Apple HomePod 2 Review: I'm Confused

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 тра 2024
  • The second generation HomePod is really good. And really bad.
    That shirt: shop.MKBHD.com
    Reviews podcast clips rant: • Apple Drops New M2 Mac...
    Tech I'm using right now: www.amazon.com/shop/MKBHD
    Playlist of MKBHD Intro music: goo.gl/B3AWV5
    Speaker provided by Apple for review.
    ~
    / mkbhd
    / mkbhd
    / mkbhd
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 5 тис.

  • @ColinCreighton
    @ColinCreighton Рік тому +14917

    In a hilarious turn of events, I think Microsoft should make a smart speaker running a version of ChatGPT and some voice recognition software.

    • @kanomee
      @kanomee Рік тому +655

      that would be such a gamechanger. like really, you can now not only use ChatGPT through chats (which is the main idea), but to integrate it with voice recognition? I reckon someone would marry their speaker in the future no cap

    • @cestlavieeee
      @cestlavieeee Рік тому +157

      this is so obvious to absolutely destroy the smart speaker market. What is microsoft thinking? is this how large companies are, slow? ITS SO CLEARLY OBVIOUS!!!

    • @paperstars9078
      @paperstars9078 Рік тому +26

      I agree, would also make it somewhat easy to miss the bullshit it spits out from time to time. Yeah, it would definetly be hilarious.

    • @RealJoseph123
      @RealJoseph123 Рік тому

      Microsoft will MDK Google. Bixby, Alexa, and Siri is going down with it. Microsoft has a advantage but they won’t use it. They aren’t that smart, we need new leadership.

    • @emmanuelnicholas7998
      @emmanuelnicholas7998 Рік тому +99

      What if Microsoft makes cortana 2.0 with capabilities of chatgpt?

  • @tayzonday
    @tayzonday Рік тому +4055

    It looks like a candle - but it burns money instead of wax.

  • @wynos0
    @wynos0 Рік тому +1417

    It’s quite a different story here in Finland, because Siri is the ONLY virtual assistant that understands Finnish. So the HomePod is by far the best smart speaker that is available here in Finland 😄

    • @niimoallotey
      @niimoallotey Рік тому +46

      Interesting!

    • @faithblack3851
      @faithblack3851 Рік тому +83

      Great insight...never occurred to me that there would be language barriers with the home assistant. I guess R&D need to immerse with language and dialect...huh.

    • @tharedpotatowwhale
      @tharedpotatowwhale Рік тому +4

      Hydrolic press

    • @ZachAgape
      @ZachAgape Рік тому +1

      hahaha xD

    • @da3v1ls93
      @da3v1ls93 Рік тому +9

      Perrrrrrrkeeellleee

  • @dielikeag0d
    @dielikeag0d Рік тому +21

    I've been trying to figure out my Bluetooth latency issues and ive been having so much trouble finding a UA-camr that spoke clearly and made it easy to read lips and you're the only person I've found that enunciates everything so clearly that you can literally see every word you're saying. Amazing. Thank you

  • @yadielrivera1740
    @yadielrivera1740 Рік тому +2519

    Got me at “If you want to hear how bad Siri is in cristal clear high definition then this is for you” 😂😂

  • @geebster.
    @geebster. Рік тому +1030

    Wow the improvement in the way it stains wooden tables is amazing!! That's some Apple engineering right there. Now you can tell what model of Homepod someone has just by looking at their tables.

    • @iflyrcmike
      @iflyrcmike Рік тому +59

      I would buy it just for the upgrade in staining ability.

    • @jisnukalita
      @jisnukalita Рік тому +3

      Yaa Imagine contana saying now ignore me

    • @JezzaTheChamp
      @JezzaTheChamp Рік тому +58

      Soon they’ll start selling “non-staining Apple tables for $5,000”

    • @MisterSixty
      @MisterSixty Рік тому +2

      😂 😂 😂 😂 😂

    • @Drewgulbas
      @Drewgulbas Рік тому +3

      seriously. Jony Ive's neck must hurt from shaking his head w the last 2 years of Apple product launch flops

  • @olliebelt9486
    @olliebelt9486 Рік тому +179

    I still have my original HomePod OG’s - I picked them up back last year along with a 2nd gen ATV 4K. I would have never paid the original price, but managed to get 2 in mint condition for $150 ($75 each). Still work perfectly and amazing when used as a stereo pair.

    • @DaviAreias
      @DaviAreias Рік тому +8

      Mine suffered from deathfarts after 1 year and that's why I'm never buying another one ever again.

    • @Demipurr
      @Demipurr Рік тому +1

      Where did you get yours?

    • @RubSomeDirtOnIt
      @RubSomeDirtOnIt Рік тому +20

      @@DaviAreias I have literally never heard that term used in reference to technology and I am crying. 😂😂😂

    • @RefurbNoob
      @RefurbNoob Рік тому +1

      @@RubSomeDirtOnIt it is a real therm tho 😂 I repair the og HomePods daily

    • @RubSomeDirtOnIt
      @RubSomeDirtOnIt Рік тому +1

      @@RefurbNoob I believe it! 😂 I just never would have imagined "deathfarts" to be a legitimate addition to my technical vocabulary. 🤣🤣🤣

  • @KLBradleySr
    @KLBradleySr Рік тому +34

    I trust your reviews and love even more that my son has someone like you as a model for what he wants to do in life! Thank. You.

  • @stiggy8322
    @stiggy8322 Рік тому +626

    An other good effect is that now suddenly 1st gen Homepods can be found way cheaper, as a month ago they were still selling for almost retail price... Now I'll be able to find an used one to pair it with mine and have a very good stereo speaker system for my bedroom !

    • @KazeHorse
      @KazeHorse Рік тому +28

      Yeah I sold mine like 4 months ago for retail. Feel a bit bad for the buyer but I legit had no idea they would copy the exact same product…
      Sound is insane from these though.

    • @coffeevie
      @coffeevie Рік тому +5

      That’s my plan as well

    • @allentastic
      @allentastic Рік тому +7

      I don’t think you can stereo pair the old with the new, just a heads up

    • @obamtl
      @obamtl Рік тому +1

      Yup! I paid £200 ($250) for the OG second hand last month.

