Want to help the channel out? Consider donating so I can upgrade my hardware: goo.gl/DJX619 Subscribe: goo.gl/vBao71 Join the (superfun!) Discord: discord.gg/3jbNnaK And follow me on Twitter: goo.gl/i4BGcy!
Judging by its use in the Rebels tv show, I think the Advance has really powerful blasters so it can function as a bomber that can cripple a cruiser in a single run but they can still function as anti-fighter weapons, making the Advance a glass cannon in this scenario.
Also a good choice! Especially since only the specific instances of the TIE Advanced used by Vader would be more finely tuned than one used by elite Imperial pilots.
I feel as if the X1 was highly underrated by you for a pretty large reason. You need to remember that while there were other Tie Advance variants, the X1 was designed for the use of Vader, and Vader alone. I get you want the equal pilots deal and all, but considering the X1 couldn't be piloted to it's full potential without Vader in the cockpit, it takes away from the ship itself, seeing that he was the only one who used it consistently. Not saying the victory should go to him, though I doubt Kylo is a better starpilot than Vader, but I think that needs to be considered.
3:03 Cluster missiles in Rogue One were the best. Especially once you've found the homing cluster missiles upgrade, which is probably more like how cluster missiles would functionally be in Star Wars.
The Malevolence has to turn it's entire hull to aim it's main weapon which is really a long range AOE weapon. It does raise the question of what happens if the ring of ions is smaller than the target it's firing at. Does the ring break up? Also the Resurgent is 50 years more advanced, is designed to attack large warships and has a large fighter compliment that it can deploy quickly, the Malevolence would rely entirely on luck to even try and land a shot that might not even win the battle.
@@AngelSamael is the target is larger it will take the full brunt of the ION cannon, which is around 1.5x the power of the Hoth ion cannon. The resurgent may have power, but if it’s power is offline then that power isn’t there (obviously).
I love the Silencer. Especially with the newer info that shows it has cloaking, and the missile launchers are actually one proton torpedo launcher and one warhead launcher. Or at least Kylo Ren's version does.
I have a distaste for the cockpit of the TIE silencer. It's a good looking craft and it makes a certain sense to have a boxy cockpit frame on a ship like that... I just don't know, it makes it seem more cargo hauler than sleek star-interceptor.
The TIE Advanced has the same wings as the TIE Bomber. It also uses the standard ball cockpit as the TIE Fighter. It wouldn't too much taller than the TIE Silencer. But yes, with 35 years of technological advancement in technology the TIE Avenger, sorry Silencer would win!
It was a good idea to take out modifications. In both cannon and legends, Vader heavily customized his ship, although what these upgrades were is unknown.
Ideas spiderman vs Darth Vader Z-95 headhunter (as it was during the clone wars) vs the x-wing And Han Solo vs a republic commando That's it hope you guys like it!
the TIE defender could very likely compete with a twin tail... if you really want a 1v1 fight a royal guard tie or Normal TIE/In with shields will deal with an X-wing just fine...dont forget the TIE/In has speed and maneuverability on its side while the X wings only 1 was durability and they are the same weapon wise....
Titan Helios Agreed, but the Tie Defender was the peak of imperial fighter design, and as such carried a lot of weapons, including 4 lasers, 2 ion cannons, and missiles, as well as having pretty decent shielding
Evan Edmonds Do you even know what the tie defender is? It's a complete reversal of imperial fighter doctrine, being a ship easily capable of destroying any other ship, or even engaging a capital ship 1v1. It would easily annihilate a tri fighter. The buzz droids wouldn't be enough to even the match.
Depends on the model of A-wing. The A wing has speed and maneuverability but the X-wing has shields and firepower as well as the strategic advantage of a droid.
They're both very respectable ships, however, I think the Silencer is the more advanced and, overall, capable ship. That having been said, I think a better matchup would've been the TIE Silencer vs. the TIE Hunter or Defender. EDIT: I know you probably made this video before this information was widely available, but the Silencer has 4 medium laser cannons, and also 2 heavy laser cannons, one between each wing. Then of course there are the 2 launchers, which can be loaded with either concussion missiles, mag-pulse warheads, or proton torpedos.
The TIE Silencer is actually equipped with 2 standard laser cannons, 2 heavy laser cannons, 1 concussion missile/mag-pulse warhead launcher, and 1 proton torpedo launcher.
