4

      A lot of answers to be found in that pub!

  • @jenniferforde8203
    @jenniferforde8203 Місяць тому +169

    Claudia needs justice god bless her❤

    • @garysimpson3592
      @garysimpson3592 Місяць тому +9

      Hard to believe, none of her friends had more idea of her men connections. Maybe they are to scared too speak out. If she was very secretive then thats been her downfall.

  • @andymatthews9132
    @andymatthews9132 Місяць тому +146

    I firmly believe the answer to this case is very close to home.

    • @maxisussex
      @maxisussex Місяць тому +1

      You think the parents were involved?

    • @andymatthews9132
      @andymatthews9132 Місяць тому +15

      Definitely not! I meant the answer to who did this is in that area. The police didn't need to cast their net wide. I believe the answer still lies near her house.

    • @melanieah5501
      @melanieah5501 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@andymatthews9132a serial killer has been likened to the cctv images and is left-handed but just a theory.

    • @techtitanuk5609
      @techtitanuk5609 Місяць тому

      Who haliway? ​@@melanieah5501

    • @kayoss8787
      @kayoss8787 Місяць тому +8

      Statistically it’s very likely it’s someone she knew. Unfortunately everyone wants a dramatic answer like a serial killer or human trafficking… usually the reality is more mundane.
      Normally timelines are very clear even with gaps. But the simple fact that it’s unclear i think whatever reason She may have stayed at someone’s house. Someone from around the corner from work.

  • @juliahill7732
    @juliahill7732 Місяць тому +206

    I hope her family gets answers soon. I cannot imagine not knowing where your loved one is. 💔

  • @pommiebears
    @pommiebears Місяць тому +217

    Peter Lawrence tried so hard to find his baby girl. I don’t know if heaven exists or not, either way, Peter is with his daughter now, or at least out of pain. RIP to Peter and Claudia 🌹

    • @fullspeedaheadbarcelona6502
      @fullspeedaheadbarcelona6502 Місяць тому +22

      There is something after we depart this life I’m certain of it.

    • @jds8863
      @jds8863 Місяць тому

      ​@@fullspeedaheadbarcelona6502yes a wooden box we call home for eternity

    • @beaulieuc8910
      @beaulieuc8910 Місяць тому +8

      she was in a her 30s not a baby girl, that is infantising grown women, there is no heaven

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +2

      Missing?

    • @markbellew4194
      @markbellew4194 Місяць тому +6

      She was an escort

  • @shirleystein6521
    @shirleystein6521 Місяць тому +179

    I really hope that the truth comes out.

  • @Rob-ke2hu
    @Rob-ke2hu Місяць тому +140

    Who was making threats and why, this should have been elaborated on.

    • @StuartHanson-fo7iw
      @StuartHanson-fo7iw Місяць тому +33

      It was threats regarding married man she’d known I do recall

    • @pallasathena1369
      @pallasathena1369 Місяць тому +25

      ​@@StuartHanson-fo7iwyes, if she had been with several then all the more reason why noone will speak.
      Have a male in our town who has aged out on messing around with several married and single women, I doubt anyone would care much if he disappeared.
      Sad testament of consequences.
      See too much of this these days.

    • @patriciasimpson7020
      @patriciasimpson7020 Місяць тому +11

      Of course it should have been. And I'm honestly baffled as to why this happened and as to how nobody faced any repercussions for doing this. I just do not understand, the case doesn't involve high end criminality. It isn't about drugs, guns or gangs or anything like that. The journalists that came to talk with people were just regular journalists reporting on a story asking people routine questions as expected, not Donal MacIntyre.
      So for anyone to then threaten a journalist for a case like this is seriously suspicious, even more so than the footage of the man near Claudia's house who may or may not have had something to do with her disappearance. I also don't get how they got away with threatening them either as if the journalists had backing and support from the police then there's no reason why they couldn't, wouldn't jump on these incidents to round up even more suspects straight away, other than being complete f**kin' idiots.
      I'm absolutely flabbergasted!😦 If those journalists did report these encounters then the individuals who were intimidating should have been arrested literally the following day as there's no justifiable reason for any of them to have behaved this way. There is the possibility that those people just don't like talking to journalists but for case's such as this even those kinds of people would still try to help as much as they could. And as the police didn't look into this I'm left with no other choice than entertaining the actual possibility that they had something to do with Claudia's murder/abduction themselves.
      I kind of do understand now why wild theories were shooting around such as Claudia possibly being trafficked. If this is how people behaved I'm surprised the idea hasn't been raised that this case is some big conspiracy where the whole town's involved.

    • @LouiseSmith-sh6mo
      @LouiseSmith-sh6mo Місяць тому +1

      Usually it’s the towns local folk not posh or middle class like she was she was nvolved with people that were involved with drugs ext …. That’s it it’s going on in my town now re a drug dealer who went missing if u know u know

    • @Savingdea
      @Savingdea Місяць тому +2

      That is an understatement when the wives found out she was not a popular woman.

  • @AntonHoward-mx9sb
    @AntonHoward-mx9sb Місяць тому +126

    The Len Goodman of British crime

  • @LizaFergison
    @LizaFergison Місяць тому +104

    Her poor father suffered so much. I hope they are reunited in Heaven.
    I don't believed she was trafficked.

    • @halfbakedproductions7887
      @halfbakedproductions7887 Місяць тому +10

      I believe she was walking to work as normal and was picked up by someone she knew. Whether that person offered to give her a lift to work then took her elsewhere, or whether the journey was normal and unremarkable then perhaps an argument occurred, is something we'll probably never know.

    • @Felicity2121
      @Felicity2121 Місяць тому +11

      Wouldn’t she be too old to traffic?

