Comparing old Vocaloid songs with their remakes part 3

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 84

  • @bluestar3939
    @bluestar3939  11 місяців тому +266

    For the vocals, when I didn't mention a software version that's because those are human singers, not vocal synths like Vocaloid or CeVIO.
    I considered not putting the piano versions of Amatsu Kitsune since those count as covers but they were also remade multiple times so I ended up including every version.
    In case anyone wonders what the BPM is, it basically measures how fast a song is. I decided to show it because sometimes the remakes are played at a different tempo than the original. Why didn't I put it on every versions of Amatsu Kitsune ? Because marasy didn't play to a metronome, he just speeds up and slows down so I can't count a BPM. But he played at a specific tempo when Rin was singing because Vocaloids need a BPM.
    The album CATEGORY【L】came out yesterday. When I saw the album trailer I thought I'll include one of those remakes in my next video.

  • @akfc.6978
    @akfc.6978 11 місяців тому +661

    Manager: How many versions of Amatsu Kitsune would you and your team-mates like to make?
    Marasy: *Yes*

  • @prince_8bit
    @prince_8bit 11 місяців тому +756

    Tengaku slays so hard in every version

    • @39IA
      @39IA 11 місяців тому +3

      100% agree

    • @lalaforuuu
      @lalaforuuu 11 місяців тому +33

      I just love that robotic sound of earlier vocaloid songs. It may stem from nostalgia, but it just hits different.

    • @FoolMisinfo
      @FoolMisinfo 11 місяців тому +9

      I respect your opinion but honestly the newest version makes it sound more robotic and vibrant than the original.
      Yes the original sounds quite robotic has well but other things such as the power , feeling and pure pouring from the guitar riffs , the drummer and music overall enhances Rin's vocals really well.
      Meanwhile the new version has less of the music and more of the vocals where said vocals have more of a distortion inclusion vibration, tengaku is a combination of both music and vocaloid which on a music standpoint would be chaotic but it isn't, it's combined well.
      I'm not saying Rin and Len wouldn't go well, in fact I think there's versions of tengaku has len where he sounds beautiful, strong yet sensitive, rin could be the stronger vocals while len could be lower and combine well but that's not what happens in the newest version.
      In the end I still appreciate the recreations of my favorite vocaloid song :D and respect your opinion because either way it is an amazing song and rightfully deserves it's popularity.

    • @straw-b6f
      @straw-b6f 11 місяців тому +1

      Couldn’t agree more😊

    • @DrizzingSakuras
      @DrizzingSakuras 11 місяців тому +3

      The "tengaku wo" sounds grittier in the old ver tho

  • @blazi64
    @blazi64 11 місяців тому +430

    I miss DECO's old way of tuning so much

    • @lalaforuuu
      @lalaforuuu 11 місяців тому +139

      That old robotic sound is what gives it so much charm. It's what made Vocaloid, well, Vocaloid!

    • @staz6881
      @staz6881 11 місяців тому +5

      Same 😢

    • @Carlyy2001
      @Carlyy2001 10 місяців тому +41

      It’s kinda why I like PinocchioP a lot. He still manages to keep the “vocaloid” sound but also having it sound melodic; a good mix of legato and staccato.

    • @monsteralfie
      @monsteralfie 10 місяців тому +16

      fr miku sounds so squeaky in his new tuning style.

    • @HanazukaNo.2
      @HanazukaNo.2 5 місяців тому

      ​@@monsteralfiesongs r still a banger

  • @rasberrymilk4753
    @rasberrymilk4753 11 місяців тому +194

    man...the original two breaths walking is still the best one...

  • @Mono-hz4ii
    @Mono-hz4ii 11 місяців тому +138

    The new version of tengaku is everything I loved about the original but better somehow

  • @yurshen.spooky
    @yurshen.spooky 11 місяців тому +99

    3:12 i was so confused when i could hear yukinas voice :')) bc i was like she isnt a voice bank and then i remembered ROSE exists

  • @everyyxy8425
    @everyyxy8425 11 місяців тому +109

    i love the ones that like, add on to the original, like the newest tengaku version. its so damn good and len being there with rin adds a really cool new layer to the song
    Also i dont really think my roar counts? it wasnt really utsuP's song in the first place, its towa's song he made for her

    • @bluestar3939
      @bluestar3939  11 місяців тому +16

      For My Roar you literally said it, Utsu-P made it. And then he remade it with a vocal synth. It doesn't matter who owns the song, it has a vocaloid or other vocal synth version and got remade.