Alfred Elfgren I mean, Thrawn was in charge of an entire system worth of ships and crew, Cole was in charge of one fleet. The technological difference is always something SW vs Halo, In Cole Protocol it was made clear that Preston was an excellent tactician
You know, the TIE Silencer kinda makes me think of what would result from the ship designers at Cloud Imperium Games getting a chance to take a crack at the TIE fighter design. It really looks like a hybrid of both Star Wars and Star Citizen design aesthetics.
This is one of, if not my favorite thing to listen to. I say listen because truthfully its pictures but I love this series. I wish I could donate to help but I can't but I guess the best I can do is give these kind words. So keep up the phenomenal work :D
darth vader's tie has a power hogging/inefficient shield generator. so if the shields are on, then the tie is a slug or very slightly faster than a standard tie. but with the shields off, the tie is pretty fast....
well.. the Emperor class is more of a carrier variant out of its sister ships and has much less offensive capabilities compared to the Retribution or the apocalypse
warhammer is ridiculous but i thoroughly believe a executor class star destroyer would curb stomp any ship from warhammer xD ( though war hammers ground units would destroy starwars lol, if i remember right a regular star destroyer's shields and weapons put out ridiculous amounts of energy ( like a 3rd of the sun) so the executor would be pure bullshit
Clearly you never heard of the Gloriana class battleship :P Base size is bigger than the Executor with the biggest Loyalist ship being 26kms, easily dwarfing the 19kms the Executor is. Also you need a source for that claim.
If you take Rogue Squadron as reference for Tie Advanced, then you should revisit Tie Fighter where : - Concussive missiles are GUIDED (and faster and need less time to catch lock compared against Photon torps) - Tie Advanced have it, and uses it. The fact is that can use any warhead, including photon torps, heavy rockets and space mines. - Compared against Tie Figther , it have shields, it's faster and have a FTL engine.
I was going to suggest a Fighter match but I did not know if you did them much but here it goes NABO STARFIGHTER vs ATTACKER ( INDEPENDENCE DAY ) respect.
I think you analysis is pretty on point. It is 35 tests newer. That's 35 years to learn from the shortcomings of previous T.I.E. iteration. I agree, the shields must be stronger now and the firepower of the Silencer seems to far out class the older interceptor. Unless of course Vader is flying it, guiding the the cluster missiles himself. In which case that is a new ball game. Also Vader was a supremely disciplined pilot, where Kyle has show hisself to be wild, erratic, undisciplined, basically a rage monster out of control. Even in a superior ship, with Vader's discipline, significantly greater power in the Force, able to multitask elaborate maneuvers while guiding the cluster rockets, Vader wins 9 out of 10 time. Just sayin'.
1. Inexpugnable-class tactical command ship VS Lucrehulk-class 2. Venator-class Star Destroyer VS Harrower-class dreadnought 3. Kom'rk-class fighter VS X-wing starfighter 4. Victory I-class Star Destroyer VS Harrower-class dreadnought 5. Kom'rk-class fighter VS StarViper-class attack platform
If Darth Vader was piloting the X1 and Kylo was piloting the Silencer, the Silencer would not win. Vader is an extremely superior pilot to Kylo. Although the the Silencer is more advanced, the X1 would still win because Vader is piloting it. It's Darth Vader. It's obvious he would win.
Zann Consortium Aggressor Class Star Destroyer (Tyber Zann' s flagship the Merciless) vs.UNSC Remembrance- Class Frigate (The Mother of Invention; the director of project freelancer's flagship(Red vs. Blue))
The interesting thing about this is that if the silencer wants to stay behind the Advanced, it's speed becomes a non factor for at least part of the battle.
makes sense. i do like the silencer design. it takes the classic tie idea and makes it sleak modern. this is argubaly what i would have assumed normal modern ties would have looked like by the last movie!
Genetically you can have more interest in certain things and can have certain skills come naturally. I have no clue if there's a scientific word for it.
You forgot that the Tie Silencer was a direct successor to the TIE Advanced's successor, the TIE/D Defender Advanced Space Superiority Fighter (Seen in Rebels, showed up in at least one X-Wing novel flying against Wedge Antilles, and an old favorite of PC Pilots who played the old TIE Fighter video game). Looking online the only weapons that the Defender had that the Silencer didn't were its dual ION Cannons. Against the TIE Defender and Advanced though, the biggest advantage the SIlencer would have was its active stealth systems designed to render it difficult to detect before it engaged an adversary. TIE Advanced - 105-110 MGLT Top Speed 12-20 Concussion Missiles (Depending on source) 4 x laser cannons TIE/D Defender - 140-150 MGLT 12 Concussion MIssiles or 8 Proton Torpedoes 4 x laser Cannons 2 x ION Cannons Experimental Tractor Beam System (forward facing only) TIE/VN Silencer - ??? MGLT (Likely easily a match for the defender) 2 x laser cannons 2 x heavy laser cannons 1 x dual launch concussion missile launcher (unknown capacity; cross compatible with imperial magpulse missiles) 1 x dual launch proton torpedo launcher (unknown capacity) Active Stealth System
Wesley Byrd I think that's a clear win for the Harrower. Despite it's age, the Harrower was a fucking beast. The Gladiator is like a picket destroyer if anything.