    • @stiggy8322
      @stiggy8322 Рік тому

      @@allentastic it’s not what I want to do. I’ll find an OG one for a better price now.

  • @coasterman0197
    @coasterman0197 Рік тому +395

    “Steve still loves me, Steve still loves me…”
    That intro was awesome lol!

  • @drthirteen5786
    @drthirteen5786 Рік тому +126

    😂 That 600$ speakers reference to 300$ tv was actually so true

    • @ErikVeland
      @ErikVeland Рік тому +7

      Not sure why this was even mentioned. You'd rather want to put in money for good audio anytime over the tiny deltas in visual acuity between TVs these days.

    • @drthirteen5786
      @drthirteen5786 Рік тому +7

      @@ErikVeland 😂 did you even go to school?

    • @teapouter6109
      @teapouter6109 Рік тому +10

      @@ErikVeland $300 TV is noticeably worse than say a $1000 42" LG C2

    • @mrowe1204
      @mrowe1204 Рік тому +1

      He’s not wrong 😂🤷🏻‍♀️😂

    • @majesticzak2390
      @majesticzak2390 Рік тому

      @@ErikVelandthat’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard

  • @SubieMooha
    @SubieMooha Рік тому +96

    Bought a discounted HomePod back in 2021. It sounds loads better than the mini. I wasn’t impressed at how it sounded at the Apple Store but at home it’s amazing! The bass frequencies are crazy good. I hope this gen can get more appreciation.

  • @FreemanLinde
    @FreemanLinde Рік тому +438

    "At least Siri sucks seamlessly on a smart speaker that sounds sweet..." is a brilliant piece of alliteration and deserves more credit than it's getting. 👏🏻

    • @oskarvnz
      @oskarvnz Рік тому +10

      It is not that serious.

    • @waheeddoesstuff
      @waheeddoesstuff Рік тому +2

      @@oskarvnz let it slide

    • @timmannchicken
      @timmannchicken Рік тому +2

      I was literally coming here to quote that same phrase. LOL.

    • @carstenb23
      @carstenb23 Рік тому +3

      @@waheeddoesstuff he's adding to the alliteration

    • @waheeddoesstuff
      @waheeddoesstuff Рік тому

      @@carstenb23 haha

  • @MrGamelover23
    @MrGamelover23 Рік тому +256

    That intro was gold, we need more of that kind of stuff on this channel. I see he's been taking notes from LTT intros.

    • @RealJoseph123
      @RealJoseph123 Рік тому +9

      Yeah, I was expecting a cinematic style intro. Wasn’t expecting the team to put together that “skit”.

    • @ak_hoops
      @ak_hoops Рік тому +1

      truly GOLDEN

    • @mattieboombatti
      @mattieboombatti Рік тому +2

      It's so unexpected, but the QUALITY

    • @Romafood
      @Romafood Рік тому +1

      Vero👏

    • @casmatt99
      @casmatt99 Рік тому +2

      A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one!

  • @apexerman1
    @apexerman1 Рік тому +51

    This is a fair and honest review. Siri wasn't even a consideration for me. I purchased the original HomePods primarily as high fidelity audio components that mesh with my Apple ecosystem. So far, they haven't disappointed. And when Apply finally supported home theater with Apple TV 4K, their function expanded considerably. The sound reproduction coupled with Dolby Atmos is remarkable... room-filled spatial sound with impressive deep bass performance. It may not compare to the highest home theater setups, but it'll do a phenomenal job for the price. Even one HomePod could suffice. Whether HomePod 2.0 will succeed is another story. Home Theater capability could give it life if it's recognized by enough people. To the Apple TV owners considering an upgrade, do it. You'll be amazed. :)

    • @ToriZealot
      @ToriZealot 10 місяців тому +2

      You cannot compare this to any serious Hifi equipment. It may sound nice on your desk however

    • @IceBlueLugia
      @IceBlueLugia 4 місяці тому +4

      @@ToriZealotWrong, it matches the quality of any hi-fi setup. Apple did a great job

    • @ToriZealot
      @ToriZealot 4 місяці тому

      @@IceBlueLugia How old are you? How many serious Hi-Fi- configurations have you tested? What is your favorite Membran material?

    • @heroninja1125
      @heroninja1125 2 місяці тому +5

      @@ToriZealot Oh man, the master gatekeeper himself is speaking. Quiet guys, if we listen carefully enough we may even hear the snake oil merchant as well!!

    • @ToriZealot
      @ToriZealot 2 місяці тому

      @@heroninja1125 I recently discovered a 120 Dollar phone that beats 50000 Dollar Studio equipment. Must be true or you are a gatekeeper. Should I also update my own posts?

  • @EddieOWright
    @EddieOWright Рік тому +46

    I have a couple of the original versions set up as a stereo pair and use it with an Apple TV as a speaker and absolutely love it. Glad to see they brought back the big one again.

  • @alanschmitt9865
    @alanschmitt9865 Рік тому +204

    "Maybe we were too early".
    I think that's bang on. $300 was a lot to ask of people for their first Apple smart speaker. Now that the Mini has been out a while and done well, I bet there are quite a few Mini owners out there who have been softened up enough to drop the cash on an "improved" version of that.

    • @jamest6504
      @jamest6504 Рік тому +8

      Yep I agree with this. I have a few minis and I honestly would consider adding a couple of these. Previously I never considered the original HomePod.

    • @Antto
      @Antto Рік тому +15

      No. This is just overpriced junk BT speaker. If you have the Mini why would you pay for this speaker also. Makes no sense. If you care about sound quality you will buy proper speakers and not this box with 1 woofer and 5 tweeters.

    • @AponTechy
      @AponTechy Рік тому +1

      I didn't think that

    • @JackieWelles
      @JackieWelles Рік тому +5

      $300 its still too much, $249 would be perfect, but ofc Apple taxes apply so.

    • @gracjackVEVO
      @gracjackVEVO Рік тому +2

      @@Antto BT speaker?

  • @keaton718
    @keaton718 Рік тому +464

    Anyone remember Apple's official iPod dock, that was a huge and very heavy hifi quality speaker? I feel like Steve Jobs was behind that and wanted a dock that he personally would want to listen to music through. And that Jobs would have been proud of the HomePod 1 and 2.

