How The Original Pinocchio Was Darker And More Twisted
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 гру 2022
- We all know that most Disney films originated from older fairytales, such as those of Hans Christian Andersen. But with all these stories, why don’t we get to know the original Pinocchio for once?
The Generalists explore the vast expanse of world history to provide you tidbits of general history knowledge to boast in every social setting.
SOURCES:
The Story of a Puppet, or The Adventures of Pinocchio | C. Collodi | First American edition (whitmorerarebooks.com)
The Adventures of Pinocchio (uchicago.edu)
The Real Story of Pinocchio Tells No Lies | Travel | Smithsonian Magazine
Gaetana Marrone; Paolo Puppa (26 December 2006). Encyclopedia of Italian Literary Studies
In the Original Story, Pinocchio killed Jiminy Cricket, Got His Feet Burnt Off, and was Hanged and Left for Dead (todayifoundout.com)
Created by James Liam and AviddaJuan. LIKE and SUBSCRIBE to The Generalists to hear more fascinating stories from across the history of the world.
More from The Generalists:
bit.ly/31H9syq
More from narrator AviddaJuan:
bit.ly/3rVl4c9
#disney
#pinocchio
#geppetto
Who's here to connect dots after playing Lies of P? 😂
ME, RIGHT HERE!
Lies of P gang stand up🗿🙌🏽
Me lol
Yessir
LEZ GO BOIS
My Grandma gave me a 1914 edition of Pinocchio when I was 8, which I treasure to this day.
Collodi wrote ‘Pinocchio’ also as an indirect satire of the then Kingdom of Italy, as testified by Collodi’s vivid depiction of the gendarmes as brutal and dumb, and of the judiciary system as incompetent and corrupt. Most characters in the book live in a state of unredeemable poverty, without any help or assistance from their community, within a society dominated by backwardness and inequality.
As to the darkness of the original text, yes, it is dark indeed. I remember from my childhood of receiving at least two ‘watered down’ editions as gift: in one of them, Pinocchio is not ‘impiccato a un albero’, meaning ‘hanged (ie. by the neck) from a tree’, but ‘appeso a un albero’, meaning generally ‘hung from a tree’, like a salami. In the other edition, he is simply ‘legato a un albero’, meaning ‘tied up onto a tree’. Pinocchio effectively throws a hammer towards the Cricket, but the fate of the animal is redacted. Likewise, in my childhood editions of the story, nobody ever ‘dies’ as it happens in the original, but simply ‘faints’, a euphemism to indicate something like a coma. Believe it or not, I never read the original before the advent of the Internet. It’s not because the original is censured in Italy or frown upon: more simply, the editors of children books prefer to play safe and redact the most controversial parts so that their edition can go on sale without risking any bad publicity.
Yeah they getting done for attempted murder on numerous situations and scenarios 😭
Here after finishing Lies of P
Now THAT captures the dark parts lol
I actually like the book better, it’s a good read and does a much better job teaching the moral of the story
not really it simply just settles at always blindly obey you're authority's no matter what the disney film actually handles it much better without automatically demonizing all childish behavior in general
@@jessicapinkman-xm2eg wtf are you talking about, at no point does any of the book tell you to blindly obey authority, i read this book just last night, and you made this up
@@jessicapinkman-xm2egthe hell do you read? Original story is how children don't appreciate the sacrifices made for them and how in youth is easy to make mistakes that will make ypur life misserable, because young don't listen to older people advices and rebel against them. This book is so sad to read, especially about doll creator, shaking from cold, because he sold his last coat for book, so his "son" can be literate and live better than him.
@@user-wg5mp4lc5s that’s the point, if you make bad choices consequences ensue but if you make good decisions it pays off in the end.
@@user-wg5mp4lc5s
It's really just about bad decisions m8. I mean you called it childish but grown men, from what I've seen, can act fairly childish as you put it.
I'm no friend to authority either m8 but don't jump off the deep end and say ALL authority sucks and that this thing says you should obey ALL authority. It's really just about bad decisions m8.
Who here after lies of P
👋
Me damn this comment
Ayo
Here after i finished lie's of p
I was looking for another one,great game 9/10
Wonder why so many new Pinnochios recently? Just found your channel. Nicely done.
“Our kids are disobedient little bastards! Write a cautionary tale that will scare them into shape!!”
……. “Oh my God…. “
Fun fact there's originally italian cel-animated adaptation that was going to be released before disney snow white the first fully cel-animated film but due to budget issues it was cancelled entirely
There are also alot fairy tales in Persian history that are passed on generation from generation mom to kids, but now because of social media this wil vanish. All cultures have their own fairy tales
I'm currently writing my first serious novel that combines Filipino mythology, history, and epics in my small attempt to not let those cultural things disappear through time. Hope to learn more about Persian mythology someday.
I just watched Guillermos & really liked it!
A favorite as well.
I couldn't finish it. It's all over the place.
The 1978 version is the most accurate
The people who are watching this probably won’t even know what I’m talking about but if you do, I’m here after playing lies of p.
Lies of P made me buy The Adventures of Pinnochio and The Wizard of Oz lmao
I am here from Lies of P
The Fox and cat are pretty well connected characters and ik you’ve probably heard this but Lies of P transferred those two well into the game! I absolutely love that game and as a souls veteran who has played every souls game countless times, LoP is one of the best Soulslikes ever! Anyways, I absolutely love the darker stories.
