We sincerely appreciate the overwhelming response we received for our inaugural industry-based webinar. We are delighted to inform you that our Advanced Course offers comprehensive coverage of over 30 service sectors, providing in-depth analysis and interlinking of GST Laws with more than 20 other Laws. To enhance your expertise in GST, we encourage you to take advantage of our Advanced Course. Access the course at the following link: gstbymm.com/courses/advanced-gst-course Thank you to all who participated in the webinar, and we look forward to supporting you in your journey towards becoming a GST expert. PS: For all questions/queries/updates, join us on WhatsApp: invite.gstbymm.com/professionals UPDATE: GUJARAT HC in the case of MUNJAAL MANISHBHAI BHATT V. UNION OF INDIA has held that "the impugned Paragraph 2 of the Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.6.2017 and identical notification under the Gujarat Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, which provides for a mandatory fixed rate of deduction of 1/3rd of total consideration towards the value of land is ultra-vires the provisions as well as the scheme of the GST Acts. The application of such a mandatory uniform rate of deduction is discriminatory, arbitrary, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India."
I was just searching on Google to understand the GST on Real Estate there was a lot of confusion but suddenly I got a video of yours it is unbelievable not to find such type of video on real estate. When a small child goes into the nursery that time how the teacher guides as a child in the same type you have given us knowledge Hats off
Can't believe that such a complicated topic has been explained in such a crisp and clear manner. The example you have designed is just super se bhi uper
Thanks sir for such a informative & valuable knowledge video. AajTak kabhi itna intrest lekar koi 2hrs ka lecture Maine consume nahi kiya tha. After listening good explanation I did it today! 😅
Always a treat to watch you ....your all videos are so helpful not only for the students but also for the practising professionals like us.... Thanks again for sharing valuable knowledge.
Sir under construction flat super buildup area 570 sq carpet Area 456 de raha h( flat price 30 lakh )gst her payment me 5% builder le raha use 1% lena chahiye na affordable property hua na per plz reply mujhe samaj me nahi aaraha ha Pura flat bangayega to fir GST lagega kya
The whole explanation was very much helpful, I only have one question as to were under the notification is it written about TOS for TDR transfer for Money + commercial seperately.
Thank you very much sir for such an excellent presentation with Case study covering all aspects of T1,T2,T3 and T4 and explaining very neatly supply, taxable person, exemption, value of supply, Time of supply, ITC availability etc under each transaction. Congratulations sir. I have a small doubt. Under T1 exemption has been computed as 600 lakhs. Where do we use this to deduct tax liability or turnover deduction. Thanking you sir
Excellent deliberation, i am a practicing Chartered Accountant it was really good. you have a long way to go, professionals can easily understand the complex subject of JDA by watching this lecture. Thanks a lot sir. One thing i would request you is to kindly also post a video of the income tax aspects of JDA if possible. Thanks again & All the best!!
at 1:33:36-at the time of computation of Value of supply aof construction service by builder to landowner, why have we not considered monetary consideration of 1cr
awsome sir, exemption of Rs 600 lack calculated but where it is deducted or benifit of this exemption where taken i could not under stand, rest i got very well. Sir you have made it very easy.
sir, I have seen so many videos for understanding real estate provision under GST I did not understand but in your explanation, all the doubts will clarify pls do such videos thank you
Hands down the best available video on the subject matter. Thank you soo very much for putting in the time and effort to make this video, so we could learn. 🙏🏽
Excellent job sir but I have a question for you 1% & 5% is applicable no ITC utilised if the builder purchase material 80%/20% registered dealer hum kaise purchase calculate karenge
.Excellent video explaining the finer point . However some doubts remain in my mind. When land is not sold to builder how can it be said that cost of flat includes cost of land or undivided cost of land.Isn't it share of Consideration for TDR? .In that way flat owner can never become owner of undivided share on land. Which rate is to be entered in returns effective or notified.? . Hope u will answer.
Sir, what you mentioned about the monetary consideration in the commercial case is understood. However, regarding the value of TDR in the commercial part, it can also be determined on the initial stage, allowing for payment and the ability to claim Input Tax Credit (ITC). If this process is delayed until the very end, the set-off for its ITC may not be possible. Kindly give your observation
Very much informative and helpful video, frankly speaking I couldn't get so much clarity after attending the ICAI's webinar what I got here, Thank you Mishraji for your efforts. I have few queries regarding the subject, kindly enlighten the same: 1. If the landowner does not want to sell the Units (which he would get as his share as per the JDA) before completion, i.e., he is not into the same line of business but due to some circumstances he has to sell the under constructed units to some outsider. In that case, whether he will be covered under T-4 & has to obtain GSTIN? 2. In the same situation as mentioned above, if he sells his share to co-owner instead of outsider, whether he will be covered under T-4 & has to obtain GSTIN? 3. At the time of filing GST Returns of a Builder, whether Effective GST % would be reported or the Notified %? One recommendation - if you also make a video on Income Tax & TDS applicability on Real Estate / JDA transactions, that will be great. Thanks once again!