    • @rph_redacted
      @rph_redacted Рік тому +13

      It sounded VERY good actually

    • @sobeautifulsrilanka
      @sobeautifulsrilanka Рік тому +10

      Had the original HomePod. It sounded like crap compared to the Google Home Max and my stereo system. No midrange. Just thump and tizzle sound, as audiophiles say. I sold mine.

    • @nixl3518
      @nixl3518 Рік тому

      @@sobeautifulsrilanka Who cares? What's a GHMax? Sounds like a vacuum cleaner, rather than a speaker name!
      Typical reaction non-Apple-ite w/ a shoulder-full of chips having being shorn away!!

    • @jamescassar5348
      @jamescassar5348 Рік тому +22

      If Steve jobs was alive today he would be rolling in his grave

    • @sobeautifulsrilanka
      @sobeautifulsrilanka Рік тому +5

      @@nixl3518 Actually, I’m almost all in on Apple. Use a Mac, iPhone, iPad. But the HomePod was very disappointing. It has crap sound , to those who know what good sound sounds like.

  • @wpoitras
    @wpoitras 11 місяців тому +1

    "I'll link that episode below the like button". I'm genuinely impressed. Very smooth way to ask people like (and everyone will hear "and subscribe" in their head) while giving them important information. Well done.

  • @sammy_sam_leonardo
    @sammy_sam_leonardo Рік тому +12

    I had the original homepod, and after 18months it inexplicably stopped working despite being on- after no luck at the Apple Store I did some online research and this was a massive issue that had no fix! I bought a mini to replace it and it’s worked perfectly since. I would imagine the original homepod had some kind of fundamental issue combined with not selling well equalled discontinuing it…

  • @keoganlarademusic918
    @keoganlarademusic918 Рік тому +87

    I feel like the target market for this is people who bought homepod minis, like them, and now feel like this would be a great addition to their existing setup. I don’t know anyone whose first google speaker was the home max, most people bought the mini, or the normal google home, and then decided to get the max

  • @andyb9664
    @andyb9664 Рік тому +113

    The closing note, he almost lost it 🤣 That was gold.

  • @stephenborgella2312
    @stephenborgella2312 Рік тому

    Love how fluid the ending of your videos have become 👍🏾

  • @juancruz3755
    @juancruz3755 Рік тому +12

    When he said “Hey siri what’s the temperature outside” my HomePod Siri also activated and surprised me 🤣

  • @morpheus9394
    @morpheus9394 Рік тому +307

    Loved that intro, very funny and very clever. You and the team just keep getting better and better, original too.

    • @prayagsuthar9856
      @prayagsuthar9856 Рік тому

      OMG yesss!!! The intro is _hilarious,_ I could totally watch it again 😆

    • @GamesForNoobs
      @GamesForNoobs Рік тому

      at first it was weird but it was funny

  • @iGageit
    @iGageit Рік тому +160

    That was the best intro I have ever seen from MKBHD Team! well done! I also do use 2 OG HomePods as my TV speakers. would recommend.

    • @custardtart1312
      @custardtart1312 Рік тому

      I came here to see if some bellend would sycophantically comment on the intro. I’m actually embarrassed for you. Pathetic.

  • @omgneal7016
    @omgneal7016 Рік тому +34

    I use 2 OG HomePods for my home theater set up and it sounds fantastic. No plans to upgrade but the threading feature is nice.

    • @drgin22
      @drgin22 Рік тому

      Same, I use two minis as my home theater speakers and it’s just enough. This bigger HomePod just seems unnecessary.

    • @manlykscorpa
      @manlykscorpa Рік тому

      That's an expensive set up

    • @MikoEZK
      @MikoEZK Рік тому

      thats cap

    • @apexerman1
      @apexerman1 Рік тому

      @@drgin22 - You might reconsider. I like my Minis too, but even one HomePod offers quite the dynamic punch for its size. It's actually remarkable how much very deep bass response occurs at low to mid-volumes. It also supports spatial enhancement from Dolby Atmos.

  • @johnnychapoy735
    @johnnychapoy735 Рік тому

    Man y’all are really creating dream content from sound visuals and just the overall content… I could only dream to be as awsome and smart as you and the crew I’m sure helps bring all this together… thank you for the content brotha

  • @tony86082
    @tony86082 Рік тому +48

    just to clarify for us audio pro's, true Atmos sound is 7.1.2 (left, center, right, 4 rear surrounds, sub and 2 overheads), the best you'll get with multiple HomePods is stereo. And if you add more than 2, it'll be summed to the same mono signal in each speaker, no separation. Which will not give you the experience the sound mixers intended (with very specific information moving through the surrounds and overheads). in case anyone cares. haha

    • @Chris_Hruska
      @Chris_Hruska Рік тому +3

      each tweeter can blast out different audio channels. its better than mono or stereo like you said. it'll probably sound better than 5.1 systems that have a sounder and woofer and two rear speakers for sure.

    • @BenJ.G
      @BenJ.G Рік тому

      Unfortunately there’s a bit more gray area than that. You’ve listed minimum requirements for true multichannel Atmos, but a setup can truly be however many speakers you’d like, or it can just be binaural (headphones plus an HRTF). Then there’s the fact that a HomePod is not just a mono speaker - there are five theaters within that intelligently project sound in different directions. Is it a true Atmos experience? Technically not. But is the experience as simple as mono or stereo? Also no.

  • @davidmarsham
    @davidmarsham Рік тому +336

    I think the key with this one is the higher adoption of the mini. I can see people who ignored this the first time, but eventually ended up getting a mini and enjoying it, wanting to add an upgrade to their setup now that they’re in the Apple smart speaker ecosystem. So to me it kind of makes sense. Maybe…?

    • @arafatrahmanshihab5268
      @arafatrahmanshihab5268 Рік тому +5

      Yeah

    • @hubear_
      @hubear_ Рік тому +17

      If it was $200-$250 max. For $300, this is a hard sell as purely a sound upgrade to the Mini.

    • @lovetheblue6659
      @lovetheblue6659 Рік тому +12

      This *does* make sense as this is exactly what we're doing! In fact, we're buying two for use with our Apple TV box in the Den. BOTTOM LINE: If you're married to the iOS ecosystem and you subscribe to iTunes Music (we have a "all-in-one" family service pack which includes Arcade, expanded Cloud Storage, TV+, and News+) then this is THE smart speaker!