They actually compare favorably in terms of size. The Harrower is 300 metters bigger, but also ~3600 years older. The real question comes down to the difference in technology. The Harrower has more gun emplacements, but if you go with the less armed version, you can argue that the fire power output should be comparable. Another question is shield tech. How much can one assume that shield technology has progressed. As an added bonus, we'd have to look at the Mk VI Supremacy Fighter Vs the Tie/LN, ships of similar design philosophy, but separated by nearly 4 millennia. Can the Ties beat out the Mk VI with 4:1 odds against them? But really, the reason I want to see them fight is because they are so similar. They are both split-nosed wedge-shaped carriers with large and low bridge sections. I originally thought about the Harrower vs Venator, but then the fighter count would be 4:1 in favor of the newer ship.
First idea: admiral Trench's Invincible (providence-class dreadnought) vs Imperial star destroyer.Second idea: the first "Phoenix Home" (modified Pelta-class frigate) vs the second one ( captured Imperial quasar-dire class carrier)
While I am relatively new to this I do have a couple of suggestions for star fighters going head-to-head...... Try these.....Alpha Class Xg-1 Star Wing (Assault Gunboat) vs TIE Interceptor , Hoersh-Kessel R-41 Starchaser vs Z-95 Headhunter AF4, or even a TIE-Wing Ugly vs a Kuat Systems Engineering - CloakShape Fighter (CS Fighter). These would be interesting match-ups..
I probably won't get it for the next vid. But I would like to see ground vehicals in versus. Second option 2-M Saber-class repulsor tank vs AAT Lets get this one
I play the game X-Wing miniatures game the Tie silencer size only experienced pilots can pilot it efficiently. When the tie advanced X1 does not need specially trained parts on its card text.
There's like 35-year-long gap between the two, so it's quite clear upfront in a regard of who'd win. I know that the development in most of the SW Galaxy has significantly slowed down during the last 4000 years or so, because they were hitting the so-called technological plateau, but even so.... Kinda unfair, I must state.
Considering that the TIE Defender is canon again, it could be interesting to see Kylo's Silencer leading (at least) a small, elite squad of Defenders or some kind of First Order revamp of the Defender concept. Speaking of the Defender, for something that might be quite different, how about pitting a single Defender (or if necessary, a small squad like 2 or 3) against a corvette class ship like the CR90 or even something dedicated for anti-starfighter work like the Imperial Raider class? Speaking from experience in the TIE Fighter game where the Defender was introduced, I've destroyed quite a few CR90's and maybe its modified version too, like in one mission where I destroyed maybe 4 of them attacking an Interdictor. Some missiles and/or quad lasers and ion cannons do the trick c:
Nice detailed vid. every time they come out with a new ship design immediately think of how it fits in the x-wing minis game ; TIE advanced x1 2/3/3/2 + TIE Interceptor 3/3/3/0 = TIE Silencer 3/3/3/1 my guess MTFBWY
I want to see the leviathan sith interdictor versus the imperial 418 interdictor I would say the normal sith interdictor but it only has 5 medium turbolasers just 5 while the leviathan has a lot more about as much at its size should have
Given that the Tie Defender does exist now in Cannon, its safe to assume that the possibility of the Tie Advanced Production variants do exist in the current star wars timeline that would later influence the Tie Silencer. Indeed the possibility Tie Defenders and or advanced in First Order Ranks should be a possibility.
If we consider just the staggeringly incredible armour on the TIE Silencer alone, it could probably go toe-to-toe with the Death Star. Did you see the crash Kylo walked away from, after Mary Rey Sue sliced a wing off? Now THAT is what ya gotta call superior (PLOT) armour. :)
just any fyi eckhart, vaders x1 also has a cluster missile launcher in the star wars battle pod, however, the mission where you play as vader, while it is still fun, isnt canon, as you blow up the millenium falcon in it but it is a cool what if story, you should check it out
Want to help the channel out?