    • @ngantran3218
      @ngantran3218 11 місяців тому +3

      ​@@bluestar3939Halyosy's Snowman also got a remake if you saw the snowman novel announcement and the rerec version

    • @sarahemojicat7477
      @sarahemojicat7477 14 днів тому

      ​@@bluestar3939 i miss deco...

  • @princekizi_zu6276
    @princekizi_zu6276 11 місяців тому +99

    Halyosy just released a new version of Snowman today!
    He also made Fire@Flower (Sparkle ver) 2 years ago, I think?

  • @realryuugu
    @realryuugu 11 місяців тому +63

    itd be so funny if this video included all of the remakes and rearrangements of utsu-p's "doll", utsu is the king of remakes lol. always somehow upgrading his sound... one of the best producers to date without a doubt.
    also another song with lots of remakes is kitsune no yomeiri from masa, i just love how each version has its own twist!! its very fun to listen to.

  • @monsteralfie
    @monsteralfie 10 місяців тому +12

    i didnt know utsu-p made songs this upbeat and cheerful. haha

  • @EnderKitty.
    @EnderKitty. 11 місяців тому +14

    15:52 "Please do not the cat" vibes with that lyric 😭

  • @fuyumijun
    @fuyumijun 11 місяців тому +44

    Since we’re counting versions with human singers, marasy actually did yet another rearrange of amatsu kitsune for the album voca-you 01 (october 2021)! It appears that god works hard but marasy works harder LOL

    • @bluestar3939
      @bluestar3939  11 місяців тому +10

      I missed it because it wasn't published by marasy himself but by the singer. Also for some reason the other songs in that album are just covers where the instrumental is just in a different key but in marasy's case the instrumental is specifically made for this album.
      And by the way that's not even the only version I missed, I found it after I made the video but he made an other piano version in the album 狐の日記帳 in August 2013.

    • @fuyumijun
      @fuyumijun 11 місяців тому +6

      @@bluestar3939 it’s oddly difficult to find details about that particular 2021 rearrange online, so it’s super easy to miss given it requires a ton of digging to even confirm ;w; I’ve seen it be listed as “amatsu kitsune -marasy piano ver-“ on a few sites, but otherwise I think it was only really mentioned that marasy had been the one who did the rearrange when the singer confirmed it on twitter. The reason why that specific song cover was the only one on the album that received an instrumental rearrange was actually because the singer and marasy had been doing a collab together at the time! There’s so many different versions of amatsu kitsune from over the past 10+ years that I feel like it’d be impossible to keep track of them all, so thank you for compiling so many of them!! There were a lot that I hadn’t heard of until now, including the 2013 version you just mentioned! ^^

  • @sappametalyippierz
    @sappametalyippierz 11 місяців тому +15

    marasy POV: damn i should make a new version of amatsu kitsune

  • @kisu_odd
    @kisu_odd 11 місяців тому +152

    Nashimoto Ui has released a new album, it's got a couple remakes. thought it would be cool if you included one of his songs sometime in one of these videos! Props for also including the Zsasz version of Striped melody btw!! Since you're including the human vocal versions, Nashimoto Ui also has a band called Araiyakashiko where he covers his songs with him on vocals, and Mononokenonomo which is a collab band with him and YM, they have a cover version of Nashimoto Ui's song "罵詈騒音" with YM on vocals.

    • @kisu_odd
      @kisu_odd 11 місяців тому +1

      i absolutely love these videos btw.