    • @sexyshyscorpio
      @sexyshyscorpio Рік тому +3

      Yeah I agree. I definitely skipped the first HomePod but have 3 minis in our bedrooms. I would love a HomePod for my living room and I’m debating one for our basement/family room set up. I might go 2 minis for the basement tho.

    • @anthonywall1228
      @anthonywall1228 Рік тому +3

      I have 6 minis and love them. Can’t see spending more money just to get a bigger product and a better sound. The minis are a great product.

  • @jacobmaz8157
    @jacobmaz8157 Рік тому

    I was watching another review of this product, I stopped 2 min in to watch your review instead, BECAUSE I wanted a quality video, the intro, the edits, the facts, the shots, I got what I came for, thank you.

  • @pedrator69
    @pedrator69 Рік тому +25

    It'll be interesting to see whether consumers will buy into this one now that they've had the experience with iPod mini. Maybe it's a build-up/upgrade strategy.

  • @TheBigNegative-PhotoChannel
    @TheBigNegative-PhotoChannel Рік тому +149

    Now we can hear Siri suck at the highes possible audio quality. 😂

    • @nixl3518
      @nixl3518 Рік тому +1

      Sounds like another negative from a -big-Negative... giving us a positive review!! If your ears suck, you can hardly blame the speaker!! 🤣

    • @TheBigNegative-PhotoChannel
      @TheBigNegative-PhotoChannel Рік тому +1

      @@nixl3518 The speaker in the thing will be top notch.
      I'm only happy when I activate a home scene "go to sleep" and siri can't execute the command because I don't have a running app. Because I said "go".
      Or the next time I want to calculate 22x32 and siri shows me "20 two multiplied by..."
      I use Siri every day and I wonder how the heck this can still be so bad when we have something like chat GPT next to it?

  • @TylerPoppe
    @TylerPoppe Рік тому +277

    I got a bunch when Best Buy sold the originals on clearance for $150 and I love them, fantastic when setup as a TV speaker that also works for music and siri (even if she's bad).

    • @peterwolanyk3428
      @peterwolanyk3428 Рік тому +13

      Ah shit that was smart. I should've done that.

    • @TylerPoppe
      @TylerPoppe Рік тому +17

      @@peterwolanyk3428 yeah I started off with one just out of curiosity. Now I have a pair for each TV and then whole house sound with music when I want. I wish they would have done these at $200. Would have sold like hot cakes.

    • @bub9587
      @bub9587 Рік тому +12

      Not gonna lie, I didn’t even know what a HomePod was until I watched this video. I thought it was Amazon Alexa variation. This really shows how much this product flopped.

    • @Fredd00007
      @Fredd00007 Рік тому +7

      Only if u only have Apple products lying around. It doesn't make sense to have speakers that only work with Apple devices.

    • @TylerPoppe
      @TylerPoppe Рік тому +1

      @@Fredd00007 That's true. But I knew that going in and so it's not a problem.

  • @DV-Vega
    @DV-Vega 11 місяців тому +3

    Thanks for the as always concise video Marques. So I already have a stereo setup combining 2 minis... how do you think they would compare sound-wise vs the output from the new Homepod? Better or worse? 2 minis or 1 new HP would be louder?

  • @DaniloMeulens
    @DaniloMeulens Рік тому

    That intro skit was probably one of the best! :D

  • @IGmeanwell
    @IGmeanwell Рік тому +47

    I waited until I could find the OG HomePods for under $250 and have a stereo pair for music. They have been solid for me, if I didn’t already have dedicated sound in the livingroom I would use them for the projector. I really enjoy them I just want them to support the use of two other HomePods for a surround setup. Just waiting on that Apple.

  • @movsesnersisyan1153
    @movsesnersisyan1153 Рік тому +170

    I currently am still rocking two of the first gen homepods using them in stereo, i will say if you do have earc on your tv you can use these speakers for you gaming and just regularly watching tv and it does sound fantastic. I was thinking about upgraded but now after watching, its more like downgrading lol. Thanks for the video.

    • @stevenswall
      @stevenswall Рік тому +6

      What does EARC have to do with these speakers? Do they have an HDMI connection?
      Apple keeps telling me (lying to me I think) that they use EARC but I swear they actually mean the Apple TV does.

    • @00SNIVY00
      @00SNIVY00 Рік тому +3

      I will wonder about a direct comparison in terms of sound, because it's possible to get a better sound out of fewer speakers, though spatial wise it might have slightly less specificity. A newer processor may help compensate.

    • @b0rme
      @b0rme Рік тому

      How do you connect them to your tv?

    • @stevenswall
      @stevenswall Рік тому +9

      @@b0rme You don't. You connect them to the Apple TV wirelessly, and then the Apple TV can use them for audio or can play audio from your TV.

    • @NithinJune
      @NithinJune Рік тому

      ?? what

  • @Shaans_Bricks
    @Shaans_Bricks Рік тому +2

    Wonderful and detailed video as always! Great intro too! Definitely one of the best tech UA-cam channels!

  • @31kr1d
    @31kr1d Рік тому +6

    Thank you this was timely, love the information and clearly entertaining too

  • @jasonsturek6510
    @jasonsturek6510 Рік тому +169

    I think it has a chance this time because the $99 mini buyers might upgrade if they've had a good experience. I have the original and have had heard a few minis playing together at the same time and I'd say that without a doubt one HomePod beats out 4-5 minis playing together. That's an odd value proposition there, but nonetheless true.

    • @LuisMartinsmw
      @LuisMartinsmw Рік тому +1

      Same. I had to race to get two of the originals when they were discontinued and I’m still very happy with them. I would prefer to see this relaunch be something more affirmatively something to stay. It does feel like it will probably flop again.

    • @stavrocoumanidis1199
      @stavrocoumanidis1199 Рік тому

      @@LuisMartinsmw why not make these wirelesss? apple missed a trick there

    • @pr3ttysus922
      @pr3ttysus922 Рік тому +3

      Literally me haha, I have a blue mini and considering buying a regular for more sound.
      Not that the mini sounds bad, I just want more bass and volume.