    • @lulubelle24
      @lulubelle24 Місяць тому +9

      ​@halfbakedproductions7887 A woman matching her description, was seen having what looked like an argument with a man on the bridge.

    • @lulubelle24
      @lulubelle24 Місяць тому +14

      I think her private life caught up with her.
      She was known for hooking up with married men.

    • @maxbluenose25
      @maxbluenose25 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@halfbakedproductions7887.you think what you want the police have already looked into that if that was the case the police would of solved that stays away Claudia was woman who slept with married men there's going to be a lot of enemies I've got no sympathy for her it's her parents I felt sorry for as they had no idea what there daughter was like

  • @paulmoore120
    @paulmoore120 Місяць тому +107

    Peter shouldn’t be wasting his time on TV. he should be running the Met.

    • @maymalone1505
      @maymalone1505 Місяць тому +12

      He would lose his independence if that happened 😮

    • @looney7022
      @looney7022 Місяць тому +6

      Wrong sex, race and gender unfortunately

    • @sarabrittlegill9587
      @sarabrittlegill9587 Місяць тому +1

      @@looney7022 Sir Mark Rowley is the current commissioner. Middle Aged white male. What’s your point?

    • @christinewigley2206
      @christinewigley2206 Місяць тому +6

      I must Admit I agree 💯💯Peter would be brilliant.

  • @madeleinealdridge1788
    @madeleinealdridge1788 Місяць тому +52

    I feel so bad that her dad passed away never knowing what happened to his child. Someone knows what happened, and I hope somebody does the right thing and tells her mum

    • @skygazer6898
      @skygazer6898 Місяць тому +6

      Same for many other parents who never get answers. look at Suzie Lampugh, her parents never got answers. It is very sad! Somone, somewhere knows who is responsible or has an inkling who did it. Popular lady, who knew lots of people, someone she trusted probably did it.

    • @odoggow8157
      @odoggow8157 Місяць тому +2

      Non of U feel bad when U make fathers go through this by the million with living son's and daughters. Single mothers have made our streets a danger to all young ppl

    • @jesclifford88
      @jesclifford88 Місяць тому +4

      @@odoggow8157just disregarding all the deadbeat dads that don’t want to bother being a parent…ok.

  • @lesliephillpott8989
    @lesliephillpott8989 Місяць тому +28

    I felt so sorry for her dad, he looked absolutely broken. RIP

  • @silversteel6312
    @silversteel6312 Місяць тому +64

    How the family get through the day and sleep through the night must be an immense challenge. We should pray for Claudia and her family 🙏

    • @wallybingbang4350
      @wallybingbang4350 Місяць тому +9

      There is nothing worse than losing a child 😱

  • @pretentiousnetname
    @pretentiousnetname Місяць тому +100

    Fantastic format, superbly executed. Bring Matthew Steeples in more - he made a highly pertinent point concerning the possible double standards 'distractions' in this case and I was keen to hear more.

    • @mjs2781
      @mjs2781 Місяць тому +15

      Thank you. I enjoyed the show and learning about this sad case was fascinating. I hope justice is done for the family.

    • @Marigold502
      @Marigold502 Місяць тому +2

      Pretentiousnetname
      I second that!

  • @angelamary9493
    @angelamary9493 Місяць тому +71

    Very sad ...

  • @Yoohooyooohoooo
    @Yoohooyooohoooo Місяць тому +55

    The way they’re talking so strongly about witness protection, this sounds to me like they’re directing this at someone in particular. They know exactly who they want to talk.

    • @jjr1728
      @jjr1728 Місяць тому +7

      UK has long relocated witsec to Canada and occasionally Australia. Family adjustments are hard.

    • @Yoohooyooohoooo
      @Yoohooyooohoooo Місяць тому +3

      @@jjr1728 very hard, indeed. I couldn’t imagine having to do that.

    • @joeanna1100
      @joeanna1100 Місяць тому

      beth horwell watch tri lambda delta

  • @be_a_bright_sparkle3687
    @be_a_bright_sparkle3687 Місяць тому +106

    It took the police too long to act. Her Dad fought tirelessly for justice.

    • @MikeEves
      @MikeEves Місяць тому +11

      Yes, the police are always slow to react. Yet come at a moments notice if a corporation is unhappy about something.

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +3

      She has a Sister?

    • @FaizaFarah-pj4dz
      @FaizaFarah-pj4dz Місяць тому +4

      ​@@irenedavo3768older sister

    • @melanieah5501
      @melanieah5501 Місяць тому +5

      ​@@MikeEvesso true. Police have double standards.

  • @sx8803
    @sx8803 Місяць тому +16

    I lived in York for 6 years and this case affected the whole city (it still does) Poor Claudia. The general consensus amongst people who live there (or atleast it was when i lived there) is that the police 100% know who it is however theres not enough evidence to prove it/prosecute and i firmly believe this… hope justice is served soon. Thinking of her family and friends 15 years on

  • @gordonjamieson861
    @gordonjamieson861 Місяць тому +53

    what a great show , these guys know whats wrong with the met and other forces .they should be asked to set up a department to make things change for the better

  • @Primrose37823
    @Primrose37823 Місяць тому +84

    Peter is entertaining. Glad to see more of him. Also agree with his opinions

    • @pommiebears
      @pommiebears Місяць тому +17

      His voice reminds me of my grandads. Old school London accent. I still have my accent here in Australia, and people ask me to say things lol. They seem to be enchanted by our accents in England.

    • @starwood213
      @starwood213 Місяць тому +6

      @@pommiebears We are. I love hearing different English accents. Perhaps reminds us oof our ancestral home. nI hope they solve this case for the sake of Claudia's family.