1. The definition of "business" under GST is very wide and controversial. Even if he/she has to sell due to "some circumstances", it will be considered as a business and will get covered under T4. As definitely the turnover will exceed 20 lakhs easily, they have to take GSTIN. 2. Yes, it doesn't matter who is the recipient. 3. Notified Rate.
Dear Sir, Really very simple and deep knowledge & Cover All aspect for Exam purpose also Practical life...... I am CA... Keep it sir, Also upload new video on others topic such as export of goods & service with all aspect for practical purpose
Sir really good presentation and appreciate the effort taken. But there are few points to note: 1) You should have taken 2/3 for value of supply of TDR as 1/3 is land. So in your example for GST payable for unbooked residential apartments should be lower of : a) 1200 lakhs*60%*2/3*10/60*18%=14.4 lakhs or b) affordable (5*45*2/3*1.5%)=2.25 lakhs + Other(5*55*2/3*7.5%)= 13.75 lakhs =2.25+13.75=16 lakhs So lower will be 14.4 lakhs . 2) Since this project is REP commercial apts. rate is 12% after deduction of value of land of 1/3rd. So ITC will be available to builder only on TDR on commercial Apts paid under RCM . But here also ITC will be of no use as he cannot use it against GST of 5% and 1% payable against residential apartments but he can use against 12% collected from customers on commercial apts. sale. ITC WILL NOT be available to builder for unbooked residential apartments paid under RCM by Builder. 3) If project was RREP then comercial apts rate would be 5% on sale to customers. Hence ITC on RCM(as discussed in point 2) paid for commercial apts. would not have been able to be utilised against any output tax payable and hence would not be able to set off against. Alos refund is not possible of this ITC.
We sincerely appreciate the overwhelming response we received for our inaugural industry-based webinar. We are delighted to inform you that our Advanced Course offers comprehensive coverage of over 30 service sectors, providing in-depth analysis and interlinking of GST Laws with more than 20 other Laws. To enhance your expertise in GST, we encourage you to take advantage of our Advanced Course. Access the course at the following link: gstbymm.com/courses/advanced-gst-course
Thank you to all who participated in the webinar, and we look forward to supporting you in your journey towards becoming a GST expert.
PS: For all questions/queries/updates, join us on WhatsApp: invite.gstbymm.com/professionals
UPDATE: GUJARAT HC in the case of MUNJAAL MANISHBHAI BHATT V. UNION OF INDIA has held that "the impugned Paragraph 2 of the Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.6.2017 and identical notification under the Gujarat Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, which provides for a mandatory fixed rate of deduction of 1/3rd of total consideration towards the value of land is ultra-vires the provisions as well as the scheme of the GST Acts. The application of such a mandatory uniform rate of deduction is discriminatory, arbitrary, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India."
Sir, can I make my final year MBA project on "impact of GST on real estate sector"?
@@rashibisaria1025 Taxation is not a preferable topic for MBA. I suggest you go with a topic of your subject of MBA. Best of Luck.
Thank you sir.
Its humble request "BETA BETA" karna band kijiye
Hope you will get some professional views as well.
Sir i am practicing Chartered accountant and i must say this video really helped me ... thank you
Aaj tk pure you tube pr is se exellent class nahi mill...may god bless u...
I was just searching on Google to understand the GST on Real Estate there was a lot of confusion but suddenly I got a video of yours it is unbelievable not to find such type of video on real estate. When a small child goes into the nursery that time how the teacher guides as a child in the same type you have given us knowledge Hats off
A Gem of a lecture.
Can't believe a lecture of such a high level can exist.Such a detailed analysis.
Sab record tod diya aapne sir aaj tak ase simply and classify smoothly lectures aaj tak mene nhi dekha sir thanks a lot of sir ji
Pure UA-cam par esa lecture nahi hai sir...You are the Best. Thank You so much.
Can't believe that such a complicated topic has been explained in such a crisp and clear manner. The example you have designed is just super se bhi uper
Very detailed explanation. Thanks for sharing the knowledge.. god bless
Thanks sir for such a informative & valuable knowledge video.
AajTak kabhi itna intrest lekar koi 2hrs ka lecture Maine consume nahi kiya tha.
After listening good explanation I did it today! 😅
Never imagined that I will understand the concept of jda,tdr thanks u sir ❤
Thanks
Sir,
This was the perfect one. I have never seen so detailed and highly analytical lecture.
Most comprehensive video ever made on this complex subject. Thank you very much.