Consider donating so I can upgrade my hardware: goo.gl/DJX619
Subscribe: goo.gl/vBao71
Join the (superfun!) Discord: discord.gg/3jbNnaK
And follow me on Twitter: goo.gl/i4BGcy!
EckhartsLadder
Titan (EVE) vs Ecilpse
yuuzhan vong vs borg please!!!!!!!!
RIDE_ THE_LIGHTNING 117 tell generation tech he does that
I suppose people just want to see ships fight and not people instead.
ISA Cruiser vs UNSC Frigate
Judging by its use in the Rebels tv show, I think the Advance has really powerful blasters so it can function as a bomber that can cripple a cruiser in a single run but they can still function as anti-fighter weapons, making the Advance a glass cannon in this scenario.
This is not a fair fight. Pit that Silencer against the LEGENDARY Defender!
Or even the TIE Hunter!
How about the TIE Avenger, which is the "production version" of the TIE Advanced!
Also a good choice! Especially since only the specific instances of the TIE Advanced used by Vader would be more finely tuned than one used by elite Imperial pilots.
The silencer is basically a more advanced defender
Mofstar , you mean a more advanced Tie Interceptor?
I feel as if the X1 was highly underrated by you for a pretty large reason. You need to remember that while there were other Tie Advance variants, the X1 was designed for the use of Vader, and Vader alone. I get you want the equal pilots deal and all, but considering the X1 couldn't be piloted to it's full potential without Vader in the cockpit, it takes away from the ship itself, seeing that he was the only one who used it consistently. Not saying the victory should go to him, though I doubt Kylo is a better starpilot than Vader, but I think that needs to be considered.
I think the Tie Defender would have been a better match for the Tie Silencer
Arguably the best tie fighters in canon
3:03 Cluster missiles in Rogue One were the best. Especially once you've found the homing cluster missiles upgrade, which is probably more like how cluster missiles would functionally be in Star Wars.
Kylo will never be such a good pilot as me...
belive me i could fly a Naboo Star Fighter when i was 9
Darth Vader you would've kicked Kylos ass in your starfighter
The force my man
And that means his father never taught him how to fly as a kid? Never let him take the Falcon or an X-Wing for a spin?
Kylo will never be powerful than darth vader
:)
Malvolence vs resurgence class battle cruiser
Blair Johnson malevolence wins, it has those two ion Cannons and could obliterate the first order cruiser.
Toxic UA-cam unless if the resurgent faces the malevolence from its side (in front of the ion cannon)
The Malevolence has to turn it's entire hull to aim it's main weapon which is really a long range AOE weapon.
It does raise the question of what happens if the ring of ions is smaller than the target it's firing at. Does the ring break up?
Also the Resurgent is 50 years more advanced, is designed to attack large warships and has a large fighter compliment that it can deploy quickly, the Malevolence would rely entirely on luck to even try and land a shot that might not even win the battle.
@@AngelSamael is the target is larger it will take the full brunt of the ION cannon, which is around 1.5x the power of the Hoth ion cannon.
The resurgent may have power, but if it’s power is offline then that power isn’t there (obviously).
I love the Silencer. Especially with the newer info that shows it has cloaking, and the missile launchers are actually one proton torpedo launcher and one warhead launcher. Or at least Kylo Ren's version does.
Grand Admiral Thrawn vs Captain Picard in a fleet battle (equal fleets, don't really want to get into the whole ISD vs Enterprise thing)
Dude you are doing that but on a larger scale no more Star Trek vs Star Wars please
he is talking about the average fleet for both, there will be more tvpes of ships
Jackson L. Austin yes but the isd vs enterprise would come up
there will be multiple ISDs and 1 Enterprise and other Fed. ships
Yeah and what's gonna be at the forefront The Chimera and The Enterprise you know cause they are gonna be the flag ships of each fleet
Do the x-Wing vs the tie Hunter cuz the tie Hunter was made to combat the x Wing
I have a distaste for the cockpit of the TIE silencer. It's a good looking craft and it makes a certain sense to have a boxy cockpit frame on a ship like that... I just don't know, it makes it seem more cargo hauler than sleek star-interceptor.
How about a squadron battle? For example the 181st Imp. Fighter Wing vs Red Squadron!
+NicRave good idea, let's see what people think
EckhartsLadder yes and also maybe do a fight between the Eta-2 actis-Class light interceptor Vs TIE/IN interceptor please
NicRave yeee boi
*EckhartsLadder starts of the video with someone jumping into an x-wing using a LADDER.
pure genius
The TIE Advanced has the same wings as the TIE Bomber. It also uses the standard ball cockpit as the TIE Fighter. It wouldn't too much taller than the TIE Silencer. But yes, with 35 years of technological advancement in technology the TIE Avenger, sorry Silencer would win!