    • @mjs2781
      @mjs2781 Місяць тому +6

      Peter is an excellent presenter. I enjoy his style and attention to being fair-minded.

    • @TimelordUK
      @TimelordUK Місяць тому +4

      I love his style and presentation. I could listen to him all day

    • @thenorthernsoulmusicchanne8939
      @thenorthernsoulmusicchanne8939 Місяць тому +11

      Proper copper.

  • @AaronfromEngland1989
    @AaronfromEngland1989 Місяць тому +15

    Shame, loads of lunatics out there in every country.

  • @Muttey2024
    @Muttey2024 Місяць тому +37

    Just not enough evidence to force a conviction but the police know.

  • @DeeDerry
    @DeeDerry Місяць тому +47

    I always go back to this case hoping for an update...Hopefully one day 🙏🏽

  • @sharonowen
    @sharonowen Місяць тому +15

    I hope she is with her Dad , and that her body is found so she can be laid to rest for her Mother’s sake. Horrible situation for all involved.

  • @knockernorton120
    @knockernorton120 Місяць тому +13

    The Police will know what happened, just can’t prove it unfortunately.

  • @tstuart7333
    @tstuart7333 Місяць тому +37

    We always get our man! BS. WHAT HAPPENED TO THIS POOR GIRL???? There is NO such thing as disappearing into thin air. So so sad.

  • @jak9483
    @jak9483 Місяць тому +30

    Hi from the States. Crimes against Women here are getting so common and I thank you for covering these issues.

    • @skye8493
      @skye8493 Місяць тому +2

      liken Riley

  • @Stroopwaffe1
    @Stroopwaffe1 Місяць тому +55

    Its not acrime to have asecret life but it leaves you open to nefarious players.

    • @halfbakedproductions7887
      @halfbakedproductions7887 Місяць тому +9

      There were rumours that she was "selling herself", you could say (although the police have denied it). That's not a crime in itself.

    • @reajo622
      @reajo622 Місяць тому +1

      Don't believe that at all​@@halfbakedproductions7887

  • @josephinewills8647
    @josephinewills8647 Місяць тому +40

    Hope this Chat Will Help , 👌👍👏👏👏👏

    • @pommiebears
      @pommiebears Місяць тому +17

      I hope so too. Keep it relevant, so it doesn’t end up collecting dust like so many seem to. I still remember when Jason Swift went missing. I still wonder what happened to that poor kid.

  • @Emma-mk8jv
    @Emma-mk8jv Місяць тому +23

    I watch this case over the years as Claudia went missing the same week my daughter was born. Shes 15 now. I think of her parent's, her mum now, and all that time without their daughter.

  • @ros9673
    @ros9673 Місяць тому +90

    It's unbelievable that there has been no conviction. It's almost like either a feared family involved or, the police

    • @ruthcollins2841
      @ruthcollins2841 Місяць тому +17

      You can't "convict" any one who hasn't been found yet to be a suspect let alone the murderer!😡🤨👎

    • @user-sz8km9dy5v
      @user-sz8km9dy5v Місяць тому +6

      Rumours I love rumours 😩

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +4

      She has a Sister?

    • @indianastones6032
      @indianastones6032 Місяць тому +6

      Need evidence to convict people and not just go off feelings. You need to be objective and not subjective.

    • @odoggow8157
      @odoggow8157 Місяць тому

      Do U have any idea how hard it is to find out the facts when U are not there witnessing it. The police are not psychic.

  • @user-hy6cd4ik6k
    @user-hy6cd4ik6k Місяць тому +11

    Can't believe that some people are harbouring poss murderer

  • @IainFrame
    @IainFrame Місяць тому +16

    It's all about the motivation. The likelihood that someone would be randomly abducted and murdered is incredibly low. Claudia was almost certainly murdered for a reason. If she was living a modest life working as a chef in the university, she clearly wasn't involved directly in crime. I think it's unlikely to be organised crime, as there's no real motivation or significant culture of organised crime in York which she appears to be on the periphery of. It's way more likely to be a very personal crime e.g. having a relationship with someone who decided it was better if she was out of the picture permanently and meticulously planned her exit. Probably a married guy who exploited her by asking for caution and secrecy, so he wouldn't get caught playing away from home, thereby coaching her into not leaving a trail. Poor Claudia - I hope this case is solved and she gets justice.

  • @lynnesummers-noble5029
    @lynnesummers-noble5029 Місяць тому +6

    I'm very glad that the police haven't given up hope on finding out what happened to Claudia.

  • @Caz_2087
    @Caz_2087 Місяць тому +54

    When people make comments that no one should comment on her private life, its popostrus. Her private life activities is the only logical reason why she is no longer here. You cant find the answers without talking about that.

    • @AJ-zx8by
      @AJ-zx8by Місяць тому +5

      but you are playing into the perpetrators hands and doing their bidding for them. If you paint her character in a negative light you are thereby disputing whether she is a victim.

    • @Caz_2087
      @Caz_2087 Місяць тому +12

      @@AJ-zx8by How do we find who the perpetrator/s is then if we don't delve into her private life as to what connections she could of had 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️
      You obviously didn't read my comment in the context it's clearly written. Painting her negatively or judging her is not the same as sticking to that line of inquiry as it is the single most logical explanation.

    • @stopgotdamndeletingmycomme8642
      @stopgotdamndeletingmycomme8642 Місяць тому +1

      @@Caz_2087 trouble is now ppl r obsessed with being virtuous n victims n white knighting n offended over nothing that they cannot compute facts its all feee fees and stunning n brave lets clap ima good dog. They cannot see that open discussion on facts leads to evidence n leads. But theyll be quick enough to sit on a motorway for sake of ukraine or watverver the latest brain warshing is

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +2

      Did they take DNA from bedding?