One stop solution... Great example sir...
sir thank u very much for such a fabulous work. made our life easier.
Isse better lecture mil gaya to batana.....❤❤❤❤❤❤ that was so helpful..can't express in wordd
Really excellent class all concept were clear after joining the class👍👍
Excellant teacher
Sir you have really understood the subject very clearly. Thanks once again
Super sir.I have fully KNOWLEDGE about after the see the video
Sir, You have covered all things at one place.
Thank you very much
Great sir 👍👍
Excellent 👌
excellent Mishra ji
Great sir. You covered all concept in single lecture
Nice information sir
Wonderful lecture sir.
Very well explained. Thank you sir
Superb
No one can teach better than you at least this topic
Hats off to you
then I think you have to watch the other lectures as well. 😂😂
Sure
Kindly check notification no 6/2019
Mind blowing....sir..... highly thankful to you...
In true sense true webinar on real estate...
Brilliant Coverage
MAZA AAGYA SIR!
Complex topic explained in very easy way....
Mind blowing class sir... priceless class. Highly Thankful to you.
Nicely explained sir ...in one shot crystal clear
Thank you very much
Always a treat to watch you ....your all videos are so helpful not only for the students but also for the practising professionals like us....
Thanks again for sharing valuable knowledge.
Sir under construction flat super buildup area 570 sq carpet Area 456 de raha h( flat price 30 lakh )gst her payment me 5% builder le raha use 1% lena chahiye na affordable property hua na per plz reply mujhe samaj me nahi aaraha ha Pura flat bangayega to fir GST lagega kya
शानदार
Amazing video. Thanks
Very nicely and explicitly explained sir. Thank you
Excellent video sir
Excellent explanation
Lajawaaaaaaaaaaaabbbb
Thanks & Regards
CA Gourav Jalan
Very good explanation thank you sir
This is must watch.. Very nice lecture thank you
superbly explained in a simple and lucid manner.
Ese to kisi ne nahi padha rakkha sir. tussi great ho...
A lot of thanks to you for preparing such kind of useful video 🙏
Wonderful explanation of the topic 👏👏👏👏 thank you so much
Good class and explanation.
The whole explanation was very much helpful, I only have one question as to were under the notification is it written about TOS for TDR transfer for Money + commercial seperately.
Notification No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
Nice video thanks sir
Such a detail explanation.. HATS OFF
Excellent explanation 👌 👏 sir,
Thank you for such a wonderful deliberation....
Thank you very much sir for such an excellent presentation with Case study covering all aspects of T1,T2,T3 and T4 and explaining very neatly supply, taxable person, exemption, value of supply, Time of supply, ITC availability etc under each transaction. Congratulations sir. I have a small doubt. Under T1 exemption has been computed as 600 lakhs. Where do we use this to deduct tax liability or turnover deduction. Thanking you sir
Great video 👍👍
Excellent deliberation, i am a practicing Chartered Accountant it was really good. you have a long way to go, professionals can easily understand the complex subject of JDA by watching this lecture. Thanks a lot sir. One thing i would request you is to kindly also post a video of the income tax aspects of JDA if possible. Thanks again & All the best!!
Thanks a lot sir. I will try my level best to share as much as I can. Need your blessings. 🙏🙏
Sir, gst law ke OR INPUT TAX CREDIT KE DETAILS DISSOLVED KORE
KON KON ITC MILEGA AND KON KON ITC NAHI MILEGA .
Excellent, wonderful way of explanation, ❤️
Excellent you have given spoonfeeding. You may also explain on SERVICE TAX.Hatsoff.
Thanks for such a awesome explanation, you really got great skills of teaching, thanks once again
very nice explanation sir
Amazing experience to watch this video..👏👏👏
superb
Thanks for Very informative vedio sir nice
Very well explained 👍🏻
Out standing lecture
Thank you sir, your videos are very helpful
very nice detailed explanation
.. thanks for your kind efforts . God bless
Nice explanation.
no words for your way of explanation sir
at 1:33:36-at the time of computation of Value of supply aof construction service by builder to landowner, why have we not considered monetary consideration of 1cr
Sir Please Class GST on Gems and Diamond. Jaise aapne GST on Real Estate Btaya hai waise hi thoda Gems and Diamond pr bhi
sure but will take time...
awsome sir, exemption of Rs 600 lack calculated but where it is deducted or benifit of this exemption where taken i could not under stand, rest i got very well. Sir you have made it very easy.
One Stap Solution Thank Sir
Great sir
sir, I have seen so many videos for understanding real estate provision under GST I did not understand but in your explanation, all the doubts will clarify pls do such videos thank you
Great job sir
Seen webinars, tried reading articles on JDA still there wasn't complete clarity. Gotta appreciate your content. It's super easy to understand.