It was a good idea to take out modifications. In both cannon and legends, Vader heavily customized his ship, although what these upgrades were is unknown.
Ideas spiderman vs Darth Vader
Z-95 headhunter (as it was during the clone wars) vs the x-wing
And Han Solo vs a republic commando
That's it hope you guys like it!
And kylo so tie looks like a vulture droid too
Seriously ? Spiderman... of all people Spiderman.
Headhunter vs X-wing is pointless, the X-wing is derived from the headhunter. You add 2 engines, 2 guns, 2 wings. It's a huge advantage.
message posted yeah but commando armor is hella strong Han solo wears no armor.
Mic Clank me vs ur mum lololol i winned
I love the silencer I think it looks amazing and in the movie it seemed to be a excellent performing ship
R2-D2 vs C1-10P (Chopper)
AdmiralSupreme nice!
I would say Chopper will win cause it is capable of doing a back flip kick attack xd
vs BT-1
C1-10 P.
R2-D2 vs NUMBER 5 😀
T-70 X-Wing VS Tie Defender
T-70 X-Wing is the upgraded model from The Force Awakens.
GSarge17 defender wins anyway since the t-70 x wings get blown up by tie fighters and fucking stormtroopers!
the TIE defender could very likely compete with a twin tail... if you really want a 1v1 fight a royal guard tie or Normal TIE/In with shields will deal with an X-wing just fine...dont forget the TIE/In has speed and maneuverability on its side while the X wings only 1 was durability and they are the same weapon wise....
Droid tri fighter vs. Tie defender
Titan Helios Defender, easily. The Defender was far more advanced
Jeff Vader yes but the tri fighter also carried buzz droids that could dismantle ships
Titan Helios Agreed, but the Tie Defender was the peak of imperial fighter design, and as such carried a lot of weapons, including 4 lasers, 2 ion cannons, and missiles, as well as having pretty decent shielding
Evan Edmonds Do you even know what the tie defender is? It's a complete reversal of imperial fighter doctrine, being a ship easily capable of destroying any other ship, or even engaging a capital ship 1v1. It would easily annihilate a tri fighter. The buzz droids wouldn't be enough to even the match.
thats not a battle, the defender would win easily
Venator vs MC40
This isn't your grandfather's TIE! - TIE Silencer advertisement
T-85 X-Wing Vs. A-Wing
Depends on the model of A-wing.
The A wing has speed and maneuverability but the X-wing has shields and firepower as well as the strategic advantage of a droid.
i thought the model number was *T-65b* !!
Franz Ferdinand the newest model of the X wing was the T-85. The T-65 was the oldest model.
T-85 was New Republic X wing
They're both very respectable ships, however, I think the Silencer is the more advanced and, overall, capable ship. That having been said, I think a better matchup would've been the TIE Silencer vs. the TIE Hunter or Defender.
EDIT: I know you probably made this video before this information was widely available, but the Silencer has 4 medium laser cannons, and also 2 heavy laser cannons, one between each wing. Then of course there are the 2 launchers, which can be loaded with either concussion missiles, mag-pulse warheads, or proton torpedos.
The TIE Silencer is actually equipped with 2 standard laser cannons, 2 heavy laser cannons, 1 concussion missile/mag-pulse warhead launcher, and 1 proton torpedo launcher.
X-83 TwinTail starfighter vs TIE Predators (Predator-class fighter)
It would be a cool match up!!
Also
Potatoes are nice.
Ebon Hawk vs Millennium Falcon
or
SC2 Terran Battle cruiser vs Venator Star Destroyer
Grand Admiral Thrawn vs UNSC Admiral Preston J Clolt ( In an fleet to fleet scenario)
Alfred Elfgren I mean, Thrawn was in charge of an entire system worth of ships and crew, Cole was in charge of one fleet. The technological difference is always something SW vs Halo, In Cole Protocol it was made clear that Preston was an excellent tactician
You know, the TIE Silencer kinda makes me think of what would result from the ship designers at Cloud Imperium Games getting a chance to take a crack at the TIE fighter design. It really looks like a hybrid of both Star Wars and Star Citizen design aesthetics.
This is one of, if not my favorite thing to listen to. I say listen because truthfully its pictures but I love this series. I wish I could donate to help but I can't but I guess the best I can do is give these kind words. So keep up the phenomenal work :D
+Nuclear Walnut I'm just glad to have you as a fan - thanks for watching!!