    • @Caz_2087
      @Caz_2087 Місяць тому +7

      @@irenedavo3768 Probably not. Probably didn't do a whole lot of anything if most UK police bodge job murder inquiries are to go by.

  • @AngelaFoley-dg5fx
    @AngelaFoley-dg5fx Місяць тому +5

    How does a person disappear goes into a house and never leaves she has to be buried somewhere In that apartment or dismembered and flushed toilet..or in a trash bin ..or someone isn't being honest when she went missing

  • @bridgetmclaughlin6198
    @bridgetmclaughlin6198 Місяць тому +34

    It must be so heartbreaking for her mother. Hopefully she’ll be found and someone charged before her mother dies.

    • @odoggow8157
      @odoggow8157 Місяць тому

      U will never know why but U r what is wrong with the world.

    • @WeirdSalad101
      @WeirdSalad101 16 днів тому +2

      @@odoggow8157show your face if you’re so proud of your strange anti-women stance

  • @lulubelle24
    @lulubelle24 Місяць тому +19

    I remember this. The police and journalists should have never judged her, for her private life.

    • @ApostleOfZeus199
      @ApostleOfZeus199 Місяць тому

      They treat grooming gang victims the same way.

  • @lorrainereid5707
    @lorrainereid5707 Місяць тому +24

    someones knows ( apart from the perp) I hope they come forward

  • @user-sf8xb8wr1y
    @user-sf8xb8wr1y Місяць тому +11

    One of the chaps who she had an affair with has something to do with this, maybe she threatened to tell their wife, this happens in many affairs and destroys marriages, she became to much of a burden for him to bare, the crime will be solved one day.

  • @bertbox69
    @bertbox69 Місяць тому +50

    99.9% of the time it's someone who knows the victim. That's how they get their victims, it's not rocket science

    • @Lonely_Goat
      @Lonely_Goat Місяць тому +9

      It's 70%

    • @fetus2280
      @fetus2280 Місяць тому +4

      @@Lonely_Goat 78% is what I got out of the googles. But ya... we are Correct. Approx 70-80% are known.

    • @fetus2280
      @fetus2280 Місяць тому

      Wrong.

    • @Lonely_Goat
      @Lonely_Goat Місяць тому

      @@fetus2280 take every mass shooting in juts America and that is not 0.01% unless you are saying mass shooters like last Vegas shooter knew every person?

    • @bertbox69
      @bertbox69 Місяць тому +3

      @@fetus2280 are we really going to argue about percentages? It was an idiomatic expression to illustrate how often it's someone they know, not a statistic 🙄

  • @courtneysquill8843
    @courtneysquill8843 Місяць тому +11

    She wasn't necessarily murdered on her way to work. She last spoke to her mum circa 20.00 and was called by a work colleague to see if she wanted a lift the following morning. He also may have called upon her the evening before but he specifically avoided the route past her house the following day on his way to work. I found that odd because people change their minds about lifts.
    She never responded to a 9pm text from a friend and never opened the text that night or the following morning.
    Her hair tongs were missing and her work whites.
    What was odd is that she was due to meet her friend after 9pm in The Nags Head yet this friend never called her or went to her door to see where she was. The house was a few doors away.
    Another friend who worked behind the bar never went to check on her after her shift ended. And that I found odd.
    Two friends who never checked up on her that night and one was expecting to meet her. This friend said something interesting: 'I regret not giving more information to the police st the time'. That suggests that she may have known who she may have been meeting.
    It wasn't just her passport left but also her cards. If she left she would have taken a card in case she needed money to get a cab.
    Whatever occurred happened at her home.

    • @tonyworrall1962
      @tonyworrall1962 Місяць тому +5

      All very suspicious with her friends, something happened elsewhere and they know.

    • @courtneysquill8843
      @courtneysquill8843 Місяць тому +5

      @@tonyworrall1962 I agree. Two comments stuck with me:
      The blond one Suzie said:
      'I wish I had given more information to the police at the time..' and 'I'm a bad friend as I couldn't find her...:
      Jen said: 'I hope that whatever happened, she was dead before she hit the ground...'. Not many deaths like that... Being shot, being hung, being knocked off road, electrocuted... (Faulty wiring, missing hair tongs...) Drugs, drink, was there a drinking game... Fight club...
      Jen also said 'I had no idea it was going to play out like that...:. What did she mean by that.
      Both of them said odd statements. Neither phoned her or walked the few doorways to knock on her door after she failed to come to the pub. Jen was living with her and had a key! And runs a bar so could at quick tidy ups...
      Suzie fails to phone or text or call on her friend the night before but phones her dad early the next day to say something is wrong. You wouldn't phone that early. You'd wait till end of the day. She knew something had happened to her to call her dad so early the next morning.

    • @tonyworrall1962
      @tonyworrall1962 Місяць тому

      @courtneysquill8843 yes, all suspicious comments, remember the Welsh police officer that took over the case said, I know people close to her know more than they are saying.
      Sue obviously knew Claudia was at risk of harm to phone her dad on the Friday morning, was it someone dodgy she was dating or knew person or persons were after her.

    • @tonyworrall1962
      @tonyworrall1962 26 днів тому

      ​@i think the bit about meeting Claudia in the pub is b.s...sue knew Claudia had to be scared of someone and jen is probably involved in it.
      I think some news came to light in the days before Claudia went missing that really caused some sxxt with several people and they got together to deal with the problem. courtneysquill8843

  • @myrants5836
    @myrants5836 Місяць тому +33

    The police lost this case right from the beginning by being way too keen to protect her image to her family. They were also too keen to protect the image of the men she was or had affairs with. So much time has now passed and I doubt they will even find out what happened to her or who was responsible.