    • @LuisMartinsmw
      @LuisMartinsmw Рік тому +1

      @@pr3ttysus922 I have a few minis as well. There’s no comparison. The original sounds worlds better

    • @LuisMartinsmw
      @LuisMartinsmw Рік тому

      @@stavrocoumanidis1199 what do you mean? They are already wireless

  • @padmo1531
    @padmo1531 Рік тому +61

    The intros just keeps getting better and better. At this point, I don't have a favorite one. They are all so damn good!😍😍😍

  • @SamsonKilanko
    @SamsonKilanko Рік тому +11

    I kinda agree with Marques on this one. Homepods are great, and sound great, but they're still a tad too expensive and quite limited. Personally, I'm pretty invested in Apple's eco-system but when it came to whole-house audio, I chose Sonos. It's not cheap but, frankly, it's not a whole lot more expensive than buying multiple Homepods. Speaking of which, MKBHD, I've never seen you review Sonos products. 🤔 Is there a reason for that? Hands down, IMHO, I still think Sonos offers the best multi-room audio system on the market today. You need to check it out.

  • @AdamGonzebra
    @AdamGonzebra 9 місяців тому

    I loved how you said in the video “and then there’s this ultimate boss feature” 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂👏👏👏👏

  • @nchia
    @nchia Рік тому +19

    Fact that this video already has almost 1.5M views, and counting, shows many are at least still very interested in this product. The only issue I have with this is the price. When the original was on run out, it was a no brainer. In any case, I’m really happy with mine - as additional to my surround speakers, and for the bedroom, and very happy it’s “back”.

  • @RishabhDesairf7627
    @RishabhDesairf7627 Рік тому +294

    After the Homepod was discontinued, it became one of the most coveted item, and used homepods were going for more than their MSRP. I remember that at one point, StockX was selling Homepods for $900. This was because people realised that while the homepod was not great value as a smart speaker, it was amazing product as a quality wireless speaker. So Apple decided to monetise on it by reintorducing it as a "second generation homepod". The same as when Nike monetizes the "collectibility" and rarity of Jordans.

    • @pcefulpolarbear
      @pcefulpolarbear Рік тому +10

      Not at all

    • @donaldwang7538
      @donaldwang7538 Рік тому +6

      Yep. I was thinking about getting a Homepod last year, but resale prices were insane. Ended up getting a Sonos 5 instead.

    • @AdamNicholsMusic
      @AdamNicholsMusic Рік тому +1

      what is wrong with the world

    • @AFreeThinkingDawg09
      @AFreeThinkingDawg09 Рік тому +6

      In regards to any wireless speaker, it’s amazing. Siri is still dumb but the quality is amazing for what it is. Better than any other wireless speakers

    • @Akosa117
      @Akosa117 Рік тому +16

      It’s not wireless

  • @vizender
    @vizender Рік тому +1

    I have a HomePod mini in my apartment, and my parents use 2 HomePods as TV speakers. Honestly, even HomePod minis are kind of premium. But you really have a great audio quality with these things, especially the big HomePod. And while Siri is indeed pretty bad, for me it honestly do the job on a speaker like the HomePod as I only use them to control devices on Apple Home as I have a few lights and other stuff in my apartment

  • @RubesM
    @RubesM 8 місяців тому

    Good review... Glad you hit the points I wanted to hear. I actually did order a mini and a homepod 2 since I was able to take advantage of my cousin's Apple employee 25% off coupon. So, it was more about the saving at this point. We pretty much are an Apple family here and this would also be a great addition. I wanted to purchase a set of Sono speakers instead and then an Apple mini, but I think I did well considering my purchase was $316 total. I'm also a bit bitter with Sonos discontinuing my speaker's software. They stopped supporting the software and pretty much made my Sonos 3 and soundbar useless. Anyway, looking forward to hearing and testing these two products out.

  • @SebastianWerner82
    @SebastianWerner82 Рік тому +23

    The microphones could hear you not just across the room but actually across the whole floor, around a few corners.
    Also, in several countries the first home pod was not available for over a year.
    Personally I prefer the HomePod over the HomePod mini.
    One thing you should note that’s kind of a bummer: You can not use HomePods as Speakers for Macs. You can do video and music, but not games or system sound or anything else that can not be pre-cached for the matter.

    • @manlish11
      @manlish11 Рік тому +3

      That’s bummer! I was thinking to buy it as permanent speaker for the Mac

  • @jessewilliams875
    @jessewilliams875 Рік тому +107

    Always appreciate your honest reviews. Super helpful.

  • @gusroden5242
    @gusroden5242 Рік тому +4

    I have got 3 now. All bought second hand barely used. The first two I got for 110 each and the second was 170, so hard to pass up.
    I love them. The bass is absolutely crazy and it is nice that you can use just these speakers for a home theatre type sound quality.

  • @ChristianPizzirani
    @ChristianPizzirani Рік тому +2

    3:54 Got a bonus temperature reading while watching this video. 😀

  • @sergiodelarosa612
    @sergiodelarosa612 Рік тому +33

    Honestly, I think the rerelease is coming out now because many users that passed on the Gen1 and snagged the mini now see the capabilities of having an automated home. I speak from personal experiences, I passed on the gen1 due to price, but the mini was reasonable enough to be able to try out. I’m actually thinking of grabbing this one and rearrange the minis together into other rooms.

    • @tiagomaqz
      @tiagomaqz Рік тому +2

      Exactly what I just said. MKHB is great but he’s too bias on his reviews.

    • @CJ-ct2mu
      @CJ-ct2mu Рік тому +6

      @@tiagomaqz Every reviewer is "bias". Plus it's not like he doesn't give reasons why he thinks what he thinks.
      He also has the luxury of being able to try out any electronics that he desires. So in comparison to other smart speakers, this one isn't the best option. Nothing wrong with that.

    • @randocalrissian9217
      @randocalrissian9217 Рік тому +2

      The used HomePod market heated up for a bit. I was never able to snag a black HomePod at a decent price after they were discontinued.