EckhartsLadder being a fan is what I'm good at :)
The Twilight vs. Slave 1
This is like my 10th try
my money is on the Slave one, that thing had too many weapons for its size 0_0
darth vader's tie has a power hogging/inefficient shield generator. so if the shields are on, then the tie is a slug or very slightly faster than a standard tie. but with the shields off, the tie is pretty fast....
Star destroyer mk2 vs MC80b
Retribution class battleship from warhammer 40k vs executor class super star destroyer
the amount of times i've tried is too damn much
feelsbad dude
well.. the Emperor class is more of a carrier variant out of its sister ships and has much less offensive capabilities compared to the Retribution or the apocalypse
warhammer is ridiculous but i thoroughly believe a executor class star destroyer would curb stomp any ship from warhammer xD ( though war hammers ground units would destroy starwars lol, if i remember right a regular star destroyer's shields and weapons put out ridiculous amounts of energy ( like a 3rd of the sun) so the executor would be pure bullshit
Clearly you never heard of the Gloriana class battleship :P
Base size is bigger than the Executor with the biggest Loyalist ship being 26kms, easily dwarfing the 19kms the Executor is.
Also you need a source for that claim.
Y wing vs tie bomber
Benson Froese y wing no question
Y wing
If you take Rogue Squadron as reference for Tie Advanced, then you should revisit Tie Fighter where :
- Concussive missiles are GUIDED (and faster and need less time to catch lock compared against Photon torps)
- Tie Advanced have it, and uses it. The fact is that can use any warhead, including photon torps, heavy rockets and space mines.
- Compared against Tie Figther , it have shields, it's faster and have a FTL engine.
Providence Dreadnought larger version VS Imperial Star Destroyer
Tinker Tanker The Providence wins, it's armor and torpedoes are OP.
I was going to suggest a Fighter match but I did not know if you did them much but here it goes NABO STARFIGHTER vs ATTACKER ( INDEPENDENCE DAY ) respect.
I think you analysis is pretty on point. It is 35 tests newer. That's 35 years to learn from the shortcomings of previous T.I.E. iteration. I agree, the shields must be stronger now and the firepower of the Silencer seems to far out class the older interceptor. Unless of course Vader is flying it, guiding the the cluster missiles himself. In which case that is a new ball game. Also Vader was a supremely disciplined pilot, where Kyle has show hisself to be wild, erratic, undisciplined, basically a rage monster out of control. Even in a superior ship, with Vader's discipline, significantly greater power in the Force, able to multitask elaborate maneuvers while guiding the cluster rockets, Vader wins 9 out of 10 time. Just sayin'.
I saw Kylo Ren's ship winning from the start. And a second bout between these ships would be good.
1. Inexpugnable-class tactical command ship VS Lucrehulk-class
2. Venator-class Star Destroyer VS Harrower-class dreadnought
3. Kom'rk-class fighter VS X-wing starfighter
4. Victory I-class Star Destroyer VS Harrower-class dreadnought
5. Kom'rk-class fighter VS StarViper-class attack platform
Hammerhead cruiser vs nebulon b frigate
wolf 568730 the hammerhead has NO chance to survive
Gabriel Brunet I'm talking about legends hammerhead cruiser from kotor,it's just idea though
If Darth Vader was piloting the X1 and Kylo was piloting the Silencer, the Silencer would not win. Vader is an extremely superior pilot to Kylo. Although the the Silencer is more advanced, the X1 would still win because Vader is piloting it. It's Darth Vader. It's obvious he would win.
Millennium Falcon vs Ebon Hawk ( Revan's ship)
there's thousands of years of weapons research, falcon will crush the ebon hawk.
tie bomber vs y wing or the gazzanti class vs the hammer head corvette or tie advanced vs x wing or darth vaders tie vs then inquisiters tie .
LAAT GUNSHIP vs pelican
Blair Johnson pelican gunship it would not be fair other wise
The LAAT would gun down the pelican in literal seconds and the pelican wouldn’t be able to fight back
The TIE Silencer looks as if it is bigger and less maneuverable than the TIE Advanced, which is more squat.
The revisit to this showdown needs to now happen.
As promised
Zann Consortium Aggressor Class Star Destroyer (Tyber Zann' s flagship the Merciless) vs.UNSC Remembrance- Class Frigate (The Mother of Invention; the director of project freelancer's flagship(Red vs. Blue))
i sooo love the silencer so much, i think Kylo will kick ass in this in the last jedi, very similar to the interceptor , great video!