    • @halfbakedproductions7887
      @halfbakedproductions7887 Місяць тому +5

      I don't think the police are being completely honest about what she was probably doing. She certainly "got around" and there is a strong rumour that she was also "selling herself", despite the police avidly denying that. The talk of someone walking up and down her street while on the phone, seemingly taking directions to her place and her being surprised to see him... certainly might seem to add up. If it was someone she already knew then why would he need directions to her place and why would she be surprised to see him?
      Now, as a consenting adult "selling yourself" to other consenting adults isn't a crime in itself, but it can open you up to all kinds of danger.

    • @tonyworrall1962
      @tonyworrall1962 Місяць тому +3

      This would explain all the relationships and knowing dodgy men.

    • @alanbradley9621
      @alanbradley9621 Місяць тому

      ​@@tonyworrall1962Would this explain these oddballs hanging around back and front of her property. Would help if police etc would state if this is amateur escort work or similar going on.

  • @ka11am
    @ka11am Місяць тому +44

    I hope she gets justice

  • @paulleonard1862
    @paulleonard1862 Місяць тому +3

    'You have the right to remain watching.' Who thought that up 😂

  • @patriciahall2223
    @patriciahall2223 Місяць тому +24

    Heartbreaking beautiful young Lady God Bless her always .

    • @lindahawker110
      @lindahawker110 24 дні тому

      She was sleeping with a few married men she wasn't that beautiful was she

  • @interabang
    @interabang Місяць тому +8

    Because the public won't speak to journalists means nothing. I wouldn't for any reason speak to them.

  • @KentDonaldson
    @KentDonaldson Місяць тому +9

    I suspect there will be a vital breakthrough in the coming years.

  • @user-ul8ut6gt1r
    @user-ul8ut6gt1r Місяць тому +7

    Prostitutes don't get looked for when they go missing, they suspected poor Claudia was a marriage wrecker in that she had affairs with multiple married men. So in effect they treated her like a nobody like as if she was nothing. So didn't really look for answers.

  • @davidandrews8963
    @davidandrews8963 Місяць тому +6

    SHADES OF SUZY LAMPLUGH VERY SAD CAN'T EVEN BEGIN TO IMAGINE WHAT HER FAMILY HAVE BEEN THROUGH I REMEMBER WHEN THE POLICE OFFICIALLY ANNOUNCED THAT CLAUDIA WAS MISSING SOMEONE ON THAT WALK SHE TOOK NABBED HER AND MADE HER DISAPPEAR. REST IN PEACE PETER MAY JUSTICE BE SERVED 🌻

  • @erwinkunze4091
    @erwinkunze4091 Місяць тому +24

    Losing a loved one to street violent crime is a horrendous experience, especially when the perpetrator or perpetrators are still at large, you feel violated and impotent in many ways. On the 27th of December 2015, my then 21 year old son was murdered by knife outside a pub and the killer remains free, hasn’t been arrested yet.

    • @IainFrame
      @IainFrame Місяць тому +13

      How awful. I hope you get justice one day.

    • @piperj4978
      @piperj4978 Місяць тому +6

      oh my goodness, I'm so terribly sorry ❤

    • @1000paulineanne
      @1000paulineanne Місяць тому +3

      So sorry for your loss ❤

    • @littleboots9800
      @littleboots9800 Місяць тому +3

      I'm very sorry for your loss.

    • @melanieah5501
      @melanieah5501 Місяць тому +3

      Sorry to hear this. My dear son is 21-yrs old & a student in East London. He has had a few confrontations in a park & outside a nightclub. I always tell him to walk away from trouble.

  • @suzannep8371
    @suzannep8371 26 днів тому +1

    I’ve just tuned in and have to say that this presenter is amazing, he’s on the ball, shrewd and articulate

  • @georginabiggs7960
    @georginabiggs7960 Місяць тому +17

    My neighbour some years ago told me he climbed over his garden fence at 3 in the morning and nobody saw him - I said I guarantee someone saw you - someone always does.

  • @dudeyfeb88coach
    @dudeyfeb88coach Місяць тому +23

    This man is the most wholesome hill street blue type non lackey in uk history .

    • @pommiebears
      @pommiebears Місяць тому +8

      Blimey, my Mum used to watch that. I think 🤔 I can still hear the theme music. Remember Crown Court too? lol.

    • @fionagregory9147
      @fionagregory9147 Місяць тому +4

      ​@@pommiebearsI do.

    • @RichieRich1234RICH
      @RichieRich1234RICH Місяць тому +3

      Hill Street Blurs. Surely you mean Dixon of Dock Green.

    • @DaibhidhBhoAlba
      @DaibhidhBhoAlba Місяць тому

      There are scaffolding boards with more personality!

    • @RichieRich1234RICH
      @RichieRich1234RICH Місяць тому +5

      @@DaibhidhBhoAlba oh i think he'd have great anecdotes down the pub actually. In the days when the police were serious and professional and smart and they actually knew who the wrong ones were. We had a family friend who was a bobby in the 50s and he was a fascinating man. He be bamboozled at the type of recruits we have nowadays.

  • @JaniceKing-dy6wc
    @JaniceKing-dy6wc Місяць тому +3

    Sadly there is no such thing as a good cop these days! As they clearly demonstrate to us every week in London

  • @user-ig7pu5jh6e
    @user-ig7pu5jh6e Місяць тому +67

    Please stop judging this poor woman for her supposed life style. She is missing possibly deceased, say a prayer for her instead 🙏

    • @Caz_2087
      @Caz_2087 Місяць тому +12

      These comments make no sense. No one has to judge her chosen life style for it to still be so very relevant and critical that it's spoke about because that is the single only logical reason why she is no longer here.

