Why did Ramana Maharshi say that the body is a thought?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 30

  • @sriramanateachingsqa
    @sriramanateachingsqa  Рік тому +1

    BOOK ANNOUNCEMENT: Michael and Sandra announced in the Q&A video on 5th August 2023 the book launch ‘Ramana Maharshi’s Forty Verses on What Is’: ua-cam.com/video/5Um4S63wClc/v-deo.html
    Download the free book sample (includes ‘Introduction by Michael James’): u.pcloud.link/publink/show?code=XZol6NVZvajJMSyzNgz6hM4lY75mkzrbjgY7
    The book is available through the following Amazon websites:
    USA: www.amazon.com/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    United Kingdom: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Canada: www.amazon.ca/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Australia: www.amazon.com.au/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Japan: www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    France: www.amazon.fr/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Germany: www.amazon.de/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Italy: www.amazon.it/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    The Netherlands: www.amazon.nl/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Poland: www.amazon.pl/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Spain: www.amazon.es/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    Sweden: www.amazon.se/dp/B0CCZYJ3NF
    In due time an ebook version will be made available; check the Amazon websites.
    Namo Ramanaya
    🙏🙏🙏

  • @godisgooey
    @godisgooey Рік тому

    Thank you for posting these small gems from Michael’s very much appreciated, long explanations.

  • @patriciaching6392
    @patriciaching6392 9 місяців тому

    Thank you Michael James. ❤ The simplicity of the pure I.

  • @aravindkumar4396
    @aravindkumar4396 Рік тому +1

    Thank you
    Om Namo Bhagavathe SriRamanaya
    🙏🙏🙏

  • @akn650
    @akn650 Рік тому +2

    Ego creates body and experiences which are thoughts orginating from a vase thought of ego.
    Once ego is felt as unreal and extinct, all body or objective thoughts become extinct.
    Om Namo Bhagavathe Sri Ramanaya!
    🙏

  • @partspieces8165
    @partspieces8165 10 місяців тому

    Well said sir.. thank u for this video

  • @JustDontMove111
    @JustDontMove111 Рік тому +1

    Wow nicely explained

  • @michaeldillon3113
    @michaeldillon3113 10 місяців тому

    🙏🕉️

  • @TheDeepening718
    @TheDeepening718 Рік тому +2

    A molecule is a thought with the potential to reveal new thoughts in the form of atoms. An atom is a thought with the potential to reveal new thoughts in the form of protons and electrons. The point is, it's within consciousness. It's like reminding someone they're only dreaming to ease them of their fear.

  • @michaelw.2909
    @michaelw.2909 Рік тому +1

    The body is a thought FORM.
    In realization.. all bodies are experienced as Thought forms.

    • @sandycarter5300
      @sandycarter5300 5 місяців тому +1

      No cohesive, continuing, organized thing constituting a "form". Just data, programs, suggesting appearance/sensation, etc.

  • @arunachalaful
    @arunachalaful Рік тому +1

    🙏

  • @Acode7940
    @Acode7940 Рік тому +1

    Nice

  • @brunoleger3787
    @brunoleger3787 Рік тому +1

    🙏💜🕉️💜🙏

  • @We-Do-NOT-Consent-303
    @We-Do-NOT-Consent-303 8 місяців тому

    Yes, all phenomenon are part of this mental reagion of this Universe.
    But this universe is bigger than mind.
    There are Oceans of Love that are fare greater then the Physical Cosmos.

  • @bigcheech1937
    @bigcheech1937 6 місяців тому

    I was meditating and the body and the surroundings disappeared into this nothingness. I was still aware but I was nothing. After like 5 mins, I found the body again and after a couple attempts opened my eyes. That’s when I knew that the body is just a concept in the mind.

    • @sandycarter5300
      @sandycarter5300 5 місяців тому

      The so-called body & mind are literally programs, "software".
      Everything "known" is just data.
      There's no cohesive, organized, continuing thing called a body or a mind. Data runs & suggests that there's something called a body/mind.

  • @sueannknoblauch2568
    @sueannknoblauch2568 Рік тому +1

    Totally exactly, sounds like myself talking to me

  • @aotlovers9721
    @aotlovers9721 7 місяців тому

    Maybe be brother
    What he is truly trying to say is that
    Body is real,
    but the mental picture we create that i m the body and have image of ourselves in brain that i am what i see in the mirror is fallacy and untrue
    Simply Body is actuality with all its senses
    But the thought or very strong belief or notion that i am this body with all the identifications based on memories (senses) or rembrance of senses is not actuality
    For very deep clarity of that one must deeply go into the question that
    1) Am I the senses ?
    because it is the building block of all the experiences and memories and perception is based on senses
    2) Am i only a bundle of memories ?
    2)what is awareness?
    Is awareness bodily sense (listening, eyes , taste, touch,smell etc)
    Is awareness any of the psychological feeling (desire , fear , happiness, pain )
    Does awareness has anything to do with Body and brain
    To understand the pure awareness
    i think j Krishnamurthy is very right person you towards awareness..
    Simply search j Krishnamurthy on
    Attention, observation and awareness
    I deeply want you too see his videos
    Specially on attention and awareness....!
    So please see

  • @MM-dh3wr
    @MM-dh3wr 3 місяці тому

    Everything is based on the initial hypothesis that Brahman alone real. This requires non-causal entities are to be denied…otherwise initial hypothesis is absurd.