    • @rventura101699rv
      @rventura101699rv Рік тому +4

      We have the original HomePod in all the rooms in our house. Super happy with the audio quality. Love the fact that we can play the same music in all the rooms, or just in certain rooms. Funny we’ve got comments from people who haven’t even experienced the full sized HomePod. So glad Apple decided to bring it back. Will be purchasing a few of these for our other place. Find it funny they the reviewer said “People don’t pay a premium for just the sound quality” - seriously- why do people buy speakers then?hello Devialet 😂😂😂

  • @mikuqt2622
    @mikuqt2622 Рік тому +166

    A comparison with other premium smart speakers like the Bose Smart Speaker 500 would be great

    • @modenaman
      @modenaman Рік тому +10

      Bose wins hands down. I tried both.

    • @annenominous7220
      @annenominous7220 Рік тому

      @@modenaman Bose, LOL

    • @Mr.BobsDog
      @Mr.BobsDog Рік тому +1

      The Bose is brilliant!

    • @subwoofermaniac
      @subwoofermaniac Рік тому

      I use the HK citation 200, must say that one stands above the latter.

  • @k1n1ami18
    @k1n1ami18 Рік тому +1

    I was one of the engineers working on it, the only thing we changed was the core, the audio speaks are just "renewed" version of the last one the are produced by the same company using the same methods.

  • @alexcuevas5633
    @alexcuevas5633 Рік тому

    An skit on a video has been a long time coming😮😭 golden!

  • @TheAlfredo1018
    @TheAlfredo1018 Рік тому +74

    I have that setup with an LG TV (around $500) and two 1st gen HomePods. They’re just amazing! I literally stopped looking for audio bars after this and they are importantly compact to me because I’ve been moving a lot in the past few years.
    And even better now, if the old fail I can now replace them!!

    • @Katatonya
      @Katatonya Рік тому +4

      How do you hook them up if they only connect to ios devices though ?

    • @amauryd
      @amauryd Рік тому +2

      i think OP has apple tv, pairs them via airplay

    • @jjsjohnson1
      @jjsjohnson1 Рік тому

      I assume you can only use them through Apple TV right?

    • @lucasbim
      @lucasbim Рік тому +2

      I have bad news for you, if one fails.. you have to buy two of the new one. AFAIK, they don't pair and old + new one. :(

    • @TheAlfredo1018
      @TheAlfredo1018 Рік тому +2

      @@lucasbim yep, I’m mentally prepared for that. Now I need to be financially prepared… but still I think I’d buy them again.

  • @RussDnB
    @RussDnB Рік тому +36

    I use 2 original HomePods in the HDMI ARC setup, and they sound phenomenal in our living room. All working with consoles too. Yes there's a tiiiiny bit of latency, especially for games that use fast and sharp sounds, but these speakers either side of the TV with no sound bar come across wonderful.
    And yeah, I'm one of the handful of crazies that have them around the home too. Nothing I love more than playing my music at a semi-low level all around the home and being able to just walk around doing what I'm doing with my music all around, and sounding nice and full in every room.

    • @mrclaytontodd
      @mrclaytontodd Рік тому

      How did you do the HDMI ARC setup? I stereo paired the originals with the latest AppleTV just via AirPlay & they drop CONSTANTLY.

    • @joshualockett6912
      @joshualockett6912 Рік тому

      @@mrclaytontodd most likely your home network setup. Do you use the stock router provided by your ISP by any chance?

    • @mrclaytontodd
      @mrclaytontodd Рік тому

      @@joshualockett6912 we have eero router and just bought our own modem too

    • @thighhigh423
      @thighhigh423 Рік тому

      @@mrclaytontodd we had to get one of the “newer” 4k Apple TVs for it to work. Sold the other to a friend. Make sure yours has ARC support

    • @joshualockett6912
      @joshualockett6912 Рік тому +1

      @@mrclaytontodd Interesting. I’ve got an eero setup too. I use a mini stereo pair for the bedroom TV (Apple TV 4K 3rd gen WiFi) with no problems whatsoever.

  • @bwoohk
    @bwoohk 4 місяці тому

    Excellent content, very professional discussion! Thank you teacher for sharing

  • @foodnstuffz
    @foodnstuffz Рік тому

    Absolutely loved the intro!

  • @SteveGoodwinAuthor
    @SteveGoodwinAuthor Рік тому +174

    Taking it to the next level, Marques allowing a device to permanent stain his table.

    • @gezeo750
      @gezeo750 Рік тому +2

      That's dedication there.

    • @devonkennedy1386
      @devonkennedy1386 Рік тому

      @@gezeo750 What exactly do you mean?

    • @devonkennedy1386
      @devonkennedy1386 Рік тому +1

      This comment makes no sense, you have no proof that isn’t just a wood table that he pulled out of a junkyard for the demo. In fact in his previous vids, he dsnt have a wood table anywhere inside the studio

    • @_richardaustin
      @_richardaustin Рік тому +15

      @@devonkennedy1386 chill out Devon, it’s not that deep

    • @SteveGoodwinAuthor
      @SteveGoodwinAuthor Рік тому +1

      @@devonkennedy1386 😁😆😂

  • @josefalido7012
    @josefalido7012 Рік тому +14

    Damn, the quality on your reviews is unmatched. Love your work man, catch you on the next one.

  • @afite1
    @afite1 Рік тому +22

    I think the problem with original HomePod was that it was missing the mini option. A $350 cost of entry just to try out an Apple speaker is a big ask. Now that there’s a HomePod mini and people can try a lower risk and lower investment to see if they even like HomePod they’ll be more open to paying up to get a better HomePod experience. Arguably the HomePod mini should have been Apple’s first smart speaker product and then followed by the more premium HomePod. While still expensive, I think the new HomePod will do better with the HomePod mini around. No one would have bought Alexa/Google speakers if the first and only options had cost $350 dollars.

  • @natrapnik1
    @natrapnik1 11 місяців тому

    We want a video about your smart home devices and also working space smart devices!
    Keep the good work! 👍

  • @jakebellacera
    @jakebellacera Рік тому +37

    On the question about this being successful or not, I think it will be. I view the original HomePod as a test run, it didn’t really work out as expected, but when the HomePod mini came out, the ecosystem started to be established. I think that the new HomePod will be successful as there is now a “market” for these things now.

    • @kas4751
      @kas4751 Рік тому +1

      Yea I’m having the same thought as u. First one was a proof of concept but people weren’t prepared to spend that much money on a smart speaker. Then they released the minis and that served as their barrier breaking HomePod. Now that people are acquainted to the idea of HomePods, they now have the option to get the big one again for better sound quality, if that’s what they want.