I can't wait til these are compared with Kylo and Vader as pilots.
The interesting thing about this is that if the silencer wants to stay behind the Advanced, it's speed becomes a non factor for at least part of the battle.
makes sense. i do like the silencer design. it takes the classic tie idea and makes it sleak modern. this is argubaly what i would have assumed normal modern ties would have looked like by the last movie!
Chiss Claw Craft Vs Tie Defender
(Sixth try now) Covenant CAS Class Assault Carrier Vs Bellator Class Super Star Destroyer With Escorts.
You gain bonus points for mentioning my favorite ship, the Tie Avenger.
The merciless hand vs the malevolence
Invisible hand?
Imperial Star Destroyer versus Providence Class Dreadnaught. (I won't stop until you do it)
Kylo’s piloting skills wouldn’t have been passed down from Vader, Vader died before Kylo was even born.
Genetically you can have more interest in certain things and can have certain skills come naturally. I have no clue if there's a scientific word for it.
You forgot that the Tie Silencer was a direct successor to the TIE Advanced's successor, the TIE/D Defender Advanced Space Superiority Fighter (Seen in Rebels, showed up in at least one X-Wing novel flying against Wedge Antilles, and an old favorite of PC Pilots who played the old TIE Fighter video game). Looking online the only weapons that the Defender had that the Silencer didn't were its dual ION Cannons. Against the TIE Defender and Advanced though, the biggest advantage the SIlencer would have was its active stealth systems designed to render it difficult to detect before it engaged an adversary.
TIE Advanced - 105-110 MGLT Top Speed
12-20 Concussion Missiles (Depending on source)
4 x laser cannons
TIE/D Defender - 140-150 MGLT
12 Concussion MIssiles or 8 Proton Torpedoes
4 x laser Cannons
2 x ION Cannons
Experimental Tractor Beam System (forward facing only)
TIE/VN Silencer - ??? MGLT (Likely easily a match for the defender)
2 x laser cannons
2 x heavy laser cannons
1 x dual launch concussion missile launcher (unknown capacity; cross compatible with imperial magpulse missiles)
1 x dual launch proton torpedo launcher (unknown capacity)
Active Stealth System
Harrower Vs Gladiator
Sith Empire's Dreadnought vs the Galactic Empire's Smallest Star Destroyer
9 minutes in should be early enough!
Wesley Byrd I think that's a clear win for the Harrower. Despite it's age, the Harrower was a fucking beast. The Gladiator is like a picket destroyer if anything.
They actually compare favorably in terms of size. The Harrower is 300 metters bigger, but also ~3600 years older. The real question comes down to the difference in technology. The Harrower has more gun emplacements, but if you go with the less armed version, you can argue that the fire power output should be comparable. Another question is shield tech. How much can one assume that shield technology has progressed.
As an added bonus, we'd have to look at the Mk VI Supremacy Fighter Vs the Tie/LN, ships of similar design philosophy, but separated by nearly 4 millennia. Can the Ties beat out the Mk VI with 4:1 odds against them?
But really, the reason I want to see them fight is because they are so similar. They are both split-nosed wedge-shaped carriers with large and low bridge sections. I originally thought about the Harrower vs Venator, but then the fighter count would be 4:1 in favor of the newer ship.
1. Modified Cr-90 "Farstar" vs. Arquitens-class
2. Mandalorian Kandosii-Class Dreadnought vs. Harrower-class
3. Hamerhead-corvette (Rogue one) vs. Crusader-class corvette
Republic LAAT Gunship vs UNSC Pelican Dropship
I like the TIE Advanced X1 better. You can't beat the power of nostalgia.
To build a Tie Silencer:
1.construct a tie interceptor
2.throw it into a trash compactor
3.done
Perhaps the TIE Silencer was built in a Trash Compactor. 😏
First idea: admiral Trench's Invincible (providence-class dreadnought) vs Imperial star destroyer.Second idea: the first "Phoenix Home" (modified Pelta-class frigate) vs the second one ( captured Imperial quasar-dire class carrier)
While I am relatively new to this I do have a couple of suggestions for star fighters going head-to-head...... Try these.....Alpha Class Xg-1 Star Wing (Assault Gunboat) vs TIE Interceptor , Hoersh-Kessel R-41 Starchaser vs Z-95 Headhunter AF4, or even a TIE-Wing Ugly vs a Kuat Systems Engineering - CloakShape Fighter (CS Fighter). These would be interesting match-ups..