    • @pooooornopigeon
      @pooooornopigeon Місяць тому +10

      Her lifestyle almost certainly is relevant to her disappearing. Prayer never worked for anyone.

    • @mjs2781
      @mjs2781 Місяць тому +9

      My sentiments exactly... If this had been a man, the attitude would have been quite different.

    • @Caz_2087
      @Caz_2087 Місяць тому +15

      @@mjs2781 Matthew, her chosen lifestyle SHOULD be talked about, not because it's any of our business or something to judge, far from it. Because it's the single logical reason why this poor woman is no longer here. If we don't speak about why she isn't here, we will never find the answer to what happened and by whom.

    • @TheSuperHarrygeorge
      @TheSuperHarrygeorge Місяць тому +9

      What is prayer going to do to resolve this ? Only Facts, Forensics and the back ground of the victim will solve the mystery of her disappearance .

  • @lindy5
    @lindy5 Місяць тому +4

    I hope they find Claudia. I used to start work early, so it's close to my heart. and I've had ex boyfriend stalkers previously. Someone on UA-cam did a tarot reading, as I followed her Claudia's path from home I saw a fairy garden. I didn't know it existed, so I had look around on Google. Online there were 3 clues the tarot lady mentioned. Bridge, Castle, snowflake. The garden is by a quiet bridge, there's a model castle, and a fairy house which looked like a snowflake above the door from a distance. I guess when you want to find out, even though people don't always believe in tarot etc, I always think to explore every possible avenue. I said a prayer for Claudia to ask her to try and contact someone who can communicate to help find her, or lead someone to where she is. God bless all the missing one's.

  • @tonyworrall1962
    @tonyworrall1962 Місяць тому +6

    For you to threaten people to keep their mouths shut, it must already be known to the people that you are a violent person, have a reputation locally.
    So, it could well be someone from the criminal community that is doing the threatening,
    Although I believe a lot of the silence is down to people not wanting to be stiched up for her disappearance.

  • @tenfold7493
    @tenfold7493 Місяць тому +11

    I go past her house all the time in Heworth York. Very nice area

  • @lizevans7645
    @lizevans7645 Місяць тому +12

    There's an amazing podcast series from BBC Sounds on her Mother's experience/story who was largely forgotten in the subsequent media coverage. She is still here and wants Claudia's house to go to good use. She also looked tirelessly.

    • @fionalchance3358
      @fionalchance3358 Місяць тому +1

      Would you know what the podcast is called? Thanks.

  • @StuartHanson-fo7iw
    @StuartHanson-fo7iw Місяць тому +16

    I’m convinced it was the creeper slinking around behind her street,either a recent ex or a fantasist with a crush from college or the pub,who else could it be?maybe simply a man who saw walking?

  • @elainebines6803
    @elainebines6803 Місяць тому +8

    Great guests

  • @yorkieterrier8868
    @yorkieterrier8868 Місяць тому +11

    Please look into the disappearance of Marsha Wray. Also in North Yorkshire in Starbeck/Knaresborough. Because she disappeared before the prevalence of CCTV and social media, in 1997 her case isn't so well known. I have am interested as 11 years before, I sold my house to Marsha and her husband.

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +1

      Wow!

    • @riabright2815
      @riabright2815 Місяць тому +1

      THAT should tell you everything.
      WHY the obsession with THIS case, when the hundreds of other "missing presumed murdered" people AND CHILDREN NEVER even make the media..............

  • @carmenpirotta9050
    @carmenpirotta9050 Місяць тому +12

    Her poor Mother x

  • @deborahdaniel6675
    @deborahdaniel6675 Місяць тому +18

    Poor love ❤️

  • @TK-ux5du
    @TK-ux5du Місяць тому +34

    Realistically, how many people would be willing to give up virtually their entire lives and go into witness protection, if the case didn't involve themselves or their loved ones directly? No matter how much help and support they would receive from the police and other agencies, I would assume hardly anyone. If they were offered millions to establish themselves in their new lives, then there would probably be a few more prepared to do it but that sort of money seems to be reserved for murderers and the like who get given new identities.

    • @user-xi1br6ur1q
      @user-xi1br6ur1q Місяць тому +8

      But could you live with yourself, or someone, knowing that they might have been the perpetrator? No way I could if I knew, living with a man who could murder or rape?

    • @TK-ux5du
      @TK-ux5du Місяць тому +12

      @user-xi1br6ur1q If you were living with them, then it would be in your best interest to report them and get out of that situation, but if it didn't impact you directly would you be willing to move cities and leave everything including family behind to help a stranger? If you would that's really admirable, but I think that, unfortunately, you're in the minority.

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +2

      @@TK-ux5dudid they take DNA from bedding?

    • @littleboots9800
      @littleboots9800 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@TK-ux5duI would. I couldn't live with myself, especially the thought that parents were desperately hoping to see justice before they died. Besides, if its necessary they will put you in Australia or somewhere like that and they find you a home, fix you up with a job, all expenses are covered. And most would only need that level of new life and identity if you were grassing up a criminal gang. In most cases just moving within the UK would be enough.
      I couldnt live with knowing I'm the one person standing inbetween a family recieving justice.