    • @carstenb23
      @carstenb23 Рік тому +1

      That's a really good prediction. I didn't think about that

  • @kefkapalazzo1
    @kefkapalazzo1 Рік тому +7

    I’m happy this is back. I was sad I waited too long for the first one

  • @JustinCachopo
    @JustinCachopo Рік тому +2

    Can you do a studio pair with the new HomePod but also use 2 minis as surround sound behind?

  • @pskyvideo
    @pskyvideo Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the speakers review !)
    Can you please tell me HomePod 2 will work well with Mac Mini / Mac Studio as desktop speakers?
    - After rebooting or shutting down the Mac Mini, will I need to manually turn on the HomePod 2 and connect the speakers to the Mac Mini each time?
    - Will there be a sound delay when watching videos on a Mac Mini?

  • @callum8184
    @callum8184 Рік тому +14

    I have two of the old original HomePod in the lounge set up in stereo. They sound great and work very well for surround sound in a smaller room. The updated version just refines the old HomePod and brings it up to date with thread etc. Glad that Apple have brought it back as a option

  • @chadbuttars9654
    @chadbuttars9654 Рік тому +3

    Great review, and true commentary. I’m getting one because the music is great on these!

  • @Hummer4798
    @Hummer4798 8 місяців тому +1

    When he said “hey siri what’s the temperature in here” it activated my HomePod mini 😂

  • @arleneandmike
    @arleneandmike Рік тому

    Stereo sound with a pair of HomePod 2s is fabulous! Immersive, deep, beautiful! It’s worth the money. ❤

  • @benniewalker312
    @benniewalker312 Рік тому +40

    You got me Marquise, as soon as you said the magic words my original HomePods OG told me the temp lol. For the record I love my original HomePods, but I was never going to pay $350 each for a stereo pair. But when Best Buy put them out for $199. I bought 2. Great purchase at that price.

  • @johnjacobian
    @johnjacobian Рік тому +83

    When Marques asked Siri the temperature, my homepod Mini responded hahaha

  • @simonbolivArrr
    @simonbolivArrr 11 місяців тому

    i have two home pod minis and really love them as my apple tv speakers - will hopefully be upgrading to those in some time

  • @aliettienne2907
    @aliettienne2907 Рік тому

    Marques you make some valid point about the speakers. At least it should pair with other speakers or be a BT pairing speaker. At least it have a removable cables (whatever it worth).

  • @vvvvwwvvvv8843
    @vvvvwwvvvv8843 Рік тому +28

    I bought a ton of these when they were $199 at Best Buy. They sound AMAZING in a stereo pair. Siri is a dumb as a bag of rocks, but sound quality was my priority, and I'm very satisfied. Glad to see Apple is re-launching the product. Even if its not a top seller, it provides a lot of value to a specific niche within the Apple ecosystem that I hope Apple continues to serve.

    • @IAmCjcj11
      @IAmCjcj11 Рік тому +1

      My Fiance got me one whenever they had that sale, and I've been looking at getting a second one again ever since. It was so painful to see apple discontinue it and then watch all the used homepods essentially selling for MSRP. Definitely not a big enough jump for me to want to buy the new one, especially at 300, but I'm really hoping maybe I can pick up a used one around that 200 mark again to have the stereo pair

  • @MillennialGeriatrico
    @MillennialGeriatrico Рік тому +106

    I freaking love your honesty. Thank you for another awesome review Marques!

    • @LosEspookys
      @LosEspookys Рік тому +1

      honesty? lol he’s talking about a speaker

    • @roeI
      @roeI Рік тому +4

      @@LosEspookys and he does so very honestly.

    • @LosEspookys
      @LosEspookys Рік тому +1

      @@roeI i would hope 😂

  • @stephenellwood161
    @stephenellwood161 Рік тому

    Finally a video who says both sides and who is not an apple addict! Thank you for a great review 👍👍👍

  • @clouded9243
    @clouded9243 Рік тому

    The skit at the beginning, very much enjoyed.

  • @FrFrFrog
    @FrFrFrog Рік тому +13

    That intro was amazing! :D And great review as usual

  • @DrizzleAllDay26
    @DrizzleAllDay26 Рік тому +3

    Your intros nowadays are really something else!! 😂 Love them

  • @mnoble61
    @mnoble61 Рік тому

    Nice rundown on the new version-thanks

  • @eric2892
    @eric2892 Рік тому

    Excellent analysis. Sharp delivery.

  • @nub-cake
    @nub-cake Рік тому +7

    Thanks for keepin it 💯 - and giving the most honest reviews of tech. It helps how you put the products in context too.

  • @cynic5581
    @cynic5581 Рік тому +10

    I got a good deal on a HomePod from and a friends and I loved it so much I bought another to make the stereo pair. They just sound soooooo good. I heard the term “room filling sound” and now that makes sense. I’ll often have it playing and in another room it sounds too loud (I live in a condo with neighbors I don’t want to bother) but when I come into the room with the HomePod it’s not loud at all the sound just carries without that “hotspot” near the speaker. I’m happy to see Apple bring it back.

    • @gelfie2208
      @gelfie2208 Рік тому

      Its that the bass, which is all the HomePod has, travels through the walls easily.

  • @CharlesWatson13
    @CharlesWatson13 Рік тому

    i LOVE my OG airpod. One of my favorite pieces of tech along with my OG 12.9 iPad Pro.

  • @cameronjosephmoncada3853
    @cameronjosephmoncada3853 9 місяців тому

    Good honest review, thank you! You’ve gained a subscriber !

  • @christopheranderson5803
    @christopheranderson5803 Рік тому +29

    Plug this into your TV as a soundbar replacement. I did and let me tell you, the sound quality increases significantly with just my two minis paired. But then I have four minis total around the apartment and it's truly amazing how the music and football game comes through. Also, Siri's strong point may never be smarts, but giving it simple directions always works better like playing a particular song or movie. Asking it simple questions like what time does the LA Lakers play tonight. Learning the simple commands and questions work so much better. But still the same old Siri, can't handle anything complex. Thanks Marques Brownlee for the review. I just ordered one!