I probably won't get it for the next vid. But I would like to see ground vehicals in versus. Second option
2-M Saber-class repulsor tank vs AAT
Lets get this one
Imperial Light Carrier Vs Arquitens class cruiser
V-Wing vs. TIE Interceptor
"He will join us or die"
- Darth Vader
I think this is one of the coolest ship designs in start wars fighter design
I like the Silencer. It just looks like a more sleek Tie Avenger and that was my favorite Tie.
Providence class vs victory 2 or Ajunta Pall vs darth zannah or The Profundity vs chaf frigate or v-wing vs A-Wing
I play the game X-Wing miniatures game the Tie silencer size only experienced pilots can pilot it efficiently. When the tie advanced X1 does not need specially trained parts on its card text.
There's like 35-year-long gap between the two, so it's quite clear upfront in a regard of who'd win. I know that the development in most of the SW Galaxy has significantly slowed down during the last 4000 years or so, because they were hitting the so-called technological plateau, but even so....
Kinda unfair, I must state.
TX-225(R1 Tank) vs TX-130 Saber Class Tank (The Battlefront 2 Republic tank)
Considering that the TIE Defender is canon again, it could be interesting to see Kylo's Silencer leading (at least) a small, elite squad of Defenders or some kind of First Order revamp of the Defender concept.
Speaking of the Defender, for something that might be quite different, how about pitting a single Defender (or if necessary, a small squad like 2 or 3) against a corvette class ship like the CR90 or even something dedicated for anti-starfighter work like the Imperial Raider class?
Speaking from experience in the TIE Fighter game where the Defender was introduced, I've destroyed quite a few CR90's and maybe its modified version too, like in one mission where I destroyed maybe 4 of them attacking an Interdictor. Some missiles and/or quad lasers and ion cannons do the trick c:
Nice detailed vid. every time they come out with a new ship design immediately think of how it fits in the x-wing minis game ; TIE advanced x1 2/3/3/2 + TIE Interceptor 3/3/3/0 = TIE Silencer 3/3/3/1 my guess MTFBWY
I want to see the leviathan sith interdictor versus the imperial 418 interdictor I would say the normal sith interdictor but it only has 5 medium turbolasers just 5 while the leviathan has a lot more about as much at its size should have
In fact the leviathian has the same amount of weapons 20 quad laser cannons expect the leviathan does have a 4 turbolasers and a few ion cannons
Tie advanced relative to its era is better than tie silencer relative to its era
For the the TIE Silencer is the First Order evolution of the TIE Avenger (Advanced X2)
Given that the Tie Defender does exist now in Cannon, its safe to assume that the possibility of the Tie Advanced Production variants do exist in the current star wars timeline that would later influence the Tie Silencer. Indeed the possibility Tie Defenders and or advanced in First Order Ranks should be a possibility.
Droid star fighter vs tie fighter
General Grievous's ship the Invisible Hand vs an Imperial 2 class star Destroyer
Harrower class dreadnought vs Munificent class star frigate (or) Providence class destroyer (1K long)
If we consider just the staggeringly incredible armour on the TIE Silencer alone, it could probably go toe-to-toe with the Death Star.
Did you see the crash Kylo walked away from, after Mary Rey Sue sliced a wing off?
Now THAT is what ya gotta call superior (PLOT) armour. :)
Krennic's imperial shuttle vs. kylo ren's shuttle next
Providence-Class Dreadnought vs. Imperial Star Destroyer
I like the x1 better. I also feel like it looks a lot better.
But if Vader and Ren flew, I'm sure Vader would fry Ren in seconds...
*Obviously*
@@FranzFerdinandVIII I'm surprised someone even found a comment of mine from 2 years ago.
super star destroyer vs independence day mothership
just any fyi eckhart, vaders x1 also has a cluster missile launcher in the star wars battle pod, however, the mission where you play as vader, while it is still fun, isnt canon, as you blow up the millenium falcon in it but it is a cool what if story, you should check it out
General Hux should have a unit called SS for Space Superiority
You should do all UNSC vs all of Republic or all of Covenant vs all of Empire.
My money's on ol' Granddad. XD
Plus, the TIE advanced x1 is more Legendary
I agree, but if Darth Vader was going up against Kylo Ren, the Advanced X1 is defiantly the winner.
SDF-1 Macross vs whatever you think would be a fair fight. or squadron of VF-1 Valkyries vs squad of either X-wings/Y wings etc. or Ties
TIE Silencer had experimental shields that were supposedly very effective, but high maintenance