    • @adeaoud3404
      @adeaoud3404 11 місяців тому +4

      WAIT WHAT ALBUM PLSGIVE ME THE NAME I Love Nashimoto

    • @kisu_odd
      @kisu_odd 11 місяців тому +3

      @@adeaoud3404 I can't send the link but it's called 月斧鍵斧一 and it exclusively uses Koharu rikka

  • @Kurikaeshiso
    @Kurikaeshiso 11 місяців тому +60

    I love when you make comparing video of old Vocaloid songs to the new Ver of the song.

    • @Kurikaeshiso
      @Kurikaeshiso 14 днів тому

      what are your talking about?

    • @Kurikaeshiso
      @Kurikaeshiso 14 днів тому

      @@stephaniepaolatelloespinoz3747ohh

    • @Kurikaeshiso
      @Kurikaeshiso 12 днів тому

      @@stephaniepaolatelloespinoz3747Oh!!

  • @abraham-kun4144
    @abraham-kun4144 11 місяців тому +48

    For the part 4, can I suggest MASA Works DESIGN's On My Seventh Birthday, Utsu-P's Fools Are Attracted to Anomaly, and Pinocchio-P's Psychedelic Smile?

  • @madysnachos
    @madysnachos 11 місяців тому +21

    tengaku no necesitaba remake, la original es perfecta

  • @warfu_
    @warfu_ 11 місяців тому +12

    Just so you know, buzzG has also been remastering some of his classics and masterpieces! (Fairytale is a good one even if it was popularized by cillia's cover!)

  • @angieartistic3605
    @angieartistic3605 10 місяців тому +5

    I came here to learn about new songs so I will write the list to add them to my playlist hshs.
    Tengaku
    Two breaths walking
    My roar
    Amatsu Kitsune
    Revenge Drama Genocider
    Shimashima melody
    Violence trigger
    Scentensive
    The rampage of Hatsune Miku
    Teo

  • @fishy-531
    @fishy-531 11 місяців тому +10

    its funny bc ive only heard tengaku in its pjdx cool melody version, i never knew it was like that lol

  • @iamnotsarcastic2847
    @iamnotsarcastic2847 11 місяців тому +26

    Can I suggest Children record (IA) and it's remake (miku) for the next part please?

  • @_.mochi.jen._
    @_.mochi.jen._ 11 місяців тому +17

    Wait hold up…. Teo has background vocals…..

  • @kissfromasiren
    @kissfromasiren 9 місяців тому +2

    wayyyyyyyyy too many versions of Kitsune but the 10th anniversary one sounds really good

  • @kriss0ul
    @kriss0ul 10 місяців тому +1

    I LOVE YOU UTSU-P

  • @warfu_
    @warfu_ 11 місяців тому +1

    Yoko Takahashi sang Amatsu Kitsune!? THE YOKO?? OMG

  • @marinamoraes6174
    @marinamoraes6174 11 місяців тому +10

    May I suggest Children Record (2012), Children Record (2013, :Re Version, from Mekakicity Records), Children Record (2014, Mekakucity Actors/M's version), Children Record Re:boot (2021), Children Record (2022, VBS 1st album version) and Children Record Re:boot (2023, Roselia version)? There is also a version released in a 1st Place IA compilation album that includes ONE as a singer, but I dunno if that one was made by Jin

    • @marinamoraes6174
      @marinamoraes6174 11 місяців тому +2

      There are also a number of Kagerou Daze versions that could make for a video, most likely. There is the original (2011), then Jin's acoustic self cover (2011?), then the Mekakucity Days version (2012), there is a self cover he sings with a member of another band, Strobe Light I think? (2013), Mekakucity Actors/M's version, it's sung by a member of the above mentioned band (2014) and Proseka version (2021). There might be more I can't remember

    • @abraham-kun4144
      @abraham-kun4144 10 місяців тому +2

      Regarding to 2023 versión of Children Record (Re:boot), there's a error. It's Afterglow, not Roselia.

  • @Nexlation
    @Nexlation 11 місяців тому +6

    You should compare some of Nanahoshi Orchestra's older work like Rubik's Cube and Mythologias end to the remakes he did on his album paranormal legacy (or in case of mythologias end, the gumi version).