    • @jesclifford88
      @jesclifford88 Місяць тому

      @@littleboots9800or someone prominent like police, politicians and celebrities

  • @stuartwilcock8113
    @stuartwilcock8113 Місяць тому +5

    Terrible situation for the family

  • @craigorford9932
    @craigorford9932 Місяць тому +2

    I really hope Claudia’s family get answers soon,And a closure to this case

  • @gabrielletanner5339
    @gabrielletanner5339 Місяць тому +17

    That person whoever they may be, is still walking around amongst us, what else could they have done I think meantime...or an ex boyfriend..

  • @lw3646
    @lw3646 20 днів тому +1

    They always say when they have absolutely no leads they hope loyalties have changed, they are basically begging for help.

  • @lucysnowe3571
    @lucysnowe3571 Місяць тому +5

    Her brave mum..hope she gets some answers soon and finds some kind of peace xx

  • @joannacopley1227
    @joannacopley1227 29 днів тому +3

    That night she spoke to her mum, she even had a message that night but didnt get back to it, it was turned off the day after at dinner time, why as the police not managed to see where she was when she spoke to her mum (by tracking the phone also why can they not see where abouts it was turned off) they know someone turned it off and the battery didnt go. Her dad even kept the payments up on the house for all them years 😢

  • @leeorr9071
    @leeorr9071 Місяць тому +9

    So sad

  • @Stroopwaffe1
    @Stroopwaffe1 Місяць тому +23

    So sad , RIP Claudia, You will be found.

  • @doriswhyte1931
    @doriswhyte1931 Місяць тому +48

    Her 2 friends know a lot more than they’ve said. Dee

    • @fionabunker8756
      @fionabunker8756 Місяць тому +2

      Who are her two friends and why would you say that? do you think they could've had something to do with it or maybe she was having an affair.

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +1

      How about her Sister? What does she know?

    • @irenedavo3768
      @irenedavo3768 Місяць тому +1

      DNA on pillows?

    • @doriswhyte1931
      @doriswhyte1931 Місяць тому +7

      @@fionabunker8756 Suzie Cooper and Jen King. Dee

    • @juliebrooke6099
      @juliebrooke6099 Місяць тому +3

      @@irenedavo3768, her sister doesn’t even live in York. I don’t see how she would know anything.

  • @halfbakedproductions7887
    @halfbakedproductions7887 Місяць тому +5

    I think the police likely have a clear picture of what happened, but have been totally unable to make anything stick. My guess is the perpetrator(s) are known to the police already as part of the enquiry given how many men they spoke to - either the police haven't yet joined the dots, or haven't been fully able to based on the evidence or lack thereof.

  • @joeletaxi821
    @joeletaxi821 Місяць тому +5

    Is it possible that the man in the cctv wanted to get something from her house knowing she was not there?

  • @Klair777
    @Klair777 Місяць тому +10

    I really hope the police get to the bottom of this & lay Claudia to rest 🤞🏻

  • @dawnb3194
    @dawnb3194 Місяць тому +4

    I have always believed that Claudia is buried in someone’s garden or cellar, relatively locally, which would gel with views in this video that on the night of her disappearance she probably visited the house of someone she knew. (May have needed a reason to stop some information coming out?) ….. 💔

    • @tonyworrall1962
      @tonyworrall1962 Місяць тому

      I think information had recently come out about her that got her killed, caused a sxxt storm locally.

  • @darrensouthward1824
    @darrensouthward1824 Місяць тому +2

    So would love this case solving. Beautiful woman and sad for her dad and family..

  • @fullspeedaheadbarcelona6502
    @fullspeedaheadbarcelona6502 Місяць тому +4

    I wonder if we will ever find out what happened to her and who is responsible.

  • @pallasathena1369
    @pallasathena1369 Місяць тому +12

    This reminds the of the Bakewell Tart case - in that case a body was found but it all involved married men as suspects.
    Infidelity is behind a lot of murder.
    Wish more young ladies realised how dangeous it is.

  • @jc-246
    @jc-246 Місяць тому +2

    Her poor family but I'm so glad answers are closer. Her poor father campaigned so hard and let's be honest that is primarily why this case is still at the forefront due to the mother and father. I really hope they find her 🙏

  • @micknufc5011
    @micknufc5011 Місяць тому +5

    Surely they could of tracked her phone company to see who she was txting or ringing aswel someone must know something or heard something hope they find her or find out whats happened

  • @Sassypants_666
    @Sassypants_666 Місяць тому +44

    This case ALWAYS stuck with me. Whatever happened to her is such a mystery.

    • @Rick_Cleland
      @Rick_Cleland Місяць тому +6

      Same. 😔

    • @Sassypants_666
      @Sassypants_666 Місяць тому +8

      @@Rick_Cleland it’s so close to where I live too. My baby sister has just moved there. I could never shake this case. It’s too relatable and so mysterious. Young woman walks home from her local-completely disappears without a trace. Some cases really stick out for there element of mystery, but this one, I’ve never forgotten.

    • @Sassypants_666
      @Sassypants_666 Місяць тому +8

      @@Rick_Cleland can you imagine the paranoia of the family too? must be so awful knowing it’s someone she knew but not knowing who. Her killer is lucky this happened before the world turned into 1984 😅 Saying that he’d probably be having the time of his life in an all female prison playing the PlayStation till the end of his days 😂😂😂😭😭

    • @Rick_Cleland
      @Rick_Cleland Місяць тому +12

      @@Sassypants_666, Ironically enough, I was born in 1984, I don't recognise the world we live in anymore.

    • @Sassypants_666
      @Sassypants_666 Місяць тому +13

      @@Rick_Cleland I’m 1992 and can already feel that- it’s heading in an unsettling and dystopian direction. I think it’s crazy all the tech we have nowadays and people STILL get away with murder.

  • @alambyant
    @alambyant Місяць тому +15

    4 people plus the host is too many for a panel on such a short show.