Hello Sir
I am CA Ajay
Your delivery towards Topic was very Goods
Hands down the best available video on the subject matter. Thank you soo very much for putting in the time and effort to make this video, so we could learn. 🙏🏽
Sir...nice video... Sir builder uncle ki jo unsold commercial shop rahegayi aur woh complition ke bad sold karta hai to uspe bhi gst lagega...?
informative video .... On lighter side, pronounciation of land is funny....😂
Very nicely explained.. Thank you
Excellent job sir but I have a question for you 1% & 5% is applicable no ITC utilised if the builder purchase material 80%/20% registered dealer hum kaise purchase calculate karenge
ua-cam.com/video/skfEiNzXI-o/v-deo.html
Thanks a lot sir🙏🙏
Very well explained
excellent delivery of concepts
.Excellent video explaining the finer point . However some doubts remain in my mind.
When land is not sold to builder how can it be said that cost of flat includes cost of land or undivided cost of land.Isn't it share of Consideration for TDR?
.In that way flat owner can never become owner of undivided share on land.
Which rate is to be entered in returns effective or notified.?
. Hope u will answer.
Sir, what you mentioned about the monetary consideration in the commercial case is understood. However, regarding the value of TDR in the commercial part, it can also be determined on the initial stage, allowing for payment and the ability to claim Input Tax Credit (ITC). If this process is delayed until the very end, the set-off for its ITC may not be possible. Kindly give your observation
Thank you Sir, Great explanation, pura concept clear ho gaya 😊
Thank you. Very informative as regards jda on gst. This is usefull even for members.
Very much informative and helpful video, frankly speaking I couldn't get so much clarity after attending the ICAI's webinar what I got here, Thank you Mishraji for your efforts.
I have few queries regarding the subject, kindly enlighten the same:
1. If the landowner does not want to sell the Units (which he would get as his share as per the JDA) before completion, i.e., he is not into the same line of business but due to some circumstances he has to sell the under constructed units to some outsider. In that case, whether he will be covered under T-4 & has to obtain GSTIN?
2. In the same situation as mentioned above, if he sells his share to co-owner instead of outsider, whether he will be covered under T-4 & has to obtain GSTIN?
3. At the time of filing GST Returns of a Builder, whether Effective GST % would be reported or the Notified %?
One recommendation - if you also make a video on Income Tax & TDS applicability on Real Estate / JDA transactions, that will be great.
Thanks once again!
1. The definition of "business" under GST is very wide and controversial. Even if he/she has to sell due to "some circumstances", it will be considered as a business and will get covered under T4. As definitely the turnover will exceed 20 lakhs easily, they have to take GSTIN.
2. Yes, it doesn't matter who is the recipient.
3. Notified Rate.
@@mmforyou Thank you so much
@mmforyou
A minor query. In particular to RREP projects (commercial
Dear Sir, Really very simple and deep knowledge & Cover All aspect for Exam purpose also Practical life...... I am CA... Keep it sir, Also upload new video on others topic such as export of goods & service with all aspect for practical purpose
Thank You!! Going to upload many practical industries based lectures. Keep Sharing.
Sir, T1 transaction mein jo commercial part tha usme apne 18% tax calculate kiye lekin usme 12% lagna chahiye na. 1/3rd to exempt hojana chahiye tha
Very nicely explained sir.
Please do a new video with more examples. ❤
Superb lecture.
Sir, what will be the time of supply to pay tax on TDR for completely commercial project?
You can avail our advisory services.
Nice 👍
Sir really good presentation and appreciate the effort taken. But there are few points to note:
1) You should have taken 2/3 for value of supply of TDR as 1/3 is land. So in your example for GST payable for unbooked residential apartments should be lower of :
a) 1200 lakhs*60%*2/3*10/60*18%=14.4 lakhs or
b) affordable (5*45*2/3*1.5%)=2.25 lakhs + Other(5*55*2/3*7.5%)= 13.75 lakhs =2.25+13.75=16 lakhs
So lower will be 14.4 lakhs .
2) Since this project is REP commercial apts. rate is 12% after deduction of value of land of 1/3rd. So ITC will be available to builder only on TDR on commercial Apts paid under RCM . But here also ITC will be of no use as he cannot use it against GST of 5% and 1% payable against residential apartments but he can use against 12% collected from customers on commercial apts. sale. ITC WILL NOT be available to builder for unbooked residential apartments paid under RCM by Builder.
3) If project was RREP then comercial apts rate would be 5% on sale to customers. Hence ITC on RCM(as discussed in point 2) paid for commercial apts. would not have been able to be utilised against any output tax payable and hence would not be able to set off against. Alos refund is not possible of this ITC.
Sir please reply
Great