    • @PunkIAm
      @PunkIAm Рік тому +3

      You must not have watched the whole review

    • @morbly
      @morbly Рік тому

      The only way you can plug this into your TV is if you have Apple TV. It's useless otherwise.

  • @antonmartinsson
    @antonmartinsson Рік тому +39

    Somewhat important note: The fact that you can't set Spotify as as your default music service is a hundred percent on Spotify nowadays. They've had something like two or three years to add support for this, but just won't do it (probably because it'll hurt their image in their legal battles against Apple).

    • @auliamate
      @auliamate Рік тому +1

      Spotify probably wants to jump on the "Apple has a monopoly on their own products" bandwagon and adding support to the HomePod would mean they CHOSE not to, and people are already a little done with Spotify as a company.

    • @ProductManagementUniversity
      @ProductManagementUniversity Рік тому

      Or maybe Spotify doesn’t want to allocate resources to support a device with low sales. That’s why people didn’t develop apps for Windows Phone or post-2013 BlackBerry.

    • @antonmartinsson
      @antonmartinsson Рік тому

      @@ProductManagementUniversity Maybe! Although I’m pretty sure they also haven’t implemented support for AirPlay 2 (which is supported by pretty much every other hardware and software product ever) yet, so I feel like it’s the former personally :)

    • @Neo.555
      @Neo.555 7 місяців тому

      It's not just Spotify though... You cannot choose the default music streaming service if I understand it correctly

  • @anothercoda3403
    @anothercoda3403 2 місяці тому

    In a sublime moment, Marques is asking Siri what the temperature outside is-and my iPhone currently casting this video to my tv via airplay responds, showing the full temperature outside *my* house on my tv…before seamlessly replaying the video with no intervention required on my part. Excellent Siri demo Marques 😂

  • @Blackbird9070
    @Blackbird9070 Рік тому

    That intro is the best thing I have seen in a while

  • @johnvest4216
    @johnvest4216 Рік тому +50

    Really interested to know if the new one sounds noticeably better than the old. That'd be a tough feat since the old one sounds so good ... so not sure how much they can squeeze out of new hardware, chip and signal processing.

    • @isaacoz4730
      @isaacoz4730 Рік тому +2

      I haven’t heard the sound quality myself but from what Marques said, it seems like the quality is nearly identical.

    • @lifeofmisschar
      @lifeofmisschar Рік тому

      Bass is improved

    • @NAdamO-xt4ht
      @NAdamO-xt4ht Рік тому +2

      He says it still sounds great. Honestly 7 tweeters was overkill and I have no doubt this new one still sounds very good.

    • @zappyhaxpro
      @zappyhaxpro Рік тому +1

      It sounds about the same which is a big deal considering it has 2 less tweeters and some other things which he mentioned while having a bit lower price tag

    • @acousticriff7579
      @acousticriff7579 Рік тому +7

      Own both. Its negligible if at all. They both sound excellent.

  • @brianduffytube
    @brianduffytube Рік тому +56

    I’ve got two of the OGs as my TV speakers and it’s been a fantastic experience. Way better than most sound bars I’ve heard and also great for playing music in the living room.

    • @chrisyue
      @chrisyue Рік тому +1

      do you think it's as good as a surround sound system?

    • @gromenteal2133
      @gromenteal2133 Рік тому

      @@chrisyue It’s absolutely NOT.

    • @brianduffytube
      @brianduffytube Рік тому +4

      @@chrisyue A surround sound speaker setup would definitely be superior. The Dolby Atmos feature sounds way better than regular stereo content, but it can’t magically put sound behind you. However, if you’re committed to the Apple ecosystem, have an AppleTV as your primary streaming box, and you listen to a lot of music in the same room as you watch movies/shows, it’s an easy pick over a soundbar.
      One of the biggest selling points for me is simplicity. Between airplay, the apple remote widget in iOS, and Siri, it’s an almost friction free experience for shows/movies/music. I do not want to fuss with a receiver, switching inputs, Bluetooth, the Sonos app, etc. I want it all to “just work”, and that’s what I’ve got.

    • @p3rrypm
      @p3rrypm Рік тому

      They don’t have the top end of the Bose 900 or Sonos arc, so I wouldn’t even consider them for movies and TV. I was hoping apple fixed that in Gen 2, but they didn’t.

  • @jelmerschmidt
    @jelmerschmidt Рік тому

    You can probably avoid the stains on your table just by wiping it off first. I don’t know why but a very powerful solvent smell came from the HomePod box. I wiped the bottom clean and no marking on the wood.

  • @wrthomas69
    @wrthomas69 Рік тому +4

    In my opinion this will shine when paired with a second one it should be a soundbar killer

  • @jackolope2217
    @jackolope2217 Рік тому +3

    Love HomePod minis and have 2. If you want something with more oomph with airplay. IKEA Sonos symfonisk is amazing. And very price effective. Even has a Ethernet jack!

  • @randocalrissian9217
    @randocalrissian9217 Рік тому +58

    I have that home theater HomePod set up with eARC Apple TV. I run my PS5 audio through those speakers and it’s sounds great. I’m sure it introduces latency but after watching Linus’ wifi crippled by Sony wireless speakers, I find my stereo HomePods working great lately.

    • @savioncrawford9947
      @savioncrawford9947 Рік тому

      Soundbars exist specifically for gaming

    • @randocalrissian9217
      @randocalrissian9217 Рік тому

      @@savioncrawford9947 sure but when I bought my HomePod pair I was more interested in the HomePods sound quality and room analysis. eARC Apple TV landed way after I bought them.

  • @LiteVideo
    @LiteVideo Рік тому

    Who makes the coffee table in the vid? Great review as always.

  • @guyg2005
    @guyg2005 9 місяців тому

    Always enjoy your take. I have a 27" iMac from late 2015. I recently upgraded memory to 32 GB. It has one TB of storage. I love the 5K monitor and it looks like I will have to buy at least a Mac Mini and a 27" Apple Studio to get the same 5K features with built in speakers and camera. 17.3M subscribers. You rock. Any suggestions would be appreciated. FYI in 2007 I bought four first generation iPhones that only worked with ATT. Verizon passed. It became a traction in our family to have a iPhone Christmas for a while. Take care, Guy