    • @Randomequestrian-pm4hl
      @Randomequestrian-pm4hl Місяць тому +8

      I think each of the 4 guests would have made interesting and varied contributions, but the show should be longer - especially if one wishes to pique the public's interest, and hopefully elicit information that may help solve the case.

    • @alambyant
      @alambyant Місяць тому +7

      @@Randomequestrian-pm4hl Agreed.

    • @danielbolton6905
      @danielbolton6905 Місяць тому +10

      Yes show needs to be longer.

    • @karekarenz7683
      @karekarenz7683 Місяць тому +2

      @@Randomequestrian-pm4hl Yes, and the baddies at the end need to be more diverse. You could get the impression that all the crooks in the UK are white.

  • @redjacc7581
    @redjacc7581 Місяць тому +4

    If someone needs an identity changed to remain safe then she must have been mixed up with a gang or organisation, but the public are simply not being told anything of substance.

    • @tonyworrall1962
      @tonyworrall1962 Місяць тому +1

      If a witness needs to go into protection then she must of had a connection to very dodgy people or persons

  • @annettemoore7264
    @annettemoore7264 Місяць тому +4

    Maybe if anonymous reports where encouraged it would help, I understand that can cause havoc as well but surely after all this time any fake claims could be easily dismissed?

  • @999hireactionvehicles9
    @999hireactionvehicles9 Місяць тому +2

    Bears striking resemblance to the estate agent from Fulham who disappeared Susie Lamplugh same age same looks and just disappeared

  • @alanhaworth3821
    @alanhaworth3821 Місяць тому +8

    What a very sad case, such a beautiful person. It’s been years of suffering for her parents. Also thoughts for Suzy Lamplugh, another beautiful person who disappeared, declared dead, presumed murdered, in 1993.

  • @simonr6643
    @simonr6643 Місяць тому +1

    The police probably have idea but need prood "TALK" About time Peter did a talk about Claudia. Someone knows and its about time justice was served.

  • @jayneverona
    @jayneverona Місяць тому +2

    Just found this show. Very interesting.

  • @colinmartin2921
    @colinmartin2921 Місяць тому +9

    A fascinating case. Her handbag was found next to a stream on the route that she took to work, so she must have left for work that morning. Two mysteries for me are the identity of a new lover that she had spent the previous night with, and the fact that on the evening before she disappeared she was due to meet two friends in the pub next door to her house but never showed up, yet her friends did not call and ask where she was.

    • @courtneysquill8843
      @courtneysquill8843 Місяць тому +3

      Her handbag wasn't found. Someone said they saw her ruck sack yet when they returned the rucksack was gone. So no one knows if it was her rucksack.

    • @courtneysquill8843
      @courtneysquill8843 Місяць тому +1

      Her handbag wasn't found. Someone said they saw her ruck sack yet when they returned the rucksack was gone. So no one knows if it was her rucksack.

    • @elaineduker.6355
      @elaineduker.6355 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@courtneysquill8843 The rucksack could have been taken by a thief, no big mystery.

    • @courtneysquill8843
      @courtneysquill8843 Місяць тому +2

      @@elaineduker.6355 The police never located the rucksack and whoever said it was there couldn't say how they knew it was definitely hers. There is no evidence it was hers. Rucksacks are ten aplenty...

    • @elaineduker.6355
      @elaineduker.6355 Місяць тому

      ​@@courtneysquill8843They are in York, it's a tourist hotspot, & University City, you can't move for people with rucksack's! I always take a small one when I go
      into York.

  • @lanemaund5097
    @lanemaund5097 Місяць тому +4

    This reporting is fantastic 👍

  • @shaneconsidine2617
    @shaneconsidine2617 Місяць тому +5

    My mother calls to my house about 3 times a year but I call to her a lot so it’s understandable Claudia’s mam didn’t know a whole load about her life.
    If I was a betting man (and I am) I wouldn’t rule out stranger abduction , reminds me of the Sarah Everard case but I don’t have enough facts to be sure. Geofencing her mobile should tell a tale.

  • @sandrabaker1312
    @sandrabaker1312 Місяць тому +3

    Someone she knew, and somebody knows the identity of them. Or have suspicions.

  • @karesage2889
    @karesage2889 Місяць тому +5

    Money talks. Was there ever a reward offered for Claudia's case??

  • @jameskingston6175
    @jameskingston6175 Місяць тому +1

    Why havn`t they put up a Reward for information!

  • @RobertLeroyParker-fi2xn
    @RobertLeroyParker-fi2xn 29 днів тому +2

    Has anyone else heard this ….”I'm extremely confident it was PR, anyone who knows the suspects arrested will know who that is. A girl that's younger than 30 had been going to the nags head recently and got on with him and went back to his house and ended up passing out asleep, when she woke up he was over her and her trousers were off. If he's capable of that, I think it speaks volumes about what else he's potentially done.” This person knows the girl it happened to…. I presume he means the walnut tree pub though that’s where some of “them” drink now

    • @ShadowSneax
      @ShadowSneax 17 днів тому +1

      I know the girl this happened to, she's only 28. It wasn't the walnut tree, it was the Nags. I've seen the text messages between her and PR.

    • @RobertLeroyParker-fi2xn
      @RobertLeroyParker-fi2xn 17 днів тому +1

      @@ShadowSneax she should go to the police ideally …. Hope your mates ok also

  • @kirstydoel7099
    @kirstydoel7099 Місяць тому +3

    Something to do with the pub next door and the landord

    • @michaelbennett5959
      @michaelbennett5959 Місяць тому +1

      Defo that got rid of mattress redecorated a room in two days the wouldn't let the police search the pub for two days cameras turned of in pub