  • @Jflowwer
    @Jflowwer 11 місяців тому

    Tengaku for Yokune Ruko is GOD

  • @akfc.6978
    @akfc.6978 11 місяців тому +9

    May I recommend Moon by Iroha (Sasaki) and The Chattering of Teeth and Lack of Common Sanity/The Chattering Lack of Common Sense by GHOST??

    • @catcuty1223
      @catcuty1223 11 місяців тому

      I think they already did moon in one of the previous videos

  • @romin8829
    @romin8829 11 місяців тому +5

    If you decide to do part 4, I recommend Mikazuki Step by r-906, which got released in 2020 and got a remake in 2023.

  • @shinxnxme
    @shinxnxme 11 місяців тому +2

    Wasnt expecting to see towa here lol

  • @user----------------------z377
    @user----------------------z377 11 місяців тому +3

    Yeah new songs to add to my vocaloid playlist

  • @gretaonneken7988
    @gretaonneken7988 11 місяців тому +3

    Okay imma comment which version I like most for each
    Original: Celestial Fox
    Remake: Tengaku, Two Breaths Walking, My Roar, Disappearance Addiction, Shimashima Melody, Teo, Violence Trigger, Scentensive, The Rampage Of Hatsune Miku
    This is the third part am I even suprised that it's same again? Remakes are often more polished but sometimes I'm just too used to the og

  • @ReigoVassal
    @ReigoVassal 10 місяців тому

    May I suggest
    - Kami no mani mani (2020)
    - Donor song (new ver)
    - Fairytale [reunion]. (especially before the final chorus part. It feels magical)
    - Kimi ga suki from Yukke. It basically also his evolution

  • @aj7842
    @aj7842 11 місяців тому +1

    if you do make a 4th part you should bring up world’s end umbrella by hachi :)

  • @Denzi-P
    @Denzi-P 11 місяців тому +2

    I’m the next video can you do the chattering of teeth and the lack of common sanity compared to the chattering lack of common sense by GHOST?

  • @REI0o0o0
    @REI0o0o0 11 місяців тому +16

    I think the MARETU remix of Disappearance Addiction would count as official since it's uploaded on Kairiki Bear's official channel

    • @bluestar3939
      @bluestar3939  11 місяців тому +15

      This video is about remakes, not remixes. A remake is when a producer rework their own song.

  • @milanesa_P
    @milanesa_P 11 місяців тому

    Tengaku has a remake? 0_0

  • @GanriaHaah
    @GanriaHaah 10 місяців тому

    May i suggest kaito - snowman?

  • @decko_choripan
    @decko_choripan 11 місяців тому

  • @Iinemiida
    @Iinemiida 11 місяців тому

    No “hey William” by omoi? 😢

  • @zukaritapresident
    @zukaritapresident 11 місяців тому +4

    i hope that the next release will include leia

    • @average_player0
      @average_player0 11 місяців тому

      leia is such a banger, hope so too-

  • @azunomes
    @azunomes 11 місяців тому +9

    0/10, needs more amatsu kitsune

  • @LuciusTY
    @LuciusTY 11 місяців тому

    where are the other versions of disappearance addiction ?

    • @bluestar3939
      @bluestar3939  11 місяців тому +1

      This video is about remakes, not remixes

  • @not_holl0w
    @not_holl0w 11 місяців тому +2

    Tengaku PLEASE come to en and jp pjsk. OR JUSR BE IN EVERY SERVER BRO PLEASE

    • @not_holl0w
      @not_holl0w 11 місяців тому

      NEVERMIND ITS OUT HOLY SHIT SHIJO!1’qbqvqvw?1!1?1? AUAUAUAUAN I NEED SHIHO ALT COVER TENGAKU.

    • @not_holl0w
      @not_holl0w 11 місяців тому +2

      Nvm no alt covers im sad 😢😢😢😢😔😔😔💔💔💔

    • @everyyxy8425
      @everyyxy8425 11 місяців тому +2

      its on jp

  • @weabooavatar399
    @weabooavatar399 11 місяців тому +8

    Put timestamps

    • @asshole_wii
      @asshole_wii 11 місяців тому

      do it yourself retard