Who? Uzi boxer? 😂
So many things making sense after playing Lies of P.
I prefer the brighter 1940 Disney movie of Pinocchio, because I loved it with all my heart for its charming message and the kindness of my favourite puppet. I do like the book as well, not equally to the Disney movie, but because I feel it's still worth reading as children would understand what Collodi was trying to show them, using the original troublesome puppet as an example. Just like how Shakespeare created relatable characters to show the people what fates would await them
Cool video. Next do an analysis of the real political subtext of the original pinocchio? (you know, the effects of growing political power of usurers)
as if the disney movie wasn't disturbing
Didn't really feel so dark. It is exact story was adapted by russian writer Alexey Tolstoy in 1936 named "Golden key" or "Adventures of Buratino" and movie based on it came out in 1939.
Disney version is darker actually in my opinion
Love your content. Remember me when you're famous -
I've got no strings......
To hold me down.......
To make me fret......
Or make me frown......
I had strings.......
But now I'm free.......
There are no strings on me........
This sounds more like warning an threat rather than a song 💀🔪
The Russia one😂😂😂 homie said that’s just too much wood!! 😂
Well, how could the storyline end with someone shooting a rifle at someone else?
Darker and grittier version of course
Thanks for the video- The original book was a lot darker and a lot different than the Disney adaptation with the Fox and Cat hanging PJ and the scene with the blue fairy had a poodle pulling a carriage made out of sponge cakes pulled by dozens of white mice was very imaginative - so imaginative that Disney did not even attempt it. I see there are under currents and directives to children to obey parents and to work hard (protestant work ethic) and go to school - else you will become a donkey (the GOP could have a field day with this). My son and I have been working on our own adaption PJ where the main character PJ is a teddy bear who comes to life when magic wool is used for stuffing and his nose glows red when he lies. We have made a trailer and hope to have the movie finished early 2024. Anyways your video has been quite educational - in our adaption Pinocchio now being PJ a teddy bear we try and stick close to the original story by Carlo Collodi which was pretty revolutionary for its time making inanimate objects sentient and alive and a lot of the tales such as the Fox and cat were to teach kids to avoid fraudsters and tricksters which has as much relevance today as it did then. Also the story deals with rebirth and has a lot of relevance to kids with disabilities that feel that they are not totally accepted as real boys - yearning to be accepted as real boys and the underlying message is that one can only be human if they are capable of empathy - caring for others which Pinocchio highlighted to the Blue Fairy caring for his Papa Geppetto
Nice
The original Pinocchio was also much more preachy and condescending. I think it could only have been written by someone who hated children. That's why I'll say the 1940 Disney version is actually 100% BETTER than the book. Not because it's less dark, but because Walt Disney understood children much more than Carlo Collodi.
and the disney wasn't dark to you either i have a feeling that the last time you even watched this film
0:22 pause
4:53 which Pinocchio is that?
This one is Guillermo del Toro's version
The Guillermo Del Toro's version which won an Oscar.
Could Pinocchio be Osiris ...Osiris grew into s tree ❤
I prefer the original or at least the darker grittier versions. The closest to that is the 1971/1978 adaptation.
Too much wood.
"HEHE WOOD" HOLDS UP PIECE OF WOOD HEHE WOOD
Pinocchio Gave Gippeto A Charlie Horse#
yeah but it's like exceedingly juvenile
Were so lucky not to have lived in them times
I enjoy the lies of p version
Where is Pinocchio's real mother?
I hate infjs.
I don’t think Pinocchio was bad just gullible.
He killed Jiminy
@@user-ky8nd2rz4f it was an accident
you are right, the book never said he was bad, it said if you do bad things, or, you be lazy and dont work hard, only bad things will come your way, and that if you get in line with the wrong types of people, you are the one who will suffer
Nobody starts out bad. It happens slowly over time, beginning from seemingly innocent disobedience, but can get out of control if someone is too prideful and stubborn to admit when they made a mistake. Pinocchio reaches that edge a few times, but turns back and apologizes to his friends and families for not listening to their warnings and assuming he should trust strangers instead.
🧟🙀:A👻Haunted🪵Object🌀##️⃣
Lazy as .... Wikipedia reader!
How's he lazy?
@@anniesolomon4876 Read the Wikipedia page about Pinocchio and you will understand why...
I want to share with you the truth and life.
All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23). God is holy and the punishment for sin is Hell. For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 6:23). Jesus Christ is the way, the truth and the life (John 14:6). He died on the cross and rose again on the third day for us all. Repent, believe in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior and follow Him
Anybody here after playing Lies of P?? Lol
The “original” Pinocchio (which is the true Pinocchio - because americans don’t know anything) is an Italian classic and an icon of childhood. Stop trying to ruin his legacy for people.
First of all, you can get your point across without insulting Americans, because we know plenty of things watch your mouth
Oh the irony in this comment. Must suck to have a sad life huh buddy?
@@user-ky8nd2rz4fCould have done without the ad hominem but to be fair Americans have a tendency to happy end everything. Nothing wrong with it. Just noticeable.