  • @atmannityananda-autognosia
    @atmannityananda-autognosia 5 місяців тому

    The body is a Thought??
    I thought it was an emotion

  • @Marco-wq7nn
    @Marco-wq7nn 9 місяців тому +1

    That the body is just a thought is a wrong statement which leads to a denial of the body and a reduction of it to consiousness. This cannot be right as the body is the basis for the subject-object distinction. On to the body hangs the senses, which means that if the body is just a thought so are the senses. With the senses we see objects, so then all objects are also thoughts and not real. The senses then are also thoughts then and so all perception is all thought based, which leads to pure subjectivity of what we see. A common worldexperience disappear then. All science then would become impossible. Saying it all just thought would lead to absurdities as thought as existing as an object is still acknowledged. Problem with this line of reasoning is that thoughts ittself are objects which are derived from objects we see. Thoughts have a distinctive shape, like letters which we see even when we just think. If what we see is a thought only, then a thought cannot exist as the shape of thoughts are derived from the sensory experience, like also using inner sounds when thinking. So saying that is something is not real because it is a thought, is ittself not real as a thought would be an object also which is defying ittself as all objects are just thoughts. Thoughts denying itsself as an object, because thoughtobjects are thoughts.
    So ofcourse you can deny the idea of thought altogether and only recognize consiousness, but if you accept the idea of thoughts then also you will have to accept the idea of objects as existing, as thoughts are made as objects, and therefore als body, as the body is also an object. Even the reduction of everything to consiousness leads to the problem that consiousness stops being a knower, as there is nothing to be known. The sense of consiousness ittself goes away without experience, as with a mirror that stop acting like one when there is nothing to reflect. You cannot deny one thing and acknowledge the other, whether it is body relating to thought, or thought relating to conciousness. Ramana did not make this clear distinction which leads to confusion and wrong statements about reality.

    • @aotlovers9721
      @aotlovers9721 7 місяців тому

      Brother
      That was really deeep that once again
      Need to have a great look on your statement to bring clarity
      And dig deeper

    • @aotlovers9721
      @aotlovers9721 7 місяців тому

      Maybe be brother
      What he is truly trying to say is that
      Body is real,
      but the mental picture we create that i m the body and have image of ourselves in brain that i am what i see in the mirror is fallacy and untrue
      Simply Body is actuality with all its senses
      But the thought or very strong belief or notion that i am this body with all the identifications based on memories (senses) or rembrance of senses is not actuality
      For very deep clarity of that one must deeply go into the question that
      1) Am I the senses ?
      because it is the building block of all the experiences and memories and perception is based on senses
      2) Am i only a bundle of memories ?
      2)what is awareness?
      Is awareness bodily sense (listening, eyes , taste, touch,smell etc)
      Is awareness any of the psychological feeling (desire , fear , happiness, pain )
      Does awareness has anything to do with Body and brain
      To understand the pure awareness
      i think j Krishnamurthy is very right person you towards awareness..
      Simply search j Krishnamurthy on
      Attention, observation and awareness
      I deeply want you too see his videos
      Specially on attention and awareness....!
      So please see

    • @GeertMeertens
      @GeertMeertens 6 місяців тому

      You seem to miss the point. Ramana said life is not different from a dream. Any dream appears in consciousness, is experienced by consciousness and consists of consciousness: consciousness is all there is. Life is but a dream. If you don't agree, there is a belief worth investigating.

    • @MM-dh3wr
      @MM-dh3wr 3 місяці тому

      You are correct. These people are mesmerised by the expression that you are GOD…that is not true. Space, time, actions, matter( includes body), machines( thought, mind etc) are the five entities ….in the universe that are non-causal…. But you are different from that

    • @Marco-wq7nn
      @Marco-wq7nn 3 місяці тому

      @@GeertMeertens that is not the case. Life seems to be a dream in the sense that you are the dreamer as you see the totality of the dream in you. But you cannot pull this analogy fully through to reality. This will lead to total solipsism that everybody you meet, even your mother is a creation by your mind. That other people ceases to exist when you are not looking at them and have no reality. Also all natural laws are then dreamed up by you, suggesting that you change gravity by just changing the dream, and can start to fly when you feel like. However reality is not like that.

  • @sourcetext
    @sourcetext Рік тому

    You don't understand it because you never had a Spiritual experience in your whole life 😢, and yet you teach as if your a teacher . do your Meditation and see for yourself. ❤
    You cant figure it out ...you can only EXPERIENCE it ....and then try to explain it to others ( a True Teacher) .

    • @kenjones102
      @kenjones102 Місяць тому

      @johnmcdonald260 Through a pure mind the absolute can be perceived. Ramakrishna’s position (somewhere in The Gospel of Ramakrishna) is that Brahman, the absolute, can be realized by means of a purified mind (Upanishads say you can perceive Brahman through a refined intellect) and that the pure atma, pure buddhi, and pure mind are one and the same.

  • @rviswanathan
    @rviswanathan Рік тому +1

    🙏